r/StructuralEngineering • • Apr 14 '24

Career/Education Advice for y'all youngsters: Don't study Structural Engineering

46 Upvotes

Its just not worth it , believe me. Even if you are interested in the subject/field you will regret it big time after some years when you notice most of ur friends in other fields have significantly higher pay with less stress. At that point its much much harder to change to something else.

I'm saying this because I wish someone had given me this advice when I was younger.

PS. I have 10 years of working experience in the field and I am highly respected at my company and even a known name in the field of structural engineering in my country.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 4d ago

Photograph/Video I am quitting this field !

0 Upvotes

As a structural engineer, if this is actually real and not some kind of joke, I'm seriously considering quitting my profession.

Jokes aside, this is genuinely alarming. Structural engineering is not something you can approach with guesswork, shortcuts, or a complete disregard for basic engineering principles. Every structural element has a purpose, and every design decision must be supported by proper calculations, engineering standards, and safety considerations.

If what we're seeing in this video is actually being implemented in a real structure, it could have extremely serious consequences. Depending on the structural configuration and the loads involved, this could compromise the building's structural integrity, potentially leading to severe damage, partial or even total structural failure, and, worst of all, loss of human lives.

Buildings are designed to protect people, not put them at risk. Structural safety is not optional, and engineering mistakes are not always visible until it's too late.

I really hope this is staged or taken out of context, because if it's not, this is beyond concerning.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 27 '25

Humor Welding-Free Connectors: The Smarter Way to Build Steel Structures

0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 10 '22

Photograph/Video Sand Storms Helped Build The Egyptian Pyramids: What do you think?

0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Feb 10 '25

Career/Education Structural Engineers for Tesla

0 Upvotes

I recently saw that Tesla is looking for structural engineers in US, especially in corpus christi in texas. Has anyone applied there yet or been offered a role? Could you share interview experience, salary expectations. If you are allready working there, what is the work environment like? Are these jobs only going to last few years or is there a career to be had there? Thanks.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Apr 19 '26

Structural Analysis/Design AI in work

2 Upvotes

Hi,

I am trying not to fall behind and use LLM more. What LLM are you using? Any tips how to use it? Like uploading regulations, using them as source, some magical prompts that help you check information, etc? I feel that I am using it only when I am lost, and can not find a solution, but I am not using it for every day tasks, which I know how to do, but with Ai help I would do them much faster.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 19 '24

Career/Education Is this an example of moment connection?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hi, we were discussing moment connections of steel in class earlier this week and when i saw this, i was curious if this is an example? In class, we only talked about beam-column connections and i was curious if it can be applied to others.

Steel plate was bolted to the concrete then hollow steel was welded on all sides to the plate. Will this actually resist moment?

Thank you!


r/StructuralEngineering • • Mar 13 '24

Structural Analysis/Design Can anyone help me with finding the reactions of this problem?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Mar 28 '24

Career/Education Where do best SE work? What is the FAANG of Structural Engineering

0 Upvotes

I was wondering what is the best career path for young, success-driven, skilled, and motivated Structural Engineers (like the top 1%), excluding administrative and management positions.

Where do the brightest, those with knowledge about design, analysis, FEM, computing, programming etc., go?

For software engineers it is (or was i dont know) FAANG or lets say some start up companies in silicon valley, but where do our guys go?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Jun 07 '26

Photograph/Video Innocent looking

0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 22 '22

Structural Analysis/Design I feel like I should know this, but someone be kind to explain why this wall is better than a straight wall at resisting wind?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Apr 04 '23

Career/Education Rant about base pay (salaried)

3 Upvotes

It doesn’t make sense to have such less base pay in this industry when a non PE kid does the same amount of work and produces the same construction documents. The base pay for a new structural engineer with a master degree should at least be $85k. Thoughts? It’s 2023, inflation etc and I feel like in a job with such liability, we deserve this pay.

With deadlines flaring up recently, I don’t see what a young engineer does less than an engineer with 5+ YOE. I don’t feel any different the day before and after getting my PE. Work quality AND QUANTITY as a EIT is uncompromised. I mean, young engineers might take a couple extra hours post work to figure something out, but employers don’t have to bother because they aren’t paying us overtime any way? We are giving you drawings before deadlines. We are given the same tasks as older engineers. Even older engineers work overtime a bit to get stuff done, but at least they have a better base pay than us.

Lol I hope all Gen Z leave this industry and make a revolution! I went to school with like 29 people, only 3 of us are still structural engineers and experiencing this financial abuse. Thanks for chasing us away! We chose this job because we like to do math and design. Didn’t expect our industry to be full of scared structural project managers with no backbone to say NO or ask for extensions to the architects


r/StructuralEngineering • • Jul 03 '22

Op Ed or Blog Post Change My Mind: Modern Bridges Are Overdesigned

0 Upvotes

I'm going to play a little devil's advocate today and am very interested to hear the community's thoughts. Disclaimer: I am a bridge engineer and this reflects my "shower thoughts" only...

