r/discordapp • u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 • Jun 09 '23
Media Comparison between old and new username format
2
u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 Jun 10 '23
Given that all canceling nitro would do is push you further down the que for getting to pick your name there's active incentive to not cancel instead, but with length of nitro subscription also being a factor there's no real incentive to buy nitro if you weren't already wanting it for something else
2
u/worMatty Jun 09 '23
Did you include the discriminator on the old format?
1
u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 Jun 10 '23
I had but I realized after posting this that the math by which I did was very incorrect and the numbers should actually be much higher
2
u/Smargesthrow Jun 10 '23
You forget that all ascii and and languages were previously allowed in the username. It's much much more than that.
1
u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 Jun 15 '23
All of those use the unicode format, which is where I got the number of characters available for the old format
179
u/Noodl14 Jun 09 '23
cant wait for XxxJake4089xxX
139
u/YaBoiBoiBoiBoi Jun 09 '23
Sorry buddy no capital letters allowed, names are locked to all lowercase because we can’t have nice things
26
u/TheCouncilOfVoices Jun 09 '23
This is what pisses me off the most. I hate having numbers visible in my username and I hate underscores. So now I’m just a sentence that all runs together on discord. :( Why must they take my capital letters away along with this bullshit update
1
20
39
u/PandaGamer8999 Jun 09 '23
x.x.x.jake_4089.x.x.x incoming
73
u/Negitive545 Jun 09 '23
Oh but don't worry, remembering x..x.x.jake__4_089.x.x..x is easier to remember than Jake#4091, so this update makes finding people easier
19
u/Hot_Hat_1225 Jun 09 '23
Sending text to Jake: “Hey Bud, I can’t find you on Discord 😭 can you repeat your name again and where all the dots and stuff go?”
1
u/RemarkableVanilla Jun 12 '23
Discord in a couple of weeks: Don't worry, we made QR codes for your friends to scan, to add you!
Thanks, Future Discord. /s
2
u/Hot_Hat_1225 Jun 12 '23
Text to Jake: “Thanks a lot bud! Scanned one of those darn QR codes you mentioned exist now to make it easier since I couldn’t get your stupid name right and my account is gone 🤬. Have fun, I’m back to MySpace.”
3
u/ShirBlackspots Jun 09 '23
Except no special characters are allowed, so just 32^36 (32 character name that can have a combination of 26 letters and/or 10 numbers) = 1.5324955408658888583583470271503e+54 user names.
There's approximately 2^33 people on the planet (8.59 billion). There's plenty
0
Jun 10 '23
[deleted]
1
u/ShirBlackspots Jun 10 '23
No, its correct.
4
u/FierceDeity_ Jun 10 '23
No it's not, also 26 chars, 10 digits, period and underscore.
So 38, 38 ^ 32, because for example 2 ^ 8 is the amount of numbers 8 bit unsigned integers can represent, 256 (0-255).
You wrote 32 ^ 36, which would be 32 characters repeated 36 times.
3
u/ShirBlackspots Jun 10 '23
Hmm... So then it becomes 3.5733461779443360768808234403936e+50 possible user name combinations if someone uses all 32 characters.
→ More replies (22)2
9
u/BlendedBaconSyrup Jun 09 '23
yeah my discord is,
"x period x period x period jake underscore four zero eight nine period x period x period x"
vs
"jake four zero eight nine"
1
1
26
u/iHaku Jun 09 '23
we back on gametags from the early 2000's again.
16
u/TheKanten Jun 09 '23
Xbox: The pool of users is too large for this system to continue to work.
Discord: Hold my tweet of a wumpus plushie in a blender bottle for some reason.
12
u/Kalek_The_Abyssian Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 10 '23
Here's what annoys me Xbox had issues with their username system so they updated to discords username system because it works. So tell me why discord switched from a solid system to an antiquated to 1 companies are moving away from? Xbox, call of duty, destiny, battlenet to name a few have all switched to discords username system because it works significantly better.
5
u/FierceDeity_ Jun 10 '23
Because discord is about being cool and unique. everyone was using their system so it isnt cool anymore... gotta go back to the cool and edgy times
1
2
1
1
44
u/Narokath Jun 09 '23
x.x.x.legolas.420.x.x.x reporting for duty. In all seriousness, this change is horrendous. I'm constantly blown away by how out of touch companies are to their consumer.
Can anyone explain to me what exactly this solves? I'm being serious.
