r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

Beginning Pages of My Fantasy Epic

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I've been pouring over these pages every time I open up to write. I've written quite a bit of the story; I just need to know how my most crucial pages are working for those who aren't me. Any criticism of any degree is much appreciated. I'm young but with a fully developed brain, so I can take just about anything.

P.S. I'm trying something unique with my chapter structure, obviously named after elements of music. The goal is to add plenty of stopping points with minor hooks and cliffhangers, so that the reader can be left satisfied both in reading on and in saving their place. I've found it very nice for plot structure; let me know how it feels to you as a reader.


r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

NSFW LitRPG Erotica Chapters 4 and 5 of a story about a succubus monster. (read content warning) NSFW

1 Upvotes

Content warning: Extreme Violence, gore, and explicit sexual content.

I'm looking for general feedback on the content and premise. Please note, Progression Fantasy LitRPG is a subgenre that has skills, stat pages, and notifications along with the prose and dialog—like a video game in novel format. This story is about a succubus monster—the nature of which can be quite offensive. I apologize if it offends you, that was not my intent.

I posted the first chapter rough draft and someone asked me to post more. So, I did a lot of editing, but it probably still needs a little line editing. I'd love to hear what you think about these two chapters. It's about 7k words. Sorry, its a little lengthy and these aren't the erotica focused chapters. There is an explicit moment, but it's glossed over because she's rushing a feed. There are scenes that are full on erotica, but these chapters are focused on the story itself.))

Chapter Four ~ a Merchant’s Love Language is Gold

The next three days went by so fast that Vesper barely registered them. The men had to train her not to drain them completely in the mornings, so they could still get their work done. She fell into a quick routine, servicing all the men a little each morning and milking them dry every night before she snuck into Aria’s tent. The two girls would always talk late into the night, and Aria told her stories about growing up with her brother on a farm.  

Tomas was picky and rough but he was not cruel to her, while Dargo and Veldar were gentle and very nice. Those two always treated her with respect and gratitude both during and after her services. Aria gave her a cute blue sundress that even had a small hole behind her tailbone for her tail to fit through, so the skirt would stay down when her tail wiggled. It was Vesper’s most prized possession, and she always took great care not to get it dirty.

Vespera grew closer to all three of the guards during that time and collected a lot of anima, choosing to store it up instead of converting it. She reasoned that she would not know anyone in the city and might want a little saved just in case she had a hard time finding food. On the night of the fourth day since she arrived through the portal, a large city appeared in the distance, ringed by thick stone walls. They camped within sight of it, and her reservoir was full as she fell asleep.

Something grabbed her and dragged her from Aria’s side, waking her suddenly from a sound sleep. Her eyes shot open, and she saw a large man she did not recognize as panic gripped her. As she was dragged from the tent, she saw a large group of men waiting outside and heard Aria yell, still inside the tent.

“What the hell is going on?!”

There must have been more than fifteen men standing around as she started to struggle and was quickly surrounded. They grabbed her legs and arms, holding her down. ‘Oh, no. I’m trapped. I can’t get away. This is it.’ She continued to struggle in a futile attempt to free herself as a man in a fancy suit leaned down and fastened a collar around her neck so tight it was uncomfortable.

They finally released her as the man in the suit spoke, “No use fighting it now. You have a slave collar around your neck. That means you’re mine to use and sell.”

Her heart sank as her eyes darted around, looking for an escape. There was none to be found as she moved into a crouch off the ground ready to bolt. Her head turned left as she heard Dargo speak.

“What’s going on here? Who are all of you?”

The man in the suit turned to look at the dwarf and said, “I’m Carson Fetters, a humble slave merchant. Tomas sold us this succubus, so we’ve come to collect her.”

“She’s a free succubus—Tomas has no right to sell her…”

“That’s not what my contract says. So, does it really matter?”

Veldaryn yelled, “Let her go! She’s not a bad monster. Vesper deserves to be free…”

Carson chuckled and said, “That’s not what this is about, and you have no right to order me around. If you insist on interfering, we’ll have to get rough.”

Vesper glanced back and forth as the conversation continued, unable to see her friends through the crowd of men. The slavers started to gather between her and the two men trying to help her. Hope started to drain from her heart, but she thought fast. ‘Convert all but thirty of my anima.’ Five flashing notifications appeared one after the other.

[Anima Conversion (rank 3) activated. (6202)]                                                    

[Anima Reservoir extremely low—find nourishment soon]                   

[935 mana restored and 4,652 experience earned.]                                      

[Level 15 achieved. (272/1,290) Nourishment Upkeep increased by 2.]

[Skills and Magic have ranked up. New skills and spells available.]

Vespera screamed out in pain and felt her spine lengthen as her body began to change. The agony forced her into a fetal position as her appendages each grew out a little. The throbbing in her skull around her two curved horns and in her tail told her those were growing as well. A jolt in her chest made her squeal and shake as her breasts swelled beneath her dress. All the while, the conversation continued around her.

Veldar exclaimed, “What are you doing to her?!”

Carson explained, “This isn’t our doing. How much did you feed her?”

Dargo said, “This is all screwed up, but I don’t see how we can change it…”

Veldar said, “We should fight for her, Dargo. What do you mean?”

“We’re paid to protect Tomas’ wagon and goods, not Vesper. It would be illegal even if the contract they have is based on lies.”

“She’s already done more than pay us for our protection, Dargo. You can’t say that she hasn’t.”

There was a pause before Dargo answered, “I can’t argue with that. Let’s do it.”

As the pain started to fade, Vesper opened her eyes to the sound of metal clashing on metal. She saw Tomas hiding behind his wagon, peeking out at the fight with wide eyes. ‘Fucking asshole sold me out and he’s just standing there like he’s the victim.’ She turned to watch as the dwarf fought off five of the men, swinging his battle axe back and forth to knock away swords in every direction. ‘Dargo’s a real man, and Veldar stood up for me, too.’ He caught a break and cleaved a man’s leg off, sending him to the ground with a hearty chuckle. 

The elf threw spells in every direction with complicated-looking hand gestures, slowly giving ground as he held the line. Two fireballs connected, setting men on fire, and a wall of fire ignited in front of him as three men rushed him. An explosion went off in the crowd of men, and several of them fell to the ground from the force. 

Aria ran out of the tent and grabbed her by the arm, pulling her to her feet. ‘I don’t have time to deal with Tomas, but if I see Dargo and Veldar again I’ll thank them properly…’ The fox girl thrust Vesper’s backpack into her arms and grabbed her hand to lead her way in a dash towards the city in the distance. The succubus’s heart pounded inside her chest as she tried to keep up.

Carson yelled, “She’s getting away! Stop, slave!”

Vespera glanced over her shoulder at the man as she felt heat from the collar around her neck. She pulled her hand from Aria’s and stopped to grip the collar as she winced in pain. The succubus pulled on the collar around her neck with all her strength and let out a low growl before she screamed.

“I am no slave!”

[Defiant Spirit activated.]

The collar shattered and crumbled in Vesper’s hand, falling from her neck as dust. ‘I guess I’m safe from the enslavement enchantment at least—but they can still capture, torture, and force me.’ The fox girl grabbed her hand again and started pulling her along as three of the slavers broke away from the fight to chase them. Aria spoke, sounding a little panicked herself.

“This is crazy, Vesper. Let’s get out of here. You can stay with my brother until you figure things out.”

“Thank you for saving me, Aria. I’ll repay you for everything somehow. I’m sorry I caused so much trouble.”

“This was Tomas, not you. You have nothing to be sorry for.”

Her voice conveyed her anger. Vesper went silent and followed after her as they approached a forest. It was not dark and dreary like Darkwoods, but the trees were big and there was lots of underbrush. Aria pulled her behind a tree and drew a dagger from her side as she looked around the tree and said.

“We can’t run the whole way there. We need to get rid of the men following us.”

“Let me handle them. I don’t want you to get in trouble for defending me. Just helping me get to safety is enough.”

“What are you going to do? Suck them to death?”

Vesper giggled at her and opened her spell list as she said, “I’ll put them to sleep first, but I won’t kill them. I used a lot of my energy to level up back there. I’ll need to eat soon. Can you just stand watch in case more show up while I’m feeding?”

____________________________________________________________

~Magic & Spells~

  • Oneiromancy (Rank 5): School of magic with spells for manipulating dreams.

    • Dreamdrift (Rank 4): Puts the target to sleep and forces them into a pleasant dream state for approximately four to eight hours unless awakened by pain.[cost: 40 mana](cooldown 15 seconds)

    • Marescape (Rank 3): Puts the target to sleep and induces a nightmare dream state for approximately one to four hours with a small chance to last forever unless awakened by receiving damage.[cost: 155 mana](cooldown 45 seconds)

    • Dream Mist (Rank 1): Creates a mist that has the same effect as Dreamdrift on anyone caught in it.[cost: 120 mana](cooldown 10 minutes)

  • Veilweaving (Rank 5): School of magic with illusion and shadow manipulation spells.

    • Veil Double (Rank 3): Creates an illusion of the caster that will act in the way the caster wants and lasts five minutes. [cost: 50 mana](cooldown 45 seconds)

    • Shadow Stomp (Rank 1): Allows the caster to paralyze an enemy for two minutes by stepping on their shadow.[cost: 75 mana](cooldown 4 minutes) 

    • Veil of Invisibility (Rank 1): Shrouds the caster in an illusion that hides them from sight. [cost: 80 mana](cooldown 5 minutes)

______________________________________________________________

Aria nodded and hid behind a tree and bushes near the edge of the forest. Vespera set down her backpack, peeking out from behind her tree. The three men ran into the forest right past Aria, and Vesper stepped out from behind the tree in front of them. All three slid to a halt, and one pointed a sword at her as he spoke firmly.

“Now don’t give us any trouble and you won’t get hurt. Where’s the fox girl?”

She just smiled at them, focused, and quickly said, “Dream Mist.”

[-120 mana]

A white mist rose up around the men from the ground as the mana left her, and they looked around in panic before they became lethargic. The three men collapsed onto the ground shortly afterward as the mist started to dissipate, and she walked over to pull their pants down. Vesper hurried the task the best she could, and her tail moved like a snake striking to attach her spade to the first man’s dick as she started pulling down the second one’s pants.

The first man was soft at first as her spade took him in, but a shiver ran down her spine as his rod swelled up inside it. She started sucking on the second one’s limp cock as she managed to open his pants. It only took her a few minutes to get their cum flowing as she had plenty of practice now. Her movements were mechanical and instinctual. Euphoria filled her, but she fought it back as she slurped down the baby batter and extracted it with her tail.

Her tail finished first, and she stood as it unlatched from her first victim. She caught her breath quickly as she made her way to the third man, and her tail quickly whipped over to attach onto the second man’s cock to finish him off. It did not take her long to get the third man’s pants down around his thighs and take him into her mouth. The second man ran dry as the third man grew hard and started to throb in her mouth a little.

Vesper stood and took a deep breath as her tail quickly latched onto the third man’s dick. Vesper looked for Aria but did not see her at first. The other girl soon appeared holding Carson hostage with a dagger to his throat and his arm pinned behind his back. Aria smiled and said.

“Look what I found—human trash.”

Vespera giggled and replied, “Nice work, Aria. We probably shouldn’t kill him, though.”

Carson smiled and gave her a careful nod as he replied, “Yes, you’re a smart monster, that’s for sure. Killing me here will only make you both criminals. I’m well known and highly respected in this kingdom. If you kill me, my benefactors will avenge me and see that you’re properly hunted and punished.”

Aria pressed her blade to his throat a little and said, “Nobody asked you. You’re just making me want to kill you more, asshole.”

