r/StructuralEngineering • u/SnooHedgehogs8530 • Oct 24 '23
Career/Education Help me decide……
Hi everyone!
I am a third year civil eng student hoping to pursue a specialization in structures and hope to work in bridges someday.
From your knowledge please guide me in choosing the courses (top 5) that would best suit my future career in bridges!
11
u/marcus333 PEng Oct 24 '23 edited Oct 24 '23
I'm a Waterloo (which are these courses) grad working as a building structural engineer now. I recommend steel, concrete, structural system (CIVE 415 - this course covers some bridge loading and design), rehab. I never took FEA and don't feel like I missed out. Dynamics is hard but gives a good understanding for earthquake loading. Either dynamics or FEA I'd say, don't take both. Bridges would probably benefit from FEA more. Wood is a good course as well, it's an arch course but on Waterloo campus. Wood is a highly used material, that you'll need if you do buildings/houses, not so much for bridges unless you get into timber bridges)
Construction is a waste of time, unless you just need a bird course and a credit. Avoid otherwise.
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 24 '23
Ah that’s cool! Thank you for your input. I have been contemplating bw FEA and Dynamics. I had a feeling dynamics might be more important, but this gives me different insight. Dynamics may be an advantage as many structural engineers don’t understand the dynamics of structures but I’ve also heard the extent of it in practice is limited to the location where you’re practicing as an engineer (i.e. high seismic areas).
I took timber design last term and I thoroughly enjoyed it! Really neat things you can do with wood.
I thought the construction course would probably benefit my peers who are looking into project management careers over structural design.
2
u/marcus333 PEng Oct 24 '23
Yea dynamics is really cool, but I particularly remember going through all the time history response and everything and the last lecture was on the National building code of Canada's (nbcc) method, and they just drew 4 straight lines over the time history response and said for 98% of Canada, that's what's done. Basically nullifying the entire course.
So while the course was really interesting, it wasn't very applicable.
Construction Eng, talks about how to do takeoffs and quantities, and determine how many trucks and ppl you need to do a job. For construction management roles, that would be helpful. For design, it's useless. The only helpful part of that course for designers was the section on concrete formwork design. But I don't think it's worth it take just for that, when the concrete formwork code gives you the forces, then it's just steel/wood design from there.
6
u/Either-Letter7071 Oct 24 '23
Structural Steel Design (Must)
Structural Concrete Design (Must)
Finite Element Analysis (very important as most structural modelling systems implement it)
Structural Dynamics (very good as graduate employers favour this)
Structural system design
Structural system design, I’m guessing, encompasses vertical/horizontal structural members and load transfer within a structure. it probably includes aspects of foundation design as well so I would choose this.
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 24 '23
Thank you!!
Here’s a little course description of structural system design fyi:
“Building loads. Lateral load systems. Floor systems for buildings. Composite construction. Introduction to bridge design.”
2
u/Either-Letter7071 Oct 24 '23
Yup, in that case structural system design is a Must.
I would even say it’s as/more important than steel and concrete design.
1
u/3771507 Oct 24 '23
I have met many engineers that had no training in wood construction and lateral resistance so that might be good.
1
1
3
u/DrIngSpaceCowboy Oct 24 '23
Choose courses you can only learn while in school and not on the job. You are paying to learn theory for the most part, you will have the rest of your career to get the practice right - and with good mentorship at any firm you will be helped with design. IMO
2
2
u/madgunner122 E.I.T. - Bridges Oct 24 '23
Personally, I would do 413, 414, 415, 422, and 512 as the top 5. Where I am at least, dynamics is not a high priority but rehabilitation is. You will want to take Finite Element Analysis, even if you don’t do well in that class, getting a good handle on what’s going on within the program will help when you start in the field. Some of the programs are a tad too black box and having an understanding of the basics will help there.
6
u/Engineer2727kk PE - Bridges Oct 24 '23
Structural dynamics is a must for bridge design. Stiffness is incredibly important.
1
u/madgunner122 E.I.T. - Bridges Oct 24 '23
Re-reading this and what winston-smith put regarding structural systems, I’m now leaning toward replacing that for structural dynamics. I do agree that it is important, but my experience with taking that class was less than adequate. Perhaps another professor and lecture material will result in a better experience than I had
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 24 '23
Hmm I see.
Here’s a little course description of structural systems fyi:
“Building loads. Lateral load systems. Floor systems for buildings. Composite construction. Introduction to bridge design.”
1
1
2
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 24 '23
Thank you for the advice! Ngl I have been quite intimidated by FEA so this motivates me.