22
u/fieryhothate Jun 09 '23
It solves the problem of not being able to be immediately found, so discord stalkers and groomers and spam messengers rejoice!
6
u/iCumWhenIdownvote Jun 10 '23
Someone important within the company or some bigshot's spoiled brat didn't want anyone copying their name.
5
u/FierceDeity_ Jun 10 '23
the removing discrims solves just some imaginary thought experiment of someone not being able to remember their discrim. but they surely remember the line longer name they have now.
tbf removing a lot of the character space at least removes untypeable names lol
2
u/petruskax Jun 09 '23
It’s not a problem, they want to monetize usernames see telegram. I get the idea but I’m not a fan. And discord wanted to get into crypto / nfts. Basically your username turns into an nft -> people can buy an sell them. At least that’s how it works on telegram but I would not be surprised if they copy the strat.
170
u/GBNTRS Jun 09 '23
Wow This change sucks
147
u/NotThatSiri Jun 09 '23
The reasoning is funny as it is because the #0001 was hard to remember. And because 4 numbers is hard to remember Discord is removing permanent invites for non-community servers because these darn invite codes for servers are soooo easy to remember compared to 4 numbers that Discord thought that it would be easier to remember if they made invite codes non-permanent.
→ More replies (12)1
50
u/-non-existance- Jun 09 '23
Wow, that's a loss on a scale of nearly 100% to 70% across all username lengths that's...wow
Granted there's still more that enough for all of earth's population many, many, many times over, but I bet, on average, everyone's username increased by 3 to 7 characters (or 5.5 I guess). Talk about a massive spike in data usage. Whereas you could store the number in a single byte (probably less) now you've added nearly 6 bytes to every single username, which means that cost something on the scale of 700 million bytes? (Going off how many monthly users there are)
9
u/josephtrocks191 Jun 09 '23
That's not how it works. Data is stored in a structured fashion so that it is easily accessible. All usernames will take up the same amount of space, regardless of how much of that space is unused.
And 700 million bytes, while it sounds like a lot, is less than a gigabyte. That's an absolutely miniscule amount of data for a company like Discord.
20
2
u/Wolf_Striker Jun 09 '23
Not saying I support this change, but wouldn’t that nearly cancel out with removing discriminators?
4
u/-non-existance- Jun 09 '23
If they were storing the discriminators poorly, yes. However, you could easily store the whole thing in 1 byte, which would cause an increase
1
u/FierceDeity_ Jun 10 '23
Theoretical at least, like, yeah, sure, you have enough possible combinations for everyone, but at some point you have a ton of trash combinations
33
u/Elvish_Champion Jun 09 '23
Hey, look, this is still big, so why the change?
Yes.
But we still can add numbers, so why the change?
Yes.
Are you going to add excuses to anything I say?
Yes.
So why the change?
Yes.
45
u/Playful_Break6272 Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 10 '23
I absolutely hate the new system. Makes me not want to use Discord anymore. The username I have gone by for 6+ years is now taken by someone else who joined Discord over 2 years after I did. Feels like I have to change names for no reason at all. With a system as it has been introduced now, if you don't got the clean username, you're an unimaginative copycat that just adds x's and _'s to force a name you want.
Why did they do this change in the first place, who asked for this? Now I can't even use my own surname anymore without adding some stupid dot, underscore, looking like some idiotic xXSephiothXx child's username. The old system was clean, this is not. Discord, suck a donut, what a garbage change. Canceled Nitro. Imagine having to tell people your username and saying it has a dot/period at the end, it sounds so stupid. At least with #0000 it was the same for every user, a standard. It was also easy system to add friends with, so their excuse for the new system being that people can't manage to add friends is so BS. Way to call your users idiots, Discord.
Think this new system is going to be any better when all the good names are taken up and more and more trashed accounts take up more and more proper names? Soon the xXx_Sephiroth69___xXx usernames will be a reality, well.. in all lowercase lettering.
6
u/xlicer Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 25 '23
The username I have gone by for 6+ years is now taken by someone else who joined Discord over 2 years after I did
I do feel the exact same. I was with the false safe impression that because my account is old (created 2016) I would be on the priority list and able to keep a clean username just like in every other platform I'm in. Just for it to be grabed by someone that created it in 2020
Tbh I'm not mad with the person that grabbed it before me, is a pity for me, they are prob just a random opportunistic individual. At least it isn't trying to impersonate me in any server I'm in, and we both seem to have completely different hobbies.
