r/DebateEvolution • • 22h ago

Video Liberty University playing fast and loose with claims

51 Upvotes

Liberty University - ahem…..has recently published a new video with the title: “Geology Professor Explains How The Genesis Flood Actually Happened”.

You’ll find it here.

The video contains a rehashing of a number of long debunked creationist “explanations”, but the showstopper is actually the title.

The guy is not a “Geology Professor”. As far as I can tell he has no expertise in earth sciences whatsoever. The “Geology Professor” - one Dr Mark Hostemeyer is actually a mechanical engineer with the dubious distinction of having coined and trademarked the term "Creationeering", a paradigm that incorporates engineering and business entrepreneurship principles in a Christian framework. “

That clearly means, “geology professor” in the parallel world where Liberty University exists.


r/DebateEvolution • • 6h ago

Link If mutations were completely random, they wouldn't have the coherence to work to a deadline...

0 Upvotes

What do you guys think of this video.....I argue that mutations being utterly random wouldn't have the necessary coherence to work successfully against a time limit....

https://youtu.be/Ft9VZHY_AhQ?si=dO8tZp7SX54BqY3w


r/DebateEvolution • • 22h ago

Evidence means nothing.

0 Upvotes

As far as christianity is concerned, there is no evidence strong enough to turn an evolutionist’s mind. So my question is, why do so many spend so much time trying to prove creationism?
Whats to gain by finding “sufficient” proof?


r/DebateEvolution • • 3d ago

Question Apologetics Press - Direct Rebuttals?

29 Upvotes

I've grown up YEC my whole life, and I'm currently in the middle of deconstruction. Yesterday I talked to my preacher at church about it, which sort of made things way more real. I'm currently very active in the church, and all of my friends attend specifically this church because I moved here to be closer to my wife's family, I work from home, and have developed literally 0 other friendships than church. My wife is YEC and I have two very young kids. All of this makes it very difficult and I feel very isolated from anyone that isn't YEC. I want to point out too that these are all wonderful people, and I really don't want to lose anyone as a friend.

Backstory aside, I believe everyone I'm likely to talk to about this will try to refer me to https://apologeticspress.org to read "their take" on various subjects, and while I'm willing to do the legwork to seek out rebuttals to each thing one at a time, I'm wondering if there is a resource somewhere that directly engages with AP in a way that could save me time. Also, I wouldn't mind some general advice on my situation.

Sorry this post is kinda all over the place.


r/DebateEvolution • • 3d ago

Evolution is not atheism

65 Upvotes

A lot of creationists and atheistic evolution proponents that I’ve seen online seem to freely conflate atheism with evolution, as if you necessarily must be an atheist to believe in evolution. Creationists do it as a sort of theological blackmail; putting both together as a package deal means people who have to give up on creationism will also have to give up on their religion. On the other hand, some atheists seem to want to use it as a trump card, the ultimate proof that God does not exist since something so profoundly complex as life can be explained through naturalistic means. I especially see a lot of this type of discourse in this sub and I don’t think it’s helping people leave their belief in creationism behind.

It is in everyone’s best interest to keep these two concepts separate and not let people push their anti-intellectual, science denying rhetoric on the general populace by taking advantage of people’s strong, deeply held religious beliefs. Science has immensely benefited society and saved countless lives, but all this collective knowledge we have gained is useless if people refuse to accept its validity. We can see the consequences of science denial with how the anti-vax movement has gained traction, and is actively causing people harm because they don’t trust the science behind vaccinations. Mixing religious rhetoric with the science of evolution unnecessarily muddies the waters when there clearly is no need for the two to be in conflict, and we should be careful to keep the two arguments separate.


r/DebateEvolution • • 3d ago

Question Why does the scientific community act as a cult when it comes to evolution theory?

0 Upvotes

I have watched the bacterium flagellum saga on Youtube, where a scientist named Michael Behe claimed that the flagellum is built from integrated parts, which poses a challenge for Evolutionary scenario of gradual incremental change.

