r/discordapp • u/LaserPon3 • Jun 06 '23
Discussion Username change makes usernames more complex (roll back the system!)
The username change is doing the opposite of what it was said to do of "making names easier to remember" now for people to get names that matches their original online identity they have to add dots, underscores and random numbers to get the name they want....
Kinda defeats the purpose of getting rid of the discriminator... An easy solution would have been to just add another 0 at the front of all discriminators..
But let's be real here.. is 4 digits really that hard to remember? Like if you can't remember 4 digits you may have issues even remembering your bank pin code.
Now many leaks are showing up off discord moderators reserving name for themselves or their friends and pictures of servers who conspired to buy 2015 accounts that people changed the name off and put nitro on purely to reserve rare names in the system.
Why did the system not just look for how long someone has had their username in total to determine if they deserved reservation on the name rather then just "random account age and then current name?" Because this is the exact thing that people are abusing to sell off rare names for thousands now.
My name (laser) got snatched by a random user with a completely random discriminator despite having had discord almost at launch and having paid for nitro on launch day consistently all the way till here.... You know the same people that financially helped discord at an early stage to get where it's now?I have never changed my name or discriminator ever since i got discord...
I have had the username laser#0001 of my 2015 account from day 1 because I work in laser entertainment for 14 years now and it seemed only fitting... ive never changed it even once so naturally I prefer to keep my name like this..
Searching from: username in discord is now a chore because I had to add an Underscore + character to get my name... (good luck with searching in chat logs guys when many will go this route)
I guess paying about 1k a year for 8 years wasn't enough for discord? (nitro boosts)
42
u/UnanalyzablePeptide Jun 06 '23
I’m canceling mine and my boyfriend is canceling his. I doubt it will do anything, but we’re not gonna support a company that ignores their customers this blatantly.
→ More replies (2)5
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
thats the spirit :)
in the end the money will drive the choice.. and while discord also gains likely with partnerships and stuff.. the subscriptions shows crowd engagement and the willingness to stick with the plaform forward.
The same reason why meta made the quest headsets cheap at first was because you bought content on your meta account that added value and moneytairy attachment to your account.... removing nitro removes that in essence. (you are less likely to stick with something you arent paying for)
104
u/Lexden Jun 06 '23
Unfortunately, Discord has made it clear that they do not care about how much their users hate this change. They would rather sink their own metaphorical ship.
Also, it feels a little late to complain about the username change now that it's already implemented. They announced it over a month ago.
63
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
that month gave a great opertunity for people to prepare to snatch the considered rare names for account resell (4 5 character names)
They did make it clear that they knew people wouldnt like it sure.. but that doesn't mean they deserve a free pass for what they are doing.. I think it's absolutely justified we can rival up against it and give them a harder time.. i think canceling your nitro is a great start.. maybe giving their socials a harder time too.... because they will be placing bets things will blow over again and again and again if you just let it be.
→ More replies (2)12
u/Jirekianu Jun 06 '23
People canceled nitro subs at the announcement of the system. But a lot of people were either unaware, or hopeful they'd change their minds. So now that it's actually happening, people will be more motivated to respond to it. The actual implementation of this system and reverting it is easier than I think you assume it is.
→ More replies (1)3
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
reverting is absolutely possibleSince they store the old names of people in a badge saying "known as"They could use that as a point to revert to.
35
u/SuspiciousPrism Jun 06 '23
I'm seeing so many people in the comments of posts like this going "ooough guys its just discord being discord stop whinging about everything go get a life" like jesus christ if we don't spearhead against these shitty changes, the user experience will get worse and worse and worse until it's just corporates trying to beat each other out with which fanbase sucks them off more.
4
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
yep thats exactly it.. and i bet they already know they are getting away with it.. just like last huge scandal discord had that also had many unsubscribing.. to them: "temporary damage it will blow over because our competition isnt good enough".
I mean discords lack of comment or adressing should be more then a clear indication.
5
u/aplleh Jun 07 '23
It will get worse, just like cable tv, youtube, fb or anything social platform for that matter. Its milking time for discord
→ More replies (1)4
u/FierceDeity_ Jun 06 '23
Maybe they'll even limit non payers more, so people who could just not use cross-server emojis and all that jank get pressurized to get back into paying.
Because stabbing them right in the wallet is the most effective move, because through all the people on discord, we may not be able to get a mass exodus just yet
143
u/gunihaveiguess Jun 06 '23
Cancel it, we're all in this to bully discord together.
Besides, don't forget part of their 'reasoning' to this; "you want to be mike or jane but theres already 9999 of them! now you can get the name that you want!" which makes NO FUCKING SENSE because any variation of mike with the numbers 1 - 9 on the end is already taken so you have to resort to m8i2k9e or mmiikk112ee or m...i...k...222e or something like that. Its just more complicated and confusing than, as you said, remembering your bank pin.
81
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
Ah yes i couldnt be "mike#1111 anymore so now i am M1k37774423
So much simpler53
u/gunihaveiguess Jun 06 '23
that is exactly, their reasoning, but with the tagline; "before you couldn't always get the username you wanted, but now you can for sure!" ;) no tricks
i wanna see their profits suffer
→ More replies (1)17
u/Spacemayo Jun 06 '23
I didn't even know my discriminator because I didn't have nitro. If I needed it I just looked at my profile and copied it. That system wasn't hard at all. If someone couldn't figure it out that's on them. Now we get to go back to the aol days of XxSepithrothCloudxX.
