r/writingfeedback • • Sep 07 '26 Bravo

Writing Advice Your writing is bad because you write like this…

Post image
660 Upvotes

I swear half of y’all on here write like this. Notice how I’m not really saying anything? I’m waffling about shite and being extra purple for no reason at all. You don’t need to do this, man. All you have to do is dial it back.

Sobering beams and shit. What the hell, man?

Please, if you do this, find a way to control it. Be precise. Make sense.


r/writingfeedback • • Mar 08 '26 Regret Heartwarming

I had my first beta reader that wasn’t AI and I cried

Post image
407 Upvotes

I’ve paid about… four or five beta readers from Fiverr and they’ve all been AI which is extremely sad. Just when I was about to give up, I found a human and she made me cry happy tears with her little notes and overall review :’) (still looking for beta readers in case anyone’s interested!)


r/writingfeedback • • May 04 '26

Critique Wanted First draft of my opening paragraph! Any critique is welcome :DD I wrote it over the course of two days.

Post image
394 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • Apr 17 '26

Announcement: The AI Problem.

296 Upvotes

Ne’er-do-wells of r/writingfeedback.

I am Isnoe, recently appointed Moderator.

I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but we’ve had a significant increase in AI generated writing being posted here. We've seen a lot of comments outlining how lax we are on this subject, to which I want to stress: I don’t think you guys fully understand just how many posts I’ve removed for AI since joining the Mod Team a few weeks ago.

The team got together and discussed this, and we want to be completely transparent: We will be removing any posts that we suspect are AI.

This will be a case-by-case basis. AI generated, AI assisted (even translation), or even if you mention you had AI draw up the story idea and you wrote it. If you want to rob yourself of creativity, that’s on you.

We don’t want those posts here. Writing a story or book that is authentically your own is an achievement. It should feel like an achievement.

A sidenote for ESL writers: Do not use AI to translate your text. It will alter it in a way that gets flagged, more often than not. When someone is ESL and trying to write outside of their native language, we are a bit more understanding if these posts get flagged—but again, it is recommended that you use alternative means to translate if they are available to you.

Be warned: If you are a brand new (or relatively new) account, have never posted in this subreddit (or any writing subreddits), and your first post is prose that has multiple AI-isms—your post will most likely be removed. Better to be safe than sorry. The main counterargument we've gotten from these accounts has been: "I've always been told I write like AI." Which, to be fair... is a pretty bad argument to make.

We will not ban a user for suspected AI use unless they explicitly admit to using AI.

Three strike rule applies here until further notice. This might seem like a headache to reviewers that want instant bans for these people (which we understand), but we’re trying to be as fair as possible.

This also applies to comments (never thought I’d have to say that), but we’ve had two accounts that were essentially AI replying to everything. “Thanks for the feedback, I’m still working on learning and improving” type cadence, every comment nearly identical aside from slight changes.

Community feedback is super important for this problem.

You guys take the time out of your day to read other people’s work and provide feedback, so I’m sure you get a little irked when you think something you’ve spent time reading wasn’t written by a person.

We’ve recently updated the report function to include AI content—use it. I (personally) don’t have the time to shift through every single new post. When you guys report a post that you think is AI, it is usually the first thing we’ll review.

That being said: If you genuinely suspect the post is AI, it would help me if you provided a citation, or specific reason. Even just one reference is helpful. I would genuinely appreciate it.

Not Helpful Example: “This reads like AI.” Okay? At this point, if you are accusing someone of using AI, you gotta at least point out why you think that.

Helpful Example: “Post uses, ‘This wasn’t just fate, it was destiny’ and includes several Rule of Three.” Now I know exactly what to look for.

When you guys call this stuff out, we do notice. We might not investigate and remove instantly, but we are actively looking for this stuff right now.

For the record: We will not be using ZeroGPT, or any other variant of “AI Detector” as the final say in determining whether a text is generated or not. It is a tool we will utilize if we suspect AI is being used, but all the indicators of usual AI writing are not jumping out.

I read through everything that is reported, or suspected of AI. I check the user history and if they have off site content, I look through it. If we don’t come to the conclusion they are using AI, we might just lock the thread, and add a note to the user profile.