Now what I found to be disturbing, is that the scientific community instead of facing the challenge honestly and accept its merit, chose to do politics and cheap PR, gaslighting, deflecting, denying, providing fake proofs etc.

Till this day, they cannot bring themself to admit that they indeed don't know how a flagellum could have evolved, and they are completely unfazed by that, and even blatantly lie to your face that they do know.

They issued a bunch of peer reviewed papers that claim to explain the evolutionary pathway, when in reality they don't, but it's enough for them to wave those around as defense. You can ask AI if any of the existing scientific papers meet the treshhold of demonstrating how the flagellum could have evolve, and it will tell you that there is no such paper or research. And I know that AI is not a perfect authority, but the thing is that nobody is, since everybody is biased, which is shame.

I find the behaviour of scientific community on this issue very disappointing.

P.S. please do not deflect this conversation to religion or any other topic, I don't care about none of that. I also don't care about Behe's personal religious beliefs, his argument against flagella stands on its own merit.

Edit: I'm not a religious person, so save your time from going after the Bible.

Edit2: i will respond to comments only if I won't get downvoted, don't want to lose karma on you here.

Edit3: people asked me what I meant by "fake proof", for example the scientists had shown that there is a simpler structure TTS3, that has some of the parts of flagellum, that serves as a needle for injection among some bacteria. Now this is not sufficient to establish an evolutionary pathway, and much more work needs to be done, but for the scientific community that was enough to proclaim that the job is done.

Edit4: i replied to a comment, and was immediately downvoted, therefore as I said, I won't be replying to any of the comments anymore.


r/DebateEvolution • • 4d ago

Discussion If evolution is so well supported by evidence, why do so many people still think it is nonsense?

11 Upvotes

Just why do they think this?


r/DebateEvolution • • 5d ago

Question If a process takes thousands or millions of years, what amount of evidence do you need to consider it observed?

23 Upvotes

A lot of people who don't believe in evolution say they do not believe that one species can become another because it hasn't been "observed" (despite the amounts of evidence we have to support it).

So what are the requirements something has to meet to be observed if it may take thousands/millions of years?

I'm assuming "observed" means closely recorded enough (whatever "enough" may be) across generations or personally watched by someone over their lifespan but if any process takes longer than that then how are we supposed to observe it?

Is it impossible for something to take thousands or millions of years to occur? If you believe the earth is young then is it impossible for any process that takes that long to eventually happen?


r/DebateEvolution • • 4d ago

Question 50ma basilsaurus fossil?

3 Upvotes

I saw a creationist bring up that they found a roughly 50 Ma fossil of Basilosaurus the other day, from the Arctic. And I'm a little confused about how we haven't properly settled the date for it yet.

I've done a bit of research, and it still seems the older date is still most favourable. Though in newer analysis's, they did find dating of dinocyst did return ages much more consistent with basilosaurus, pertaining to 41–39.1 Ma. However, my research has found that the mammalian fossils around the basilosaurid did support the older age, as did the strontium dating.

I'm not sure if this is a time thing and we need to do more dating, or if somehow the fossil shifted or the other fossils shifted, but idk if that's a bit more dramatic.

If anyone has some good answers for why this anomaly is here, that'll be cool.

*edit
Original paper: "Eocene basilosaurid whales from the La Meseta Formation, Marambio (Seymour) Island, Antarctica"


r/DebateEvolution • • 5d ago

Ramblings on Theistic Evolution

9 Upvotes

⠀1. Biological evolution is true.

⠀1.1. The laws of nature are never violated.

⠀2. If evolution is true and the laws of nature always hold, then God never intervened in the evolutionary process.

⠀2.1. If God is responsible for the evolutionary process, then he must have acted before it happened.

⠀2.2. One suggestion is that God precisely predetermined the initial conditions that would certainly lead to evolution.

