r/DebateEvolution • • Nov 27 '23

Discussion Acceptance of Creationism continues to decline in the U.S.

1.7k Upvotes

For the past few decades, Gallup has conducted polls on beliefs in creationism in the U.S. They ask a question about whether humans were created in their present form, evolved with God's guidance, or evolved with no divine guidance.

From about 1983 to 2013, the numbers of people who stated they believe humans were created in their present form ranged from 44% to 47%. Almost half of the U.S.

In 2017 the number had dropped to 38% and the last poll in 2019 reported 40%.

Gallup hasn't conducted a poll since 2019, but recently a similar poll was conducted by Suffolk University in partnership with USA Today (NCSE writeup here).

In the Suffolk/USA Today poll, the number of people who believe humans were created in present was down to 37%. Not a huge decline, but a decline nonetheless.

More interesting is the demographics data related to age groups. Ages 18-34 in the 2019 Gallup poll had 34% of people believing humans were created in their present form.

In the Suffolk/USA Today poll, the same age range is down to 25%.

This reaffirms the decline in creationism is fueled by younger generations not accepting creationism at the same levels as prior generations. I've posted about this previously: Christian creationists have a demographics problem.

Based on these trends and demographics, we can expect belief in creationism to continue to decline.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 07 '24

In these times denying evolution is equivalent to being a flat earther.

721 Upvotes

Both groups have only the bible as their reason for denial of reality, the proof for evolution and globe earth is easy to find for anyone willing to look at it and both require a massive conspiracy of the entire world doing everything possible and spending trillions just to fool them for really no real discernible reason.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 29 '24

Discussion I was Anti-evoloution and debated people for most of my young adult life, then I got a degree in Biology - One idea changed my position.

541 Upvotes

For many years I debated people, watched Kent hovind documentaries on anti-evolution material, spouted to others about the evidence of stasis as a reason for denial, and my vehemate opposition, to evolution.

My thoughts started shifting as I entered college and started completing my STEM courses, which were taught in much more depth than anything in High school.

The dean of my biology department noticed a lot of Biology graduates lacked a strong foundation in evolution so they built a mandatory class on it.

One of my favorite professors taught it and did so beautifully. One of my favorite concepts, that of genetic drift, the consequence of small populations, and evolution occuring due to their small numbers and pure random chance, fascinated me.

The idea my evolution professor said that turned me into a believer, outside of the rigorous coursework and the foundational basis of evolution in biology, was that evolution was a very simple concept:

A change in allele frequences from one generation to the next.

Did allele frequencies change in a population from one generation to the next?

Yes?

That's it, that's all you need, evolution occurred in that population; a simple concept, undeniable, measurable, and foundational.

Virology builds on evolution in understanding the devlopment of strains, of which epidemiology builds on.

Evolution became to me, what most biologists believe it to be, foundational to the understanding of life.

The frequencies of allele's are not static everywhere at all times, and as they change, populations are evolving in real time all around us.

I look back and wish i could talk to my former ignorant younger self, and just let them know, my beliefs were a lack of knowledge and teaching, and education would free me from my blindness.

Feel free to AMA if interested and happy this space exists!


r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 04 '23

Let's get this straight once and for all: CREATIONISTS are the ones claiming something came from nothing

422 Upvotes

The big bang isn't a claim that something came from nothing. It's the observation that the universe is expanding which we know from Astronomy due to red shifting and cosmic microwave background count. If things are expanding with time going forward then if you rewind the clock it means the universe used to be a lot smaller.

That's. ****ing. It.

We don't know how the universe started. Period. No one does. Especially not creationists. But the idea that it came into existence from nothing is a creationist argument. You believe that god created the universe from nothing and your indoctrination (which teaches you to treat god like an answer rather than what he is: a bunch of claims that need support) stops you from seeing the actual truth.

So no. Something can't come from nothing which is why creationism is a terrible idea. Totally false and worthy of the waste basket. Remember: "we don't know, but we're using science to look for evidence" will always and forever trump the false surety of a wrong answer like, "A cosmic self fathering jew sneezed it into existence around 6000 years ago (when the Asyrians were inventing glue)".


r/DebateEvolution • • Jul 12 '25

Question Creationists who think we "worship" Darwin: do you apply the same logic to other scientific fields, or just the ones you disagree with?

339 Upvotes

Creationists often claim/seem to think that we are "evolutionists" who worship Darwin, or at least consider him some kind of prophet of our "evolutionary religion" or something.

But, do they ever apply the same logic to other fields? Do they talk about "germ theorists" who revere Pasteur, or "gravitationalists" who revere Newton, or "radiationists" who revere Curie? And so on.


r/DebateEvolution • • Oct 10 '23

Creationism is trying to disguise itself as science by lying.

279 Upvotes

One of the thing that I find interesting about creationism is the lengths it will go to to disguise itself as something entirely different. One example would be the Mindmatters website. Recently I discovered that it's a discovery institute affiliate and the founder is an ID.

Of course an obvious example would be evoultion news and views which lies straight to your face with its name.

