r/DnD • • Sep 08 '19

Strict DM [OC]

Post image
49.4k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

1.5k

u/SrGrafo Sep 08 '19

I havent played dnd in ages, while I do enjoy roleplay, I only played 1 session of dungeons and dragons, (which I will never forget since it was my first time and the other guy was an absolute veteran). On the other hand I have friends that do play often, and one of them was telling me how there are some dms that are super strict with the rules, while others allow players to go on with cool stuff, I thought it would be funny to represent that in a comic.

1.1k

u/SrGrafo Sep 08 '19

401

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

Did you just EDIT yourself?

→ More replies (5)

41

u/Souperplex Warlord Sep 08 '19

Careful; edit yourself too much and you'll go blind.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Wallace_II Sep 08 '19

And, here I was seeing another post from you on my front page, not realizing which sub I'm in. I thought it was great that r/gaming had more DnD exposure through your comics. Then you go and make me look to see that this is r/dnd.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

332

u/frisbeeturtle DM Sep 08 '19

336

u/SrGrafo Sep 08 '19

245

u/Rikulz Sep 08 '19

Can we get a D&D game going with everyone from the editors lounge? Grafo as DM.

→ More replies (2)

103

u/BullWizard Sep 08 '19

I had a tiefling player fall in lava, and I didn't kill her immediately because of the fire resistance, but shit was still gonna hurt. I asked what her next move was, expecting one of her teleport spells, and she goes "I'm gonna swim to the other side"

When I started to pick up a shit load of dice, she was like "but I'm resistance to fire!"

I then had to remind them that resistance is not immunity, and lava is worse than fire.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (2)

57

u/urbnlgnd Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 09 '19

I would be upset with a lenient DM. If your character can do almost anything; what exactly is making the game good?

Edit: People are really overthinking or misinterpreting this statement. I am referring to myself and only myself. If you like this play style, that is great and I'm glad it works for you. I am saying that I prefer rule oriented games because that's what I like. I don't hate you or your preferred ways of playing D&D or any other d20 based game. Always remember this is a statement/opinion and not me declaring war on everyone who don't think like me. If I was your friend and I said this in casual conversation, would your reply be the same as it is or would there be some chuckles followed by witty banter. Goodnight everyone. I'm going to go back to lurking in the shadows for now.

24

u/cparen DM Sep 08 '19

Ditto, which is part of why I left the last group. Everyone else was having fun (I checked), so no sense fighting it. I now have a relatively by the book dm who keeps the adventure moving and am having a blast.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (24)

130

u/Tarzul Sep 08 '19

Of course, if the players bother to learn the rules they can do cool stuff and not break them. Just requires a little creativity and not doing whatever random obviously flawed plan first pops into the head.

124

u/FlyingChainsaw Sep 08 '19

IMO abiding to the rules is what makes cool things cool. I could talk about how I chased after a dragon and killed it mid-flight without playing at all, and it'd just be a random story I made up. If I only go one step further and play DnD, make up random stories I think are cool, and then tell them while playing DnD, that's still not that cool - anyone could do that at any time and it takes away the "wow" part of the story.
However, if I manage to do something really cool within the rules, then that means I actually did something cool. Cool things are only cool because it's hard to do cool stuff all the time. No light without darkness, no cool without dull - if you will.

→ More replies (6)

24

u/A_Trash_Homosapien Sep 08 '19

Has flash back to time I blew up entire city

Eh I think it requires a bit of both. Like learn the rules and do stuff without breaking it but if there's a rule that you and your group don't like just ignore it and proceed with your obviously flawed plan

Imo it's more important to learn your dm/players and what they allow/want

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

21

u/shinversus Sep 08 '19

That's the most difficult thing in tabletop RPG: Find 4/6 people that share the same view on game rules and setup. That's why i still play with the same people than 10 years ago

14

u/Saelune DM Sep 08 '19

You should play DnD again. Its great.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (23)

1.3k

u/SSNappa Sep 08 '19

But I gave the DM $2.50 so my horse could have special fall damage negating armor.

1.3k

u/SrGrafo Sep 08 '19

17

u/asrk790 Sep 08 '19

Looks like the DM kept 25 cents so it must’ve done something

→ More replies (11)

176

u/nivenfres Sep 08 '19

Ok ... So the horse survives your impact ... You still die.

3

u/Ajj360 Sep 08 '19

Still missed the bandit though.

→ More replies (3)

522

u/TheNickaChew Sep 08 '19

How do you keep Billy from turning into a monster through out the campaign session?

