r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 02 '24

The militant atheists here might be doing more harm than good...

38 Upvotes

I am assuming that the primary goal of the "evolutionists" (aka realists) here is to, well, convince creationists that they are, in fact, wrong about creationism vs evolution. I know that's why I'm here.

And I know that a not insignificant fraction of the folks here are atheists, which is 100% fine. I am a theist myself, but I do not in any way insist that others also be so.

But a fraction of the atheists here get... really dismissive, insulting, and/or flat out rude about the mere concept of a Creator. I take absolutely no issue with the folks who say things like "You talk about there not being enough proof of evolution, but where's the proof of your God?" or whatever, ie the ones saying that there is no reasonable scientific reason to insist on a Creator as a causal agent. I'm talking about the ones who dump on religion/God/the concept of faith in addition to or aside from whatever actual factual point or whatever they're trying to argue (eg "And so that's how the eye probably evolved. And by the way, religion is dumb.")

The problem is... if you tell people things that basically boil down to "You can either accept evolution or believe in God, not both", some of them... are going to reject evolution because believing in God is more important to them.

So, while I entirely understand the desire to fire back when someone is being insulting or whatever, could y'all please try to refrain from snapping out insults about the mere concept of a Divine Being or whatever when not actually provoked? I know I'm not the only theist here arguing on the evolution side, and it's really, really annoying when someone, eg, tries to claim that we can't actually be decent scientists while holding any sort of religious beliefs.

Edit: perhaps I should have used the term "anti-theist" instead of "militant atheist". Too late now...

Edit the second: I am not a creationist. I am not defending creationists. If you start tearing apart the bad arguments of creationists, I will be right there with you (though I will try to be polite about it at least as long as they are). I fully accept evolution, abiogenesis, the Big Bang, and all the rest. Really. Not a creationist.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 15 '26

Discussion I am a creationist. AMA.

97 Upvotes

This sub looks like an evolutionary echo chamber so I thought you guys would like to talk to someone who doesn't affirm your beliefs. AMA.

Edit: Have some patience. I can't write small essays to a 100 people at the same time. And I will type in stages since I don't want to make a billion arguments in one reply.

Edit 2: I am replying to your comments. But people piling up after each of my replies to share their profound opinion on my level of mental retardation for not replying within 10 minutes and people downvoting my replies into oblivion hides them. I will not continue typing since no one is reading the small essays I am writing and the ones who see them don't seem to engage fairly or even engage at all. I am trying to find my own reply to see the replies to it and I can't find it among all the replies telling me to reply already or just take me for stupid for disagreeing with them. Fair to say that I see why creationists don't come to this sub often.


r/DebateEvolution • • Mar 19 '24

Question What’s the point of this sub if non-evolution based ideas are downvoted into oblivion?

4 Upvotes

I believe in evolution (if it matters) but saw the sub to see different viewpoints. It’s obvious that the average Redditor more Liberal / Evolution based, but was bummed out to see any other debating opinion either downvoted to oblivion, or 29 people arguing against 1 that they’re daft.

So if anyone that has interest to question the status quo gets basically squelched, why have this sub?

edit: already being downvoted into oblivion

edit2: thanks for debating with me today, but I’m all out of time


r/DebateEvolution • • Oct 27 '24

I'm looking into evolutionist responses to intelligent design...

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone, this is my first time posting to this community, and I thought I should start out asking for feedback. I'm a Young Earth Creationist, but I recently began looking into arguments for intelligent design from the ID websites. I understand that there is a lot of controversy over the age of the earth, it seems like a good case can be made both for and against a young earth. I am mystified as to how anyone can reject the intelligent design arguments though. So since I'm new to ID, I just finished reading this introduction to their arguments:

https://www.discovery.org/a/25274/

I'm not a scientist by any means, so I thought it would be best to start if I asked you all for your thoughts in response to an introductory article. What I'm trying to find out, is how it is possible for people to reject intelligent design. These arguments seem so convincing to me, that I'm inclined to call intelligent design a scientific fact. But I'm new to all this. I'm trying to learn why anyone would reject these arguments, and I appreciate any responses that I may get. Thank you all in advance.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jun 25 '24

Discussion Evolution makes no sense!

