r/discordapp • • Jun 09 '23

Discussion What if discord had forced pomelo, but retained discrims?

I believe forcing every user into a pomelo handle but retaining discriminators resolves most of the issues raised in their announcement. While this is still inconvenient for many users, I still think this is much less disruptive - you certainly don't get people fighting over names.

In fact, they could add 2 more digits to the discriminator, and then no one would be fighting over names (any more than they already are).

Thoughts?

====

Downside I see is that it fails to create unique users in the same format as other social media, their likely main goal of the update although I haven't seen them say it explicitly.

25 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

23

u/Hazboi Jun 10 '23

you're on the right track, but the optimal solution imo would just have been to keep the old username system. it's worked as intended for 8 years now, there's no need for a change lol

9

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '23

Old system with an extra digit, keep display names because they're actually good

15

u/dapperwoke Jun 10 '23

discord went one step forward with the whole display name change and 12 steps back with their username change.

3

u/throwawayemail420 Jun 13 '23

Imagine you have something unique. Literally nobody else on the internet is identified with how you do it. It only required four digits (not groups of numbers, just four bytes!) for you to stand out among dozens of competitors, including being able to turn down a $10 billion purchase offer with no stigma attached. Nobody has a problem with it. Nobody except the people intent to monetize every atom in the universe. Flush that whole thing down the drain because you want to look exactly like everyone else after a system that's identified you for eight years. AND THEN YOU DO IT WORSE.

3

u/SiggiJG Jun 16 '23

If the old username system was such a huge problem, a better solution would have been to do what Steam does. Allow unlimited people to have the same name, with no discriminators, no restrictions on what characters can be in your name, and use friend codes to add friends. It works!

Then literally everyone can have the name they want even if there are already 9999 Mikes and 9999 Janes, no name black market, and no need to worry about some creep trying to violate your privacy using just your name. And everyone would be happy!

And if they still wanted to have a reason for people to subscribe to Nitro, maybe make vanity friend codes a Nitro perk.

2

u/Hazboi Jun 16 '23

this, absolutely. i'd prefer it over going back to discrims, honestly. every user already has a unique id anyway!

5

u/FlurryShy Jun 10 '23

in the end every user has always been unique and identified by their numerical ID. the username#discrim as well as the pomelo are nothing more than aliases to your ID. so yes, they could have easily done a pomelo style alias besides the discriminator style alias. and that is more or less how it works right now as well since all merged accounts have username#0000 for (presumably) backwards-compatibility. my old android app still works but shows people as such.

would it be somewhat confusing to have multiple IDs? maybe. would it have been better than what they did? absolutely.

2

u/blazincannons Jun 15 '23

Can you fill me in on what pomelo is? Is it a naming style or scheme?

2

u/FlurryShy Jun 16 '23

it is Discords internal name for the unique username "feature". found via data-mining and modifying the client.

2

u/Agant Jun 10 '23

What would've made more sense is to give a random number and don't let people change it. I say that because they said it was creating more "discrimination". Ironic how it's even more discriminatory with the change.

Someone already proposed to add a letter, it's even better, it add way more possibility.

They're just making it like facebook, twitter and more and sell it.

1

u/throwawayemail420 Jun 13 '23

It makes a lot more sense than what they're doing now.

Nerd rant: Factorio is a good example, which uses the Lua Programming language. Basically, Lua's naming scheme uses [A-Za-z_0-9] to identify "simple" names. A minus isn't in there, because a minus means subtraction, and would be "bad" to use in a simple name. Except they do allow a "full" description, and [the Factorio developers] picked a consistent style to turn all spaces in game names with hyphens instead. The result was almost nobody used random unicode stuff or random casing, lowercase and hyphen-as-space and minus' go where they go (and it's easy to tell them apart), and it's all voluntary.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23

And make the usernames even more complicated? Thanks no, imagine having to add ┈━═☆❣️xx丅𝚒ꪑꪑ𝒚xxx❣️☆═━┈#917402, the @ is way better, and it’s not a big deal if you don’t get the exact one you wanted just set the display name as whatever you want, done problem solved.

2

u/AuroraCelery Jun 15 '23

I'm glad they got rid of special characters from usernames and replaced it with display names, but fr, there was no reason to change how the entire system works and replace it with one that limits your users even further. they could've easily kept the discrims

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '23

then it's the user's fault for setting that as their username

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '23

It's been 4 months 💀

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '23

/shrug

0

u/miqumi May 17 '25

was there any need to remove the #discrim?