I'm mad however at Discord for this stupid and unnecessary change. The old system was miles better than this fucking joke
4
u/FlippenDonkey Jun 09 '23
just add .1234 or whatever number you already had...
8
u/nervegear3 Jun 09 '23
It could be impossible because the only difference between "Jake#1234" and "jake#1234" is a capital j, which the ability to use was removed.
→ More replies (9)0
Jun 09 '23
[deleted]
12
u/Playful_Break6272 Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
Of course it isn't, but needless changes like this is stupid. The username system it had was fine. When you got to start adding dots, underscores, your old numbers, xxusernamexx variants, etc., the whole point of the change is pointless. It doesn't make it easier for people to add each other. It was already easy. Who asked for this change. Was this a hot debate in the userbase? It comes out of nowhere. Their blog post is basically saying people are so stupid they can't figure out the old system. How are they going to figure out the new one as more and more names are claimed and they are forced into the weird username territory. If you have to end up adding numbers again yourself, it's no better than the old system.
I don't want to be .username or xxusernamexx or username0001 or newrandomusername. I had a username for years. Sure, it had a hashtag and some numbers behind it that I would have to give friends to add me, but that was a standard. It felt nice to feel like you had your own online username. It was a clean username. Now I am forced to get some weird username that doesn't feel like my own, because my own which was literally my surname was taken by someone who made an account two years after I did.
1
1
u/Salmizu Jun 10 '23
DISCORD makes it sound like its entire functionality is adding people. Literally the entire statement for this change was about adding friends and how its a herculean task remembering 4 numbers when doing so.
1
67
u/pooO_Oooq Jun 09 '23
old: yeah add me. im bob#4683.
new: yeah im bob, but with four x'es before and 9 after with underscores between the x but not between the x'es and "bob" cuz that was taken so i chose to add full stops there instead.
2
u/katyusha-the-smol Jun 09 '23
I went from V#7326 (A number important to me) to V.__
Not a terrible change but I definitely got lucky being so early.
1
u/Shanman150 Jun 09 '23
Out of curiosity, if 7326 was important to you why didn't you chose v7326, v.7326, 7326v, or any other combination of those? I'm glad you got something you liked though!
1
u/katyusha-the-smol Jun 10 '23
Cause I dislike the idea of a numerical username. It looks to the average person that I chose V and just added some numbers, whereas with a discriminator it was clear it was a deliberate choice of a number.
1
u/Shanman150 Jun 10 '23
It actually wasn't clear though - everyone got 4 digits assigned to them, and you had to specify in your comment that the number was important to you. To anyone who didn't know that, it would look like you chose V and got assigned some random numbers.
1
u/katyusha-the-smol Jun 10 '23
The point is is that im not the 7326th V, which is what the latter looks, whereas the discriminator had nothing to do with my actual username. I also had nitro to choose my discriminator. I dont like numbers in usernames.
2
-10
Jun 09 '23
No. You can be bob4683. What difference does it makev
19
u/drkekyll Jun 09 '23
but if i'm still bob4683 in the end, why did we change anything at all?
4
Jun 09 '23
Agreed. To me it seems like a pointless change. In someways you can look at this in a positive way, meaning you don’t need nitro to change those numbers.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Umpato Jun 09 '23
Because now you can be bob4683 and hundreds, thousands of users who do not understand how discriminators work can now fully understand how their username work.
I'm tired of countless people i've met not even knowing what a discriminator is, or what their number was. It's an incredible niche system that very few companies uses and many users who aren't tech savy do not understand.
I've had to explain to classmates/teachers how it worked and they still couldn't fully get it. It's not a widely used system.
So now you can be bob4683 instead of bob#4683, nothing changes for you, but makes other people's lives easier.
2
u/drkekyll Jun 10 '23
I've had to explain to classmates/teachers how it worked and they still couldn't fully get it. It's not a widely used system.
it's also an unbelievably simple concept. you also have numbers in case someone else wants to be "bob." your anecdote doesn't make me feel like this change is good. it makes me feel like humanity is fucking doomed.
→ More replies (5)0
Jun 09 '23
[deleted]
4
u/Negitive545 Jun 09 '23
Then why change it?
→ More replies (11)1
u/Shanman150 Jun 09 '23
Because according to Discord's metrics, new users struggled to understand the discriminator system, most users didn't know their discriminator off the top of their head, and a huge percentage of friend requests did not meet their targets.
