r/Exmo_Spirituality • u/hyrle • Oct 07 '16
i am "church broken"
TL-DR: I'm church broken because I can't trust other people. But I am trying, because we can't fix all that is broken alone.
I've been thinking about the words "church broke" ever since I heard the phrase being discussed as a result of the leaked video with Gordon Smith. Clearly, being part of the ex-Mormon community, I would dare say that most of us - regardless of whether or not we have returned to church practice - are anything but "church broke". As I thought about myself, I thought the better words for me would be "church broken".
Growing up as a child, I was always the child that craved the praise of adults. I did well in school because when I scored well, I was praised. I was devoted to church and everyone at church was always praising me on how spiritual and how strong my testimony was. I was addicted to this praise and continuously sought it when I was young, eventually going on a mission, going to BYU and getting married in the temple, all because that's the ideal that was set before me. But at home - well, there was frequent abuse by my father, and enabling of that by my mother. Life at home was anything but the perfect LDS paradise. We'd have to put on the face of perfection once we got to church - looking like that happy family, knowing that if we didn't, we were in for one hell of a day after church. I got many a Sabbath day whoopin' for not acting perfect at church.
But getting married in the temple was what ended up "church breaking" me. See, I married a woman who was a lot like my mother. Very emotional - mostly sad - and devoted to essentially constantly sabatoging any happiness in our household. First and foremost her own, but also mine. I'm a hard person to keep down, though. So here I was, outside of the insular world of the happy YSA wards (which - let's face it - are mostly a social club and not really "church" per se) - and faced with the prospect of living in a Utah family ward. For the first time, I was in a position where I no longer had too many people whose praise I was seeking. Now, I was in a position where I was guiding myself.
It wasn't long after that time where I realized that "enduring to the end" was going to mean enduring an endless stream of stuff that I didn't like. I began to notice all the "isms" we complain about existing in the church. I started noticing how social pecking orders existed. I noticed how the biblical scholar Sunday School teacher - one of the most amazing religion teachers I ever encountered - was bashed behind her back despite being the more knowledgeable person about the Bible that I had ever encountered. I noticed how the poor, the awkward and the introverted were cast aside. As a poor barely-post-college student and introvert myself, I noticed how I was often excluded from social situations, along with my ex-wife.
I began to form doubts. I began to see what I now realize is the tribalism, and I couldn't reconcile that with the first commandment. At the same time, socializing on the internet had opened me up to a whole host of new tribes, and I began to learn that there was not only great people in them, but great truths - truths I wasn't being taught in church. I began to question, began to doubt, and began to be frustrated with LDS culture. I slipped in and out of activity for years. This excluded me even more. I was not "church broke". I was "church broken".
My ex-wife had started down the path of faith transition with me, but she didn't stay on it. She returned to the church, and even though it was clear to me that it was one of the many things contributing to the depression in her life. We eventually suffered through a transformational event - the death of our only child - and my relationship with her fell apart only six months after that. Without our son and without the church, we had nothing holding us together. We were worlds apart as people.
I eventually began life anew. I dove into studying subjects like emotional intelligence and coping skills. I studied other philosophies and religious tenents. I studied atheism, various form of theism and eventually decided that there was beauty in many of these explanations but none of them really truly fully encompassed everything I beleived. I became a universalist - though I wouldn't discover the word for it for several years, when in 2009 I decided to attend the Unitarian Universalist church (as it was near Christmas time and it felt right to be "religious again".)
I liked what I saw with the UU church. Logically, I liked their philosophy, but I didn't trust the preacher and people kept telling me that I should go out for choir and for singles activities, and to come back. I felt smothered. I didn't want smothering. The Mormons smothered me. I didn't like that. I didn't want to be welcomed. I wanted to be left alone, to decide whether I liked this or not. I eventually decided UU stuff wasn't for me. I once again went unchurched, but I adopted the label "universalist" because it was the first thing besides "agnostic" that I found that felt like it fit what I believed.
I eventually found another woman - a women who was Mormon, but still attended most of the time. She wasn't orthodox, but she wasn't questioning either. We dated. She broke a few rules with me, but never really wanted to go too "un-Mormon"I figured that she probably liked me but would eventually get tired of my non-Mormonism and leave me. Six months passed. She hadn't left me. She didn't even seem to be questioning us. I decided that this relationship was serious, and we began exploring it more deeply. We married three and a half years after we started dating, outside the temple ofc, in a beautiful secular ceremony performed by an LDS bishop who refrained from saying anything that made me want to punch him in the face. (He was told not to mention temples, but that the concept of eternal families was fine.) I had finally found what didn't feel like a broken relationship. I finally felt less broken. Still broken. But less.
Fast-forward to 2015. I'm still a secular agnostic universalist. I don't like the LDS church but I don't hate it either. I know it's not for me, but it didn't seem to be doing anything bad for our family. Being a former BYU student, I still like BYU. I bonded with my wife and her family over BYU football. Then the Madi Barney story broke. I felt clearly morally outraged. I sought others and found only those on the ex-Mormon side and maybe a few Progressive Mormons seemed to care. I was pissed. No longer could I like BYU. I was not only church broken now, but BYU broken too.
I became more heavily involved with the exmo community, moving from NOM to Reddit. I had gone from "ex-Mormon lite" to mainlining it. I could never bring myself to go full evangelical atheist, but I understood their outrage. They are "church broken" too after all. I finally let myself be angry at Mormonism - something I had never allowed earlier in my "slow fade". The relationship with my wife became strained. She loved her church and I clearly hated it. She took it personally, and I didn't want her to. I had to let go of the anger and the negativity, but found it very difficult to do so.
But I wanted to help and wanted to help people heal. I couldn't do that by simply raging against the machine. I began to study spiritual abuse. I began to study information about groups and individuals who healed it. Some were evangelical atheists, some we "spiritual". I found myself gravitating to the spiritual side. I began to learn more about mindfulness and meditation. I tried it, and felt a lot of the anger subside. I still felt hurt and pain, but I now felt like I had tools to address it.
I continued to learn more about mindfulness and meditation. I could never do it for all that long by myself. I began to study about other religions, leaning towards Buddhism but not really grasping or feeling connected with the theology. I took a quiz at BeliefNet, thinking maybe I was supposed to try UU again. Nope. It tells me that Liberal Quakers had what I want. Quakers? WTF? Buckled hats? I literally knew nothing about them.
So, lacking wisdom, I asked Google. The more I learned, the more I liked. 15 minutes drive away? I could give it a try. And so I did. I found a community I liked. I loved the meditation. I loved their approach. But I didn't trust them. I still don't. I see the imperfections. I see the people who claim to practice the values but then say something that's against them. I begin to feel like this is Mormonism all over again - but without the need to play follow the leader.
But they still let me be my own authority. I don't have to agree with that which I don't like. I don't have to accept other people's hypocracy as my own - I can choose my own way to "Quaker". I am still "church broken", but I am in charge of me. So I will continue to church for now, because I've found many people who I do love and feel a connection with there, even amongst those who I do not. I am broken, but I can still church. My way. Broken as it might be. Because I can only do good in the world if I don't stay on my island. I can only make it a better place if I am with other people. No longer will I stand alone in trying to fix what's broken. I will be with others to share my stories, my wisdom and my experiences - and to hear of theirs as well. Together, maybe we can all make things a little less broken.