Vesper giggled again and said, “Calm down, Aria. He can’t enslave me. I’m immune to enslavement magic. I earned the skill Defiant Spirit right after I spawned.”

He raised a brow and said, “Just because a collar doesn’t work, doesn’t mean you can’t be enslaved… Don’t think that skill makes you safe.”

“If you come after me again, I will kill you regardless of the consequences. Marescape.”

[-155 mana]

The succubus felt faint as the mana escaped her. Black energy emitted from Carson’s eyes as he went limp in Aria’s arms. The fox girl slowly lowered him to the ground before she looked back up at the succubus surprised. As he started to wail in his sleep, Aria asked.

“What did you do to him, Vesper?”

“I sent him to his own personal hell… At least, for now.”

Aria laughed and sighed before she casually replied, “We better get going.”

Vesper grabbed her backpack and put it on. As the two girls walked through the quiet forest, Aria took Vesper by the hand. She felt awkward as the silence grew between them, but decided not to press. 

‘Aria is the best. I wouldn’t know what to do without her.’ Her status windows opened, and she scanned the changes as they walked. ‘Wow, my mana is over my maximum… Wait, did it just decrease?’ She watched her mana for a minute. ‘Yep, it just decreased again—maybe it bleeds out of me over time when I fill it past the threshold.’

_________________________________________________________

Level: 15 (272/1,290) Vitality: 220/220 Mana: 803/260 

Anima Reservoir: 1325/6720 Nourishment Upkeep: -28 anima/hour 

~Attributes~

Strength: 16 Agility: 30 Endurance: 22 

Intelligence: 23 Will: 23 Wit: 21 Charm: 34

__________________________________________________________

Aria squeezed her hand and spoke, sounding disheartened, “I can’t believe Tomas tried to sell you off. I heard him make the deal with you, and it’s not like you didn’t pay your way. I’ll never work for him again.”

Vesper swallowed hard and took a deep breath before she replied, “It was a surprise to me, too. I mean, we weren’t close, but I thought we had a mutual understanding. I know I’m worth a lot as a slave, but I’m not an object to be sold. I’m a free person, and I don’t belong to him.”

“Yeah, I’m sorry you have to deal with all that. I’m not sure life will be any easier for you in the city. I heard there are sentient monsters, but they’re treated like second-class citizens and there’s not exactly a lot of you running around.”

“Well, I don’t want to live in the woods and feed off other monsters. I’d rather have give and take relationships like I formed with Dargo and Veldar. They did right by me back there… I hope they’re okay.”

“They’re both a lot tougher than they look. I’m sure they’ll be fine.”

“I still feel bad for leaving them behind like that.”

“Don’t feel bad—they wanted you to escape. Going back would ruin their sacrifice.”

Vesper looked at her with a worried expression as she said, “You just said they’d live, though. What do you mean?”

Aria shrugged and replied, “They’ll survive, but the way that slaver was talking…”

“What?”

“They’ll probably be arrested.”

Vesper stopped and said, “Now we have to go back.”

Aria tilted her head and gave her a look of endearment as she said, “No, Vesper. Listen to me, we need to get you somewhere safe. Those two can take care of themselves, and I can look into getting them out of trouble once you're safe. If we go back now, then you and I will be in trouble too.”

Vespera gave her a dead stare for a moment and sighed before she started walking again. The gate came into view as they exited the forest, and there were several guards in platemail with spears at the entrance. She distracted herself by reading the changes on her skill list.

___________________________________________________________

~Skills~

…

Anima Conversion (Rank 5)...

Anima Reservoir (Rank 4)...

Allure (Rank 5)...

Prehensile Tail (Rank 4): Grants conscious motor control over the tail, allowing intermediate coordination.

Succubus Embrace (Rank 4): The spaded tip of the tail now opens up… Can now also sting victims at will, causing temporary paralysis for two hours.

Razor Claws (Rank 2): Nails can morph into claws with razor sharp edges and back to normal at will.

Mesmerize (Rank 1): When hungry or angry, the succubus’s eyes have a chance to hypnotize their prey.

_______________________________________________________________

Aria led her up to the gate as Vespera finished reading the changes to her skills. ‘Looks like most of it just got stronger, but now I have claws and even a stinger. Mesmerize sounds useful, too. I hope I don’t have to use any of it…’ The guards did not stop them, and the two girls walked further down the street. The city inside the walls was massive and appeared to go on forever.

In the distance a giant castle rose up behind another wall. The buildings were mostly made of wood, but a few were made of stone, and all of them were at least two stories tall. Some buildings were four stories tall. People of all different races crowded the cobblestone streets and brick sidewalks. Carts, food stalls, carriages, and the occasional wagon appeared at random as they walked down the busy street. 

Several alleyways and smaller streets branched off between buildings in a grid pattern that went on and on. Vesper held on tight to Aria’s hand, and her heart started to pound with anxiety as she was led further in, down one of the other streets. In the distance, she noticed another huge stone structure about a third of the size of the castle. It had three floors and lots of windows, towering over the brick wall that surrounded it. 

“That’s the magic academy my brother studies at,” Aria explained.

Vesper followed the fox girl down an alleyway. They turned left down another, and then right. After walking for what felt like ten minutes, they came to a tall building in the grid of alleyways with a wooden door. Aria opened it and led her inside, pulling her up a long stairwell to the fourth floor. They passed several doors as each floor had five. At the top, she knocked on a door with the number seventeen painted on it.

Chapter Five ~ a Summoner’s Terms

The door opened to reveal a man wearing a bathrobe, who appeared to be eighteen or nineteen. He had short and messy red hair with fox ears that twitched as he saw Vesper and leaned to the side to take her in. His smile slowly grew into a grin as his blue eyes lit up. With excitement, he spoke casually with his sister.

“Woah, sis! You didn’t have to bring me a gift. She’s bangin’! Where’d you find a succubus?”

“Shut up—she’s not a gift, dork.”

Vesper took a few steps back from him and said, “I’m not an object.”

His mouth dropped open as his eyes went wide, and he looked at his sister as he said, “She can talk. Holy mother of Eris. She can talk,” as his sister gave him a slow nod with a disappointed gleam in her eyes, he looked at Vesper again and continued, “I’m sorry. Please, forgive me. I thought you were a normal monster. You’re absolutely right—you’re not an object. Some of my best friends are monsters. Please, come in and make yourself comfortable.”

He quickly turned around and took four long steps across the room to a small table and picked up a pair of black fingerless gloves. Aria grabbed her hand and led Vesper inside, closing the door behind them. The succubus studied the strange man with curiosity in her eyes as he turned around, standing straight and wearing the fingerless gloves. The fox man made several hand gestures using both hands in front of his chest before he brought his hands up in front of his face making a box around his right eye with his fingers.

Aria narrowed her eyes at him and asked, “What are you doing, Quinton?”

He did not answer her but spoke several minutes later, “Holy mother of Eris. Not only is she a named monster, but she’s pretty high level. Her skills are amazing, and her stats aren’t bad for a mage type monster. I can’t believe she has a title and a unique skill! Immune to pact, tamed, and enslaved effects. That’s intense!”

“Will you stop acting like a kid in a candy shop for ten minutes… She’s in trouble and needs your help.”

Vesper’s eyes darted around the messy apartment as she meekly asked, “How do you know all those things about me?”

He dropped his hands and smiled as he said, “I used one of my summoner spells, Identify Monster. It shows me all your information. It’s a pleasure to meet you, Vespera the Unbroken. Now what can I do for you?”

She finally looked at him again and replied, “I need a place to stay. Slavers are chasing me.”

His eyebrows raised and he pursed his lips before he shook his head as he answered frankly, “Sorry, I can’t help you. The laws around here regarding monsters are pretty strict. You either have to be tamed, in a pact, under contract, or enslaved. The only way you can be free here is if you get a master that’s kind enough to free you and give you the proper paperwork associated with it. 

“If my friends or I gave you a place to stay, then we would be aiding an illegal monster resident and could be put in prison for several years. In fact, I think you should leave and not get my sister involved any further. I’m not trying to be mean, but you need to understand we’re all in danger because of you right now.”

Aria started yelling at him, “What do you mean?! That’s a load of…”

Vesper’s hearing went out as her head started to spin and tears started to flow down her cheeks. ‘Is my life really a joke? What am I supposed to do? I have to be a slave? I can’t be free unless I live wild? How will I learn who I am?’ She started to turn around and reach for the door, but someone grabbed her wrist. She quickly turned around to see Quinton talking, holding her wrist as her hearing slowly returned.

“... finish… Let’s have a talk.”

She shook her head and said, “I’m sorry. I didn’t catch all of that.”

“I said ‘Wait, let me finish. Let’s have a talk.’ Why don’t you come sit down for just a moment. I can tell you’re a little overwhelmed and under a lot of stress. Maybe I can help you if you’re willing to negotiate. I should also explain some things you probably don’t understand.”

Vespera’s eyes darted around a little before she sniffled and quietly said, “Okay.”

He led her to a couch and sat down beside her before he explained, “The law is very strict, but there are loopholes. One is to be bought by a friend, who has the money and influence to provide you with the proper freedom paperwork. This requires you to be enslaved, though. That’s not possible for you. Another way is to form a pact with a summoner or be tamed by a tamer. Those two are impossible for you as well. 

“Summoners like me do have one other option when forming a magical bond with a monster. Pacts are formed without the monster’s consent, forceful by nature, and most monsters don’t have intelligence, so it’s the most common type of bond summoners use. We can also form a magical contract. These are fundamentally different from pacts because both parties must agree on terms. It’s also the only way you can stay in the city without being hunted by the constables.

“Contracts require a lot of special materials and a ritual—they’re very expensive to perform. They’re used when dealing with powerful and intelligent monsters like yourself. For example, a vampire or a dragon. These creatures, like you, can resist a pact and communicate most of the time. I do have the materials myself, but… I’ll just be honest, I was saving them in case I ever met a dragon.

“I never thought I’d meet a named succubus, though. You’re a very powerful monster in your own way, so I might be willing to help you if you form a contract with me. Now before you object, that will mean that I technically own you according to the law, but we can write up the contract so you’ll have most of your freedoms intact.”

Vesper slowly calmed down as she listened before she took a deep breath and said, “Okay, explain this contract magic. What does it mean, and what will you expect of me at the bare minimum?”

He slowly nodded and explained further, “Well, the contract can take many forms, but let’s just get this out of the way. Summoners use monsters to fight, so if I need you in a battle you’ll have to help. You’ll have to obey me in combat, but I can write it in our contract that you don’t have to obey me outside of combat. 

“Normally, a summoner’s minions live in another dimensional space formed from the pact or contract. You’ll have one, too, but I can write it in your contract that you don’t have to use it. When I summon you, you will have to answer my call. The magic will bring you to me but it can’t send you anywhere except the dimensional space created by the contract.

“I can also cast spells on you to heal you or boost your abilities but I have no combat spells myself. Summoner magic is actually one of the most difficult to learn, and I’m really not all that smart so I decided to focus on one school of magic. If you form a contract with me, I’d also be willing to help provide you with food. 

“I’m aware of your dietary needs and have taken several classes on monster ecology. So, I might even know more about your species than you do. I can even charge people to let you feed on them and give you a predetermined cut of the earnings. Though, I will be taking a small cut for arranging it since it’ll take time and effort. Outside of combat, you’ll be free to do as you please as long as you’re not breaking any local laws.”

“That’s a lot to take in… Normally, I’d just say no but knowing I’ll be hunted if I don’t… I’ll do it. Don’t trick me, though. I want a fair contract. Just like you said. I want freedom and all of it. I’ll help you fight if you protect my freedom.”