Again, hate to stress this, we are trying to be fair. If a writer includes AI-isms unintentionally, we want to give them a fair chance to either prove the authenticity of their writing, or give them feedback about what specifically they need to change.

Several of you have done this, particularly with ESL writers that use AI to translate. You give them feedback on how to avoid the AI-isms. Good on you.

We don’t want to start a witch hunt, but we aren’t really open to debate about the use of AI. We don’t want it here, period.

If you have any suggestions for how to deal with this problem, we are open to them. You can comment here, or you can Mod Mail us.

If you suspect someone is using AI but don’t want to leave a comment or report, again, you can Mod Mail us.

We are actively looking through the posts. The community having eyes on this helps immensely.

We will be making further announcements throughout the week. Our Mod Team is still hashing out how to deal with “rude” criticisms, looking into providing user flairs for trusted reviewers, etc-etc.

One quick point to make at the end, on a personal note: My status as Moderator does not mean you cannot disagree, or think my feedback is bogus or outright terrible. I comment often. You will not be banned, removed, or whatever for speaking your mind.

4/18/2026 Note: Some users (one in particular who loves using AI to edit) seem to have taken that above sentence as an explicit statement of: "If I admit to using AI, you can't ban me, because I'm just speaking my mind. Hypocrite."

If you admit to using AI, we will ban you. Period.


r/writingfeedback • • Feb 09 '26

Opening page for a Dystopian novel set in Paris. Does the hook land?

Post image
284 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • Mar 19 '26

Should I keep going?

Post image
257 Upvotes

I’ll be honest, I have no education or experience as a writer. I posted that first paragraph as a joke to poke fun at some friends who were workshopping hooks for their stories. I just tried to write something dumb. People say they like it though, and they seem interested in seeing how it turns out, but I can’t tell if they’re joking too.


r/writingfeedback • • May 21 '26

General Advice For the love of god, edit what you write before posting!

254 Upvotes

It makes zero sense to post asking for feedback on setting, characters, or plot when your writing is LOADED with punctuation and grammatical errors. At the bare minimum, save yourself the embarrassment and everyone’s time by READING the shit that you post. And I’m saying this because there’s no way you wrote a thirty word run on sentence thinking the main issue is dialogue. Be forreal.


r/writingfeedback • • Feb 18 '26

Critique Wanted Fantasy Academia - opening paragraphs.

Post image
238 Upvotes

Hey everyone! 😊

I’m working on the first draft of a fantasy novel, and I’d love some feedback on the opening.

English isn’t my first language. I have some writing experience from university, but that was academic work, not speculative fiction. So I tend to doubt my prose.

∙	Would you keep reading?

∙	How does the prose feel to you?

∙	Does the opening hook you?

Any feedback, advice, or even just your honest reaction would be super helpful. Thank you so much for taking the time to read!


r/writingfeedback • • Jun 22 '26 Heartwarming

Killing Time: Chapter One Feedback

Thumbnail
gallery
207 Upvotes

Good morning, everyone. I'm currently in the process of querying agents for my novel Killing Time. I've been working on this novel in tandem with another over time and wanted to get some feedback on the first chapter for fun. Thank you in advance for your time!


r/writingfeedback • • Jun 25 '26 Heartwarming

Feedback Wanted Tried editing and revising to the best of my abilities.

Post image
190 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • Feb 08 '26

First Paragraph share

Post image
160 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • Aug 12 '26

Writing Advice Advice For People Posting Work

156 Upvotes

When you post work, you're asking us to lend you our time. I'm not lending my time to someone who doesn't first spend their own time proofreading their first page.

There is ZERO excuse for having glaring typos, grammar errors, tense slippage, or continuity errors, on the very first page of a work you make public. I'm not going to read your work when it's obvious you've tossed it up for people to fix without truly having read it for yourself.

And for damn good reason.

The most valuable thing you can do to improve your writing? Read it for yourself.

We all have more experience reading high-quality work than we do writing it. Read your work. Proof it. Compare it to your favorite author's works. What are they doing that you're not? What are you doing that they're not? Do this, and your work will improve.

I don't think my philosophy is unique. You want good feedback? Want us to read your work?

Proof before you post.


r/writingfeedback • • Jun 20 '26

Surviving Natalie Finch

Thumbnail
gallery
147 Upvotes

Does this brief opening pique your interest?


r/writingfeedback • • Aug 15 '26

Feedback Wanted first chapter first draft

Thumbnail
gallery
143 Upvotes

any thoughts welcome


r/writingfeedback • • Mar 18 '26

Critique Wanted Looking for feedback for the opening page for my gothic fantasy novel

Post image
139 Upvotes

What I'm looking for is:

  • Does this page have enough of a hook?

  • How is the tone?

  • Is the prose strong enough?

I'm looking for feedback and areas for improvement. The rest of the novel came together far more easily than the first two pages, so any feedback here, even outside the above requests, would be really appreciated! :)


r/writingfeedback • • Oct 01 '26

General Feedback Wanted Would you continue reading? (1,300 words)

Thumbnail
gallery
132 Upvotes

This is the first chapter of my dark fantasy novel, any feedback would be helpful. Thank you for your time reading <3 I did post a version of this a while back but a lot has changed since then. Is there a little too much description? Does it keep you intrigued?


r/writingfeedback • • Dec 11 '25

Trying to make the first 300 words of my book as good as possible

Post image
131 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • Apr 14 '26

Critique Wanted Would you keep reading?

Thumbnail
gallery
123 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback • • 14d ago

Gentle Feedback Wanted First time sharing my writing with anyone (Be gentle!)

Thumbnail
gallery
121 Upvotes

Long time reader, first time writer.

Have just started writing and have been a bit apprehensive about showing anyone I know in case it’s flaming garbage. Famously strangers on the internet are always kind and patient so I thought I’d ask for any initial thoughts.

I have a rough plot and structure in mind, but I’d really appreciate feedback on my general writing style please.

Cheers! :)


r/writingfeedback • • Jun 01 '26

Critique Wanted Any feedback on my first page?

Post image
117 Upvotes

This novel is complete.
If anyone is interested in reading further, I’m also looking for a couple of beta readers!


r/writingfeedback • • Mar 28 '26

An experiment in spotting AI in writing

114 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm concerned about the amount of AI slop going unchallenged, or even being praised, by online communities, just by using a minimum of prompt engineering techniques. Even blatant, untuned ChatGPT gets given the benefit of the doubt, and sometimes, all it takes is using a different model (in the linked example, my money is on Gemini).

If called out, such people will sometimes admit to using an LLM "to organize their thoughts", or for "editing, because English is not their native language", and complain that objections to such usage of LLMs are "ableist."

To explain what goes on, and avoid a "Did not! - Did too!" with a slop peddler, I decided to generate a "story" myself and then explain exactly what I did.

This exercise is here.

First of all, I apologize to everyone who responded in earnest. My intention wasn't to prank you, and I know you'd have picked up on the issues, if not the fact it was generated, if you had the time to read the text closely.

So, what did I do?

I used a free-tier general purpose chatbot, which is an extremely budget option. There are expensive specialist writing models, some of which had controversially been peddled by NaNoWriMo. I will not advertise them here.

At this point, I didn't know what the story would be. My focus was entirely on the deceptive style. I tested it by generating chapters on "a man looking for his keys in a dark room" and "a woman stuck on a train that's forty minutes late."

For the style, I used the following:

First, slighty broken grammar. This is the untagged dialogue people reviewers commented on, as well as some mixed tenses they missed. This is a very common trick. Online, people will just do a find/replace all to remove apostrophes (don't -> dont) since the reader doesn't expect AI to make such mistakes. Also, note I made absolutely no choices other than prompting it to tone it down (the first version sounded like Forrest Gump.) The untagged dialogue came entirely from the LLM.

Second, banned figures of speech. "Clouds hung over their head like unanswered questions" is a very telltale sign of AI.

Third, the replacement of em dash constructs with subordinate conjunctions. Some people spotted the awkward use of the conjunction "because" that resulted from this.

Fourth, a cadence protocol. Regular cadence is also a telltale sign of AI, so I told it to pick between short and long sentences randomly. Again, some people spotted run-on sentences created by this rule.

Fifth, a similar protocol to stop and "muse" on things. This is what produced "eggs with brown bits that get stuck between your teeth" or whatever.

