r/cheesemaking • • 23d ago

If only I could sell some cheese. Just a vent/rant.

0 Upvotes

I'm so fed up with the system. I've always wanted to be a traditional cheesemaker. Since my suburban childhood reading ye olde time books I always dreamt of handmilking cows and making aged cheeses. Now I'm doing it on my own homestead and it's going beautifully. My passion seems to have bred a natural talent.

I had dairy goats, now just one house cow(I want two!!) and am making beautiful wheels of many kinds. I'm so proud of my shiny healthy livestock and the freestyle raw milk aged cheeses I'm turning out. With only a wine fridge and a single cow in milk I have around 20kg of cheese aging on rotation at any given time. About half the joy of cheesemaking for me is the cattle. They are beautiful emotionally attached animals and my daily joy! Because I dont want to turn a delightful hobby into a stressful full-time job, I have no interest in increasing production towards a business model.

I just love to share my passion project cheese. Everyone who visits tastes and leaves with free wedges. So many ask very seriously if I'll sell to them because now they crave the silky REAL stuff after only ever tasting insipid rubbery supermarket cheeses before.

I would love to be able to sell a small amount at low prices to local acquaintances, just to contribute towards cost of my hobby. But I can't, not without risking my entire land value in fines and penalties. People don't understand that and pressure me saying they won't tell! Lol sure, but someone else might and it's a risk I can't take sorry.

I understand the chemistry and microbiology of raw milk cheese and the hygiene requirements, age for 3 months etc. Cheese was a staple preserved food long before modern knowledge of these things though.

I looked into all the regulations and compliance costs if I want to sell and it's simply not possible financially and practically for just a side hustle. The big dairy industry and their henchmen the "food safety" regulators will not tolerate anyone buying cheese that is not mass produced in a sterile environment. Yet people are regularly hospitalized from eating unregulated berries or lettuce 🙄 🤔

I dream of a lost world where people were actually allowed the freedom of choice to visit a small farm, inspect the husbandry and production methods, taste the product and decide for themselves if they'd like to buy it. Imagine that.

//Rant over.


r/cheesemaking • • Aug 09 '24

Recipe The creation of cheese

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/cheesemaking • • Jul 23 '25

When you have to use grocery store milk

2 Upvotes

This is not a new concept. But you can get curd similar to what one gets from vat pasteurized non homo or even raw milk by starting with pasteurized skim milk and adjusting to your desired butterfat levels with heavy cream. What’s relatively new is that we all now have Chat GPT to make the calculations. As a biochemist/microbiologist, I can do those calculations. But a lot of people may not know how and I am lazy. So I now have the bot do it. We just need to tell it what we want to do. I’m in USA where milk is sold in 1 US gallon (3785 mL) jugs. So I just tell the bot that I need 4 gallons of milk @ 3.5% butterfat and that final volume is not important. And that I have 0% skim milk and 35% (read the label) heavy cream to use to achieve this. And then it cranks out the arithmetic and you’re ready to go, in any units you want.

The reason this works is because in large scale milk processing in the US, the first thing that happens at the plant when the milk comes in is that all the cream is spun off, leaving skim (0%) milk. This is so they can re-create various final milk products of different butterfat levels before final pasteurization, homogenization and packaging. So while the skim milk is certainly pasteurized, there is no need to homogenize it as there is nothing to homogenize. And cream to be sold as cream isn’t either although it might be ultra pasteurized. But the key is that the skim milk, which comprises most all of your final cheesemilk, is not homogenized the way whole milk is. I find that this method gives me more moist cheeses because the curds are stronger and can be stirred to the proper texture without shattering so much and losing so much whey compared to when I use regular grocery store bulk quality pasteurized, homogenized whole milk.


r/cheesemaking • • Sep 17 '21

Experiment Yesterday I was making Mac cheese it didn’t go well but I was left with this in the pot and decided to put it in a container for the night seeing if I could make some cheese and today this is what I have I don’t know what it is but you guys help me

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/cheesemaking • • Aug 13 '22

Experiment Can you take store bought cheese and make parmesan with it?

0 Upvotes

Wondering if any of you wizards have brined/salt rubbed an otherwise mild and unsalty storebought cheese, and aged it to make good parmesan/pecorino type cheese?


r/cheesemaking • • Apr 24 '25

What is some software idea that you all think is lacking in the cheese making world?

1 Upvotes

I'm curious... what is some software, product, or some service that would be of help for people in the cheese making world? What is missing?


r/cheesemaking • • Oct 25 '24

Raw Milk Smoked Beer Cheddar

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/cheesemaking • • Sep 08 '24

Experiment Why is it difficult to make Cheese with lactose free milk?