0 Upvotes

I'm a Christian who doesn't believe in the concept of evolution, but I'm open to the idea of it, but I just can't wrap my head around it, but I want to understand it. What I don't understand is how on earth a fish cam evolve into an amphibian, then into mammals into monkeys into Humans. How? How is a fishes gene pool expansive enough to change so rapidly, I mean, i get that it's over millions of years, but surely there' a line drawn. Like, a lion and a tiger can mate and reproduce, but a lion and a dog couldn't, because their biology just doesn't allow them to reproduce and thus evolve new species. A dog can come in all shapes and sizes, but it can't grow wings, it's gene pools isn't large enough to grow wings. I'm open to hearing explanations for these doubts of mine, in fact I want to, but just keep in mind I'm not attacking evolution, i just wanna understand it.


r/DebateEvolution • • Mar 11 '24

Question What will humans evolve into next?

0 Upvotes

If you believe, which most of you do, that humans, as they stand today, evolved from an ape like ancestor, referred to as (hominins) from 6 million years ago, according to the Smithsonian Institute, what do you estimate humans will evolve into in another 6 million years or any time in the distant or near future.

("There is no way of knowing what humans will evolve into" is not an acceptable answer. This is an exercise in theorizing about the theory of evolution, from the time scale, to the whole idea behind it all. If evolution is true, real, and as abundant as some claim, you should be able to confidently theorize about it's future capabilities)


r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 21 '24

Discussion I am not skeptical of the process of evolution but the overall conclusion made from it.

2 Upvotes

I’d like to start by saying I am not out to intellectually one up anyone. If anyone is getting one uped today, its probably me in the comments section.

What I understand is that we do see evolutionary processes carry out today. We can go look at many organisms actually that we know have already changed to some degree.

To my understanding however a question remains as to the “randomness” of evolution and also why it should mean a land animal became a whale etc and not just that various versions of organisms exist so that they can still exist, because if they didn’t, the environment would not permit the existence.

Something I will often see in life is that people attribute things to “randomness” when it is not fully understood. The more something is understood, the less random it becomes.

Overall though 2 conundrums come up for me here.

  1. How do we know animal A came from animal B?

To my understanding here the accepted reason is that we only see certain organisms at certain depths in the fossil record which would assign them to a certain time period.

But how do we know that layering is even consistent? Have we also dug up enough everywhere to establish this uniformity of the geological record is the same everywhere? If earth started with some version of everything, would we even see anything different in the record?

Take this discovery of Chimp fossils back in 2005 which showed chimps 500k years ago:

https://www.livescience.com/9326-chimp-fossils.html

Now this might sound crazy but is there even enough time here to even expect all these organisms to gradually change?

The first organisms pop up 3.7B years ago. If humans came from chimps, then 500k years old is just what we happened to find. If anything I would think we can push chimps back further. But maybe it takes 500k years to get something new and unique. If that were the case you would have only 7,400 periods per say for these jumps to happen from those first organisms to what is around today.

But even mammals in general don’t show up until 225M years ago. This gives you 450 periods. Its probably less than that for both as it seems to take longer than 500k years to get something new.

So how are we to expect evolution alone through gradual incredibly slow change to account for the diversity of life on this closed time table?

Then its like, did humans even come from chimps at all and have they just been saying that because it looked convenient at the time. Then if thats the case, how much is really assumed just out of convenience?

Basically how do we know what effectively evolved from what besides assuming everything evolved and working backwards off this to make a tree. The tree being built off visible and genetic commonalities?

