r/discordapp • • Jun 08 '23

Discussion Reserved Usernames and Why You Can't Claim Them

If you've gotten access to the new username system recently, you may have found that your old username is unavailable. You may have tried a bunch of different names, but all of them just show as unavailable DESPITE nobody having claimed them yet (you can check this by sending a username a friend request).

Now you may have the question 'If this name isn't claimed... then why can't I take it?' Well, it seems to come down to Discord's way of protecting other people's names from being stolen.

The reservation system for users seems to work like this. Let's say your username on the old system is martin#0001. You've just recieved the notification to update your name. If you are the first user to recieve the new update, then Discord will let you choose the name 'martin'. The important part: only a user with the name martin#xxxx can claim 'martin'. So if your username was fish#0001 but you got the rollout before anyone had claimed 'martin', you would NOT be able to take it. It should also be noted due to the restrictions behind new usernames, 'MaRtIn#xxxx', 'Martin!#xxxx' would also count as being the same as just 'martin'.

What this does is cause problems for users with common names, as if a different Martin beats you to that name, Discord makes you pick a completely unique name- one that isn't used on the new OR the old username system. If you didn't get 'martin', but you wanted to get '_martin_', you'd better hope there isn't currently a user out there called _martin_#xxxx.

However, if you have a more specific name and are still waiting on the roll out, since only people with your name can take it, it prevents random users from sniping it from you. Another thing that should be noted is that if you had changed your username to something else after March 1st 2023 Discord will not let you pick that new name even if you're the first one - you'll also have to find something completely unique.

I hope this post sheds some light on the issue that so many people are having with not being able to claim names that aren't taken yet. Please note that the only thing Discord staff have said about this is that 'they are aware of it' and a lot of the information has been sourced by testing it with migrated users.

91 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

44

u/Fissie Jun 08 '23 edited Jun 23 '23

Been using the same name on Discord since 2015, never changed it, still can't claim it. Trying to add the name says it's unavailable. So I'd bet on this being wrong.

Edit in case anyone ever finds this: A friend who knows someone at Discord had them look into it, turns out the "e" in my name was a cyrillic e (like they use in russian), and they don't do username reservations for characters like that. I don't remember ever doing this, but I checked through the username on my badge and they were right. At least now I know why.

4

u/coldstar Jun 09 '23

Same here. December 2015 account, I couldn't claim the exact username I've been using for 7+ years. (And no one else had claimed the username.) After two days of trying multiple times a day to claim the name, a March 2016 account with no Nitro claims it. No idea how this is "first come, first served."

3

u/Fissie Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 23 '23

Mine still isn't taken, I've been checking at least once a day. I wouldn't have been mad at having to pick a username if I actually got to keep my name, or lost it to someone who has an older account at least... Now I'm just frustrated at the lack of transparency on how it all works.

Edit in case anyone ever finds this: A friend who knows someone at Discord had them look into it, turns out the "e" in my name was a cyrillic e (like they use in russian), and they don't do username reservations for characters like that. I don't remember ever doing this, but I checked through the username on my badge and they were right. At least now I know why.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

3

u/Fissie Jun 09 '23

Trying to add the username I've been trying to get. It just says to double check that the username is correct, which means no one is using it.

1

u/zileomefiu Jun 17 '23

Same thing happened to me as a small contect creator with 9k on tiktok

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

1

u/rlT-Tlr Jun 12 '23

You can check which usernames aren’t taken by trying to change your username but don’t put your password in. When you get prompted to do the robot check tap out of it (if on phone). It will either say “username is unavailable..” or it will say “password does not match” which means it is available

5

u/igniteice Jun 08 '23

I was ignite#0001 (through intro). Been on Discord since Oct 2016. I was unable to choose 'ignite' yesterday morning -- it said it was taken. It does not appear to be taken though. Oh well. I used the same name I use for everything else, igniteice. Not a big deal I guess.

1

u/boxs_of_kittens Jun 09 '23

I have the same exact issue. My name isn't taken, checked it by adding the name as a friend. I had it since Sep 2016, yet I can't claim it.