I'm from 2015 and still waiting on my change. Someone already claimed the name I use anyway.
→ More replies (10)9
Jun 06 '23
"if you wanna add my discord it's 'm1ke99.', make sure you include the dot, 'm1ke99' is a different guy"
18
Jun 06 '23
Plus...I don't think ANYONE said out loud 'add me on discord my username is n1cerackbru#1832" ever
we all send out tag to the person. Simple as that.
→ More replies (4)25
u/insomniacsCataclysm Jun 06 '23
also thei reasoning isn’t even accurate. if you wanted to have “Mike”, you could literally just keep clicking the “create account” button until it found an unused discriminator
22
u/gunihaveiguess Jun 06 '23
Correct! Even if there is 9999 of them (WHICH IS HIGHLY UNLIKELY), you could still add like a single period and try until you get an unused discrimator
→ More replies (1)8
u/NightOfTheLivingHam Jun 06 '23
It reminds me of what connect wise did with screen connects Linux server version. They got rid of it because of an exploit in the windows version that did not affect the legs version. Therefore they had to discontinue the Linux version because of a zero day exploit that affected windows. That was their rationale for killing it. Which annoys those of us you don't want to get an extra windows license to run one service.
→ More replies (1)7
u/iHaku Jun 06 '23
you also just... never need to use it.
if you meet someone on discord, you add them directly.
if you meet someone online, you tab out and see the ID.
if you meet someone irl you... pull out your phone and check the ID on your discord app.
lor you just remember it, but i cba to do that when i have access to it already 100% of the time.
20
u/Flawed_L0gic Jun 06 '23
Cancelling nitro at the end of my subscription. Drop in the bucket but I'm just not content with supporting a platform that engages in this level of destructive changes whilst giving nothing but radio silence.
1
4
u/Rukitorth Jun 06 '23
Even when they make necessary changes they seem to avoid communicating why its necessary, like, why?
35
u/Eli_White_ Jun 06 '23
Cancel your nitro Genuinely Discord users should be cancelling nitro and migrating en masse. Discord devs have shown repeatedly that they're either too stupid and oblivious to understand their product, their user base, and everything between. Or they just don't care and will do what they want with Discord and turn it into their personal playground.
Even if you're not upset about the name system explicitly Discord has shown they don't care about us, or discords sustainability
We're being given a faulty, lesser product that benefits the devs, and when we get upset, they come here, spit in our faces, and tell us we NEED the change. Remember guys, discord is a company And companies aren't your friend There's ALWAYS alternatives
→ More replies (4)20
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
i think its less the devs and more the higher ups in this case.
I bet plenty of devs would speak out if it werent for their job on the line doing so.→ More replies (2)
63
u/heavenlydelusion Jun 06 '23
They're never going to roll it back. A lot of us including me are pissed off but there's the other group of people who managed to get the names they wanted who are all happy and supportive of the changed
6
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
I sadly think the same... because most companies refuse to acknowledge their mistakes and just believe in it blowing over...
Honestly more reason to give them a hard time... make an example out of this company being so disrespectful to their userbase.
11
u/pikapichupi Jun 06 '23
I agree, at this point they are in a sunk cost policy. Even before they publicly announced it they would have put a lot of man hours into making this change, they had the reserved username list already generated prior to making the public announcement and they started converting staff members over to the new system the same day they made the announcement, which means that the back end was already in place to start making the change before they even announced they were making the change,
a change like that isn't as easy as changing a primary key and dumping a column in a table they would have had to code in the API for and they would have to do sanitation checks they have to have a system that can check whether or not you are allowed to update your name, they needed the front end side to show you the alert and be able to check whether or not the name has been used already, plus they needed a system to be able to properly reserve your username and if that name is already reserved reserve a secondary name based off your username and discriminator while also limiting that reserved username to only be available by you based off the seniority and status of your account, it's not as easy as it sounds making something like that. Lots of wasted money in both directions in my opinion
7
u/DigitalPrincess234 Jun 06 '23
Honestly I personally would respect discord a LOT if they came out and said “we weren’t in touch with our community when we did this, that was our mistake” and rolled it back. NO COMPANY does that and it would be a shocker.
Yes they’d lose a lot but right now their nitro subs are dropping like.
Well I don’t have a specific number so not flies—
But long term this loss of trust is going to affect them. Disc has burnt me one too many times and because of that I’ll be leaving the platform once my social group does/using alternatives whenever available. They’ve lost my support expect for the bare minimum interaction since they kind of have this niche to themselves.
→ More replies (1)38
u/ItzYuzuru Jun 06 '23
I haven't gotten my username yet but if i get it I'd still hate on this. The old system was just million times better. Having discriminators literally made it so people on the platform wouldn't be discriminated. The irony in that statement
23
u/Detenator Jun 06 '23
I got my username. This system is the most braindead decision I have ever seen them make.
Super reactions are kind of stupid but it's not a step backwards. Soundboard is kind of useless for me but it's still a bonus feature. But this is strictly a big fuck you, especially to anybody who purchased original nitro to change their discriminator.
→ More replies (2)1
12
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
to adress impersonisation and the old system: Just remove unicode? Or limit it using whitelisted character sets?? Then individually give people who used such characters a clear timeframe to think of alternatives.. rather then a "SURPRISE" roll out like we have been getting.
