TL;DR: with our recent move I didn't have internet access for a week or so and so random thoughts and whatnot congealed into a semi-cogent form, which spilled out from my brain onto my computer and which I now present to you. Some thoughts and feelings about religion and why I'm an atheist. Sorry it's so long and if you don't make it through reading all of it I wouldn't blame you, but I feel like I need to get these things off my chest. Also, sorry for two posts in one day. I'm sure we can all deal with it though.
An existential quandary. That’s the trope you might hear now and then from those that go through a faith crisis and/or lose all faith in some deity. It’s more than just a fanciful hipster term used by those that feel they need something academic and eloquent sounding to name the period of life through which they are passing. For me it’s the very essence of what I have been and continue to experience as I seek to find if there is even any meaning, let alone new meaning, to this life. This is not my story. This is a small piece of what has happened to me. For me, it was never really one or two things that led me to where I am today, but rather a conglomeration of many things that have brought me to the conclusions I have reached thus far. That said (i.e., I’m long winded), this is in an important part of my journey.
When I was around fourteen or so years old, I had come to the conclusion that the religion I was raised in made little to no sense and I saw no purpose in fulfilling a mission, as was and still is required of every “worthy” young man (we’ve all seen/experienced/heard the stories of the golden boys in various wards that would go out drinking, smoking, having sex, and all the “unholy” and “impure” practices and then suddenly they’re headed out on a mission; praise to the man). I had no desire to spread the good word about something I found to be ridiculous and untenable. When my parents found out I didn’t want to serve a mission, it broke my mom’s heart, much like I know it’s broken today. She colluded with my friends to try and bring it up and to show me what they were doing. The problem with that is I’ve never been a follower. My family has never really understood me nor do they know who I am, but rather have a caricature of who they think I am and this is all they see, even to this day.
A couple of months before I turned 17, some friends and I were in a car wreck (SUV that rolled over literally in the middle of nowhere). They were fine other than cuts, bruises, and one broken thumb. I was thrown from the vehicle, which luckily did not roll on top of me, but was lucky enough to have my fall broken by a rock. There are plenty of funny stories like when my aunt and uncle showed up, she was in tears because all they knew was that I was in a bad wreck and had been life-flighted to the hospital (middle of nowhere), and they walk into the emergency room with me sitting on a gurney covered in blood from head to toe and I just look at here and say, “pessimist.” But this isn’t about that incident in my life. What it did was scramble my brain. Because of the rock I hit my head on, I lost about a month or more’s worth of time, though I remember bits and pieces. Later I would find out that I should have taken a semester off from school, which I could have made up over a summer, and that because of the accident my left and right sides of my brains don’t really communicate. A good example of this is that people usually associate someone’s face with a name. I don’t. I usually have to relate some other nonphysical characteristic with a person if I’m to remember their name. One more story, because it’s funny. In my mid-twenties I had been dating this girl for about four months and we had arranged to spend the day together. On my way there to pick her up, I realized I didn’t remember her name. No big deal. Someone there will say her name before we leave, right? Wrong. We then went on to spend the next 6-8 hours together, the whole time I had no idea what her name was. Two minutes after I dropped her off, I remembered it. Kathy. I still know it to this day, but have no idea what her face looks like.
The head injury did change some aspects of my personality as well. I was slightly less independent and started to care a little more what people thought of me. As part of that, I began to want to believe the church was true and started to act like everyone else who said they just knew. I didn’t know jack shit. I started to read the book of mormon (BoM), though it literally gave me migraine headaches to do so. Being the wonderfully stubborn person that I am, I powered through until I could stand to read it without wanting to throw up from the physical pain. I also took this as satan trying to keep me from doing what was right. I was starting to get my persecution complex down pat.
The following summer after the car accident, I went to a helamen’s camp or whatever they call it where they isolate the young men from the outside world and then use techniques which are well known to be used by cults to isolate and indoctrinate their followers (i.e., brainwashing among other things). As a part of this ritualized grooming and brainwashing, they took us out into the woods in groups of five or six, where a trusted leader gave us each a small rock and told us to place it in our shoe and to not take it out, no matter what. We were then blindfolded, led to the start of a trail, had our hand placed on a pipe suspended just above waist high and told by another trusted leader to follow the pipe, or rod, and to not let go. Along the trail other people from the camp, all of them in leadership positions, begin calling to you as you traverse the path all while being blindfolded, asking for help, telling you to come get a drink and take a rest.
