r/discordapp • • Jun 14 '23

Discussion If Microsoft can add #digits to profiles the why is discord removing them??

482 Upvotes

161 comments sorted by

37

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23 edited Jun 14 '23

Because it’s not aways there are #, they only are added when your username is already used by another user.

11

u/Og_Enigma Jun 14 '23

I know how it works. What im asking is if microsoft can add it as NEW FEATURE and pull it off then why is discord removing it? There is zero point in this from the consumer side

7

u/hydrogelic Jun 14 '23

They laughed at me when i wanted ms to go ahead and buy discord. Look how much they are ruining it themselves

6

u/dont-respond Jun 14 '23

Such an odd system, but I guess they didn't want to take away usernames from people that have had them for like 15 years, but also needed to address the fact that there's a finite number of desirable names, so at least they give a shit

0

u/Og_Enigma Jun 14 '23

Released in 2015, my account was made early 2017 - is that not enough tenure? They took my username away from me so your point doesnt stand

Finite names is the reason microsoft switched to using #discriminators, discord is just going backwards

3

u/dont-respond Jun 14 '23

You misread my comment. We're talking about xbox

1

u/Og_Enigma Jun 14 '23

My bad, long day πŸ˜…

1

u/RevivedThrinaxodon Jun 14 '23

"It's evolving, just backwards"

24

u/povi9 Jun 14 '23

That's true.
Source: Xbox Support

Anyway, YouTube recently introduced its handles. WhatsApp is also rumored to be considering usernames. That's what popular platforms want.

6

u/AaronTechnic Jun 14 '23

YouTube usernames are a positive change. Finding a youtube channel that's small is hard when you can choose the same name.

10

u/davidemo89 Jun 14 '23

This is what we had 25 years ago, a long time before social networks even existed. Why do you all think discriminators are a gaming things? Nicknames where a gaming thing

-6

u/povi9 Jun 14 '23

Personally, I think discriminators are a gaming thing. When introducing the change which is the update of usernames, it turned out that for many people the problem is to add a number to the nickname. Usernames are universal, and I believe that was one of the big reasons for the change.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23 edited May 05 '24

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/povi9 Jun 14 '23

Currently, it's your opinion. No reference to my entire message. So, do you know 5-10 places of (popular) non-gaming websites/apps/services that have usernames with discriminators?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23 edited May 04 '24

[removed] β€” view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

When exactly did he "move the goalpost"? He very clearly said "personally" can you not read? Are you always this pissed off? That can't be healthy. Get some help

5

u/Kenchy710 Jun 14 '23

Yep, this is the right answer.

3

u/mrstoffer Jun 14 '23

And most games don't even support the # and just tuck the 4 digits after your username

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

Yea that kind of breaks the point because would be the same as adding numbers on your name so you could have it, but the way it works is that the games need to add support to it normally newer games have but old ones no, but not every new game has it sometimes they don't.

258

u/EternalShadows060 Jun 14 '23

Cuz half the company by now is probably being run by people who used to work in social networks smh

56

u/SamiTheAnxiousBean Jun 14 '23

literally that tho

according to glassdoor they've started employing a shit ton of social media managers instead of social/community managers and employees as higher ups

106

u/AcousticJamm Jun 14 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

Because Discord is being run by monkeys

Edit: What I said is very offensive. I apologize to any monkeys I offended.

28

u/YaBoiHS Jun 14 '23

Now now, monkeys are actually smarter than discord employees.

5

u/Neutrovertido Jun 15 '23

jesus christ, that edit was brutal

5

u/Cherry_Yo1n Jun 15 '23

as a fellow monkey i thank you for your apology

2

u/jedimoogle Jun 15 '23

it's alright man, we're still workign on that script tho.

181

u/sosiskha Jun 14 '23

because discriminators are a gamer thing and discord wants to grow their userbase by appealing to a broader audience

104

u/Bedu009 Jun 14 '23

Which they already fucking did it's a chat platform smh
What's next? They gonna change the logo?

80

u/vlken69 Jun 14 '23

What's next? They gonna change the logo?

Do you think this is the initial logo?

46

u/Bedu009 Jun 14 '23

It's still the original design just simplified
But the design is based on a game controller

37

u/EpicCode Jun 14 '23

Old logo was still better too πŸ˜”

22

u/SHBazTBone Jun 14 '23

Old logo AND the old font.