9
u/ciel_lanila Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
If impersonation fighting was a reason, a person I know is experiencing irony. People frequented targeted them for impersonation down to copying their avatar and bio info.
When they woke up they found they missed their slot and someone else got their name.
EDIT:
Looks like they were able to work out a solution with the person that got their name. In this case, it seemed to be two people aiming for the same name legitimately instead of one of the impersonators snagging it.
377
u/LowerSorbet7240 Jun 06 '23
The irony of this is?
Discord are removing discriminators "to make it easier to find friends". But I was playing Among Us earlier tonight (yeah yeah, shush, I like it), and d'you know what? I just recalled the devs for the game added discriminator usernames so that you could add friends in Among Us.
Literally how far are the Discord devs' heads up their own asses????
255
u/DorkMuffin6730 Jun 06 '23
xbox changed too to add a 4 number discriminator system. battlenet as well. actually going backwards
46
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
because it incentivises people to use more common names while keeping the descriminators organized with numbers.. its a far better system.
169
u/greeneggiwegs Jun 06 '23
Fucking splatoon has it now. It seems like everyone is moving TOWARDS it
→ More replies (3)67
u/LowerSorbet7240 Jun 06 '23
Really? Damn, news to me! Good on 'em
Apparently TeamSpeak are also adding discriminators to their usernames.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (6)49
u/inikul Jun 06 '23
battle.net actually has 5 digit discriminators. How futuristic.
→ More replies (6)42
u/Dreamerlax Jun 06 '23
To chase the Twatter/IG user base.
12
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
twitter has been in decline and either you start with something or you stick with what you have.. simple
10
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
why does a gaming platform want that anyway? they arent even a direct chatting platform minus the horrible dm way
34
u/pikapichupi Jun 06 '23
This right here is exactly what they're trying to do and it's stupid, he saw that Twitter is a roaring dumpster fire and that users are fleeing the platform left and right so he's trying to incentivize those users leaving the platform, without realizing that there are multiple better options than Discord for them to flee to. No one uses Discord for the same use case that Twitter does they're completely different platforms. Twitter is for social media and news updates Discord is for communication and live chat, two completely different areas I wouldn't even begin to recommend Discord as a replacement for Twitter, I barely recommend masodon as a replacement for Twitter lol
→ More replies (1)25
u/Cringelord123456 Jun 06 '23
Discord doesn't actually care about simplicity. All their claims that it makes it easier are lies, and they know it. They actually want to make their site more akin to places like Instagram or Snapchat, but they're just lying to people so they don't piss us off even more.
33
u/pikapichupi Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Battle.net actually started with discriminators, there is zero point to a system having unique names in 2023, especially a system such as Discord which already has a user ID to uniquely identify users. The username plus discriminator combo was more ease of access for people to be able to find someone while keeping the same identity, on the database side they're not going to be using you username anyway to identify the user what's freaking stupid is the fact that they knew that my name was already reserved so they reserved my name plus my discriminator as the username that I should keep what the hell at that point what is the point
lol I got downvoted, I think I must have found the one person who liked this username change
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)4
u/Pomodorosan Jun 06 '23
Battle.net uses discriminators...
Companies always have a reason to make changes, and they also have a "reason" which they tell the userbase.
20
Jun 06 '23
Whoever is pushing this change needs to be fired stat.
13
3
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
Also before someone mentions about username in servers: You could have done with with a discriminator too.
On top of that despite changing your username.. if you use commands like:
From: username
it will be hard to search your name if you used an _ to find your posts because you will end up having to type much more to start a search.
→ More replies (1)
8
Jun 06 '23
TL;DR - Discord needs to revert back to their original username system, as it was working perfectly fine and they had no reason to change it.
This “new” Username system change has been getting hate. Hate to the extent of Discord users saying “Let’s switch platforms,” “Any better platforms than Discord?” and even a user making a claim stating that this new username change is “unsafe” for Discord users.
The old username system was working perfectly fine, no issues nor problems and Discord didn’t have a reason to switch to this new and weird system which provides disservice to almost all of users on Discord.
Discord really needs to get their shit together and stop bringing disservice to their users, just to kiss ass to their investors and shareholders. Discord should be providing a service, not a disservice making everyone wanting to boycott the service.
Quite hypocritical for me to say this as I am making this response, however we shouldn’t be complaining in a Reddit forum/ thread; because only a select few of discord staff sees these posts, replies, etc. We need to go to Discord’s official site, create tickets to tell the developers to revert back to their old username system.
6
Jun 06 '23
Not to mention, it wasn’t even that hard to memorize the 4 digit number (discriminator) at the end of a Username. The discriminator system made user’s account secure, but with this update, it’s less safer and secure.
→ More replies (1)1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
please make tickets.. please spam their twitter comments where they pretend all is good and well.. provoke a official response from discord..
4
u/Swagsire Jun 06 '23
I'm kinda confused about this whole thing. You can still have display names, right? Like those aren't going anywhere right? Why does the username matter? No one uses their full username in servers anyway. People will likely still use whatever their display name is.
Plus can't you avoid this whole situation by just making your username Bob5722 but have the display name still be Bob like it always has? I understand people are upset about the whole situation but I wasn't really sure why when display names have always been a thing.
