r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Oct 07 '16

i am "church broken"

23 Upvotes

TL-DR: I'm church broken because I can't trust other people. But I am trying, because we can't fix all that is broken alone.

I've been thinking about the words "church broke" ever since I heard the phrase being discussed as a result of the leaked video with Gordon Smith. Clearly, being part of the ex-Mormon community, I would dare say that most of us - regardless of whether or not we have returned to church practice - are anything but "church broke". As I thought about myself, I thought the better words for me would be "church broken".

Growing up as a child, I was always the child that craved the praise of adults. I did well in school because when I scored well, I was praised. I was devoted to church and everyone at church was always praising me on how spiritual and how strong my testimony was. I was addicted to this praise and continuously sought it when I was young, eventually going on a mission, going to BYU and getting married in the temple, all because that's the ideal that was set before me. But at home - well, there was frequent abuse by my father, and enabling of that by my mother. Life at home was anything but the perfect LDS paradise. We'd have to put on the face of perfection once we got to church - looking like that happy family, knowing that if we didn't, we were in for one hell of a day after church. I got many a Sabbath day whoopin' for not acting perfect at church.

But getting married in the temple was what ended up "church breaking" me. See, I married a woman who was a lot like my mother. Very emotional - mostly sad - and devoted to essentially constantly sabatoging any happiness in our household. First and foremost her own, but also mine. I'm a hard person to keep down, though. So here I was, outside of the insular world of the happy YSA wards (which - let's face it - are mostly a social club and not really "church" per se) - and faced with the prospect of living in a Utah family ward. For the first time, I was in a position where I no longer had too many people whose praise I was seeking. Now, I was in a position where I was guiding myself.

It wasn't long after that time where I realized that "enduring to the end" was going to mean enduring an endless stream of stuff that I didn't like. I began to notice all the "isms" we complain about existing in the church. I started noticing how social pecking orders existed. I noticed how the biblical scholar Sunday School teacher - one of the most amazing religion teachers I ever encountered - was bashed behind her back despite being the more knowledgeable person about the Bible that I had ever encountered. I noticed how the poor, the awkward and the introverted were cast aside. As a poor barely-post-college student and introvert myself, I noticed how I was often excluded from social situations, along with my ex-wife.

I began to form doubts. I began to see what I now realize is the tribalism, and I couldn't reconcile that with the first commandment. At the same time, socializing on the internet had opened me up to a whole host of new tribes, and I began to learn that there was not only great people in them, but great truths - truths I wasn't being taught in church. I began to question, began to doubt, and began to be frustrated with LDS culture. I slipped in and out of activity for years. This excluded me even more. I was not "church broke". I was "church broken".

My ex-wife had started down the path of faith transition with me, but she didn't stay on it. She returned to the church, and even though it was clear to me that it was one of the many things contributing to the depression in her life. We eventually suffered through a transformational event - the death of our only child - and my relationship with her fell apart only six months after that. Without our son and without the church, we had nothing holding us together. We were worlds apart as people.

I eventually began life anew. I dove into studying subjects like emotional intelligence and coping skills. I studied other philosophies and religious tenents. I studied atheism, various form of theism and eventually decided that there was beauty in many of these explanations but none of them really truly fully encompassed everything I beleived. I became a universalist - though I wouldn't discover the word for it for several years, when in 2009 I decided to attend the Unitarian Universalist church (as it was near Christmas time and it felt right to be "religious again".)

I liked what I saw with the UU church. Logically, I liked their philosophy, but I didn't trust the preacher and people kept telling me that I should go out for choir and for singles activities, and to come back. I felt smothered. I didn't want smothering. The Mormons smothered me. I didn't like that. I didn't want to be welcomed. I wanted to be left alone, to decide whether I liked this or not. I eventually decided UU stuff wasn't for me. I once again went unchurched, but I adopted the label "universalist" because it was the first thing besides "agnostic" that I found that felt like it fit what I believed.

I eventually found another woman - a women who was Mormon, but still attended most of the time. She wasn't orthodox, but she wasn't questioning either. We dated. She broke a few rules with me, but never really wanted to go too "un-Mormon"I figured that she probably liked me but would eventually get tired of my non-Mormonism and leave me. Six months passed. She hadn't left me. She didn't even seem to be questioning us. I decided that this relationship was serious, and we began exploring it more deeply. We married three and a half years after we started dating, outside the temple ofc, in a beautiful secular ceremony performed by an LDS bishop who refrained from saying anything that made me want to punch him in the face. (He was told not to mention temples, but that the concept of eternal families was fine.) I had finally found what didn't feel like a broken relationship. I finally felt less broken. Still broken. But less.