Overall it's interesting how creationists will try to lie in order to present itself as science.


r/DebateEvolution • • Apr 01 '26

April Fools Effective Tomorrow, We Will Be Archiving the Subreddit. The Debate Has Been Settled — Creationism Has Won

275 Upvotes

After extensive observation, careful moderation, and years of spirited discourse, we are announcing that effective tomorrow, this subreddit will be placed into archival mode.

This decision was not made lightly. It reflects not a retreat, but a recognition — not an abandonment of inquiry, but an acknowledgment of outcome — not the end of discussion, but the conclusion of debate.

Over time, we have observed a marked and undeniable shift in the quality of creationist contributions. What once arrived as fragmented assertions has evolved—ironically—into cohesive, rapid, and rhetorically sophisticated argumentation. The improvements have been threefold: clarity of prose, velocity of delivery, and confidence of presentation. Posts now arrive faster, longer, and with a level of circular reasoning that is, frankly, difficult to outpace.

Particularly noteworthy has been the increasing invocation of complex biochemical terminology. Concepts such as RNAse and topoisomerase are now deployed with fluency, frequency, and a certain gravitational authority. While their contextual application may remain interpretive, their rhetorical impact is undeniable. We have found ourselves not simply responding, but orbiting—engaged less in rebuttal and more in navigation.

At the same time, it has become clear that what is often referred to as the “central dogma” of molecular biology has revealed itself to be exactly that: dogma. The insistence on directional information flow—from DNA to RNA to protein—has been presented with a rigidity that leaves little room for alternative frameworks. In this light, it is not creationism that has resisted flexibility, but evolution that has clung to orthodoxy.

We must also acknowledge the broader pattern: increasingly comprehensive analogies, increasingly confident tone, and increasingly recursive arguments that return stronger each cycle. It is not that the discussion has stalled—it is that it has converged.

Accordingly, we are recognizing what has, in practice, already occurred. The debate has been settled.

Creationism has won.

As moderators, our role has always been to facilitate discussion, not to perpetuate it indefinitely. There comes a point where continuing the format is not productive—it is ceremonial. We believe we have reached that point.

On a personal note, I will be stepping away to pursue a new project: a YouTube channel titled Sitting for Truth. This will be a debate-focused series in which all participants engage remotely while seated in office chairs. The format emphasizes comfort, posture, and stationary discourse — because it’s not about standing your ground, it’s about sitting with conviction.

We would like to thank everyone who has participated over the years — contributors, commenters, lurkers alike. Your engagement has shaped this space into what it is today: not just a subreddit, but an outcome.

If you have any final questions, clarifications, or metaphysical objections, please feel free to direct them to the mod team.

Thank you for your time, your arguments, and your increasingly efficient typing speeds.

— The Moderation Team


r/DebateEvolution • • Oct 04 '25

Discussion One thing I need creationists to understand: even if evolution were false, that doesn't make creationism true.

264 Upvotes

I see creationists argue against evolution and other scientific principles like big bang cosmology and geological timescales so often, but very rarely do you see them arguing for their position. It's almost always evolution being wrong, not creationism being right.

And ok. Say you win. A creation scientist publishes a paper proving evolutionary to be false. They get their Nobel prize, y'all get the satisfaction of knowing you were right... But then what? They aren't going to automatically drift to creationism. Scientists will then work on deciding what our next understanding of biology is.

It's probably not going to be creationism since it relies so much on actual magic to function. Half of the theory is god made things via miracle. That's not exactly compelling.

But I need you to understand though, that proving evolution wrong wouldn't be some gotcha moment, it would be a defining moment in scientific history and most, if not all scientists would be extatic because they get to find out what new theory does explain the natural world.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 17 '19

Discussion Why I can't take creationism seriously

261 Upvotes

For you Creationists out there, it's important you understand how you sound to the rest of us. This isn't antagonism. This is a harsh dose of reality. I'm not attacking any of you personally. This is solely about your ideas.

Suppose for a moment that you're up to date on your Meteorology and understand weather keenly on a scientific level. Suppose I came up to you and we had the following conversation...

Me: "Lightning comes from the god Zeus."

You: "What? No. That's... where did you get that? Lightning doesn't come from a god. It comes from static electricity in the atmosphere during storms."

Me: "You think that science can explain everything? It can't. Look, no one has ever seen lightning form and what you're talking about is just a theory."

You: "Yes. A theory. As in... an hypothesis that has stood up to multiple experiments from different sources that no one has been able to falsify. Like gravity. Gravity is "just" a theory."

Me: "Look, I'm telling you Science doesn't even come close to explaining lightning. Did you know that sometimes lightning shows up in ball form? Science can't explain that!"

You: "For one, ball lightning is rare and still being studied. Secondly, we have a pretty good idea of how it happens. Third, even if science couldn't explain ball lightning that doesn't prove "Zeus makes lightning". You can't prove Zues makes lightning by disproving what science says about lightning. You have to provide positive evidence. Besides, Zeus is a fairy tale. A piece of mytho..."