2. How isn’t evolution purposeful if not in a way guided?

Oftentimes I will hear in a lecture or video that x animal has these features because it helps them do xyz. Or water animals found the water scarce for food, so they just up and evolved to be on land where they could obtain food. Then went back into the water from land because the food scarcity. I had heard this in relation to whales and the reason being because of the hip bones. But then I learned that we know the hip bones actually have a sexual function and are not just a leftover vestige. That circles back to not knowing something being attributed to randomness.

If all these organisms just so happen to be propagating because their genes somehow know what to throw out and keep with these favored genes being passed on over and over. How is this not seemingly directed in some way, being less random and more purposeful?

Today we are able to actively change everything. Ourselves, our environment, plants and animals. Humans will “select” features and keep people alive that otherwise wouldn’t be alive to pass on their genes. How do we know early intelligences didn’t do this as well?

I understand that the gene dice roll to a newly birthed organism is random right? But if the dice keep coming up with similar numbers, at what point do we say the dice are loaded?

I look forward to your comments, thanks


r/DebateEvolution • • Dec 16 '23

Question If life were discovered that were genetically 60% similar to humans on a distant planet would you doubt evolution?(question I saw elsewhere)

1 Upvotes

EDIT: I'm speaking sequence homology. 60% homology would put you somewhere in the territory of animals. For all the people telling me that humans share 60% of our DNA with a banana, I hate to break this to you, but your high school biology teacher was wrong.

EDIT 2: Because this keeps getting brought up, sharing DNA and 60% homology are not the same thing, stop conflating them.

EDIT 3: I'm turning off reply notifications to this post. Was hoping for thoughtful answers, which I received several of, but the majority have been kneejerk, dismissive, more often than not contained factual innacuracies, and were often just answering a different question. Consider if you're the best person to discuss facts on evolution. Feel free to comment, but you speaking into the void at this point.

I saw a similar question elsewhere and was curious to see what people on here would think. Most people said this wouldn't challenge evolution, and many doubled down and said this would strengthen the theory. I don't know though, I think this hypothetical would actually make me question evolution (or at least universal common ancestry). Would there be convergent evolution with life on earth and life on another planet? Most likely, but there's no reason it would be genetically similar. Life would most likely evolve it's own genetic code on a different planet, so the idea that DNA might being largely homologous makes no sense among other things.also, I'm making no attempt to say the theory of evolution is wrong. think it's so well supported that the proposition of my post (that DNA on a different planet is 60% homologous to humans) won't ever be observed.


r/DebateEvolution • • May 09 '24

Why this never ends... team rosters.

1 Upvotes

If there's one thing we on the science side like to do it's make categories and sort things. :)

Here's the problem with this entire debate...

Our Team:

"TEACHER" -- People who want to educate and provide information thinking that proper info will convince opponent

"TORCHER" -- People who are sick of the opponents and just want to hurl insults

"TRAFFIC COP" -- People who police the language to be "more precise" which causes confusion among the uninformed. (see: "Well, actually... it's not that we descended from apes, we are apes, therefore evolution is correct."

Their Team:

"FANATIC" -- People with an ideological opposition to both the correct and incorrect information about biology.

"TEEN" -- People who've just been introduced to either side and have legit questions.

"CROOK" -- People who push creationism for financial reasons but know it's incorrect.

So, what happens when we have debates

Teacher vs Teen = Ideal situation, potential to educate.

Teacher vs Fanatic = Waste of time, fun for fanatic

Teacher vs Crook = Waste of time, chance for crook to gain audience

Torcher vs Teen = Worst situation, potential to drive them to the other side

Torcher vs Fanatic = Waste of time, fun for both

Torcher vs Crook = Waste of time, chance for crook to gain audience

Traffic Cop vs Teen = Inevitable confusion, potential to drive away, very very small potential to educate.

Traffic Cop vs Fanatc = Waste of Time

Traffic Cop vs Crook = Waste of time, chance for crook to gain audience

So, as you can see, of all the scenarios, there's only one which is truly beneficial to our side, and 2/3 of our side would run that one scenario by jumping in and acting the way they (we) do.

I get it. You get fed up with educating and turn torcher. I did.