Fast-forward to 2015. I'm still a secular agnostic universalist. I don't like the LDS church but I don't hate it either. I know it's not for me, but it didn't seem to be doing anything bad for our family. Being a former BYU student, I still like BYU. I bonded with my wife and her family over BYU football. Then the Madi Barney story broke. I felt clearly morally outraged. I sought others and found only those on the ex-Mormon side and maybe a few Progressive Mormons seemed to care. I was pissed. No longer could I like BYU. I was not only church broken now, but BYU broken too.

I became more heavily involved with the exmo community, moving from NOM to Reddit. I had gone from "ex-Mormon lite" to mainlining it. I could never bring myself to go full evangelical atheist, but I understood their outrage. They are "church broken" too after all. I finally let myself be angry at Mormonism - something I had never allowed earlier in my "slow fade". The relationship with my wife became strained. She loved her church and I clearly hated it. She took it personally, and I didn't want her to. I had to let go of the anger and the negativity, but found it very difficult to do so.

But I wanted to help and wanted to help people heal. I couldn't do that by simply raging against the machine. I began to study spiritual abuse. I began to study information about groups and individuals who healed it. Some were evangelical atheists, some we "spiritual". I found myself gravitating to the spiritual side. I began to learn more about mindfulness and meditation. I tried it, and felt a lot of the anger subside. I still felt hurt and pain, but I now felt like I had tools to address it.

I continued to learn more about mindfulness and meditation. I could never do it for all that long by myself. I began to study about other religions, leaning towards Buddhism but not really grasping or feeling connected with the theology. I took a quiz at BeliefNet, thinking maybe I was supposed to try UU again. Nope. It tells me that Liberal Quakers had what I want. Quakers? WTF? Buckled hats? I literally knew nothing about them.

So, lacking wisdom, I asked Google. The more I learned, the more I liked. 15 minutes drive away? I could give it a try. And so I did. I found a community I liked. I loved the meditation. I loved their approach. But I didn't trust them. I still don't. I see the imperfections. I see the people who claim to practice the values but then say something that's against them. I begin to feel like this is Mormonism all over again - but without the need to play follow the leader.

But they still let me be my own authority. I don't have to agree with that which I don't like. I don't have to accept other people's hypocracy as my own - I can choose my own way to "Quaker". I am still "church broken", but I am in charge of me. So I will continue to church for now, because I've found many people who I do love and feel a connection with there, even amongst those who I do not. I am broken, but I can still church. My way. Broken as it might be. Because I can only do good in the world if I don't stay on my island. I can only make it a better place if I am with other people. No longer will I stand alone in trying to fix what's broken. I will be with others to share my stories, my wisdom and my experiences - and to hear of theirs as well. Together, maybe we can all make things a little less broken.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Feb 21 '18

59 Percent of Millennials Raised in a Church Have Dropped Out—And They’re Trying to Tell Us Why.

Thumbnail
faithit.com
19 Upvotes

r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Jul 11 '18

Should

18 Upvotes

Recently something devastating happened in my life. I don't want to talk about what it was, only about how I am coping with grief. (For those who know me, it doesn't involve either of my kids.)

I found myself rather unexpectedly feeling a real need to meditate--something I've been trying off and on for a while now. It helped immediately, and I've continued it over the past few days.

It struck me just now that there isn't any "should" about this--or doesn't have to be; maybe I bring some exmo shouldness to it, but there's no expectation, in the same way that there's no shame in my mind wandering, just the observation of it.

This is so profoundly different from Mormonism, and so much more effective. I really don't remember a time when I felt a real need to pray or to go to church. I remember feeling an urgency, that this is what I should do, but not a need from within myself for the experience itself.

Just a passing thought.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Oct 05 '17

So long!

17 Upvotes

I was excommunicated from /r/Exmormon recently. Because of that, I'd rather not be involved in this satellite community and have removed all of my posts from here. It was fun while it lasted! I hope everyone finds a spiritual path that fulfills them!


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Oct 16 '16

Prayer

17 Upvotes

Just wanted to share with someone how excited I am. I have been trying for months to get past the Mormon prayer format and feel like I could just let out my real feelings.

Yesterday I had a really rough day and needed an outlet. When I was alone I said a prayer that was more heartfelt than usual. It wasn't long or life-changing, but it felt good and real. It's honestly a relief for me to feel something. Life has been very hard this last year and I have felt alone in many ways.

That's it, nothing too over the top. I just felt more peace than I have in a long time and that is something to celebrate in my eyes.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Sep 16 '16

Only sort of mormon related

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Jun 01 '16

Spirituality through the natural world.

16 Upvotes

As a followup to my recent post, I'd like to share a recent experience I had that I think I can classify as spiritual.