8

u/Ayanqmi Jun 08 '23

Is this information based on any evidence?

It does sound logical and it explains everything I've tested so far, this is pretty much the exact same theory I've come up with as it hasn't been proven wrong and no other information has surfaced about this. I'd love to get confirmation on this.

9

u/inikul Jun 08 '23 edited Jun 30 '23

If it's true, they definitely aren't held if any person had that name. I think there must be some sort of cut off in terms of registration dates. I saw someone say their name got taken by an earlier account, but they contacted that person only to find out that their name was taken and it was their second choice, meaning the later registration date person didn't get it reserved for some reason. However, they still weren't able to claim it.

Reading this again, though, the way it's written doesn't remove the possibility that the earlier user actually originally used the same name as the later user (their "second choice") and just wanted to change to a new one (their "preferred name").

4

u/Ayanqmi Jun 08 '23

Yeah, this "system" doesn't seem to explain everything, but we can't assume it's entirely wrong. I don't like to base my assumptions on anything that hasn't been proven yet, but we can't rule it out completely, as we have to assume there are more layers to this thing.

I hope we can get some answers soon so I can act accordingly, as I have the prompt myself, but can't seem to find any name that hasn't been taken or is unavailable.

Thank you for bringing this up.

1

u/awkwardist Jun 09 '23

It's not the only time I've heard someone mention Staff malfeasance. I saw a post yesterday that claimed they had a friend on staff who verified that "names of friends" were being reserved regardless of account status, age, etc.

But no proof was provided, no screen caps. I can absolutely believe it, but without actual proof, it's just more conjecture and theorycrafting for something that a lot of people dislike.

It sure does *feel* right, though. The same way most ambiguous "facts" feel right, depending on who's receiving them. Fun times we live in.

4

u/KeepTheMeemees Jun 09 '23

Member since 2015 and nitro and mine is taken, cancelling nitro now

3

u/Existing_Roll_9598 Jun 09 '23

What this does is cause problems for users with common names, as if a different Martin beats you to that name, Discord makes you pick a completely unique name- one that isn't used on the new OR the old username system. If you didn't get 'martin', but you wanted to get 'martin', you'd better hope there isn't currently a user out there called martin#xxxx.

The weird thing for me is, is I was able to claim “usernamey” (I was one of the many “Username”s before the update and obviously “username” itself was taken) and I had an alt that has the name Usernamey. It’s actually OLDER than my current account (but my current has nitro) so I should not have been able to get my name if it were reserved. But I was still able to? Maybe I’m reading this wrong but I’m not seeing how this should’ve worked.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '23

Whenever a company withholds information, it’s almost positive that something fishy is going on behind the scene that they don’t want exposed. We’ve seen screen shots these last few weeks of staff getting first pick on both their personal and business accounts. I’m sure there’s a system but a system with a lot of loop holes.

2

u/FrostedBooty Jun 08 '23

So how long is the name reserved for?? We have to wait until whoever gets a chance? So lame

2

u/daisypeachh Jun 09 '23

so what if the person it was reserved for never claims it? i feel like they can’t hold them indefinitely but i’ve been trying my preferred username for a few days now and it’s still unavailable but no one is using it

1

u/Richiieee Jun 09 '23

I just asked a similar question. I guess we just wait and hope with enough time it becomes available for anyone to claim?

1

u/Able_Palpitation1224 Jun 13 '23

Please someone answer this question

2

u/Richiieee Jun 09 '23

But then how long does that person have to claim it? What if days go by and the name still hasn't been claimed?

2

u/Kojelis Jun 09 '23

damn bloody annoying, it give me the option to get _username instead of username. when I try to add the username as friend it says its not found.

3

u/PandoraBot Jun 08 '23 edited Jun 10 '23

Doesn't seem right, I have two accounts with a certain very random name and I can't claim that name on either of those, when I try to add the username to check availability it says the user does not exist.

update: it looks like my third account which was created in 2017 was reserving the name instead of my two 2015 accounts... once I changed the name on that account I was able to claim it.