“Sis, you don’t have to worry about Vespera. I’ll talk things out with her, and treat her fairly. If you’re tired, you can go to sleep. This will take a while.”

Aria sighed and sat down in the armchair nearby as she replied frankly, “Vesper is my friend. I love her okay? She’s like a sister to me, so I’ll stay right here and make sure you don’t behave like an idiot. She’s not a bad monster and deserves to be treated with dignity… I’m also pretty sure she stopped me from doing something that would have landed me in prison. So, I owe her.”

Quinton’s eyebrows rose as his left ear twitched, and he replied, “Okay, noted,” he looked back at Vesper and asked her directly, “I need to know everything you’ve done since you spawned that might get you in trouble. Everything, and you can’t lie or I won’t be able to protect you. Examples include murder, slaughtering a village, stealing, and anything like that. I need details, too. How long has it been since you spawned?”

Vesper hesitated and looked down as she started playing with her hands nervously and replied quietly, “I spawned about four days ago. After I spawned, two monster hunters found me, and one grabbed me by the tail. One said to kill me, but the other said I would bring more gold if they sold me. They roughed me up a little and said they were going to rape me, so I put them to sleep,” she paused and choked up a little as she continued, “I was starving… so I fed on them. I was mad too, so I killed them afterward and took their things.”

Aria blinked and said, “Holy shit, Vesper. You’ve been through a lot.”

Quinton pressed his lips together and said, “Sounds like self-defense to me. Did anyone see you do it?”

Vespera slowly shook her head and said, “I don’t think so. If they did, they never revealed themselves.”

“Okay, so that never leaves this room. Never tell anyone about it again. That goes for you too, Aria. Anything else?”

Aria gave her brother a quick nod as Vesper started to explain, “Well, before we came here Tomas tried to sell me to slavers and we ran away. Three of them attacked me in the woods, and I put them to sleep. Then I fed on them, but I didn’t kill them. Your sister caught the leader and was going to kill him, but I put him to sleep too and we ran here. Other than that, I’ve been a good girl—I promise.” 

He slowly nodded and said, “Okay, once we have a contract, I can protect you from the slavers. Tomas didn’t legally own you, right?”

She shook her head fervently and said, “No, I made a verbal agreement with him to pleasure him on the trip for a ride. Dargo, Veldar, and Aria were all witnesses. I kept my end of the agreement, and he tried to sell me once we got close to town.”

“Good, that’s really good,” he scratched his chin and paused before he asked, “Okay, what happened to Dargo and Veldar?” 

“They said I paid for their protection because I gave them pleasure, too. They fought the slavers while we escaped.”

“Sounds like we might have a few loose ends, but I can figure it out. I have a few friends in high places around here. We’ll find out what happened to Dargo and Veldar, okay? I can tell you’re worried about them.”

“What about Tomas, he’s still out there?”

His eyebrow raised as he replied, “What about Tomas? He’ll never bother you again, but there’s not much we can do about him. You’ll have to let it go.”

She slowly nodded and asked him, “I’m not happy but okay, so now what?”

Quinton stood and disappeared into the other room, returning several minutes later with a large box. He set it down by the table and sat back down as he opened it. He pulled out a thick piece of parchment with a purple hue, two cloth sacks, an inkwell with red ink, and a fancy looking pen with a gemstone on top. Each item was arranged neatly on the table as he talked. 

“Now we negotiate and form a magical contract. That’s the only way I can protect you. I’m guessing the terms I laid out before are acceptable?”

“This is still all a little much. Tell me again the terms, please?”

“You will consent to being my partner in battle, following my orders in combat, and being summoned by me. I will allow you the freedom to choose where you live and what you do outside of battle, within the bounds of local laws. You can also live with me here or inside the dimension created by our contract if you want. I won’t require you to follow orders outside of combat unless we’re training. You’ll be required to train with me at least twice a week, but I’d like to do more at first since you just spawned. 

“I’ll provide you with people to feed off and charge them a fee. I’ll keep twenty percent and you’ll get paid eighty percent of the earnings. I’ll also pay your yearly taxes, but you’ll be required to buy necessities and luxuries yourself. Of course, you’re free to choose your feeding partners for yourself, and I won’t make you feed off someone you don’t like. It will also be in our contract that you can’t use your spells on me or feed off me without my permission.”

“I agree. I like those terms, but will the required training be part of the contract?”

“Two times a week, yes. I’ll add a stipulation in there. Something like… for as long as I feel it's necessary. If you don’t need to train, we can stop training. You will be fighting battles for me. I want to be clear about that, because in just a few weeks there’s a school tournament. I’ll be entering this year. If we do well, then my friend can get me a job with the constables. That will help me keep you safe.”

“Okay, then I want it to be in my contract that you can only refer to me by my name or as your partner. I’m not a slave, servant, or a minion. I want to keep my freedom and identity. I also want it so you can’t trade my contract away without my permission.”

“I can do that. I’ll also include that the contract will end when I die, since you’ll probably live longer than me,” he picked up the pen and knocked a few books out of the way onto the floor as he carefully added, “Oh and it is standard for you to share ten percent of your combat experience with me. Otherwise, I won’t be able to level when we fight.”

She blinked and asked, “Really?”

“Yes, I’m a summoner—you’re my weapon. I told you I can’t fight on my own.”

“That doesn’t apply to experience from my skills, right?”

“You mean Anima Conversion?”

“Yeah…”

“Nope, it doesn’t apply to that. I only take from combat because we fight as a team and wouldn’t earn experience otherwise.”

She shrugged and said, “You can take half if you want. I gain a lot more from conversion.”

He looked at her with an eyebrow raised and asked, “Really?”

Vesper gave him a meek nod, and a smile grew on his lips. He opened the inkwell and dipped the tip of his pen in it before he started to write up the contract on the violet parchment. It took a while for him to finish as he drew tiny runes around the edges. At the bottom, he signed his name ‘Quinton Tia’Vior’ and dipped the pin again before he passed it to her.

She stared into his eyes as she hesitated to take the pen, and he spoke again, “Alright, you have to sign your full name and title. So, Vespera the Unbroken, right underneath my name.”

Vespera looked over the document and read it all carefully. Everything they agreed on was there, while some of it was worded a little differently. The first part especially, regarding her role to be his partner in combat. It was just more elaborate, including some sort of bond they would form as summon and summoner. Everything else was exactly as they agreed, but she still asked.

“Why is all this extra stuff in the beginning?”

“It’s part of the spell. We can’t form a contract without the bond, but it’s worded in the way we agreed upon, right?”

She hesitated and looked it over one more time before she admitted, “Yes. Sorry, I don’t mean to be picky. This just feels like it’s important. I don’t want to sign something I don’t understand.”

“I’m glad you’re taking it seriously. It is serious and will change both our lives. Hopefully, for the better. These terms are especially generous from what I was taught. 

“I’m putting a lot of trust in you, Vespera. The bond allows me to cast my special summoner spells on you to help you in combat but it also forms a link between us so we can communicate from a distance. It might take some getting used to but it’s essential for the contract to work and for us to be successful as a team.”

“Can I ask you to add something?”

“What?”

“I want you to add that you won’t let me starve. You said you’ll help me find food, but you also said that I need permission to feed off you. If there’s no other food and I’m starving, I want you to promise you’ll feed me.”

He hesitated but smiled and said, “Okay, Vesper. That’s fair.”

Quinton took the pen back and added the line to the bottom of the clauses. When she read it, it was very specific but added the condition like she asked. She quickly took the pen and added her name below his like he instructed. Vesper slowly sat back on the couch and handed him the pen back, appearing distant.

He moved the parchment over and grabbed the first sack, opening the top. He spread black sand from it in a line that formed a circle with an intricate pattern inside that twisted and swirled from the inside out with sharp turns. The process took him almost half an hour and he was very careful. 

Afterward he picked up the next sack and removed several large gemstones that were rough and uncut, placing them carefully around the edge of the pattern and toward the center in seven curved lines with one in the center. The summoner took a deep breath and carefully placed the parchment on top of the gemstones. He looked at her as he picked the pen back up and pulled a tiny brush out of the top by the gemstone as he said.

“Okay, where do you want my seal?”

Vesper tilted her head and asked, “Your seal?”

“The contract and bond have a physical representation on the summon—it's a seal that says you’re my partner. It should be visible, since it will be your proof that you can be here. Without it, someone else might try to tame or enslave you. Tamers and slavers use collars, but summoners use seals. If this were a pact, the seal would just magically appear on you but with a contract I have to put it on you myself.”

“Where does it usually go?”

“Well, a pact puts them on the forehead, but I thought you might want it in a place that looks better. Maybe your shoulder blade or collarbone? You want it in a place you can show someone if they ask, but also in a place that someone can’t easily cut off you. The legs, arms, hands, and feet will be targets for people who want to steal you. That’s why pact seals appear on the forehead by default.”

Her eyebrow raised on its own as she said, “This is a lot more complicated than I thought it would be.”

“Pacts are simpler, but contracts are complicated. Well?”

She let out a sigh and thought about it before she said, “How about on my neck under my ear?”

He smiled and said, “That’ll be cute, and you can hide it with your hair when it grows out. Okay, sit still for me. This has to be exactly right and this ink is expensive.”

He dipped the brush and moved in closer, moving her hair and tilting her head with one hand before he started working on her neck. Quinton was extremely careful and it took a long time as he dipped the brush several times, drawing the circle and pattern. The ink was wet and sticky, while the tip of the brush tickled her. She tried her best to sit still for him, and he stood as he finished.

He spoke again, “Alright, now stand beside me.”

She followed his instruction as he started performing complex gestures with his hands and fingers in front of his chest again. His eyes were closed, and he appeared hyperfocused. After about a minute of that, there was a loud sizzle from the table and green flames engulfed the parchment on the table. The mark on her neck grew warm and started to burn as she said.

“Ouch, what’s that about?”

He grabbed the parchment and handed it to her as he replied, “It’s done. The seal will be there until I die. We’re partners.”

Vesper took the parchment from him and realized there was a coating across it now that felt like glass. It was stiff and hard. The black powder and gemstones were gone from the table, only white ash remained. She handed it back to him as she asked.

“So, the contract is done? Is it indestructible now or something?”

Quinton accepted it back and explained, “Something like that, they can be destroyed but it takes a lot of power. The spell is that way on purpose. The contract and the seal are connected. If one is destroyed the other will be, too. I’ll deposit this at the bank associated with the academy for us. You can never be too safe, but for now you’re safe—and that’s what matters.”

Vesper slowly smiled at him and hugged him as she said, “Thank you, Quinton. I hope our partnership is a good one. I’ll do my best to support you in combat, I promise.”


r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

Starting a new story. Let me know what you think of the opening.