You can disagree with the change, but let's not pretend Discord did it just to upset the users.
1
u/Playful_Break6272 Jun 10 '23
They could educate, make it easier to understand, make it easier to copy (like they have with easy copy to clipboard buttons so you can paste it to friends). People manage to learn the pin to their bank cards. Or their phones. People aren't that stupid. Discord is saying they are.
1
u/Shanman150 Jun 10 '23
Sure, you can educate around roadblocks. That's one way to try to overcome the issue, put more work on the users who don't understand the system so that they can learn it. Another way is to change the system to remove those difficulties altogether.
1
u/Salmizu Jun 10 '23
Except there are a lot of bobs in the world, doubt bob 4683 is available anymore. In the old system there were 9999 "bob"s after all those got taken there were 9999 "bob1"s and so on.
0
Jun 10 '23
[deleted]
1
u/Salmizu Jun 10 '23
Theres so many things wrong with your reasoning. For starters the discriminator is not a part of the username. So no youre just straight up wrong already.
But if we were to pretend to believe the braindead arguement that it is a part of the username for a moment, its still not an equal part of the username as it wasnt visible or when it was it was less visible than the username proper so if we humor your flawed logic bob4683 became bob4683 so even then its still not "exactly the same" as you put it. And actually it was bob#4683 which you no longer can use as # is a banned symbol so its not the same even in that regard.
And then even if we ignore that fact, since "the situation is still exactly the same" why change it? Especially when it introduced a whole lot of brand new flaws while remaining the "same" otherwise.
Not to mention how even those number diarrheas if anyone were attached to them and would otherwise take are getting lifted from people cause of how theyre implementing the change.
AND even after that, this new version makes it so YOU have to deal with adding the stupid extra numbers instead of it being autogenerated for convenience.
0
14
u/TheArcher6969 Jun 09 '23
The issue is glaring yet they ignore. C-Suit decision, I'm afraid. C-Suits don't use Discord.
11
u/Odd-Can7098 Jun 09 '23
I have noticed that usernames on Discord are being sold for real money. How about introducing some sort of "discriminator" to give multiple people the chance to have the same username. 4-5 numbers would be very clear.
73
u/moekana Jun 09 '23
So is there even a point of nitro now that we lost custom identifiers?
27
2
u/Splatoonkindaguy Jun 09 '23
You get usernames earlier ig
9
Jun 09 '23
No, you might have a chance to get it, My account is from August 2016 and Nitro since 2021, but still am waiting for the chance to change
5
u/Aqueous_xD Jun 09 '23
My username was taken by an account from September 2016 and nitro since 2021 so it seems like you'll get it soon
3
u/DragonRiderMax Jun 09 '23
I had nitro since jan 22 and acc dec 19 and got username today
The rollout is sus
1
1
1
u/omgsomeoneactually32 Jun 09 '23
My account is from may 2020, been a nitro sub since sep 2020. Yesterday they prompted me to select my username.
Luckily my username is 3 words long so I got it without any numbers or changing anything!
1
u/Umpato Jun 09 '23
I mean, if the only reason you used nitro was to change the numbers, then no.
I use nitro for the other dozens of things it offers.
1
-112
Jun 09 '23
You had $10 nitro just to have a custom discriminator lmao?
57
u/0xAB51NTH Jun 09 '23
Mostly for that, and why not? Everyone pays for what they deem worthy, someone might have bought nitro for livestream background and someone might have bought them only for discriminator.
→ More replies (3)3
u/majikayo666 Jun 09 '23
then you can't believe how people paid for nitro just to have #0001 or #0666 or something lol
6
Jun 09 '23
That's wild to me ngl
1
u/majikayo666 Jun 09 '23
yeah same here. yet it's upto people to how to spend their money and all and it's basically why capitalism works and thus discord can earn lots of money from nitro alone. also the thing is for you $10 may have the value enough to not want to waste it on nitro but for some people $10 is nothing. people like to show off themselves and they basically like lots of options they like to customize their life so no wonder people pay $10 just for number not many people even see. it's funny but reality of the situation
I personally think discord sell some basic features that should have been free from the start but since capitalism works just fine not many people ain't against paying nitro. in the future social medias may make account creation paid and people will pay it just because paying for it is a statement of wealth. for me when people spend their money on trivial stuff it's not a sign of wealth but a sign of being an idiot. these kind of people are the type who doesn't care saving up money and therefore they can easily go poor. not to mention they are the type who makes lots of bad decisions in their life so I wouldn't want them in my life
2
u/condoulo Jun 09 '23
I’m in over 100 servers, and I’d still like to join a few more without leaving the ones I’m in, so that makes Nitro worth it to me.