→ More replies (2)1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
username matters because its used in commands and chat search and now i have to say "add me Underscore laser"
Instead of add me laser 0001 which is MUCH easier to remember.Also searching means having to type in all kind of weird characters just to do a chat search.. absolute pain... seems like a small thing but if you use discord every single day.. gets old quick
4
u/casualknowledge Jun 06 '23
We can also solve the "official account" problem with discriminators. Make something like #0000 unobtainable through normal means, something Discord gives to "official" users, e.g. partners, brands, etc. This can also be treated specially by Discord so Doritos#0000 will render as just Doritos.
1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
yes exactly.. or just dont allow those reaaaaly specific names and ditch unicode already.. done
3
u/0oohno Jun 06 '23
wait has it started i didnt know
5
u/Shagyam Jun 06 '23
Yes.
A lot of staff, Devs and server owners already had their pick. Yesterday a lot of good 2015 accounts got their pick too.
3
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
me got that yesterday but my account was snatched by someone who likely bought a slightly earlier 2015 account and changed their username to play the reservation card.There are screenshots floating around of discord account sale servers who were selling and providing instructions 1~2 months prior to all this
it's pretty easy to tell because they have a very random discriminator meaning they didn't have that username early on (otherwise they would have customized it)
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)3
7
u/TheWaslijn Jun 06 '23
Roll back the system? Yeah they ain't gonna do that :(
6
u/LaserPon3 Jun 06 '23
it would be a massive statement though and they can because you have badge that says "used to be known as"
6
u/diamondpic69 Jun 06 '23
Only way forward is to cancel. They don't pay attention to the reddit. Vote with your wallets, it affects the shareholders too
4
u/OnyxDesigns Jun 06 '23
Every time discord does something this whole sub says they're gonna cancel their nitro in protest and yet doing that hasn't accomplished anything yet. You guys are a vocal minority.
→ More replies (3)
801
u/Aerocatia Jun 06 '23
They did not even tell us when the rollout was starting so we could be there and at least have a chance.
I lost the name I have had on discord for over 7 years, with nitro since nitro tags existed, all because I am not glued to the internet 24/7.
I feel cheated.
249
u/nxqv Jun 06 '23
Yep I missed it by less than an hour and the names I wanted got yoinked. My backup names are all seemingly "reserved" and can't be taken despite no one having them.
108
Jun 06 '23
If I was to guess, they are reserved by some inactive 2015 accounts.
108
u/SigiSeaver Jun 06 '23
There's no actual reservation for regular accounts. I lost mine to an account that's younger than mine. If there was reservation I should have had the chance first.
If names are being reserved it has to be by discord specifically I'm guessing.
→ More replies (12)20
u/TheMerryMeatMan Jun 06 '23
There's definitely a reservation system, but it's a shit one and we know for a fact that staff have been grabbing up vanity names for themselves in the process
→ More replies (2)25
u/tysonedwards Jun 06 '23
Same. I have a 2015 account with Nitro for most of it. I am still waiting for the “opportunity” to choose my new username, and my 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th picks are all taken. And not like I am trying for something especially unique or exciting. 2 are common misspellings of my name!
This rollout is all manner of mismanaged.
→ More replies (1)10
u/PDX_Aaron Jun 06 '23
I have a 2016 account and still haven’t gotten the rollout smh
→ More replies (8)13
5
u/National-Bison-3236 Jun 06 '23
As far as i know the username changes aren‘t even all at once, but rather spread over a few weeks
5
u/amblerkr Jun 07 '23
You're right, Discord should have given more notice.
People with time differences may be at a disadvantage.
→ More replies (13)5
u/Resies Jun 06 '23
Yeah I've had name#0001 for at least 4 or 5 years, if not longer, and I lost it despite being March 2016 with at least 5 years of nitro and glued to the internet.
→ More replies (1)
153
u/SpaceyWazey Jun 06 '23
Canceled Nitro today, at this point I'd suggest others to do the same.
61
→ More replies (3)16
u/YamiZee1 Jun 06 '23
I didn't actually pay for nitro, but I got it for free on epic games. Cancelled immediately after getting it lol
2
u/somatopsychic Jun 06 '23
In come the username complaint posts lol I've been waiting for this since they announced it, I wonder how/if discord will react at all. Hope you get your username though.
1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 24 '23 edited Jun 24 '23
as expected they will ignore it.. they wont even hint at it in the slightest. Even on their twitter they didn't post the announcement and intentionally ignore anyone who even mentions it.. the new "Clear all friend requests" feature is because people with "rare names" got mass added and rather then blaming it on that they instead said
"when you join a random roblox server.. pretty sure a stab towards guilded being funded by roblox"
It signals the company is doomed with the future going down the same route as many big companies went from being "honest and transparent" to being sneaky.. closed... and forcefull
I know you can't simply switch platforms but to make a user transition easier I suggest most people to make an account on say guilded or matrix and just run both platforms next to eachother for now.. that way it becomes an easier deal for more to do the same.
2
u/itthiccomode Jun 07 '23
Right? I was talking to some members on a discord server yesterday about the change and was wondering the same thing. They all sat down, and came to an entire system rework over just adding another fucking zero? Ridiculous.
1
2
u/konxchos Jun 07 '23
the discord mods reserving names for themselves is pretty dumb imo especially when they should be the ones to have discord_(their name here). like that steve guy who stole the name steve and stole the name taco for his alt account no less lmao
1
2
u/AirDur Jun 07 '23
sam871902 is easier to remember than Sam#7809 for Discord staff, apparently
1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 24 '23
I dont doubt they knew this would happen.
