r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner • Nov 06 '17
Discussion DSC, Episode 1x8, Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum
-= DSC, Season 1, Episode 8, Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum=-
The USS Discovery is tasked with a high priority mission to planet Pahvo and learn the science behind the Klingons' cloaking technology.
Written By: Kirsten Beyer
Directed By: John Scott
Original Air Date: 5 November 2017
Stardate: 1308.9
3
u/Kraken15 Nov 07 '17
It seems like a lot of potential stories are being thrown away in this series. Just off the top of my head, T'Kuvma's been killed, Voq was abandoned (although presumably he'll return), Vice-Admiral Cornwell appears to be dead, and L'Rell's been imprisoned instead of either escaping with Cornwell or pretending to serve under Kol while undermining his regime.
Also, I don't know what they're going to do about Saru - what he did and how he broke, shouldn't that end his career, or at least result in his demotion from first officer? My guess is that he'll stay right where he is, although I'm betting they continue to explore his issues about fear, safety, and Burnham "taking" things from him.
3
u/milkisklim Nov 07 '17
Star fleet is pretty forgiving when it comes to their officers undergoing short term bouts of insanity.
1
u/I_am_a_haiku_bot Nov 07 '17
Star fleet is pretty forgiving
when it comes to their officers undergoing
short term bouts of insanity.
-english_haiku_bot
4
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
The series returns to its serialized storyline, and the weaknesses return.
On the podcast, I mentioned that this felt like Misdirection: The Episode. Everything here seems like it was supposed to be a mystery or misdirection, but the writing was so fast paced and loose that you're left unsure of whether or not the mysteries are intentional. Is this something that will be explained going forward, or was it bad writing? For things like the status of the admiral, why can't the show just give us a hint as to her condition? Do we gain anything by being left in the dark as to whether or not shes alive or dead?
The Pahvos planet is typical Trek but the Saru story was confusing. I spent the entire episode thinking he was possessed. But I guess he just decided to do all that on his own? And he's still somehow the XO?
The serialized story continues to clash with the stand alone history of Trek. Like the "vital dilithium mining planet" from a few episodes ago, we're suddenly told about a planet that can end the war. Except, to accomplish our goals we send 3 people in on foot? The war storyline continues to be the weak link and exists in the background to a detrimental degree.
http://thepenskypodcast.com/si-vis-pacem-para-bellum/