r/cheesemaking • • Jan 01 '25

Troubleshooting My butterkase wheel was left unattended for 1.5 weeks for xmas break šŸ’€ Is there a way to salvage this?

Post image
11.1k Upvotes

The "troubleshooting" flair seems like an understatement


r/cheesemaking • • Jan 07 '25

I’m concerned about the lack of mold growth on this cheese

Thumbnail
gallery
7.5k Upvotes

I made this cheese November 24, so six weeks ago now. It has been in a constant 54F with 83% humidity cheese cave. I have two hygrometers and two thermometers in the cave and I feel pretty good about those numbers. I have just started moving away from vacuum packing and this is the first natural rind cheese in the cave. There are two now. My question is, shouldn’t there be more mold growth by now? Or is this looking good so far. I’ve made quite a bit of cheese successfully, but I don’t have much experience with natural rinds.


r/cheesemaking • • Jan 09 '25

3 month old natural rind low moisture Mozzarella made from water buffalo milk

Thumbnail
gallery
6.8k Upvotes

r/cheesemaking • • Jan 05 '25

I just opened my cheddar and this is inside.. thoughts?

Post image
5.9k Upvotes

Is this safe to eat?? I'm guessing not. Any guesses what this is or what happened?


r/cheesemaking • • Apr 01 '26 Obsessed Heartwarming

I opened the 10 YO Home Made Parmesan.

Thumbnail
gallery
4.5k Upvotes

I braced myself and opened the bag.

I had a sniff, and realized that I had, sadly, gone too far.

Rather than the fruity notes I had hoped for, I got "Toast" and "Caramel". First taste confirmed that the cheese had been slowly deteriorating in flavor since I had opened it's sister 4 years ago. As I lost fruity flavor, the upside was Umami had increased, and crystal formation was just ridiculous.

I don't think I have ever seen a cheese as packed with crystals. The Umami was so strong, it actually numbed my tongue.

All is not lost though. I can exploit the cheese as a cooking ingredient so I will grate it and freeze it for later use. I believe it will be the perfect addition to a Caesar salad sauce and the basis of amazing omelets.


r/cheesemaking • • Oct 28 '25

Stray dog broke into my garage and ate my gouda

Thumbnail
gallery
4.4k Upvotes

A stray dog broke into my garage and ate my gouda. It was only a week old.doesthis look normal? Isn't that a whole lot of holes (mechanical holes?)? I opened it up to check it since I had to throw it out anyway.


r/cheesemaking • • Jan 22 '25

Advice Forgot the calcium chloride and decided to see what would happen anyway. Shockingly it didn’t work

Thumbnail
gallery
3.5k Upvotes

Followed this recipe: https://cheesemaking.com/products/brie-cheese-making-recipe?srsltid=AfmBOopOx0J1JGkFexcG-bSXzS-NUKHSeAfHkYs5RoJeTqn0HZyOGB0o

But forgot to add the calcium chloride :( would this also explain the rind having an overly strong ammonia smell/taste or is there something else I have messed up there? Ended up cutting into it after 6 weeks

Going to try make a pasta sauce with the liquid cheese sauce I have instead 🤣


r/cheesemaking • • Jan 09 '25

Cheese gone bad - late blowing

Thumbnail
gallery
3.3k Upvotes

By popular demand: When would a professional cheese maker throw away a cheese?

Well, the above three wheels got thrown. They were not edible. The round holes are the same as in Emmentaler/Swiss Cheese. They are a fault, but the cheese is usually still usable for dishes with molten cheese, where the different taste does not really matter. Too warm aging spaces and not ideal hygiene (for example plastic spoons or thermometers) can cause this.

The cracks are most likely caused by clostridium b - which makes the cheese taste bitter and soap-like. These should absolutely be thrown. Some people heat it, but the risk is still there in my opinion. There are different causes, I found it to be caused most likely by bad water quality or cows who get to eat bad food - like moldy grass or hay.

I tend to not take pictures of bad cheese, so I only have these two causes for you, but if you have any questions, I will try to answer them :)

Also, show us your bad cheeses for troubleshooting!


r/cheesemaking • • Apr 20 '25

Her first cheese! She helped milk the cows and goats and then bossed me around in the kitchen. She did a good job stirring curds ā€œfor hours and hours!ā€

Post image
3.0k Upvotes

We followed the Ibores recipe on NEC, https://cheesemaking.com/products/ibores-cheese-making-recipe, very straightforward cheese to make! We did mix goat and cow milk for this one.


r/cheesemaking • • May 01 '25

(Failure) Thai chili infused honey and gochujang gouda. Just fed it to the trash bin.

