r/discordapp • • Jun 11 '23

Discussion Of all things they could've done with the change, why limit themselves to only letters, numbers, underscore and punctum?

like everywhere else they allow spaces, dashes, slashes, other symbols, the underscore has a counterpart, where is that one? I want my spaces, it's not unique enough. I'm fine with the discord issued numbers being removed but at least let us keep the rest because i guarantee you no one would have the same name as me, with or without spaces, I used to be C a n d y - e t t e, now i can't even do that

129 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

10

u/Carp222 Jun 12 '23

Actually, the spaces are one of the only good things about the new restrictions. C a n d y - e t t e is impossible to tag.

0

u/Myuric Jun 12 '23

You do realize that you Tag display names dont you?

0

u/Carp222 Jun 13 '23

Someone that goes by C a n d y - e t t e will probably make that their display name too. It is very, very good that we have some form of space restriction like this so everyone at least has a taggable name.

1

u/Myuric Jun 13 '23

Are you even listening?! Tag names are display names and those wont change. Only the "user" name for friend requests.

His / Her Displayname to tag will stay the same as Candy ette.

1

u/Carp222 Jun 14 '23

You don’t just tag the display name. You can tag by username too. My point from the beginning is that if you allowed spaces in the username, someone could make their username AND display name c a n d y e t t e and it would become a huge pain in the ass to ping them.

-10

u/Candy_Worthy Jun 12 '23

That's the point, I don't want to be tagged, the servers I'm in i barely need to be pinged anyway because I'm always active unless I sleep.

9

u/Flukxyz Jun 12 '23

as one user pointed out, spaces are naturally delimiters in most programming languages and this change is for the better overall, along with this being pinged gets almost fucking impossible so in hindsight this is a good change

10

u/Seliba Jun 12 '23

That's not quite correct, most modern programming languages don't care about if and how many spaces you use because they use semicolons as delimiters. More importantly, spaces are delimiters in most natural languages, so it makes sense for them to be disallowed since distinguishing between a name with a space and a name followed by a space and another unrelated word can be quite challenging

1

u/Flukxyz Jun 12 '23

ah i see thank you for correcting me

51

u/Neal Jun 11 '23

They don’t allow spaces, dashes, slashes and other symbols anywhere else (at least not any other major social)

32

u/theSG-17 Jun 11 '23

Hyphens are allowed most places. In fact before Discord the only place I ran into not being able to use a hyphen was Xbox Live. Thankfully PSN allows it.

7

u/SycoJack Jun 11 '23

But Xbox Live does, or did, allow spaces.

4

u/Toocheeba Jun 12 '23

It's to avoid people mixing underscores and hyphens so names don't look messy.

2

u/AbsolutelyRadikal Jun 12 '23

barcode names:

9

u/YamiZee1 Jun 11 '23

Really the only thing theirs is missing is upper case characters. I think Twitter is the only exception to that one that I can't think of

2

u/IkouyDaBolt Jun 11 '23

YouTube as well, though like Twitter it only applies to the display name rather than the URL.

1

u/PhilMinecraft2005 Jun 12 '23

Facebook too, they allow upper case letters

24

u/pm_me_cute_sloths_ Jun 11 '23

They don’t allow umlauts as well, so I can’t do something like Lëtzebuerg

33

u/PrincessEev Jun 11 '23

Because they're dumb and can't conceptualize knowing a language that isn't English.

9

u/ForceBlade Jun 12 '23

I hear you. I do. But sanitizing that database would be a disaster. I'd let people use anything in unicode if it weren't such a huge problem for DBAs. Let alone potentially unwanted characters with exploit potential.

7

u/IkouyDaBolt Jun 11 '23

If they're going towards a "social media" like platform then it would need to be typed within a web browser or equivalent.

2

u/DjBurba Jun 12 '23

Well my nick was pretty simple and didn't change so I'm ok... I won't miss the numbers, i never remember them anyway

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23

This new update SUCKS

7

u/Thetsizzeler Jun 11 '23

Probably because you can’t have spaces in usernames on most websites. Are you going to complain about other websites not allowing spaces too (like how you have no spaces on your Reddit username) or are you just going to complain about discord because it’s the cool thing to do?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23

It sucks everywhere that does that

8

u/smartboyathome Jun 12 '23

From a programming perspective, you got to get more complicated with the ping user syntax if spaces are involved. Spaces are naturally delimiters in many languages, so you'd need an escape of some form, like @"A User", "@A User", or @A\ User. None of these are great solutions, so the easiest is to just not allow spaces in usernames.

Of all that went wrong with the current rollout, this decision isn't one of them.

2

u/yeebledeebledoo Jun 12 '23

thank you for the explanation! that does make sense

1

u/EasternGamer Jun 12 '23

From a programming perspective on Discord’s side at least, this is a non-issue. Any mention you do is automatically converted into <@userId>.

And mentions you attempt to perform in Discord show the list of possible options as you type them. As well as being automatically sorted by relevance (last time a message sent). So very rarely you will encounter a situation when you can’t select it from the mention list. And if that situation does occur, such as pinging a moderator, right clicking on their name will show a “mention” button.

You can’t type spaces when performing the search, that is true, but hardly the driving reason for this change since in 99.9% of cases, pinging someone not relevant to the conversation (those that have not made a comment) who also has a very non-descript name with a space right after a character and not be towards the top of the member list (admins, moderators etc.)

