r/writingfeedback • u/Choddeh • Dec 20 '25
r/writingfeedback • u/avdillard • 11d ago
NSFW First time poster. Be firm, but gentle, please.
I’ve been working on this story for a few weeks now, and decided to get a little feedback on the first chapter. If I submitted it incorrectly or the formatting is wrong, I apologize.
r/writingfeedback • u/No_Dark9371 • Oct 17 '26
Blunt Feedback Wanted Draft of my debut novel (hopefully): “A Gleeful Camaraderie; or, Divers Phenomenæ.”
Do not be nice, though yet it is in draft. A man cannot guess these things, he either is the thing, or he is not (as said Friedrich Nietzsche). I would of you ask to forsake even your conscience but I will not (though, you may think, I have asked this of you) for truly fear. Enough of that. Look to the work. Inspired by that of the Waste Land, Cantos, Blood Meridian, Kafka’s Metamorphosis, the terminal comedy (as I have called it, mock at that what you will) of OCD, and much others works (Dostoevsky, Dante, Melville, Joyce, onward-onward). I have not been able to properly set even these months later the first chapter to… a presentable degree in my eyes, but I will present it yet. Perhaps you will laugh at this too (“He plays as if he were the Underground Man!”)
r/writingfeedback • u/DiamondKnightXIII • Jan 16 '26
Critique Wanted A snippet from the first chapter of my book. Please lmk what you think!
Hi, I'm looking for feedback on my writing style so I know whether to continue writing this way or not. Your feedback would be greatly appreciated!
This is The Eclipted Apocalypse. It's a story about a young teenage girl named Chloe who is emotionless, protecting a special needs boy named Evan as they try to survive in a world where a dark substance has scattered throughout their town beneath a never ending eclipse, consuming anyone who shows any form of fear, sadness, distress, or any other negative emotion, and transforming them into maniacs with no inhibition that won't hesitate to act on something unhinged.
If you're interested in reading the full chapter, you can view the Google Docs or PDF version with these links!
Google Doc version: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xWTO8-JSfDx6PUOMQ2Do2TE1vLltFUlrOyusJvuo5zU/edit?tab=t.0
PDF version: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1n6g5j-GJZsWKTq9whTGJPRW-MLA0fg-F/view?usp=sharing
r/writingfeedback • u/Gang-Buster-5000 • Jul 27 '26
Feedback Wanted Draft #2 of my horror story, would love some feedback!
Really having a hard time putting an idea to paper. I feel like there's something here and I'm just rushing it a little too hard. Also feels very untrimmed. Would love some thoughts on it!
r/writingfeedback • u/Difficult-Pain-1826 • Sep 19 '26
Blunt Feedback Wanted Please help benchmark my natural ability—500 word opener
Looking for honest feedback on this rough first draft opener. I'm trying to benchmark where my natural baseline writing ability (if any!) falls.
Any and all feedback is welcome! Craft notes, gut reaction to voice, hook, etc.
Edit: Want to genuinely thank everyone for taking the time to provide feedback. This experiment has been super informative and helpful.
I’m very new to all of this. My intention was to post as raw of a word vomit first draft ‘opening’ I possibly could, to get an idea of my base strengths and weaknesses.
I started drafting a memoir a couple months ago. So, the comments saying this felt like nonfiction memoir/essay I’m going to take as a good sign! Thank you all!
r/writingfeedback • u/WaySensitive4333 • Apr 18 '26
Would you read further?
It is a fantasy novel if not obvious, I am only 17 and English is not my first language so I might have made grammatical errors. Apologies.
If any of you want further plot direction to help decide just ask! I'll respond ASAP.
r/writingfeedback • u/nashamagirl99 • Oct 09 '26
General Feedback Wanted Feedback on first pages, plus how much French to include
The story is set in France but written in English. Some of the feedback I received here was to cut back on use of French words. In this edit I replaced the greetings but kept words referring to characters, but am willing to adjust that too. Story is magical realism about a young girl who is saved from a suicide attempt by a chance encounter with a stranger and stumbles upon a strange and potentially mystical circus. It is meant to have an old fashioned, fairytale like quality and definitely leans into melodrama.