2

u/aerondda Jun 08 '23

In fact, there was a post on here a few weeks ago that explained how the reserving works that came from a Discord Partner.

Basically, it does not reserve a username for you based on whether you got the access first or not, the usernames are already reserved since a few weeks ago from a snapshot. So whatever username you had at that time was reserved for you IF your registration date is the earliest of any other user with the same name at that time (and of course assuming nobody with higher priority claimed it - such as a large Discord bot, staff, Discord partners, verified server owners, etc.). Otherwise (if someone with higher priority claimed your name or you are not the user with the earliest registration date), the username that was reserved for you is your username plus discriminator.

Here's the post (it was removed for whatever reason, scroll through the comments to find an archived version of it): https://www.reddit.com/r/discordapp/comments/13mceaw/

5

u/Ayanqmi Jun 08 '23

this doesn't explain the contradictions or anything brought up in the comments of this post, though

1

u/coldstar Jun 09 '23

It doesn't seem to grant priority by registration date, weirdly. I couldn't claim my username despite it being untaken. I have a December 2015 account. After two days of trying multiple times to get the name, a March 2016 account with no nitro gets the name.

1

u/aerondda Jun 09 '23

It's possible that the user who claimed it has higher priority (eg. discord partner, bot developer, staff, verified server owner). Reservations for regular users are the last priority pool and those are based on registration date, so perhaps that user did not claim it yet and claimed the reserved name just now. Or maybe I'm also wrong, who knows anymore. This whole reserving usernames is a very strange decision. I don't see why they didn't just convert all users to their reserved username right away if you have no chance to claim other names regardless, it seems this whole registration date based rollout makes no sense if everybody's username is already reserved anyway.

1

u/coldstar Jun 09 '23

I'm now thinking the name reservations aren't done by account age, but by how long you've had that name (or possibly when you first started using that name). I originally had a team tag on my name (e.g., WNxUsername) and only switched to solely the name itself ("Username") a few months later, shortly after the person who got the name created their account.

If that's true, though, it's very odd. They're rolling out the ability to choose usernames based on account age but then not using account age for reserved names, creating lots of confusion and seemingly unclaimable names.

1

u/StarlitBun Jun 10 '23

my issue with it is i changed my user all the time because there was no reason not to, so now with the change I wouldve liked to pick something to stick with but none of my choices are available even tho my account is old as heck

1

u/HearnKiwi Jun 09 '23

My account is as old as Nov 2nd, 2015 and my discriminator was #0001; and I still couldn't get my name. It was such a random drop too. Several names that I couldn't claim either and when I tried to add them to kindly ask for the name if they just got it on a whim it showed that no such user existed. It's really ridiculous. Worst update ever. Nitro does NOTHING for usernames now.

1

u/EthdGaming Jun 08 '23

Praying this is correct since nobody has my name, but other people who have had the name change haven't been able to claim it either

1

u/Kristalderp Jun 09 '23

I guess this is why I got my username first before others who had older accs by a few months even with Nitro (May 2016 vs jan 2016). I never changed my name or my 4 digits ever, but the other kristals did or joined later. So I had 1st pick prio to the name "Kristal".

1

u/fayemma Jun 09 '23

its downright the old system for me yet, i can change my username but i still have the numbers

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '23

same for me have you figured it out

1

u/DeathAtNoon Jun 10 '23

It wouldn't let me take "deathatnoon" despite me being like the only DeathAtNoon on the internet

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '23

the "death" part of the username might be against the username rules

1

u/DeathAtNoon Jun 12 '23

the issue with that theory, is that deathatnoon12 works

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '23

it never gave me the notification to claim my name and ive googled how to claim it and everything just says that you need tot make sure your email is verified (mine is alr). and ive restarted discord to make sure there isn't an update. when i go to setting>my account> edit username. it just does the same thing that it used to be when you changed your username. i also tried on the mobile app and no luck there either. can anyone help me. ive been using this username for a long ass time and i dont want to change it lmao.

