r/StarTrekViewingParty • Showrunner • Oct 31 '17

Discussion DSC, Episode 1x7, Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad

-= DSC, Season 1, Episode 7, Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad=-

As the USS Discovery crew attempts to let loose at a party, an unwelcome visitor comes aboard bringing about a problematic and twisted sequence of events.

 

8 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

6

u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Oct 31 '17

Miles away my favorite episode of DSC yet! When I saw the preview for it I was pretty excited because "time loop" is exactly the kind of Trek weird sci-fi stuff I love and was worried we wouldn't get that with DSC. I was starting to expect almost exclusively world-building Trek w/r/t the Klingon war. This is the episode I wanted to see!

I feel like the party scene is something completely different that we never saw on Trek before, but it's well executed IMO. It's realistic to me that there would be a drinking party or two on board a Federation star ship during the TOS years, which this is so close to it might as well be.

As I've never seen the TOS Mudd episodes I can't judge how suitable having him as this particular character is, but I do like his character quite a bit! His personality is akin to Q, but with more malevolence and less regard for others.

I really like Stammets as he is now, but I'm still kinda unsure how he's outside of time. I guess it's something to do with the spore drive putting him into some sort of weird flux? I'm going to guess that spore drive is cancer city. Oh well, no matter. It's forgivable if it tells a good story and this absolutely did.

It's hard to rate these as there have only been seven episodes, but I'm going to adopt the Pensky scale and say this is probably going to end up being a 4/5.

4

u/KingofDerby Oct 31 '17

As I've never seen the TOS Mudd episodes I can't judge how suitable having him as this particular character is, but I do like his character quite a bit! His personality is akin to Q, but with more malevolence and less regard for others.

He's played more for laughs in TOS and TAS...but he's sill does evile things. DIS acknowledges his evil.

3

u/dittbub Oct 31 '17

I find it odd no one is talking more about the Captains danger room. He is keeping/making torture death pain pills? Those weren't mudds. Those belonged to Lorca

4

u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Nov 01 '17

You have a good point. I put it down to "weapons collector" but he's got some brutal stuff in there. Sort of like Kivas Fajo.

I could see Lorca getting into some twisted situations throughout this series. He's not Picard with his somewhat rigid morality, not Sisko who would appreciate the whole "Context is for kings" thing. I think he compares most directly to Jonathan "I will cut you!" Archer.

3

u/nanoman92 Nov 03 '17

Isn't that gun the same from "the most toys"?

3

u/boeman1995 Oct 31 '17

Not sure what to think of it. The whole time loop principle is a bit old to me. I seem to remember multiple episodes in the TNG/VOY/DS9-span that did the same basic thing. It feels like an easy way to fill an episode as well. I will say that I liked the way they executed it. Mudd was portrated very well, love his personality. Also hate it! I'm also really liking the whole Stamets-story developing and I feel like Anthony is doing an amazing job; Stamets is a super well-played character imo!

3

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

I liked this one! It's obviously a lift of Cause and Effect with the goal of setting up I, Mudd but it kept my attention and restored some fun to the series.

The neat trick was to turn the plot heavy Cause and Effect narrative into a character piece that examines Burnham and the others. Pretty smart to do, and hopefully the show sticks with this track.