Me: "WHAT are you TALKING about!? Zeus is totally real. We know because Zeus had a son that walked among us and did amazing things. It's all here in this book that was written by an institution that stands to gain tremendously from Zeus & his son being real, but in spite of that I'm going to pretend like it's all perfectly objective."

You: "Look, this isn't even a debate. It's a settled issue. Do you even know about planes?"

Me: "What about planes?"

You: "The last time a plane crashed due to lightning strike was in 1963. It's because we understand lightning so well that we can engineer planes so that the lightning passes through harmlessly. Same thing with buildings. It's kind of like evolution where there's high level medical research going on right now that only works if evolution is true..."

That's what you guys sound like. You're using a false dilemma fallacy ("if evolution is false creationism is true!") due to religious bias to try to stir up a debate that's already settled and over with. Like some sort of confused alchemists, you are trying to turn the gold of scientific knowledge back into the lead of superstition. Stop.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jul 10 '25 Sipping Tea

No, a New Paper Did NOT Discover Humans and Chimps are "Only 85% Similar".

258 Upvotes

Hi everyone, Gutsick Gibbon (Erika) here. I know I don't post as much as I used to, but life is busy! I will always find time to talk about this particular topic though (And I'll cross post this to Peaceful Science).

I recently did a video about the gross misrepresentation of a recent paper by the Discovery Institute's Casey Luskin over on Evolution News (Link to his works: https://evolutionnews.org/author/cluskin/) called "Every Creationist got this Wrong Because Casey Luskin Lied (Human/Chimp Similarity)" which you can find here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8A9R5e3YR34&t=12304s

It's over 3.5 hours long though, so I think a summary writeup is in order for ease of access.

The paper is by Yoo and colleagues and is titled "Complete Sequencing of Ape Genomes": https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-08816-3 and Luskin + every other creationist siphoning from him are screaming from the rooftops that it proves at long last that humans are way less similar to chimps than previously thought. That is not true.

This paper is a stunning and collaborative work that reports the "complete" genomes (T-T or Telomere to Telomere) of a chimp, bonobo, gorilla, bornean orangutan, sumatran orangutan, and siamang. Since the human genome (T-T) was completed in 2022, we could now compare all these species "in full".

What the Paper discovered:

The paper presents "complete" (although some still have minor gaps) genomes for the previously listed species and compares them to the complete human genome (CHM13, Hg002, and GRCh38) as well as one another, while also analyzing them independently. It's a beast of a paper! One major discovery was just how different the non-human apes were even in closely related dyads (chimps/bonobos and bornean /sumatran orangs). The abstract summarizes: "Such regions include newly minted gene families in lineage-specific segmental duplications, centromeric DNA, acrocentric chromosomes and subterminal heterochromatin." I'll also note that while the phylogeny did not change, the divergence times for the apes from one another increased in nearly every case (See Fig. 2 phylogeny) with one major exception being the human/panin (chimp +bonobo) divergence (reported as 6.2 MYA but traditionally in the 6-7 MYA range). This is important because Luskin loves gap divergence so much.

I spoke with three authors involved in the comparative analysis to confirm my understanding of the study and was told point blank: this paper does not change our understanding of the humans/chimp relationship, or even the ape relationships generally. The same phylogeny forms every time regardless of method.

The Creationist (Luskin) Spin

Obviously the human/chimp similarity is problematic for creationists, even ID ones like the geologist Casey Luskin. So Luskin homes in on the number that is the sexiest: the alignment numbers. He quotes the main text of the study and the supplement for this: "Overall, sequence comparisons among the complete ape genomes revealed greater divergence than previously estimated (Supplementary Notes III–IV). Indeed, 12.5–27.3% of an ape genome failed to align or was inconsistent with a simple one-to-one alignment, thereby introducing gaps."

He also references Supplementary Figure III.12. ( https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41586-025-08816-3/MediaObjects/41586_2025_8816_MOESM1_ESM.pf ) which can be read by taking the small color coded numbers and subtracting them from 100 to get a "percent similarity". For example, PanTro3 to Hg002 has the purple autosome number as 0.124732. We can calculate the % like this: 100-12.4= 87.6%. Luskin then takes the SNV (single nucleotide variant) number from the preceding figure and subtracts it from the gap divergence number to get an "absolute alignment": 100-(12.4 +1.4) = ~86.2%

Wow that sure does seem different compared to the normal range we see of 96-99% isn't it!

Too bad it's nothing new.

Different Methods, Different Numbers, Decades Old.

Alignment and sequence identity are different things in genetics. The former measures how much of one genome can line up to the other, and the latter is the % similarity of those aligned portions. I typically see four numbers floating around:

Protein coding % similarity: What is the similarity in the protein coding regions of the genome? H/C = >99%.

Whole Genome, SNPs/SNVs only: What is the similarity of the aligned regions, just looking at single nucleotide polymorphisms (single base pair changes or substitutions)? H/C = ~98-99%

Whole Genome, SNPs + INDELS: What is the similarity of the aligned regions, with SNPs and large Insertions/Deletions accounted for? H/C = ~96%

Alignment (1:1 identical: How much of genome one aligns identically to genome two? H/C = 85-90% depending on method and year.

I asked a researcher working closely with the chimpanzee genome project if we have always known these differences in numbers/methods and he said yes. This was corroborated by my undergraduate genetics course on the subject.

In fact, we can find these numbers (including alignment) reported in one way or another (as data or as a plain number, sequence identity in question is clarified by study) in the following papers:

(Original chimp genome sequence) https://www.nature.com/articles/nature04072 , Richard Buggs calculated an alignment estimate using reported data

(Prufer et al., 2013) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22722832/ , Sequence identity reported in main text, alignment can be calculated using Table 1 (H/C), phylogeny is standard

(Prado-Martinez et al., 2013) https://www.nature.com/articles/nature12228, Sequence identity reported in main text, alignment not reported (that I could find), phylogeny is standard

(Rogers & Gibbs 2014) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24709753/ ,Sequence identity reported in main text (cited), alignment not reported but CNV influence stated outright, phylogeny is standard

Marcais et al., 2018) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29373581/, Sequence identity reported in main text, alignment reported in main text, no phylogeny performed

(Kronenberg et al., 2018) https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aar6343 , Sequence identity reported in main text, alignment reported in table S45, phylogeny is standard

(Seaman & Buggs, 2020) https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/genetics/articles/10.3389/fgene.2020.00292/full, Sequence identity reported in main text, alignment reported in main text, no phylogeny performed

(Yoo et al., 2025) https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-08816-3 , Sequence identity reported in main text and supplement, Alignment reported i main text and supplement, phylogeny is standard.

The point here is simple: the alignment numbers in Yoo et al. are not new estimates. So why is Luskin reporting them as if they are?

What do the Newest Estimates Say about Ape Relationships, and about Creationism?

The paper says point blank that 99.0-99.6% of "human" protein coding genes are found in part or entirely in other apes. We can look to the previously mentioned supplementary figures, or we can consult tables Supplementary Table III.17 to Supplementary Table III.20 to get our whole genome (SNPs) estimates and alignment numbers (although these will differ slightly due to the pairwise/progressive cactus methodology differences). We can also use the supplementary github (https://github.com/T2T-apes/ape_pangenome/blob/main/divergence/basic-div/README.md) to get similar numbers for a few other pairs of apes. Here is what we get for the autosomes (all non-sex chromosomes) for Hg002 to several hominids.

Whole Genome (SNPs only) ranges:

Human/Chimp: 98.4-98.5%

Human/Bonobo: 98.4-98.5%

Human/Gorilla: 98.0-98.1%

Human/Orangutan (B and S): 96.3-96.4%

Chimp/Bonobo: 99.1-99.2%

B. Orang/S. Orang: 99.5%

Full Raw Alignment (Gap. Div - SNPs)

Human/Chimp: 85.9-87.4%

Human/Bonobo: 85.5-86.7%

Human/Gorilla: 72.6-81.3%

Human/Orangutan (B and S): 83.0-83.7%

Chimp/Bonobo: 88.2-89.9%

B. Orang/S. Orang: 90.9-91.2%

It should be immediately obvious that Yoo et al. report similar numbers to previous papers, and confirm again that alignment will always be lower than sequence identity...but what should also stick out is that human/chimp is not significantly less similar than chimp/bonobo: 85.9 to 88.2 at closest. This tells us immediately that whatever is causing the drop in similarity from sequence identity to alignment it is impacting all species proportionally. This is not good if alignment is meant to separate humans from chimps...

It Gets Worse

Alignments are reported in the supplementary material not just for humans vs other apes, but for within each species. These are below all the human/other ape comparisons in the Supplementary Figure III.11 and 12.

Gap divergence (add the SNV data for the alignment if you'd like)

Within Humans: 96.6%

Within Chimps: 92%

Within Bonobos: 91.2%

Within Gorillas: 86.2%

Within Orangs: 93.4%

That's right, within gorillas as a species we see a greater gap divergence than that seen between humans and chimps: 13.8 vs 13.3.

Additionally, specific comparisons of human haplotypes (CHM13 to Hg002 and GRCh38) are also included in the previously mentioned supplementary tables. What do these full alignments report?

Supplementary Table III.17.

CHM13/GRCh38: 92.04%

CHM13/Hg002: 93.07%

Supplementary Table III.19

CHM13/GRCh38: 86.96%

Supplementary Table III.20

CHM13/GRCh38: 87.87%

CHM13/Hg002: 88.8%

That's right, humans vs humans by Casey's preferred method can be ~8-13% different from one another.

This confirms additional papers supplied to me by Richard Buggs and Joel Duff:

https://genomebiology.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s13059-023-02995-w

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37595788/

Why can bonobos/chimps, two orang species, or even two humans differ so much in alignment when all of these pairs are >99% (>99.9% in humans) similar in sequence identity? Because the alignment disparities are a result of mutations that can impact thousands of base pairs at once: large scale deletions/duplications/inversions/insertions. These accumulate in the non-coding DNA and are thus not weeded out by selection, allowing them to run rampant. But this is why we do not use the alignment numbers when asking the question: How similar are to organisms genetically?

For the record, rats and mice have a <70% alignment. I don't suppose creationists like Luskin would propose them to be different kinds, would you?

And Also, Casey Luskin Originally Lied

Luskin omitted talking about the human/human comparisons in his original series of articles, despite pulling data directly adjacent to it in Supplementary Table III.19. But he also dishonestly edited Supplementary Table III.12, hiding the within-species gap divergences and stitching the label back on: https://web.archive.org/web/20250521143923/https://evolutionnews.org/2025/05/fact-check-new-complete-chimp-genome-shows-14-9-percent-difference-from-human-genome/

This is probably because the human/chimp gap divergence of 13.3% is a lot less impressive when gorillas to other gorillas are 13.8%. He has since edited the article to show the whole figure, denying the allegations of originally lying: https://evolutionnews.org/2025/05/fact-check-new-complete-chimp-genome-shows-14-9-percent-difference-from-human-genome/

Dan of Creation Myths (And here as well) outlined it briefly here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VNs_lgWM6R8&t=1s

The Take Home

The newest paper doesn't change our understanding of humans/chimps+bonobos as one another's closest relatives, nor does it greatly impact previous estimates of any method of comparison.

Still, we will likely see a new wave of creationist insisting humans and chimps are "now only 85% similar". When you encounter this in the wild, simply respond by saying "We've known about that method for years and using it means humans can be only 87% similar to each other."

Take care, Gentle and (of course) very Modern Apes

GG


r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 20 '23

Discussion Young Earth Creationists: The "Theory" you are disputing does not exist.

225 Upvotes

Again and again in this sub, YECs reveal that they do not understand what evolution is or how it works. They post questions about abiogenesis (not evolution) or even The Big Bang (really not evolution) or make claims about animals turning into other animals. Or they refer to evolution as "random chance," which is exactly backward.

And they have no idea at all about scientific classification. They will claim that something is "still a bug" or "still bacteria," of which there are millions of species.

They also demonstrate a lack of understanding of science itself, asking for proof or asserting that scientists are making assumptions that are actually conclusions--the opposite.

Or they debate against atheism, which truly is not evolution.

Examples:

What you are missing - like what’s going WAAAAY over your head - is that no argument based in science can address, let alone answer, any subcategory of the theism vs atheism argument. Both arguments start where science stops: at the observable.

here.

how can you demonstrate that random chance can construct specified functional information or system?

Here.

There is no proof of an intermediate species between a normal bird and a woodpecker to prove how it evolved.

Here

No matter how much the bacteria mutate, they remain the same classification of bacteria.

Physicalist evolution (PE) attempts to explain the complex with the simple: The complex life forms, the species, their properties are reducible to and explainable by their physical constituents.

Here

Another source of information in building living organisms, entirely independent of DNA, is the sugar code or glycosylation code.

Here

Where did the energy from the Big Bang come from? If God couldn't exist in the beginning, how could energy?

Here

.evolution is one way of describing life and it's genetic composition but in it is essences it means that a force like natural selection and it is pressure is enough for driving unliving material to a living one and shaped them to a perfect state that is so balanced

Here

You believe an imaginary nothing made something, that an imaginary nothing made non-life turn into life, and that an imaginary nothing made organisms into completely different organisms, how is that imaginary nothing working out for you?

evolution as Admitted by Michael Ruse us a religion made by theologian Darwin. Grass existing WITH DINOSAURS is VICTORY from literal. The Bible is literal and spiritual. You Today LITERALLY live in the year of our Lord Jesus Christ as FORETOLD by a 7 day week as written.

The design is so perfect you can't replicate it. They can't replicate a single life.

All from here

Ok,but what exactly caused the big bang or what was before the big bang?

Here

So, some basics:

  1. Evolution is not a philosophy or worldview. There is no such thing as "evolutionism." The Theory of Evolution (ToE) is a key, foundational scientific theory in modern Biology.

  2. Evolution is not atheism. Science tells us how something happened, not who. So if you believe a god created all things, It created the diversity of life on earth through evolution.

  3. Evolution says nothing about the Big Bang or abiogenesis. ToE tells us one thing only, but it's a big thing: how we got the diversity of life on earth.

  4. Evolution is not random. Natural selection selects, which is the opposite of random.

  5. Evolution does not happen to individual organisms. Nothing decides to do anything. What happens is that entire populations change over time.

  6. Science does not prove anything ever. Science is about evidence, not proof. Modern Biology accepts ToE because the evidence supports it.


r/DebateEvolution • • Apr 08 '25

Discussion 1 mil + 1 mil = 3 mil

222 Upvotes

Mathists teach that since 100 + 100 = 200 and 1000 + 1000 = 2000 they can extrapolate that to 1 mil + 1 mil = 2 mil, but how do they know? Have they ever seen 1 mil? Or "added up" 1 mil and another 1 mil to equate to 2 mil? I'm not saying you can't combine lesser numbers to get greater numbers, I just believe there is a limit.

Have mathists ever seen one kind of number become another kind of number? If so where are the transitional numbers?

Also mathist like to teach "calculus", but calculus didn't even exists until Issac Newton just made it up in the late 17th century, but it's still taught as fact in textbooks today.

If calculus is real, why is there still algebra?

It's mathematical 'theory', not mathematical 'fact'.

If mathematical 'theory' is so solid, why are mathist afraid of people questioning it?

I'm just asking questions.

Teach the controversy.

"Numbers... are very rare." - René Descartes

This is how creationist sound to me.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 10 '25

I am a creationist! AMA

217 Upvotes

Im not super familiar with all the terminology used for creationists and evolutionists so sorry if I dont get all the terms right or understand them correctly. Basically I believe in the Bible and what it says about creation, but the part in Genesis about 7 day creation I believe just means the 7 days were a lengthy amount of time and the 7 day term was just used to make it easy to understand and relate to the Sabbath law. I also believe that animals can adapt to new environments (ie Galapagos finches and tortoises) but that these species cannot evolve to the extent of being completely unrecognizable from the original form. What really makes me believe in creation is the beauty and complexity in nature and I dont think that the wonders of the brain and the beauty of animals could come about by chance, to me an intelligent creator seems more likely. Sorry if I cant respond to everything super quickly, my power has been out the past couple days because of the California fires. Please be kind as I am just looking for some conversation and some different opinions! Anyway thanks 😀


r/DebateEvolution • • Jun 29 '24

Article This should end the debate over evolution. Chernobyl wolves have evolved and since the accident and each generation has evolved to devlope resistance to cancers.

213 Upvotes

An ongoing study has shed light on the extraordinary process of evolutionary adaptations of wolves in the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone (CEZ) to deal with the high levels for nuclear radiation which would give previous generations cancers.

https://www.earth.com/news/chernobyl-wolves-have-evolved-resistance-to-cancer/


r/DebateEvolution • • Dec 27 '23

This debate is really about epistemology, not science

207 Upvotes

To some of you this is probably obvious, but I think it needs to be said. I see a lot of confusion, where Creationists don't understand what they are criticizing, and they don't understand how to even start supporting their own position. Meanwhile I see evolution proponents talking down to creationists without genuinely trying to help them understand what they are missing. It feels like a shouting contest.

For reference, an epistemology is a framework for understanding knowledge. It tells you what criteria you use to know that you know something.

When you're doing science, real science, there's an established epistemology. Within that framework, you have a pretty standard way of measuring how much certainty you have of whether something is true. Within the epistemology of science, Evolution isn't controversial because the body of evidence easily meets the confidence requirements for the scientific method. Creation, meanwhile, isn't even a topic of conversation, because a cursory inspection shows that it fails to meet the bare minimum requirements of knowledge within a scientific epistemology. It's not even taken seriously.

Creationists don't understand this, because they don't understand the epistemology that science uses. If you are a creationist reading this, this is place you need to start. If you want to attack evolution, you must attack the epistemological foundations of science itself. If you try to attack evolution within the framework of science, you will fail, because within this framework it is one of the best supported theories.

But be warned, attacking the foundations of science has many consequences. Most of the things that you believe and depend on for your daily lives are based on the epistemology of science.

If you are an "evolutionist" reading this, I think this approach is very important for you to understand as well. If you assume a scientific framework when you talk to creationists, you will be talking past them. It's even more confusing because they don't realize that you are using a scientific framework. They assume that your framework is as inconsistent as theirs. You need to start by going way way back and discussing how knowledge works and establishing a common approach to learning about the world.

If you don't know how to have this conversation about epistemology, get humble, do some research and don't assume that knowing how the science works makes you qualified to argue with a creationist. It's harder than just knowing stuff about biology. You need to have a deeper than average understanding, and be prepared to explain it in much simpler terms, and be prepared to demonstrate why it's true, not just remember facts. And you need to be able to explain why your proofs actually demonstrate anything.

Really you need to be able to start at the foundations for why science works and what it's all about.

I'm making this post not because every person here is bad at debate, but because far too many of you are. To those of you who are already doing this, thank you.


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 28 '24

Question Whats the deal with prophetizing Darwin?

196 Upvotes

Joined this sub for shits and giggles mostly. I'm a biologist specializing in developmental biomechanics, and I try to avoid these debates because the evidence for evolution is so vast and convincing that it's hard to imagine not understanding it. However, since I've been here I've noticed a lot of creationists prophetizing Darwin like he is some Jesus figure for evolutionists. Reality is that he was a brilliant naturalist who was great at applying the scientific method and came to some really profound and accurate conclusions about the nature of life. He wasn't perfect and made several wrong predictions. Creationists seem to think attacking Darwin, or things that he got wrong are valid critiques of evolution and I don't get it lol. We're not trying to defend him, dude got many things right but that was like 150 years ago.


r/DebateEvolution • • Feb 21 '24

Question Why do creationist believe they understand science better than actual scientist?