I also get it, you want to seem smart so you police everyone's language.

But none of this is working us toward and end goal


r/DebateEvolution • • Nov 28 '24

Discussion I'm a theologian ― ask me anything

9 Upvotes

Hello, my name is David. I studied Christian theology propaedeutic studies, as well as undergraduate studies. For the past two years, I have been doing apologetics or rational defence of the Christian faith on social media, and conservative Christian activism in real life. Object to me in any way you can, concerning the topic of the subreddit, or ask me any question.


r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 03 '26

Discussion Turns out I was wrong.(INTELLIGENT DESIGN GONE WRONG!!!!)

0 Upvotes

Yeah, after researching about how corn couldn’t have evolved, I read an article that said corn is a domesticated plant, whose wild ancestor is drastically different.

It doesn’t have a cylindrical shape and it’s much smaller, with only a few kernels per plant.

I thought the evolutionists who told me it was domesticated were scrambling to find an answer to my challenge, but it was me who was wrong.

You can’t make savory, buttery popcorn with it or anything that modern corn can.

Which brings to me to admit……this was just a goof.

I knew corn was domesticated, microevolved not macro though , and experienced mutations that changed its anatomy, but it didn’t provide new genetic information.

Anyways, let’s move on from corn, no need to bash a joke.

Stay fine tuned for intelligent design posts in the future.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 03 '26

Question What is one thing that, if proven, would instantly disprove the theory of evolution?

2 Upvotes

I think this is a great way to create new experiments and tests on the subject


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 21 '26

Question Does anyone else struggle with believing the very beginning of evolution?

0 Upvotes

I’m pretty convinced by evolution after a point… like monkeys to humans, deer to giraffes adapting over time through natural selection. That part makes sense to me.

But what I can’t fully wrap my head around is the jump from simple bacteria to complex organisms.

Things like the digestive system, kidneys, heart, the way organs are so organized, male and female systems working together to reproduce, all of that feels… extremely intricate. Sometimes it’s hard for me to believe it all came together purely by chance and natural selection.

At the same time, I don’t believe in religion either, so the “created by God” explanation doesn’t convince me at all.


r/DebateEvolution • • Feb 03 '24

Question Honest question for non-believers who have come to the conclusion that Evolution eliminates the existence of God.

0 Upvotes

Why is it your belief or understanding that evolution and God are incompatiblel? I am honestly searching for information and understanding. I do not have extensive knowledge on evolution in general or as an explanation of the origin of mankind. I personally have not heard of any scientific evidence that eliminates the possibility of God.

Can evolution explain the existence of consciousness, or spirit?


r/DebateEvolution • • Mar 07 '26

Does evolution contradict the bible

1 Upvotes

I do not think evolution contradicts the Bible


r/DebateEvolution • • Dec 31 '25

Meta Mountains prove the earth is young

0 Upvotes

As a card carrying young earther (I believe life is old and was seeded by a deity I’ll discuss in a later post) I submit the following proof.

Mountains owe their existence to two processes, orogeny, that is the deformation of earth’s crust as it compresses forcing rock upwards. The second, and we can say dominate process at least regarding time is erosion, that is the elements removing material and carrying it way providing us with topography. o

As erosion is the dominate process at work, we should expect the earth to be devoid of mountains and be perfectly flat. Thus, earth must be young as not all of the mountains are eroded.

If you disagree you can post here if you’re a cuck, or at r/liarsforlyell.

Checkmate old earthers.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jul 05 '25

Question Giants. Did they exist?

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone ,

I’m currently making this post for someone since that person can’t post on Reddit anymore. So here goes:

Could a 60 ( around 30 meters tall) cubits man from the Islamic paradigm feasibly exist on earth?

I personally disagree for a multitude of reasons ( square cube law, calorie intake, lack of evidence and so on). But he would like to hear the opinions of others

Thanks in advance


r/DebateEvolution • • Oct 15 '20

Discussion You won't get me on board with evolution soon, or atleast, not with the way you are arguing.