At the end you come to find out that it’s supposed to be a representation of life, where we come through the veil, being blinded/blindfolded and then having to hold to the rod (not that one; self-abuse is never condoned) to make it back. Those of us who had listened to the trusted leader and not taken that infernal stone out of our shoe were chastised because this represented sin and all we had to do was reach down and cast it out, letting the blood of christ wash over us. Little did they understand just how well they were representing the church and its leaders in this deceitful manner in which they conducted themselves. We’re told that we need to trust the church leaders and do what they say, yet all through life they are telling us things that are not only unhealthy for us but that, if you believe in christ, will lead you into strange paths and away from god. At the end, many people were upset over what had happened. I figure it out pretty quickly and thought it was particularly stupid. This didn’t prevent me from getting suckered into the rest of their underhanded program.
At the end of the week, I was a blubbering shell of a human, just like everyone else there, weak and ready to be built up in the image of what they wanted us all to be. I struggled after this, a lot, because I wanted to be a “good” mormon boy but I also didn’t want to have to do so at my own personal expense. Some would call this pride or selfishness. I just call it being an individual. Through twisted mental gymnastics, I was eventually able to sort things out for myself and do what I needed to in order to fit their mold. Time came and went until it was time to go on my mission. In that intervening time, I was introduced to existentialist philosophy. For the first time in my life, I found something that spoke to my “soul,” if you will. Suddenly things were clear. Yes, life is absurd. No, there is no purpose beyond being a good person. I pushed this all aside in order to “do what is right.”
I went to mexico on my mission and met a lot of great people. I feel mountains of guilt for having introduced those good people into a cult, some of which will likely remain for a handful of generations at the very least. I was able to help “convert” people that had been considered eternal investigators and others that had sworn they would never join the church. There is one family in particular that I have in mind and it breaks my heart to know that I am partly responsible for roping him and his children into this cult (his wife was already a member and he had met with dozens upon dozens of missionaries for almost a decade). I loved that family. It makes me sad to know I may have caused more damage than good, especially if there is an afterlife. I can’t even write about it without bringing tears to my eyes. I honestly hope they have all left the church by now. While on my mission, to better help and teach people, I began to imagine what it would be like to someone to hear what we teach and what is said at church and conference for the first time. The reason for this was (another story):
One day, a nice older lady invited us in for dinner once we said we were missionaries for jesus cristo, not caring which religion we laid claim to. She served us a very nice lunch of beans and rice (it really was quite good) and since we were followers of christ like her, she put on some of her favorite sermons which had been taped for us to listen to. It was a fiery preacher from the states, so it was in English, and they went a little something like:
“The Bread of Life is The Lord!! And The Lord Fed His Chosen People on Mana in the Wilderness!!! AND DAVID CALLED FORTH UNTO THE LORD SAYING, GIVE ME THE BREAD OF LIFE THAT I MIGHT NOT PERISH!! AND THE LORD SENT DOWN FIRE FROM THE HEAVENS ABOVE, DEVOIRING ROCK, STONE, AND ALL THAT THEY COULD SEE SO THAT ALL MIGHT BELIEVE!!!!!!! CAN I GET AN AMEN?!!!”
Sure there are a bunch of stories from the bible all mixed up in there, but that’s what he was doing and it really confused me. This is what started me to thinking about what it might sound like to someone who had never heard of the mormon church and they went to sunday meetings or, god forbid, conference sessions.
I quickly came to the realization that it all sounded crazy. Surprisingly, this did not cause me to doubt, but rather to just take a different approach to the way I would sell the gospel and sell it I did. After all, it was god's work (that he couldn't do himself?) and I enjoying excelling at something.