4

u/AgentSquirrely Jun 14 '23

The old font and logo did look more appealing to gamers

16

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

It looked more appealing period. We need to stop amplifying this narrative that there's a dichotomy between "gamer" and "functional".

-16

u/Aspyse Jun 14 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

No it objectively wasn't. There are valid criticisms for Discord's recent decisions but just blatantly hopping on the hate train like this is icky. The old logo was asymmetrical and had elements far too thin to print on small media or to display properly on small screens. It vastly improved on scalability while completely retaining brand recognition.

There have been countless bad corporate logo redesigns, Discord's wasn't one of them.

EDIT: These are explicitly the reasons they stated for the redesign, and are straight up just fundamental design principles. They set out to fix these issues, and they did, without compromising its identity or even its overall silhouette.

8

u/malthev1111 Jun 14 '23

Nah old logo was better

8

u/Xfigico Jun 14 '23

The controller logo I prefer the new one honestly. Looks cleaner and the weird wing things are gone which I always thought looked off

That font and blurple change though hurt my eyes and soul. The old ones looked cool and were unique enough, man

2

u/Cu5s3d Jun 14 '23

I'd honestly like to see what small screen the old logo wouldn't have been properly displayed on, and if the new logo would look better. I can't quite think of any screen the discord logo would ever appear on that would cause it to look janky.

1

u/VirtuousContract Jun 14 '23

Whitney was a good font to use, Ginto sucked ass.

I like "gg sans", but the name could have been so much cooler.

0

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

How dare stuff not be symmetrical just because. We need more logos that are just four colors blended on a different setting like every Google product now.

1

u/FlyingAsparagus142 Jun 15 '23

wumpus sobbing in the corner

25

u/DexClem Jun 14 '23

Might change the logo to a blue bird or a big F, maybe. That might actually suit them.

5

u/Bedu009 Jun 14 '23

Thankfully they'd get sued

2

u/jedimoogle Jun 15 '23

they're p close to getting that F in chat right now...

5

u/FlurryShy Jun 14 '23

nah... they did that 2 years ago already... so it'll be fine for another 2-4 years probably... wonder what current eye-bleed-blue turns into then? neon-flashbang-blue?

but fear not! they will find other ways to fuck up till then πŸ‘

1

u/Cancer000 Jun 14 '23

team up with instagram to make forums the main method of communication

1

u/jedimoogle Jun 15 '23

they did.

4

u/Boiez Jun 14 '23

But like the core idea of discord that it is made for gamers and not the broader audience. I get that they can change that 'idea', but they're just straying from their original approach.

13

u/CptBlackBird2 Jun 14 '23

gamers love discriminators because the average gamer is great at discrimination

10

u/Synergiance Jun 14 '23

Discriminators are only thought of as a gamer thing. It’s stupid to go along with that line of thought.

9

u/ItzYaBoiLegend Jun 14 '23

Discord was originally made for gamers. Its old name on the play store was Discord Chat For Gamers

9

u/shurpness Jun 14 '23

I remember when their homepage compared themselves to Skype, TeamSpeak and one other I forgot and telling us to ditch em as Discord was "better". Tbh, I feel like the pandemic really changed Discord a lot and I wonder where Discord would've been right now if it weren't for the pandemic. They even have templates for study group and school club when you want to create a server.

3

u/NvaderGir Jun 14 '23

There were "study room" discords where people would do homework or study with webcam on and muted. Yes the pandemic changed Discord

3

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

And people are back in the office/classroom and companies are using tools like Slack that are actually built for business use and/or running through a enterprise VPN.

Discord is trying to hitch its wagon to a horse that doesn't exist anymore.

1

u/ItzYaBoiLegend Jun 14 '23

Very true. A lot has changed in dc after the pandemic.

2

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

"Gamer thing" my god damned foot. Just because Zuckerberg doesn't do it doesn't mean "only gamers like a clean name".

2

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

Uh, no, discriminators are not "a gamer thing", it's simply a solution to a "supply" problem.

Imagine if surnames didn't exist and only one person on the planet could have a specific name at any one time. It'd be absolutely stupid and Discord is inviting essentially that, creating a problem that was already solved.

2

u/ThatFatGuyMJL Jun 14 '23

It's not only that.

Discord biggest mistake was letting people change the numbers.

This had caused a major issue with people pretending to be others and getting away with it did to those 4 numbers at the end.

