Hello everyone,
This post is to address the concerns by the subreddit community. We are going to try to break down each concern topic by topic to fully cover what happened, and how we are going to handle things moving forward.
Censorship? / Guilded.
To start, we would like to apologize. We messed up. We said that the term Guilded being used on posts was not being removed but we were wrong. Our automoderator configuration was removing the term and causing confusion among the community and ourselves. The original intention was if the term was flagged, to let us know to review it to make sure it was not advertising since this subreddit is about Discord.
Additionally, to address the concern about users being banned for promoting Guilded: Two users were banned during this time, one for spam and one for advertising and being a nuisance.
The user banned for spam took a screenshot of a comment that was removed, citing that we were censoring users. The comment in question should not have been removed and is now available per the first topic of this post, but the user screenshotting these continued to repost the screenshots of the removal of their own posts. Since it was spamming the subreddit, they were banned.
The other user banned made an account just yesterday to be a nuisance and troll around with trying to get users to notice them and what their username was. This behavior was not appropriate, and they were also banned.
Going forward: The configuration has been properly updated. To give proper clarification on this, you are allowed to talk about Guilded (and other software that is similar to / competing with Discord). Stuff like comparing Guilded to Discord with features and such is okay. However, any blatant advertising of Guilded, or telling users to leave Discord for Guilded is not allowed. (This includes other software as well).
If you have any questions regarding this, please reply here so we can provide information.
Branding updates / Inconsistent removals?
There were concerns regarding us removing content criticizing Discord about their new branding. This is not the case. If you check the subreddit’s home page, you will see many posts about Discord’s branding, including criticisms, suggestions, or creations relating to it. In fact, our team has been pretty lenient with this topic since it's such a big change to the platform. Some posts that would normally be removed have been left up because we want to allow the subreddit to give their opinion/feedback to Discord about this change.
Additionally, from the sheer amount of volume of content being posted here recently (particularly due to the branding update), some content that should have been removed may have been missed or removed after some time. We apologize for this as our team has been very busy, which is why you may see some removals being inconsistent.
Moving forward, we are not adjusting this as we want to allow users to express their feedback/opinions. To note, some posts may be removed in accordance with our subreddit guidelines, but if you have concerns over a post that was removed that should not have been, please let us know via Modmail so we can look further into it.
What else is happening to the subreddit?
We are currently working on improving the functionality of the subreddit. We are looking to add flairs, revamp the rules and expand what content we allow on the subreddit, expand the removal reasons on posts removed, and update automod since it has its issues. Our subreddit is nearing a million subscribers so we hope to have these new features out soon!