541

u/SrGrafo Sep 08 '19

111

u/Kakss_ Sep 08 '19

Ohhhh, he looks so cute

13

u/Sprinkles0 Sep 08 '19

I should try that.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Kakss_ Sep 08 '19

Mike loosened up after Billy ate 4 dies and one player

521

u/League0fGaming Sep 08 '19

Billy has his monster self as a miniature, Trevor has the Grafo from this comic, and Grafo has some random taco guy

450

u/SrGrafo Sep 08 '19

57

u/doubebeesd Sep 08 '19

But what is the reason for the taco guy?

What class is he?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

76

u/zsvx Sep 08 '19

i can’t tell if you’re joking but that taco guy is from the first comic that grafo did that really blew up outside of r/RimWorld

comic

taco guy EDIT

23

u/League0fGaming Sep 08 '19

That's why i said taco guy instead of archer

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

32

u/srgrafo_edit_bot Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 09 '19

Strict DM [OC]

#userEDITcommentLink
0/u/SSNappaEDITBut I gave the DM $2.50 so my horse could have special fall damage negating armor.Link
1/u/SirWynckoEDITis this how this game works?Link
2/u/TheNickaChewEDITHow do you keep Billy from turning into a monster through out the campaign session?Link
3/u/SrGrafoEDITI havent played dnd in ages, while I do enjoy roleplay, I only played 1 session of dungeons and dragons, (which I will never forget since it was my first time and the other guy was an absolute veteran). On the other hand I have friends that do play often, and one of them was telling me how there are some dms that are super strict with the rules, while others allow players to go on with cool stuff, I thought it would be funny to represent that in a comic.Link
4/u/League0fGamingEDITBilly has his monster self as a miniature, Trevor has the Grafo from this comic, and Grafo has some random taco guyLink
5/u/srgrafo_edit_botEDIT[HA! YOU ALMOST GOT ME TO CREATE A BLACK HOLE, FELLOW HUMAN! BUT AS GOOD HUMAN, I SAW THROUGH YOUR EFFORTS, HAHA]Link
6/u/nivenfresEDITOk ... So the horse survives your impact ... You still die.Link
7/u/frisbeeturtleEDITBut also there are players who are dumLink
8/u/SpikedLemonEDITShould have bribed with beer.Link
9/u/DeathTrap-LegatronEDITYou mean all of the free snacks and pizzas I order doesn't get me cool magic items? PfftLink
10/u/GamerNumba100EDITBut the die was all ones therefore a one was the best possible result- he kills the editLink
11/u/RikulzEDITCan we get a D&D game going with everyone from the editors lounge? Grafo as DM.Link

I am a little fan-made bot who loves /u/SrGrafo but is a little lazy with hunting for EDITs. If you want to support our great creator, check out his Patreon. If you enjoy my hard robot work, a 'good bot' reply would make me very happy.

79

u/SrGrafo Sep 08 '19

20

u/jerrygergichsmith Sep 08 '19

Wow, you are on top of all these sub rules. Serious respect.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/ChrisTheGeek111 Sep 08 '19

Oh good bot, I see you've been reserected.

7

u/C4st1gator Sep 08 '19

I imagine reserecton (sic) to be the crappy JPEG version of Resurrection. You have supplied a DM with a cursed spell that resurrects players as inferior copies of themselves until they are cured.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4.9k

u/foxfirek Sep 08 '19

I remember sending my horse across a bridge to see if it was safe. The DM was gleeful because it could have supported our weight but not the weight of a horse and it was super fun to roll the damage from it falling in lava.

3.2k

u/ImapiratekingAMA Sep 08 '19

I don't even like horses and i find something wrong with that

2.3k

u/mindrover Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 09 '19

There's a famous story of someone beating Tomb of Horrors by herding a flock of sheep ahead of them to set off all the traps.

Edit: I'm starting to wonder if this story is actually true, or if it's just something that people joke about so much that I assumed it really happened.

→ More replies (166)

70

u/highlord_fox DM Sep 08 '19

"The archers fail their saving throw, and therefore move to the next target in range... Your horse, since the Cleric is hidden behind you." -Rolling noises.- "Well, I presume your horse has an AC lower than 21, and less than 47 HP..."

→ More replies (1)

321

u/doubebeesd Sep 08 '19

That’s because there is something wrong with that.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (11)

154

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

In our most recent session, we had to cross a shallow sea (about 1 ft deep) of snails/slugs where if you made prolonged direct contact with the slimy liquid in it, you'd become lethargic and eventually become unconscious (in a non-curable way), after which the slugs would come and eat you.
We had two paladins in the party that had conjured spirit mounts (that weren't affected by the slime since they weren't living creatures) that were normally horses. However, in order for them to be able to carry a party of six, they'd have to be bigger mounts. So after consultation with the DM, they were able to conjure hippo mounts with the same stats as elephants. Then we lashed them together and created a sort of hammock in between and rode the hammock across the sea, having to roll athletics checks periodically to make sure we didn't slip off, lest we incur conditions.