If you couldn't change the discriminator I don't think they'd have removed it

1

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

Being able to change the number was an actual viable solution to the "harassment lightning rod" that permanent names have already created.

0

u/Darcano Jun 14 '23

That's shifting the blame away from people blindly falling for it. Besides, now it just means there's a lot of competition between scammers for names that big actors use, but one or two letters are changed, like m and rn, l and I, o and 0, etc.

1

u/summonsays Jun 15 '23

Yeah that ain't happening. I pitched to use discord at work (I'm in IT and our office is all IT people). The older people couldn't get past the name "Discord". Man I just want a voice chat I can turn individual people up or down in : (.

10

u/AgentSquirrely Jun 14 '23

Discord is backwards back to the 2000s scandals they go

28

u/ValseHoop Jun 14 '23

Because according to discord we (the users) are to dumb to remember 4 number

7

u/VirtuousContract Jun 14 '23

Seeing how many users fall for the most obvious of scams, I do think that a lot of users are not capable of remembering four digits. However, this is a good thing and probably one of the few things that were protecting themselves of even worse things.

1

u/AcousticJamm Aug 17 '23

Yea sure, because I'd ALWAYS remember a full-on username better than a 4-digit number. And the username is always going to be EXACTLY what I expect, right?

23

u/Inserthouse235 Jun 14 '23

Discord has been sabotaged by crooks in white suits that only care about profits!!!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23

[deleted]

2

u/Inserthouse235 Jun 15 '23

θͺ°γ οΌŸ

16

u/win7rules Jun 14 '23

Because discord doesn’t care about their users, and apparently they think remembering x.x._tim2917481848_x.x is easier than remembering tim#9174

2

u/ChuckNorrisUSAF Jun 14 '23

Works fine with #s on BNet.

2

u/YourDarlingNoor Jun 15 '23

For years on xbox, you had unique names but a few years ago they added tags just like how battle net works, lol the fact that discord is going backwards amazes me...

3

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

To copy other social networks to appeal to investors as a safer option because they're not doing anything weird or different.

2

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

Insinuating social networks are successful because they don't have a discriminator is like saying the same network is successful because of the color of the share button. Completely inconsequential.

1

u/artemuswithau Jun 14 '23

Aren't only a handful of games supporting this modern username system, though? I know when I played Halo: MCC, my GT was [name]1234 rather than [name]#1234. Correct me if I'm wrong.

1

u/Xfernandox91 Jun 14 '23

Not even just on Xbox, it's been working perfectly fine for discord since the beginning of discord

1

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

Why should Microsoft's actions be a standard? Anything they touch turns to dust

1

u/livelaughjoe Jun 15 '23

theyre changing EVERYTHING and its so annoying

1

u/Matthew98788 Jun 15 '23

Discord dying for our discriminators

1

u/jedimoogle Jun 15 '23

I read over the highlights

>former Meta staff

ah. fuck all of us, every one. we are boned.

-1

u/worMatty Jun 14 '23

Here is the official blog post explaining why.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[removed] β€” view removed comment

-6

u/v941 Jun 15 '23

i like the change, the reason they gave is good too, its pretty hard to add people with font names and zero width spaces

5

u/Maxie_69 Jun 15 '23

...and xxxsex69master69420noscopexxx is easier?

1

u/v941 Jun 15 '23

yes actually, that is much easier to type than π•©π•©π•©π–˜π–Šπ–π–’π–†π–˜π–™π–Šπ–—69π–“π–”π–˜π–ˆπ–”π–•π–Šπ•©π•©π•©#6171

1

u/Maxie_69 Jun 15 '23

Except you won't need to name yourself that because a whooping 9999 people can have the same exact name, you could literally just put sex or walter as your username and it'd work. That's the whole point here

1

u/v941 Jun 15 '23

correct you also dont need to name yourself xxxsex69master69420noscopexxx

if ur old name was walter#8985 just be walter8985 and use walter as ur display name, nobody will care

2

u/Maxie_69 Jun 15 '23

And THAT shows how pointless and stupid the update is, what are they aiming for here? At least reddit has a reason to charge $20M for third party apps albeit dumb as hell, they want money. What will discord get from this? It won't even make them extra money and there is zero situations where they will ever make money from this, they're doing this for the sake of change

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23

[deleted]

1

u/Maxie_69 Jun 16 '23

Are you a professional moron or just a gifted amateur? That's literally the comment i just replied to, i told you already NOBODY needs to fucking have that username in the first place because 9999 people can have the exact same username. The number has gone down to 1, what part did you not understand here?