→ More replies (7)1
u/LichenLiaison Jun 09 '23
I got my original one stolen by someone else. Like I was #6461 until I got notified that someone else took that number, and it was an account that never even had a PFP, I think someone was just mad at me.
It really fucked up a lot of my stuff tho since I had my username and discriminator listed as contact for a lot of stuff I can’t go back on and change
3
Jun 09 '23
No, the number of “unique” 2 letter names was always 1,156. Only 1156 people can have the username “XX#0001”. There is literally no difference for this change. Yes you could argue it’s pointless but no one is actually losing there names here.
Everyone called “Mike” never owned the username “Mike”
2
u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 Jun 10 '23
Except the new format only allows lowercase letters and numbers, and no longer allows literally any valid unicode character (of which there are 149,186), mathematically there fewer valid combinations of character that can be used for a username under the new format
1
Jun 10 '23
The different unicodes allowed for impersonation scams so this is actually a good change
1
u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 Jun 10 '23
And those same scams are still just as possible with the new format, seeing as those same scams just use tricks like adding a random letter or number onto the copy and pretending that the original name was already taken by someone else on other sites and that still fools dozens because it sounds legit. Not to mention, despite it coming from a Latin based language "è" and any other letter that has a diacritic symbol attached to it isn't considered a Latin character, causing anyone who had their username in a language that includes them (for example, native speakers of those languages) to be forced to give it up. The new system litterally limits everyone, international users included, to the English alphabet only
6
u/plainenglishh Jun 09 '23
sorry but you arent allowed to think logically about this change, you have to get outraged for no reason.
2
u/xyzes Jun 09 '23
You’re talking about logic being used in this thread, and yet I see zero logical arguments in it.
2
u/plainenglishh Jun 10 '23
do you need sentences to be in a debate format to extract any meaning from them? any sound of mind person can easily understand what points theyre making
1
u/xyzes Jun 10 '23
No, I would just expect the points to not be complete nonsense and misinformation. The discriminator is not part of the username, that’s why it has a different name. Plus they said “no one is actually losing their names here” which is bullshit because, for starters, people with non-Latin or non-standard characters won’t be able to have that any longer. It’s an idiotic thing to say there is no difference.
1
u/plainenglishh Jun 10 '23
just because the username and discriminator have different fields in the api doesnt mean that in all practical purposes they act combined. the only place they were separated is now handled by the display name (which can support non latin characters btw). also good luck using the internet/computers without using Latin characters lol
1
u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 Jun 10 '23
What point were you trying to make with that last sentence, the fact that Latin characters exist doesn't invalidate that anyone using non-latin characters in their username, like for example if they wanted to put their name in their own language and it includes a letter with diacritics or their language uses a different alphabet than English does, won't be able to use that name anymore
→ More replies (4)1
u/xyzes Jun 10 '23
Are you actually an idiot or just pretending to be to troll others? Just because non-Latin characters could be used, it doesn’t mean you can’t use Latin characters in the internet/computers. As a matter of fact you were probably already using Latin characters in your username before. That is beyond stupid.
→ More replies (2)1
Jun 09 '23
ik man its so dumb how much people care about a username change - a username which is hidden behind a desplay name anyways
1
u/plainenglishh Jun 09 '23
they literally handed people MORE customisability and people managed to work themselves up over it. they act as if removing the requirement for a "#0000" at the end of their name is bad in any way shape or form
1
u/TechNaWolf Jun 09 '23
Something I noticed as well, it carries over into DMs, your display name that is. Before this change you had no way of having a different name in a dm but not it's the same as your display. Thought that was neat
1
u/xyzes Jun 10 '23
“More customizability” lmao. You are spreading misinformation. The problem with this change is more than just the removal of the discriminator and you know that damn well.
1
u/plainenglishh Jun 10 '23
more customisability in regards to the format of your username. also "You are spreading misinformation" in regards to a comment about a discord change is peak redditor lmfaoo
1
u/xyzes Jun 10 '23
You could customize your username way more before this change because of the entire range of unicode characters AND being able to choose any of 10k possible discriminators. So no, there is not more customizability however you look at it. And not sure what your point is with that last comment. Do you think misinformation is good/beneficial just because of the context or because it’s a niche gamer platform? Try to use your brain more and think about this objectively next time.