2
u/mrjsmith82 P.E. Oct 24 '23
Bridge Design Structural Engineer here.
Order of importance:
414
413
415
422
512
596
505
460
315
1
2
2
u/ClearCalcs Oct 24 '23
Waterloo grad here as well, fun to see the courses haven't changed much :-) Great suggestions already posted in the comments. I'll suggest two courses that might not be as directly related to your bridge ambitions but I think you could find valuable, and as another poster said, you're less likely to have the chance to learn on-the-job.
Rehab course, when I took it, went over bridges as well. Some interesting insights into bridge asset management and assignments that made you think very differently than the typical design courses. If you'll be working in bridges, odds are you'll be looking at existing bridges and at least the basic knowledge of rehabilitation/evaluation will likely serve you well.
Another course I took was CIVE700 - Smart Structures. It was during my Masters but was also open to undergrad. That was a really fun course and definitely learned a lot about the tech side of structural engineering. It probably won't be as directly impactful in a typical engineering office, but for me it opened my eyes to the world of tech which ended up completely redirecting my career. And specifically with bridges there is an ongoing push for more monitoring and using tech to accelerate inspections so this might be an interesting aspect for you.
Hope this helps and good luck!
Laurent
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 25 '23
Woah ClearCals!
Thank you for your insight, it’s really great to hear from a UW grad.
This makes me furthermore interested in Rehab and I will be taking the course. Curious about the Smart Structures course, it sounds very up and coming. I can see how the industry could benefit majorly from technological advancements. I’ll definitely be remembering this piece of info - a tech meets structural engineering career didn’t cross my mind!
2
u/ANEPICLIE P. Eng. Oct 25 '23
The course codes look exactly like the University of Waterloo...
Insofar as my opinion and memory goes, on that assumption:
CIVE 422 is difficult but Dr. Gracie is a a very knowledgeable professor.
CIVE 413 is essential; Dr. Xu's notes are useful and he is knowledgeable. I have TA'd this course before.
CIVE 414 is essential; Dr. Polak is knowledgeable but be prepared to put in extra work to make coherent notes.
CIVE 505 is very useful, but also another difficult course for many. Recommend.
CIVE 415 is a broad array of structural design topics but focuses on the building code.
I took these 5 courses in my fourth year, and they would be my top 5. Although Dr. Walbridge, assuming he is teaching CIVE 512, is an excellent lecturer.
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 25 '23
You guessed correctly! Thank you for the response. I’m considering 512 even more because I love prof walbridge, he’s amazing.
I had a question about 422 — what FEA program does the class have students work on? ETABS? or ANSYS/ABAQUS?
Is the course mostly theory and math heavy than it is practical?
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 25 '23
Oh. Yeah that sounds pretty nullifying.
I am currently doing a PM internship and have learnt some things about concrete formwork design and what it requires on the job!
1
u/JerrGrylls P.E. Oct 24 '23
Steel, Concrete, and Construction Eng are probably the most useful, so I’d go with one of those. But I took two finite element analysis classes and they were a couple of my favorites…getting to learn what the programs are actually calculating was really interesting. Again, not as useful in real-world application as steel, concrete, or construction, but certainly not a waste either.
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 24 '23
Thanks! One of my profs did emphasis the ever-growing importance of engineers actually knowing what their softwares are spitting out.
1
u/mango-butt-fetish Oct 24 '23
Damn do they not offer sustainability engineering? That was a fun class.
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 25 '23
They do! Although it’s not required for the specialization, so I could take it if it interests me.
1
u/TapSmoke Oct 24 '23 edited Oct 24 '23
Everyone here got it covered already but I'm gonna add my 2 cents for some courses.
FEM: Personally, I think it is very interesting but don't expect to learn how to use FEM softwares like the ones you will use in the job from this class. Usually the content is very very theoretical and starts from the very fundamental building blocks for the method. There is a huge gap between what is usually within 1-2 semester FEM course and the implementation in real life. The knowledge from the class usually wouldn't help you much when you stuck modelling a bridge so to speak. Will be more useful if you go to academic path tho.
Nevertheless, those were just my heads up and I'm not trying to stop you from taking the class. Personally, I found it a really interesting and cool topic but I just dont like when people get the wrong idea what to expect.
Rehab: This one really depends on the content and the professor. It can end up being the worst course in your degree or the best one ever. I'd say dig deeper into the syllabus. It would be quite useful for bridges too. If you land in a big firm one day your firm will win a big project that not only consists of designs but also assessment of existing bridges. This will definitely come in handy. But this depends on where you live too.