⠀2.3. If the universe is non-deterministic (as standard QM strongly suggests), God couldn't have precisely predetermined the initial conditions.

⠀2.3. If the universe is non-deterministic, it is still possible for God to have produced the conditions that would probably lead to life and evolution (e.g., a very large universe with chemistry, etc). Call this "probabilistic creation."

⠀3. Some suggest God could have acted at the Big Bang so that evolution would probably come about.

⠀3.1. Either the Big Bang is the absolute beginning, or it is a transition from an infinite or timeless phase.

⠀3.2. If the Big Bang was a transition from an infinite or timeless phase, then God must have acted on the pre-existing universe in order to bring about the conditions that would one day probably lead to evolution.

⠀3.3. Acting on the natural universe to change the conditions is a violation of the laws of nature; the violation is simply relocated from evolution to the Big Bang.

⠀3.4. Some suggest the Big Bang was purely quantum; in that state, it was non-deterministic, allowing for God to influence the state of affairs without violating laws of nature.

⠀3.5. If the quantum state was non-deterministic, then changing the random outcomes would be a violation of the laws of physics, i.e., it would be changing the way the state naturally behaves. That's again relocating the violation.

⠀4. If the Big Bang was the absolute beginning of the universe, then God -- violating no law -- could have created the cosmos with the conditions that would probably lead to evolution.

⠀4.1. There is no good reason to suppose that the Big Bang was the beginning and good reasons to think it was not the beginning, e.g., the inadequacy of relativity, the primacy of quantum effects, etc.


r/DebateEvolution • • 4d ago

Discussion Why haven't any plants evolved the ability to move from spot to spot?

0 Upvotes

It seems like that would be a survival advantage. If an environment gets bad for a plant, the plant just dies, whereas if they could change their spot, they could move to a different environment.


r/DebateEvolution • • 4d ago

Self generated life

0 Upvotes

Here's what I conclude:" It takes at least millions of processes or systems to operate simultaneously for life to be sustainable. The odds of each system originating by chance are mathematically impossible. When you couple them all together the odds surpass 1 in all the atoms in the universe. Thus to even begin to believe in self generated life to the smallest degree is insanity!"

By me.


r/DebateEvolution • • 6d ago

Discussion An Evolutionary Game Theory Perspective on Apologetics Strategy and Adoption using Lotka-Volterra Predator Prey Model

25 Upvotes

( TL;DR: Creationist/Dawah apologetics evolve like prey escaping predators. Whenever scientists debunk one niche, they mutate into a new field their opponents haven't studied. Having lost on biology and anthropology (90s–00s), scriptural science (00s–10s), and morality (10s–15s), they now hide behind philosophy jargons to bluff empiricists, while continuously misapplying basic philosophy terms and quote-mining pro-evolution scholars in the process. Once more critics with cross-disciplinary math/philosophy fluency call their bluff, they'll likely mutate again. Prediction on next stop: consciousness and neuroscience. )

If you spend enough time watching modern anti-evolution debates or debating creationists yourselves, especially the recent wave coming out of the Dawah apologetics sphere (like Subboor Ahmad and Hamza Tzortzis’ recent Islam21c podcast on abandoning "Muslim Darwinism"), something hilarious can be seen. Apologetic arguments themselves undergo frequency-dependent selection. Suppose we're predators while they're the preys in this model.

As critic populations (predators) saturate a niche and drive down the fitness of an argument, the apologists (prey) don't go extinct but undergo a cyclical population rebound by migrating into a unguarded academic field. Whenever empirical biologists and mathematicians close off one ecological niche by exposing their misinformation, the apologetic strategy just mutates its signaling strategy to exploit whatever field they assume their opponent hasn't studied, instead of admitting defeat.

Nowadays, whenever you try to bring empirical and concrete biological evidence for theory of evolution, they'd immediately jump to philosophy of science and abstract epistemology, throwing away terms like underdetermination, instrumentalism, methodological naturalism, the Münchhausen trilemma, likelihoodism, modal contingency etc. Caveat is that it often works on most of the people and biologists because most biologists are not trained in abstract philosophy and hence can't come up with an immediate answer, making them go silent often and overwhelm the opposition with such abstraction.

