r/DnD • • Sep 08 '19

Strict DM [OC]

Post image
49.4k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

19

u/Ioneos Sep 08 '19

If I'm not mistaken to effectively negate the fall the arrow would have to be as heavy as the archer and travel more than twice the speed of the descent.

20

u/LuBuAteMyDog Sep 08 '19

So I just gotta be STRONK and have a THICC arrow?

2

u/Ioneos Sep 08 '19

Exactamundo my brother.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19 edited Sep 09 '19

I'm going to be that guy with the physics, but it'd be fun (and gruesome) as hell to imagine so here we go:

TL;DR: As the arrow leaves your bow, the water around it's head starts to condense, creating a ball of mist that rapidly expands, engulfing first your arms, then your torso and as it reaches your head you hear a BOOM that signals the speed of sound being broken, and you start feeling blood drip in your shoulders as you notice that your timpanic membrane has burst and that was the last sound you'll ever hear, until a cleric can call upon the gods to regenerate them. At the same time, your bow - that is also moving faster than sound - shoots upwards and with all your might you try to keep hold of it, something that feels as if you had decided to grab a missile at half speed. You feel your arm to detaching itself from your body and as the humidity settles you notice that you have stopped falling, only to start being pulled by gravity again. Your comrades, once the clouds have settled, see you in a 3m crater, about 30cm deep, smaller and smaller gushes of blood leave the whole in your arm, as every heartbeat has a little less blood to pump. There are no remains of the bandit or your arm anywhere to be seen.

To calculate this, we can use the conservation of momentum as if it was a collision. If you saw a reverse footage of someone shooting arrows on ice, it'd look like a collision, actually, so that makes sense. We break the situation into 3 different views: The whole, the arrow leaving the bow and the bow stopping you.

Assumptions:

  • You weight equal to the average human: 75Kg

  • You're falling belly first, giving you the smallest terminal velocity posible (56m/s, 200Km/h or 120 mph)

  • You're firing an english longbow, with a heavy head/fletching, meaning your bow weights 5Kgs

  • Your arrow has the biggest length, heavy shaft head and fletching. That means it weights around 1Kg, and is 83cm (33in) long.

  • Your bow is enchanted with an unbreaking spell and can shoot arrows at any speed, because it isn't fun. the answer would be "your bow breaks" or "you can't fire that fast"

1 The Whole

First imagine as if you threw the arrow, and there was no bow to consider. With the total weight on you (yourself, bow and arrow) and speed, we can calculate your momentum as p = m*v = 4536Kgm/s. With our assumptions, it has to be fired at 4536m/s (16329Km/h or 10146mph). 13 times the speed of sound.

But wait, there's more! It was already travelling at 56 m/s down, so the total end velocity is 4592m/s (16529Km/h, 10266mph). In the grand scheme of thigns it doesn't make that much of a difference, but I'm thorough. That gives you an idea of how extreme this situation is at the start, but that'd be assuming the force is evenly applied in your body. Let's move to the more realistic description

2 The arrow leaving the bow

With the calculated arrow speed of 4592m/s we can calculate the speed of the bow when the arrow left using the same conservation of momentum. It gives us a speed of 907m/s (3265 Km/h, 2029 mph). That means the bow goes almost 3 times the speed of sound in the other direction.

3 The bow pulling you to a stop

If you're firing straight down with the whole length of your arm (which is as long as your arrow shaft, 83cm/33in) before really pulling you, the bow will travel the length of your arm twice: once until it reaches your shoulders, then again until your arm is extended above your head. Being generous, I'm going to say that the force is evenly distributed along the travel path.

Using conservation of energy we know the the amount of force needed F = E/d where E is the kinetic energy and d is the distance travelled. E = m * v^(2)/2 = 5 * 907^(2)/2 = 2.05MJ, and d = 1.66m. So the force you apply during the whopping 1.8 miliseconds that this takes is 1.2 million Newtons of force. The same as trying to lift a 120 ton object. around 5 times more than the 26 tons of force needed to rip a limb off.