There is a hidden motive thats either preserved for the future or something else... but whatever it is: discord isn't being honest with us.
2
u/InotSydxx Jun 23 '23
The worst part is that it makes it so much harder to friend people because when I was trying to friend somebody I met online they kept saying the user is wrong and my friend says my user doesn’t exist
1
u/LaserPon3 Jul 02 '23
The worst part is that it makes it so much harder to friend people because when I was trying to friend somebody I met online they kept saying the user is wrong and my friend says my user doesn’t exist
to me the worst part is the search now bing awful.
If i type in
"From: Laser
It will not auto fill in or think "oh thats his shown name" and list results in the discord client....Nope i have to fill "laser.exe" every time to get that to work... so broken
133
u/Acendia Jun 06 '23
Chiming in, also cancelled Nitro for the first time. Just as you said, this change does literally the opposite of what they said it was meant to accomplish, it was so foreseeable too. I wasn't aware that such a change was even coming until it prompted me to do so yet I immediately understood the ramifications.
My trust in them being able to keep a high quality service plummeted in an instant.
7
u/Quirky-Stress-823 Jun 07 '23
The limit of 9999 Mikes was too low, so we changed it to 1.
— Discord
→ More replies (3)
242
u/Gobeman1 Jun 06 '23
can't wait for the return of xxx_the_real_bean_xxx kinda names
71
u/Dreamerlax Jun 06 '23
I guess newer users will be forced to use variations of that lol.
→ More replies (2)19
u/MembershipContent918 Jun 06 '23
I had a long standing account that was from 2015 but it ended up being deleted because I had lost my 2FA and discord said nothing I could do without those codes. So I ended up making a new account this year so now I'm at the back of the line with my preferred name almost guaranteed to be gone forever. I like the old system better...couldn't they have just added a qr code to scam that was unique per user. That's something pokemon go has. It's pretty simple and effective.
19
15
→ More replies (3)37
339
u/SloidVoid Jun 06 '23
Cancelled my nitro. This system is garbage and no one wanted it.
35
→ More replies (4)42
60
u/Synergiance Jun 06 '23
“Made my and my friends names simpler though, you all are just exaggerating” - discord devs, probably.
→ More replies (2)
266
u/Fabfixer Jun 06 '23
Cancel your nitro, also canceled mine after having it for ~5 years, Join the resistance brother, you're not alone.
it's pointless now, we don't get anything for the nitro.
37
18
12
u/daten-shi Jun 06 '23
I've just cancelled mine as well. I've had Nitro consistently since 07/07/2018, and even had it here and there before that with my 2015 account.
50
u/CompleetRandom Jun 06 '23
Just cancelled as well, I'm so fucking done. Been supporting them for years
50
u/encarton Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 07 '23
Similar situation for me. A younger account that didn't appear to have nitro got my preferred name. Sent in a support ticket about it and got an automated response. Replied to that and got a human response, but of course there is nothing they can do about it. But hey, at least they got my complaint.
I've also since canceled my long time Nitro sub that I've had since the start basically and made sure to put in the reason as the new naming system. Sadly it won't be felt until Jan since it is a year sub.
This is all could have been avoided if they made the username change with the case and special character restrictions but also just... kept the discriminators. It would have avoided so much trouble.
Now we'll have to deal with:
Squatters
Stalkers
Black markets
Increased attacks to steal names (hacking, IRL threats, etc)
More confusing names to remember since you have to append random stuff to your desired name, hard for both you to remember and for other people to remember when you share it with them!
Favoritism; Discord has been seen revoking some claimed names to give them to brands, e-celebrities, and so on
And more!
75
u/Kyl0_Bren Jun 06 '23
It's funny cuz you can literally just copy your full username by clicking/tapping it once. It's really not that hard, you don't even need to memorize those 4 numbers if it's that hard
41
u/Kyl0_Bren Jun 06 '23
Or just, you know
look with your eyes31
u/Fittsa Jun 06 '23
but trust me guys it'll be so much easier to remember Katey293729622 over Katey#7263!!!!!!!!!!!!
→ More replies (1)
68
u/dragu_la Jun 06 '23
I've literally not seen ONE positive comment about this new username system. What the hell makes them think this is good??? Sounds like one person suggested it and they ran with it cus they have no other ideas for the app.
Bye dragula, definitely not getting that one. I am dragu_la or dragu.la on a lot of things, but I'm guessing those will be taken too... resorting to the old xxdragu1axx probably 🙄.
→ More replies (30)
28
u/Craft57738 Jun 06 '23
It’s almost as if changing a username system 8 years in is a bad idea. Literally adding one or two more digits into the discriminator would’ve been easier. Hell, people used to remember phone numbers (and you should still know yours), so what’s so hard about remembering a number you use every day especially when you can copy paste it?
→ More replies (1)5
u/FierceDeity_ Jun 06 '23
Hell people used to remember ICQ numbers rather than names. They just kept adding digits and people started selling low digit ICQ numbers. But here, this is not something PERSONALIZED. If someone wants their first name and it's obviously taken, of course that's gonna hurt much more. I'd rather have my first name and 5 random numbers because hey, I don't need the numbers to be part of my identity, but JoshXx2352 will be part of the identity
24
5
u/SkippyThe13th Jun 06 '23
I really don't understand why everyone is so worked up over this. We still have display names. I literally never look at my username as it exists behind my display name.
