r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Sep 24 '17
Discussion DSC, Episodes 1x1 & 1x2, The Vulcan Hello & Battle at the Binary Stars
-= DSC, Season 1, Episodes 1 & 2, The Vulcan Hello & Battle at the Binary Stars =-
The Vulcan Hello: While patrolling Federation space, the USS Shenzhou encounters an object of unknown origin, putting First Officer Michael Burnham to her greatest test yet.
Battle at the Binary Stars: Face to face with Klingon vessels, the USS Shenzhou prepares for the possibility of war if negotiations fail. Amidst the turmoil, Burnham looks back to her Vulcan upbringing for guidance.
Written By: Bryan Fuller, Alex Kurtzman, Akiva Goldsman
Directed By: David Semel
Original Air Date: 24 September, 2017
Stardate: Unknown
•
u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 27 '17
Reminder: in the US, only the first episode will be shown on CBS. The second will be on CBS all access.
We are combining these episodes for the sake of simplicity, as they both release today.
Attention! We are considering how to handle the DS9 and Discovery schedules going forward. We invite everyone to fill out the poll here!
1
u/BunchOCrunch Sep 25 '17
This confuses me a bit. I watched the first episode last night on TV. Are you saying all future episodes will only be on CBS All Access? Or is CBS All Access just going to be one episode ahead of regular TV?
2
u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder Sep 25 '17
All future episodes will only be on CBS All Access, unfortunately.
I'm curious if enough people pirate it or just share a single subscription and then cancel it as soon as the show is over (as my friends and I plan to do) if CBS decides to abandon the idea.
1
u/BunchOCrunch Sep 25 '17
Damn, that's unfortunate.
1
u/dittbub Sep 26 '17
I read this
Access subscribers in the United States and Canada. For those outside the US and Canada, Star Trek: Discovery will air on Netflix, with episodes coming within 24 hours of their CBS All Access debuts.
But it looks like CBS All Access isn't even available in Canada yet? Are Canadians just fucked?
https://www.gamespot.com/articles/star-trek-discovery-release-time-how-to-watch-new-/1100-6453477/
2
8
u/dittbub Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 26 '17
Going into this I knew very little of what to expect. I've purposely not kept up on it. I didn't even know it was airing today until I visited this sub and saw this thread!
I expected this show to take one of 3 directions. 2 of those routes I think I could like and enjoy. The 3rd not so much. The first route, If they went a completely traditional trek approach I think I would like it. My opinion though has always been we've had already 28 seasons of traditional, formulaic, trek. The second route; being something completely new and novel for star trek (which I think this opener and 'next week preview' shows will be the case). The third route was the approach I was dreading. Some kind of compromise between traditional and new that would have the positives of neither and make a mess of a show.
Star trek discovery does show us that there still exists the traditional trek world. But instead of telling this story through a ship, its told through a main character.
I love this approach and direction. And I have to say so far I LOVE this character. I love her backstory. I love the acting. This acting is far and above anything we've seen in the campy old treks (good acting in traditional trek is the exception, not the rule).
I'm a little unclear of the timeline. I'm reading this show IS NOT in the JJ Abrams universe? This is after Star Trek: Enterprise but before TOS? Is that right?
The one thing I don't like is the design of the Klingons. They look more plasticy and fake than before. Why did they take away all the hair? And their costumes look like weird renaissance man-dresses.... I would have preferred more warrior garb!? Animal skins? Bone necklaces?
I do like the premise however of the upcoming Klingon war and the Klingon politics/culture they've designed. My problems are with the visual/superficial designs.
I really liked how they've tied in this show to the previous treks using the Sarek character. I take it Micheal is something akin to Spock's older adoptive sister? I really can't wait to learn more about this character.
I'm unsure how to take this new found ability for Vulcans to mind meld across vast distances... or did I misread that scene? Its not terrible just not sure or not I like it. Some things shouldn't be messed with... but I will keep an open mind!
When I saw the android at coms I rolled my eyes. I thought 'you can't have a Data BEFORE Data!'. I was relieved the thing went down with the ship.
The preview for next week looked interesting. I hope they keep this new format up. I hope they can use it to keep the spirit of trek alive in new and interesting ways. We will still get to see deep-space phenomena to tell courageous stories that exemplify the best of humanity? Or will we just get a story of good guys and bad guys ala star wars?
Anyways I am thoroughly excited to once again have NEW trek in my life!
3
u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Sep 26 '17
I thought the Daft Trek robot wasn't necessarily an android. It could be something more akin to Siri. A robotic assistant on the bridge, like an anthropomorphic extension of the computer itself.