1
u/Umpato Jun 09 '23
This subreddit is going absolutely nuts over this change. It's such a small simple thing.
2
u/xyzes Jun 09 '23
How dense are you? The hashtag and the four numbers at the end are not part of the username, that’s why it has a different name (a “discriminator”). Also everyone who had usernames with non-Latin characters literally IS going to lose their usernames. But whatever helps ya sleep at night
1
Jun 09 '23
The username plus the discriminator in the old system are equivalent to the username in the new system. In the old system, the username alone is completely fucking useless without the discriminator. Are you stupid?
1
u/xyzes Jun 10 '23
The only stupid thing being said here is that there is no difference with this change. Legit can’t tell if you people are slow in the brain or just enjoy licking the tech industry’s boots. In any case, yeah the username is useless without the discriminator. And? I don’t see your point there. They are still different things that together allow for so many more combinations. Plus, if you just give both to someone it’s no longer useless. Surely you’re not enough of an idiot that remembering 4 digits was too difficult for you.
1
1
u/TechNaWolf Jun 09 '23
Just leave your display name as is then?
2
u/xyzes Jun 10 '23
Nobody was talking about display names. Also fyi you can’t add someone by their display name. Have you even used this app at all?
2
u/TechNaWolf Jun 10 '23
No I'm new here never touched the app at all, don't even know what you're discussing tbh
1
u/Darki_5 Jun 10 '23
Display names don't show up for me. So instead of seeing something like 'Bob' it's now 'bob3728' which sucks
1
Jun 09 '23
yes, it is. if someone asks for your discord name, your name is "abc#WXYZ". the only name you have that doesnt have these numbers is your display name so you are making a fuss over nothing. just because reddit told you to be outraged doesnt mean you cant look at things logically. The change is pointless, but no where near as big of a deal as its being made out to be.
5
u/Professional_Bit_711 Jun 09 '23
Overall, the change is quite a minus, but there is at least 1 good thing. After all, there will be no people with characters that cannot be mention.
0
u/Hot_Hat_1225 Jun 09 '23
Just copy and paste always worked for us 🤷🏼♀️
2
u/TechNaWolf Jun 09 '23
How you copy and paste some persons name you met at a bar lol
2
u/Hot_Hat_1225 Jun 09 '23
The person talked about people in a server that can’t be mentioned because of special characters - we always simply copy and mention from profile. I never met a person in a bar that I had to add on Discord. The very few rl people I met other places and wanted to add simply sent me their name - and from there I copied and put into search. It’s really not that challenging to find a solution 🤷🏼♀️
1
u/TechNaWolf Jun 09 '23
so if I said my name is wayofthe水 good luck finding this me if you cant type that character, miss a capital, or i didnt happen to know the #XXXX off hand. your relegated to outright copying it for it to be "easy" and that's simply a bad design. now the only guess work is whatever they decided to make the username now
1
u/Hot_Hat_1225 Jun 09 '23
wayofthe水 - copy and paste IS a thing…
1
u/TechNaWolf Jun 09 '23
Im trying to explain how that would be difficult if you actually idk go outside and meet people, tell me how do you copy it... take a picture of it? ask for a phone # and txt it to that, air drop? all things thats more work than having a system where the far less likely to be an issue, and you just enter wayofthewater or oven wayofthewater7897 still easier to convey to someone than wayofthe水#7897
→ More replies (2)
4
u/ActionDesigner Jun 09 '23
What hurts me the most is that my username I had for the past 7 years has been taken by a 2015 account (me being 2016) and that I have been disabled by discord for “underage” and even tho I have appealed. They keep closing my tickets, that’s the worst experiencing. A backstab while hurt
1
Jun 09 '23
You also have to count the discriminator as part of the username. Without it the username is literally useless (in the old system).
1
u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 Jun 10 '23
And I trying to explain how I included it I just realized my math was off because I should have multiplied the number of possible permutations of the discriminator by my original values and then added those two values together since two completely unique names can have the same number as their discriminator, so the values for the old format should actually be much higher
0
Jun 10 '23
You have to count your social security number as part of your real lifename. Without it your name is literally useless.