1 Upvotes

This is not a critique of evolutionary theory, but how you guys defend it. Could I just say your arguments for evolution are generally terrible? Not "the" arguments written in the universities that I don't understand. But your arguments. Why are your arguments terrible? I will start with this simple principle I have learned that helps me get involved in rational debates: I will not be convinced by an argument I do not understand.

You may have a logically convincing argument for evolution, but good luck convincing me, because you cannot seem to explain yourself. You may say that if I can't understand the discussion, I just need to look into it more. However, not everyone is a scientist, and you need to convince rational thinkers caught up in other fields of study that don't have time to look into every detail of this debate, and that includes me. Someone who thinks rationally will not change their mind unless they can explain to themselves why their new position is correct, and you people arguing for evolution just aren't giving me the tools.

The most effective argument against young earth creationsim is this:

"Andromeda is 2 million light-years away."

That's because it is easy for the average person to understand 100% of the facts that are being presented in this argument.

1: it takes light 1 year to travel 1 light-year. 2: andromeda is 2 million light-years away. 3: we can see andromeda.

The rest of the argument follows logically from these three facts.

But here is the least effective argument against my beliefs I hear used alot:

"Just look at the tree of life! It completely disproves the Bible."

I have often heard the tree of life described as the single biggest piece of evidence against young earth creationsim. It is not. It is a mountain of millions of different pieces of evidence that is near impossible for any single person to get an intellectual grasp on. I can't challenge it's validity because when you bring it up I can barely know what you are talking about. Before we can even talk about the tree of life, we have to deconstruct the tree of life and understand how it works on an intellectual level, and then we can discuss whether or not it is valid and disproves the Bible. You guys have it easy, you have to argue against 9 (or fewer) chapters at the very beginning of a single religious text whose literal interpretation is defended by a minority of the books believers today. You don't need to use tactics fit for deception, such as covering up your argument with a multitude of words, to bring much bigger guns then we are allowed to have access to.

So please, if you are arguing against Young Earth Creationism, make a real argument, don't just throw a million page of scientific papers at us and expect us to be convinced. We can't read all of that. Do you expect us to be convinced in an hour by an argument that will take us twelve years to fully grasp? Why do your arguments need to be so complicated?

Here's what you actually need to do to disprove Young Earth Creationism:

Prove that any specific creature in the fossil record existed before 7000 years ago.

That's all you need to do, and if you made an argument that could convince me that a specific creature was living and breathing before seven thousand years ago, I would immediately have to become something other than YEC, but arguing that the tree of life proves me wrong when you can't be bothered to point out a specific example and prove that examples validity just won't fly with me. I bet you can make a convincing argument that a specific creature was alive before 7000 years ago, you have to many tools for this task to be to difficult for you. Please, present me with a creature that lived before 7000 years ago, and then explain why we know it is that old and not younger.

As for my part, I have to prove that a specific creature claimed to go extinct millions or more years ago is actually a relatively recent inhabitant of our planet, and only if I do that can I throw the timeline into disarray.

Edit: also, please don't delete your replies. I want to go back over this post next summer to use it for assistance in research.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jul 23 '23

Discussion The deliciousness of crab makes me wonder about intelligent design

4 Upvotes

I want to say up front that I know what I’m about to say sounds ridiculous. I’ve been told by a lot of people that I must be a moron. If so, whatever. I’m just being honest.

I get how humans would evolve to find most animals delicious. Like, I eat a cow and I think it’s delicious and that makes sense. People evolved to eat things with fat and protein. That’s a cow. Pretty straightforward. Same with pigs or chicken or what have you.

But a crab? Most crabs live deep in the water where people are very unlikely to find them. We’re not really evolved to eat crabs because they’re not going to be a common food source.

And yet today I ate a very delicious Dungeness crab and it was just SO GOOD. Like, impossibly good. Like, “this thing was designed to be eaten“ good. I didn’t even need butter or anything. I just lightly steamed the crab, cracked it open, and ate it. So I’m not even like somebody could say that I’m really enjoying a sauce or butter or something.