1 Upvotes

I am Lactose intolerant and I have been craving for cheese but dont have enough options in the market. I tried making it with lactose free milk (without culture and Rennet). It was my first attempt and it turned out shit. I tried making it with normal milk and it wasnt so bad. I dont have understanding of making cheese and i want to understand what makes cheese making difficult with lactose free cheese. Also if I want to make cream cheese with culture will the flavour be better or will that depend on my process of making it.

I have a few questions.

  1. Is it better to use Lactose free milk from the market or should I make lactose free milk by adding lactase enzymes.

  2. should I use citric acid powder or vinegar or lime ( does that make a difference?). What happens if I add too much.

  3. Should I be using rennet and culture for this cream cheese? Will take bring flavour to my cheese and not just taste like solidfied milk.

  4. What is the best way to add flavour other than cultures. How does a company like Philadelphia cream cheese do it.


r/cheesemaking • • Apr 13 '26

Help what have I created? D:

Post image
0 Upvotes

First of all, I have no clue what I'm doing and the process I'm going to tell you about is most likely gonna cause you to cringe. I tried, I panicked and I have no idea what I made.

About 1-2 weeks ago I had a bunch of leftover cream and decided to try to make cream cheese. I did a bunch of research and since it takes way less cream than I thought I decided to go rogue. The process:
- Put 3dl cream and 3dl milk (1,5%) in a pot
- Forgot the thermometer and brought it to almost boiling
- Added 3 tbsp of lemon juice
- Let it sit for 15min
- Nothing happened. Start googling. Seems like it can be too little lemon
- Added more lemon. Nothing
- Seems like it could be too low heat. Heat it up again. Forgot the thermometer again
- Added more lemon
- Wait 10min. Nothing??!?
- Getting annoyed
- Dumped a bunch of butter milk in
- Heated it up again and, you guessed it, forgot the thermometer
- Nothing
- Gave up and left it out for a few hours
- Decided to put it in this jar and leave it on the counter

I am sorry to have offended the craft of cheesemaking

Yesterday I noticed that there is separation at the bottom. I am gonna assume that this won't be safe to consume at this point and I'm terrified of opening it. So did I actually make something or is this just trash?


r/cheesemaking • • Jul 12 '22

Advice how can I get a rind ay home

0 Upvotes

How can I get a rind at home without special environments and stuff ??


r/cheesemaking • • Sep 23 '16

Moldy Cheese Opinions Wanted. Please help

Thumbnail
goo.gl
0 Upvotes

r/cheesemaking • • Sep 02 '26

Recipe Every cheese recipe says use non-iodised salt and almost none of them explain why, so I went and found out

51 Upvotes

Best answer I found is that iodine is an antimicrobial. That's literally why it's in table salt in the first place, and it's what's in the stuff a surgeon paints on skin. Cheese is a controlled bacterial culture, so putting an antimicrobial in at the salting stage is working against your own starter. Makes sense.

Thing nobody seems to mention is anti caking agents. Sodium ferrocyanide and silicon dioxide don't really dissolve, so brine goes cloudy and you can end up with residue on a rind. Cosmetic more than anything but it looks off on a white mould.

Which I think means the actual requirement is just salt with nothing else in it.

Two things I'm unsure about. Does it actually matter on a hard cheese where the salting happens after the culture's done its work? And has anyone had a problem using damp sea salt for brine? I'm using celtic sea salt light grey and it's got a fair bit of water in it so I've started weighing rather than measuring, but I don't know how much I'm off by. It also leaves fine sediment in the brine which I assume is clay from the bed and I don't know if that's an issue or just untidy.


r/cheesemaking • • Jun 06 '25

Advice Did my milk turn itself into cheese?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I found my whole milk like this yesterday. The jug felt pressurized so I cracked the cap to relieve it. Something hissed out but I didn't notice any foul odor. The expiration date is today (June 6), but it was looking a little sketchy maybe three days ago. The temperature of my fridge is on the recommended setting. What in the world happened?


r/cheesemaking • • Sep 19 '24

How to make store bought Gouda not melt when frying it on a skillet?

2 Upvotes

How can I increase/decrease it's pH, to mimic haloumi cheese?

You may be wondering why I am asking this stupid question. But, Gouda is one of the cheapest cheeses I can find.


r/cheesemaking • • Aug 06 '25

Pasteurizing store-bought milk?

0 Upvotes

Are there downsides or risks to buying raw milk from the store and pasteurizing it at home for use in cheesemaking (or ice cream, drinking, etc, if you know)?

Assuming you use good technique, good tools, the right temperature and times.

For example, have you experienced any issues with raw milk bacteria that was killed by home pasteurizing, but lived long enough (thanks to the supply chain) to excrete byproducts/toxins?

I know that is an issue with meat that has been above the safe zone, you may kill all the bacteria with a good long cook at 165, but that doesn't mean you won't get sick.