1
1
u/DrummerGaming Jun 13 '23 edited Jun 13 '23
I just proof-checked for myself, while the point is accurate, the math is incorrect.
The equation for the new format should be 38^x, with x being the number of characters. The new format can only use lowercase English letters, numbers 0-9, underscores and periods. If you're keeping track, that's 38 characters. But the equation used in the image is 34^x
As for the old format, while the math is correct (as there are 149,186 characters in unicode), it doesn't account for user tags (#0000) at the end. So if we include that, then you should multiply by 9999. On top of that, two different names can have the same number tag, so adding initial value before multiplying will account for that. The equation should be ((149,186^x)*9999)+(149,186^x)
Either way, OP's point still stands. Here are the numbers with the corrections:
Old format:
2 characters: 222,564,625,960,000
32 characters: 3.624918372×10^169
New format:
2 characters: 1,444
32 characters: 3.573346177×10^50
1
u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 Jun 15 '23 edited Jun 15 '23
Thank you for correcting my math on this, however I did try to include the discriminator in my original math for the old format, I just did so incorrectly.
Also with the new format, since ".." and "__" aren't can't exist anywhere in the username, shouldn't the equation also take that into account by subtracting 2 from the total possible variations(something I believe both of us forgot to take into account with our math)
9
u/Apprehensive-Hawk513 Jun 09 '23
dont forget you cant have two periods next to each other for some fucking reason
4
Jun 09 '23
That makes sense. Why would it be easy to add someone who's name is "username....username..."
1
u/Apprehensive-Hawk513 Jun 09 '23
for the sake of discussion, what makes that more difficult than any other character repeated multiple times? username____username___ is the same. genuinely curious, if ive missed some logic behind it i would like to know :)
3
Jun 09 '23
It's just not clean from a structure standpoint. Repeating names is one thing but repeating symbols and special characters gets messy
1
u/Apprehensive-Hawk513 Jun 10 '23
i understand that part, im asking why they would ban repeating periods but not repeating underscores, for example
2
u/1A-2 Jun 09 '23
anyway we could wait this change out? im thinking about completely avoiding the name change and waiting the process out to see if i can bypass it
2
u/Acaicia Jun 09 '23
They'll eventually lock you out until you change your username. A bit like when you create an account without a phone number and Discord forces you to add one almost immediately
1
u/snickle Jun 10 '23
? I've had my account since 2018 and they haven't asked me to add a phone number yet.
2
2
u/1A-2 Jun 10 '23
i dont know where else to post this but how is this possible?[picture] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1096779957495156766/1116905099780968498/IMG_2462.png
2
2
u/VeilstoneMyth Jun 10 '23
I wish they'd at least kept the ability to use non-latin characters. I understand that it can be annoying or inaccessible when people use the "quirky" fonts or emojis, but at the same time, it isolates people who prefer their usernames being in another alphabet.
2
u/DOnnyr0n Jun 10 '23
I will never begin to understand how discord decided this was a good idea that would actually help people.
It is clearly just some stupid marketing thing that only benefits the company.
2
2
u/Inevitable-Ear-3162 Jun 10 '23
By the way, I tried every single combination of 2 character username, and none of them were available
2
u/Teutonic-Order Jun 11 '23
Im just going to use the same name with my original discriminator and a hyphen. Well done Discord, absolutely nothing changed. Complete lunacy on their part.
1
1
u/Pythien Jun 10 '23
Why not just adding one number more at the end of the username?! This change makes me sad.
1
u/EpixStorm Jun 10 '23
I think if all nitro users will cancel their subscription because of this change, discord will roll it back.
1
u/PM_ME_SOME_SCIENCE Jun 10 '23
Shouldn't the number of unique 2 character usernames be 38²-2=1442? -2 because ".." and "__" aren't allowed
1
Jun 12 '23
honestly the dumbest, most unnecessary and pathetic change discord has ever made.
How about, instead of pissing off most of your users, you do something productive like making the mobile app not be nearly unusable? or maybe making streams not lag for god knows what reason?
1
u/-Lunar_Shadow- Jun 16 '23
It would be a good idea to threaten that if discord doesn’t change this then 80% of it’s users will start using amino, reddit, snapchat, etc instead of using discord which would be bad for the app and the discord CEO and whoever else would lose A LOT of money because nobody would be using their app other than a few people.
1
u/am_Nein Jun 17 '23
Let's all give it up for discord, who actively bullshits their way into oblivion!
