r/discordapp • u/A-Coward-At-Heart • Jun 08 '23
Discussion Artists/Commissioners/Streamers/etc and the new username changes
So I'm an artist online (not the name of reddit account, this is an alt) and I've realized that this update uniquely screws with other users in my bubble. If you're using discord for personal or friend connection use, yeah the new name change sucks but in essence you could change your name and it won't be too huge of a deal overall, even though it sucks. However, for those who use discord for their business or freelancing, this has gotten fairly concerning.
My artist name has two versions to it, [main] and [main additional] if that makes sense. My main name is what I used for discord initially and for some of my other social accounts, but my main additional name I used for some of my more formal things like my website and such. I'm known as both but luckily my name is so niche that I had no issue getting [main] with the username switch (thank God).
However, as I'm sure other creators have thought about, there's now a huge issue with the way that usernames can be chosen now. Someone could take [main additional] and pretend to be me, and while unlikely for my particular situation, the fact that the usernames are now exclusive can make name scamming like this far more convincing. For some people, their main name could be already taken by someone else, meaning that they either have to think about rebranding or try to make it clear to their followers what their main account is.
At this point I'm questioning if I should make an alt account to claim [main additional] to try and protect it from being used otherwise, but if this is done en mass I can definetly see it being a source of issues. Users are already doing this to try and 'claim' popular or possibly purchasable names, and that's not my intent with my possible alt account. I'm simply nervous to lose my branding in case I ever wanted to switch to the former rather than the later.
For other creators, what are your thoughts? Have you already lost your name? Do you also have an alt name that you want to keep or are nervous about losing? I'd really like to hear your thoughts on this!
(Also, PLEASE NOTE: I know that the old system already had this issue with other impersonating accounts, but I've found that since people were aware of the fact that there can be repeated names, they were more careful overall to who they friended, dmed, gave information to, etc. With this update, I suspect that there will be less awareness to this and could lead to people falling for scams and such, but I do think this issue is moreso a thing with creators or those who use discord for monetary reasons.)
6
u/kkkkae_ Jun 09 '23
artist here as well, the thing i liked about discord usernames was that i didn't NEED to go by my artist username, it was cosy and private. but now I feel like i HAVE to go by my artist name in case someone takes my artist name, if that makes sense. and i hate that because while i communicate with some of my clients through discord, it's meant to be a chat app at its core, not a business app or social media. (plus I'd rather some people not know my artist name.)
4
u/throwaway_ballon92 Jun 09 '23
yeah i am in the same situation :( im just starting out but i rather keep things anonymous
4
4
u/MutaitoSensei Jun 09 '23
My post was deleted because apparently this one covers what I mentioned, but it isn't the case. I'll add to the conversation in this case.
My name was fairly common, so it got taken of course. Luckily my usual Steam name was not taken, so it's mine. Problem is, Discord offered me this differentiator as a suggestion:
Old: WildFlower#8639 Suggested: .wildflower
So, a tiny dot was somehow less misleading than 4 numbers? Nobody would miss the . If someone tries to impersonate the account holder?
This makes absolutely no sense. If anything, it will lead to more scams.
1
u/Scarlett_Temptress Jun 15 '23
This is exactly the "option" that I was "suggested"/"offered" by them. I've posted a response, to a response, already (which I'm about to retype into a reply to the main creator of that post, so my response actually gets seen.....)
Anyway, that was one thing that slipped my mind - while typing up my mini-essay - in the now (checks time...) over 6-7 hours that I've spent on this. .....it was that silly little dot, in front of my old username.
I may have not been on social media as much these past few years,* (I'm sure you understand what I'm referring to....it was that & also a lot of things happening in my life that are too personal for an internet post).... Getting back to the beginning of that sentence, regarding social media: (continued from *).....but I cannot think of more than maybe one or two (IF ANY) that start with a period (dot).
So, exactly what you said. Unless I am really out of touch, I don't see people (or large/small companies, or official organizations, or medical-related entities, or celebrities, or professional athletes, or....I can't think of any other good examples at the moment) who use "." at the beginning of the username/screenname/email anywhere.
So again, YES! One THOUSAND times YES! I can completely see how this may end up being a problem.
(If I forgot something, or made mistakes, my apologies, it's getting later and later, and I have been spending waaaay too much mental energy on this.)
2
u/thejawa Jun 08 '23
Someone could take [main additional] and pretend to be me, and while unlikely for my particular situation, the fact that the usernames are now exclusive can make name scamming like this far more convincing.
How is this different than on Etsy, Twitter, etc etc etc?
9
u/ernest314 Jun 08 '23
It's not, and those sites have the exact same issues. They all had to implement verification/reputation and maintain way more moderation in order to deal with it. The difference is Discord currently already has built a system that handles this much more elegantly, and they're actively choosing to dismantle it.
-1
u/majikayo666 Jun 08 '23
perhaps to fix this issue discord can start selling verified badge just like twitter does
7
u/beastpack Jun 08 '23
Not a creator, but it’s going to become hard to know whether the person with the username is the real guy or not. If I see a popular name, I’ll have to check and make sure the actual creator got their name before trusting. Which isn’t great.