r/soma • • Feb 12 '16

Why SOMA is not depressing and why you're wrong about the whole game (Warning : Spoilers)

0 Upvotes

The events in SOMA are either intentionally or unintentionally misleading. Your conscious does not "die" throughout and you maintain "continuity", and I will explain why. One conscience can in fact exist in two places and people killing themselves to maintain continuity was simply ridiculous. For more about why this is I recommend you watch the movie "Primer", and touch up on the quantum mechanics involved in the earlier parts of the movie.

Also the theory in philosophy of Roko's Basilisk helps explain this. Although this theory is nonsense it asks vital questions about one's consciousness. In this theory, a supercomputer, that will be created in the distant future, with godlike powers is designed to save all of humanity and store a simulation of each individual person on a hard drive, and give each of them eternal happiness. But if you have knowledge of this computer and do not aid in it's creation it will create a simulation of you and torture your simulation for eternity. But, this can be considered moral because the longer it takes to create the machine the more human lives are lost, and its end goal is to save all of humanity. This asks the question "who cares if a simulation of me is being tortured? Its not me." Well technically speaking that simulation is in fact you and your own consciousness will be transferred into that simulation. Meaning, you will be the simulation. The human mind is simply information in physical matter. If this physical matter were to be simply copied elsewhere there would be nothing distinguishable between the original and the copy. Therefore if this were to happen there would be two copies of the same person and one consciousness operating two bodies separately. The point that some characters in SOMA make is that after making the copy the original body will experience different sensations and their brain will diverge from the copy and they will not become identical and therefore continuity will break between consciousness’s. The first reason this is false is because as soon as a copy is created you consciousness occupies both the consciousness of the copy created and the original body, and therefore any changes occurring after the creation of the copy to the original body will have no effect on the clone and the same conscious will continue to occupy both existences. Along with this thinking that slight changes in one's brain will change your consciousness is ridiculous. That would imply that every time you your brain changes (like going to sleep, losing brain cells through injury, losing memories, etc.) your consciousness dies. Therefore slight changes in your conscious would not kill your conscious and making a clone with slight changes in its brain would still mean that your conscious would travel over.

But how would your conscious experience traveling over to a new body/inhabitation?

Most likely your conscious would experience it in a linear fashion. In the case of SOMA Simon would first experience his whole life with full continuity. Then Simon would be "reborn" again into body 2. This time his conscious would have no knowledge of any of his life past being scanned in the doctor’s office. After this Simon would go through his life up until to point where his conscious is transferred into another body. At this point he can experience the pain of isolation for the rest of his existence in that body depending on whether or not you decide to kill Simon body 2 in body 3. Then Simon’s conscious would be “reborn” again in body 3. This time with no recollection of what happened past the point of him being scanned into that body. Simon would then experience the rest of his depressing life in this body. Including feeling left behind by Catherine and wandering around in isolation until his death. But after this, he would be reborn again within the ARK without knowledge of what happened after he was scanned the last time.

What happens to humanity?

If you did not destroy WAU then humanity has a chance at being constructed, maybe as robots, by this supercomputer than can potentially learn enough to bring humanity back to life, even if they simply possess metal frames.

More info on the philosophy behind this if anyone is curious:

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Roko's_basilisk

http://existentialcomics.com/comic/1

https://www.reddit.com/r/rokosbasilisk/

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0390384/plotsummary?ref_=tt_stry_pl


r/soma • • Mar 29 '25

The Choir

Post image
0 Upvotes

The Choir

A seething, shuddering abomination of flesh, The Choir is a towering biomechanical horror formed from dozens of human bodies fused into a grotesque whole. It lumbers forward with a gait that is both labored and disturbingly fluid, dragging roots of twisted muscle and blackened sinew across the ground like a creeping infestation.

Its form is a cacophony of misplaced anatomy: torsos merged spine-to-spine, arms where no arms should be, legs jutting sideways, some twitching, others useless. Rising from its back and shoulders is a dense forest of malformed heads—each a bulbous, eyeless mass lit with clusters of glowing, bioluminescent orbs. These lights are not for sight, but function as sensory organs—detecting heat, movement, and electromagnetic fields. The orbs pulse in eerie harmony, as if singing a silent hymn only the dead can hear.

Why "The Choir"? Because each of the heads still screams—not audibly, but psychically. The creature exudes a low, mind-rattling hum of pain and fractured consciousness, a psychic feedback loop that can drive the weak-willed to hallucinations or madness. These heads are not simply growths—they're aware. Some whisper memories in dead voices, while others retain fragmented personalities, arguing or weeping in tortured unison.

Behavior and Abilities:

Hive Perception: The heads share information in a networked consciousness. The Choir doesn’t think—it responds, interpreting threats and emotional states with disturbing accuracy.

Light as a Weapon: The orbs can flash in concentrated bursts of blinding light, enough to dazzle or disrupt nearby electronics.

Corruption Trail: Wherever it moves, it leaves behind a pulsing trail of structure gel-laced biomass. These cancerous growths can infest environments and interfere with machinery, slowly converting the area into something... alien.

Absorption: Organic material caught in its path is not merely consumed—it's joined. Victims are added to the mass, still conscious for a time, their nervous systems hijacked to fuel the Choir’s locomotion and awareness.

Origin: Speculated to be a failed—or perfected—WAU experiment in immortal preservation. Whether it was created intentionally or emerged as an accident of rogue gel and desperation is unknown. What is clear is that it should not exist.