1
u/lightoutlaw Jun 09 '23
Honestly, im not going to switch to the new format of usernames.
6
u/Umpato Jun 09 '23
You have no choice. Eventually you'll be forced, to be able to keep using the app.
0
u/Sarcastic_warframe Jun 09 '23
So you're mad that the quattuorquinquagintillion amount of possible usernames has gone down to a quindecillion...um sounds like yall need to get more creative with your usernames because uh yeah
2
u/Songbird1996 Songbird#2443 Jun 10 '23
I'm not, I just got bored and decided to figure out how many each format allowed for, what I am mad about with the new system is that it causes anyone who doesn't have a language that uses the English alphabet to be forced to come up with a new username in a language that they may not speak or at the very least isn't their first language
-17
u/imphantasy Jun 09 '23
-# of display names infinite
-# of people that can use any name they want infinite
-32
u/ppsz Jun 09 '23
You didn't have unique 2 character usernames, because in fact those were 6 character usernames. You always had 4 numbers forced on you
15
Jun 09 '23
The number isn't part of the username
5
u/ppsz Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
You couldn't invite or identify someone without the discriminator, because name itself wasn't unique. So either you treat name and discriminator as one or you can't say about unique usernames.
If you talk about username as the name shown to others, you probably (like all of the people down voting me) didn't understand that now everyone will have unique username for invites and identification and non unique display name that everyone will see
2
u/nervegear3 Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
I feel as though this is not quite accurate. If you go to google.com/whateveryousearched/thatgoesaftertheforwardslash and I asked what website you were on, you would say Google. That common / separates the website name from the rest of what was there. The # did the same thing for the discriminator. If I was to talk about bo#5835, I wouldn't call them bo#5835, because the 5835 is separated from the actual username by the #, just like it is for every other username. When then referring to bo5835, their actual name now includes those numbers. There is no clear separation that every account will use to separate a name and 4 numbers.
Another example is something like 1337#7331. While before the change it was clear what the name was, it becomes much harder to read "leet" from 13377331.
To be fair though, I would not be as upset about the change if we had some of the basic extra characters in the ASCII system, such as !?[]<> ect. As well as capital letters. My username practically everywhere else has a capital X at the beginning and <3 at the end, which I can't do now for no apparent reason. It would still fix the problem where letters aren't from the English keyboard and are therefore impossible to add without copying and pasting the name as anyone can simply type the name out.
1
u/ppsz Jun 09 '23
But you can still have your name with capital letter and emoji. On top of username you have display name that will show everywhere - on your profile, next to messages, on friends list. New unique username basically replaces username#discriminator combo, but whatever you had as an username, you can still have as a display name. Like in your example, bo5835 is going to show as a "bo" exactly like before, but nobody will have to figure out if it was "bo#5835", "Bo#5835", "bO#5835" or "BO#5835" when trying to send a friend request for example. Well they can even be "ßö" if they wish, without making it problematic to ping or send a friend request
1
u/nervegear3 Jun 10 '23
Actually I cannot. I have already had the chance to select my username, and capitals and special characters such as < are not allowed. Neither are emojis.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Shanman150 Jun 09 '23
I think the point is that the only use for usernames is adding friends. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I can't think of any other situation in which I've ever needed my username as opposed to the current Display Name.
So if you were adding a friend, bo#5835 was what you needed to use. There was no "bo" as a username apart from that. Every other place their name is displayed is the display name - so you can still 100% go by "bo" wherever you like. But when someone adds you, just like before, you have to be "bo5835".
To use your analogy, adding a friend is asking "What is your url?" while display names are "what website are you?"
1
u/nervegear3 Jun 10 '23
I mean, if display name is the only thing important, then why is there a twitter username black market when you can change the display name? The same thing applies to Discord. People care about what their actual username says. While some people may not, and I completely see their point of view, some people really do.
→ More replies (1)0
2
u/panjadotme Jun 09 '23
they're booing you, but you're right
5
u/ppsz Jun 09 '23
I think the biggest problem is, before noone had unique username, so everyone was ok with it, but now only some people are going to have unique username without any numbers and it grinds their gears
-1
u/BananaCupcak3 Jun 09 '23
my god just use the same 4 numbers you had in your discriminator at the end of your user
363
u/SoupahKnux Jun 09 '23
let's be real here though, there is no way Discord will be able to reach a point where they have... hold on... 10 quindecillion accounts in a lifetime