→ More replies (0)

-3

u/saladLO Jun 15 '23

dont name yourself that then easy

5

u/Maxie_69 Jun 15 '23

What would i name myself then? saladLO? My usual username is already taken and i had to use a more complicated one, this is a downgrade

1

u/saladLO Jun 15 '23

what is your current username right now

1

u/Maxie_69 Jun 15 '23

MaxerV19, changed from Maxie

-4

u/saladLO Jun 15 '23

dude, its not a big deal. why cant mfs understand that?? just change your display name to maxie, your actual username will only be needed when people want to add you

6

u/Maxie_69 Jun 15 '23

Yeah but why even do this when discriminators worked perfectly? There was absolutely nothing wrong about it, and i don't like the idea of display name since that's just the equivalent of server nicknames but global

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Certain_Attention_24 Jun 15 '23

Why is this a big deal for you?

1

u/Vandheer23 Jun 15 '23

it’s a big deal because not only is it trying to fix something that didn’t beed to be fixed in the first place, but is also bound to cause even further issues with account selling. It was already an issue with certain badges (I’ve had offers from people to buy my account for the early supporter badge), and now that only one person can have a username at a time, that problem is only going to be amplified.

-4

u/Marbletm Jun 14 '23

It surprises me how little people actually know the full context behind the decision.Here's a copy of a Discord message I sent to a friend explaining it:

So, they wanted to get rid of names with capitalized letters to prevent scam and such. They couldn't just change all accounts to lower case because of the discriminator though. It was possible for both the account Username#0001 and username#0001 to exist at the same time, so then Username#0001 could no longer have their discriminator because username#0001 would get it, this would mean that 1/3rd of Discord would be affected in some way. It could be that they could no longer have their discriminator or that there weren't enough discriminators around for the amount of people wanting the nickname.So that's when they thought of the new display name field.The display name would be for the people who wouldn't be able to get their username because of the limit on the amount of people who could claim a certain username.But having a display name, server nickname, tag and discriminator is a bit much from a UX (User Experience) perspective.So, they did away with the discriminator to simplify it.

I based the information in there on a blog post by Discord.

I get the decision, I understand why they felt the need to do it, I will continue using Discord, but I don't like it.

4

u/Ispita Jun 14 '23 edited Jun 14 '23

If this is really a reason just reroll the Username#0001 to username#anything. This change was not done because of any technical limitation. They also said that only 9999 people could use the same name so now only 1 can. What a great change! They could have solved this just by adding more numbers to the end or simply the person that wanted let's say mike just juse mike1#number like that but now thousands of people that used mike are forced to put stupid number to their name because there can only be 1 mike.

No one had the spine to explain them at discord? Fire them all useless people and hire someone that actually knows shit.

2

u/Alliyna Jun 14 '23

I mean, they could've just added a 5th digit. Blizzard does it just fine

3

u/SkeleToasty Jun 14 '23

Or even done what valorant does and allow for letter discriminators too lmao. Discord just didn’t think of everything before rolling out a garbage update

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23

Letter discriminators would look worse than adding another number, imo.

2

u/BrodatyBear Jun 14 '23

1/3rd of Discord would be affected in some way

Now it's 100%.
I agree that having usernames case-sensitive was a bad design (it negatively surprised me like 1/2 year ago). Imho a good practice would be to allow different cases, but having checks case-insensitive.
Example for clarity: you can name yourself Marbletm#ABCD or marbletm#ABCD or MarbleTM#ABCD but 2 accounts with different cases are not possible, e.g. if MarbleTM#ABCD, then Marbletm#ABCD is not allowed).

There are many ways to mitigate that in a better way and sure, some people would have to change names anyway, but the current one is IMHO the worst one and affects everyone.
Another problem is that before the rollout, people suggested changes but discord refused to participate in the discussion when it was in a better state. Some staff just responded with quotes from their article, and since then there's been silence.

0

u/Ispita Jun 14 '23

They know for sure that they messed up they just don't know what to do. They don't want to look like an absolute clown by rolling it back.

