r/Palworld • • Oct 29 '25

Discussion Progress!

Post image
15.3k Upvotes

426 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

522

u/SS4Leonjr Oct 29 '25

I can imagine the judge just facepalming whilst shaking their head.. then saying "You know how dumb this sounds right??, so many other games use the summon mechanic you're trying to claim on... you didn't invent this!"

263

u/ztomiczombie Oct 29 '25

It's not just the number of games with a summoning mechanic its that games had it long before Pokémon.

99

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '25

Summon a skeleton, thats a paddeling

37

u/Particular_Cow1304 Oct 30 '25

Smite said skeleton with divine light, that’s a paladin

7

u/AlphaBearMode Oct 30 '25

Underrated 🥇

2

u/Pokemon-Master-RED Oct 31 '25

This gave me a laugh I genuinely needed today. Thank you.

1

u/SS4Leonjr Oct 29 '25

That's why I said the bit of "you didn't invent this!"

Because there's quite a few games that came before Pokémon that had the "Summon a creature to battle for you" that Nintendo was trying to patent..

41

u/Alex_Duos Oct 30 '25

The judge:

14

u/JockstrapCummies Oct 30 '25

I know it's not pronounced as such, but every time I see this "Yare yare daze" phrase quoted from JoJo I imagine it's a piratey "Yarrr yarrrrr, dayzzz!"

3

u/helpfulDeathgod Lucky Pal Nov 01 '25

Apparently it's because a "third-party" presented evidence that it was already done before. Including... by Pokemon GO.

1

u/5Hjsdnujhdfu8nubi Oct 29 '25

the judge

The judge hasn't made any verdict, this is a patent authority. This isn't even a complete dismissal, they're allowed to appeal or reason why it's still fine.

1

u/Perfecto_Desconocido Oct 29 '25

It's like the judge telling Nintendo, "You have no power here!"

1

u/Dazza477 Oct 30 '25

Surely they're now investigating how the patent was ever approved in the first place

1

u/UnknownFoxAlpha Oct 30 '25

If they had jumped on it like 30 some years ago then maybe but now? Not a shot and I love it.

1

u/SS4Leonjr Oct 31 '25

Thing is Square Enix first had summoning in FF V with the summoner class.. then VI had the summons you could do via the Magicite and the Espers.., then VII came along with the summon materias... so if Square wanted to they could sue Nintendo for trying to patent "summoning a creature to battle for you"