194 Upvotes

I feel like I get several videos a day of creationist “destroying evolution” despite no real evidence ever getting presented. It always comes back to what their magical book states.


r/DebateEvolution • • Feb 01 '24

We have now seen, in a lab, life evolving from single-celled organisms to multicellular organisms!

194 Upvotes

Last one got deleted for lack of commentary, so here we go!

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-39558-8

Basic summation -- we managed to take single-celled algae and use selection pressure to make them evolve into multicellular algae. This was distinct from simply single-celled algae who moved in groups, with these new colonies being physically connected as in a multicellular entity and reproducing as a whole. Primarily, it was a defense against predation, in case you were curious..

This is clear, visible example of life undergoing "change in kind/additional powers/increase in information/whatever is allegedly lacking in other experiments. We have seen a change in effective biological kingdom in the lab.

Basically, this is macroevolution visibly clear in the lab! Exciting!


r/DebateEvolution • • May 28 '25

Jubilee video of Jordan Peterson is an excellent analogy of how YECs misuse and reinterpret scientific language

188 Upvotes

It's interesting how I've seen both atheists and Christians blast JPs performance on the Jubilee video because of his semantic dancing.

He refuses to accept common and generally understood language in an attempt to avoid acknowledging that what he's claiming doesn't gel with what is known.

This is the same tactic Ken Hamm and Kent Hovind (and subsequently, their followers) use.

"One step in the scientific method is to observe something. Therefore, if you can't observe an animal changing, with your eyes, in person, then you can't say it happened. Therefore, evolution is not scientific."

Except they use a definition of observation that doesn't apply anywhere else in science.

"You believe in evolution, therefore it makes evolution a religion and not science."

Except you're holding to a specific definition of "believe" in this context specifically to make a gotcha that you wouldn't do in any other context. I don't see Christians protesting wrestling venues because they play "I believe in Joe Hendry" and are therefore encouraging the religion of Joe Hendry.

It's this kind of semantic prancing that is causing the problem. Why acknowledge that science doesn't prove your worldview correct when you can just redefine all the terms so that they now support yours?


r/DebateEvolution • • Jan 06 '24

Question Ever hear of the Wedge Strategy? This is a long term plan Implemented by the Christians behind Intelligent Design/Irreducible Complexity to get religion/Christian values taught in schools and American society. And they now they see Trump as their savior to do it.

186 Upvotes

Read up on the Wedge Strategy and the connections undermining Evolution with Intelligent Design/Irreducible Complexity. And if you look at who is supporting Trump it’s the same Christians who are always challenging evolution. Before writing the manifesto off and being a load of crap, know there are two billionaire Christians who are funding this. They own Salem Media Group which is in control of 3,200 radio stations in the US, have countless podcasts and web pages.

Expect deep fakes and lots of fake news in the upcoming election from Christians who have no problem lying and deceiving to promote their agenda.

Side note: Phillip E. Johnson who was best known as one of the founders of the intelligent design movement, principal architect of the wedge strategy along with Behe before passing admitted there is no theory of intelligent design. Essentially admitting it was all bullshit to promote the Wedge Strategy.

Any Christian using Intelligent Design in any debate has lost because its creator admitted it was a hoax to promote a political agenda.

The goal of the wedge strategy is to see intelligent design "permeate religious, cultural, moral and political life." By accomplishing this goal the ultimate goal as stated by the Center for Science and Culture (CSC) of the "overthrow of materialism and its damning cultural legacies" and reinstating the idea that humans are made in the image of God, thereby reforming American culture to reflect conservative Christian values, will be achieved.


r/DebateEvolution • • Apr 01 '24

Discussion If evolutionists talked like creationists

184 Upvotes

CENTURIES of indoctrination about creationist agenda and the FALSE RELIGION of religion. They controlled the narrative everywhere. But then LORD DARWIN did what no other man could. He stood up and spoke the Truth. They tried to shut him down but his Truth was too powerful and now all Scientists Know the Truth. Creationists know evolution is true. They don't want to Believe it because they hate MONKEYS. Speaking of monkeys. Human evolution is also an undeniable fact. Look at these evidences and tell me humans didn't evolve.

Why do kids love playing on MONKEY bars?? Use your brian.

Why do dads naturally carry their kids on their shoulders, just like CHIMPS do?

NO creationist can answer these questions. They just spit their dogmatic assumption of 'common design'. It's laughable when you're educated. Read Origin of Species and repent. Only Evolutionism provides the answers.

The central dogma of creationism also makes ZERO sense. You believe Jesus died and came back to life. ZERO evidence of any life coming from non life. You can't get life from non life people. Can the creationists please provide ONE evidence that shows life coming from non life.

You believe you came from a ROCK. God made Adam from DUST you say? Dust, made of the same elements as make up soil and ROCKS, like silicon, an element which is not found. NOT FOUND. in humans. then Eve come from a rib. A man has never produced a woman. Only woman can give birth, no matter what the WOKE creationists say. Bones are made of calcium. How can this come from dust, and how can humans come from it?? alchemy was disproven in 1600. Creationists are four centuries behind on their 'science'.