Dynamics: You probably won't have much to do with dynamics in the entry level role, but if you want to continue as a designer you can't avoid this. I didn't take it so I had to learn on the fly. Not recommended but doable. I feel like the resources online are easier to find than other subjects.
Other courses that might be interesting (not sure if they are availble there): Earthquake design (that covers nonlinear behavior) and wind engineering would be useful but that depends on the area. The latter is kind of a requirement if you wanna do long-span bridges at some point (unless your firm hires an outsource). Geotech/foundation is also useful.
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 25 '23
Thank you very much! I appreciate your thorough response.
I am looking for practicality above most things when selecting my courses so this helps me visualize how useful FEA could be to me, as I’m not considering the academic path at all.
I’ve definitely settled on rehab, especially where I’m from there is a lot assessment and monitoring of existing bridges. And even a new international bridge project, the Gordie Howe Bridge :)
I took a geotech / foundation design course last term and it was most definitely helpful.
1
u/brokeCoder Oct 25 '23
Re FEA - ask around and find out what FEA program they'll be having you work on. If it's an industry standard tool like ETABS, go for the FEA course. But if it's something like ANSYS/ABAQUS - I'd recommend dropping it.
This will sound like a rant, but FEA courses for civil/structural engineers in unis - in my admittedly limited experience - don't give you practical insights on how to build FEA models properly. They'll bombard you with theory and math (99% of which you'll never use in your usual day - to - day) and call it a day. You're much better off learning FEA on the job.
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 25 '23
Thank you for the idea - I’ll definitely be messaging upper years who took FEA to see what they learnt in the class.
And yeah I’d like to avoid those theory heavy and abstract math classes, practicality is more important imo.
3
1
1
u/EngiNerdBrian P.E./S.E. - Bridges Oct 25 '23
In order of importance:
Steel - Concrete - Structural Systems
Finite Elements
Building Systems or Construction Engineering dealers choice
1
u/AlexRSasha Oct 24 '23 edited Oct 24 '23
Must take: structural steel, structural concrete
Finite elements: depends on your school. Where I went it was very theory heavy, with little practical application. I learned how to develop FEA software, rather than apply to real world problems.
Structural dynamics: would highly recommend if you plan to do design in earthquake regions, vibrating equipment, or high rise structures. Personally this was my favourite subject as it ties together a lot of engineering theory. It will be math heavy (I.e. calculus, differential equations).
Rehabilitation: useful background if you plan to work in infrastructure/public projects or historic buildings.
If you plan to work in bridges also look for a prestressed concrete course.
1
u/leadfoot9 P.E., as if that even means anything Oct 25 '23
Gotta love how that ABET-approved curriculum forces you to "choose" which fundamental topics you study vs. neglect in favor of studying Open Channel Flow and Landfill Engineering for Civil breadth.
If this isn't U.S., then I'm sorry that your academic accreditation body also makes you choose.
1
u/giant2179 P.E. Oct 26 '23
Steel, concrete, systems, Dynamics and rehab. A lot of people will recommend FEA, but it's the only course I took that I feel like I got nothing relevant towards my career. Plus it was real freaking hard.
0
u/Crayonalyst Oct 24 '23
REHAB.
Steel and concrete design can be learned on the job. FEA will be learned on the job. Structural dynamics is kind of niche.
0
Oct 24 '23
[deleted]
2
u/BigNYCguy P.E. Oct 24 '23
I don’t do bridges either but I found my bridge class helpful because it went into plate girders and other topics that I didn’t get in my core classes.
1
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 24 '23
There many more! However I must chose at least 5 of these for the specialization to meet requirements and currently I can only fit 5 in my schedule alongside my other classes.
0
Oct 24 '23
[deleted]
1
u/SnooHedgehogs8530 Oct 25 '23
Thank you for your suggestions. Definitely going for 413, 414, 415 and 512.
I didn’t think 596 would be a useful course to me but your insight makes me think otherwise. I’d like to think even If I don’t end up taking it, I’ll have some experience from two project management internships I have done.
41
u/Winston_Smith-1984 P.E./S.E. Oct 24 '23
Absolute 100% must take: structural steel and structural concrete design. Those are non-negotiable.
If you want to work in bridges, then you’d probably want to take both Finite Elements and Structural Dynamics.
There’s are a few classes that I don’t know what they mean (e.g., what’s meant by Structural System Design), so they could be great or useless, so the last one kind of depends.