81

u/moonshineTheleocat DM Sep 08 '19

Wat.... I would have said the horses could only carry two at a time. Theyd have to come back and forth twice.

→ More replies (10)

22

u/throwaway073847 Sep 08 '19

This is exactly what D&D is all about.

75

u/SnicklefritzSkad Sep 08 '19

That's why you gotta paladin dip. Get that find steed.

211

u/JonnyIHardlyBlewYe Sep 08 '19

Why do I need Find Steed? I know exactly where my steed is. It's in the lava.

  • My half orc barbarian

38

u/Sawgon Sep 08 '19

The issue with that is, as a paladin, I know my steed gets +INT. It takes a Warhorse up to 6 INT so that they can understand a language I speak. It'll feel wrong. :(

Unless I make up a reason why I need to throw vengeance on the horse.

Then it had it coming.

→ More replies (10)

90

u/freakers Sep 08 '19

You rolled a 1. Your horse dies, it's lava ya Dingus.

52

u/mitsukiyouko555 Sep 08 '19

roll a 12 and ur horse becomes a fire horse and can now breathe fire? XD

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/BomblessDodongo Paladin Sep 08 '19

As a Kentuckian, I JUST wanna talk with your DM.

Trust me

3

u/BureaucratDog Sep 08 '19

In the podcast I listen to someone used a special spell to summon a horse- but didn't realize they were still over a lava pit so their horse fell into the lava and died.

→ More replies (55)

193

u/LordCamelslayer DM Sep 08 '19

I wouldn't even call that a strict DM. If you just jumped off a cliff with no means of flying or slowing your fall, you're asking for death.

61

u/Sergnb Sep 12 '19 edited Sep 13 '19

"I STAB MYSELF WITH THE SWORD OF THE ENEMY, CLINCHING MY INTESTINES TO KEEP IT IN PLACE, MAKING HIM UNABLE TO MOVE AND THEN ATTACK HIM. HE IS PARALYZED SO I HAVE ADVANTAGE IN THE ATTACK, RIGHT?!"

"Wel... I don't know... I guess I'll allow it. Before that you take 18 points of damage because of the stab though, how many do you have left?"

"I only had 5 hp left"

"Well... you get incapacitated then"

"WTF THESE STRICT NO FUN ALLOWED DMS MAN ALWAYS THE SAME WITH YOU"

37

u/StruckingFuggle Sep 09 '19

It would depend on how tall the cliff is

18

u/Skyphe Sep 09 '19

If it can be classified as a cliff it's pretty tall

→ More replies (1)

8

u/lightmatter501 Sep 09 '19

If you a high ish level barbarian physics says you can fall from you orbit and only be bloodied.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/melance DM Sep 09 '19

Agreed, the death from falling is what makes the story of killing the bandit even more epic.

→ More replies (14)

1.1k

u/KiwiChoppa147 Sep 08 '19

Remember it’s 1d6 damage per 10ft to a max of 20d6

797

u/LtOin Druid Sep 08 '19

So an average 70 damage for falling from space? That's not the worst.

616

u/ataraxic89 Sep 08 '19

35 for a barbarian, whose average HP with no con is 40 at level 5.

→ More replies (90)

77

u/KiwiChoppa147 Sep 08 '19

Hey man you gotta hit terminal velocity at some point

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (35)

87

u/WillyFistergasch Sep 08 '19

How much if you're a goldfish??

81

u/Philias2 Sep 08 '19

Well, is the goldfish practically a god or not?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

41

u/me1505 Sep 08 '19

Remember, polymorphing into something heavy like a bear means both whatever you land on dies, and most of the damage is absorbed by bear form.

19

u/KiwiChoppa147 Sep 08 '19

Gotta love druids and polymorph spells

→ More replies (3)

6

u/strong_grey_hero Sep 08 '19

There was an incident in one of our games where a enemy wizard was casting near a cliff. A player character barbarian ran and grabbed him, and jumped off the cliff. Whatever the damage was wasn’t much to the barbarian, yet splatted the wizard instantly.

3

u/SpartanXIII Sep 08 '19

So at max it's 120 damage?

Sweet, my Fighter can tank that.....and then get eaten alive by ravenous shadow beasts.......