0 Upvotes

He ate with the same appetite he brought to a woman, shaking his great head from side to side, forcing his mouth deeper into the soft matter, slurping and sucking until there was little left worth taking. 
First, a blow with the tip of his blade where the forehead bent back to the skull, enough force to leave a crack. Then the rest was by fingers and teeth. Burying his face, chin scraping sinew and bone. 
Manners had deserted him long ago. They had gone with his first hungry bite of human flesh, and he had never found cause to mourn them.
By the time he had chewed the meat and reached the bones, hunger had ceased to matter. Rather it was the end of a contest between Hunter and human that kept him going.* *
I chased you. I caught you. I ate you. And now I shall break your bones between my teeth.
There was satisfaction in that. A last victory over a being that could neither flee nor fight.
And within those bones lay the finest prize of all.
Human marrow.
He cracked the larger bones with his powerful jaws, grinding through their hard shells until the soft richness within could be drawn out. He sucked. And sucked again. Turning fragments with his tongue, stopping to spit shards of bone from his mouth before returning to his work.
The others knew that sound.
Only when the cracking gave way to the long wet slurps, the others knew he was near the end, and they entered.
They came cautiously, their eyes moving between him and the remains. Some fell upon the scraps immediately. Others searched among the bodies for anything he had overlooked. A strip of flesh beneath an arm. The meat between ribs. A foot still carrying enough skin to warrant the trouble.
Spitting out a clot of hair and gristle, he watched them. Calloused fingers raked through his beard, catching caked blood before jerking free. Still, he watched them.  
Do not muck the hair of the long one, it will do good to cover my root. 
He settled into the cracked crevice of erosion, a perfect shape for him to let his legs split, belly hang and arms dangle. A grunt let out of both celebration from a fine meal and the energy expended. 
Three men had supplied this particular feast. Two had been skin and bone. There was no pleasure in such meat, though he had enjoyed worrying the scraps from the hallows and grooves of the skeleton. The last, a bloated man. Calfs ballooned over ankles and blubber from the belly stretched over his tiny pizzle. There weren't many larders around these days which made this yield even more special. The softbelly would last for several days. They would return to his carcass again and again, much as the ocean devils returned to the bloated corpse of a whale.   


r/writingfeedback • • 5h ago

General Feedback Wanted Feedback on Chapter one of My Dark Fantasy

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

About 10k words into book 1 of a new fantasy series I'm writing. This first book is called the devil of Magarak, and is set in a sengoku type era fictionalized Japan. I still have to do a little bit of clean up with this first chapter but i really like what i have so far.

Any feedback would be appreciated but i really want to know if the intro gripped you at all and fi the action was easy enough to follow.


r/writingfeedback • • 5h ago

General Feedback Wanted My first ever short story "Leave a mark as you go" title is to submit to a reeds contest

1 Upvotes

5th & Wesson, away from the busy traffic at 1st & Woodbury but not quite as in the boonies as 11th & MLK. I stand in a row of 5, which is how people know we were erected to fill a need, being that we stood more than two or three. Meant to be of real use and paid for with tax dollars from the people who shall sit in us, and boy, did they ever sit. Some of them rushed in through the door sweating & swearing. Muttering to their god, first time or practiced plea is unknown to me. All I know is their hurry subsides as soon as they close my door & open my lid. Then they stay a long while and add their musings to the inside of my stall walls.

None of us remain unsullied by humanity being forced to remain still & ponder in the semi-private space we create for them. A solitary third space of biological necessity. They uncap their markers & pens to leave their mark where they know there will be a captive audience.

Many of them draw the same symbol, beginning with 2 touching circles, you know the one, created to abstract anatomy. Then there are the ones with more chrome than me on their face who use their Posca pens & white highlighters to engage in the same crudeness with a more self important expression. They are doing essentially the same thing but, with more tools & skill, they feel they have a claim to the cultural high ground. That they are making a commentary on the practice & telling a story of humanity in which they are the benevolent narrators. All of which is mierda since a dick & balls are a dick & balls no matter how good you are at drawing.

Those who esteem themselves a little higher use their alcohol felt pens as they ponder. The latest philosophers to sit upon marble (or, in this case, porcelain) thinking of questions that both sound deep & can be deep. Many obsess over dead Russians & ponder the meaning of life. "Why do I earn to eat only for it to return to the toilet? I may as well dump it straight in."

"My natural purpose will likely have been achieved by my uncle getting me a job at his hedge firm, so everything else that I do is unnatural. We built the matrix because we don’t have enough barriers to success."

"Who am I achieving success for? My dog already eats like a king."

Many others reflect on their relationships, at least those that aren't arguing on the phone with their family while disturbing ginger Picasso 3 doors down. Or the unlucky saps who need to use our government mandated changing table, which costs the taxpayer up to $3,150 (Yes truly).

"Does my mom love the adult I have become?"

"Why is moving so scary? I don't know anyone & I still need people."

"Why does my BF limp after going out on a boy’s night?"

"There are up to 40 new people I see a day and none of them know I stole Minion playing cards from Walmart."

"To be liked is just as important as being loved. After all, some people still love their abusive drunkard fathers."

"My dad is gay."

"I just want to find love in a hopeless place."

I take a personal offense at the last one (if I had feelings, or do I? Does every public toilet? Think about that next time you scroll Sonic Rule 34 on your lunchbreak Carl), because after writing that, he, because of course it's a he, started asking the girl washing her hands if she had a Snapchat. This is a very hopeful place, Marcelo. Also gender neutral if you noticed. Some of the notes on my walls have even raised hope in my flushometer valve (heart).

"Start my new job today!!!"

"She said yes, even without a ring!"

"I am getting pegged tonightttt!!!" (followed by stick figure drawings that I assume is giving us the night's gameplan).

"You are loved" (drawing of a heart).

"You matter" (Drawing of a pie sliced in five pieces?).

"I found my son."

“I am the son, where is my child support” (arrow pointing to prior entry).

"She's my soulmate" (pretty sure that's a grilled cheese next to it)

"To the weary depositor, let me tell you a tale. It is my 77th birthday today which I spent burying my wife, & I couldn't be happier.

We met at my uncle's picnic in early autumn & I couldn't take my eyes off her or her corduroy scarf. I found my courage and we went on 2 dates, one at Johnny Rockets & another at Das Malts. With her, my heart would sing & I could see in full color after years of grey. Smitten was an understatement & in love was only the start of my feelings for her.

Before I could ask her to marry me, I was drafted into the Vietnam War & shipped away before her family could return from the Pocono Mountains. War was just that...war. I tried to keep my hands free of blood by enrolling as a medic and skirting the front lines. Through circumstances unknown to me, the Chicago 7 read my name among the deceased & my sweetheart thought me dead. Upon returning, I could not find her until I spoke to the bowling alley manager. Her family had returned to Vermont, which is where I booked my next ticket. Instead of happiness when I found her, there was a rueful smile and tears as she showed me she had no hair left on her head. ‘Cancer,’ she told me, the word more hot & heavy than any bullet I took.

She wanted me to go home & enjoy freedom instead of the front lines of her war. To chase skirts swishing behind girls with curls and whole lungs. I told her that was impossible because she was the home I fought for. We spent the summer in cafes, by lakes and amongst weeping willows with tire swings. I married her every day in a small ceremony for the birds and frogs. ‘For every day I will need to be away from you, I will marry you again’ I told her when she rolled her eyes. Toward the end of the summer, she tried harder & harder to hide from me, worried about my heartache. Each time I would find her faster and faster. ‘I will never stop looking for you,’ I told her as I put her hand to my heart, ‘till the end of my days’. This heart is strong I told her, Nam couldn't stop it after all. In late autumn, we heard there had been a new discovery in Hodgkin's lymphoma and she was able to get a first treatment. Her smile was bright after the surgery. She asked me for a redo before hugging me tight, ‘Welcome back from Vietnam, weary soldier. You look like you could use a warm bed and three tight hugs a day’.

So I was very happy to bury her now at age 77 instead of 27."

A touching tale that took up all of my south wall. The author, a middle schooler named Agnes in a Carhartt hoodie, has a great literary career ahead of her as long as she doesn't let the Blue Razz do her in.

As you saw in some of the earlier entries & my penis grumble earlier, drawings fill up just as much space on my walls as the words. Some of my patrons are too in awe of my library of respite to find their own voice to add, so they draw their additions. Grease pens, paint pens, markers, sharpies, even chalk found its way onto my walls, but the worst by far was the 15 year-old, denim clad delinquent that rattled his can & engaged in the most noxious of dick art.

After his masterpiece session, my next visitor had both the art and an ambulance ride, due to the fumes inducing a fainting spell, to appreciate. The graffiti goblin had not left yet when the body hit the floor and had enough chivalry to make the call. Clearly, the swift consequences were taken to heart: he never returned for the paint he had stashed in the trash before the paramedics came. Agnes survived the ordeal since she was able to return & finish her entry, the cretin's denim jacket with a Basquiat pin over her hoodie. The cretin only returned once, to write "I did" under his hopeless place wish from before.

Still taking offense.


r/writingfeedback • • 5h ago

General Feedback Wanted The prologue of my sapphic historical psychological thriller novel

Post image
1 Upvotes

Looking for alpha readers who are interested. Current novel is about 41,000 words


r/writingfeedback • • 5h ago

General Feedback Wanted Is this engaging?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

All feedback is welcome! I’m not a good judge of my own writing. Is it too slow? Too wordy? Not engaging? Thank you!! It’s Dark Fantasy:)


r/writingfeedback • • 8h ago

General Feedback Wanted Is this an improvement from the last one I posted?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

The first 3 pages of the short story.


r/writingfeedback • • 10h ago

General Feedback Wanted Just a first draft for a short film about a character that I plan to use again later in a feature length script. It is still an early-ish draft and not perfect, but I still just want some opinions and feedback on what I have

0 Upvotes

INT-House in Düsseldorf-September 23rd, 1914

A mother covered in soot and surrounded by the remains of her decimated house after the September 22nd Düsseldorf bombing: as her husband (HEINRICH GUSTAFEN) searches the rubble of their home with a couple friends.

The mother (FRIEDA GUSTAFEN) cradles the silent newborn FRIEDERICH GUSTAFEN)

Heinrich: Das ganze oberste Stockwerk ist am Arsch (The entire top floor is f#cked)

Friend #1: Eine Standuhr gefunden. Könnte sie jetzt wahrscheinlich verkaufen, da dein Tresor weg ist. (Found a grandfather clock. Could probably sell it now that your safe is gone)

Another man comes from the basement.

Friend #2: Du hattest Glück, hier unten ist eigentlich alles in Ordnung. Nimm Frieda’s Porzellan weg. (you've gotten lucky, everything down here is pretty much fine. take away Frieda's China)

Heinrich: Du kannst die Uhr geben, wenn du willst, das verdammte Ding ist kaputt, seit wir es bekommen haben. (you can have the clock if you want, damned thing has been broken since we got it)

Heinrich kneels with Frieda, kissing her forehead before resting his own on hers.

Heinrich: wir werden okay sein, Frieda, wir können bei meinem Bruder Rolf bleiben, bis wir ein neues Zuhause finden. (we'll be okay Frieda, we can stay with my brother Rolf until we can find a new home)

Frieda: Aber ich will nicht bei Rolf bleiben, ich will unser Zuhause. (But I don't want to stay with Rolf, I want our home)

Heinrich smiles.

Heinrich: Was stimmt nicht mit Rolf? (What’s wrong with Rolf?)

Frieda gives a weak chuckle and the crunch of the now ashen wood under the friend's foot takes us to 1933.

EXT-Düsseldorf Street-April 1st 1933

We have a following shot of Friederich walking through the streets of Düsseldorf as SA stormtroopers coat the streets, all bearing anti-sematic signs as he watches a Jewish shopkeeper thrown through his shop window.

The stormtroopers who through him come out of his store and spit and laugh at him as they walk by.

Friederich uses the boycott distraction to drag him to an alley unseen and rests him against the wall.

Friederich: Geht es Ihnen gut, Herr Portnoy? (Are you okay, Mr. Portnoy?)

Mr. Portnoy winces at the glass resting in his side.

Mr. Portnoy: Nicht meine beste Stunde, aber auch nicht meine dunkelste. (Not my finest hour, but not my darkest either.)

The two have a small chuckle as Friederich runs to the store and comes back with bandages and a beer.

Friederich: Hier, Sir, ich würde Ihnen ein Zeichen geben, wenn ich eine entbehren könnte (here sir, I'd give you mark if I could spare you one)

Mr. Portnoy shrugs him off.