Sixth, a rule to limit sensory descriptions (AI is eager to "show, not tell" when writing, and originally every single paragraph assaulted all five senses to a comic effect.)

After that, I used some basic persona prompting.

Now, a common counterargument to objections against AI is "it's just another tool for the authors to express themselves." Well, having locked the style in place, the "story" was done in two prompts:

* "A soldier returns from war", and

* "A soldier brings up violence in a detached way."

And this is why AI slop is so incredibly toxic to human creativity. The text communicates nothing. It picked bits and pieces from real world art (I think I see some of Sling Blade in the lawnmower scene) and cobbled them together. It seems meaningful because all this stuff was meaningful in another context, but here, it's all probabilistically selected tropes.

In their brilliantly sharp review, u/isnoe noted that the story made no sense from the veteran point of view. This is not how veterans speak and think. There is no genuine experience being conveyed here. I'd go further and note:

* the LLM had not "decided" on a time period;

* the "strands" don't fit together (there is the cat motif, but why does a widow with a serving son keep the picture of a cat in the most prominent place?)

* ham-fisted parallels (the lawnmowers not having mud on their tires, which is a very subtle remnant of LLMs tending to define things by what they're not, and battlefields aren't clean);

* complete non sequiturs (why would "everything be heavy" in the army? Why would the mother scream?)

Finally, when someone pulls a few tricks like I did, what are the surefire ways of spotting it? First, try as I might, I couldn't kill the regular cadence of sentences (IT-was THE-on LY-thing I-could GET-out is perfectly iambic - DA-dum, DA-dum, DA-dum).

Second, the vocabulary is too rich for how little is actually said.

So when a story seems very "literate" - the vocabulary is rich, the sentences flow well - but you are left with the impression that not much has actually been said and bits of story don't quite come together - castles suddenly appear out of nowhere, battles are full of singing swords but not of actual action, motifs don't carry over from paragraph to paragraph - that's 99.999999% AI.

Oh, and molars. LLMs love the word "molars", for some reason.

Again, deepest apologies to everyone who responded earnestly, and I hope this has been informative. Feel free to ask anything. And promise - no more LLMs. This post is all me.


r/writingfeedback • • May 24 '26

Critique Wanted Would love some feedback on the first chapter of my literary post-apocalyptic novel

Thumbnail
gallery
110 Upvotes

Hello folks.

Long time lurker, first time poster. Thought it was time to muster some courage and post here to get some feedback on my writing. This is the first chapter of my first ever attempt at a novel. Your feedback will give me lots to ponder. Thanks.


r/writingfeedback • • Feb 19 '26

Critique Wanted First Draft - Tentative Opener

Thumbnail
gallery
110 Upvotes

Hi, all!

This is a very tentative opener to a WIP. It takes place three weeks post-invasion from an alien race. While I want the book to begin mid-supply run (and lead into the main plot), I am not sure about how this opener feels. It is only the first draft and I'm thinking of scrapping it later once I am finished. I included the entire first chapter for curiosity's sake. As I said, I'm not married to it.

A couple of questions:

  1. Do you find the opener slow?

  2. Do you find the explanation of the invasion long to get to?

  3. How do you feel about the writing itself?

  4. If you read books in this genre, how do you feel about the above outline?

Edit: I tried to reply to everyone so I apologize if I missed you, but thank you so much for taking the time to read my chapter draft & comment. It means a lot to me and gave me so much insight and a small confidence boost to keep writing. I'm glad for all of the tips and feedback I received. I appreciate you guys!


r/writingfeedback • • Nov 29 '25

AI writing

100 Upvotes

I wonder how long it will be before people realize that asking AI to generate content simply from a prompt idea is NOT writing regardless of how good they think it is. Posting it for comments is a waste of time as most will see it for what it is. I do believe AI is a valuable tool in the hands of serious writers but those who use it will do it quietly and the end product will not be discernible as AI in any way.

Using AI is not a quick path to writing riches … hopefully at some point in the future this realization will finally settle in and we will see much less of it


r/writingfeedback • • Jan 12 '26

Critique Wanted Please be nice (but please be honest)

Thumbnail
gallery
97 Upvotes

Im trying to get back into writing. Is this worth continuing? Would you be interested in reading?