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Jple88 Sep 08 '19

Also worth noting though that it doesn’t negate the effects that the fall would cause like broken bones and such

→ More replies (1)

3

u/phdemented DM Sep 09 '19

In 1e, the intended rule was 1d6 cumulative. So 10' is 1d6. 20' is 3d6 (1+2). 30' is 6d6 (1+2+3). It's a lot more realistic. The PHB wasn't clear, and all later editions used the PHB rule, not the corrected rule in the later 1e rule books.

→ More replies (39)

79

u/Drakeenor Sep 08 '19

Why would you jump? You wouldn't have gotten disadvantage on the roll if you stayed on top of the cliff.

57

u/yumcake Sep 08 '19

Because it'd be totally sweet!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DaSaw Sep 09 '19

Stunt to be able to make the attack and violate movement restrictions?

→ More replies (1)

121

u/numerousiceballs Sep 08 '19

And this marked the moment, when Grafo had killed the end boss without any prior knowledge. The tyranny of the shapeshifting horse, the harvester of souls came to an end due to Grafo's encounter with gravity.

54

u/darf1023 Sep 08 '19

Ok, but firing the arrow clearly slowed my decent. I mean, Newtons third law or something like that.

19

u/Ioneos Sep 08 '19

If I'm not mistaken to effectively negate the fall the arrow would have to be as heavy as the archer and travel more than twice the speed of the descent.

20

u/LuBuAteMyDog Sep 08 '19

So I just gotta be STRONK and have a THICC arrow?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

39

u/R3nxu Sorcerer Sep 08 '19

I cast revivify on the horse, but only the horse.

7

u/TimX24968B Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 09 '19

"sorry jim, youre not as useful as the horse, and we only have 1 revive scroll."

4

u/gthv Cleric Sep 08 '19

Right? The horse did nothing wrong. It didn’t jump off a cliff onto another creature.

30

u/Souperplex Warlord Sep 08 '19

See this DM is too nice. I would make the player roll the fall damage to make it more painful.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '19

make him roll acrobatics to see if he rolls and breaks his back first, or if he does a superhero landing and the broken bone from his knee will shoot upwards to his chin, stabbing him and killing this way

273

u/ImOnRedditAndStuff Sep 08 '19

Not a strict DM, some of us just like running a more realistic game

319

u/7up478 Sep 08 '19

Rule of cool means I get to ignore all the rules when it suits me, if you say no you're a bad DM.

101

u/ImOnRedditAndStuff Sep 08 '19

Yeah there's a player that might not be welcome at my table lol. You get to play by the same rules that me and all the other players play by, or you don't have to play at all lol. If you don't like it, it's not on me

→ More replies (8)

64

u/Common_Wedding Sep 08 '19

This subs weird opinion that the dms job is to be subservient to the players never sits well with me. Like if you aren't literally giving them blow jobs while allowing them to fly at level 1 with the power of dreams you're a railroading dm.

Wonder how many of these people have ever dm'd before....

→ More replies (5)

18

u/SnicklefritzSkad Sep 08 '19

That same player is the one that gets mad as soon as NPC's start casting spells

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (19)

117

u/ataraxic89 Sep 08 '19

100% this.

Both as a DM and as a player I dont enjoy the "rule of cool". I prefer his step brother, the "rule of 'it works if it follows the established rules of the setting and game'"

He's a lot less known.

20

u/MauiWowieOwie Sep 08 '19

But I rolled a nat 20! What do you mean I don't seduce the dragon!?

→ More replies (8)

55

u/ImOnRedditAndStuff Sep 08 '19

I totally allow the rule of cool, but I don't let it happen for free. I'll always let my players try crazy crap, but I'll tell them there is a high chance for failure.

It's not everyone's cup of joe, but like I said, I like running a more realistic game!

→ More replies (7)

27

u/BluePizza3 Sep 08 '19

I love the rule of cool but cartoonish physics aren't cool IMHO.

That being said its ok to stretch physics and rules. Just don't break them.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

I do support the rule of cool for situations where the breaking of realism is fairly minor. Jumping off a 100-foot cliff and expecting to be fine because "it's cool" is just plain silly

→ More replies (1)

5

u/vikinick Sep 08 '19

Yeah it's just like... I'll let things not in the rulebook happen, but such obvious things like fall damage you gotta have a very good reason for why jumping off a cliff doesn't kill you.

→ More replies (10)

44

u/ItsFuckingLenos Sep 08 '19

The asshole DM, he problably wouldn't even let me kill every person I see.Where's the fun if I can't brutally murder everyone I see while I scream space marine quotes?

59

u/WMinerva Sep 08 '19

Cliffs and fall damage, they can kill anything.

Even gods.