r/writingfeedback • u/TheDukeFontaine • Aug 23 '26
Feedback Wanted Nightmare
Hello everyone, I have been working to better my writing skills, so far, I think my biggest issue is seeing proper prose? When I line edit, I can't seem to find the best way to make it flow better. I would like to share a dream I had and used as a writing exercise. I think with constructive criticism it'll help me get better. I'm sure there are a plethora of grammatical issues and punctuation issues, you are more than welcome to point them out. Let me know if you liked the story or not, if you did not, please let me know why!
r/writingfeedback • u/FinanceNew9240 • Aug 08 '26
Feedback Wanted First time writer. Looking for feedback to opener for ten year long novel
First time writer. Hobbyist hoping to turn this into something more. Been writing this fiction since first year of uni 10 years ago. In my first few paragraphs of the first chapter, does my book hook? Also vagueness of this boy/that boy is personally artistic so I can drop smidge details about characters before introducing since there is a lot of characters I’ve had to build. Does this flop or not? My writing style is also 75% prose heavy world holding, 25% dialogue. I hate dialogue.
r/writingfeedback • u/vrn14v • Sep 17 '26
Blunt Feedback Wanted Trying my hand at an atmospheric horror/thriller. Need an honest and blunt feedback about the prologue.
r/writingfeedback • u/Icy_Internet_7159 • 19d ago
General Feedback Wanted Where would you stop reading?
The oven timer goes off, then the doorbell, barely audible over Fitzgerald’s croons (both the swing-jazz on the kitchen speaker and Luther’s Maine coon.) The Christmas party is set for seven and the big hand is nearing thirty. Luther stands in the middle of his one-bedroom in a wrinkled dress shirt (“No time to iron, work extra busy this time of year” AKA “I forgot”) and a red and white stripe tie—arguably candy cane, arguably barber shop pole. After a moment of deliberation, he steps into the kitchen and pulls on the oven mitts. He’s outdone himself this year—Gran’s sweet potato casserole with marshmallows and pecans. Luther is not a self-proclaimed chef but he sure as hell can follow a recipe perfectly. Gotta do Gran justice; after all, she was the only family member Luther could stand enough to say he loved. Then she had to up and die five years ago, leaving Luther with an egg-sugar-flour ratio and no reason to go home for the holidays. That’s fine, he doesn’t like Wisconsin anyway.
Luther sets the metal tray on the stove and turns off the timer. Now, how to transport the casserole? The Christmas party will be hosted at Nina’s; Nina lives six blocks up on Jefferson (not far enough to take a taxi, as if that’s in the current budget); biking is plausible but Luther doesn’t have one with a handy-dandy basket in front for the casserole. He also isn’t the type to steer a bike one-handed. (Up a hill? Surely not.) He’ll walk. Shoes, where are the nice leather ones? Luther remembers he’s still got on the oven mitts when he tries to lace them up. He leaves them on the table next to last week’s newspaper and some cold coffee. Fitzgerald, the vociferous beast, weaves through Luther’s legs, purring incessantly and getting cat hair all over his pantlegs. (Really, Fitzy?)
A distant chime rings just as he stands, fur floating, settling on the carpet. He completely forgot someone had rung the doorbell. Luther isn’t expecting anyone. Suddenly, he’s very aware of the mess, the music volume, the cat hair coating every surface. Who’s he kidding, it’s probably just the UPS guy.
“Hiya.” Luther goes for a jolly tone as he opens the door—it’s nearly Christmas.
“Hey, Lu. God, it’s been forever.” A pause. (Luther: mouth agape.)
“Tomiko,” Luther breathes. “Why—”
“Ew, don’t call me that.” Tom wrinkles her nose. “You know I hate it when you call me that.”
“I…” Luther rubs a hand over his face, chuckling to himself. “I just can’t believe you’re here, Tom, is all.”
“Yeah, yeah.” She pushes past him into the apartment, but he can hear the smile in her voice. Luther lets the door close and leans against the frame.
“Making ourselves at home, are we?”
“You got Ella on.” Tom notes, disregarding Luther’s question.
“Had to. I was making the sweet potato casserole. Recipe practically calls for it.” He shoves his hands in his pockets. He’ll still get to Nina’s on time if he leaves in the next five minutes.
“Smells good.” Tom wanders into the kitchen alcove.
“So, you’re in the city for how long?”
“Why do you ask?” Tom doesn’t look up at him when he joins her in front of the oven. She’s dutifully inspecting the toast of the marshmallows.
“I dunno, we should catch up.” Tom eyes him. Her hair is lighter than he remembers.