In asymmetric signaling games, a low-cost mimicry strategy of a prey thrives as long as the predator (empirical scientists in this case) can't easily distinguish real academic rigor from bluffing. Over the last 30 years, anti-evolution rhetoric has gone through like about four distinct adaptive radiations:

Epoch 1— Direct Empirical Denial (1990s–2000s): Attacks the physical data head-on (no transitional fossils, irreducible complexity, young earth) or just misinterpret the empirical data or cherry pick. It ceased to be ESS (Evolutionary Stable Strategy) after genomics, ERV mapping, and Chromosome 2 fusion made direct biological denial suicidal. Even casual YouTube skeptics memorized the rebuttals, driving the fitness payoff of this strategy towards zero as time passes by. Michael Behe getting smothered in 2005 Dover trial was the final nail to the coffin.

Epoch 2— Scriptural Concordism (2000-2010s): Claims ancient texts miraculously predicted modern embryology, cosmology, quantum mechanics, and genetics. Critics applied the exact same literalist hermeneutics to expose blatant scientific errors in those texts. The strategy became a liability.

Epoch 3— Morality (2010-2015s): Tries to claim moral high ground. But as soon as critics used empirical data to show that atheist countries have lower crime rates than so called religious countries and explained morality using biology & evolution, this temporary ESS also died out.

Epoch 4— Weaponized Philosophy of Science (2015–Present): As you can see, they abandoned biology entirely to hide behind philosophical jargons as their apologist leaders taught them. But this is almost like a poker bluff that depends entirely on whether the person they're debating against is knowledgeable on philosophy and mathematics. So the moment the opposition turns out to be proficient in mathematics, philosophy, and deduction, their payoff becomes highly negative (evident when I debated them and they went totally silent after getting exposed on misapplying or messing up basic philosophy and logic terms). Once people fluent in both quantitative biology and formal logic/meta-ethics start policing these threads, the mimicry collapses immediately. Thus predators just have to adopt to cross-disciplinary skills to catch the bluffs and prevent misinformation from spreading.

Because their followers blindly parrot talking points from podcasts without ever opening an actual textbook or peer-reviewed journal, they routinely commit massive category errors and straight-up invent fake scholarly consensuses. Here are the top four I just ran into:

  1. They love claiming that science is a dogmatic religion that blindly assumes non-material things don't exist. Apparently, nobody told them that mathematicians, theoretical computer scientists, and physicists routinely study abstract, non-material entities (algorithms, proofs, information structures) without mass or spatial coordinates. Just a classical conflating methodological naturalism with metaphysical naturalism. Some even thinks that deduction is superior to induction.

  2. One person tried to argue that metaphysical naturalism fails the problem of contingency because without a libertarian free-will creator, naturalists end up with modal collapse. Anyone who has actually read modal metaphysics knows that modal collapse is a notorious headache for classical theists (specifically regarding Divine Simplicity), not physicalists. They literally grabbed a weapon built to attack their own theology and swung it at naturalism, assuming the empiricist would have zero clue about this terminology.

  3. They often claim "it's now the consensus among atheist philosophers that moral statements are neither true nor false, just tools for manipulation." A 30-second check of the PhilPapers Survey proves the exact opposite. A substantial majority of academic philosophers (the vast majority of whom are atheists) lean toward moral realism, not non-cognitivism. They literally fabricate statistics to dodge ethical critiques, like what the heck?

  4. Another fake academic consensus they invented when cornered on mathematical impossibility of human genetic diversity originating from a literal breeding pair (N_e=2) is "science is tentative and biologists now accept the bottleneck hypothesis is false." In reality, recent literature (e.g., Hu et al. 2023; Terhorst 2024; Cousins & Durvasula 2025; Zhou et al. 2026) is debating the exact magnitude and statistical modeling of Pleistocene bottlenecks, not whether bottlenecks occurred, and certainly never validating a two-person origin. And they still don't know the simple difference between census size and effective population size.