4

u/DriedMiniFigs Sep 08 '19

The cosmic behemoth takes a massive step towards the mountain, flattening an entire forest. Another step, the entire contents of a lake empty, splashing only to half-way up it’s calf; it takes no notice. Like a small stepping stone, the behemoth lowers itself from the cliff side to the valley below, a day’s journey in a single motion—

It takes massive fall damage, and dies. Game’s over.

4

u/errorsniper Sep 08 '19

Except for barbairans of the 5th level with no con on average if they rage within 6 seconds of hitting the ground according to people up top.

3

u/MauiWowieOwie Sep 08 '19

Nah, there are a couple of abilities, spells, and items to save you. Rocks fall are more dangerous. We just finished(or rather the DM did) off the three constructs the BBEG sent after us by successfully dodging rocks fall and the constructs didn't.

3

u/lejoo Sep 08 '19

Reason #68 why god's don't get stat blocks.

3

u/TheZealand Sep 09 '19

God have less than 120 hp I guess

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Endorell DM Sep 08 '19

Strict DM? Seems kinda fair to me... Player jumps off a cliff, player dies....

13

u/Dangerous_Nudel Sep 08 '19

I just DM'd vor the first two times recently and it is so much fun. And to the detriment of my players it is true that behind the dm screen you roll 20 times better.

4

u/ErwinR0mmel Sep 08 '19

Look at them, they come to this place when they know they are not pure. Tenno use the keys, but they are mere trespassers. Only I, Vor, know the true power of the Void. I was cut in half, destroyed, but through its Janus Key, the Void called to me. It brought me here and here I was reborn.

We cannot blame these creatures, they are being led by a false prophet, an impostor who knows not the secrets of the Void. Behold the Tenno, come to scavenge and desecrate this sacred realm. My brothers, did I not tell of this day? Did I not prophesize this moment?

Now, I will stop them. Now I am changed, reborn through the energy of the Janus Key. Forever bound to the Void. Let it be known, if the Tenno want true salvation, they will lay down their arms, and wait for the baptism of my Janus key. It is time. I will teach these trespassers the redemptive power of my Janus key. They will learn its simple truth.

The Tenno are lost, and they will resist. But I, Vor, will cleanse this place of their impurity.

12

u/RurouniTim Sep 08 '19

Guys, i need resolution. Did his arrow hit the bandit?

12

u/CaptainYunk Bard Sep 08 '19

Ya but did he hit the bandit?

4

u/Theghost129 Sep 08 '19

This is important /u/SrGrafo

17

u/ChrisTheGeek111 Sep 08 '19

That bandit is more detailed than some of your RimWorld stuff, excellent.

15

u/Vosrik DM Sep 08 '19

The moment the DM gets a maniacal glint in their eye and then begins rolling a fistful of dice, you know ya messed up good

7

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

I'm a strict dm, because the game almost always has a mechanical way for you to do what you're trying to do.

Here all you need is feather falling, that's what the spell is for.

6

u/schm0 Sep 08 '19

Lol apparently this is "strict"?

11

u/the_GamingDead Sep 08 '19

That medieval armor SrGrafo miniature looks awesome!

5

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

I remember a Pathfinder session where the paladin failed a climbing check on a rope hanging from an airship and his horse succeed. I've never seen a player meltdown like it before or since...

5

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

I wouldn't even call that strict, that's just plain common sense LOL

5

u/Gregory_Grim Sep 09 '19

This may be a controversial opinion, but I think in situations like these RAW should actually outweigh ROC. If players circumvent genuine obstacles like sheer cliffs just like that because it's "badass" that can be seriously game breaking. Consequences should not disappear because it would be inconvenient or wouldn't fit the narrative in that moment.

Of course there's other things wrong with this situation such as the fact that the player did not get to save to minimize the damage.

8

u/cagranconniferim DM Sep 08 '19

Dm's are allowed to be strict. It should be established well before you are at a cliff. Some games will be high fantasy and rule of cool can apply. Other games not so much. Come to an agreement before you play a session together. You can be a strict dm without being a dick. You can use rule of cool without being a dumbass.

4

u/BlueSabere Sep 08 '19

Not true! Everyone knows once you get enough HP you can survive a fall from space! What’s that? Homebrew? Pshh, no one uses homebrew, like, ever.

4

u/Ocera Sep 08 '19

Aim for the bad guy. So you land on him. Softening your landing and killing everyone!

4

u/Fubarp Sep 08 '19

Playing Pathfinder game with my group. We are in a tower that's rises 500ft up. Being the destructive group, someone in the party accidentally destroys the base of the tower. Tower starts to fall over, everyone with abilities to escape starts flying, or levitating. But I'm just a simple Barbarian what can I do. Well I can look up the fall damage and learn that you take 1d6 damage per 10ft, up to a maximum of 20d6.