-1

u/Prajwal-_- Jun 14 '23

They are expanding (userbase 😁)

-2

u/Beacda Jun 14 '23

Well that's how life runs

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/Beacda Jun 15 '23

I did have something to say. If you don't like it, then don't interact.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

17

u/GMDMelonYT Jun 14 '23

unless discord themselves are selling accounts then they gain practically nothing from this

18

u/ShaeTsu Jun 14 '23

They gain money from all the companies that paid for this to happen so they could have official branded accounts with no discriminators for their massive community servers.

15

u/le_honk Jun 14 '23

They could've made it only for THEM in that case. Like, if someone has no discriminator, they're legitemately the partnered guy

1

u/Ihcend Jun 14 '23

no they probably didn't. an official branded account would most likely be a bot in a server with a help token. except bots are going to keep the discriminator for now so it doesn't even benefit them.

2

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

Permanent, immutable identifiers are a data harvester's wet dream.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

8

u/Og_Enigma Jun 14 '23

Easier to share? You know there is a β€œcopy id” button right? Doing that adds the # automatically, its not like to have to remeber the digits seperately….

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

5

u/Cu5s3d Jun 14 '23

Yeah, people always ask for my discord out on the street while my phone is dead, i'm glad they're removing the big numbers so i can remember my nickname now

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

2

u/VirtuousContract Jun 14 '23

If someone can't remember four numbers, they probably do not care about their Discord account enough which probably means that they have never been asked to provide their name and discriminator outside of the internet.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

0

u/SkeleToasty Jun 14 '23

Dawg. Just take the L

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

1

u/SkeleToasty Jun 14 '23

One experience doesn’t speak for millions of others though

→ More replies (0)

1

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

If you're under the belief "x_b0b1234_x" is easier than Bob#1234 then nobody here can help you.

0

u/TTV_ExpertNugget Jun 14 '23

it's not that bad.. besides no one has a username like that, not when every other site has the same username system as discord is adapting to

1

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

Bullshit, look at just about any online platform with more than a handful of users and you'll see countless names looking like that. "Adapting to" (nice euphemism for regression) that system is how you get more of them, not less. It was such a problem with Xbox Live that led to them changing the system to begin with.

Some will outright suggest mangled nonsense when a name is taken.

0

u/TTV_ExpertNugget Jun 14 '23

whatever dude I like it, you don't idrc. argue with me all you like it's not gonna change fuck all

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

16

u/Og_Enigma Jun 14 '23

I cant expect to have a super short name even though i have had this super short name since my account creation in 2017? Nice logic man…

And the discriminator isnt what i want - i want the user name that i have been using for 6 years!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

-1

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

so it is unreasonable to expect to get a simple username like that on a platform of hundreds of millions

Worked fine for eight years.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

1

u/TheKanten Jun 14 '23

And now if someone wants to add you, you have to give them whatever jumbled mess Discord forced you into rather than 4 digits you had the ability to choose on your own.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)

7

u/EternalShadows060 Jun 14 '23

Discord certainly failed to address that problem

0

u/Doctor_Lark Jun 14 '23

I can and do expect a super short username when it's the one I've had since 2018. My username has been my name since then, but now it's some random variation I had to fight with for 30 minutes to get that I don't even remember cause it is something born out of brute force instead of being the one I wanted. I'd much rather just have a #1532 after my name than the shit I got.

1

u/SleepingAnt Jun 15 '23

You joined in 2018... 3 years after the platform launched and was already hugely popular at the time, and you expect to be able to claim a short username?

You were just late broski 🀣

1

u/Doctor_Lark Jun 21 '23

After I already had it and it got taken away for no good reason? Yeah, you're damn right I expect it

25

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[removed] β€” view removed comment

15

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

Discord was thinking?

7

u/Caesarin0 Jun 14 '23

They may not have a brain, but they had an idea.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

How inconsiderate of me.

2

u/saladLO Jun 14 '23

it sucks on xbox. it forces you to have numbers on your username without telling you

1

u/AgentSquirrely Jun 14 '23

Well at least its more secured which is much better

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23

I mean, to get the new username I got a message on my Xbox telling me "Hey, usernames are changing, put in your new one and alternate now"

So unless they gave you one of those individually written out alternate usernames (Without the discriminator) without asking you what you wanted it to be, you were absolutely told.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

[deleted]

3

u/saladLO Jun 14 '23

"The better system" is, in fact, NOT the one that shoves very visible numbers on a username you have to PAY to change.

There are not many games who support the feature to HIDE them.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23

Actually, it's that some games don't support the new usernames, which is why they had you put in an alternate when updating your username on Xbox if/when they updated it.