I know this sounds silly but it’s just so hard to believe that a grand creator wasn’t involved somehow in making crabs so delicious. They’re just too good, yet too rare in the human diet.

This world is so full of delicious things to eat. They are so good. I could eat fish every day. But I don’t think humans evolved to eat fish as their primary diet. So why are they so good? Most fish isn’t even that fatty. So presumably it shouldn’t be as delicious as something like a well marbled cow. Yet I’ll take a halibut any day of the week.

I’m not rejecting the fossil record or anything. I’m just saying, there are fish and shellfish and seaweed that are so delicious that it defies explanation.


r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 28 '25

Question Why did humans evolve a larger brain if brain size correlates with intelligence only a little?

0 Upvotes

The hominins have gradually been evolving larger brains. But isn't that a bad evolutionary strategy since larger brains only help with intelligence a little and consume much more energy. Why didn't the brain just evolve to become more complex, since that is what is most important for intelligence. Isn't that more efficient?


r/DebateEvolution • • Dec 20 '23

Question How does natural selection decide that giraffes need long necks?

0 Upvotes

Apparently long necks on giraffes is an example of natural selection but how does the natural selection process know to evolve long necks?

How can random mutations know to produce proteins that will give giraffes long necks, there is a missing link I'm not understanding here and why don't the giraffes die off on the process while their necks are evolving?

At what point within the biology of a giraffe does it signal "hey you need a longer neck I'll just create some proteins that will fix that for you". It doesn't make sense to me that a biological process can just "know" out of thin air to create a longer neck?


r/DebateEvolution • • Dec 04 '20

Meta I fell in and out of love with this echo chamber of a sub.

3 Upvotes

No one who actually believes in Creationism gets any space to expose their views and truly talk about it because this has become a hostile place for them to do so.

i have thought about messaging the mods and suggest a new rating thinking, like "the more polemical, the more karma it should get so it sparks discussion, and the sub has DEBATE in its name. We should prioritize that.

It's like the top answer to an askreddit post about cops were" A friend of mine..." which is still cool and all but not the raw viewpoint I was looking for.

It would be fun to get 10 people out of this sub, that is teeming with very brilliant minds, and just for kicks split them in 2 groups, one for and the other against Creationism. If creationists can't think on their own as the majority of the posts here says, let's put our own minds at work here. If you think this means publicly giving Creationists more chance to stand their ground, and you are an Evolutionist, then just DM me and let's try and have some fun, I'll be against just for the fun of debating.

Please, if there are still any creationists on this sub, message me. I'd like to non aggressively listen to what you have to say because I want to see how that makes sense in your head and won't try to talk you out of it. Purely understand...

I hope my plea is heeded, I'm an evolutionist working on my empathy. And just a message to most people of this sub: if you want to feel you're making a difference by teaching others the most reasonable thinking you know, dont be a dick about it. That scares the people whose opinions this subs lacks so much.

edit: Creationism is not illegal to be taught in Brazil. This is a Brazilian school that teaches Creationism. I have argued with a teacher from there before and it got quite heated and in the end she ignored me because she was not that well versed in her science. So maybe that's why I say stuff like Evolutionism or have a more open approach to it. I truly believe in Charles Darwins ideas but I will not interact any further because just like the rest of reddit, most of you guys just love to prove you are right, not teach me that I am wrong. Thank you, and I regret posting this to such an aggressive community


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 24 '25

Question Can genetics change my YEC view? A serious question.

5 Upvotes

So, yesterday I posted a general challenge to those who believe in evolution. I had some good replies that I'm still planning to get to. Thanks. Others ridiculed my YEC view. I get it. But I have a really interesting question based on my studies today.

I started looking into Whale evolution today because of a new post that appeared on this subreddit. I specifically wanted to learn more about the genetic link because, quite honestly, fossils are too much of an just-so story most of the time. When I see drawings, I say, "Wow!" When I see the actual bones, "I say, where are the bones?" Anyway, I digress. I learned about converged genes, the shared Prestin gene in Hippos and cetaceans (whales, dolphins, etc.) and had a cool thought.