I ask because of an allergy that means I can't eat almost any store-bought pasteurized milk or cream. There's just one producer locally that doesn't add anything to their pasteurized dairy, but it goes out of stock unpredictably. Raw milk, of course, doesn't have the additives I'm allergic to.

(My immune system and I are not interested in consuming raw milk or cheese made from raw milk.)

I searched for information on home pasteurization before asking but the advice, from university extension programs etc, is "home pasteurization works! here's how!" without discussing store-bought raw milk, presumably aimed at farmers.


r/cheesemaking • • Dec 11 '21

Raw milk cheese and babies and moms? Real answers only, please!

0 Upvotes

A friend recently asked if I made cheese with raw milk and then said that it was maybe not for breastfeeding mothers or babies. She is not a crazy person, btw- The raw milk is from a certified dairy in CA Edit- sorry, I meant to ask; is there anything there? I didn’t mean just to throw that out there


r/cheesemaking • • May 13 '24

Why is raw milk such a controversial thing?

30 Upvotes

Ever since ive started to dabble a little into making my own dairy products and such ive seen the subject of raw milk come up more and more obviously… and im the kind of person that goes ham into doing research on a topic. Like i go into mega nerd mode cuz i want to get all the angles and hear all the sides, especially if its something that could potentially be harmful if i get something wrong. But when i look at conversations of people discussing raw milk… those discussions get so unhinged and honestly im just aghast at that because wtf… its just milk guys, calm down? But people talk like you’re on about the rona back in 2020… its just gloves off… and on top of all that, apparently its considered a right wing extremist thing to even consider drinking it? So it just adds an extra layer of insults to the whole bag of anger that it already is. And i just honestly dont get it. I dont get why wanting to get away from industrialized farming and its products is bad or extremist… or being concerned with our food and wanting more nutrition from it or just wanting to even just try to live more traditionally is just so controversial and hated when only a decade or so ago being into things like raw milk and whole foods and making your own kambucha (which ive just recently heard apparently can make people sick too if done incorrectly) was all very crunchy leftist hippy dippy stuff before. Now its “trad” right wing, and “anti science” …wtf is this world man? Why cant we just all calm tf down, and talk to each other like we’re all just humans trying to figure this shit out?

Idk man sorry for the rant but this is just bothering me so much lately. Raw milk shouldnt be something that pisses anyone off. None of this should. Im probably not going to partake myself given i want to get pregnant again soon and its like, if I wouldnt eat sushi obviously probably not get into that whole thing too… but people drank raw milk for a very long time before Pasteur… so i dont get the ride or die about it like its not even remotely possible to find a way to safely produce it. I own my own chickens and ive never gotten sick from eating their eggs either. And ive even waterglassed them successfully… something people for some reason now believe is completely unsafe. How did people live before industrialization? Did they just not? Is that the answer? They just didnt and we dont actually exist and the universe is a hologram? Cuz that seems to be the only thing the internet is willing to believe anymore.


r/cheesemaking • • Dec 21 '24

Could you make weed-infused cheese?!

3 Upvotes

This would change Everything to the better


r/cheesemaking • • Feb 04 '24

What cheese is cheese dip?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve tried cheese wiz and cheese from a can. Nothing tastes like the cheese in these dips. What is it? How do you get just the cheese?


r/cheesemaking • • Jan 31 '25

Why is my homemade cream cheese drying out when i put it in the oven?

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone! first post in this sub. I made some cream cheese using just milk and lime and blended up the curds that formed.

I used this cheese as a filling for a bagel bomb(similar to a jalapeno pizza popper) and it pretty much dried out. When i use store bought cream cheese with the same recipe it seems to be almost liquidy and oozey, and nice.

Why is this happening?


r/cheesemaking • • Jun 18 '15

As a moderator of /r/CheeseWorld..

4 Upvotes

I would like to extend a warm welcoming hand from our lovely, cheese filled subreddit. May we all bask in the cheddar together.


r/cheesemaking • • Dec 10 '25

Could I make a cheese in my stomach if I consumed the proper ingrediants?

0 Upvotes

Can I make cheese in my stomach if I consumed the required amounts of milk and rennet? Accounting for acidity and such too.


r/cheesemaking • • Feb 22 '26

Bourbon flavoured Brie

Post image
5 Upvotes

Does anyone know of any brie style cheese that is infused with bourbon (kind of like a truffle brie)? The only thing I can find close is a baked brie with a bourbon sauce/bourbon caramel poured over the top. I’m looking for inspiration and suggestions on how to make a Brie with bourbon in the milk/curd. Would it work the same way as normal or would the alcohol affect the culture growth? Picture is just for reference.


r/cheesemaking • • Sep 23 '22

Can cheese be only rind?

1 Upvotes

I am currently having a debate and I thought to ask you guys,

"Can cheese be completely rind?"

I know rind is usually found on the outside of the cheese, but can a cheese be made of completely what the rind is?