r/DnD • • Sep 08 '19

Strict DM [OC]

Post image
49.4k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

57

u/urbnlgnd Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 09 '19

I would be upset with a lenient DM. If your character can do almost anything; what exactly is making the game good?

Edit: People are really overthinking or misinterpreting this statement. I am referring to myself and only myself. If you like this play style, that is great and I'm glad it works for you. I am saying that I prefer rule oriented games because that's what I like. I don't hate you or your preferred ways of playing D&D or any other d20 based game. Always remember this is a statement/opinion and not me declaring war on everyone who don't think like me. If I was your friend and I said this in casual conversation, would your reply be the same as it is or would there be some chuckles followed by witty banter. Goodnight everyone. I'm going to go back to lurking in the shadows for now.

24

u/cparen DM Sep 08 '19

Ditto, which is part of why I left the last group. Everyone else was having fun (I checked), so no sense fighting it. I now have a relatively by the book dm who keeps the adventure moving and am having a blast.

5

u/Equeon Warlock Sep 09 '19

Yeah, I love it when players make crazy exploits through creativity and imagination and not only "rule of cool" or "leniency". I usually taper down the wackiest ideas with a reasonable penalty ("you can certainly try") and more often than not they still go for it.

But my players aren't backflipping to the moon and oneshotting dragons through fuckery.

4

u/epraider Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19

Having fun goofing around with your buddies. That’s basically my group did. I didn’t let them do absurd shit and ignore all rules, but I would let frivolous things slide, and if they could make a case for why they should be able to do something or it was particularly hilarious, it was good.

2

u/DaSaw Sep 09 '19

Different people like different kinds of stories. It's like movies. Some movies shoot for a realistic aesthetic. Others let their characters get away with ridiculous action scenes. And then there's cartoons, which have their own rules.

You mean to tell me you could have slipped out of those handcuffs at any time?!

No! Only if it's funny!

0

u/DeficitDragons Sep 08 '19

Compelling story?

3

u/urbnlgnd Sep 08 '19

I know that could be a valid reason which is why I said "I would". For me the story comes from the characters and their rolls or creative thinking to work around the rules. This is the age old God mode good/bad argument.

1

u/Vulkan192 Sep 08 '19

But if you knew there was valid reasons, why ask the question? Even more, why shoot down the answers you’re given?

1

u/urbnlgnd Sep 08 '19

Did you miss the part where I try to take sure people understand I'm talking about myself? I never shot anything down. I did not try to make an argument. Why are people trying to fight?

1

u/Vulkan192 Sep 08 '19

Because you asked a question and then shot someone who answered it down.

1

u/Barbarossa6969 Sep 08 '19

It's called a rhetorical question dipshit.

0

u/Vulkan192 Sep 08 '19

It’s called ‘being a dick’, asshole.

0

u/Barbarossa6969 Sep 08 '19

Yes, you have indeed been being a dick.

0

u/Vulkan192 Sep 08 '19

Clever. You work really hard on that one bud? Mommy must be so proud. If you go tell her maybe she’ll let you have some chocolate milk before bedtime.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/urbnlgnd Sep 08 '19

I was giving my personal opinion. I never called it trash or stupid or invalid. Why do you want to fight?

1

u/Vulkan192 Sep 08 '19

I don’t. Why did you ask the question if you’re just going to dismiss the answers you get?

1

u/urbnlgnd Sep 08 '19

Are you even reading the comments?

0

u/Vulkan192 Sep 08 '19

Yes. A question was asked, the answer was dismissed.

→ More replies (0)

-9

u/saintash Sorcerer Sep 08 '19

Cause its fun?

Just as long as you don't argue when the dm say says no to something it makes the game more fun if you have moments of leniency.

Constant strict rules blow.

I came to play a game. Not fallow rule rules like the Bible.

5

u/urbnlgnd Sep 08 '19

The rules are not "strict" per se but more like checks and balances.

6

u/RocketPapaya413 Sep 08 '19

The rules are basically the fundamental physical laws of the world.

If I made a real-life plan based on assuming that gravity exists and then somebody else just decided that gravity exists for them then how could any sort of consistency or expectations exist?

1

u/urbnlgnd Sep 08 '19

Yes and as a DM you use the rules to make a no gravity scenario work. Checks and balances are what the laws of the universe boil down to.

2

u/markevens Sep 09 '19

Then play a different system that isn't so rule dependent.

The rules of D&D are open enough to be extremely creative, but your character can't encompass every cool thing possible in the game at once.

So many times when a player wants to do something outside of their character's abilities, there is some class feature that will allow it. If they want to do that cool thing, they can work within the rules to do it.