Mr. Portnoy: Freundlichkeit kostet nichts, mein Junge. (There is no cost for kindness my boy)

Friederich removes the glass and bandages him as Mr. Portnoy drinks the beer.

Mr. Portnoy: Weißt du, ich habe meiner Frau versprochen, dass ich nicht mehr in solche Situationen geräte, wenn der Krieg vorbei ist. Ich schätze, das ist mein Preis dafür, dass ich das anmaße. (Y’know, I promised my wife I would stop getting in these situations when the war ended. Guess this is my price for assuming)

Friederich: Du bist ein harter Kerl, weil du überhaupt überlebt hast. (You're a tough bastard for surviving anyway)

Mr. Portnoy frowns at him.

Mr. Portnoy: Sprache, mein Junge. (Language, my boy)

The two let out a smile as a gunshot fires us into the next scene.

EXT-Düsseldorf market-August 1st, 1935

Friederich leaps onto a cart stand wearing a swastika armband with a taped-on x.

Friederich: Hört mich jetzt, meine deutschen Brüder! Wir alle stehen unter der Kontrolle einer meisterhaft ausgeklügelten Täuschung! Hitler ist kein Gott und er ist nicht unser Führer! Ich bitte euch, durchschaut seine Lügen und beendet den Wahnsinn dieser nazistischen, idiopathischen Diktatur! Es lebe der Widerstand! (Hear me now my German brothers! We are all under the control of a beautifully crafted deceit! Hitler is no God and he is no leader of ours! See through his lies I beg of you and end the madness of this Nazi idiopathic dictatorships! Hail resistance!)

He hears the stomps of running SA boots and runs down, only to be dragged into an alley by Mr. Portnoy who takes him to a side entrance that contains his family.

Mr. Portnoy: Bist du verrückt, Junge! (Are you mad, boy!)

Friederich is still in shock from the sudden grab.

Mr. Portnoy: Versuchst du, dich erschießen zu lassen? (Are you trying to get yourself shot?)

Friederich stammers but composes himself.

Friederich: Erwarten Sie von mir, dass ich nichts tue, während sie mein Land entehren und Ihr Volk verfolgen? (Do you expect me to do nothing as they bastardise my country and persecute your kind?)

Mr. Portnoy sighs.

Mr. Portnoy: Ich weiß, dass du es gut meinst, aber das ist kein Kampf für einen Einzelnen, und es ist auch nicht deine Aufgabe, deiner Mutter das Leben noch schwerer zu machen, als du es ohnehin schon getan hast. (I know you mean well but this is not one man's fight, nor is it your job to make your mother's life even harder than you already have.)

Friederich: Das ist größer als ich und meine Mutter. (This is bigger than me and mum)

Mr. Portnoy has not got fight in him.

Mr. Portnoy: Nutzt die Gassen und eilt nach Hause. Und sei dir bewusst, dass ich nicht jedes Mal da sein kann, um dich zu retten, wenn du die Wut der Nazis herausforderst. (Use the alleys and scurry home. And know I cannot be there to save you every time you tempt the Nazi's fury)

Friederich gives Mr. Portnoy’s son (Hans) a reciprocated glance before leaving.

The door's lock clicking and taking us to February 4th, 1938.

INT-Run down house in Düsseldorf-NIGHT

Friederich rushes downstairs in his sleepwear as his father is forced outside by an SS officer.

SS officer: Herr Gustafen, Sie stehen wegen der Verbreitung von Anti-Führer-Materialien vor Gericht, wie plädieren Sie? (Mr. Gustafen, you are on trial for the distribution of anti-Führer materials, how do you plead?)

Frieda is being restrained by two stormtroopers, yelling and kicking and begging for her husband’s life. Heinriche looks at Friederich one last time, knowing his son is guilty but not wanting him to die. Friederich stays silent at the bottom of the stairs. Mouthing an apology to his father.

Frieda watches with tears in her eyes as her husband is put at gunpoint and knows him too well to expect him to rat out their son.

Heinriche: Schuldiger, unmenschlicher Hund (guilty, inhuman dog)

The instant ring of the execution takes to 1940.

INT-Store basement-November 17th, 1940

Friederich sits at the table with the family of Mr. Portnoy, eating scraps from the kindly new owner's lunch and dinner.

They eat in silence, Friederich writing in a notebook and never moving his body. Only once does he look from his works to spot Hans staring at him with a deep concern that seems to bury itself deep in Friederich's dust covered eyes. He reaches for Friederich’s hand but is distracted when his father asks him about the food.

Friederich’s blink takes us to 1943.

INT-Store basement-August 2nd, 1943

Friederich is awoken by the sound of a gunshot and a body collapsing to the floor. He turns in his bed to see Mr. Portnoy lying still in the ground.

His body rested next to the kindly shop owner that kept them hidden for as long as he could.

Amoure Plastique plays as we get a slow-motion montage of the family's tears and Friederich's silent compliance as he is dragged into the back of the truck, holding onto Hans's arm just to keep himself from collapsing both physically and mentally.

But he cannot stop Hans from rushing the officers and getting riddled with pistol shells.

Friederich still stays silent.

His face just reads pure nihility.

The song remains playing as we cut to April 29th, 1945

Friederich stays silent as American soldiers surround him, reassuring him with words too muffled for the audience to hear.

The sound of an American gun ripping through a guards chest takes us to 1949 as Friederich shakes hands with Leonard Montefiore, as he holds his bestselling autobiography and a sign above them celebrates the opening of Friederich's charity for holocaust survivors.

The song climaxes as we see Friederich heading into the Sicilian Ballroom and the bottom of the screen reads 1955.

The credits roll as Hai già vinta la causa! Plays


r/writingfeedback • • 12h ago

General Feedback Wanted Please give me some critical constructive criticism and feedback on the first chapter of my novel (A brief history of old man McGunderson)