So they always are following a pattern: they just selectively pick up paper titles, quotes, and claims and then make a sweeping generalized claim to convince the audience that academics are fighting with each other. Just like they did with Elliott Sober to claim that world's reknown philosopher thinks evolution is weak when he actually strongly supports common ancestry (he later called Subboor out for misrepresenting his works in skydivephil's channel's video interview), or with Denis Noble to claim that modern synthesis is collapsing as well as evolution, when Noble is a pro-evolutionist himself just debating the mechanisms, or with Mariuscz Tabaczek to claim that world's reknown academic theologian is using Aristotelian Metaphysics to debunk evolution when Tabaczek actually accepts evolution himself.

Seriously, if your religion is really the truth, you won't need to misrepresent academic sources to the public. It'd stand on its own. Nor you'd be giving speeches in public but rather write articles for non-predatory journal publications. But let alone biology journals, they can't even publish their thesis on theology and philosophy journals and we know why.

Now Epoch 4 will also begin to rapidly lose its protective camouflage and evolutionary advantage soon as more actual philosophers and mathematicians face their nonsense. My guess is that their new strategy in Epoch 5 will shift towards consciousness, neuroscience and panpsychism. Whether apologetic population will converge to zero depends on how much they lose their population to rationalism after some of those people seeing the overwhelming evidences and dishonest tactics relative to birth rates of apologetic population. But it's definitely not a simple cauchy sequence convergence to zero because A_n > 0.


r/DebateEvolution • • 5d ago

Discussion The common ancestors of human and chimpanzees could still exist today.

0 Upvotes

Yes, it could still exist today if it didn't go extinct. Evolution doesn't actually require it to have gone extinct, that is just how things happened.


r/DebateEvolution • • 7d ago

Discussion Darwinists can't even explain how salt crystals form

155 Upvotes

It's simple math. Consider a typical salt crystal like you'd find in a salt shaker. It has a mass of about 0.1mg, and around 2x1018 ions in all arranged in a face-centered cubic lattice. If we round that down to 1e18 the cube root is 106, so we can model a single salt crystal as a lattice of Na and Cl ions with edge lengths of about a million ions.

Let's simplify the calculation, but notice that all of these simplifications are done in the direction that would make crystal formation more likely:

  • Assume that the only things that exist in the universe are Na and Cl ions, nothing else that could disrupt crystal formation.

  • Assume that these exist in a perfect 1:1 ratio, as would be required for a salt crystal.

  • Select 1e18 ions randomly. By the earlier assumption means we'll have the correct number of each, a ridiculously lenient assumption.

  • Assume that by pure chance those ions are arranged in a cubic lattice. It's hard to express just how lenient an assumption this is, given the infinitely many ways those ions could be arranged.

The number of ways to arrange 1018 ions, half Na and half Cl, is unimaginably huge, even when we treat all the Na ions as interchangeable and the same for the Cl ions. You can check this with a statistics calculator but the number of unique permutations is on the order of a staggering 101018 , a number with hundreds of quadrillions of digits!

To believe that a salt crystal could form by natural random processes is nothing but the pure arrogance of atheists who will grasp at anything to avoid believing in God.



/S of course, but all those creationist arguments that multiply big numbers together and then marvel at how improbable something is are making the same mistake. What they're attempting to model, whether they understand enough to realize it or not, is based on transparently bogus assumptions, so the numbers they calculate are entirely meaningless.


r/DebateEvolution • • 7d ago

Requesting Advice on Good Resources

8 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I hope this is an acceptable type of post for this subreddit. I've found a lot of good information and resources from posts here, and was hoping to get some help in that area.

Some quick background on me: I was raised (and homeschooled) in a YEC household and community. I've since done a lot of learning, and am now a firm believer in evolution.