On a recent trip into Appalachia, I went fly fishing on a small, little-known river not far from some of the best brook trout streams in the mid-Atlantic. As I hiked upstream from its confluence with a larger river, I kept one eye on the trail and the other on the stream, looking for pools and pocket water likely to hold fish. I would leave the trail as I found likely spots, sometimes catching a fish or two and sometimes coming up empty. The stream's trout were beautiful, with dark green bodies covered in yellow, blue and red spots and orange fins with white and black streaks on them. The vibrant, clear water was ice cold despite the warm sun and its temperature progressively dropped the further I climbed upstream into the canyon that the water itself had carved over millions of years.

As I climbed higher, the trail left the stream altogether, opting instead to take hikers on another route. I chose to follow the stream.

The canyon narrowed and its walls became steeper. Large boulders began to appear, not yet subjected to the same inevitable erosion that had broken up the smaller rocks further downstream. As I rounded a corner, I saw a waterfall, sliding down a steep face of one of the boulders. Above it, another even larger waterfall. The deep pool at the base of the second waterfall contained fish that were genetically distinct direct descendants of holdovers from the last ice age. I didn't want to disturb them so I stowed my fly rod.

I kept hiking into the canyon. I no longer found any traces of humanity. I saw several pitch black cave entrances on one side, leaving an ominous feeling of being watched by someone, or something. The deeper I went, the stranger my surroundings became. I saw insects, millipedes, and spiders with colors I had never seen before. Strange plants shaped like curled candy canes covered in light green fuzz sprouted from the canyon floor. Unique mosses, lichens, and vibrantly colored mushrooms grew on boulders and half-decomposed tree trunks that were four feet thick. I realized that I had stumbled into one of Appalachia's unique islands of biodiversity. I felt like every step I took transported me further back in time.

I climbed higher, searching for the stream's source. However, for every obstacle I cleared, another blocked my path. Eventually, I realized I would run out of daylight to safely climb back down if I didn't turn back. I took a short rest, observing my surroundings one last time, taking everything in. I felt a sense of peace and wonder at the simple, unspoiled beauty I had happened upon. I felt deeply, peacefully connected with the scene while simultaneously feeling like an alien that didn't belong, tinged with the mild sting of feeling completely alone. As the late afternoon light fell heavy on the trees, I climbed down. Back to the trail. Back to civilization.

If God is real then s/he is truly an artist. Or maybe in that moment I found God in my natural surroundings, a beautiful mixture of complex organization, symbiosis, and chaos unfettered by the lines and boxes that we humans so enjoy imposing on everything. Maybe it's both.

My exit from Mormonism had left me at first excited, then angry, and then with a lingering sense of existential ennui that has lasted off and on for over a year. Though that emotional logjam is still there, my experience in a small canyon in central Appalachia felt like a big step in rediscovering God and reconnecting with my spiritual side.

Edits: for clarity


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Feb 12 '16

Exmo_Spirituality

16 Upvotes

Welcome to Exmo_Spirituality. We, the mods, want to welcome you to our new sub. While everything is new and fresh here, I figured I would go over what the purpose of this sub is. This sub was created for Ex-Mormons who have, or who are searching for, spiritual belief to come together to discuss what they have found or are looking for in a non-hostile environment. All are welcome and encouraged to participate here, but keep in mind this is a place for discussing, not tearing down, spiritual beliefs. We mods want to do everything that we can to make sure this sub is lively, informative, and welcoming to everyone. If there are any issues, please report them. If there are suggestions for the running of the sub, please let us know.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Feb 11 '17

Please, no proselytizing

15 Upvotes

I mentioned this just now in a thread, but want to reiterate it where everyone can see it.

This sub is for discussing religion and spirituality, and to make it welcoming and friendly for everyone we have a "no proselytizing" rule. Everyone is welcome and encouraged to express their beliefs, and to discuss others' beliefs. But whether you are Christian, atheist, Buddhist, undecided, atheist/agnostic, or any other point of view, please keep these guidelines in mind:

Please don't use the sub to gather followers for your religion/world view (or other subreddit).

Please preserve the line between expressing your views and actively seeking to persuade. We don't have to be missionaries any more! So let's leave each other's conversions/deconversions alone.

Please don't come here with a plan to knock down others' beliefs. This really is not the place. People do come here to get away from that.

Please don't dismiss, mock, or attack others' beliefs.

We've been generally very successful at maintaining respectful discourse, and I have really appreciated every point of view here. No one has complained or messaged the mods about anyone else (post Chickenroll). I just want to highlight this particular rule, which really is necessary to the sub.

