r/Palworld • • Oct 29 '25

Discussion Progress!

Post image
15.3k Upvotes

426 comments sorted by

View all comments

33

u/Neither_Willingness3 Oct 29 '25

I just watched FritangaPlays youtube video about this. Beyond hilarious they lost this in their home land.

16

u/kogasabu Oct 29 '25

They haven't technically lost, it's a non-final rejection.

It's still a good sign, but it's not a full on win for PocketPair.

That said, if you actually read the article, it states that this patent being rejected (Non-final or otherwise) won't actually mean anything for the lawsuit, because it's a pending patent and not one of the ones Nintendo is suing for.

5

u/Neither_Willingness3 Oct 29 '25

Very true. Still an embarrassing moment publicly for them imho. I hope pocketpair sees the support from us on the sidelines and keeps on keeping on.

1

u/kogasabu Oct 29 '25

Eh, it's not really that embarrassing for them. You're kinda overstating how much this patent getting a non-final rejection means, especially because the judge presiding over the case can still use it against PocketPair if they so desire.

1

u/Ipokeyoumuch Oct 29 '25

Eh not really? Non-final rejections are uncommon but they happen during the patent prosecution process. Nintendo has an opportunity to argue and present why the patent examiner is incorrect in their analysis, fight against the prior art, or amend the patent to fit the needs of the patent examiner. It also does mean it can be evidence during litigation but it isn't the end all as there are non-final rejections that ultimately have the one with he non-final rejections win (though rare). 

1

u/connectplum_ Oct 30 '25

No, it's not. It's a totally normal process in patent where you apply and reaply them until it's accepted lmao this is what we get for folks talking about what they dont know about

1

u/connectplum_ Oct 30 '25

Imagine actually watching fritanga who makes videos based in misinformation including on the video you're talking about. Nintendo didn't lose anything, the lawsuit still is going on and the only thing that happened is regarding a patent filled post lawsuit that was denied and nintendo still can reaply and if denied again, to appeal.