1 Upvotes

Chapter 1: The Beginning of Time and All Its Problems
Before there was light, there was McGunderson. And before there was cosmic noise, there was the sound of McGunderson complaining about the endless abyss being too dark, too lonely, and altogether too drafty.
He had been floating in that black nothing for longer than any clock could measure, which was convenient, because clocks had not been invented yet and would not have helped anyway. McGunderson drifted, turned, tumbled, and occasionally tried to sit, only to discover that sitting required something to sit on. There was nothing. Not a rock, not a cloud, not so much as a polite suggestion of solid ground. He kicked his legs in the pure dark and windmilled his arms until his shoulders ached, which was also inconvenient, because he had no idea what shoulders were for or why they should hurt when there was nothing to lean on.
After several eternities spent grumbling to himself, McGunderson finally decided that something ought to be done about it. So he stood up.
Unfortunately, there was no ground to stand on.
In the endless void, McGunderson began drifting in earnest—turning over, under, and around in a desperate attempt to find his footing. He kicked, flailed, and generally made a thorough fool of himself, though he took some small comfort in the fact that nobody had been invented yet to witness it. The silence pressed in on every side. It was the sort of silence that made a man feel very small and very old, even if he could not remember ever being young.
He began cursing in a language that both time and he himself would eventually forget. The words tumbled out of him in a rising tide of irritation. Then, in the absolute silence of the void, with nothing to cover up the sound or blame it on, McGunderson passed gas.
It was no ordinary gas. It began to spark, collapsing inward upon itself before detonating in a blinding flash that illuminated the cosmos. For the first time, McGunderson could see himself: a plump, wrinkled old man with pale-peach skin, covered from head to toe in snow-white fuzz. He did not remember becoming this old. Then again, he did not remember ever being young, either, so he decided not to dwell on it. More pressing was the fact that he was rocketing away from the blast at several times the speed of light.
He hurtled past nascent galaxies and swirling dust clouds, past knots of glowing matter that would one day become stars, past the first tentative swirls of something that looked suspiciously like it might become interesting later. McGunderson watched it all streak by with the mild annoyance of a man who had just been late for an appointment he had never scheduled. He eventually reached what appeared to be the edge of the universe. Unfortunately, he did not stop there. He punched right through it, looped inexplicably around the other side, and began hurtling straight back toward a newly forming planet.
This was, as far as McGunderson was concerned, a terribly inconvenient turn of events. He crashed into the Earth with the sort of force that rearranges continents, shearing off a massive chunk of debris that settled into orbit as the Moon. The impact left a crater the size of a small country. He lay in the middle of it, rather pleased with himself, though he was not entirely sure what he had just accomplished. All he knew was that his lower back was throbbing and he needed a nap.
Eventually, McGunderson hauled himself up and attempted to walk. He was terrible at it. Without control over his legs or his center of gravity, he flopped around like a fish out of water—assuming the fish had knobbly knees and was furiously kicking rocks. The ground was soft and warm and smelled of new earth. He took three steps, fell, took four more, fell again, and decided that walking was an overrated skill that the universe would probably invent a better version of later.
While flailing to stay upright, McGunderson accidentally smooshed a butterfly.
Horrified by his carelessness, he scooped up the tiny creature and attempted to comfort it. When that failed, he tried performing CPR, blowing earnestly into what he assumed was the butterfly’s mouth—though he was not entirely certain whether butterflies had mouths, let alone where one might be kept. In his enthusiasm, he inhaled sharply and swallowed it.
It was a rough few days for McGunderson after that. The fuzzy, powdery taste of butterfly refused to leave his tongue no matter how many times he spat or scraped his teeth against his sleeve. He eventually crawled across the dusty plains in search of water, not because he was thirsty, but because the aftertaste had become a personal insult. Rounding a ridge, he spotted a watering hole—and beside it stood a stegosaurus.
McGunderson froze. He had never seen anything quite like it: four sturdy legs, a spiked tail, and a magnificent row of bony plates running down its back. At last, he thought. Somebody else. He had been alone for an eternity—which, given the circumstances, was a literal measurement—and he was determined to make a friend.
He slowly pulled himself upright, a process involving significant grunting and one deeply undignified fall onto his backside. The stegosaurus lifted its head.
McGunderson beamed. “Well, hello there!”
The stegosaurus stared at him. McGunderson waved. The dinosaur took a cautious step backward, so McGunderson waved with both hands, hoping to project warmth and trustworthiness. The stegosaurus let out a low, uncertain rumble.
“Yes, yes! That’s the spirit!” McGunderson exclaimed. “I knew you’d be pleased to see me.”
The stegosaurus promptly turned around and walked away.
“Now, hold on a minute,” McGunderson frowned. “That’s no way to make friends!”
He hurried after it. The stegosaurus quickened its pace; McGunderson quickened his. Before long, the dinosaur was sprinting, and McGunderson was lumbering behind in what could generously be described as a series of controlled forward collapses.
“Wait! Come back!” he shouted. “I haven’t even told you my name! It’s McGunderson!”
The dinosaur let out a distressed bellow and ran faster.
“Well, you don’t have to be rude about it!”
Neither of them noticed the shadow emerging from the treeline ahead. It was an Allosaurus, its muscular body crouched low, eyes locked onto the fleeing stegosaurus. It had been stalking the area for hours, and its intentions were considerably less neighborly than McGunderson’s.
McGunderson skidded to a halt. “Oh, hello! Another one!” He waved cheerfully. The predator remained dead still, watching the stegosaurus approach. “Well, aren’t you a quiet one?”
Before the stegosaurus could veer away, the Allosaurus lunged.
The attack happened so fast McGunderson barely registered it. The stegosaurus stumbled as the predator struck, swinging its spiked tail wildly in defense. For a moment, McGunderson watched in mild confusion. He had never seen two locals interact in such an aggressive manner before.
“Now, now!” he called out. “There’s no need for all this!”
The Allosaurus ignored him. Realizing this was less of a lively debate and more of a murder attempt, McGunderson marched toward them, puffing out his chest to look authoritative. “HEY! That’s quite enough of that!”
The Allosaurus paused and turned its massive head toward him. McGunderson stopped marching. The apex predator stared. McGunderson stared back.
“Well,” McGunderson said quietly, taking a step backward. “I suppose you two have some business to attend to.”
He took another step back. He had never been particularly good at mediating disputes, especially when the participants were several tons heavier than he was. Then he looked at the stegosaurus. It was the very first creature he had ever tried to befriend, and it was losing badly.
McGunderson sighed. “Oh, for goodness’ sake.”
He plunged a hand into his enormous burlap sack, rummaging past a handful of smooth stones, a bent metal rod he could not identify, and an old wooden spoon, until his fingers closed around a rather soggy sandwich. He examined the sandwich. Then he examined the Allosaurus.
“Here!” he shouted, hurling the sandwich across the clearing. It landed with a wet splat several feet away. The Allosaurus blinked at it. “There you are,” McGunderson offered brightly. “Something to eat!”
The predator stared at the soggy bread, looked back at McGunderson with mild disgust, and returned to attacking the stegosaurus.
McGunderson sighed. It was going to be a long day.
The next few days were decidedly lonely. Not only had his first friend been eaten by his second friend, but his second friend had subsequently been crushed beneath a falling redwood tree. McGunderson was not entirely sure what to make of this chain of events. He had only been trying to socialize, and now both of them were dead. It felt terribly inconsiderate.
That evening, McGunderson sat beside a small campfire, roasting a slab of the Allosaurus. Since the creature was no longer using its body, he reasoned, it seemed a shame to let it go to waste. He took a bite and chewed thoughtfully. It tasted like a cross between burnt alligator and very tough chicken. Not wonderful, certainly, but edible.
With a heavy sigh, he packed up his sack and resumed wandering.
He walked across the colossal supercontinent beneath his feet—which was doing a perfectly fine job of being a landmass until it abruptly began splitting apart. Every few centuries, the ground would tremble, crack, or shift beneath him, sending McGunderson tumbling onto his backside. He would spend several minutes lecturing the dirt on its poor structural integrity before dusting himself off and marching onward.
Millions of years slipped by. Mountains rose, oceans shifted, and entire eras came and went. McGunderson, however, remained stubbornly unchanged: still old, still covered in white fuzz, and still deeply unimpressed with his surroundings. He watched forests thicken and thin, watched rivers carve new paths, watched the sky change color in ways that felt personal. Sometimes he sat on a hill and talked to the horizon for hours, explaining in great detail why the weather had been unacceptable lately. The horizon never answered, which McGunderson took as agreement.
Eventually, he began to notice a troubling trend. The wildlife was shrinking.
Where were the colossal bodies? The terrifying teeth? The magnificent plates and horns? One afternoon, while trudging through a dense woodland, McGunderson spotted a small creature pecking at a fallen log. It was not particularly large, nor particularly intimidating, and—most disturbingly of all—it was covered in feathers.
McGunderson frowned. “What on earth are you supposed to be?”
The Velociraptor lifted its head and tilted it curiously. McGunderson leaned forward, inspecting it from snout to tail.
“Goodness,” he muttered. “They really have gone downhill. Look at you! You’re practically a chicken! Feathers, of all things. Whatever happened to a proper set of scales? You can hardly expect anyone to take you seriously looking like that.”
The raptor chirped softly and trotted away into the undergrowth.
McGunderson folded his arms. It was painfully obvious that the planet had lost its standards. He had watched the universe ignite, built the Moon, and survived continental drift—surely he could fix a minor case of evolutionary decline. If nobody else was going to take responsibility, it would have to be him.
“Yes,” he nodded firmly. “I shall have to sort this out.”
He had absolutely no idea how, though that had never stopped him before.
For weeks, McGunderson searched for a cure, questioning passing dinosaurs who universally ignored him. Eventually, his wandering led him to the base of a massive volcano. Smoke drifted from its peak, and a strange orange glow pulsed deep within the crater.
McGunderson climbed to the rim and peered over. Far below, a thick orange liquid bubbled angrily, releasing plumes of gas that smelled overwhelmingly of rotten eggs. He wrinkled his nose, watching it churn.
Suddenly, inspiration struck. He did not know what the liquid was, nor did he have the faintest grasp of geology, but it was bright, glowing, and vastly more interesting than regular pond water. Something that dramatic had to be medicinal.
“I don’t quite understand the science,” he muttered, “but I believe this might restore them to their former glory.”
Getting the liquid out, however, posed a logistical problem. The crater walls were sheer rock. Looking around, McGunderson spotted a massive boulder resting near the rim. He had once seen clever birds drop pebbles into a deep puddle to raise the water level so they could drink. By that exact same logic, dropping a boulder into the volcano ought to displace the glowing orange soup right up to the surface.
McGunderson pressed both hands against the boulder and shoved. Nothing happened. He braced his heels, grunted, and pushed until his knees popped and his shoulder made a concerning clicking noise. The boulder shifted an inch.
“This is ridiculous,” he panted, abandoning it for a considerably smaller rock nearby.
With tremendous effort, he rolled the smaller boulder to the lip of the crater and gave it one final heave. It vanished over the edge. A deep, muffled thud echoed from below, followed by the sound of shifting rock.
McGunderson leaned over to inspect his handiwork. The boulder had wedged itself squarely into the main volcanic vent, plugging the flow of magma. The bubbling quieted. The orange glow dimmed. Within moments, the mountain fell completely silent.
McGunderson blinked at the crater, then down at his hands. He was not entirely sure what he had done, but it looked remarkably decisive.
“Well,” he said, dusting off his palms, “that wasn’t so difficult.”
He turned and marched back down the mountain, thoroughly satisfied. He had fixed the volcano, which meant the dinosaurs were practically saved already. He was far too busy congratulating himself to notice that the dinosaurs had not actually changed back—or that deep beneath the crust, pressure was beginning to build at an alarming rate.
When the dinosaurs stubbornly remained small and feathery over the next few weeks, McGunderson concluded the issue was simply one of application. Clearly, the creatures needed hands-on care.
At the base of the mountain, he constructed a small wooden hut. Several walls leaned at perilous angles, the roof boasted a gaping skylight, and the front door was held together primarily by optimism. Above the entrance, he nailed a crooked wooden plank:
DINOSAUR TREATMENT CENTRE
(No Appointment Necessary)
He sat on a stump outside and waited. It was not long before a curious Velociraptor wandered into the clearing.
“Ah! There you are!” McGunderson stood up briskly. “Don’t be shy. Let’s have a look at you.”
Before the raptor could bolt, McGunderson grabbed it firmly around the neck and began pulling upward, attempting to stretch it into a more respectable, sauropod-like proportion. The raptor squawked indignantly and sank its teeth into his thumb.
“Ouch! Goodness, there’s no need to be difficult—I’m trying to improve you!”
The raptor snapped at him again and darted into the woods. McGunderson frowned, sucking on his thumb. Clearly, the smaller models lacked the temperament for modern medicine. He needed a patient with real presence.
He found a Tyrannosaurus rex standing in a nearby fern glade. McGunderson strode up, eyeing the massive predator critically.
“Yes, yes, I see the problem immediately,” he announced, pointing at the dinosaur’s chest. “Those arms are entirely too small. What on earth are you supposed to do with those?”
The T-Rex lowered its massive head, blinking in bewilderment. McGunderson stepped closer, grabbed one of the tiny forearms, and began tugging outward with all his might. “Don’t worry! Just relax the shoulder—”
With an irritated huff, the T-Rex swung its heavy tail, launching McGunderson twenty feet into a patch of ferns.
“Well,” McGunderson wheezed from the bushes as the predator stalked away, “that was rather unnecessary.”
Word travels fast, even without language. Over the next several months, the local dinosaur population reached a rare consensus. Predators and herbivores, carnivores and scavengers—all put aside millions of years of evolutionary rivalry to agree on one undeniable fact: the fuzzy old man had to go.
It was an unprecedented diplomatic achievement. McGunderson, naturally, remained completely oblivious.
One morning, he was busy hammering a loose plank back onto his hut after a heavy rainstorm. “Terrible craftsmanship,” he muttered as the plank fell off for the third time. “You can’t build anything these days without it falling apart.”
Behind him, the treeline rustled. A T-Rex stepped into the clearing, flanked by two Velociraptors, a Triceratops, and several agitated Hadrosaurs. Moving in eerie, coordinated silence, they began to advance.
McGunderson heard the heavy footsteps and turned around. Seeing the massive wall of teeth, horns, and claws bearing down on him, his face lit up.
“Ah! Patients! Wonderful!” He waved enthusiastically with both hands. “Come along, come along! There’s no need to rush, I’ll get to all of you!”
The herd broke into a full charge.
Just before they reached him, the ground violently lurched.
The dinosaurs skidded to a halt as a deafening roar tore through the valley. Behind them, the volcano finally gave up trying to digest McGunderson’s boulder. The mountain blew its top in a cataclysmic eruption, firing a column of ash and molten rock straight into the stratosphere—along with the boulder itself, which shot past the atmosphere like a bullet from a rifle.
The dinosaurs completely forgot their truce. Panic erupted, and the entire herd stampeded away from the mountain.
“Now, hold on a minute!” McGunderson shouted, lumbering after them. “Where are you all going? The clinic is open!”
High above the Earth, the volcanic boulder drifted into the silent blackness of space, colliding squarely with a massive asteroid passing nearby. The impact nudged the asteroid just a fraction of a degree off its harmless trajectory—aiming it directly at the Earth.
Back on the ground, McGunderson tripped over a root and landed face-first in the dirt. As he pushed himself up, the midday sun suddenly dimmed. A colossal shadow fell over the forest.
McGunderson squinted up at the sky. Hurtling through the clouds was a flaming mountain of rock. He stared at it, then glanced back at the smoking volcano, then back at the sky.
“Oh,” McGunderson said softly. “Oh, dear.”
For the very first time in his existence, a tiny, nagging suspicion crept into his mind that he might have made a mistake. He turned toward the fleeing dinosaurs. “GUYS! WAIT! I THINK WE NEED TO HAVE A QUICK CHAT—”
The asteroid struck directly on top of the Dinosaur Treatment Centre.
The resulting shockwave flattened the forest in a heartbeat, launching McGunderson miles through the air. He tumbled end over end through the ash-choked sky before crashing unceremoniously into a jagged, rocky gorge—a region that, millions of years later, tourists would pay good money to photograph as the Grand Canyon.
For a long time, McGunderson did not move. When he finally stirred, the world had gone dark and silent. Thick grey dust blanketed everything, blocking out the sun.
He sat up, coughing, and tried to brush the ash from his beard, mostly just moving the dirt from one patch of fuzz to another. He stood up and stumbled through the gloom.
“Hello?” he called out into the silence. “Anyone?”
His boot struck something hard beneath the ash. He bent down and picked up a massive, bleached bone. A few feet away lay another. And another.
McGunderson stood still, holding the bone in his hands. Slowly, the truth sank in. They were gone. All of them. He had only wanted to make them bigger, stronger, and a bit more respectable.
He lowered the bone and sat heavily on a nearby rock. He was alone again.
“Well,” he sighed to the empty wasteland, “at least nothing is trying to eat me anymore.”
He stood up, hoisted his burlap sack over his shoulder, and began walking blindly into the ash. Three steps later, he stubbed his toe violently against a sharp stone and toppled onto his backside.
“Honestly!” he shouted at the rock. “What’s that doing there?”
He picked himself up, grumbling under his breath, and continued wandering into the dark—completely convinced that none of this would have happened if people had just cooperated.
The silence after the impact was different from the silence of the void. That earlier silence had been empty. This one was full of absence. McGunderson walked through it for what felt like years, though time had become even less reliable than usual. He found more bones. He found the broken remains of his hut, half-buried and blackened. He found a single unbroken plate from the stegosaurus, still somehow upright in the ash, and he sat beside it for a long time without speaking.
He had wanted company. He had wanted the world to be a little more orderly, a little more impressive, a little less inclined toward feathers and shrinkage. Instead he had emptied it. The realization settled into him the way cold settles into joints—slowly, thoroughly, and without the courtesy of asking permission.
He did not cry. He was not certain he knew how. But something in his chest felt heavier than the burlap sack, and for the first time he wondered whether the weight he carried had always been more than stones and a spoon.
When the ash finally began to thin and a pale light returned to the sky, McGunderson stood, brushed what he could from his fuzz, and walked on. He did not know where he was going. He only knew that standing still felt worse.


r/writingfeedback • • 13h ago

Requesting any and all feedback for Flash Fiction

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

This piece is inspired by letters that I would find in antique shops. Thought it would be a fun form to play with. Thanks!


r/writingfeedback • • 14h ago

General Feedback Wanted Carpal Smash - first draft read

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
0 Upvotes

Hi there. I'm just getting back into writing and this is my first completed first draft of a short story.