The idea that hippos and whales are related come from this shared Preston gene (among other genes), which enable them to hear underwater. Now, creationists simply assert that both animals were created to hear underwater using the same building blocks. So we're at a stale mate.

But it helped me to realize what could actually be evidence that my YEC worldview could not dismiss easily. I'm having a hard time putting it into words because my grasp on the whole thing seems fleeting; as if I have a clear concept or thought, and then it goes away into vagueness. I'll try to describe it but it probably won't make any sense.

If there were a neutral genetic mutation that occurred in a species millions of years ago, something that was distinct from its immediate ancestor (its parents), but it was a neutral mutation that allowed no greater or lesser benefit that resulted in equal selection rates, you would end up with a population of two groups. One with and one without the mutation.

From here, One group could evolve into whales, the other group could evolve into Hippos but I think this neutral mutation would "catch the ride" and appear equally distributed in each of the populations. This is where my mind starts to get fuzzy. Maybe someone can explain if this is possivble.

As the millions of years pass, we end up with modern animals. If this neutral genetic mutation could be found equally distributed between whales, dolphins, hippos, and other artiodactyls, which come form the pakicetus, I think that would be something to expect. Wouldn't this be much more convincing of the relationship of these animals rather than just observing Hippos and Whales share the Prestin protein?

Did that make sense?

Is there anything like that observed?

Edit: It appears I'm getting a lot of response from evolutionists that seem to think the motivation behind my question is suspect. I'm going to ignore your response. I might not understand too much but I think my inquiry is well-developed, and the seriousness of the question is self-evident. I will hope and wait for the more reasoned response from someone willing to help me.


r/DebateEvolution • • Apr 04 '22

Problems with human ancestors

1 Upvotes

I would like to point out that many of the human "ancestors" have problems that prevent them from being human ancestors:

sahelanthropus tchadensis: The problem with considering this animal a human ancestor comes from the fact that we have only found an upper skull and a few jaw pieces, the cranium of sahelanthropus seems a lot like a bonobo and so does its reconstruction:https://humanorigins.si.edu/evidence/human-fossils/species/sahelanthropus-tchadensis

Lucy(Australopithecus Afarensis): The problem with this ancestor is that it is only 40% complete. There have many other A. Afarensis bones, these are all just fragments in an area. The laetoli footprints cannot be of Lucy's for the following reasons:

  1. They were found 200 feet away from Lucy

  2. The kind of being that would make such footprints is a 6ft tall man, and Lucy is not 6ft tall.

  3. The footprints are completely human-like

Australopithecus Africanus: Almost no fossil pieces that I can find on the internet. To give it credit it has more skull evidence than Lucy: The skull has a cranium way too much like a chimp and most of the teeth look like they have been damaged.

Homo erectus: Homo erectus is an unstable taxonomic species. Homo erectus skulls often look very different from each other and some scientists are fighting to reclassify homo erectus as Australopithecus. Also a study on Aborigines showed that they have many facial features like homo erectus.

Neanderthals: These are way too humanlike to be considered a different species. Science shows that Neanderthals buried their dead, had control over fire, practiced religion, wore make up, used tools, and even mated with homo sapiens.

Basically all human ancestors fall under 2 camps:

completely ape like(Austrolepithecines)

completely human like(homo genus)


r/DebateEvolution • • Aug 05 '25

Evolution and Natural Selectioin

0 Upvotes

I think after a few debates today, I might have figured out what is being said between this word Evolution and this statement Natural Selection.

This is my take away, correct me please if I still don’t understand.

Evolution - what happens to change a living thing by mutation. No intelligence needed.

Natural Selection - Either a thing that has mutated lives or dies when living in the world after the mutation. So that the healthy living thing can then procreate and produce healthy offspring.

Am I close to understanding yet?