Change my mind: modern bridges are overdesigned.

In the USA, the bridges designed and constructed today utilize a factor of safety / reliability that is too high. Why? I consider bridges to be a part of the greater transportation system. When I think about transportation safety, it's about getting safely from Point A to Point B, not just the 1000' when you cross the river. Looking at the transportation system as a whole, injuries and fatalities are almost entirely attributed to "off the bridge" incidents, while a relatively small amount are due to structural collapse of a bridge, culvert, wall, or tunnel.

In the US today, an average of 35,000 car-related fatalities occurs each year. This is a huge number, but it is actually down from the statistics of 50 years ago, when on several occasions the fatalities totaled above 50,000 in a given year. This is an encouraging improvement of safety when you consider the increase of population and vehicle miles traveled. I have not pinned down an exact number on bridge collapse fatalities, but I do not see any data that would indicate that the average fatality rate is greater than 10 deaths/year.

So why is so much of our focus on structural collapses, instead of the system as a whole? I am speaking to a group of engineers, who excel in making rational, data-based decisions about prudent and economical decisions for the benefit of the public. Should we not instead direct our resources to the elephant in the room, the 35,000 fatalities that are attributed every year to our roadways?

Here are a few rebuttals I have thought of:

  • Strong and reliable bridges play a huge role in the mindsets of Americans. If public confidence in our bridges were to falter, there could be significant unforeseen consequences. Driving 80mph on a busy freeway is a risk most Americans are willing to take, and take responsibility for. The structural adequacy of a bridge, however, is out of the public's hands. How would the public feel if there was an increased chance of structural failure on the bridges?

  • Overdesigned bridges could be more cost-effective solutions. Given the immense cost of the planning, engineering, mobilization, and construction of bridges, it is better to design and build a stout structure that will have a strong chance to live its 100 year design life. The actual material quantities from more stringent specifications and designs are minor relative to mobilization costs, delays to traffic during construction, etc. Not to mention the cost incurred when collapse happens - cleanup, lawsuits, long-term shut-down of a route, etc. I think the point on cost-effectiveness is especially true on long-span bridges. On more conventional, short span bridges, the argument may be made that there are areas where less stringent designs could be more economical.

  • Serviceability and maintenance issues - continuation of the point above, diminished design and construction requirements could be countered by increased cost in maintaining the bridge.

  • Who would sign up to design or build a bridge with a lower factor of safety?? I, as a bridge engineer, would be a little wary. I find our job to have ample stress already to protect the public's life safety when driving across our modern bridges.

Interested to know if anyone has any good data or research on this, or knows about the threshold of "reliability" that the AASHTO LRFD specifications are based upon. Before anyone balks at the suggestion of reducing design requirements, let me remind you that we have already drawn a line in the sand with our modern specifications. Those responsible for developing codes and specifications have found a certain threshold of risk vs economy that has been deemed satisfactory - bridges could certainly be designed to more extreme requirements than those of today, all but eliminating any chance of structural collapse.

Thoughts?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Jan 24 '24

Structural Analysis/Design What does this symbol mean?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Jan 10 '26

Structural Analysis/Design The Best Collection Of Civil Engineering Spreadsheets

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

In daily practice, I still find Excel spreadsheets very useful for preliminary design, verification, and quick checks in civil engineering projects—especially for reinforced concrete, geotechnical calculations, hydraulics, and construction planning.

I recently organized a structured collection of civil engineering spreadsheets covering topics such as:

  • reinforced concrete design checks

  • foundations and bearing capacity

  • box culverts and slabs

  • basic hydraulic and drainage calculations

  • construction and quantity-related tools

The goal was not to replace detailed software analysis, but to provide transparent calculation tools that help engineers understand assumptions, validate results, and perform fast engineering checks.

I’d genuinely like to hear from other engineers here:

  • Do you still rely on Excel spreadsheets in your professional work?

  • For which tasks do you find them most useful (preliminary design, verification, teaching, etc.)?

  • Are there specific spreadsheet-based calculations you think are still missing or poorly documented online?

For anyone interested in seeing how the spreadsheets are organized, here is the reference page I put together:
 The Best Collection of Civil Engineering Spreadsheets
https://www.theengineeringcommunity.org/the-best-collection-of-civil-engineering-spreadsheets/

I’d appreciate any feedback, criticism, or suggestions for improvement.
Thanks in advance for sharing your experience.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Mar 22 '24

Career/Education No PE exam license for Equity

0 Upvotes

Washington state IS EXPLORING alternative pathways to practice law instead of the current pathway: passing the bar exam.

