r/DnD • • Sep 08 '19

Strict DM [OC]

Post image
49.4k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

273

u/ImOnRedditAndStuff Sep 08 '19

Not a strict DM, some of us just like running a more realistic game

319

u/7up478 Sep 08 '19

Rule of cool means I get to ignore all the rules when it suits me, if you say no you're a bad DM.

101

u/ImOnRedditAndStuff Sep 08 '19

Yeah there's a player that might not be welcome at my table lol. You get to play by the same rules that me and all the other players play by, or you don't have to play at all lol. If you don't like it, it's not on me

39

u/MauiWowieOwie Sep 08 '19

Needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few. Many players forget this. That's why we discuss how a campaign will be run beforehand, especially if it's a homebrew. Also why session 0's exists for groups that don't already know each other.

13

u/ImOnRedditAndStuff Sep 08 '19

Totally agree. Session 0 is probably one of the most important things. Even for players that know each other

10

u/Bantersmith Sep 08 '19

I've played in many campaigns over the years, and I cannot stress enough how much I correlate session zeros with successful campaigns.

My group has been gaming together for years, run three concurrent campaigns at a time, are great friends outside the game, and we still do a session zero. It's crucial to make sure you're all going for the same tone of game, and know what's expected/permitted, not to mention linking backstories together can be a great way of ensuring a good party bond and co-operative role-play!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Javeyn Sep 08 '19

That's when I bust out the Rule of Ridiculousness by exclaiming,

"Yeaaaaah, that's ridiculous. You failed."

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

[deleted]

17

u/ImOnRedditAndStuff Sep 08 '19

Is that a reference to Keyleth, from Critical Role, cliff diving?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

64

u/Common_Wedding Sep 08 '19

This subs weird opinion that the dms job is to be subservient to the players never sits well with me. Like if you aren't literally giving them blow jobs while allowing them to fly at level 1 with the power of dreams you're a railroading dm.

Wonder how many of these people have ever dm'd before....

23

u/StrangerDangerBeware Sep 08 '19

That's because most people on Reddit are younger, and most D&D players don't DM. So you have young players that probably never DMed a long campaign before, which leads to some very strange expectations.

4

u/MonaganX Sep 08 '19

It's just the other side of the medal of the more old-school grognardy view of the DM as a malicious deity cheering over rolling a killing blow on a PC.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/SnicklefritzSkad Sep 08 '19

That same player is the one that gets mad as soon as NPC's start casting spells

12

u/uhbijnokm Sep 08 '19

Lol I had player at least somewhat sincerely upset that the enemy boss they were sent to hunt down had a multi attack and an AC of 18. Another player had to remind him that his own AC was 17.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

117

u/ataraxic89 Sep 08 '19

100% this.

Both as a DM and as a player I dont enjoy the "rule of cool". I prefer his step brother, the "rule of 'it works if it follows the established rules of the setting and game'"

He's a lot less known.

20

u/MauiWowieOwie Sep 08 '19

But I rolled a nat 20! What do you mean I don't seduce the dragon!?

4

u/CollinsCouldveDucked Sep 08 '19

I was playing a short form rp thing and the dm was sort of weakwilled.

Basically one memeber of the party fucked his way through the whole session and my guy ate berries and avoided eyecontact.

5

u/MauiWowieOwie Sep 08 '19

That sucks. Gotta have a DM that don't put up with that shit.

"You wanna fuck the dragon? Okay, sure. He's male, roll a constitution save..."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

55

u/ImOnRedditAndStuff Sep 08 '19

I totally allow the rule of cool, but I don't let it happen for free. I'll always let my players try crazy crap, but I'll tell them there is a high chance for failure.

It's not everyone's cup of joe, but like I said, I like running a more realistic game!

26

u/jackofblaze Sep 08 '19

I mean, if you think about it, doing something crazy is a lot cooler with the chance of failure or death than without.

19

u/Jtoad Sep 08 '19

My group calls it the risk of cool.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

27

u/BluePizza3 Sep 08 '19

I love the rule of cool but cartoonish physics aren't cool IMHO.

That being said its ok to stretch physics and rules. Just don't break them.

5

u/GrandMasterEternal DM Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19

Yeah, rule of cool does mean the thing actually needs to be cool. The point is that it's something not entirely realistic, but not entirely possible. The less realistic, the harder the roll. An easy rule of cool roll would be something like kicking off a wall to get a little extra height on a jump. Not really RaW or all that realistic if the character isn't particularly agile.

A harder rule of cool would be, say, wrestling a dragon into submission and riding it around.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

I do support the rule of cool for situations where the breaking of realism is fairly minor. Jumping off a 100-foot cliff and expecting to be fine because "it's cool" is just plain silly

→ More replies (1)

5

u/vikinick Sep 08 '19

Yeah it's just like... I'll let things not in the rulebook happen, but such obvious things like fall damage you gotta have a very good reason for why jumping off a cliff doesn't kill you.

→ More replies (10)