I've been doing a lot of reading and learning on different topics related to evolution. However, I'm looking for good resources on a few specific topics, mostly as counterpoints to some common YEC talking points that I learned growing up. Those topics are:

  1. The bird vs lizard-hipped dinosaurs. I know from some passing mentions in other books that the "bird" and "lizard" hip designations are outdated misnomers. But I'd like a resource that provides a detailed discussion of why that is and how we can see the "lizard-hipped" dinosaurs evolving into birds.

  2. A common talking point I saw growing up was along the lines of "Scientists rely on radiometric dating, but we used xyz dating method on the rocks from Mt St Helens (for instance) and got this crazy result that disproves the whole theory." I'd love a resource that covers what the YECs were doing and where they went wrong in the examples they use for these arguments.

  3. In school, I read several books (with titles like "Refuting Evolution" or "Evolution: The Grand Experiment"), which were focused on trying to argue against Evolution. Looking back, these books were filled with fallacies and bad arguments, but I liked the format. I'd be interested in a book of the same type, but arguing for evolution/against YEC beliefs. I've seen the following books mentioned, but they all seem a bit old (admittedly, I don't know if that would be as much of an issue in this instance as it usually is for scientific literature, given that YEC arguments probably haven't progressed much since these books were published). Does anyone know if they're still worthwhile reads?

    • The Counter-Creationism Handbook (2005)

    • Why Evolution Works (and Creationism Fails) (2009)

    • The Evidence for Evolution (2011)

    • Why Evolution Is True (2009)

    • The Greatest Show on Earth (2009) - I do intend to read this one. I've already read some other books by Richard Dawkins, and have greatly enjoyed them.

    • Science and Earth History: The Evolution/Creation Controversy (1987)

    • Creationism's Trojan Horse (2004, 2007)

Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!


r/DebateEvolution • • 7d ago

Discussion I went down an Edmontosaurus collagen rabbit hole

11 Upvotes

I was briefly debating with some YEC on facebook who claimed to have personally found non or partially permineralized dinosaur remains from the Morison formation. Though I had asked if such remains were known in the literature because to my knowledge, aside from obvious amber fossils, Mesozoic dinosaur remains are completely permineralized. Though, he had seemingly cited this unrelated paper here (unrelated because the actual skeletal material is permineralized) https://pubs.acs.org/ancham/article/97/5/2618/3607084/Evidence-for-Endogenous-Collagen-in-Edmontosaurus

And yes, I am aware dinosaur collagen isn’t unheard of. It has been known about since the 1960s.

One of the 7 authors, Steve Taylor, is an Electrical Engineer who does work for Answers in Genesis while the lead author is Lucien Tuinstra. Who had actually published this paper for preprint in 2023 but who also didn’t get his phd in paleoproteinomics until May of 2026. The paper was published in 2025 and his phd Thesis was actually on this SAME specimen which I was able to find here. https://livrepository.liverpool.ac.uk/3197969/1/201452939_Dec2025.pdf

I had backtracked on this hypothesis based on Joel Duff’s videos on this paper. However, I had originally thought that this was a Mark Armitage situation (where he misidentified a Bison horn for a Triceratops horn). After all this is not published in a paper that necessarily has anything to do with paleontology, it’s a secular chemistry paper. Furthermore, I had noticed that this Edmontosaurus material (UOL GEO.1) at first glance looks similar the pubis and ischium of a mastodon https://valleyofthemastodon.wordpress.com/2016/02/05/fossil-friday-mastodon-pelvis/

Why did I look at mastodon? Well because the paper discusses that,
“Supplementary Table S3 lists a total of at least 41 discovered collagen sequences from UOL GEO.1. It also lists PTMs for the first eight accessions and refers to the raw data (login details are on page 1 of the Supporting Information. See also Figure S4 caption). These matched a mixture of extant and extinct fauna found in the SwissProt database. The most abundant of these matched peptides were from domestic chicken (Gallus gallus), followed by American mastodon (Mammut americanum). In addition, peptides from other proteins were detected in the Edmontosaurus sample. Over a hundred actin peptides were found. Furthermore, 61 hemoglobin, 158 histone, and 92 tubulin peptides were also detected…