After my mission, I found out partly why I was so “successful” particularly in areas of my mission where others had failed (I was usually sent to reopen or to areas where they were having little success). For one, I’m tenacious as all get out and for another, I’m a damned good salesman. After my mission, I went door to door selling $1000+ vacuums for a short period of time (2-3 months) and was known to be able to get into people’s houses like you wouldn’t believe. I was also able to sell them like they were hotcakes, especially for someone new. In later sales jobs, I would drive the other salesman batty because I’m not motivated by money and would do the bare minimum that I had to, until some sort of competition would arise and then I would do just enough to win the competition, not because I wanted the prize or even to win, but rather to spite someone else I didn’t like. I’m also a vindictive bastard when I want to be.
It was never about being converted myself, I convinced myself that I believed, but I didn’t; it was about being the best at what I was doing. I had spent literally hours on my knees, begging, pleading, crying out in the anguish of my soul to know if the church and other assorted potpourri were true both before, during, and after my mission. Nothing. I’ve related in other threads where this same scenario played itself out, but with me being in a severe depression and just wanting to know I wasn’t alone and was loved. I was loved, just not by someone that isn’t there. My family, in spite of our differences and their inability to ever get to know me, they always have and always will love me. For that alone, I am forever grateful to them no matter what else may happen. In spite of their love and my wonderful wife and daughter who are the best two things to have ever happened to me, I have come to accept that I am alone in this cold and unforgiving void we call life. I don’t like to share the reasons why I’ve come to this conclusion as they are unpleasant in the extreme even for me to think about, which I don’t very often.
During the time that all of this was going on, the deep seeds of misogyny and sexism had been planted, bloomed, and were flourishing as well inside of me. For some unknown reason, racism never took with me, this in spite of being friends with a family of southern confederates and neo-nazi sympathizers when I was a kid. We’ll return to my sexism shortly.
My first semester back from college, I took a literature class taught by a physics professor where we started with the play hamlet and classical physics of deterministic systems and worked our way through the ages to a modern playwright’s work and chaos, where the smallest changes at the beginning have unforeseeable outcomes on the final results. In this class, my ideas of god and how the eternities work were challenged and not in a small way. In many ways this was good. I truly began to question again the reality of my surroundings and what everything meant to me. Existential thought and ideas rearing their heads again, making the most sense to me.
I recall this day very vividly, which means it is most likely not a very reliable memory, as I needed somewhere quiet where I could think things through. Remember, I had just returned from my mission not three months prior. I went to the institute of religion, of all places, and found a secluded corner where I sat. Mulling over the different thoughts and questions I had running through my mind:
“God knows everything…but predestination isn’t a thing, he just knows what we’ll do, so it’s really not that it’s all determined beforehand and that we have no choice in the matter. It’s just that god knows what choices we’ll make and where we’ll end up no matter what…but what I’ve now learned is that this doesn’t work because the world is not deterministic and even the slightest changes in the initial conditions can cause massive differences and unforeseeable consequences in the outcomes, so how can god know everything? He (of course god has a penis and guaranteed it’s f%#*ing huge!!) is just so much more advanced and can understand things we can’t…”
and round and round I went for hours. Until finally, something clicked, or rather failed and it all seemed to make sense to me. I can’t tell you what or how or anything like that because that part I don’t recall whatsoever. Whatever it was, though, my happy little apologist mind had decided that everything was alright with the universe and I could go on my merry way, continuing to believe in fairytales like I did before. The physics and math department were made up of almost exclusively never-mos and who shared with me wonderful insight and perspectives on the world I would not have otherwise gained. The chemistry faculty, on the other hand, were entirely tbm’s with the exception of one never-mo. My research adviser was probably more nom than tbm, but he was still pretty hardcore and I looked up to him for many things included how one could be a scientist and still believe in god.
Several people, including my cousin, who is an engineer and I recently found out went on a mission because of things I said and did, otherwise he might not be active in the church right now (this is something else I am conflicted over in the extreme), have pointed out the chemist Eyring, the father of the current ga, who was a great scientist and always maintained his belief in the mormon religion. I’ve read the books/pamphlets that he circulated and even as a tbm they seemed to stretch credulity a bit for me. My guess is, and this is also based on how his son behaves when he thinks he can get away with it, is that he was nom in the extreme and likely did not believe but due to sunk cost was not willing to give it up. I do not think that Eyring, the scientist, is a good example for others to follow as it will lead down a path of living a conflicted life.