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

I opened this at four weeks and it was not bad! Very immature, but the honey flavor was there and it was spicy in a pleasant way. The bean paste in the gochujang prevented knitting a bit but it was actually not as dry and acidic as it looks. I was encouraged! So I vacuum sealed it back up and into the cave it went. Fast forward to tonight. I opened it up and it smelled like alcohol. Very boozy. I could definitely smell the gochujang a bit, but, I could also smell a faint vomit like scent. I cut it open and it smelled worse. Tasted a bit and spit it directly out. Just awful. Something fermented in that cheese in a very off putting way. So into the bin it went. It was experimental and I had a good time with it! Always fun to make cheese! Even when it doesn’t turn out as I’d hoped it would. Anyway, gochujang and honey, don’t do it. šŸ˜‚


r/cheesemaking • • Jan 11 '25

Double-cream cheese

Thumbnail
gallery
2.8k Upvotes

My double-cream cheese ladies and gentlemen! I used the same triple cream recipe from cheesemaking but with less cream because I wanted more balance. Very tasty, nice texture. Super satisfied! I aged it for approximately 3-4 weeks


r/cheesemaking • • Jan 22 '26

Troubleshooting Failing upwards? I tried making mozzarella with a gallon of whole milk (regular pasteurized) and white vinegar and it came out a cream cheese style consistency. It’s still delicious and convenient for sandwiches, but what happened here?

2.0k Upvotes

r/cheesemaking • • Feb 01 '25

is this safe to eat

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

its a soft raw milk chevre style goats cheese, 6 days old and stored in a fridge but it is more watery than it should have been. covered it with a layer of food grade charcoal but got a white fuzzy mold. tastes pretty much the same


r/cheesemaking • • Feb 03 '26 Bravo

I finally did it! I aged a cheese that didn’t go off!

Thumbnail
gallery
1.5k Upvotes

Started this hobby a few years ago and made my cheese cave in 2024. Had consistent issues with affinage (textures and rind development were all ok for the ā€œoffā€ cheeses. I’m currently troubleshooting for pH at cheesemaking or humidity in the containers, as I didn’t monitor either of those until a few cheeses ago).

I’ve made about 10-12 wheels since 2024 for aging and FINALLY cut into a 12 month aged Gouda that just sings. I’m so happy!


r/cheesemaking • • Jan 12 '25

Got cocky after two successful batches of fresh cheese, and successfully made a squeaky halloumi!

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

Best Christmas present ever. Too exciting to wait to fry some before posting!


r/cheesemaking • • Jun 09 '25

I made cheese but it’s gross

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

This is a high butterfat cheese that I washed daily for about a week and a half in Imperial Hard Cider, then finished aging in the fridge for a month.Wild Penicillium grew on it after a while. It looks tasty but tastes fermented or rotten. Does anybody have any idea why this happened?


r/cheesemaking • • Oct 28 '20

I have been hard at work repairing the damage to my cheese supplies, the fridges are slowly refilling.

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/cheesemaking • • Mar 23 '25

This is the most delicious cheese I have ever made. A Tomme recipe gone wrong and I almost threw it out.

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

I made this two months ago and was following the NEC recipe. I was already forgoing the mycodore mold powder as I didn’t have any and they are sold out. As it came time to add the cultures I put in the MA4002 and then grabbed MM100 instead of LH100 and threw that in before I realized the mistake. So I tried skimming off a bit of the mesophilic menagerie, as best I could even see it, and added the LH100. It was raw milk and I also didn’t reduce the called for doses. Then the curds didn’t knit quite the way I wanted probably because the PH was too low thanks to the screw ups. Thank you very much u/mikekchar for helping me with the rind on this one! He suggested closing the gaps with a wet paintbrush, which actually worked! After I got the rind fixed I was just going to age it to work more on learning natural rinds then toss it after a couple of months. I got it out today and cut it open. Holy hell it’s SO good! Just an absolutely delicious cheese. Everyone I’ve had taste it so far is blown away. I’m stunned. And I can’t ever repeat it. Such an incredible happy accident! Don’t give up on wonky wheels! You just never know. Named it Frankencheese. Learned a ton from this one!


r/cheesemaking • • Apr 30 '26

somebody can explain lore of this photo

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/cheesemaking • • Dec 26 '20

Not at all experienced in cheese making, just wanted to share that I made my first wheel :)

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/cheesemaking • • Jan 16 '25

First Manchego

Thumbnail
gallery
1.3k Upvotes

My nieces creates a charcuterie board containing Manchego, which I wasn’t aware of. So I decided to make it. Can’t wait to try!


r/cheesemaking • • Jan 14 '25

White Cheddar

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

Hope folks aren’t getting tired of seeing my cheeses. This is a four month white cheddar. Texture and flavor are spot on and I’m pretty proud of this one. I’ll age half for another four months or so. But the other half is getting eaten and passed around to friends! Sharper than I was expecting, in a very good way!


r/cheesemaking • • Dec 28 '24 Take My Silver

Three weeks in the cave so far. Gave it a fresh coat of smoked paprika and olive oil.

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

Brushed off a very small amount of white mold and freshened up the rind. Pretty happy so far.


r/cheesemaking • • Apr 14 '21

My family has a small organic farm, where we make cheese. It was established in 1991 by my father, today our gouda is officially among the best our country has to offer. When we were visited by the agricultural attache of the Netherlands, after tasting the cheese he purchased multiple wheels.

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes