r/DebateEvolution • • 9d ago

evolution 2.0

i am reading evolution 2.0 by Perry Marshall and I have gotten to the part where he states that generations of fruit flies went through radiation and none of them adapted but rather had a bunch of mutations that were not helpful like legs sticking out of their head. he claims this helps disprove the idea that evolution is random because his overall claim in the book is that evolution exists with a creator (god)

0 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

30

u/BranchLatter4294 9d ago

No one has ever claimed that evolution is random (except maybe evolution deniers).

-7

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

oh really, that's interesting because in his book he says it's completely random and that natural selection will rule out the negative adaptations and keep the positive ones. Maybe I'm reading straight propaganda, though.

33

u/BranchLatter4294 9d ago

There is a difference between mutations being random, and evolution being random.

2

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

got it thanks

14

u/Kriss3d 9d ago

Imagine a dice that each time it rolls something gets a slightly higher chance of rolling that number again. And you can make dices duplicate themselves.

Imagine rolling a billion of them and picking off any that don't roll a 6. You roll those that did again and keep removing those that don't roll 6. Once in a while. You make them duplicate to keep the amount of dices up.

You know what you're going to end with?

Dices that only roll 6.

2

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

Thanks, this is a great explanation! So the issue with the fruit fly experiment is that they haven't studied the fruit flies long enough?

3

u/ilikestatic 9d ago

It could also be that the mutations are not affecting survival one way or the other. If the mutation causes the fruit flies to die, then we’ll see that mutation disappear from the population. If a mutation causes the fruit flies to become better at survival and passing on their genes, then we’ll likely see the mutation become more prevalent in the population.

But if the mutation doesn’t change the fly’s ability to survive or pass on its genes, then we might not see any change. Like if a fruit fly with a leg sticking out of its head is not helpful or harmful to the fly’s survival, then it may still get passed on to other fruit flies anyway, because nothing is stopping the fly from passing it on.

3

u/Uncynical_Diogenes 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago edited 9d ago

There has never been an experiment that exposed successive generations of fruit flies to radiation over a decade or more to see if the lineage evolved resistance to it, full stop. (I’m pretty confident in saying this, because you should have cited it if you had one)

We actually have done that with other organisms, like the Long Term E. coli Evolution experiment, which show exactly what we predict according to Evolution AND whose results disproved Behe’s definition of Irreducible Complexity. These kinds of studies have indeed refuted creationist arguments.

That is not what is happening here. That creationist you read is lying about the experiments that have happened and is lying about the expectations that the Theory of Evolution actually predicts.

You do not seem to currently grasp the difference between long-term evolution studies and mutagenesis studies. I don’t think you can demonstrate why the latter would ever have results expected of the former.

21

u/Uncynical_Diogenes 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

Mutations are random. Selection is not.

18

u/twizzjewink 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

He wanted the answer to be God so that's what he wrote. That's not science.

-1

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

personally im an atheist but i am wondering why the fruit flies didnt evolve to form resistance to the radiation

10

u/Uncynical_Diogenes 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

Why do you think they should quickly evolve resistance to artificially high levels of radiation as encountered in fruit fly mutagenesis studies?

Because a creationist told you they should and you believed him?

2

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

not at all i was just curious as to why and was looking for someone to explain it to me im still very new to evolution so i was trying to read books about it but stumbled upon this evolution book made by a creationist

2

u/BranchLatter4294 9d ago

If you are interested in how science works and how to avoid being confused by creationists, consider reading The Demon Haunted World by Carl Sagan.

1

u/Fun_in_Space 8d ago

Reading books by people with no background in the right kind of science is a waste of time. Read book by experts who debunk those people.

1

u/junegoesaround5689 Dabbling my ToE(s) in debates 8d ago

There are a number of recommended and accurate books, websites, videos, etc about evolution in the wiki at r/evolution. See https://www.reddit.com/r/evolution/wiki/index/

It can be instructive to read/hear what creationists claim but probably not until you have enough accurate background information about evolution so you can recognize where they differ from the scientific consensus.

7

u/twizzjewink 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

Like the fungus at Chernobyl did? It literally eats radiation.

1

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

oh thanks for letting me know that i had no idea so basically the fruit flies is just one outlier example of something not producing helpful adaptations?

4

u/This-Professional-39 9d ago

More a matter of generations. You need a consistent influence over multiple generations for random resistance to develop and permeate a population. A single event on a single or very few generations isn't going to have much of an evolutionary effect

3

u/XRotNRollX You know who else evolved from an ape? MY MOM 9d ago

Evolution doesn't say "well, this is a problem, let's come up with a solution." Evolution provides a library of genes in a population so that, if the environmental pressures change, some segment of the population might still survive.

2

u/twizzjewink 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

I don't know tbh. I don't know enough about evolutionary biology or the experiment in question.

1

u/junegoesaround5689 Dabbling my ToE(s) in debates 8d ago edited 8d ago

You‘re pretty close but radiation experiments were never intended to test evolutionary theory as a whole. They had many different purposes from finding out how genes react when radiated to what compounds might mitigate against radiation damage to tissues. The antennae on the head experiments had near zero to do with any of what the book claims (as you’ve described it).

The experiments where legs grew instead of antennae a) were initially discovered in the early 20th century to even be possible by a natural mutation in a fly in a lab, b) were then induced by exposing whole populations of flies to mutagens (chemical & radiation) to get it to happen to one or two flies again and try to figure out what gene was involved, then how and why it worked that way, and c) eventually the mutation was able to be induced using modern DNA recombination (and later Crispr9 tech), with no radiation involved, in order to study the HOX genes and their control of how embryos develop body plans.

It was never an experiment testing evolutionary theory, per se.

6

u/noodlyman 9d ago

Resistance to radiation is a Big Ask. That's not to say it couldn't happen to a limited degree by improved DNA repair, but it's the sort of thing you might to see change over thousands of years, not a handful of years in the lab.

Also if you completely overwhelm the system too much by just breaking it, then it wouldn't have much change to evolve fixes.

1

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

okay i understand its just a matter of time

3

u/Unlimited_Bacon 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

It is not a matter of time so, no, you don't understand.

24

u/Indrigotheir 9d ago

Because the experiments weren't taking the survivors of the radiation and radiating them or their offspring in the next cycle of radiation.

It was radiating a different population of fruitflies every time.

If the radiation were in the natural world, if there were survivors, the survivors of the radiation would be hit by it over and over, and eventually they would develop a resistance. This could be replicated in a lab; the author just wasn't't interested.

8

u/Unlimited_Bacon 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

eventually they would develop a resistance.

To be completely clear to OP, their ancestors would develop a resistance (or go extinct if they failed to develop resistance). The surviving population isn't going to develop a resistance during their lifetime that they didn't already have when they were born.

1

u/Ayasugi-san 8d ago

their ancestors would develop a resistance

Do you mean descendants? Their ancestors are dead.

1

u/Unlimited_Bacon 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 8d ago

Their dead ancestors accumulated the mutations that lead to the surviving population having resistance.

•

u/Changed_By_Support 2h ago

Or, alternatively, the population began to have a higher prevalence of already present genetic features that develop radiation resistance in response to the high radiation exposure selecting for radiation resistance. The mutations could be entirely unrelated to the changes in genetic frequency that foster the radiation resistance.

7

u/CTR0 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

If the radiation were in the natural world, if there were survivors, the survivors of the radiation would be hit by it over and over, and eventually they would develop a resistance. This could be replicated in a lab; the author just wasn't't interested.

Observational studies of Chernobyl see this

1

u/junegoesaround5689 Dabbling my ToE(s) in debates 8d ago

I was gonna mention this. It’s a natural experiment in extreme evolutionary pressure and shows that a wide variety of organisms have evolved some resistance to the radiation contamination of the environment after the Chernobyl accident. There’s also a large increase in all sorts of cancers, tumors, reduction of lifespans, etc, but some plants and animals have and are surviving.

1

u/Ayasugi-san 9d ago

Because the experiments weren't taking the survivors of the radiation and radiating them or their offspring in the next cycle of radiation.

It was radiating a different population of fruitflies every time.

...what was the point? To disprove the creationist idea that all organisms innately have all the genetics they need to survive and are just waiting for a trigger to express them?

3

u/Indrigotheir 9d ago

I mean, there are tons of valid purposes for a study like this; how does radiation affect DNA, do drosophila have a resistance, etc etc. The author the OP refers to is just being willfully misrepresentative of the data

1

u/Ayasugi-san 9d ago

Ah. I was stuck thinking that the point of the experiment was to learn something about evolution. Wasn't considering that it was looking into something else.

3

u/Indrigotheir 9d ago

Yeah, really doubt the author is capable of doing actual science. He probably just dug through studies performed by actual scientists until he found one he could misrepresent in this way

3

u/Augustus420 9d ago

That may not even be something that's possible for animals.

If a population doesn't occasionally have members that are resistant to evolution then there's nothing for natural selection to work with.

3

u/ipreuss 9d ago

There is no guarantee that a helpful mutation is even possible. Also, many mutations happen gradually over many generations.

That’s why climate change is such a debacle - not because adaptation is impossible, but because the change is too fast for evolution to keep up, in many cases.

3

u/beardslap 9d ago

If you threw a million mice into the middle of the Pacific Ocean, would you expect any to produce offspring with gills?

2

u/evocativename 9d ago

What selection pressure would there be to cause that?

Think about how evolution works: differential reproductive success. How would resistance to radiation in this population result in more offspring?

1

u/Literally_-_Hitler 9d ago

Why would you expect them to? Humans can't do it either. 

7

u/Fun_in_Space 9d ago

Mutations are random. Natural selection is not. Even if evolution was proven wrong, that does not prove a god is real.

I just looked up Perry Marshall. He is an engineer. He has no education in any of the life sciences. He should have some if he is going to write a book about evolution.

4

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

i agree, he mentioned it in the intro of his book on why he's qualified. Something about coding exists in both DNA and engineering, but i think I'm just going to stop reading this book; it seems like it's propaganda

8

u/10coatsInAWeasel Reject pseudoscience, return to monke 🦧 9d ago

There’s an internet adage called the ‘Salem hypothesis’ and it sounds like this guy fits it to a T. In short, it’s the idea that people who claim to be scientists and are attacking evolution seem to be super likely to be engineers, not biologists or similar. Aka, the exact people who are likely to read design into things even when it doesn’t exist

4

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

oh wow i just looked into it thats very interesting thanks for letting me know!

6

u/Fun_in_Space 9d ago

Another creationist who thinks DNA is like computer code. Ridiculous.

-2

u/wellwisher-1 9d ago edited 9d ago

I am of the belief that statistics violates the laws of thermodynamics therefore its application for the science of evolution make the current model of evolution violate thermodynamics. Let me show my proof.

In thermodynamics, there are what are called State Functions and state variables. The most common are temperature, volume, pressure, free energy, entropy and enthalpy.

From Google search: A state function is a thermodynamic property whose value depends only on the current equilibrium state of a system—not on the path or history used to reach that state. A state variable is a measurable or quantifiable parameter (such as pressure, volume, or temperature) that defines that equilibrium state*.* 

State functions are a set of constants that can define the current equilibrium state of any specific state of matter, independently, of how you reach that final state. We can have two teams, one that uses random assumptions to reach that end state. The other team can do it logically from the other side, and when both reach the same final state, both teams will get the same set of equilibrium thermodynamic state constants; sharp data points, and not fuzzy dice and margins of error.

A good way to describe a state function it is like taking a snapshot still photo which stops time. If you had an active process, and we have no motion blur, everything stops in time, into unchanging places, not subject to any further change; state constants. State variables are more useful to engineers who need to make real things that can persist by obeying the laws and functions of thermodynamics.

Statistics does not deal with time the same way. With statistics we have more what could be described as a time based journey to a final state. For example, say I have a six sided dice and I can toss that dice one toss per second, it will take an average six seconds to cycle through all the six side options. If we stop time any random place, all we would get is whatever side was last thrown and that would remain constant and not change. You can not do statistics with the thermodynamic time constraint. Random mightl change sequence each pass. The idea of state constants is the same states of matter have the same set of constants. It is more logical.

This was sort of explained by the thought experiment called Schrödinger's cat. In quantum mechanics, Schrödinger's cat is a thought experiment concerning quantum superposition. In the thought experiment, a hypothetical cat inside a closed box may be considered to be simultaneously both alive and dead while it is unobserved, as a result of its fate being linked to a random subatomic event that may or may not occur. 

As long as your statistical assumptions needs time to cycle a dice in a closed box, you can pretend any number is possible on any throw. Only over a long time does it get tight. Once you open the box you immediately have the constant state predicted by thermodynamics. It can only be one way and the rest were all imaginary since they violated thermodynamic laws; rules of a game.

Water at 25C and 1 atmosphere of pressure always has a measured entropy constant of 69.97 J/mole=K. When most people define entropy, they think in terms of randomness or complexity, but in thermodynamic states, even entropy remains constant an even repeatable, since it is reflection of thermodynamic equilibrium at specific conditions.

5

u/gliptic 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 8d ago

I am of the belief that statistics violates the laws of thermodynamics

Where do you think thermodynamics comes from? Also, you seem to have forgotten to make an argument, much less a proof, of this below.

For example, say I have a six sided dice and I can toss that dice one toss per second, it will take an average six seconds to cycle through all the six side options.

This is clearly nonsense. 6 seconds is the minimum time, not any average.

As long as your statistical assumptions needs time to cycle a dice in a closed box, you can pretend any number is possible on any throw. Only over a long time does it get tight. Once you open the box you immediately have the constant state predicted by thermodynamics. It can only be one way and the rest were all imaginary since they violated thermodynamic laws; rules of a game.

This is very much not what quantum mechanics or the Schrödinger's cat thought experiment says. If you wanted to make some point about thermodynamics, why the hell did you bring up quantum mechanics? The point with the thought experiment is that the state of the cat is non-deterministic and literally unsettled until the box is opened, nothing about violating thermodynamics. You're just word waffling with no destination.

5

u/gitgud_x 🧬 🦍 GREAT APE 🦍 🧬 8d ago

statistics violates the laws of thermodynamics

Do the words "statistical mechanics" mean anything to you?

0

u/wellwisher-1 8d ago

I believe statistics math applies to the quantum state of matter, but not to the macro states of matter; chemistry and bigger.

The Heisenberg uncertainty principle states that it is impossible to simultaneously know both the exact position and the exact momentum (or speed) of a quantum particle. The more accurately we measure one of these pairs of variables, the less certain we are of the other.

According to Einstein, we or humans live in space-time where space and time are connected like two people in a three legged race. This tether of space-time adds limitation to our space-time universe, like the speed of light.

In the three legged race, the two people when racing have to reflect each other as they move, since one left leg and one right leg are tied. And the team is only as fast as the weakest link. Space-time imposes limitations called the laws of Physics and thermodynamics.

Once we reach the quantum state of matter, this tethered connection of space-time appears to break down. The position, which is a function of space and the momentum which is a function of time are no longer acting like they connected the same way, rather they now appear to behave in an inverse relationship. As one gets better, the other gets worse, and vice versa.

Now the rules of space-time do not fully apply and statistical mechanics is needed. If we cut the tether of the three legged races of space-time this would be like the two runners now able to run free style and not have to coordinate and the faster runner can win for the team, opening new options that do not exist with the tether. If I could move in space independently of time; free style, I could be omnipresent. This is a classic attribute of God. Quantum entanglement s when two quantum particles are synchronized in time independent of space.

However, the looser rules of the quantum state, do not apply to the stricter rules of space-time and macro states, since space and time remain tethered and thermodynamic limits apply. There are two separate states, and there is a cut off with each state having it own rules. Applying statistics to the macro states of life which is bound to space-time is invalid. The only value for that math is at the quantum level; electrons and photons are quantum particles. But the DNA is not. DNA does not phase in and out of time and space but is tethered to remain there to be seem with a snap shot.

I chose to model life with the concept of entropy, since entropy is the bridge between the macro and quantum states able to move energy back and forth by removing or adding the tether of space-time. With entropy net increasing over time, entropy keeps adding energy into the quantum state that is the foundation behind the macro states of life. To do evolution right we need to keep the math separate.

1

u/gitgud_x 🧬 🦍 GREAT APE 🦍 🧬 7d ago

You're conflating "quantum" with "not at equilibrium". That's all this is.

1

u/wellwisher-1 6d ago

Quantum is where time and space appear to disconnect into a different relationship and randomness appears. However, a collection of random quantum events can still be in equilibrium and definitive as a macro state.

As an example, a gas is composed umpteen particles with kinetic energy banging off each other and the walls of the container. This creates pressure. At the level of each gas molecule like N2 and O2, this is modeled with statistical mechanics, as random collisions, vibrations ands and degrees of freedom, since there are so many units to model each with many ways to express energy.

Even though this is modeled as random in the quantum state, we can maintain a constant macro state tire pressure at 35 PSI. The macro state can remain constant. Both quantum and macro are connected, but one level is random; quantum, and the other is not; macro. Both are part of a paradoxical team. These are called state variables with connected quantum and macro components.

Macro states are larger things like a tree, tire or glass of water that is persistent in space and time and definitive and follows common sense logic. There is no odds for the front left tire on my car to reappear on.a neighbors car, the next day, all by itself. It will stay fixed in one place.

But as we magnify down, smaller and smaller into the quantum state, the relationship between space and time change and uncertainty appears at that level, the sum of which defines the constant and definitive equilibrium macro state of the tire and its air.

A good example to see this, with hard measurable numbers is a glass of water has a measured entropy value of 69.97J/mole-K. Even though entropy expresses randomness, this number is a repeatable constant for the macro state of a glass of water at those very same conditions. It is always the same number even though entropy implies random at some level; quantum level.

That number also represents the amount of free energy, divided by temperature, bouncing around randomly in the quantum state. It is bouncing randomly, but it is also a constant amount of energy, and is sort of the glue, that hold the larger macro state, constant. This way the properties of this glass of water remain fixed and constant at those conditions; sure thing.

If we evaporate the water to make water vapor the measured entropy increases to 188.8J/mole-K. Water vapor takes up 1600 times as much space as liquid water, and therefore has more wiggled room to hold more energy. There are more degree of freedom in the quantum state to hold energy; translate, rotate, vibrate, twist or torsion, etc.

There is not enough room to do all that, extra, in liquid water so the measured entropy is much less in liquid water. This extra fixed amount of energy in the quantum state of water vapor alters the properties of water vapor, with that macro state remaining definitive in terms of chemical and physical properties. The reaction rates are always the same. The quantum glue is a fixed amount.

If we lower the measured entropy back to that of liquid water, I will need to shed the difference of about 118J/mole-K of randomly moving free energy. This is exothermic and is called the heat of vaporization. If we then wish to go back to water vapor, this direction is endothermic and will need to absorb 118J/mole-K. When we sweat and the sweat evaporates, heat is disappeared into the quantum state, to fill in the extra degrees freedom of the vapor state of water.

Life is immersed in the paradox of quantum and connected macro states. But at the level of macro states the current math used to make predictions for evolution, is better suited to the quantum state and therefore misrepresents the macro state, which is governed by logic and predictable reason and order; state functions.

The DNA is a macro state. If we make two chromosomes with the same base sequence they will behave alike, even if we add similar mutations to the same places. This is like two different glasses of water both at 25C. Both will have the same quantum energy bouncing randomly around that glues and supports the chemical and physical properties of each chromosome the exact same ways.

With the entropy of the universe having to increase, that means the fixed support energy with the measured entropy of the macro states of life do have to increase over and evolve.

Evolution implies and requires moving energy into quantum state to be the support glue for the advancing but definitive macro states of life, from cells to humans. Our bodies have a lot of support quantum energy that glues us into a persistent macro lifeform; living state. The quantum state is where space and time is more disconnected so there are more places to squirrel away energy to glue us all together.

The movement from cold blooded to warm blooded allowed life to have more background quantum energy; heat for entropy, to glue together higher energy macro states.

4

u/Fun_in_Space 9d ago

I can't even tell what point you are trying to make.

BTW, the Earth is not a closed system. We get energy from the sun.

1

u/wellwisher-1 8d ago

The point I was making is the statistical math used for evolution violates the laws of thermodynamics. Natural selection, on the other hand, is simple and logical and is consistent with thermodynamics. Half the model needs to be purged and/or fixed if real science is important.

I have yet to find anyone who can explain that math approach in a simple to understand way. Everyone seems to blindly accept the rules of a math game and think it applies to tangible reality.

For example, in the last or recent midterms elections in the USA, the same math had very close races, but in the end they were not close. How do you explain that? With evolution trying correlate a past, millions of years ago, we cannot know for sure, so close races never reaches a final state of lab actuality, allowing the bull crap that violates thermodynamics, to linger. Good magic trick.

Math is a tool and not a statement of fact. It follows its own premises that we create. I, computer games, the math we can add infinite lives to the game play. But that does not make this possible in reality. In its own game world, those are the rules and the math makes it appear to happen during game play. We need to test it against know reality called the laws of thermodynamics to realize closed box imaginary is not same as open box observation; Schrödinger's cat.

There are very few laws of science and they all occur within thermodynamics and state functions. These are provable facts and are the gold standard in science, if reality is important. You take a snap shot of reality and freeze time and all the key thermodynamic components are in an equilibrium state. The black box adds fantasy that is Neve observe if you open the black box.

You are right, the earth is not a closed system. The universe is a closed system due to the law of energy conservation. Energy cannot be created or destroyed only made to change form; closed universe with all the energy value it needs. This allows entropy to increase by changing the form of energy.

On earth, the sun increases the entropy of the surface water by making water vapor which adds atmospheric partial pressure; humidity and high pressure systems. The earth then lowers the entropy of the water vapor back to liquid and solid making clouds, rain and snow; low pressure systems. We also have the seasons of hot and cold, which average over time. The poles and equator also each have different conditions relative to the sun. The sun increase entropy but earth gravity lowers it.

String Theory was also a math illusion, where the math was creating an alternate reality that appeared to add up, but it too did not follow the laws of science.

3

u/-zero-joke- 🧬 its 253 ice pieces needed 8d ago

LLM posting or schizophrenic episode, who can tell?

2

u/gliptic 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 8d ago

Reads like organic crack-pottery to me I'm afraid.

1

u/XRotNRollX You know who else evolved from an ape? MY MOM 8d ago

Seems more like mania, but Goldwater Rule is in effect.

2

u/twizzjewink 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 8d ago

Mark Twain famously said: There are lies, damned lies, and statistics.

The problem with statistics is that they CAN lie; they can deceive; and they can be horribly incomplete.

1

u/Ayasugi-san 7d ago

Or to quote Homer Simpson: People can come up with statistics to prove anything. Forfty percent of people know that.

1

u/twizzjewink 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 7d ago

I wonder what the statistics are about bad statistics..

1

u/melympia 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 7d ago

"Never trust statistics you didn't fake yourself."

5

u/Kriss3d 9d ago

Sure. And we agree that the flies with ransom legs and such didn't get to pass on their genes right?

So anyone with a random mutation that happens to tolerate the radiation would get to do just that.

And thats how the theory of evolution works.

1

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

oh okay, I understand. So is the issue with the fly study just that they haven't been studied long enough to produce a helpful adaptation?

5

u/Indrigotheir 9d ago

If they are flies in a lab, there is no "helpful" in the way you are thinking; lab flies are bred and have very little input on their own survival or fitness.

With out this survival pressure you would see in the real world, there's nothing pushing the mutations to be helpful. The fly that's blind and the fly with X-ray vision both survive and reproduce in the lab; neither mutation is "helpful" in this setting.

2

u/Plasterofmuppets 9d ago

I’ll disagree a bit.  Any mutation that is interesting enough to the researcher is pro-survival.  It’s a selection pressure that isn’t replicated in the outside world.

4

u/GraveDiggingCynic 9d ago

I'd say one of the problems with such studies, or rather with the way some people interpret such studies, is that these are meant to replicate how evolution happens. In general, any individual subjected to massive doses of ionizing radiation that so heavily damage the germ line are, even if the somehow manage to survive the exposure event themselves, are not likely going to have produce offspring that have any degree of fitness.

The purpose of such experiments is generally to see how environmental mutagenic phenomena affect development, by exposing individuals to large doses of radiation or toxins, far beyond what would happen outside of large hydrogen bomb fission events.