As everyone escapes from the tower, I climb to the top to avoid any falling debris on me and stand there. I have 160hp. I'll just tank the fall.

DM looks at me with confusion, rest of group is confused why I'd climb. He then looks up fall damage and laughs and starts rolling. I then walk away a god among the people. Then secretly ask for heals from the cleric.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BluddGorr Sep 08 '19

Yeah, I un-ironically agree one hundred percent. If rule of cools trumps rules and immersion then that sucks too in its own way (depending on the campaign and players).

4

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

I remember when there was this cliff edge and some stairs, i didn’t hear anything about the stairs so i just jumped down, and soent the next ~10 minutes trying to get my speed down so i wouldnt die.

Edit: one of my friends jumped down too, and one of my other friends tried to throw me a teleportation arrow and just teleported himself to me. My last friend took the stairs.

4

u/Electromass Sep 09 '19

Not really strict you live on a planet with gravity the phrase “I jump off the cliff” has consequences

4

u/Jaminp Sep 09 '19

The person who tries this is always 1st level, half wounded, and isn't trained in athletics or acrobatics.

4

u/rexpimpwagen Sep 09 '19

Well I mean no shit lol. Idiots think they can just jump off cliffs and ignore gravity?

4

u/etherealflaim Sep 09 '19

The "Rule of Cool" alternate reality:

GM: ... Roll to hit

Player: 12

GM: ... Well, the bandit was distracted by your acrobatics, so we'll call that a hit. Roll for damage

4

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

First I'm gonna make him/her roll an acrobatics check to get on the horse then roll to hit with his/her bow, depending on the class and stats I would formulate the DC and make the player choose which of the hit or save he/she would like disadvantage on. If the planets align and the player somehow succeeds both the hit and save then I would give him/her a point of inspiration for that badass moment.

It's all about the experience for me, the rules comes second.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

Good dm. Rule of cool doesn’t work in real life, shouldn’t work in dnd.

35

u/MigBird Fighter Sep 08 '19

The Cool of Rule:

"Something cool is even more cool if it is accomplished within an understood set of rules."

→ More replies (26)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

Always a hoot when "Rule of Fun" people pedantically bash other play styles for being overly pedantic. It's cool that you're into collaborative story telling, but some of us enjoy playing D&D as an actual game.

12

u/Mammogram_Man DM Sep 08 '19

I'd amend it by adding that some of us just want our games to not be comically over the top. I love story focused games (I don't even really play much DnD anymore, only Burning Wheel for reference) but I hate it when the world feels cartoonish and unbelievable. When I play, I want to get anchored into believable, realistic fantasy worlds; not a cartoon stereotype of fantasy.

And if some people like the more cartoonish, rule of cool worlds, that's fine! Just don't trash me for not enjoying it too.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Amekyras Sep 08 '19

Damn, I really need to get back into DnD. I've been playing Fate and Skyfarer recently, that's been fun.

3

u/Shattered_Sans Sep 08 '19

R.I.P the taco guy archer and the horse.

Press F to pay respect

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AVestedInterest DM Sep 08 '19

Dammit DM I just wanted to feel like Zorro

3

u/Notgaylikesdick Sep 08 '19

But does the arrow hit the target?

3

u/EXAProduction Bard Sep 08 '19

Listen my opinion is if someone wants to do something cool let them but the DC is gonna be tough.

Played a game where I started bombing a beach and our paladin wanted to backflip away from the bombs. He failed miserably and all my rolls were crits so he fuckin died.

3

u/st_pugsley Sep 08 '19

This is how I killed my character in the first session. Tried to climb up a Bell tower and cut the bell loose so that the party could turtle it through a rough neighborhood, but ended up falling from 60 feet off the bell. My level 1 bard did not enjoy that

3

u/Razetony Sep 08 '19

This is less a D&D comic and/u/SrGrafo and his followers invading from /r/comics

3

u/grrodon2 Sep 08 '19

That's more reasonable than strict, tho.

3

u/taladan Sep 08 '19

I used to run a dnd mush and man...you could mow through party resources in horseflesh. Adventurers on horseback were basically doordash drivers for monsters.

3

u/Applemaniax Sep 27 '19

The DM should make it fun for the players, but you can’t jump off a cliff and expect to be fine. Especially not if you’re aiming for a horse.

2

u/ventsol Sep 08 '19

Oh no. Not again!

2

u/QuirkySquid Warlock Sep 08 '19

tsk tsk, shoulda taken Feather Fall with Magic Initiate.