“Isn’t that what we’re doing now?” She must’ve gotten highlights or something.
“Right.” He can afford to be a few minutes late to the party. Everyone from work will be there, Nina won’t mind. Heck, with the way she gets when hosting, she won’t even notice if he slips in at fifteen-past. Anyway, the casserole’s a good enough excuse. Tom is drumming her fingers on the countertop. “Can I get you something to drink?”
“You got Busch Light?” Luther laughs. Tom’s fully serious and this makes him laugh harder. “What? Not tryna be funny, Luther.”
“Nothing! Nothing. Reminds me of the old days.”
“Okay, but for real. No Busch Light?”
“No Busch Light. Got none of that here.”
“Oh?” Tom raises a brow.
“Quit a few years back. Almost five now.” Luther traces a circular coffee stain on the countertop with his pinky. “Gran never liked me drinking, and after… Well, I just figured.”
“It’s really been a while, hasn’t it?” Luther isn’t sure what exactly Tom’s referring to. It’s been a while since a lot of things.
“I suppose it has. Some water?” He fills a glass in the sink. Jazz still hums from the speaker but Ella isn’t singing anymore. The other Fitzgerald slinks by Luther’s ankles, jealous of the way his eyes follow the uninvited guest. “How long ya here for?”
“‘Til the 23rd.”
“Tom, it is the 23rd.” She’s busy gulping down the water. “Long journey? You’re still in California, right?”
“Yep. Good memory, I’ll give you that.” Tom wipes her mouth with the back of her hand. “Your tap filter though—sheesh.”
“Means a lot coming from a Busch Light fanatic.”
Tom steps up close to Luther to put the glass in the sink behind him. “Work. That’s why I’m here.” Is that the only reason? (He doesn’t ask.)
“They’ve got you worked to the bone, this close to Christmas and all.”
“Alright, Lu. Interrogation time’s over.” They both know Tom has no plans for the 25th. She, like Luther, tends to avoid home over the holidays. “Say, do you remember that one year Alex Trebony asked me to winter formal?”
“God, it’s been ages since I’ve heard that name.”
“Do you?” Luther thinks for a moment.
“No, I don’t actually. That’s weird, I mean, we used to tell each other everything.”
“Or, you told me every detail of your life and I just listened the whole time.” Tom grins.
“Terrible liar, you are.”
“But anyway, I never went with him.”
“No shit.”
“And I told him, get this, that you had already asked me.”
“Plausible.” Luther rubs his cheek. He hasn’t shaved for two days and he wonders if it’s obvious.
“I can’t even remember who I ended up going with. Julian… or was it Sean?” It was Paul, but Luther only shrugs in response. Tom wants a reaction from him and he isn’t bothered to give her one. (I can read you like a book, Luther doesn’t say, an old one I’ve read a million times before.)
“High school dances. A bit random, no?”
“Random of me to show up. It’s normal to reminisce, Luther.”
“Sure,” he hesitates. “Are you gonna tell me why you’re actually here?”
“Work. It really is work.” Tom bends down to stroke the cat. Turns out, Fitzgerald isn’t loyal after all, and permits the ear-scratchies with a purr. “There was a conference here they wanted someone to go to. No one in the city could make it. Everyone’s got family stuff, and I—you know. They knew I’d be free.”
Bullshit.
“Are you seeing someone?” Tom straightens up quickly, brushing cat hair from her jeans. Luther didn’t mean to ask that, lest she get the wrong idea. “As in, are you here for someone?” Worse. Luther winces. He might not recover from this.
“You really think I’d fly all the way across the country for a guy, the day before Christmas Eve?”
“I mean, the old Tom wouldn’t. But I dunno, maybe you’ve changed.”
This is about half the short story, lmk if you’d be interested in reading the whole piece
r/writingfeedback • u/Leather-Dentist5854 • May 09 '26
My first 3 pages of my story. Please review it.
It's a fantasy story. Just few pages. Hope you like it and leave a honest review.
r/writingfeedback • u/Eivy_1 • Dec 27 '25
Would you keep reading?? I need as much critism as possible.