Actual mutation events are generally far more discreet and limited than blowing gaping holes through chromosomes that translation repair systems can't possibly cope with. Whether it is horizontal transfer of some genes, a bit of ionizing radiation knocking around some nucleotides, or more often than not the replicationmachinery itself screwing up (probably the most common cause of mutations), these generally are not catastrophic events, because, well, as fruit fly experiments or significant mistakes in recombination won't end up propagating. In some lineages, even substantial changes, like polyploidy are not only survivable, but can improve fitness; because at the end of the day, the genome's role is encoding proteins and providing the mutation events aren't creating all kinds of developmental or systemic issues, the descendants can keep on ticking.

The kind of mutation Creationists tend to invoke isn't a mechanism for evolution at all, but rather deleterious in nature. Actual mutations that do drive evolution are usually much more discrete, so that to see the process at play you can't just look at a few generations after you blasted your preferred mutagenic raygun at the experimental group, but rather have to observe an accretion of relatively small changes over time on populations.

Another thing I'd add is that Creationists tend to think of evolution as some sort of zero sum game; either a beneficial mutation appears and evolution is an incredible success, or the mutation is deleterious and organisms die. But because mutations generally are far more discrete, we don't think in terms of win vs. lose, but in terms of fitness. Any given population has some members who are more "fit" (that is more able to survive in their environment, compete for mating opportunities or all the other ways germ lines get passed on), and individuals who are less "fit". Not all the "fit" individuals will end up passing on their genes (maybe they got struck by a boulder or buried in a tar pit), and not all "less fit" individuals will be denied the opportunity to reproduce.

The real engine of evolution is *variation*, because fitness is a moving target. Environments are always changing, populations are always changing, so, to put in somewhat oversimplified terms, what is "fit" today may be "unfit" tomorrow, and vice versa. I bet the first whitish black bears had a hard time getting a date, but at the extreme snowier ends of their ancient range, the measure of fitness inverted, and suddenly, ol' whitey was, if not all that sexually attractive, had the singular form of fitness of being the only game in town.

2

u/Kriss3d 9d ago

Yes. Or the radiation was such an abrubt and severe event that none survived.

But we have this very much already. Antibiotics was made to treat bacterial infections. Antibiotics is chemicals produced by biological microorganisms.

It was really great and could be used to kill off a ton of bacteria. Hooray!

It would kill pretty much all the bacteria until so few remained the body could fight them off.. Mostly.

The world is saved!

Only of those. Bacterial infections where the antibiotics didn't kill all of it. A tiny tiny fraction survived. And when hit with antibiotics again most got killed but a few of them survived.

Those bacteria multiplied ad they tend to do.

Guess what..

Now these bacteria had a much better chance of surviving antibiotics. Rise and repeat for even just about hundred years and now many of those kinds of bacteria that were usually easily killed suddenly didn't get that bothered with antibiotics anymore.

That's evolution at work.

6

u/jnpha 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

RE "random":

If you mean equiprobable like rolling a fair die, then no. Random here means "random to fitness".
I like this summary from Dawkins' 1986 (40-year-old) book:

This all began with a discussion over what is meant when we say that mutation is ‘random’. I listed three respects in which mutation is not random: it is induced by X-rays, etc.; mutation rates are different for different genes; and forward mutation rates do not have to equal backward mutation rates. To this, we have now added a fourth respect in which mutation is not random. Mutation is non-random in the sense that it can only make alterations to existing processes of embryonic development. It cannot conjure, out of thin air, any conceivable change that selection might favour. The variation that is available for selection is constrained by the processes of embryology, as they actually exist.

1

u/Competitive-Box61 9d ago

This just shows that none of those fruit flies were born with mutations that enabled them to survive radiation.

Is he suggesting that god tried to make the flies resistant to radiation and just failed because they turned out deformed?

Science books > whatever you read.

2

u/MindlessAgency7809 9d ago

unfortunately i picked up this book thinking it was a science book i am still very new to studing evoltuion and i am an atheist myself the title of the book was misleading.

3

u/No_Vehicle_5085 9d ago

You can do a search for free biology and evolution textbooks. There are some very decent college level textbooks in PDF format that are downloadable. A good biology textbook will give you a good background for understand the evolution.