1

u/Elegant-Bee5420 Jun 13 '23

i've used the same 4 letter username for 6 years now and got it today without any problem. this update is going to start a revelution.

1

u/XxPUSHPENDRAxX Jun 14 '23

Why I cannot claim my username "pushpendra". Its not taken by anyone!!

1

u/rand-o7 Jun 14 '23

I have had my account since late 2017, changed my name to Bucket-of-blonk in early 2019. and for some reason I can't get 'bucketofblonk' but I can get 'bucketofblonk.'. No one has 'bucketofblonk'. discord just wanted me to put a symbol for no reason

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23

Quick question.. I have 2 accounts which I wanted to swab their usernames. I changed 1 account's name to something random.. and the other to the first account's username.. but it said "this username is already taken".. how long is the cooldown for usernames?

1

u/cchlove Jun 20 '23

i have the same question but according to some other people, the cooldown is 24hrs. however, it's been over 24hrs for me already and i still haven't been able to change it...

1

u/tooclever4u Jul 07 '23

did you find out how long it takes?

1

u/leafyo Jun 16 '23

there are also some very old accounts that have the yellow exclamation mark in their profile and seems dumb to give them the username when it's most likely that they are inactive on discord. smh

1

u/zileomefiu Jun 17 '23

They reserved my username, i have a tiktok account with that username that has over 9k followers

1

u/Flayrox Jun 17 '23

It's super sad, my very first username was "Flayrox", I changed it to "Flay" so that people would call me by that one instead because it's shorter, but in fact my username on all the other networks and social media is "Flayrox". This means that I want the same thing on Discord, if I knew I would have put Flayrox back so that I could have it, I'm now afraid to know whether or not I'll be able to have it, because I'm sure that discord will eventually change the username of all accounts so that everyone adopts this new system, so I want to know if I'll be able to have it afterwards. Hopefully I'll be able to find some information in this post, thanks! (Discord, please make sure my username is available, I really don't want it to end up in the wild... The person whose username is reserved for me is probably inactive...)

1

u/rxocky Jun 25 '23

Exact same situation here

1

u/Chieriichi Jun 18 '23

What’s the reasoning for not allowing new names past March 1 ?? Is they’re completely new, I don’t get it 💀

1

u/oSuqi Jun 19 '23

I had my username auto reserved for me not really sure why or how but i know this because for one my username is 4 letters. two i had people in my server attempt to take my username from me just to see if they could and then would tell me my username might be taken already because it wouldn’t let them take it, i’ve been boosting for over 2 years and my account was made in 2018 but the day i got the username update low and behold i was able to take the username even though it wasn’t available for older discord accounts to do so. I am not friends with discord staff, i’m not partnered etc. the username rollout is just completely fucked and did not fairly or properly launch.

1

u/geminuri Jun 23 '23 edited Jun 23 '23

not true. lol. discord isn't reserving shit for anyone. my husband and i had our username#0001 for YEARS and we weren't able to claim our names. other people got it before us, obviously. we checked it by adding them to friends lists.. and they went through.

discord employees and those partnered with discord got first grabs and that's most likely why people with name#0001 didn't get their name.

or

discord's ability to let one person have Name#0001 and then name#0001, same spelling, just one was capitalized and the other was not. so then that would make 1 other person out there able to claim the name. We both had ours capitalized, but were aware that there was also a lowercased name out there being used by someone. so who knows. i personally don't think they were reserving anything for anyone just based on experience.

1

u/notsosolidsnakeOW Jun 25 '23

Like many people my name was taken so I took a varient of it And DMed the guy with it (not for any mal reasons just to chat about how funny our name choices were) We talked for a few weeks and he told me today he actually wanted to change names so I can take the original once it's up! He changed his and then several hours went by and my name is still not available but if I look it up the names being used by anyone either (when I go to add them) We found out that the name get to be held incas he wants to change it back?? (He tested this by changing his name back ) so does anyone know how long till the names free?