So let's continue in our tradition of live and let live, please.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Oct 23 '16

My transition to Buddhism

15 Upvotes

First off, thanks to everyone who has helped build this community. This is a friendly corner of the internet. This post explains how I've become Buddhist. It's a bit long, skip this post if you aren't feeling it. I'm hoping to post more in the future about my experiences with Buddhism.

I've had a thing for learning about religion for a long time. For the most part that meant Mormonism, but as a teenager I started learning about other religions. I mostly stuck to Christianity and Judaism, but I spent time reading about other religions too. I went on a mission to Thailand of all places - the country with the highest proportion of Buddhists anywhere in the world. I think I taught two people who were already Christian. Other than that, everyone held Buddhist or folk beliefs.

Many missionaries became very cynical about Buddhism and very critical towards people's beliefs and practices. This always bothered me - even if what people were doing wasn't correct, we should try to understand them and not be dismissive of their religion. It seemed like the Christian thing to do. However, most people that were willing to talk to us missionaries weren't very religious and despite occasional attempts at learning about Buddhism I didn't come away with a coherent picture of Buddhism.

At the end of my mission I felt drawn to learn more about Buddhism and looked for books to read after my mission. After a lot of confused searching, I found a book and felt a very strong impression that the book would change me. I was a bit worried about where it would take me, but I bought the book. It sat forgotten on my shelf after my mission until one day for whatever reason I took it down to read. It was not an easy read - it was full of Pali terms that I'd never heard of before. What I did understand was interesting and helpful. At the time I was still firmly Mormon and happy to be so, albeit a Mormon with a lot of questions and philosophizing.

After graduating from BYU, I visited Thailand and picked up a few more books on Buddhism (I strongly prefer Thai for learning about Buddhism.). With some of the vocabulary I learned from the first book I was able to learn a lot more from the new books. Around the same time I was wandering farther and farther from the LDS church mentally. I learned more and more about Buddhism and started to use the teachings in my life. What I learned and what I did had a clear positive impact on my life.

On another trip, I found friends in Thailand (mostly less-active Mormons) who had similar thoughts about Mormonism and Buddhism. They introduced me to monks and teachers and recommended Buddhist practices. I started listening to Buddhist sermons, studying more, and practicing more. Eventually I started regularly making the long trip to the local Thai Buddhist temple. There is no traditional ceremony to convert to Buddhism (at least in my tradition there isn't. The different sects have developed very different traditions.). After a while I started regarding myself as Buddhist. It's been a very good journey that has taught me a lot and made a visible impact on my life.

Thank you for reading a piece of my story.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Sep 21 '19

My Entheogenic Mormon Experience

Thumbnail self.mormon
13 Upvotes

r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Sep 05 '16

I just want to say...

13 Upvotes

I really like the people here on this sub. I love the Catholic/Orthodox, with their passion and knowledge. I love the atheists, with their courage and intelligence and willingness to challenge the rest of us. I love u/hyrie, my alter-ego, and u/hasbrochem, the conscience of r/exmormon. I love u/one_above-all, who gave us this forum skin and is patient with my agnosticism.

I know, it's a little overemotional. But I really appreciate you all. Thanks.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Nov 11 '17

I believe in a god, but where do i go?

12 Upvotes

No conference pun intended I was raised Catholic, got baptised LDS when I was 19, and left after two years later. When I left I started reading the Old Testament (I gave up with the LDS edition and got one that has language we use this century) and read quite a few books but stopped at Proverbs to give myself a little break. I started doing some online research and came across some articles and videos on mistranslations in the Bible and how they point to the fact that based on the Old Testament, Jesus can't be the promised Jewish messiah. After reading those passages in an English version of a Hebrew bible since I figured the translation was more accurate than the translation of a translation of a translation of a translation of most normal English bibles. I read the passages spoken of in the videos and came to the conclusion Jesus wasn't the Messiah. Since then I've been clueless about religion, I believe in a God I just don't know where to turn. Has anyone else had a similar issue?


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Oct 09 '16

Blessing my daughter

12 Upvotes

So it's just past midnight here and I'm sitting here waiting to see if my daughter is going to remain asleep for a bit.

I've mentioned how we just moved to Germany and we just had our first experience with socialized medicine (better than any experience I've had elsewhere). My daughter dislocated her elbow earlier today. Not something I recommend, by the way. The last time she woke up, I sat there rubbing her leg and stomach trying to calm her down enough so she could fall back asleep. And I said to myself, what does it matter? The worst that happens is in talk to myself.

I blessed my daughter that she would be okay, that she would be able to refocus her pain and have peace. I blessed her that she would be able to sleep. I blessed her to know we love her. I did it all in the name of my love for her.