I'd appreciate any feedback and responses and all types of criticism (both good and bad).

Story is at the google docs link.

Title is Carpal Smash.
It's a story of a boy on his walk to school among friends.

Thanks in advance!


r/writingfeedback • • 14h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Honest Feedback Wanted - Fantasy Romance

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi all! I am looking for honest feedback on the first chapter of my fantasy romance novel, The Spy and The Spare (approx. 1800 words).

Short blurb for context (WIP, not at all official): The Spy and The Spare follows two characters as they navigate rising political tensions, the threat of civil war, and their own personal lives.

I am open to any/all feedback.

Thank you in advance!


r/writingfeedback • • 15h ago

General Feedback Wanted The Caged Crown - Prologue, Chapter One, Chapter Two

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Synopsis:

In 1966, when the politically inexperienced 20-year-old Queen of Midoria ascends to the throne, Elenora Ashila inherits a kingdom that has become politically polarized. Things take a turn when General Rikard Pereno urges her to make him prime minister and dissolve parliament because of the ‘’threat’’ of communism. Months later, a caretaker hands her a telegram from a foreign reporter that tells her about the repression, disappearances, and overreach happening in her kingdom. That’s when the Queen decides to slowly counter Pereno’s government by using her royal prerogatives.


r/writingfeedback • • 15h ago

Writing Advice First time writer with bomb book idea but need advice on how and where to start

0 Upvotes

So I have a super bomb idea of writing a mini book about a black royal family with all the drama and three sisters being the main leads or whatever. But I’m having trouble on where to even start the story. I wanna make a series with like 12+ episodes and loads of drama but I’m literally stuck. Anyone have any advice on where to start??


r/writingfeedback • • 17h ago

Epistolary Fantasy: Feedback wanted

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

This is a short piece I wrote to workshop tone and setting for a larger work. A mix of old weird fiction/ dark fantasy/ expedition novels using Slavic/ Greek folk tales.

Would this be a concept you would want expanded on? And is there anything which sticks out as distracting.

Thank you!


r/writingfeedback • • 17h ago

Writing Advice Expanding your writing

0 Upvotes

how to you guys fill out full pages with just a few ideas without being overly descriptive. i write really short and id like to expand it. idk if that makes sense sob


r/writingfeedback • • 17h ago

General Feedback Wanted Would love some feedback dark historic fantasy

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Would love some feedback on this seven page short story set in a larger world I’ve created.


r/writingfeedback • • 21h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted It Takes you Away Chapter 1

0 Upvotes

Here's a draft version of what will hopefully become a fully fledged book. Constructive criticism is appreciated.

This book will contain the following themes:

*Abuse and Trauma

*Masculinity

*Mental Health

*Relationships

*Grief

*Chapter 1*
The time is 2AM. He sat, hunched forward at his desk with both hands covering his face. The feeling of utter despair swept over and leaving him wondering, what am I doing with my life?  

Now this wasn't the first time Tony had asked himself this question. But when you decide to stay up until 2AM you suddenly question the very existence of life itself. But for Tony this stemmed from much more.

Picture this, a young boy raised in a home consisting of himself, his mother and older brother. His father: missing or should I say 'absent in action' was the elephant in the room that people couldn't help but prod. He was always asked about his background, apparently, being British didn't quite hit the surface for some. This he had gotten used to and could answer in an amusing way that what would normally cause friction, ended up breaking the ice. And for Tony,   breaking the ice seemed to be his pastime. The same couldn't be said about his 'family', namely his father whenever the subject arose. Whenever the topic was imminent, Tony had rehearsed his response. Conversations or scripts always went like this:

"So you live at home?"
"That's the one." - Give them a big grin T, so they don't think you're annoyed (Tony told himself) all the while plastering a smile on his face
"Do you have any siblings?"
"I have one older, his name's Seth."
"And your parents?"
"Yes, I live with my mum and Seth"(Here it comes...)
"Oh your mum...." 
Tony paused. He could feel his mouth running dry. 
"And what about your dad?"

Tony paused. He knew that whatever he said next would change the speaker's impression, something that he wanted to resolve immediately but felt powerless towards. 

"He's not in the picture."

"Oh, I see."

There it is, the one question he hated more than most things. It made him feel vulnerable and pitiable. Over the years, Tony became well aware of what this question really meant. And yet there was still nothing he could do about it. 

Time had passed, and the family of three became two as Seth left the nest. Tony's older brother still lived in close proximity so he could stay over whenever he liked. It suited him that way, he could get the best of both worlds. 

Staying at home had its perks and it meant more bargain for his buck as he had dreams of having a house to call his own. So why did he question how his life was going? 

Growing up, Tony's home was far from paradise. At 5 years old, a firm hand struck his face when he was unable to finish his food. Fast forward to his pubescent years when at 12 years of age, a fist fight broke out in school which led him to detention and deep waters at home. But what was the harm of fighting anyway thought Tony, it's no different than being at home. 

Despite his turbulent years, he still managed grades that were satisfactory to society but never enough for his mother. Seth saw things differently, he encouraged his brother to do his best. 

"Come on T. Put your brain in it. " 
"Hah my brain. Why bother", he muttered looking at his chemistry worksheet. 

"It's not like the science teacher's gonna notice. It's always stop talking Tony, or turn around Tony and do your work. I'm telling you, Mr Nicks is out to get me. It's as if I'm his only source of entertainment. And mate, there's some real weirdos in our class. But does he pick on them? No!"  

Tony looked back at his homework. "Stupid chemistry. As balancing equations makes the world go round".

Seth sighed and smiled. 

"Thanks for letting me know T. It sucks to get picked on like that. But, you could prove him wrong. You, know pull a little bit of reverse psychology"
"Pfft yeah right."
"I'll give you a month. If you do well and I mean really well, consider that new Sonic game all yours."
"All right you're on. Should I start calling you Noel Edmonds?"

Seth was a clever young man and a hard worker at that. He was an all rounder and achieved nothing lower than an A in all his school subjects. He was well-behaved, witty, charismatic and he was loved by peers and adults. "What a lovely little boy you have." "He's got an old head on young shoulders" "Your son has a bright future ahead of him".  Life couldn't be easier for him, thought Tony. 

If only the compliments ended there. At home, comparisons were a song, criticism were its lyrics and discipline was the melody. Tony could even start the song himself before it began. 

"Why can't you get A's and B's?"

"When I was your age I wasn't being lazy, I studied every night. How do you think I built a life for myself in this country?"

"What is wrong with you?"

"Stupid"

"Idiot"

"Rat"

"How dare you talk back to your mum!"

And

"Why can't you be more like Seth?"

Years of such words moved Tony to come to an understanding that perhaps his mum was right after all. Although the constant song of criticism ceased, the words lingered in his mind whenever failure was on the horizon. As a teen, the house of cards as he called it, was too fragile to stand near so he found his escapism. A simple remedy which he swore could soothe all woes: his friends.

The boys made it their regular routine to gather at the Smith's where all woes were closely examined, dissected and a solution was brought. After a wrong turn on a day out, the four boys found themselves in a pub which later became their meeting place for local discussions. 

Tony wasn't sure if it was Cody's contagious laughter, Timothy's words of wisdom or Derrick's narration style but he always felt at home with the boys, his brothers. There were others that came along the way but the four of them stayed together as thick as thieves.

And for Tony, this was his haven. 


r/writingfeedback • • 22h ago

First pages of a YA sci-fi story-- would you keep reading? Experimenting with voice a bit.

0 Upvotes

I was all cosy-like, off to z-town all droolin and snoring. As always the very kindly neighbour, Mr Sunshine, was a-peepin through the window at about as early as that bird with the worm and all—like 9 in the mornin.

BANGBANGBANGBANGBANG!

“Billie, I swear to god if you’re still asleep, I’ll rip yer freakin face off!”

That’s my impression a Siddy, he’s got that smokers’ grind in his voice. See, Siddy won’t be rippin no faces, but he gets moody as a dark cloud and won’t gimme any ‘bacco, and lemme tell ya, this lady needs a puff in the mornin.  I get up all trippin a couple and shimmyin my jeans up my ass and yankin on some boots. I done a wonder on my dorm room, sure, it’s got it all, my guitar, my skateboard, tapes and cans and butts on the floor.

When I swing the door open, I lean myself nice and casual on the frame, so’s he thinks I been up all along.

“Who me? Born ready! No sleep.” I drawl at him.

He rolls his eyes over bags big enough you’d pay extra takin em on the railo—I’m not bein an ass, I stole that line from his own ma! But seriously, if there’s anyone who looks like they’re on no sleep, it’s Sid. Time froze on his cheeks, so his stubble is always around 5 o’clock, and he speaks all blurry like his words is molasses.

Sid pulls his ratty beanie over his eyes and groans like an old dog settling under the table as he starts walkin. I clank after him, swingin on my ID jacket and shakin my hair to get the leaves n twigs loose, leavin a little trail on the swingin walkway over the mech block. Where was I again last night…? Ah man, HA! Okay, that’s a whole other thing. Heheheh.

Ah, anyways, I run after Siddy slappin at the box a ‘bacco in the leg of his cargos.

“Ya weren’t sleepin then huh?” He hands me the cig he'd just lit and sparks another.

“That’s right!” I cough. “I’m like that cowboy feller, Huck Norris!”

“Chuck.”

“I just wait!”

He hums like he does when I been real funny but he’s in a funk he don’t wanna quit. Whateva! Prolly just couldn’t hear me cos of the mech below us, them gears grindin and chains clangin and fellers on shift all hollerin over it all. I spot Suki with grease on her eyebrow haulin something up from the engine block with her sleeves rolled up and a tattoo sleeve of oil down her arms.

“Hey, Suki!” Sid drops the box a ‘bacco down to his sister. She catches it in one hand, man, she’s so cool.

“You got Billie outta bed, then.” the cig on her lips waggling as she talks. “How’d ya spin that one?”

“Haha, yeah!” I holler it with all my chest before I realise that’s not an answer to her question, and she wasn’t even talkin to me. Oh my god, I’m such an idiot, ah shit.