Several sequences, including those from chicken (Gallus gallus) and dog (Canis lupus familiaris), returned sequence identity scores at least as high as hadrosaur (Brachylophosaurus canadensis). The question arises as to whether such results indicate contamination. Modern humans of course associate with chicken and dog, but not likely with rat (Rattus norvegicus) and not at all with mastodon (Mammut americanum), both of which also scored higher than B. canadensis. Since it is not possible for mastodon sequence to have entered the analysis stream via modern contamination, then alternate explanations for it and accompanying taxa should be sought.”

Despite the paper insisting contamination to be unlikely, contamination was brought up as a possibility for the collagen of this specimen in this article https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12291109/

What is everyone’s thoughts about this paper specifically? To me the collagen being similar to the American mastodon seems unlikely though I guess not impossible. After all bat and whale proteins involved in echolocation are identical. Though, is my alternative identification for this fossil at all likely or is this more likely to be actual Edmontosaurus material? I am of course not a trained expert so I want the opinion of others, hopefully somebody actually qualified to compare the anatomy.

I’m currently assuming it is Edmontosaurus material with original collagen just from the fact that the amount of collagen in the bone is very negligible compared to that of a modern turkey and bison as the paper showed in table 2. As we would expect from ancient collagen found in an ancient dinosaur. If it was a mastodon bone I would think it would have more collagen in it.


r/DebateEvolution • • 6d ago

Question Will human evolution be broken from now on?

0 Upvotes

For most of human history, evolution was driven by natural selection. People who were better adapted to their environment were more likely to survive and reproduce, while those who weren’t adapted were less likely to pass on their genes.

For example, humans gradually developed traits that helped them survive in different climates. Cooperation is another example: humans are highly social and cooperative, probably because individuals who were better at cooperating had better chances of survival back then.

But nowadays, many of these selection “criteria” have been significantly reduced or even eliminated. Modern medicine, technology and social structures allow people to survive and reproduce regardless of many traits that would have put their ancestors at a disadvantage.

Does this mean natural selection is becoming less effective? Could it even lead to some kind of evolutionary regression over generations?

There’s also the demographic aspect. Developed countries tend to have much lower birth rates, while many developing countries have significantly higher ones. Could these differences influence the direction of human evolution over the coming centuries?

I’m curious about where human evolution is heading. Are we entering an era where evolution becomes increasingly artificial, driven by genetic engineering and technology rather than natural selection? Or will natural selection simply continue, but under completely different rules?

What’s your opinion on this?


r/DebateEvolution • • 8d ago

Theoretical Assumption:Words are simply mathematical formulas for human reasoning and understanding.

0 Upvotes

The survival instinct seeks to understand, this gives us evolutionary knowledge and intelligence. The ability to learn. however those words meanings change and drift as the pass between minds same concept different viewpoints attached but still one formula it's only true meaning the shared understanding in the group who speaks it to each other shared understanding of the same words builds trust. Earliest writings in early community groups generally were just basic resource tracking eventually arguments led to written laws the community could agree upon to live by. power in some words inflated granting authority others remained more neutral and common. Bread makers became kings who claimed divine right to rule and speak for the gods this lead to wars, Religious conquests and struggles for power over the communities that led to toppled governments and new laws. But written words were still treaded as sacred as they represented faith and trust in the community while growing power and sacred dogmas continued to concentrate wealth and power in specific groups making it hard to trust rulers do to word inflation.


r/DebateEvolution • • 9d ago

Nucleobases found in asteroid

43 Upvotes

On the abiogenesis front, the asteroid Ryugu has been confirmed to contain all five primary nucleobases that form DnA and RnA! Super exciting research! We all know that abiogenesis is a separate field of study than evolutionary biology, but I feel this is relevant for people who are questioning the origins of life.


r/DebateEvolution • • 9d ago

Question Abiogenesis question

13 Upvotes

Hey all!