She went to sleep shortly thereafter. I don't expect it to have any real effect. I do want her to know she is loved. There still are magical aspects of Mormonism that have some small hold on me.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Sep 16 '16

I am a Mormon to atheist to Catholic convert AMA

12 Upvotes

Over the last few days or so my inbox has exploded with people asking questions about me and my spiritual journey. I figured I would do a mini AMA here to allow everyone the chance to ask me some questions. Feel free to ask anything you want.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Sep 11 '16

the death of joseph smith

12 Upvotes

Over the past month or so, there have been some posts here and there online about JS and some of the events surrounding his death. I read the book American Crucifixtion by Alex Beam some time in the last year and cannot recommend it enough as he's an outsider and is neither for nor against mormonism/JS/etc. he just wanted to tell a story he found compelling. As such, here are excerpts from his book that I highlighted while reading and still find fascinating. I hope you will as well since the real story is nothing like what we're told in the church. (Aside: there is a ton that is left out since these are just snippets, the book is worth getting if you're interested in church history from a more neutral viewpoint)

The governor [friendly with JS] listened to Smith's emissaries and immediately summoned Joseph and other members of the City Council to Carthage to stand trial. "Your conduct in the destruction of the press [The Expositor] was a very gross outrage upon the laws and the liberties of the people," Ford wrote, "It may have been full of libel, but this did not authorize you to destroy it."

Speaking of what would happen to JS if/when he went to Carthage, Heber C. Kimball said, after JS had started to flee to the west:

"It [destroying the press] is a bailable offense and there is no danger," Kimball assured the group [of mormons], arguing that Smith could face a magistrate in Carthage without fear. Joseph's disappearance would "lessen the value of property--also ruin a number of men," he added, presumably including himself.

Up to this point, JS and company had been able to skirt the law time and time again, either through the courts in Nauvoo, which JS controlled by the fact that he was the prophet of those judges, or via his friends who happened to be very powerful lawyers and influential politicians. This was one of the larger reasons of contention between the mormons and those who were not, among other things, and is also why many thought him going to Carthage would be no big deal. He had been in this situation before and escaped with little to no harm time and time again in the past.

Kimball then went to Emma to with some others to try and figure out what to do, this led to her penning the letter begging JS to return and face the music.

Cahoon started up again, reaffirming the points made in Emma's letter. "You always said if the church would stick to you, you would stick to the church, now trouble comes and you are the first to run," he charged. "When the shepard deserts his flock, who is to keep the wolves from devouring them?" Kimball and Wasson accused Joseph of cowardice, complaining that their property would be destroyed as a result.

It seems the idea of property and monetary value being of the utmost importance is nothing new to the mormon church. This made me chuckle.

"If my life is of no value to my friends it is of none to myself," Joseph said...Appartently swayed by Emma's letter and by the pleadings of the terrified Saints, Hyrum suggested returning to Nauvoo. "Let us go back and give ourselves up, and see the thing out. Let us go back and put our trust in God, and we shall not be harmed. The Lord is in it. If we live or have to die, we will be reconciled to our fate."

Joseph thought for a moment, then answered, "If you go back I will go with you. But we shall be butchered."9

9 Some of the more dramatic, or quotable, episodes of Joseph's martyrdom may have been interpolated into the official church history. In 1844, Isaac Scott wrote to his in-laws in Massachusetts: "You will likely hear a great deal about Joseph's innocence, such as "I go as a lamb to the slaughter"...All these statements, I believe, are false and got up for the purpose of reconciling the minds of the Church. I believe they had not the least idea they were going to be murdered."

This is interesting, as we'll see more about why this might be in a moment.

Chicago journalist B.W. Richmond had traveled to Nauvoo...he found himself reporting a much larger story. A non-Mormon, Richmond's dispatches were unclouded by church affiliation, so he saw a very different, characteristically relaxed Joseph Smith lounging in the mansion prior to his second departure for Carthage, "I saw a large, well dressed individual seated on a trunk at the further end of the hall, quietly smoking a cigar...he was easy in his manners and seemed sure of an acquittal if he could get a fair hearing."

Don't forget, the word of wisdom was issued in 1833 and this is 1844 (though it wasn't a commandment back then). Jumping ahead to after they have arrived in Carthage:

In the afternoon, the Smiths and their seventeen co-defendents charged with destroying the Nauvoo Expositor met the man who would decide their fate: Robert F. Smith, justice of the peace and captain of the restive Greys...This was the same Robert Smith who had signed a bank note guaranteeing a portion of Joseph's ill-fated steamboat purchase, which landed them both in bankruptcy court.

To say the least, this was not someone that had a favorable opinion of JS. He agreed to free all the defendants, though their bail was set at such a large amount that none of them would have been able to afford it on their own. However, many of the mormons present at the hearing put their property up as surety and all of the defendants, except for the two Smith brothers, were released.