I've received a few negative comments, but none actually explained what was wrong. I'm genuinely curious and I accept any kind of advice.
r/writingfeedback • u/Thisyorkshiredreamer • Sep 21 '26
General Feedback Wanted Would this opener keep you reading? (Speculative/book club thriller)
Any feedback/criticism would be really great. Thanks, guys.
r/writingfeedback • u/DressLower3434 • Mar 24 '26
Would appreciate some feedback of my first chapter. I tried writing like Cormac McCarthy.
please be brutal.
r/writingfeedback • u/nmyikes444 • Sep 11 '26
Gentle Feedback Wanted First chapter feedback
Hi, my names Willow and I have been writing for a while now but I’ve just started my first book. Without spoiling anything it’s a drama/thriller. I was wondering for some feedback, specifically asking the question of if this makes you want to read on? I haven’t gained a lot of traction as I publish a chapter weekly and have low views. I’m obviously not doing it for views but it’s important to know my writing is not god awful or boring. I’ll attach the link in case anyone wants to read more, at the moment I’m just using Wattpad as I like the format. Disclaimer: This is not a fanfiction
Thank you
r/writingfeedback • u/No-Cap5498 • May 19 '26
Does this short story intro hook you?
I’m writing a short story for a creative writing class. I’m a junior in Hs and would love to know ways I could improve! Thank u! Please lmk!
r/writingfeedback • u/MadVista1 • Mar 16 '26
Seeking BRUTAL feedback. NSFW
*** UPDATE ***
Feel free to read the inital version of UPS, below OR if you're upto it you can read the revised and expanded UPS 2.0 here: https://www.reddit.com/r/UPS_TheEvolution/comments/1rx2pob/evolution_20/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button
UPS 1.0 (the old version)
Brutal feedback is encouraged. I'd prefer what you didn't like, but an occasional mention of something you did like is not unappreciated. Below is the short piece. ***Somewhat mature writing is involved in the piece. If the mods feel it is too much, I'd like a comment to what violated the standard.
Here goes...
For almost thirteen years it had wallowed. Not unlike its entomological namesake, the Cicada, hadn’t been hibernating – it was very much a living orgy of life - an impenetrable bed of zebra mussels sucking and spitting below the waterline, and the annual spring-time fornication fest of mayflies above board. Though it hadn’t moved out of its slip under its own power since forever, the Cicada was still being sporadically prepared for its eventual circumnavigation of the planet.
“It’s not dead,” Tern told anyone whose uninvited nose liked to invade other people’s business, “it’s resting with intent.”
Anyone who knew her, Tern that is (as opposed to the Cicada), sooner-or-later came to the realization that the Cicada’s aspirational looping of La Tierra was about as likely as Tern dropping one of her rust-resistant Koken wrenches into Lake Erie.
Those who believed her explanation, Tern dismissed as suckers. Her philosophy: most people believed the wrong things for reasons that had nothing to do with evidence. Tern’s preference for unvarnished truth and pragmatism had long ago lost its ability to be patient with populist ignorance. She just didn’t give a phlying phuck how anyone felt about the lack of her lingual guardrails. Her tongue was pretty promiscuous when it came to one’s nether regions, be it male or female, unlike her obsessively monogamous attachment to her repair tools.
If Helen’s face could launch a thousand ships, Tern’s at thirty-three, would make sure you were happy to be on board. She had the kind of face people kept trying to assign stories to. In work clothes she looked like the offspring of Jason Vorhees and Margot Robbie - grimed nail beds, overalls marinated in marine diesel oil, a gray tank top shrink-wrapping her constantly dewy melons, all topped off by a coif of dirty blonde hair tied up in a rag (Aunt Jemima-style) and penetrated by a No. 2 pencil. Anyone who had seen her butt-naked, clamped their lips tighter than an ape’s anus. It wasn’t that they were sworn to secrecy, they just didn’t want competition for their own irregular hook-ups with her.
She was an untamed beast of accidental sexuality in an aquatic zoo of phloating phuck houses.
r/writingfeedback • u/Ahmed-Esm • Jun 24 '26
Feedback Wanted First fight scene I've wrote. Knight Vs Werewolf.
Edit: written* sorry.
It's the first of many duels I'm (hopefully) going to write for my book. So, I want to know if this flows well and isn't too Blow-by-blow-y. Also, I'm thinking of cutting the internal monologue.
