r/StarTrekViewingParty • Showrunner • Oct 02 '17

Discussion DSC, Episode 1x3, Context is for Kings

-= DSC, Season 1, Episode 3, Context is for Kings =-

Michael Burnham finds herself aboard the USS Discovery, where she quickly realizes things are not as they seem, including the mysterious Captain Gabriel Lorca.

 

9 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

5

u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder Oct 03 '17

I really liked it. A lot more than 1 and 2.

Lorca is fantastic and is my new favorite character.

Discovery is so fucking weird. Black badges? Black alert? Weird tech? I'm on board.

Episode felt better put together as well, but there's still some clunky exposition.

Thank God Saru is sticking around. That promotion is deserved.

So THAT'S where we get the TV MA rating! Worthwhile, I say. That felt like something out of Fringe (and I loved Fringe).

Did she say "shit"? I'm down with that.

Much more promising than the last episodes.

6

u/dittbub Oct 03 '17

I liked it too! But "Breath Scan" is a little too weird tech for me

4

u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Oct 03 '17

Kinda gross too.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '17

It also seems incredibly weak as a security system (as we see). At least make it a retina scan!

2

u/Seedify Oct 04 '17

I liked it a lot. However, some people have stated that the whole idea the "this is a warship" thing goes against everything Trek. I guess I agree with that, but still, this was a captivating episode...

1

u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Oct 06 '17

"this is a warship" thing goes against everything Trek

I'm with /u/pensky on this one, the Klingon war has been canon since TOS so I'll give it a pass. However I am alarmed that most dramatic TV can't get past ultraviolence these days.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '17

Eh, the Defiant is a warship.

7

u/remog Oct 03 '17 edited Oct 03 '17

I kind of thought that Captain Lorca has a kind of Captain Ransom vibe to him. A Desperate zeal to win at all costs - ethics be damned.

A quote came to mind from Ransom in the VOY episode "Equinox":

It's easy to cling to principles when you're standing on a vessel with its bulkheads intact, manned by a crew that's not starving.

5

u/dittbub Oct 03 '17

I hope that tribble is sterilized.

3

u/mandy009 Oct 03 '17

I thought it was a Mirror Universe episode at first. Very edgy.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

The pacing of the dialogue made it difficult to know what was being said at times. I had to rewatch the episode twice just to catch everything.

2

u/heywhereskitt Oct 06 '17

This episode was an improvement on the Prologue, for me. I'm glad Michelle Yeoh's guest appearance is over. I'm starting to like Michael a bit more, but Saru is my favorite character. I love Lorca's mystery and darkness (even though I keep thinking of Isaacs' character in Cure for Wellness). I'm excited. This is the first Trek series I've followed on air.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

I enjoyed it less than the first two episodes. The prologue, IMO, had a nice mix of modernity and Trek tropes while Context is for Kings felt too modern and detached from the expectations of a Trek series.

I'm having an issue with the information pacing, as it's taking a long time to establish anything about the universe we're in. I have a hard time understanding where we are, both location-wise and timeline-wise. I need an episode or two where we stay on Discovery, learn about the ship, and learn about the Federation's ethos at this time in history.

Lorca is fine but the performance exceeds the characterization. He seems like a generic, "morally grey" character at this pooint (those fortune cookies...) and needs time to establish himself.

I don't think it was a disaster of an episode but it moved the series in a direction I hope to avoid. Future episodes can hopefully turn us in a more interesting direction.

https://youtu.be/yb4CAabx5eg