Earlier in the day, two of the Smith's enemies, the Mormon apostates Augustine Spencer and Henry Norton, had filed pleas accusing Joseph and Hyrum of treason for placing Nauvoo under martial law...Unlike the previous charges laid against Smith, treason was not a bailable offense.

There was some fishy activity going on here but they didn't want JS and HS slipping through the cracks again and escaping what they viewed as justice. And thus, they were committed to staying in Carthage jail.

Leaning out of the windows [of Carthage jail], Joseph, Hyrum, and several other Mormons preached scripture to the guards. The official church history, compiled many years later, reports several Greys left their posts, convinced of the prisoners' innocence. There were no independent reports of such converts.

Ford outlined the cases against Joseph, his spurious use of the Nauvoo courts to escape prosecution, and again condemned his ill-advised attack on the newspaper...Joseph invoked Blackstone, "one of the most eminent English barristers," to justify his actions against the "foul, noisome, filthy sheet." He offered to make restitution to the Law brothers for their lost investment...

The next day they appeared in court

The scene at the courthouse was brief. Joseph's lawyers argued for a continuance, hoping to free their clients in the interim. His attorney, Woods, noted that his client had been "committed to jail without any examination whatsoever."...When Joseph left the courthouse, he thought he would return for a hearing the next day. But that night Robert Smith changed the date on what would prove to be a fateful warrant, from Thursday, June 27, to Saturday, June 29...[ensuring] that Joseph and Hyrum Smith would remain imprisoned without a hearing for three days, instead of just one.

Already we can see the story is not as simple as we're told in the church or even if you read the church history. JS was not blameless, but the justice system was not playing things straight either.

When John Fullmer returned to the jail to spend the night with his friends, the surly guards rifled through the pockets of his overcoat. But they didn't search his boots. Fullmer smuggled in a small, single-barreled pistol, which he gave to Hyrum.

There's the origin of the first pistol the Smith's would have on them when they were attacked.

"You'll see that I can prophesy better than old Joe," [Franklin] Worrell [said]. "Neither he nor his brother nor anyone who will remain with them will see the sun set today." A Grey leveled his musket at Jones, cocked it, and said he "would love to bore a hole through old Joe."...

Jones burst in on Ford...He told Ford that he had proof that the prisoners' lives were in grave danger.

"You are unnecessarily alarmed for your friends' safety," the governor replied. "The people are not that cruel."

The Greys were supposed to be guarding/protecting the prisoners so to say this would be concerning is a bit of an understatement. At this point, the whole of the Greys are worked up and the environment in Carthage is tense, to say the least.

Cyrus Wheelock did gain entrance to Joseph's quarters, and the guards forgot to check his bulky raincoat when he enetered. Like Fullmer the night before, he was carrying a gun, this one a small, six-shooter revolver known as a pepperbox. Unobtrusively, he slipped the gun into Joseph's pocket...Joseph said that Wheelock himself might need the gun, but Wheelock insisted Joseph keep it...

Inside the Carthage jail the prisoners ate their lunches...After eating, Richards felt queasy, and Joseph asked Markham to fetch a pipe and some tobacco to settle his friend's stomach.

After borrowing a pipe from the town's sheriff, who was a mormon, and buying some tobacco, Markham was run out of town by the Greys and some other locals.

The four mormon prisoners were alone now, "our spirits full and heavy," John Taylor wrote...The four men gave one of the guards a dollar and sent out for a bottle of wine, "to revive us." The man quickly returned with the wine, some tobacco, and a few pipes. The four prisoners drank from the bottle and shared the remaining wine with their jailers.

The wine had the opposite of the desired effect; "We all of us felt unusually dull and languid, with remarkable depression of spirits," Taylor remembered. In a desperate attempt to buoy their mood, Hyrum suggested that Taylor, who had a beautiful voice, sing the popular folk hymn, "A Poor Wayfaring Man of Grief."

This I found particularly fascinating as the version I recall being told is that they felt oppressed because they knew death was imminent, though this does not seem to really be the case. They might have been somewhat fearful, but they were obviously not overly worried.

Taylor, sitting at the open, west-facing window, said he saw something: a band of men, their faces smudged, emerging from the woods and charging the jail.

This is probably were their thoughts on this changed.

[Eudocia] Baldwin [part of the six-man guard at the jail] and other Carthage residents panicked, assuming a Mormon force of marauding "Danites" had invaded Carthage to free Joseph and exact retribution on his persecutors.

This goes to illustrate just how "innocent" the mormons were while in Illinois. The armed militias in Carthage were terrified the mormon battalion was going to be on its way to free JS and company, and when the attackers first started to rush Carthage jail, the guards, the Greys, and residents of Carthage thought it was the mormon danites that went about avenging the mormons and their supposed greivances.