1

u/rxocky Jun 25 '23

Don't make your friend test this again, there is a cooldown period that's been speculated to be around 24h-48h and once this period is over the name becomes available. However if the original user changes their name back to to that name again that period resets. This is what a lot of people are calling "juggling" and what they're doing to keep rare names reserved for them.

1

u/notsosolidsnakeOW Jun 25 '23

Didn't have him do it he just tried on his own and figured as much So in 2 days the name should be available?

1

u/rxocky Jun 25 '23

That is the assumption anyway. I'm currently in the process of trying to a claim a username that's under a cooldown too so we'll see how that goes. Good luck!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '23

Waited 5 days now on one

1

u/notsosolidsnakeOW Jun 27 '23

i got it the next day, 24 hours unless its being rotated

1

u/BleedBluePunk Jun 26 '23

I changed my name to “blackcats” at it worked.

I then decided I wanted it on a different account so I changed it, logged on the other one, and changed it to that. It says it’s taken.

1

u/raalenjoyer Jun 26 '23

Yeah my name that I've had for a few years now is unavailable despite nobody claiming it.

1

u/Vexzy_ Jun 27 '23

I honestly hate this new system. Lost a username I made years ago.

1

u/OmniscientIniquitous Jun 30 '23

Don't worry guys, just make your username something like: "d1sc0rddevsareidiots." I did that.

My account is from 2016 and I had nitro (cancelled now obv) yet my username was reserved for someone else even though it isn't taken yet.

1

u/Exz1- Jul 08 '23

lets say I have 2 accounts, one account is named whatever but the another account has a username that i want to become my first account.... can i switch them or no?

1

u/JosephDaGenius1215 Jul 09 '23

couldn't get my user, no-one had claimed it and it was completely to myself. got the rollout before most, and someone got it before me. i managed to convince them to let me have it, and i tried to set it as my user after they changed it but it says it's still fucking unavailable even though i know for a fact it was available before. its been 3 days and i still can't fucking use it. absolute bullshit.

1

u/Ok-Distribution5632 Jul 10 '23

Why haven’t I gotten this option yet? I still have the numbers

1

u/Midspeed Jul 24 '23

I did recently try getting my new username and was thinking what the heck I've had my account since September 2016 and since it says supposedly my username is not available, I sent a request to what would be my username and that person has been a member since... April 2016 :'(

So I suppose at least that much makes sense.

1

u/ichigo-p Jun 09 '23

I agree with OP’s claim.

To verify this, I tried to change my own username to my friend’s or someone else’s username that I thought was unique enough and had not received the username update notification/dm.

For example, I searched for a username like “yotocoloxxxx” (xxxx being censored) which has 12 characters and attempted to change my username to that name. Surprisingly, it was not available. This shows that the name is reserved by discord to prevent others from taking it.

So the question is when will the reserved name become available?
Suppose you want to use “martin” as your default username but it is reserved. I think it will become available after the username update is completed for all users.
If the reserved username belongs to an inactive user, it might become available once the system changes their username automatically.
For instance, let’s say discord reserves “martin” for Martin#0001 and this user is inactive. I think after the deadline for the username change, discord will change Martin#0001 to “martin1” and then “martin” will be free for anyone. Of course, this is just my speculation based on what I found and experimented with.

I could be wrong. But I support OP’s claim.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23

[deleted]

34

u/Woofer210 Jun 08 '23

There are no good sources, discord won’t tell us anything, but this does appear to be how the system works

9

u/Ayanqmi Jun 08 '23

It'd be easy if it did, it sadly doesn't explain all of it, there's still contradictions.

9

u/rvcheeel Jun 08 '23

The source is trust me bro

3

u/PositivePlay9608 Jun 09 '23

his sources is that he made it the fuck up!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

1

u/scarifieuse Jun 10 '23

do we have any idea of how long the release cd is ? Are any of the username you claimed released now ?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23

[deleted]

1

u/Chieriichi Jun 18 '23

Does this holding function still apply (with the new account user refresh) with a completely new name that I made up after March 1 2023??

I realized that this is probably my problem as it has already been 24+ hours since my second alt changed off a name that I was saving for my first alt