During my undergraduate education, I met many young women, some strange, some perplexing, others enthralling, and yet other infuriating. I’m sure I was this and much more to them as well. The one thing that confused me the most was that the women that would flirt the most were the ones that were married, particularly if they were mormon. Nothing would ever come from it, but to a single male, it was very confusing. I still don’t understand it and in a way that I can’t really describe, it makes me sad. The important women that I met, though, helped me to change my views and ideas that I had about the “roles” and “duties” of the sexes in a relationship. Most of them have no idea what they did for me and all I can do is send them silent “thank you”’s through the ether. What they eventually did was not just challenge but they collectively destroyed my views on women and what their role(s) in society, the family, and life are. I now have a greater respect for women in general and the many contributions they have and continue to make to every aspect of life. Since the sciences are of particular import to me, this is one area I like to focus on, though literature, the arts and humanities are also not to be neglected. One of my favorites is Jane Austen. Misunderstood and often maligned as a romantic. The woman was a genius and extremely adept with the pen. She was and is one of the greatest satirists this world has ever seen, so much so, that people still don’t understand this aspect of her writing to this day. Every word seethes with loathing for the lovers and romantics of her stories, their ignorance of life and disregard for the logical and common sense brought to glaring life with each biting phrase and paragraph. She will forever hold a special place in my heart. While I did not enjoy Middlemarch, I appreciate what Eliot had to endure, publishing under a man’s name so as to be able to show her true genius to the world that they might appreciate it. Madame Curie, who in the last portion of her life, couldn’t even afford the element she had discovered to continue her research because of greedy capitalization and her not wanting to patent the method for making radium because “it belongs to the people.” Working in a man's world, she discovered radiation, one of the most important discoveries of the 20th century, and helped to advance science by leaps and bounds from her tireless work. The list goes on and on.
During my graduate studies, I have worked under nothing but atheists and who are some of the most moral individuals I know. All while watching those that espouse a belief in god game the system, abuse their positions both in how they work their graduate students as well as having illicit and often illegal (due to university guidelines and sexual harassment laws) relationships with the women under their “care,” among other things. This is anecdotal, but it is what has helped me to form the opinions and views I have. In my own experiences, including being excommunicated once while I was a tbm, which is nothing short of soul crushing and does not make you into a better person, I have seen very little in the way of morality being espoused and practiced and mostly have watched as “believers” in a higher-being use those beliefs to twist and distort their own actions into being justified. Mitt Romney is a great example of this. His business practices, while completely legal and a perfect example of the corporate America mindset, are completely antithetical to the teachings of jesus.
While I was a missionary in mexico I talked to many people who, due to the corruption they would see within the catholic church, that is may have indeed fallen into this new word we were telling them about, “apostasy,” and that maybe a restoration was truly needed for god’s one true church to rule them all to be here on earth in its fullness (whatever that may mean). This only lead to further confirmation bias of what we were preaching and had been spoon-fed (a nice white-washed version of the history of the Mormon church) this coupled with the numerous rumors that would fly about the mission, only helped to further solidify my beliefs that this was the one and only. Every now and then, though, we would run across someone that would challenge us and our thought process. There was one man in particular that I recall. He challenged us to find the word “church” in the bible, particularly as used by jesus. It’s not there. This person planted a seed.
Next, there was another person who asked us what the definition of a church was, because jesus said that where ever there were two or more meeting in his name, he would be there (i.e., does this then constitute as being a church?). Both of these would be important evolutionary points for me in my thought process and what I think about organized religion (/u/sarahpratt’s post spurred this).
For me, life is absurd. There is no real meaning though there are plenty of opportunities for us to assign what we see as meaning to the random and varied experiences we and others have.
I had often said that if I wasn’t mormon I would be an atheist. All I saw and continue to see in any religion is the absurd taken to an extreme. The adoration of a deity made human, tortured and gruesomely murdered (supposedly) to atone for all of our “sins.” We then are to cannibalize him to continually remember what he did every week. This alone makes little to no sense to me.