Here are some sources just for starters, but there are additional free textbooks available as well.

https://open.umn.edu/opentextbooks/subjects/biology

https://lib.lavc.edu/c.php?g=571229&p=5250640

https://open.umn.edu/opentextbooks/textbooks/understanding-organisms-an-evolutionary-ecological-and-comparative-approach

Here is a primer on evolution - also free:

https://irl.umsl.edu/oer/36/

if you don't have a strong background from high school, you can start here to refresh your memory:

https://flexbooks.ck12.org/cbook/ck-12-biology-flexbook-2.0/?_gl=1*7doy45*_gcl_au*NDg1Nzk1NDI3LjE3OTQwODYyMDQ.*_ga*NTUzNjUwNTIzLjE3OTQwODYyMDU.*_ga_7PBE4L0PZZ*czE3OTQwODYyMDQkbzEkZzAkdDE3OTQwODYyMTckajQ3JGwwJGg0OTU3NDEzMDAkZG44d0NvWVZCUnhLcVA2a2k1cmw0VGx1NVFUbGhiQktMc1E.

There is quite a bit of nonsense on the internet, but there is also some great stuff! I hope you find some of these helpful. It's a great thing to be curious and I wish you well on your journey.

2

u/Competitive-Box61 9d ago

Either a text book on evolutionary bio or taking a class would be better. It's a complex subject that I've seen a bunch of people struggle to explain properly.

2

u/tpawap 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago

Complaining about something those experiments didn't show, that they weren't supposed to nor expected to show => just a strawman.

Look up the Luria-Delbrück experiments for something that was supposed to determine the randomness of mutations, or something like de novo multicellularity experiments, that show selection in action.

2

u/Pretend-Rule-929 1d ago

Theistic evolutionist here. Got to the section on transposition and caught myself thinking “this guy just told me for the last few chapters randomness and natrual selection are not the driving factors in evolution and now just told me that cells Randomly shuffle genetic information or a “sentence” until it has a new useful meaning. And then the cells wich benefit survive and go on to become the dominant in a population. I feel he did something like this

It's like telling me circles don't exist, then explaining that what I'm looking at is actually a continuous arrangement of curved lines forming a closed shape. You've just described a circle without wanting to call it one.

There not the same process buuuut.

1

u/BranchLatter4294 9d ago

In the observed instances of speciation, we have seen no evidence that magic was involved.

https://talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-speciation.html

1

u/GraveDiggingCynic 9d ago

It takes a deep misunderstanding of any physical process to invoke randomness. Clearly evolution, like any physical process, has patterns that create a degree of predictability; even in populations, even very small populations where novel genes can move relatively quickly throughout the entire population.

Unpredictable != random. Not in biology. Not even in quantum field theory.

1

u/Slow_Lawyer7477 🧬 Flagellum-Evolver 7d ago

Fitness landscape theory can make sense of this. Consider the possibility that fruit flies are already so exceptionally highly adapted to their specific niche that most mutations push them away from the "local optimum". Natural selection has honed the fruit fly morphology so all their "parts" are pretty close to optimally matched together.

There isn't space for another pair of legs on their thorax (the middle body section in between the head and abdomen) where all insects have their legs attached. So to further "adapt" a fruit fly to benefit from yet another pair of legs would require a very significant rewiring of the thorax itself to accompany this.

The three-pairs-of-legs-on-the-thorax-evolution happened very early, at the very origin of insects, and has been pretty much the optimal solution ever since.

1

u/melympia 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 7d ago

"Fruit flies had random mutations. This proves evolution is not random." Is that the point Perry Marshal is trying to sell?

First of all, mutations are random. However, selection is not. But... fruit flies were exposed to X-ray radiation to increase the number of mutations in them so there was more to experiment with. (Probably among other things increasing mutation rate.) And these fruit flies were artificially selected by humans. Not by nature. Fruit flies are not terribly bothered by their antennae being (partially) turned into legs (that's actually what happens in the antennapedia mutation with "legs sticking out their heads") or a number of other conditions as long as they are in a lab, get their nutritous food served to them and don't have to deal with predators or anything else flies in the wild have to deal with. So, these new traits are neither selected for or against. They are neutral.

Others can be lethal if occuring in a double dose, but even then, as long as there is offspring, the flies will live on.