I hope that when they win the lawsuit they add back all the features they had to remove, and release a special Pal to celebrate that is a "Pikaclone" that is only useful as a workslave
Passive skill makes it work faster the longer you keep it at a single monotonous task. Call it something like "Repetitive iteration". Give it only level 1 handiwork, but the skill scales it up over time to be actually good.
Would actually be useful and funny. Also, I dont think there's a pal with that skill yet.
Sadly the "creature gliding" patent is still active, so we're not getting that back most likely. All stuff related to "catching creatures in spheres" is game, though, as far as I know.
You know what, fair. I think we're all just angry at Game Freak for being a bunch of dipshits and we wanna be petty. I really hope Palworld gets a lot of success in the future and becomes a genuine bit of competition for Pokemon. And I say this as a Pokemon fan because it's getting too big for its britches and I hope to see it improve.
They basically have. Nintendo dont have any patents to use at this point in their current lawsuit. So it'll probably default and hopefully Nintendo is forced to pay pocket pairs lawyers
I hope so too, the mechanics that they are arguing about are not only stupid to claim, but if they win, its sets a precedent that gets other companies involved. Nintendo is big, but getting into a fight with that many other game companies is bad for everyone.
jingglyfluff (dark/electric) work suitability: generates electricity
at a distance it is often mistaken for lamball until get a closer look and notice it is shockingly different. a tiny creature inside a sizeable ball of fluff that roots itself in place to try and prevent being blown away. prone to shocking itself as any mild breeze causes the fluff to rub itself the wrong way. enjoys singing its own praises on nights when nothing is happening.
partner skill: monotone when in base, increase sanity restoration of sleeping pals.
It’s insane with the amount of money that company has they literally can’t just make a good game. They’d rather spend it suing the shit out of everyone who does what they ought to be doing.
Was it all of them? Where's the original article? I'd love to read it if true.
I'm worried because a similar case because a scumbag blogger celebrated early for his win in our country but got jailed because only one of the cases was dismissed. The guy deserved it. But the lesson that can be learned on this is not to celebrate early and let your guard down.
Also, I'm worried about their rabid fans in Japan may take matters in their own hands.
It's a patent Nintendo filed after the lawsuit began that was given a non-final rejection, which means it can still be used in court and, if it is given a final rejection, doesn't actually impact the trial at all.
I don't think links are allowed (I've tried twice and neither comment is showing up). The article is on Gamesfray, and is pertaining to a patent Nintendo filed after the lawsuit began but isn't directly used in the lawsuit. It was given a non-final rejection, can still be used in court unless it's given a final rejection, and ultimately it being rejected has no bearing on the lawsuit as a whole.
If it is fully rejected, then it can call into question the validity of the parent patents Nintendo is suing over, but the rejection as it currently stands does not mean much.
Tl;Dr It throws doubt into whether the patents they're suing over are even justified because the similar mechanics have been used in prior games. If the other three patents are rejected the case can be entirely thrown out.
Galeclaw and all "glider" Pals were patched to no longer be "rideable" when the lawsuit started, instead they now just recolour your glider and buff it.
Tossing the palspheres over the walls of forts so my Relaxaurus could clear it out while I fought my way around was one of the coolest things thematically, and I really hope it gets to come back!
Don't really miss that but getting carried by Galeclaw will always be in my hearth I still can't believe Nintendo really got away with that lawsuit. I can't even remember this beeing a thing in pokémon at all xD
You can throw spheres to catch Pals, but your own Pals just spawn beside you. Before the changes, you would throw your own spheres out to summon your Pals wherever you aim.
I can imagine the judge just facepalming whilst shaking their head.. then saying "You know how dumb this sounds right??, so many other games use the summon mechanic you're trying to claim on... you didn't invent this!"
I know it's not pronounced as such, but every time I see this "Yare yare daze" phrase quoted from JoJo I imagine it's a piratey "Yarrr yarrrrr, dayzzz!"
Like they could lease them out if they wanted. Plenty of developers would shill out some dollars for it. Better than letting it sit there doing nothing for anyone
Personally I've still got the hump over Ōkami being forced to ditch its loading screen minigames in I think every single release except the OG PS2 version because it was patented, that sucked.
It's just insane how low the barrier is for 'inventing' mechanics that are basically extremely generic.
It's not at all about creativity or investing in ideas, but purely who manages to register it first. Hence why companies are just throwing every single concept in bulk at these patent offices to see what sticks.
What I think of every time I hear "Keep on keeping on!":
You can place holographic signs that show up in other people's games. People spam them at the Distribution Centers because all the players will run across them, as opposed to if you placed them somewhere random in the wild. Half of the signs that get placed will play a "Keep on keeping on!" recording as you walk through them.
It's kind of annoying, and became a joke within the subreddit.
I would not say lack but more like they don't care and know that the consumers will still buy the same product over and over again so no need to higher anyone to get more ideas out and pay more to make stuff.
Guys guys. There is something fishy happenning with the comment section.
Some comments seem to be auto deleted, this include some of mines (but not all), and if I go in anonymous browsing I see some other comments labelled as deleted too. And the count between the number of comments and the number display is way off, way too much to just be 1-2 guys who decided to dleetehteir comments by themselfs.
Op said he gave the link in a comment... I guess this one was deleted.
They haven't technically lost, it's a non-final rejection.
It's still a good sign, but it's not a full on win for PocketPair.