LINK: https://komonews.com/news/local/washington-state-drops-bar-exam-requirement-to-reduce-barriers-and-inequities-seattle-tacoma-olympia-spokane-northwest-pacific-legal-court-justice-ruling-nextgen-anthony-varona-ube-uniform-bar-exam-national-conference-of-bar-examiners

Do you think the PE will no longer be a requirement in order to also “remove barriers and inequities”? Considering Asce is having elections and DEI is the main focus of one candidate I do not think we are far away.

MODS removed the previous post for misinformation. Although not op I have reposted with corrected information.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Aug 13 '26

Career/Education Firms Actually Fighting for Social and Environmental Justice?

10 Upvotes

For context I am a leftist who was drawn to this career to make the world better in a concrete (get it?) way. If you disagree with those views that’s cool, not here to fight.

I know everyone will have different opinions on the ethics of various project types, (and we can discuss the environmental impact of building with concrete at all, somewhere else), but in general I’m struggling with the lack of genuine commitment from companies to these ideals.

I’m tired of companies supposedly “building a better world” or being “committed to embodied carbon reduction” while churning out tons of data center projects or being unwilling to say they won’t work on detention facilities.

Anyone have experience at or know of firms genuinely trying to build a better world?

TLDR: Do you know any firms that actually refuse projects based on social and environmental justice concerns?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Dec 17 '24

Wood Design Why Wood is the Big Winner in Cement’s Global Upheaval

Thumbnail
woodcentral.com.au
4 Upvotes

The World Cement Association (WCA) has predicted that global demand for cement and clinker production will drop far more than expected, with the peak body for cement predicting that the use of global cement will drop by as much as 30% from 4.2 billion tonnes per year to three billion between now and 2050.

That is according to a new white paper, Long-Term Forecast for Cement and Clinker Demand, which predicts that demand for clinker, the main ingredient for Portland cement, will drop from 2.8 billion tonnes per year to less than 1.9 billion tonnes and perhaps as low as 1 billion tonnes in response to, amongst other things, growing demand for mass timber and geopolymers.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Feb 11 '25

Structural Analysis/Design How do You design this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, i need to make a structural design for a Masonry box using steel trusses.

But I don't know yet, if trusses shall be designed to resist seismic loads? Or should I consider gravitational and Wind loads combos only?

Thanks


r/StructuralEngineering • • Oct 24 '23

Career/Education Help me decide……

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I am a third year civil eng student hoping to pursue a specialization in structures and hope to work in bridges someday.

From your knowledge please guide me in choosing the courses (top 5) that would best suit my future career in bridges!


r/StructuralEngineering • • Jun 15 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Improper BBS in bridge slab before concreting in present of gov. engineer

0 Upvotes

Why bentup bar is not provided as per drawing


r/StructuralEngineering • • 28d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Modular math components in documents

0 Upvotes

Hi guys,

Kev @ Iron Atlas Pty Ltd here:

We are based in Brisbane, Australia, and have been working on a tool which directly addresses some workflow / calculation friction that we've experienced in engineering and science (specifically Structural Eng).

Having used many "calculation tools" in the industry (i.e. Excel, mathcad, etc) we came to realise the benefit of shared repositories and reusable modules for calculations that teams repeat and share. This coupled with solving capabilities, units, and AI tooling built-in (where you can edit / QA any outputs and collaborate / work with the models), we think we have landed on the current math sweet-spot.

Think specific "modules" for sections of the standards that you commonly reference in your calculation set. For us it has been things like plate bending modules, concrete bending estimators, Euler buckling modules, linear interpolation, specific sections of standards like AS4100, AS3600 etc. These are built by you/your team and are fast and seamless to insert anywhere in a document (with traceable history/error reporting/updates).

We are beginning Beta testing this week and are looking for 10 - 20 eng/scientists to try Modular MathDesk and help shape and red-team the product before it hits public release v1.0.0

The closed beta is free. We’re asking for activation and onboarding, at least two sessions totalling roughly two hours over your first two weeks, and short check-ins (via discord/email)

Complete that participation and receive 3 months of free v1.0.0 access after launch. At the team’s discretion, up to five testers may receive 1 year total instead, for useful contributions. No bug discovery, praise, public posting or message quota required.

Apply for beta by 26th October, 9:00AM Brisbane time (GMT+10), by heading to modularmathdesk dot com and we will shortlist testers with a good fit and begin onboarding.

If testing isn’t for you, you can join the launch list on the same page for release updates and introductory pricing when we launch officially soon.

Thanks and look forward to building something great
(watch the app in action)


r/StructuralEngineering • • May 09 '24

Structural Analysis/Design Hangers upside down?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Are these hangers upside down at this LVL / fascia board?

The joists are cantilevered out and the LVL is fastened to the ends using the hangers. Wouldn't it make more sense for them to be installed the top of the joists/trusses instead of from the bottom?