You didn't misread the mind melding scene, I don't think. Since Sarek said "communicating over these distances takes a significant physical cost" I'd say it was actually him communicating with her telepathically. Which is a bit friggin' intrusive IMO, but I guess Vulcans are cool with that.
4
u/dittbub Sep 26 '17
Apparently Ensign Daft Punk is a squid! https://www.reddit.com/r/StarTrekDiscovery/comments/72i325/does_anyone_have_detailsbackstory_on_ensign_daft/dniyya8/
2
u/dittbub Sep 26 '17
At first I thought that scene was like, her just visualizing him. Cause they mind melded in the past so he would be 'part of her' in a sense and this was a way to manifest that. A form of meditation self introspection or something...
I thought that would have been better anyway
1
u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Sep 26 '17
I think so too. Without the line about physical cost it could have easily been interpreted there esp. with him mentioning her carrying his Katra. Which is also not how I understood Katra to work, but that's a fairly minor inconsistency IMO.
5
u/legendx Sep 25 '17
For comparison I'd be curious to hear the reactions of those who remember seeing Encounter at Farpoint the night it aired. Was the design, writing, acting, etc good enough to tell yourself "This will definitely have 7 seasons and 4 movies"
6
9
u/PureGoldX58 Sep 25 '17
I think it's important to remember that this is a prologue, the rest of the series could be very different.
3
u/alambert212 Sep 25 '17
Yes I think that's a very good point, especially with the death of Captain Georgiou and the preview we got of Captain Lorca. I still didn't like Michael's character and her decisions in this. But we'll see...
4
u/Tired8281 Sep 25 '17
So, the Klingons only got it together a few years before Arena and Errand Of Mercy. And somehow they fell apart after Judgement. There's what, 150 years between Judgement and Errand Of Mercy, right? And there was a Romulan War in there somewhere, too. The timeline seems really forced, about the only thing it's consistent with is the Voyager episode about B'elanna's messiah kid (which this is obviously a prequel/origin story to). The ships and effects look Abramverse, especially the bridge of the Shenzhou, which looked totally like a slight redress of the bridge from 2009 (with less lens flare thank god!).
4
u/Lessthanzerofucks Sep 25 '17
Michael was trying to avoid a war, and she knew how to do it. I think her mutiny made perfect sense, and the consequences were worth the risk. Definitely emotionally motivated and that’s the point. 🖖
1
u/dittbub Sep 25 '17
I think the point is it was logically motivated!
I think the ambiguity is the point :P
ALSO loved the scene where she out-logics the computer to escape the brigg
4
u/KingofDerby Sep 25 '17
Had a tear in my eye when the classic trek notes played...
This is the first time I've not been years behind on watching a series. While the Trek of the TOS films was 'my' Trek, TNG was what I was bought up on, DS9 was the the one that always spoke to me, and VOY was what I bonded with others over. They each have their place in my heart and from the moment I heard that sound, I knew this would have it's own place.
Surprised that there are no probes, either for scanning or acting as a relay.
Daft Punk on the Bridge!
Why are you killing yourself to get to the bridge to tell the captain in person? Just call her up on the phone!
I really enjoyed this. Can't wait for next week!
Like that, while the klingons on the big ship have a shared fashion sense and similar facial features, what little we see of the other klingons shows different faces and fashions. To often, races in Trek are too uniform. Considering the design history of Klingons in Trek, we have an opportunity to really show some variety.
3
u/alambert212 Sep 25 '17
Wow so a lot of thoughts after that. First, it really did feel like Trek to me. Definitely more JJ-verse style, but that's how any modern Trek show will feel. The bridge looked amazing and felt like a federation ship to me. The costumes, sets, CGI and makeup all looked great to me, I can see why it was expensive.
Like most people around here, I wasn't a fan of Michael or her character. Knocking out her captain of seven years over a hunch like that definitely doesn't seem like something a first officer in the federation would ever do. The only thing that makes this a bit better was her sentencing at the end. I'd say life in prison is almost harsh by federation standards. Also, for those who didn't watch the After Trek show, Sonequa Martin-Green strongly suggested we will have plenty more ups and downs with her character, like tonight's episodes. We'll see what that means going forward but it looks like our main character won't be perfect, let alone very likable (at least thus far).
A lot of people have been dogging on the acting. I agree for the most part, but there were some positives. I actually liked Lt. Saru. From the trailer I thought he was gonna be my least favorite and make my eyes roll the most. But his acting and backstory were much better than I expected and I'm glad to see he will be in future episodes. The actor who played Sarek was also better than I expected. Looking forward to more of him I hope. Yes, acting needs improving but thankfully Jason Isaacs looks set to be an important character starting next week, so that should help.