On top of that, we’re supposed to spend a blink of an eye here on earth to “learn and prepare” for an eternity of being gods. One chance. One short, halting chance. Screw it up and you’re fucked for eternity. Forever consigned to be a servant at best, at worst, stuck in perpetual stupidity where you can only advance so much and then you’re just stuck. All of an eternity, one shot, simply based on a single solitary blink of an eye we spend here on earth. Again, this is nonsensical. What kind of loving just god would behave in such a way? It’s like putting your three year old in a room full of candy and vegetables and telling them that they have to pick wisely in the next second to eat only vegetables, otherwise they’ll spend the rest of their life out in the cold. Religious people say things like this all the time. “We can’t comprehend/understand what god sees…” Yes. And a three year old can’t understand what you do. So is it then really fair to judge them based on what they do when they don’t have the capacity to comprehend what you do?
As I mentioned, the people who comport themselves in a more moral manner are often those that have no religious affiliation. The people that have helped me the most in my life have also been those same irreligious persons. The friends/acquaintances I have that are religious, especially those who are mormon, are generally the least reliable and when it comes to hard moral choices they will often use their religion to justify their actions rather than use it to guide them. This is hard for me to admit because I really do have kind feelings for my friends and acquaintances.
Organized religion itself might not be bad, but if we’re to use jesus’s own words to judge their worth, by their fruits you will know them, they tend to fail miserably on average. Suicide missions, inquisitions, torture sessions, confess and receive a quick death, the destruction of the library of Alexandria, burning of witches and those that made pacts with the devil, the child crusades, the other crusades, genital mutilation (male and female), genocide, child molestation and abuse (the mormon religion is rank with this as well), and on and on and on. “But atheists have done lots of awful things too Mao, Stalin, Mussolini, Hitler…” Let’s get this out of the way.
First, Hitler was not an atheist. He was a deist at worst and did believe in a god. There’s one off the list.
Mao, Stalin, Mussolini saw the use of religious organizations and how they were used to control people. They replaced religion with the cult of personality (cf. e.g., North Korea for a more modern example). They never did their atrocities in the name of atheism. Atheism is not a religion. I know some of you here think differently but it’s simply not a religion. It’s like saying not working is an occupation. A non-belief in god doesn’t drive someone to kill in the name of their lack of belief. There are plenty of cases and examples where a belief in a higher power has driven people to carry out horrible actions. A belief in god doesn’t necessarily drive someone to do these things, it just gives those that do an excuse.
If someone requires religion to not go out raping, plundering, murdering, and committing all kinds of crimes then they best get out there and find that religion which will keep them under control. Most people, I would hope at least, do not require the strictures of organized religion to be a good person. I don’t know that there is something wrong with organized religion, I just don’t see how it provides something beneficial without bringing in many other harmful things with it, especially where the good things it brings can be obtained elsewhere without many of the worries about the harmful aspects of organized religion.
My older sister, a deist at best though she claims to be a tbm, likes to use Life of Pi as her way of viewing these things, where it doesn’t really matter how the story is told and so why not choose the prettier version. The problem with this, from my point of view, is that you’re assuming that without a belief in god there is no beauty, no wonder, nothing worth living for. Since my acceptance of my own atheism, the world has new light and beauty in it. My relationships have grown deeper and more meaningful. All because I have come to realize that this is all there is. There is no chance to makes things right, or better, or improve them in the next life. There is no second chance and so I have to make the best of it now. I can’t use the magic blood of some torture victim put to death for treason (that’s what crucifixion was reserved for) to fix some mistake I might have made. I have to do the best that I can with what I have and now, not later.
For me, religion, organized or otherwise, represents oppression, sexism, misogyny, hate, mental abuse, physical abuse, sexual abuse, emotional abuse, brainwashing, inequality, racism, anti-intellectual, us-vs-them, and much more, none of which are good. Again, you can provide examples of the good that they do, but when I see even one person suffering because of the religion, it makes the good they do null and void, particularly when that good can easily be done without the scaffolding setup by said religion.