→ More replies (4)1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 24 '23
it makes searching a lot more difficult because that's based of your username and not your display names.
3
u/-Lugubrious- Jun 07 '23
FYI, if you were the FIRST person to use your "USERNAME", that you say is yours.... you will get it.
Don't be mad because you were the 35th hundred Kittenuwu and think you should be the one to get the name.
1
3
20
u/ThaSaxDerp Jun 06 '23
I keep seeing the "people can't remember their discriminator" but like... Pull out your phone and look at it. I've had the same one since 2015 and have no idea what it is lol
16
u/ZennyRL Jun 06 '23
I think that's part of what ruined the statistic discord collected in the first place, they think nobody can remember it but it's that nobody has needed to. We have phones
16
16
54
u/Pureomnipotence Jun 06 '23
Bro cancel your nitro. I cancelled mine nitro after a 2016 user got my name. Screw giving them money anymore.
21
u/pikapichupi Jun 06 '23
Yeah I was forced into it yesterday, I have Nitro (have since 2017) and my accounts from 2015 my top six names were taken already, I don't know how they did the name reservation system on the back end but it's absolutely trash, I'm glad they're still a display name but I really think that the discriminator system was significantly better. If their system was to remove all sense of identity from someone they succeeded tenfold
→ More replies (3)
3
Jun 06 '23
Me personally couldn't care less how much you people paid for Nitro.
It should not matter at all. Then you go and complain about "pay to win" models in games.
Hilariously ironic.
1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 24 '23
in the end someone has to fund a platform to keep it available for everyone.. why punish those people?
→ More replies (1)
8
Jun 06 '23
It's easy, cancel nitro, switch to other platforms, let the memory of what was once a safe heaven crumble to dust,
4
Jun 06 '23
The problem is, there aren’t “better” platforms that can compete with the level of Discord.
→ More replies (4)
26
u/ItzYuzuru Jun 06 '23
It's gonna be a devastating blow on discord's financial condition as most people (including me ofcourse) straight out cancelled their nitro sub. Supporting the application for years and this is the best they got for us is just sad. I wanted to preserve the nitro classic for years to come as it's not available anymore and would be smth like a souvenir but fuck it, would rather save the money for smth else
→ More replies (1)18
u/Shirinx Jun 06 '23
I'm gonna be honest, if that were true and "most" subs did unsub I really think something would have been done. I'm actually willing to be the numbers aren't as high as we wish they were
→ More replies (10)
7
u/ClogsInBronteland Jun 06 '23
The easy remembering of names was never the real reason. That was just an excuse to push it through.
7
u/RepulsiveAd2971 Jun 06 '23
Look into Guilded, it pretty much seems to be Discord but with features we have been begging for years for.
→ More replies (2)0
6
u/A-Lamia Jun 06 '23
I have never paid for Nitro, so I don't feel too bad about it, but when I made my account, there were no discriminators; they even advertised signing up to reserve your name, and I did (lamia), and I got my name snipped because I live on the other side of the world. I also remember when they advertised getting rid of unique names as being better for everyone. I was a little salty, but it was for the best; now I just feel double bad lol. They also advertised having a smaller memory footprint and using less CPU than Skype.
I guess they've lied about two things now.
6
u/DizzySlurpo Jun 06 '23
it's such p2w trash considering it seems like the only people that are even able to pick currently are nitro subscribers, my account is a non-nitro 2015 account and i still haven't gotten a prompt to change my name at all.
2
Jun 06 '23
you can make your new username laser0001, whats the issue?
→ More replies (1)1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
because it looks bad.
With the discriminator there was a good reason to.Now its just a mockery.
2
u/MindBlownGaming Jun 06 '23
Discord has to honor intellectual property and my name is trademarked. So, when it’s available for me to change my username without the digits and it’s taken I’ll have hit discord with a Notice of intellectual property claim and notice of intent to sue.
1
10
u/Nuclear_Kim_Jong_un Jun 06 '23
They're going full corpo mode, don't care about the user base anymore.
6
u/ManySleeplessNights Jun 06 '23
It's a shame too cos they were one of the last well known media platforms that still retained some sense of personality and uniqueness about them. Nothing lasts forever I guess.
5
u/VoxNerduli Jun 06 '23
I was thinking about buying nitro yesterday. Well looks like i’m not doing that now!
5
5
u/Hot_Hat_1225 Jun 06 '23
I so agree. I have always supported Discord and defended them against all kinds of changes causing uproars. Name plus hashtag plus discriminator was so easy to remember since 2017 and easy to tell others searching for me. Underscores, dots and what not just to make my name somewhat similar to before I find much harder and plain annoying. Some changes didn’t make me happy, but I accepted, but this for the first time made me actually UNhappy :/
5
13
u/riverofpower Jun 06 '23
Nitro since beginning of 2017, cancelled after someone who’s never supported discord sniped my username. I’m done with discord, it’s been straight downhill since 2017. The instant an alternative comes around I’m gone.
→ More replies (4)
4
u/National-Bison-3236 Jun 06 '23
There is one thing i don‘t understand about this entire thing…
who needs to remember usernames in the first place? If you want a new friend then you either have their username from a server or ask them, why would you have to remember it?
