r/DebateEvolution • u/tamtrible • Jan 02 '24
The militant atheists here might be doing more harm than good...
I am assuming that the primary goal of the "evolutionists" (aka realists) here is to, well, convince creationists that they are, in fact, wrong about creationism vs evolution. I know that's why I'm here.
And I know that a not insignificant fraction of the folks here are atheists, which is 100% fine. I am a theist myself, but I do not in any way insist that others also be so.
But a fraction of the atheists here get... really dismissive, insulting, and/or flat out rude about the mere concept of a Creator. I take absolutely no issue with the folks who say things like "You talk about there not being enough proof of evolution, but where's the proof of your God?" or whatever, ie the ones saying that there is no reasonable scientific reason to insist on a Creator as a causal agent. I'm talking about the ones who dump on religion/God/the concept of faith in addition to or aside from whatever actual factual point or whatever they're trying to argue (eg "And so that's how the eye probably evolved. And by the way, religion is dumb.")
The problem is... if you tell people things that basically boil down to "You can either accept evolution or believe in God, not both", some of them... are going to reject evolution because believing in God is more important to them.
So, while I entirely understand the desire to fire back when someone is being insulting or whatever, could y'all please try to refrain from snapping out insults about the mere concept of a Divine Being or whatever when not actually provoked? I know I'm not the only theist here arguing on the evolution side, and it's really, really annoying when someone, eg, tries to claim that we can't actually be decent scientists while holding any sort of religious beliefs.
Edit: perhaps I should have used the term "anti-theist" instead of "militant atheist". Too late now...
Edit the second: I am not a creationist. I am not defending creationists. If you start tearing apart the bad arguments of creationists, I will be right there with you (though I will try to be polite about it at least as long as they are). I fully accept evolution, abiogenesis, the Big Bang, and all the rest. Really. Not a creationist.