r/StarTrekViewingParty • Co-Founder • Jan 08 '18

Discussion DSC, Episode 1x10, Despite Yourself

-= DSC, Season 1, Episode 10, Despite Yourself =-

While in unfamiliar territory, the USS Discovery crew is forced to get creative in their next efforts to survive opposing and unprecedented forces and return home.

 

6 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

6

u/RobLoach Jan 09 '18

I love this show.

3

u/KingofDerby Jan 09 '18

New rival to the Monster Maroons for the title of best uniform.

Jaw dropped in horror at 'that' death.

2

u/theworldtheworld Jan 12 '18

Well, it's nice that ol' Two-Takes is back in the big chair...

1

u/mrgeebaby Jan 11 '18

I have always struggled with the Mirror Universe episodes, especially in the Treks that have an ongoing plot. In DS9 they seemed to get in the way of the plot; as the Dominion War was heating up and the plot building momentum they would hit us with a MU episode and break the inertia of the season. The OS was obviously goofy with evil Kirk and the Terran Empire - and today we still have the same goofyness. At least here they are mixing it in with the main plot, but again it just feels like a distraction or ‘filler’ to me.

2

u/Robbap Jan 12 '18

I think there's some potential for it to not be filler. They brought the the Defiant which had gone not only to the MU, but into its past. People have also gone on record that the Klingon War will be season one only.

I'd wager they're setting it up, that the back half of this season will be trying to get back to the Prime Universe via however the Defiant travelled, but wind up in the future. If the means of travel the Defiant used correlate present-day PU to past-MU, then by that logic present-day MU would correlate to future-PU.

The season-ending cliffhanger could be that they wind up in the future-PU, sort of a "got home but not really home" kind of deal. Would also tie in why the spore drive is never mentioned in any other series - the two ships that used it were both lost with all hands, it was declared to dangerous and buried deep in some records. Personally, I've kind of given up hope that they're sort out the continuity with the spore drive, but that would be one way out.

We use the MU as a plot device, rather than a side tangent, we work in spore drive continuity, and also have the Klingon War only take place in season one, since it's long since over in whatever future they jump to. Season two then can have potential to split the crew - do we try to get back to our own time, or do we make the best of where we are now? Burnham's mutiny in the season one premiere gets mirrored, as we now have a whole group of the crew that wants to mutiny against whatever the captain's decision is. And there's our main story arc for the first half of season two.