"I STAB MYSELF WITH THE SWORD OF THE ENEMY, CLINCHING MY INTESTINES TO KEEP IT IN PLACE, MAKING HIM UNABLE TO MOVE AND THEN ATTACK HIM. HE IS PARALYZED SO I HAVE ADVANTAGE IN THE ATTACK, RIGHT?!"
"Wel... I don't know... I guess I'll allow it. Before that you take 18 points of damage because of the stab though, how many do you have left?"
"I only had 5 hp left"
"Well... you get incapacitated then"
"WTF THESE STRICT NO FUN ALLOWED DMS MAN ALWAYS THE SAME WITH YOU"
Not even necessarily bloodied! If he rages right before hitting the ground and he's lv 20, the average damage he'll take is 35, which means that even if he rolled 0 every level up, his (likely) +5 in con along 20 levels would soak that damage easily!
Though, as a DM, after hitting the die cap I'd start rolling less dies and adding full dies to the result, so falling from orbit would mean 120 damage. If he used average on every level up, he'd have 245 HP, so still not bloodied!
The horse is going to slow your fall like Feather fall? Like, you gonna stop real quick when you hit the horse. And depending on how high the cliff, that horse is dead. Super dead.
I absolutely allow and endorse Rule of Cool at my table, but to a realistic extent. If you're style killing an enemy, hell yes. If you're trying to use a horse to break your fall, you'll likely regret it. A player death at that point is definitely on them for being stupid.
Personally I try to balance the rule of cool with the "rule of I'm three beers in and just thought of a hilarious way for it to go wrong". In this case I would probably allow the player not to die but, if their argument is that the horse will break the fall, that fall is going to break that horse. That player is going to become covered in blood and broken bones one way or another.
That also works. At the end of the day, so long as everyone was entertained, that's all I aim for. The fact that they keep coming back makes it worth it.
Won't lie, I thought of that too when I first saw this. Prime example of what happens when players are stupid. It will forever be one of my favorite Critical Role moments because of that. Plus it was just funny.
I love the second campaing so much but goddamn never will ever come Close to the we're basically gods moment. Perfection for all the wrong reasons, and a perfect illustration of why I love Matt.
193
u/LordCamelslayer DM Sep 08 '19
I wouldn't even call that a strict DM. If you just jumped off a cliff with no means of flying or slowing your fall, you're asking for death.