She gives me a sort of neutral dunno-what-you-said thumbs up without really lookin at me and gets back to haulin. I’m starin at the floor and tryna look cool and normal but I can tell Sid’s givin me a funny side eye.

 

 

 

 

 

 


r/writingfeedback • • 23h ago

Gentle Feedback Wanted First thing I’ve written for fun, any help or feedback appreciated, would also be happy to give (amateur) feedback in return.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

General Feedback Wanted Help with feedback for my mom's eulegy speech

Post image
11 Upvotes

I just finished my draft for my mom's eulogy. I've never had to give a speech like this before, and given that she died sorta unexpectedly, I didn't think I'd have to give one at all. I just don't want to mess up or say the wrong thing. Please let me know if there's anything I should change or if it sounds dumb in general. Appreciate any and all feedback.


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

Beginner Writer Seeking ways to LEARN how to Improve my writing

1 Upvotes

Like the title says. I am a beginner writer pursuing a career in literature. and I am interested in ways to learn how to write! more specifically, I do not have a writing critic so how will I know what is good writing and bad writing, and what to improve? Thanks for the help!


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

General Feedback Wanted First chapter of a light fantasy about a demon musician

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Blurb: Victor is the headlining act for a music festival in the long isolated nation of the fae. While that concert is still two months away he has decided to spend his vacation seeing the rest of the country and looking for the woman of his dreams. He knows she's out there somewhere. Finding her may become secondary to dealing with a portal incident bubbling under the surface.

Genres: light fantasy, cozy, light romance elements.

General feedback is appreciated. Looking for if the story grabs you and when and also for what reason. Is the start too slow? Is the chapter too long? ( i expect a lot of people saying as much)


r/writingfeedback • • 1d ago

What do you think of this one the second chapter

0 Upvotes

In the heart of the dense forest, I stood staring with eyes wide with shock and fear. Directly in front of me lay a massive, scorched crater spanning over a hundred meters in diameter. It was the aftermath of the colossal fireball that had plummeted from the sky just moments ago, landing dangerously close to me. I was trembling violently from sheer terror, nearly collapsing to the ground as my weak legs threatened to give out beneath me.

"What in the heavens was that?" I whispered, my voice cracking.

I replayed the events of the last few moments in my mind—lifting my head toward the sky after all that agony, only to see a gigantic, blazing meteor that I had mistaken for the sun at first glance. Had those towering trees not intercepted its path and absorbed the brunt of the impact, I would have been reduced to charred remains by now.

I need to get out of here immediately. That was the only coherent thought I could muster amidst the whirlwind of events that had left me disoriented and without a clue where to go.

I began walking slowly and with great difficulty through the woods, finally taking in my surroundings properly after everything that had happened. The forest floor was carpeted with fallen leaves and bizarrely shaped weeds of every conceivable color—so vibrant and unnatural that merely looking at them made me nauseous.

As I walked, I finally realized just how minuscule I looked in this forest, as if I had shrunk in size! The leaves were ridiculously massive; were it not for a few normal-sized blades of grass scattered nearby, I would have genuinely believed I had been turned into a dwarf.

"The air is so humid..." I muttered under my breath. "I need some peace and quiet, and a shelter to gather my scattered thoughts. These trees are huge enough; if I can find a large hollow in one of them, I can use it as a temporary cave—at least until whatever entity is tossing meteors like pebbles decides my direction is a good spot to throw another sun at!"

Right now, my head was swarming with so many racing thoughts that I couldn't even keep track of them, but priorities came first.

I stopped before a colossal tree resembling a towering skyscraper. Right at the base of its trunk was a cavity large enough for me to squeeze inside. Just to be sure the hollow was empty, I picked up a few pebbles and tossed them in, bracing for any lurking danger.

It seemed my luck had finally turned around; not a single sound or sign indicated that any creature was inside. Cautiously, I slipped through the opening and looked up.

Whoa, it’s as spacious in here as you’d expect from a tree this size. I wonder if this hollow is natural, or if something dug a burrow here?

"Doesn't matter," I told myself. "At least it looks safe enough."

I sat down in a relatively clean corner of the hollow and began to think. What the hell just happened? Is all of this because of that comment? Isn't freedom of speech supposed to be protected by law?

Right after that thought, I slapped my forehead. Does that thing have any sense of restraint? Even humans don't care about the law that much, let alone an abstract cosmic entity! First things first, let's give it a name to call it by... "Yellow." I think that's good enough. It’s not like it has any features besides a cube or a yellow circle anyway. As for its personality, let's just forget about it—I don't even want to think about it, lest it decide to wipe out the planet with me on it just because it finds it entertaining somehow.

"Now that that's settled, let's move on to the second point: the cheat I asked for."

In my state back when "Yellow" was floating in front of me, the whole situation felt like jumping out of a fighter jet without a parachute toward my certain death. All I wanted at that moment was to disappear, and the very first thing that popped into my head was a web novel I hadn't even read, though the entire internet hyped it up. All I knew from what I'd heard was that insects in it possessed various abilities across different ranks. Since all I wanted was concealment, I took a shot in the dark and said: butterflies.

"Alright, then..." I said aloud after calming down a bit. "Where are my butterflies?"

The very second the words left my mouth, a strange chime of music echoed in the air! I jumped to my feet as if a fire had been lit beneath me, whipping my head left and right in panic.

Please don't be Yellow! I thought in terror.

Suddenly, a translucent blue window materialized in front of me, displaying crisp text:

[Welcome, User. This System has been created to serve you by: @@#$\(#(-#)\)]

Is this thing a "System," just like most web novels have? I wondered silently, only for the System to reply immediately as if reading my mind:

[I am. By the way, what is speaking to you right now is merely an introductory interface; you will be on your own once I explain how the System operates.]

A critical question popped into my mind, and I asked nervously, "There aren't going to be any mandatory quests or penalties for failure, right?"

[Correct,] the System replied. [I am designed in a very simple manner—or rather, the Creator didn't care enough to program complex features. Simply put, I will never force you to do anything.]

I finally let out a deep breath I hadn't realized I was holding since the window appeared. I refuse to become a slave to my own cheat.

"Please, explain how you work, then," I asked expectantly.

[Certainly,] the System said. [Your cheat, in simple terms, is the "Genetic Modification of Insects." As for the price, it is your lifespan; for every modification, a specific amount of your remaining years will be deducted.]

"What?!" I leaped back in shock. "What do you mean by 'my lifespan'?! Are you trying to kill me?!"

[You possess nothing else of value to offer in exchange other than your lifespan. Frankly, this is quite generous on my part.]

Of course it is—you and Yellow are cut from the exact same cloth, or rather, he's your maker! I muttered bitterly under my breath.

[You can genetically modify insects, though there are limits based on species, feasibility, and rationality. That is to say, the more logical and closer to the insect's natural traits the desired modification is, the lower the cost—and vice versa.]

I stood there, taking in every word carefully and analyzing it. So, in other words, the stronger the base insect, the higher the modification cost. And if I want to keep the cost low, I need to modify them gradually in stages.

[Yes,] the System confirmed, reading my thoughts, before adding: [Furthermore, the stronger the enhanced trait is, the higher the price will be, even if the base insect itself is weak.]

This is getting complicated... I thought to myself.

Just then, the System's voice chimed in again:

[Congratulations, you do have something to be happy about. The butterflies you wished for outside the System already possess all the traits you requested for free. However, you only have two of them: one male and one female, and their resulting offspring cannot reproduce among themselves. If you wish, you may use the System to accelerate their breeding in exchange for a portion of your lifespan.]

I sat down on the ground, mulling over its words. There's no avoiding this... I just hope their reproductive cycle isn't too long.

I looked up and asked, "What's the price for accelerating mating, egg hatching, and metamorphosis from caterpillar to butterfly?"

[Considering how terribly short your life is, let's set it at this rate...]

What does it mean by "short"?! I'm in my twenties! I could easily live to seventy if I'm lucky!

The exact instant that thought crossed my mind, a terrifying roar echoed through the woods. It sounded as though it came from miles away, yet its sheer force washed over me, making my entire body vibrate.

I let out a dry, sarcastic chuckle. "Looks like my lifespan really is pretty short... heh."

The System continued coldly: [Every hour of acceleration will cost you ten seconds of your lifespan. This rate is solely because some insect life cycles span several years.]

"That's actually much better than I thought!" I said with relief.

[That is strictly the cost for acceleration. Everything else depends on genetic modification.]

Of course it does, I thought sarcastically.

[Well then, that covers everything. Goodbye.]

"Hey, wait! I still have things I want to ask! What is this world? Where am I? And where's the exit to this forest?!"

I waited for an answer, but none came; the blue window vanished completely into thin air. It seemed all I had to my name now was a System closer to a shop where I sold my own life... and two butterflies.

After a few minutes—at least, I think it was a few minutes, as everything that had just happened left my sense of time completely scrambled—I decided to take action.

Let's see what I should do now. The top priority is staying safe, and for that, I need my butterflies to multiply.

System, I called out in my mind.

The blue window popped back into view, displaying the available options, including "Acceleration." However, before jumping straight into it, I wanted to check something crucial: what if I wanted to see through their eyes and transmit my voice through them? How much would that cost me?

As soon as I projected the request into my thoughts, the price appeared on the screen. I buried my face in my hands, exhausted. Each of those two traits would cost five years of my life—ten whole years in total!

This is a massive gamble, yet I feel like I have to take it. If I apply the modification before accelerating their breeding, the newly hatched butterflies will inherit these abilities naturally. If I get this done now, I won't need to modify any butterflies for a very long time... Still, ten years is a huge chunk! I already feel like my end is creeping closer.

I inputted the specifications and confirmed the transaction. All that happened was that the two butterflies glowed with a faint light for a brief second, while I felt no physical change in my body whatsoever. I breathed a sigh of relief, comforted by the fact that sacrificing lifespan didn't instantly age me.

"It just shaves time off the end so I drop dead sooner... hahaha," I muttered with a dark laugh.

"Alright, let's start building the swarm before something in this giant forest notices me... Let's see."

I began running the math in my head: It looks like butterflies take about 35 days to complete their full life cycle, which equals 840 hours. How much of my time will that take? Let's calculate... 8,400 seconds—roughly two hours and twenty minutes of my life! That's not bad at all; since a female lays around 300 eggs at a time, I'm in the clear.

"There's a catch, though..." I murmured, furrowing my brows. "I'll need to let the caterpillars go outside to feed on leaves midway through the process, and I'm definitely going to lose a lot of them to the predators in this forest—especially since their offspring can't breed on their own. So, the only solution is a bulk investment! I'll sell an entire week of my lifespan to push the original pair's reproduction to maximum capacity..."

I paused for a second before letting out a bitter laugh. "Wow, here I am throwing away my life like water! Let's do the math... one full week is 604,800 seconds, which gives me over 60,000 hours of acceleration! That's enough for 72 consecutive breeding cycles, and at 300 eggs per batch, that comes out to over 21,000 butterflies!"

My eyes widened in astonishment at the sheer scale of the number forming in my mind. Filled with sudden excitement, I said to myself, "With numbers like that... nothing in this world will ever find me!"

The moment I hit confirm, the process began immediately. I watched intently as the two butterflies transformed into twin orbs of green light and merged together. Wherever that emerald glow flashed, dozens of tiny eggs materialized—and the instant they appeared, they hatched!

I stared at the sudden, writhing mass with a grimace. Watching hundreds of caterpillars crawling outward to feed... disgusting. It's fascinating, and it's going to keep me safe, sure—but it is seriously gross!

Within just a single minute, thousands upon thousands of tiny eggs appeared and hatched in rapid succession, carpeting the floor of the tree hollow as the swarm marched out toward the leaves of the forest