r/Palworld • • Oct 29 '25

Discussion Progress!

Post image
15.3k Upvotes

426 comments sorted by

View all comments

39

u/Invisible_Target Oct 29 '25

You couldn’t have linked the actual article?

23

u/RampageTaco Oct 29 '25

Or even the website this was from.

20

u/kogasabu Oct 29 '25

This is the article.

It's... Not as good as the clickbait has you believe. It's a non-final rejection on a patent that isn't even part of the lawsuit.

5

u/xxxxMugxxxx Oct 29 '25

https://www.windowscentral.com/gaming/nintendos-palworld-case-japan-patent-office-rejects-claim-not-original-enough

Here ya go.

Tl;Dr It throws doubt into whether the patents they're suing over are even justified because the similar mechanics have been used in prior games. If the other three patents are rejected the case can be entirely thrown out.

1

u/gunick06 Oct 29 '25

It’s not a patent, it’s an application. It’s not part of the lawsuit and has no legal effect on the litigation. Applications are normally rejected a few times before they grant as patents.

1

u/sphinxorosi Oct 29 '25 edited Oct 29 '25

This is the only one I see from Google but I’m not sure if the site is trustworthy

Edit: Seems as this site has been tracking the lawsuit for some time.

https://gamesfray.com/japan-patent-office-rejects-nintendo-application-relevant-to-palworld-dispute-cites-games-like-ark-as-prior-art-after-third-party-submission/

1

u/No_Rich_5111 Oct 29 '25

Not sure if the quote on post is directly from this, but the link of the related article is here. Same article used on other post from r/games.

https://gamesfray.com/japan-patent-office-rejects-nintendo-application-relevant-to-palworld-dispute-cites-games-like-ark-as-prior-art-after-third-party-submission/

-51

u/Low-Window7968 Oct 29 '25

I did in the comments.

31

u/ballom29 Oct 29 '25 edited Oct 29 '25

No you didn't.

Are you sure you didn't forgot to actually publish the comment?

edit : I think Op comment was auto deleted, there are a big chunck of comments auto deleted there.

3

u/Low-Window7968 Oct 29 '25

The moderator may have taken it down because it has pals competitions name in it. I'll try again though, sorry about that!

https://www.windowscentral.com/gaming/nintendos-palworld-case-japan-patent-office-rejects-claim-not-original-enough

2

u/ballom29 Oct 29 '25

First, yeap I see this one.

second : ohhhh I forgot about that, I did find it previously odd because i've seen some name clearly written in other posts.
For my own comment the one trigger word could be the balls that start with a P

edit : apprently the mess was cleared, I see many other comments now.

3

u/Vinyl_DjPon3 Oct 29 '25

Is this a subreddit that doesn't allow links to news sites in the comments? Because that is infuriatingly common tbh.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/MikeAndros0 Oct 29 '25

Umm, hate to break it to ya. But, I don't see it.

6

u/Nr1231 Oct 29 '25

Could you try again or link it here because I can’t see it.

9

u/dragon_bacon Oct 29 '25

There's no link in the comments.

1

u/Savira88 Oct 29 '25

Sorry bud, but I can only find 3 comments from you in this post, "that's why they're mad", "same!" and "I did in the comments."

Maybe reddit got hungry and ate it, maybe you forgot to actually send it, who knows...

2

u/ballom29 Oct 29 '25

I'll say reddit is very hungry, there are many comments, including some of mines, wich are either not showing up or marked as deleted

→ More replies (2)