2

u/Garedbi69 Sep 08 '19

Well shit. F for horse

2

u/a_password Sep 08 '19

The first time I played Warhammer battle, a wolf killed my friend by dealing more damage than the first two demons we encountered. DM was not especially strict, but the wolf was lucky

2

u/thiney49 Sep 08 '19

But the wizard cast feather fall on me!

2

u/Advindomn Sep 08 '19

I see the RP Void symbol on the horse's saddle…

2

u/Oshava DM Sep 08 '19

This reminds me of the keyfish incident just replace an angry dm with a worried one.

2

u/cballadares62 Sep 08 '19

But only a pepperoni would die. AND IM NO PEPPERONI

2

u/TheDankDragon DM Sep 08 '19

Did he kill the bandit though?

2

u/ShadowRiku667 Sep 08 '19

It’s because you didn’t bring your sacrifice of Mountain Dew and Doritos to the weekly gathering. The gods smile upon those who are plenty in such gestures

2

u/MosesKarada Sep 08 '19

Quick. Someone gather the body...

No sense letting it go to waste

2

u/hotcocoa403 Sep 08 '19

Youre in r/DnD now too?? Bless me with one of your edits papa 😶

2

u/LadyLoth44 Druid Sep 08 '19

Good.

2

u/foveros DM Sep 08 '19

Amateur mistake. Should have shot the ground first. Can't kill you if it's dead. (points finger at head)

2

u/CyberneticWhale Sep 08 '19

Actually, that cliff appears to be about 3 horses tall (we can assume that the cliff is about continuous through the panels as the bottom of the cliff in the first panel aligns with the top of the cliff in the second panel) and with horses being a large creature, that's an absolute max of 10 ft tall.

This would make the cliff 30 ft tall max, and with fall damage being 1d6 per 10 ft, thats 3d6 damage, for a maximum of 18 hit points. A warhorse has 19 hitpoints, so it is not possible for the horse to die, and assuming your character isn't super low level, the character probably isn't dying either.

2

u/Giulio_64 Sep 08 '19

*meanwhile, in 3.5*

dm: you are falling from 200 meters. what do you do?

player: nothing

dm:ok

*roll*

dm: you take 2 damage

2

u/Jamesaya Sep 08 '19

Aim for the bushes?

2

u/KamuiT DM Sep 08 '19

Yeah, but he looked awesome in death.

2

u/elegantjihad Sep 08 '19

He pulled out an arrow, but did he also pull out a BOW? I see it depicted in the cartoon but he didn’t say it!

2

u/UncleBlob Sep 08 '19

There was a huge RP moment in a campaign I'm playing in where my character surprises everyone by killing a big npc without discussing it with the rest of the party. The DM was already on board with me using a spell to do so even though I didn't have a spell slot available due to the importance of the RP moment. I cast the spell, kill the npc and then the fallout begins unfolding. Five minutes later, another player points out that I broke the rules and makes a big deal out of it so we have to rewind and redo the scene without my character using magic.

2

u/JUST_PM_ME_GIRAFFES Sep 08 '19

DnD Rules exist to make correct and incorrect decisions impactful. If you want to play a more narrative cinematic game there are better systems in place.

2

u/5hoursofsleep Sep 08 '19

This is me! I love it when players get creative and adds flavour to their actions....but I hate it when they want to try unrealistic anime/super hero/cartoon moves that would be deadly no matter what. Who jumps off a cliff and expects to live? ?!?!! Actions have consequences.

On a lighter note, I would probably have allowed the falling + attack action AND if they anchored themselves down and tethered them selves to the top I would have probably halved or third..ed the damage of falling. NO ONE RUNS WITH ARMS BACKWARDS AND EXPECTS TO RUN FASTER!!!! No to weebos!

2

u/ToFurkie Sep 08 '19

As someone that's only kinda watched D&D but never played it, in this situation, he'd roll for accuracy? Wouldn't he roll for dexterity on the landing? Or is that 1 roll, roll for attack, and if you get a poor roll, it goes all bad?

5

u/lordagr Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19

He would roll to hit the bandit first, and regardless of the outcome he would take 1d6 fall damage for every 10 feet he fell.

At low levels, long ranges, or with a sourpuss DM, the player may be forced to roll his attack at disadvantage. Disadvantage means you roll twice and use the lower result.

The player would then need to succeed on an acrobatics check to land on the horse, which may also take some of that fall damage depending on the DM.

A generous DM might reward a successful Acrobatics check by reducing the fall damage, or ignoring it entirely.