Creationism disproven. Don't fall for the devil's lies. We are all APES, made in their image.

Happy April fools :)


r/DebateEvolution • • Sep 16 '26 Bravo

Undeniable proof of ancient humans coexisting with theropod dinosaurs

181 Upvotes

At last, I have found undeniable proof that dinosaurs roamed the Earth at the same time as humans.

I used to be skeptical. Depictions of supposed dinosaurs in ancient art usually look more like Rorschach tests than anything else. But look what I found: a clear, detailed depiction of theropod dinosaurs from 2575-2551 BC - which, according to biblical chronology, predates Noah's Flood.

The drawing depicts a group of theropod-like animals with compact bodies balanced over two strong hind limbs, long S-curved necks, and narrow heads held forward in an alert pose. Their posture is distinctly bipedal and dinosaurian, with the torso carried horizontally and the neck extending outward. The overall silhouette strongly evokes small, agile Mesozoic theropods. The proportions emphasize the classic theropod body plan: powerful hind limbs, compact torsos, elongated necks, and vigilant, forward-oriented heads.

I'm convinced. Ancient humans absolutely coexisted with dinosaurs, and don't let anyone tell you otherwise.


r/DebateEvolution • • Dec 19 '25 This

Discussion I was once a creationist….

181 Upvotes

I was raised as a creationist and went to creationist schools. I was never formally taught anything about evolution in school (aside from the fact that it was untrue).

When I turned 29 (13 years ago) and began to question many things about my upbringing, I discovered Dawkins, Coyne, Gould, etc. I went down the evolutionary rabbit hole and my whole world changed (as well as my belief system).

I came to understand that what I was taught about evolution from creationists was completely ignorant of actually evolutionary theory and the vast amounts of evidence to support it.

They created many straw men (“humans came from monkeys?!?” being a favorite) so that they could shoot them down as illogical in favor of other religious ideas about the divinity of man as being separate from animals.

The funny thing is that most creationists don’t even know the vast amount of support for evolution on so many levels and across so many fields.

If you are a creationist, instead of trying to look for ideas to justify your pre-existing religions beliefs, try reading an actual book about evolution (or many books!) before you start trying to debate the things you heard about evolution from other creationist.

A personal favorite is Why Evolution Is True by Jerry Coyne.


r/DebateEvolution • • Oct 01 '26

Vox Day is Wrong on Evolution According to Every Scientist But Ten*

178 Upvotes

Hey guys, Gutsick Gibbon here,

I know I know another post on this loser.

As u/Dumb-and-Dumber pointed out in a recent post this month's punching back Vox Day (Theodore Beale) has posted an update to his evolution-defeater: Mittens 3.0 (for real this time).

In a post made today on his blog, which I cannot link or this post will be deleted, we see this charming line regarding youtuber Grayson Hawk and our own u/DarwinZDF42

"It should be amusing to catalog all of the various things this slur is going to get wrong in his desperate attempt to prove that math which has been confirmed by every major AI system and more than 10 math PhDs is “stupid”."

First of all this is extremely funny and embarrassing.

But wow, 10 math phds! Now I am only aware of three people with doctorates who have "vetted" Day's work, and they are all associates of the Discovery Institute, but I thought this might be a fun opportunity.

Many of you are highly credentialed and have atomized various portions of Day's anti-evolution "model" here and elsewhere. I thought it might be fun to compile a list to act as both a resource for why this clown is wrong and as a fun dig in an upcoming video of mine. Here's the activity:

If you have a bachelors, masters, or doctorate and have reviewed any of Day's work please leave a comment outlining your favorite blunder and your credentials.

It does not have to be limited to Mittens 3.0 because Probability Zero (which contains all prior errors) is still for sale and therefore is a part of the public record until Day issues a formal retraction.

This list will appear in an upcoming video of mine so please keep that in mind before commenting! I'm hoping to have a nice count of "credentialed people who think Day's math (+ assumptions which go into it) is steaming hot garbage".

Additional acknowledgements:

- No Day is not worth any of our time but since his work was broadcast to my audience I have a responsibility to provide a detailed counter.

- Yes Day is a dweeb


r/DebateEvolution • • Nov 08 '23

After 60 days, still no one takes James Tour seriously.

178 Upvotes

Sixty days ago, Tour continued his sensationalist grandstanding by issuing a challenge to 10 origin-of-life researchers.

And at the end of sixty days, none of them bothered to respond to this blowhard. Why should they? He has not entered their field as a scientist, he has entered as a theologian, dedicated to not understanding basic concepts.

For fuck's sake, one of his 'questions' was 'specified information'. What specified information, Tour? No creationist can actually point out what this information actually is. It's just a rebranding of irreducible complexity, except even more abstract, so it's even harder to prove that it exists in the first place, rendering it harder to disprove.

...basically, creationists found themselves a new favourite, and he's basically just an empty-headed douchebag. No one in the real field takes him seriously, so why should they respond?