That said, if you actually read the article, it states that this patent being rejected (Non-final or otherwise) won't actually mean anything for the lawsuit, because it's a pending patent and not one of the ones Nintendo is suing for.
For information if I understood correctly : The patent wich was rejected is 2024-031879 , because a reminder nintendo didn't sued with one but multiple patents.
So what this one do ? It's the pokeball patent !
(ironic it's the first one to crumble considering it's the one who sound the most """legitimate""" as a core element of pokemon)
Lol of course Japan refuses it! How many Japanese games have you summoning characters to fight on your behalf... final fantasy... there is like 4000000 titles alone in the final fantasy franchise. Idiots.
The "lacking originality" ruling is just too perfect. Fingers crossed this legal win means we get all those cut features back. A new workslave Pal as a victory celebration would be the ultimate power move.
I think its too early to celebrate given how relentless and greedy nintendo is. But Im having trouble containing my excitement lol. I wonder if this means we'll get the ball throwing to release pals back? I remember they removed that preemptively and not because nintendo ordered them to.
It's a major step in the right direction. Pokémon hasn't had that much a leg to stand on and I'm thankfully not blind, which makes it easy to see. Inspiration and copying are two very different things. And considering its former devs they're bashing.. I want Palworld to win this whole thing. It will give that gaming industry the spirit they need to see that will allow them to make products outside of the team they originally worked for without problem.
Nintendo honestly need to just grow up and make their own damn awesome pokemon universe MMORPG survival open world builder etc blah blah have every available region etc and it could be huge
Everything we do is just grabbing elements from the world around us. It’s all just copy pasting various elements together bit by bit until it looks slightly different and claiming originality and creativity when that doesn’t exist. Like this opinion. I copied this opinion from UG Krishnamurti.
Man, when I was growing up Nintendo was a shining king of video games.
Now they're just an overly litigious group of ass clowns that need lawsuits to make up for the fact that most of their games are either mediocre or just the same, though successful game concept milked dry (Mario Party, Smash Bros etc)
I'd love to take a "I no longer support Nintendo products because I disagree with the company!" stance but honestly, I don't support Nintendo because, while I lack respect for the company, I'm just not interested in their low effort bullshit anymore.
Indi developers still put passion into their games and that's what most of us are here for. I hope that Pocket Pair wins more and more against Nintendo. Maybe it'll make Nintendo rehhink their tactics but I doubt it.
This is amazing news! I'm the same as alot of the other guys who have already said about stuff getting patched back in. I hope it can and will be, I never got the chance to do the whole gliding about shooting using Galeclaw. I was so confused when I kept popping out a glider instead of the Pal and thought I had done something wrong or missed a step I even tried not having a glider equipped and had Galeclaw out as my pal till I went googleing.
Is there a catch? Sorry to be a pessimist but every time I see one of these articles it’s always a 1 step forward 2 steps back kinda thing for this case…
Yesh! It is a good news for gaming industry as a whole! Pkm fans should also be glad because Nintendo can focus more on their games (I'm talking about YOU Legend ZA)
The new battle mechanics I’ve seen in the little bits of media in the new Pokemon game look awfully sus and copied from palworld. Would hate to see someone patient that then sue Nintendo.
I will give Nintendo credit though, they done an awesome job making the latest pokemon game in the same software that Roblox games are made in.
From what I can gather Nintendo only lost the crazy claim that game mods can't be considered as prior art. That by itself is huge, but it only supports Pocketpair's case and the lawsuit continues on.
This is actually pretty big considering it's in Japan, where Nintendo typically wins anything they throw themselves at without issue. The fact that this whole thing is still (openly) going nowhere beyond Pocket Pair changing a few mechanics to err on the side of caution is pretty telling.
The only reason they get away with it is their 'for kids' image. Which goes a long way to forgiving them of their transgressions but they are one of the worst companies for abusing the courts.
next up is justice for shironeko project. Nintendo sued this game back in the days for 5 patent infringement i recall, being stuff like touchscreen wasd movement on mobile game, see through player character idea when player is behind wall or buildings and such. Nintendo is practically reason why JRPG can't make progress.
The picture is mentioning something from this article on the subject. A more accurate summary would be "this doesn't have any impact on the case; but speculation says maybe it actually could, maybe."
Nintendo is literally incapable of making anything that isn't factually trash. My switch doesn't charge anymore unless the tv is on the same HDMI channel as the switch. So when my niece wants to get destroyed in mario kart, its dead even though its plugged in 24/7. Same for the joy cons. But I was smart and bought a separate joy con charger from a different company because nintendo can't make something that's not trash. Well nintendo's trash making capabilities are so strong that my fully charged spare joy cons are rendered obsolete because I need to charge the dead joy cons (that shouldn't be dead because they're charging 24/7) so I can unpair them and hook up the fully charged joy cons.
Of course this all started when they announced the switch 2 because nintendo can only make trash and they wanted to trick people into upgrading to the new trash.
This is excellent! I just started playing this game and I can’t believe how much better it is than pretty much any Pokemon game I’ve ever played (maybe not the newest Pokemon snap but that’s a different kind of game anyway) and I used to love Pokemon.
Nintendo is literally trying to do everything they can to squash Palworld except try to make a better game 😂 Nintendo really did lose its soul when Satoru died, it’s so disappointing
1.7k
u/lezard2191 Oct 29 '25
I hope that when they win the lawsuit they add back all the features they had to remove, and release a special Pal to celebrate that is a "Pikaclone" that is only useful as a workslave