EDIT: Some formating to find the numbers more easily and the bonus round, plus an update to the TL;DR

4 The power of the bow

Answering to IRL requests, let's check how power this bow has to be. The arrow, flying at that speed, has a kinetic energy of 1 * 4536^(2)/2 = 20MJ (the arrow is flying with the energy of 5Kg of TNT). The bow, to produce this energy, can be seen as a spring, so the energy in it is calculated by: k*x^(2)/2 = 20MJ, x is the distance of the draw, which is 80 centimeters, and k is the coeficient of the spring, which can be calculated to be: 64MJ/m^(2). That number doesn't mean much, so let's turn into a useful one: draw weight. At full draw, the force is F = k*x = 64297800 * 0.8 = 51MN. 51 Million of Newtons of force (11.5M pounds). Also enough to rip your arm out but then you can't fire, so not fun

5 The size of the crater

Using a cool explosion crater calculator I found online, I plugged the 5Kg of TNT and figured that the crater would be 3m (10 feet) in diameter and 35 cm (a foot) deep. I'd say the dude is quite dead.

EDIT 2: decided to calculate how the numbers would go if the arrow weighted as much as the person + the bow: 80Kg.

1 The Whole

The arrow, now, has a much greater impact on the momentum of the fall. The new mass is m = 160Kg and the speed is still 56m/s so the new momentum is 8960Kgm/s. With an 80Kg arrow we now have the new arrow speed being 112m/s, 400km/h, 250mph, basically twice the speed (props to u/Ioneos, you got that part right).

2 arrow leaving the bow

The bow, flinging the log, will acquire a bigger speed now. To move all 8960Kgm/s of momentum, it has to go 1792m/s up. Or mach 5 (5 times the speed of sound).

3 the bow pulling you to a halt

The new kinetic energy of the bow is E = 5*1792^(2)/2 = 8MJ, about 4 times more than the first situation, and around 2 Kg of TNT pulling your arm to a stop in less than 2 miliseconds

4 the power of the bow

The kinetic energy of the log will be E = 80 * 112^(2)/2 = 502KJ. so the coeficient of the spring is k = 501760 / 0.8^(2) = 784000 J/m^(2) which gives a full draw strengh of 672200N. Much more manageable.

5 The size of the hole

Well, with the 125g TNT worth of energy, you can only get a 60cm hole, about 5 cm deep. Really, quite small.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

u/Rising_Swell, I saw your argument with u/Ioneos in another thread, so here's the specific math.

1

u/Rising_Swell Sep 09 '19

So what happens if you do as they suggested and use a stupid-weighted arrow for shits and gigs? ya know, for more physics.

Also if you wanted to add a TL;DR, i'd suggest 'very dead'

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Done

1

u/Rising_Swell Sep 10 '19

That's awesome, great job dude :D

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '19

Thanks :)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '19

u/SrGrafo, is this enough to get an edit?

3

u/darf1023 Sep 08 '19

Nah. Totally gonna work.

1

u/Rising_Swell Sep 09 '19

Given the speed of the arrow is probably a lot more than twice the descent, you could probably go with a lighter arrow.

1

u/Ioneos Sep 09 '19

Not if the arrow has the same weight of the archer. It will definitely require twice or more the decent velocity, I'm just terrible at math so I'm not trying to be specific.

1

u/Rising_Swell Sep 09 '19

Have you ever seen an arrow get fired? The speed is generally a lot faster than falling, so if you could magically fire the arrow regardless of weight, at normal arrow speeds, the arrow could weigh less due it it travelling more than twice the speed of the falling person.

1

u/Ioneos Sep 09 '19 edited Sep 09 '19

Have you ever seen a log fired from a bow? We're talking forces much greater than humans could ever generate. I made a physics joke without knowing the exact math. That said I'm a hobby archer, I know how fast an arrow travels from my 80# recurve. When you increase the mass of the projectile it requires more force to propel it at the same speed. If you wish to slow your fall from a cliff with a bow it would require a projectile that weighs what you do propelled at at least 2+ times your fall speed.

1

u/Rising_Swell Sep 09 '19

That, at a base line, doesn't make sense to me unless you mean the force required to fire it at that speed is what needs to go up. A bigger arrow doesn't need more speed than a smaller one as far as i know, it would just need more force to get to said speed. So you could use a smaller arrow (smaller than the giant one) and fire it at a faster speed than before and have the same effect. Or fire a normal arrow at a speed measured in % of the speed of light presumably to do the same. Your bow may have structural issues for literally any of these scenarios though.