4
u/Sleeked Jun 06 '23
Long time supporter and my account was created in Dec 2015. Lost name to random account from 2016. I thought it was supposed to be order of account created but clearly not. I've cancelled my nitro as well. Usernames don't need to be changed at all. I'd agree with the lowercase but other than that, this change is stupid.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/AdmiralToucan Jun 06 '23
I lost my name to a 2021 account that bought nitro 4 days ago, even though my account was made in June 2015. I'll be cancelling my Nitro because I don't know how a newer account was above me in priority.
4
u/Anomaline Jun 06 '23
Two days into the rollout and every name I want is taken unless I start adding random numbers and crap to them.
So nice to be using a service for seven years only to be told to fuck off and pick a new name because someone else got dibs.
4
u/AlexWIWA Jun 07 '23
We memorize phone numbers and zipcodes, but discord thinks 5 digits is too hard.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/SignificantWolf119 Jun 06 '23
1k a year on discord? you’re a loser lmfao
3
u/Molasses95 Jun 07 '23
And you probably spend 1k on something that someone else doesn't like. Good job 👍
→ More replies (3)1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
well that's uncalled for.
I use a platform daily and at the time I felt it was worth it to me.. consider some people spend thousands on some of their games or on going to clubs or casinos... that's absolutely your choice and there is nothing wrong with it..→ More replies (1)
1
u/Beginning-Idea2170 Jun 07 '23
Just curious, are you able to make your new name have the number still? Like could you just make the new name “laser#0001?”
1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
i believe you can only have underscores and dots.. which doesn't really look or search great at all. It made sense when everyone was pulled on a similar level of having numbers but now it's just dumb.
1
u/InfiniteFraise Jun 07 '23
well, sr LaserPon3, looks like you found a new name here in Reddit. So you can find another (or even the same, if you want) name for discord :)
1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
my name on reddit is actually very old. I never figured out how to change it and would if I could have.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/theadrux Jun 07 '23
imo, discord doesn't care about us at all. I read somewhere that this change was catered towards brands that want their original @ names so, since we're not the target for this change, fuck y'all.
I guess they wager that brands are going to pay more than you guy's nitro
2
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
they could literally have made exceptional rule for brands not having a discriminator at all and regular users to still maintain it.. would have solved it without forcing anyone to change anything from their day 1 names.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/GabaMC Jun 07 '23
While I agree with most of the things, I disagree with one thing: That it makes it more complex for the simple user to realize how this works. The thing is, we are already used to this system for most of social media, even YouTube recently, so, it's not that big of a deal to the average user, but what I agree is that there are a lot of fishy stuff that can happened behind all of this
1
u/LaserPon3 Jun 07 '23
yeah but those started like that day 1
the only drastic change youtube had was locking in emails with accounts because people changed emails of compromised accounts to steal them.However this is so late stage that its simply not ok... There is also a lot of untold motives because the alibis for this change seem somewhat very weak and aren't holding much reason for the amount of anger this is logically creating.
1
u/tr6umph Jun 14 '23
wait, will i be able to change my username back to my old one ? or are they completely robbing you of being able to pick a username ?
1
1
u/Sami_1999 Jun 23 '23
Discord becoming more normie with each year.
They redesigned their home page from that gamer type to normie thingy, simplified their logo and text and now they made the user name like other social media services.
Can't wait to find out what they downgrade over the next few years.
1
u/LaserPon3 Jul 02 '23
same happened to their advertising.. its now not marketing to gamers anymore.. its now trying to be everything.. I think discord has lost grip of their targeted audience quite sometime ago.
6
u/RisingFire2 Jun 06 '23
The funny thing about this is just that "Oh hey we want more people to be able to use the name mike" or something.. But in reality sure, you can have that be done but you also can't.. In a way. Like say you want your tag with @ to have mike in it u/mike is not available because oh guess what, it's.. Not unique enough. Oh what about @ mike2 nope. @ mike nz.. Idk. Like honestly it just.. Feels like a system that's gonna cause more problems then solutions.
3
u/NesuneNyx Jun 06 '23
I got my desired name, after a good bit of anxiety and worry that it'd be taken.
That said...
Fuck discord for following through and pushing this after all the backlash. Fuck nitro. Fuck any single cent for them with such an asinine change.
3
u/ibeatyou9 Jun 06 '23
I managed to get eve. I've had 6 other people message me upset they didn't get. 0001 and 0002 were both sad I got it. This system is so stupid. Let us be numerically different again.
→ More replies (3)
3
u/staticecho Jun 06 '23
I kept my nitro when they said they would give nitro users first chances in hopes I’d keep the username I’ve had since June 2015. Now this is being rolled out and I’ve seen non nitro users who made their account after mine already get to pick usernames. Not only are the discord staff cheating us, the whole thing they said about how earlier users would get access to this change first was nothing but a lie. Canceling my nitro right now, I wasn’t happy with this change but now that they have been actively caught screwing over their community I won’t support them in the slightest anymore. — am still waiting to be able to do the name change.