It's interesting to see the Klingons here. 24 divided houses being brought together here. Are we seeing a reigniting of the Klingon religious and warrior culture? It seems like the divided houses didn't put much into either of those at the beginning here.
Overall, I'm still excited to watch the upcoming episodes. I'm happy to have Trek back even if it has a different feel (every Trek show does). We will see how the rest of this season goes, but it's not the worst start to a Trek show out there. If only we didn't have to deal with CBS All Access
3
Sep 25 '17
I enjoyed it. I liked it a bit more on the first watch (high emotions and whatnot) than the second. The second watch made things seem a little less epic and smaller in scope, which isn't necessarily a bad thing but made the impact feel lessened.
I like the stuff they're doing with the aliens: Klingons, Vulcans, etc. All the choice feel appropriate for the universe and make sense in context of what we already know.
I like the set design and costuming.
I loved T'Kuvma and will be disappointed if that's the last we see of him.
Michelle Yeoh... not a great actress.
The ship battle felt empty. We never see another bridge or eventalk to another captain. The ships feel disposable.
Podcast: https://youtu.be/N0t2I_OLFn4
5
2
u/theworldtheworld Sep 24 '17 edited Sep 24 '17
Gah, Hollywood hack Akiva Goldsman! So did Meyer ever really join the writing team, or was that just a false lead?
Anyway, I'm afraid I will sit this one out, but I look forward to reading people's impressions!
2
u/Mandeponium Sep 27 '17
I had mixed feelings but my biggest complaint by far was Michael attacking her captain and trying to take over the ship. It was a cool scene, but not very believable.
Also I'm a little bummed we won't have the Asian lady as captain for the series. Her acting was pretty wooden but I still liked her a lot better than Michael. And I didn't really care for the spoiler in the opening credits either: "Special Guest Star 'Michelle Yeoh.'"
1
u/heywhereskitt Oct 05 '17
My biggest complaint is the credits. Where are the horns? Also, I don't care about all 20 Producers. Save that shit for imdb.
2
u/katamuro Sep 27 '17
Love it. The CGI, the storyline, the actors. So far I love everything about it. Finally a Star Trek that feels alive.
2
u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Sep 28 '17
I really liked the episodes. The second more than the first. Unfortunately I did a dummy and watched the 2nd before the first accidentally. Didn't realize until the end. Now that I think about it, what happened to the title cards? I liked the title cards. It's just weird that TV seems to be like that these days, just dropping you right in. I didn't flinch when the first thing I see is the XO pointing a dustbuster at the captain.
Going back to the first after the 2nd was weird. I kind of wish I hadn't done it that way, but still. Really enjoyed it.
Saru is my standout favorite character right now. I'm really looking forward to more of him. Also I think Cmdr. Burnham's great! The human raised vulcan idea is a good one, although I'm not sure why they needed to drag Sarek into it. It could be a new vulcan, but that's fine.
Also having a prologue on another ship is a nice touch. I thought it was a lot if TNG had started following Riker under Captain Pressman on the Pegasus as they test the cloak and the crew mutinies against the treaty violation. I felt like it was a strong start and Trek shows are sometimes hit or miss on their first episode.
I was pleasantly surprised but it's hard to judge by just the first episode. As it really was one episode. I won't get too into the CBS thing, because it kind of does feel like a shakedown that ultimately might get the show into trouble regarding a second season. I've heard a theory that they're testing this on US CBS AA and worldwide on NetFlix as a barometer of their service vs. the program itself. So best case scenario: CBS AA flops, NetFlix has a hit, it's a great show and CBS goes full NetFlix for S2. Of course, I know nothing about how TV licensing goes so...
1
u/kompergator Sep 28 '17
Anyone think that the Captain and Number One opening the well at the beginning is technically a breach of the Prime Directive?
1
u/unnapping Sep 25 '17
Disappointing. It's just going to be about war with the Klingons. I don't find that interesting. This is not Star Trek, it's Star Wars.
8
u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder Sep 25 '17
The Vulcan Hello
I was really uncertain, and I think I'm still kinda uncertain. Parts I liked, other parts I didn't.
Dialogue is bad. Dutch angles are bad. Writing isn't great. Acting isn't very good either. I'm not a fan of Michael.
Sets and props are great. CGI is great. I love all the old sound effects! And I love the TOS-movie Red Alert graphic! Contrary to others, it felt like Star Trek. Also, strangely, I think my favorite character is actually the really tall "I fear death" alien whose name I don't remember. He actually had the best acting, I thought so anyway, and his race backstory works for me.
Honestly my biggest complaint is that I just don't like the new Klingons. :( I miss oldschool Klingons...