Yes, I know they're different. 😉 I'm just trying to get a feel for the broader communities' thoughts on the matter.

So I know that we can make pretty much every biomolecule we need for life right now in primordial conditions, and as we have seen there appears to be plenty of biomolecules or biomolecular precursors in extraterrestrial environments (I'm breezing through this, although its all wildly cool).

I also know that we have baseline membranes that can form, and we have protocells that can form (I'm not that familiar on those), and we have rudimentary cells that can form like spudcells.

I think where I trip up is how those cells could survive in what would likely be a hostile environment?

Like let's imagine the most rudimentary of cells. in my mind (if the rna world is correct, and that works with everything I've read) that would have to be membrane encapsulated, self replicating rna, where the rna keeps repping and somewhat random membrane division leads to a diverse population of membrane encapsulated self replicating rnas.

I just worry cause that doesnt seem to be the most robust cell model and I think any slight change to the environment could lead to the whole thing collapsing and dying. And even the rudimentary cells that we have made show very little resilience. Granted there's nothing to compete with, but the environment doesn't care about that.

I think what would have to happen is this would have to be in an extremely stable environment that could allow for a robust cell to evolve on the peripherals of the environment, as it were. But I dont know how believable that is in primordial conditions.

I dont know, abiogenesis isn't my expertise but I'm trying to make it so. 😅 Am I missing something? What are your thoughts?

Thank you all!


r/DebateEvolution • • 8d ago

evolution 2.0

0 Upvotes

i am reading evolution 2.0 by Perry Marshall and I have gotten to the part where he states that generations of fruit flies went through radiation and none of them adapted but rather had a bunch of mutations that were not helpful like legs sticking out of their head. he claims this helps disprove the idea that evolution is random because his overall claim in the book is that evolution exists with a creator (god)


r/DebateEvolution • • 8d ago

Question Question about the Multiverse/anthropic selection theory

0 Upvotes

If there are countless universes, and we necessarily find ourselves in one where the fundamental "knobs" are fine-tuned to allow for human consciousness, doesn't that also imply the existence of countless other universes where those "knobs" are slightly different? Not different enough to make consciousness impossible, but enough to make life increasingly more miserable—for example, where we evolve to have constant pain, or we are ugly, or we are all way more subject to depression and suicidal tendencies due to the absence of such thing as fine-tuning.

In other words, is this true? Cause if it is we are impossibly lucky not only to exist in a life-permitting universe, but to exist in a beautiful one, which persuades me to think that in this case, the theory undermines itself. It is illogical to me to think that there were so many universes which would be living hell and I just randomly ended up in one in a thousand where it's not.


r/DebateEvolution • • 10d ago

Question Curiosity question- How do 2 species become distinct?

12 Upvotes

I understand that one thing that makes 2 species distinct is their inability to breed and produce fertile offspring. But at what point do two individuals have enough genetic variation to be different species? In generation A, two individuals have very little difference. By generation K, they have slightly different genetics but are still fully able to have fertile offspring. Same thing at generation L. But then at generation M, they can't? I don't understand what is happening between generation L and M that causes the inability to have fertile offspring? Thanks!


r/DebateEvolution • • 11d ago

Discussion If Science Is Wrong, How Would We Ever Know the Truth?

11 Upvotes

If you reject scientific evidence, like the evidence that humans evolved from a common ancestor with other apes, then what would actually be required for us to know the truth? How would we go about figuring it out? And if your answer is that it's impossible for humans to ever know, how can you be certain of that? How do you distinguish between something we genuinely cannot discover and something we simply haven't figured out yet? At what point does "we don't know" become "we can never know," and what evidence justifies drawing that line?