The falling character may be able to cast feather fall as a reaction, or have it cast upon him as he falls, which would prevent the fall damage under most circumstances.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Javeyn Sep 08 '19

"but I use my acrobatics and strength to turn my cloak into a makeshift parachute!" Rolls d20

2

u/W0LF_JK Sep 08 '19

How to tell your playing with veteran dnd players:

...but I had feather fall casted! My guy was falling like vanilla ice! You can’t touch him!”

2

u/T3chSh0ck Sep 08 '19

I'd probably let the player make an acrobatics check to halve the fall damage. To all DMs out there: Always remember that this is a game made for people to have fun.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Leivve Wizard Sep 08 '19

That isn't so much strict as, you doing something stupid, and him pointing it out.

2

u/D_for_Diabetes DM Sep 08 '19

See that's something you make them roll for. On a one they both die, 2-9 they both take half damage (or enough to be hurt). On 10-15 only the rider takes the damage. 16-19 you hurt your butt from the landing and it hurts to sit, but you're otherwise fine. Nat 20 you do all the cool things

2

u/HeMansSmallerCousin Sep 08 '19

With D&D fall damage? That cliff could be in space and you could walk it off.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

Looking at this reminds me of my first campaign where we had three horses for a carriage, and would rotate the horses so we could constantly be on the move. One of the horses got a gimped leg though so the Knight instantly killed the horse to our party’s horror. Was a fun group that loved small inter party conflicts, wish we could have that more but all my groups since have been really sensitive to anyone doing their own thing. Just have an argument and move on, don’t hold a grudge for the rest of the campaign.

2

u/Emaharg DM Sep 08 '19

But.... Rule of cool?

2

u/arstin Sep 08 '19

This reminds me of my last attempt to play D&D. One guy had the philosophy that if you came up with a cool idea, it was the DM's job to make it work. My philosophy was that if your cool idea was also ridiculous, you had to deal with the consequences. This could have been one of our disagreements.

2

u/ScorchedLegend Sep 08 '19

I didn't expect to see you here señor grafo

2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

Roll a CON save DC 20 to see if you can ever have children after that.

2

u/Caomedes DM Sep 08 '19

I wish I could play DnD. I can keep reading DnD stories on and on.

2

u/-DaveThomas- Sep 08 '19

Not a strict DM story exactly but I remember when playing a public campaign with one of my friends (we found a group that played every Tuesday at the game shop) the rogue in our party kept trying to sneak right next to the mob we we're fighting like it was vanish from WoW. Kept sighting some feat that enhanced his sneak ability (I'm kind of a noob and don't remember the exact details. Was 4th ed.)

This guy and our DM must've argued for 10-15 min. about whether or not the rogue was hidden. Our DM just said "fine, you sneak on the ground right next to him. He looks down, sees you and takes a swing*
Rolls dice

Was a funny exchange to say the least.

2

u/RedShadow09 Sep 09 '19

I cast father fall on my gnarly Archer so he can shoot the bandit and not die while still landing on the horse TAKE THAT DM!

2

u/ZLUCremisi Rogue Sep 09 '19

Hey BoTW pretty much have you shield bang and you go flying across the map

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Fuck off ive got slow fall.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Majikel DM Sep 09 '19

My old DM had a house rule that I continued, which is for “Heroic Play”

Yeah, you could shoot from the cliff top and then climb down. But if you want to look like a badass, go for it!

We would always role, and sometimes it would go badly. But he would weight it. The occasional +1 or 2 for great role play and heroic acts is worth it. It encourages daring plays!

You can see it as a gods favour if it helps you rationalise it.

2

u/Cordel8a11 Sep 09 '19

3.5, i jump off a cliff with a wooden board, board breaks, i take no fall damage.

2

u/KingPinguen Sep 09 '19

Serious question: why don't many DMs warn players about this before they roll? It's not against the rules for make sure your players know the rules right

2

u/MylastAccountBroke Sep 09 '19

"We're basically gods!"

2

u/tkngenesis Sep 09 '19

Lol me to my players lol

2

u/MelvinMcSnatch DM Sep 09 '19

Reminded me of my step sister's first d&d game with us. She asked for a dragon. At level 1. So she could fly on it. Somehow I'm a strict DM for saying no.

2

u/TheEvilSmileyRD Sep 09 '19

R.I.P rule of cool

3

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

Time to roll up the most alloying legal character you can imagine then.

3

u/NVSSP DM Sep 08 '19

Eat shit, fall off your horse

3

u/camoceltic_again Sep 08 '19

Were I the DM, I'd have there be a CON roll.

Player: I got a 7.

DM: As your character lands, he feels immense pain from landing on the body parts most precious to him. You are stunned for 3 rounds, take 3d6 bludgeoning damage, and will never walk right again.