Aeth and Qain are magic system terms I made up.
r/writingfeedback • u/chaliced10 • 29d ago
General Feedback Wanted Critique and Advice on Boring Prose
Hi y'all! This is the beginning segment of a short story I'm writing with a friend (they are coming up with the story while I'm doing the actual writing). I'm very much a hobbyist, but I also want to write at a decent quality. Whenever I go over my work, something about the prose just always feels off, so if any of you can impart some wisdom on this inexperienced young lad, it'd be much appreciated
Edit: Thank you all for the feedback!
r/writingfeedback • u/Odd-Flower2724 • Oct 06 '26
My dark fantasy. Is there any hope for this?
I write a dark fantasy novel in 48000 words. Is there any chance of publishing the book?
r/writingfeedback • u/Ronin0843 • Sep 27 '26
How’s this for an opening paragraph?
I was trying to go for something that would immediately the tone and grab the reader into this dark like city setting. For context if you already couldn’t tell the premise is based around a jazz player in the big city using jazz as a connection to his late father and his overall struggle for meaning. I just want to make sure I’m not over doing any imagery or exposition dumping but accurately guiding the reader into the world.
r/writingfeedback • u/insomniazher • May 03 '26
Looking for feedback on my romcom novel
i'm trying to write a novel that looks like a rom-com on the surface
i have just one question, you don't have to read everything
would you keep reading? and why?
thank you very much
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1cIWTxl31-cL0HSL7B_OZgmuITzQAMs8onSvVRgHnlAc/edit?usp=drivesdk
5/5 EDIT: After reading your feedbacks, I have some part realized where and what I was doing wrong. I tried to fix the problems I made in the Google Docs link. If you could, please check it out, I tried my best.
Thank you, and I appreciate every single one of you
r/writingfeedback • u/congratzuplaydurself • Mar 10 '26
Asking Advice I'm on my way to becoming Audra Winters and I don't like this trajectory. Any tips/suggestions to improve?
I was a former "gifted kid" who did not cultivate myself and just became a painfully mediocre adult at (currently) 21. I guess this "gifted kid" label (i.e. being placed in "gifted" classes back in elementary and middle school) made me develop a remarkably inflated ego and complacency over how much effort I really have to put in. And when I grew older and other people quickly caught up to my effortless innate "talent" by putting in more dedication and effort, I started crashing out because this expectation-reality mismatch wasn't something I was used to - it was sorta ingrained to me that I could just wing it and make something amazing in just one day.
I also have a really improper mindset with writing. Overall, when writing stories, I seem way more interested in fantasy and worldbuilding than writing something authentic or artistically substantial. I also write just to satiate my intellectual ego - I want to be seen as a quirky and unique artist without actually doing the work to cultivate myself as one. I feel more interested in self indulgence and writing to explore my fantasies that I can't do so IRL than writing to communicate emotions and universal human themes to others. Hence, this makes all my stories seem as shallow and confounded with unnecessary details as an evaporating murky puddle in the summer. I also don't do well with criticism and view it as an inherent attack on my character (i.e. I felt called out for being insular or uncultivated) rather than an attack on just my work (hence I'll lash out), no matter how much I remind myself to separate the art from the artist, even when it comes to my own work.
I think there's a lot I'm missing out on culturally, on the greater works of art/literature like Dostoyevsky and Kafka, instead just reading and watching lowbrow slop, but my brain has just been too rotted by short form slop on the internet to read more than just a bite-sized chunk at a time. There's also this neurotic feeling of envy I have for these renowned authors and auteurs (like Dostoyevsky or David Lynch) that is holding me back from actually exploring their work. It's as if to me they are gods or deities that shine a blinding bright light over my whole body that causes me to tremble in respect yet also fear from a distance rather than approaching closer. I feel sort of like Moses when confronted with the burning bush. I would like to confront and overcome this fear and envy.
Why am I deciding to post this? Well recently, I got my whole Reddit account banned for posting a story that was unintentionally misogynistic and ableist (and everyone ended up mass-reporting me for it). I realize that it's not 100% my fault as I was raised in a capitalist environment (in fact in one of the reddest states of all - Mississippi) that prioritized hierarchy and tradition over the humanities and grew up in teenage anime and gaming communities which are notorious for infantilizing/objectifying women, but it certainly is 100% my responsibility to push myself towards change, especially now that I'm self aware. It is my responsibility and a fault on my own character that I wasn't intellectually curious enough to question these backwards conventional views on gender and disability that were shoved down my throat at an early age.
I guess maybe I should use some tips from you ... uh ... more seasoned writers or readers out there.