r/StarTrekViewingParty • Co-Founder • Oct 10 '17

Discussion DSC, Episode 1x4, The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry

-= DSC, Season 1, Episode 4, The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry =-

With tensions and stakes high as Starfleet continues in their efforts to end the war with the Klingons, Burnham begins to settle in to her new position aboard the USS Discovery.

 

10 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

9

u/dittbub Oct 10 '17

finger scan good enough for postage but not spore rooms

6

u/Kraken15 Oct 10 '17

Also something to look forward to in the future: Postage that doesn't stop beeping, ever, until you open it.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

Obviously a breath scan is excessively difficult to falsify. I could just cut your hand off and get your mail.

5

u/mandy009 Oct 10 '17

When Burnham somehow assumes the heretofore violent creature is a peckish fungitarian, the film editing cuts to a new action scene every six seconds. They condense all the plot resolution of a bunch of tactical and consequential preparation we don't see given proper deference. Gives the appearance of a rushed job, maybe also on the writer's and producer's parts.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '17

I still have all the concerns that I've had since ep3, but this one felt more like Trek than the previous show. I would appreciate an episode that establishes the universe and ship a bit more, because it feels like we're flying by the seat of our pants at this point. There's very little to grab on to for establishment.

5

u/Kraken15 Oct 10 '17

Some things I didn't enjoy:

-The woman (3rd officer?) who thinks its a good idea to attempt to anesthetize an unknown by heretofore unstoppable killing machine with standard medicines and who then proceeds to attempt to "cut off its claws" using one of the same guns heretofore shown to be completely ineffective against it. Also, her attitude that anything short of, apparently, mounting the creature on a gun to weaponize is serves no purpose - Burnham's been working for, like, a couple of hours as far as I can tell, just getting a general picture of the creature, and this woman's already, "Okay, too much playtime, there's no possible way having even the vaguest idea how this creature lives could help us in our mission to weaponize it."

-The magic hand waving with the harness that the other Starfleet ship just happened to come up that interacts with the brain/nervous system of the unknown creature and uses it as a navigation system. with that now enables us to fly anywhere. Also, although phasers set to kill can't do anything, this little robot with some needles can easily pierce the creature's hide.

-The Klingons have just been chilling where they are, for six months, because they don't want to steal fuel from the only working ship because it's "dishonorable" because yada yada yada, enemy's ship, yada yada.

-Voq, who seems to have no leadership qualities whatsoever, taking the place of T'Kuvma, who, if nothing else, had charisma.

 

Some things I liked:

-Burnham's description of the creature as simply being what it is instead of being good or evil - very Trek, in my opinion, and this looks like it will be a recurring theme tying into Burnham, Captain Lorca, etc.

-Most of the character interaction, save for what's noted above.

-Confirmation, via the call from the admiral Captain Lorca took, that, at least for the time being, Lorca isn't going completely AWOL with this project and the Discovery is still tied into the greater Starfleet command chain - in the last episode, this sense of being part of the greater whole was a little thin, in my opinion.

 

There are more nitpicks above than compliments because it's easier to nitpick, but, anyway, I'm having fun and enjoying the new series. This is my first time posting here, so I didn't get a chance to mention it in the previous episode thread, but I really like the possibilities posed by the new technologies, designs, atmosphere, etc., and hope they keep this Trek in its own timeline, inspired by the other two, but not necessarily connected - because if they try to lodge Discovery into either of the other two timelines, things start to get pretty crowded and weird what with the lack of any mentions of this big Klingon war or the development of the Infinite Improbability Mushroom Drive that we are no longer using in the 23rd or 24th century, for some reason. If this new show is inspired by, but separate from the other timelines, it'll provide a lot more room to grow and explore, I think.

6

u/Kraken15 Oct 10 '17

Ooh! Ooh! Also, why is there no airlock or somesuch for safely putting things/people in and out of the creature's cage? Or why didn't they just beam things in there?

6

u/thewaterballoonist Oct 10 '17

I think the woman getting ripped by Ripper was an example of the disfunction on the Discovery. It's not a crew we've seen in star trek before. Sure DS9 and VOY had their interpersonal conflict, but they managed to work together as a crew. This was an example of someone acting in a distinctly non-trek way and getting grizzly-manned as a result.

There's a conflict happening between the scientists and Lorca's war effort. Lorca's hoping Michael will be the bridge.

2

u/Kraken15 Oct 10 '17

I agree, although it was still horror movie-stupid on the part of that woman. Also, she seemed like a perfectly intelligent and serviceable character up to this point. I think she would have been more useful to keep around to backup Lorca, hear his private musings, and slowly reinforce and build the scientist vs. war effort tension you refer to instead of killing her off. It seems like we're already running kind of low on characters with any kind of history and who we should care about.

2

u/heywhereskitt Oct 11 '17

Agreed. Another example would be the blonde spore engineer who started throwing a temper tantrum when asked to do his job. Scotty might have talked a little shit, but he followed orders. This guy has been mean to everyone so far.

2

u/heywhereskitt Oct 11 '17

I also didn't enjoy seeing the security officer die. She was a complete micromanaging jerk, but she didn't have to die. This isn't GoT. There doesn't have to be a death every episode.

Saru is down to earth and completely genuine. With all the talk this week about character likeability I've decided to pick Saru as my champion. Can't wait to see him grow. Don't kill him!

I am enjoying this series a lot as well. This is the first Trek series I've chosen to watch while on air. Every episode seems to resolve some of the issues I had with the episode before it. With EP04, I enjoyed seeing the Ripper AND Lorna become something more than monsters.

Lastly, is there a Klingon romance brewing with Voq and his ASSistant?

EDIT: die

1

u/sinda_rella Oct 11 '17

This is literally just like the plot of Doctor Who's "The Beast Below" Season 5, Episode 2.

1

u/I_am_a_haiku_bot Oct 11 '17

This is literally just like

the plot of Doctor Who's "The Beast

Below" Season 5, Episode 2.


-english_haiku_bot