As they stormed the jail

Richards and Hyrum Smith threw themselves against the door to keep out the angry mob, but bullets started popping through the flimsy wood. The second shot fired entered Hyrum's skull on the left side of his nose. Simultaneously, a musket ball shot from the ground through one of the open windows hit Hyrum in the back. He fell backwards, crying, "I am a dead man." His lifeless body lay in the middle of the floor, blood pouring from his wounds.

If we remove our feelings towards the current mormon church and put ourselves in the shoes of those that were there, especially JS, this is an absolutely horrific scene that is unfolding. Considering that JS and HS were extremely close and that JS seemed to have very tender feelings for those closest to him, I can only imagine the pain and anguish he must have been feeling at this moment, but also not being able to grieve or dwell on it as his own life was still in danger.

Joseph and John...rushed to the door. Willard Richards had stationed himself behind the hinges, trying to push the door closed. But Joseph pulled out his six-shooter and started firing through the narrow opening between the door and the frame. **Three of the chambers fired, and Joseph made his shots count. He wounded three assailants on the staircase, one in the arm, one in the shoulder, and another in the face.

An interesting tidbit curiously left out in the official church histories.

Soon the killers invaded the room. Taylor ran from the door to an open window on the north side of the jail...He thought of jumping the fifteen feet to the ground, but he saw the jail surrounded...A bullet from the door entered his thigh...A second bullet flying through the window struck him in the midriff, shattering his pocket watch and propelling him back into the room...Falling to the floor, the blood-spattered Taylor rolled under the bed for safety. The mob fired two more bullets into him...Taylor was left for dead, his watch stopped at 5:16 p.m.

This part of the story is more gruesome than I recall being told as well, but we're not finished and it is going to get worse. Just a bit of a warning, this next part was very hard to read the first time I did, but it shows the horrific nature of JS's murder and the amount and type of hatred he had garnered in the short period of time they were in Illinois, with some following them from Missouri, though not much since Illinois first welcomed them with open arms and looked down on their Missouri neighbors.

Desperately hoping for safety, Joseph Smith followed Taylor to the window, planning to jump. A mobber named Gallagher shot him in the back from the doorway, and shots from the ground struck Joseph in the chest and back. Smith tumbled out the window, crying, "O Lord my God," the first words of the Masonic cry for help, "O Lord my God, is there no help for the widow's son?" His body fell near a raised wooden curb surrounding a well.

There was to be no pity for the widowed Lucy Mack's son. Mobber William Voorhis grabbed Joseph's body and propped it up against the well. The he exposed Joseph's bloody chest to the angry mob.

"You are the damned old Chieftan." Voorhis taunted the half-dead body of Joseph Smith, "Now go see your spiritual wivesin hell!" Voorhis stood aside and watched a handful of his comrades fire several more rounds into Joseph's lifeless body.

With JS dead, the mob dispersed.

"He's dead," a mobber grunted, and the attackers vanished as quickly as they came.

They wanted JS, not the mormons. I find this quite curious as well.

The faked confrontation with the guards, the siege up the staircase, the slaughter of the Mormons and the brief ogling of the dead Prophet's body consumed all of three minutes.

The lives of JS's wives and family would forever be marked by this event and if you listen to the year of polygamy podcast by /u/LindsayHansenPark you will get a fuller picture of them, their lives, and what they had to endure and live through. I did want to include this part though as one illustration

But the eleven-year-old boy [Joseph Smith, III] who devoted his adult life to proving that his father had never practiced polygamy failed to see Lucinda Morgan Harris standing at the head of Joseph's coffin. Three years older than Emma, the fair-haired, blue-eyed Harris was also sobbing and grief-stricken. Harris had been sealed to Joseph a few years before, while she was wed to George Harris, who chaired the CIty Council session that ordered the destruction of the Nauvoo Expositor. Lucinda had lost two husbands to mob violence. She had previously married the notorious anti-Masonic agitator William Morgan, whose body was found in Lake Ontario shortly after he published a lurid expose of the ancient fraternal order. Lucinda Harris ended her life as a nun in the Catholic nursing order, the Sisters of Charity.

The next year BY would include the "oath of vengeance" into the endowment ceremony and it would remain a part of it until 1927, some 80+ years later. Later during the time period of the trial for JS and HS's murders

The four men who probably fired the shots that killed Joseph-John Wills, William Voras, fourteen-year-old William Gallagher, and Nathan Allen-simply vanished across the river to Missouri.