3
u/AccomplishedLack2549 Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
EDIT: i canceled my nitro after 3 years. i'm not giving money to developers who can't even give me the time or day so i can have a CHANCE to solve an issue THEY created. thanks for your continued support discord, keep it up!
im so sick and tired of discord. no encryption, a bunch of ultimately useless features that get added that we're paying for through nitro subs, and now impersonation- the thing we wanted to stop- is much easier.
didn't give us a time or chance to be around. thought since i worked from home i'd be able to secure my own account at least, guess not.
forced to use discord, forced to pay for it to boost a server i moderate, and i'm repaid by getting my money over 3 years taken, my discriminator that i initially bought nitro to change taken, and my username taken
i'm done paying for nitro and i'm tired of handing over money to developers who don't even listen. 100% was robbed today.
3
u/Jirekianu Jun 06 '23
Account sales, people being harassed in DMs, and discord giving front of the line cuts for their friends/admins.
Truly, this is better than discords claims that half or so of users couldn't figure out the discriminator system. I'm really glad we have to deal with XxXRealtem0genXxX shit all over again. Great job guys.
Whatever executive(s) made this decision I hope shit their pants in public.
3
u/Cyndergate Jun 07 '23
I have a 2015 account, October. Early Supporter. Nitro for years consistently.
A 2016 account who's not partner, and with not having nitro as long - got my username I've had for eight over seven years. They got the update yesterday.
I still haven't gotten the update.
2
u/planetarial Jun 06 '23
Yeah it really feels nice that I got my username taken when I've had it since early 2016
2
u/Nood1e Jun 06 '23
I just tried to add someone to message them using their new name, but I can't because I need to put the 4 digits after their name. What a shit system.
2
u/Crotaro Jun 06 '23
Yea, fuck this, I'll make my name the same as it was, discriminator included.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
2
u/LadyDalama Jun 06 '23
I'm a 2016 account with no Nitro and I'm still waiting to be offered the opportunity to change my name.. What a shit system.
2
u/atuarre Jun 06 '23
I don't like how the username thing was rolled out. All the good short usernames have been snatched up by the people who got to pick first because of whatever bs excuse they gave for people to be able to go first. Everyone should have been able to change their username at the same time. If they were so worried about brands, then freeze those names from the jump.
2
u/ks0908 Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 30 '23
Content removed (using Power Delete Suite) as I no longer wish to support a company that seeks to both undermine its users/moderators/developers AND make a profit on their backs.
To understand why check out the summary at hhttps://www.reddit.com/r/Save3rdPartyApps/comments/14hkd5u
I do not consent for content of my posts to be restored by Reddit Staff or subreddit moderators, no matter how usefull for community they may or may not be. If such restored posts are noticed a complaint will be raised with EU in regards of violating GDPR provisions
2
u/cakey_cakes Jun 06 '23
Sharing stuff (ie from imgur, reddit etc) to people via mobile shows their username rather than their nickname and idk who is who right now unleas their nicknames match their usernames. This system is stupid.
2
u/GravityMan5 Jun 06 '23
I feel like we might need to go to... extreme measures to revert this change.
2
u/Dante8411 Jun 07 '23
It was absolutely not that discriminators were too complicated. I straight-up don't buy that. I don't know EXACTLY how, probably by pushing Nitro, but this change has to be motivated by greed, and as soon as they ask me to ruin my name I'm asking my friends if they're willing to shit to an alternative.
2
2
Jun 07 '23
My friend got a three letter word as a name (the same word he has had as a name for many years) and has gotten around 30 friend requests from random people he dosen't know, I don't understand what kind of shit they are smoking over at Discord Hq but I want some
2
u/Spebby Jun 07 '23 edited Jun 07 '23
I've had this username for a pretty long time, not since discord launched, but for at least 6 years or so. My account is from 2015, had nitro, and has been active and an account from 2016 got the username already. I've still not been given the option to get one of the new usernames.
EDIT: joined the rest of the thread and cancelled my nitro.
2
u/Stormflier Jun 07 '23
Damn its almost like everything everyone warned them about that they plugged their ears and went "I'm not listening you're just hating!" to was completely true.
2
u/IamOverIt8 Jun 07 '23 edited Jun 07 '23
Glad I'm not the only one pissed off about this. Has there been any official comment about this bullshit?
The icing on the cake for me is my new username has a lowercase first letter and not capitalized. My OCD is flaring up, because I know I capitllalized it. I have to pay $10 to capitalize it now. 😆
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Droploris Jun 07 '23
I'm doing my part, canceled nitro just now
A big reason to why ive had Nitro was being able to customize the discriminator - it's gone now
2
Jun 10 '23
“Four digits isn’t that hard to remember” ~ dude who is upset he can’t have 001 anymore as his discriminator
2
u/Captain_Cosmos_Red Jun 11 '23
It’s fucking stupid. One of the key things that made discord better than other social media apps was that multiple people can have the same username and all that unique bullshit could be avoided. Now it’s all fucked up. It’s by far the worst “update” ever and I’m extremely pissed. I’m gonna lose my username, there’s no way in hell I’ll get to keep it, even though it’s what I’m known as and a second name for me.
4 digits is not hard to remember. People can fucking write it down if it’s difficult to remember. And now it’s gonna be 100x harder and more annoying just to make a fucking username.
I think that we should give ‘em heck. Everyone in the discord community should rant about why this sucks everywhere. Even if nothing is done, it’s worth a shot, at least to express how pissed we are.
→ More replies (1)
2
209
u/MilesPikachu Jun 06 '23
Despite all the backlash they still push this update, I canceled mine once I got the notification.