I find it infinitely more annoying that typing @everyone will result in pinging someone that is named @ever in a server. Unless they fixed that since last I needed to use it.

Personally, I don’t have spaces in my name. Personally, my name is unchanged aside from case changes. Yet, personally, I still hate the change they’ve made for the greater community impact it has, all for problems that never really mattered/couldn’t be solved quite easily. (Extending discriminators)

1

u/Seliba Jun 12 '23

While the issue you're hinting at here is correct (the detection and handling of multi-word usernames in natural language), it really doesn't have anything to do with the fact that strings need to be escaped. Stuff like that could easily be dealt with behind the scenes and hidden from us, the users of the app, if they wanted to - with forum threads that contain spaces, they clearly didn't.

1

u/jnkangel Jun 12 '23

It sucks to escape characters more than not being able to use them

0

u/Rip_SR Jun 12 '23

Are other websites giving and then taking away the ability to have spaces in your username? Are they making so that you get used to having a specific username and then rolling out a change that denies you the username and the next closest version of the username?

1

u/LoneAviatorNSFW Jun 13 '23

Bc they wanna be like the other kids, wanna be more like Twitter.

Instead of, you know. Being unique.

1

u/TBHCreez Jun 12 '23

Probably because it'll be hard to type the special characters from PC? Mobile keyboard offers more symbols than PC one does. That's just my speculation though.

1

u/Rip_SR Jun 12 '23

Since when is a space a special character?

1

u/Slight-Formal-2226 Jun 12 '23

Wait till Elon Musk's children identify their preferred pronoun... Yall gon have to give up

-19

u/SeawolfGaming Jun 11 '23

Just set it as your Display name instead of your Username and stop fucking complaining.

12

u/Candy_Worthy Jun 11 '23

Already did, but it doesn't hide the fact that people want their username back

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23

Not that I don't think the update is terrible, why do you care so much about a username, when your display name is what is seen, and used even with mentioning?

If my old username was friendA and now my new username is friendA12, my display still shows friendA. People can still mention me with friendA, and everyone still addresses me as friendA. Nothing changed.

9

u/Candy_Worthy Jun 11 '23

It's not just about hiding their username with a display name. It's the fact that it's the username that you tell people to find you, it's something people hold dear for years, even decades because it is their identity on the internet. When snotty brats and entitled people take that away from you because they were just "first" to take it then who are you really, the original FriendA or a fake FriendA? Display names can be change on any server if you so choose so with nitro but that's not the issue.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23

Well I use discord as a way to communicate with friends, and sometimes meet new people, through playing games. This is why discord was created. Obviously there are others who use it for seperate reasons however.

This is why when you add a friend, you either have to be in a group with them, or have their username.

I don't think the person who took FriendA away from me is entiteled or a brat, I guess unless he bragged about it to my face. I can accept there are more than a few FriendA's out there.Maybe its a matter of opinion. Which in that case there is no right or wrong.

My actual username I go by is 3 characters, but I have a few other usernames I go by for cases like these though. If not FriendA then FriendB or FriendC. I know in the end that all my friends and anyone new I meet will address me as my display name, or whatever they want I suppose I'm not one to care too much.

Even though I have 3 different usernames, I wasn't able to get a single one, but i'm not that upset about it. I don't dislike the update, but I think it was a stupid idea. I know someone else who probably is in my same situation is probably upset about that. And I respect their opinion.

1

u/Candy_Worthy Jun 11 '23

As do I, though I am quite certain no one would have my way of typing it, any of the variant ways I have across the vast internet.

1

u/KcHecKa KcHecKa#7949 Jun 11 '23

what's your zip code?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23

[deleted]

2

u/discordapp-ModTeam Jun 12 '23

Hi there! Your comment has been removed for violating our community rules:

  • Rule 1 - Keep it civil and respectful, and do not make personal attacks or use offensive language in addressing others. We have no tolerance for discrimination on this subreddit.


If you have any questions about the removal please contact our mod team here.

-3

u/SeawolfGaming Jun 11 '23

Nah that's what you sound like in the circle jerk here while gobbling Cock.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23

[deleted]

3

u/SeawolfGaming Jun 11 '23

I'm not trying, it's a fucking circle jerk echo chamber in this subreddit. Outside of here barely anyone gives a fuck

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23

Because it should be simple specially without people using special fancy letters that you can only get by copying them.

1

u/Rip_SR Jun 12 '23

You find it difficult to type a space?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23 edited Jun 12 '23

Not just spaces like those weird fancy letter they put they you can only get by copying them.

This: 𝖝𝖝𝖝𝕮𝖔𝖔𝖑𝕿𝖎𝖒𝖒𝖞𝖝𝖝𝖝#1234 https://lingojam.com/FancyTextGenerator

1

u/Rip_SR Jun 12 '23

What does that have to do with this post then??

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23

The new username system doesn’t allow that and it’s good, not allowing spaces is worth it to not have those weird usernames.

1

u/Rip_SR Jun 12 '23

I'm not following your lack of thinking here, how exactly does using spaces in a username cause the other characters to appear?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23

After that comment I’m just not responding anymore like what

3

u/Rip_SR Jun 12 '23

I mean the post is talking about spaces, and your talking about special characters, you are saying that using spaces causes special characters to be used, and that just doesn't logically track. There is no line of thinking that I can imagine that gives you the conclusion of, allowing the use of spaces means allowing the use of special characters, or more accurately, allows for the usage of special characters due to the use of the spacebar.