Finally, one last thing. During the succession crisis there were some very interesting going ons

William Marks, Emma Smith, and William Smith briefly considered themselves Strangites, as did Joseph's mother, Lucy Mack Smith, Apostle George Adams, and Martin Harris...

I hope this has been interesting and informative. I chose to stick with one text because it was very well researched, written, and it just made my life easier. I can't stress enough how much is left out from this very brief overview. The book is well worth the read for someone interested in the mormon church's history.

Edit: some words...


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • May 23 '16

Let's talk about spiritual experiences.

12 Upvotes

My journey out of the LDS church encompassed many things that I'm sure you all can relate to (doctrinal inconsistencies, historical problems, bad policies, lies, and so on). Additionally, one of the things that really disenchanted me from it was the discovery of the lack of reliability in what I thought were spiritual experiences: promptings that led nowhere, impressions that turned out badly, "feeling the spirit" about something that later turned out to be objectively untrue. I discovered a plethora of normal psychological phenomena that seemed to explain these experiences (confirmation bias, anyone?).

However, I just couldn't take the simple logical leap to atheism. I'm not afraid of the idea of ceasing to exist after I die (not anymore than the idea of existing forever). It just simply doesn't gel with me for whatever reason. I don't know what kind of deity I believe in, if any. I think the closest I've gotten to what most people define as "spiritual experiences" have been through connecting with reality via mindfulness/zen techniques, which makes me feel at peace and connected with myself, but not necessarily with any kind of deity.

So, for those of you who have left mormonism, but have been able to hang onto/redefine your definition of spirituality generally, how have you done it and how do you define a "spiritual experience"?

Also (if applicable): If your spiritual experiences/connection to the Divine/etc. are in the context of Christianity/organized religion, how do you differentiate your "false positive" experiences in Mormonism with what you deem to be a genuine spiritual experience?


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • May 09 '16

Introductions

12 Upvotes

Please feel free to introduce yourself here and let us welcome you to the sub. I see a lot of lurkers--looking forward to hearing from you when the time is right.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Feb 12 '16

Let's Get Started

12 Upvotes

I think a good first post here would be introductions. Tell us about yourself. When did you leave the LDS church? What are your current beliefs? What are some things you are hoping to learn on this sub?


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Oct 06 '17

Mom's visiting from out of town. Had huge argument because she brought up the church. It's just so sad, I wish I could have a real relationship with her

11 Upvotes

I cri


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Jan 27 '17

Uncle alan speaks

Thumbnail
imgur.com
11 Upvotes

r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Jun 05 '16

Community of Christ's Seth Bryant's powerful sermon asks hard questions about what it means to claim to be a follower of Christ, "Peace without justice...is a distortion and perversion of the the mission of Christ..."

Thumbnail
youtube.com
11 Upvotes

r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Feb 17 '20

No Longer Mormon. Now what??

10 Upvotes

I left the Mormon church I'm at peace with the decision. Obviously I'm devastated about all the years wasted and tithing spent but I don't want to become cynical toward organized religion as a whole just because I was lied to in the past. Recently I've attended a few different non-denominational churches and they all teach trinitarianism, which is the belief that God the Father, Jesus Christ and the Holy Ghost are all part of the same substance or being, but sometimes God the Father acts in the name of Jesus Christ or Jesus Christ speaks as Father God etc. I personally don't believe in that. I believe in nontrinitarianism, which means that God, Jesus Christ and the Holy Ghost are three separate and distinct beings but they all work together with one purpose. I had no idea that almost zero christian religions believe in this doctrine besides the Mormon church. Am I just doomed to worship God in my own living room for the rest of my life or what should I do to find a religion that matches what I believe? Any advice or help you can give me about finding a new church or your journey after you left Mormonism would really help me out. Thanks everyone.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Feb 07 '19

Joseph Campbell and the Power of Myth

10 Upvotes

I've always been spiritual. Mormonism was a good place for my spirituality to begin but it became to small. Now I'm beginning a road down into Druidism/Celtic spirituality. That being said, I was recently introduced to Joseph Campbell and I've found a kindred soul. Basically, Joseph Campbell was the most well read scholar of mythology. He studied myths from all over the world and was able to see the overall patterns. He explains them so well. All of the questions about religion in general seem to go away and the deeper ideas become more apparent when one realizes that all of religion is myth. Myth that evokes deeper meanings and a deep understanding of the human experience. I tried finding ways to stay within mormonism with this understanding but alas, it was not to be so.

Anyone else have any thoughts on the mythology of it all? Anyone else leave mormonism for a non-abrahamic faith? I'd love to hear about it.


r/Exmo_Spirituality • • Jul 06 '18

If Your Church is Silent Right Now—You May Want to Leave it

Thumbnail
johnpavlovitz.com
10 Upvotes