Weaknesses: Slow and massive, the Choir’s strength is in endurance and psychological warfare, not agility. It can be delayed or damaged with extreme heat, sound-based weapons, or precision strikes to the neural cluster buried deep beneath its thoracic plating. But reaching it is another story.


r/soma • • Sep 27 '26

Spoiler Some Omicron Staff Members (furry interpretations)

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

Adam Golaski, Raleigh Herber, and Julia Dahl.
Some notes:

My designs are based primarily on where the characters lived/their confirmed nationalities. And they’re all land animals to give them a distinction from the marine life in the game.

Adam’s ref is based on Josh Truax’s portrayal in the Transmissions miniseries. Mainly cause his body can’t be identified in game. (My personal theory is that Terry found and revived him and he became a Proxy)

Simon 1 and Imogen Reed are both raccoons but I figured I should make Raleigh a different animal instead.

Me and my boyfriend came up with the headcanon of Julia being trans due to the file name of her corpse being “Corpse_Omicron_male_1”


r/soma • • Aug 04 '20

SOMA 2?!

0 Upvotes

Is SOMA 2 thought about to be released? Or is it just gonna end here since Simon is in the ARK now? I think a good sequel would be about the ARK falling to its doom back to earth since its orbital stabilisers malfunctioned due to debris from the meteorite that hit Earth itself, therefore we could regain control back to the Simon that was left in site Tau, and relive the monster nightmare again. How cool is that?!


r/soma • • Dec 19 '22

Please

0 Upvotes

Need soma you in my life


r/soma • • Dec 14 '16

Spoiler Will Frictional Games' next game have better gameplay? NSFW

0 Upvotes

Circlejerk SOMA all you want, but the gameplay was absolutely boring, elementary puzzles that require little thought, clicking buttons everywhere and hiding from annoying monsters got stale. I hope they improve on the game play aspects of their next games.

Penumbra had decent puzzles, Amnesia's was almost as simple as SOMA's but had the benefit of being more scary to compensate as well as the hide and run mechanic had not become stale yet at the time of A:TDD release in 2010.


r/soma • • Oct 01 '25

Catherine is an antagonist

Post image
0 Upvotes

Now I won't claim she's the "main antagonist" because there simply isn't one in the game. However, her intentions and actions against Simon are explicitly antagonistic.


r/soma • • Jun 16 '20

Video Pewdiepie cries at SOMA's ending [SPOILER] Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/soma • • Sep 10 '25

SOMA is actually a horror game

34 Upvotes

No jokes. I'll elaborate. Just wanted to share my story.

First, I don't like horror games. Imo that's the scariest media to possible, so probably I'm already a little biased on that.

Since the release, I've been hearing a lot of praise about this game from a friend who specifically mentioned that although that's a great game, it's not a horror at all. More like walking simulator or visual novel, he said.

Another one, a diehard frictional games fan, considered it's worst in a terms of horror in comparison to their previous titles.

So last January I finally reached my hands to it, thinking like "well, that's probably a short movie for a day or two, whatever, let's find out "

Just to mention - I am a seaman, so die to my working schedule I played only at night, in complete darkness, with the wall I leaned at the sofa behind me constantly vibrating as shit, with the headphones and on projector with gamepad.

And it took me two weeks to finish it. Abt 30 hra play time for the first run since every step with the monsters arround was an achievement for me.

I did not had any internet on board, so I made photo of every possibly crucial information which may be useful later, like maps, notes, stuff lists, even Amy's drawings at upsilon

What I want to tell is not only it as important as in any other horror game to play it in a proper condition, but also realize what is happening around you.

I can't remember any other similar horror game to bring such bonds to a character you only know from his name in some list.

And then you realize that the events finalized shortly before your appearance on pathos ii.

Just think about it - Amy is sitting there alone for at least half a year. Carl robot may still be under torture by the time you launch the ARK. Jin (imo) was sent by the wau to "rescue" Sarah only about few months before Simon 2 birth. Even Terry and the proxies, like a true rock band they are, still be hanging out with their hollow guests connected to a fleshy wau network - about 5 months already, and who knows how many more after you leave theta.

And to only think about that Simon 2 gets to live after descending in to abyss - that's a true horror. What choice will he have other than to take a leap of the faith, following you.

It's no coincidence that the community try to recreate chronology, find out all the bodies and who they belong to - that's what make it really scary to me - the bond to the characters, and to the enemies.

That poor Construct , still roaming the remains of upsilon after your departure, that's what make it scary for me. When you realize there is nothing more in this world except those names on the notes and lists, except those mockingbird robots, tirelessly running in circles - you just can't think they are not real or not alive.

Wau did nothing wrong. It tried it's best for what it had.

Ross - probably the only guy we should dislike.

Simon 2 could join wau. Simon 3 could hoin wau. Simon 4 is saved anyway.

But the loneliness and meaningless torture of those accidental wau creatures gives my shivers. They will stay there forever.

What a beautiful game. Not only an excellent story, not only the great sound and game design, but a deeply immersive (lol) horror which will follow you months and,probably, years afterwards


r/soma • • Feb 01 '25

Spoiler Everyone Missed The Point Of SOMA

4 Upvotes

Having recently played the game i’m late to the party. But i’ve not seen a post touch on what appears to be the true essence of the game. Apologies in advance if my hypothesis seems lofty or patronising.

  1. The game was over before it started.

The game begins with all of humanity dead with the exception of the woman guarding the ARC. Simon Catherine and all other scans are computer programs that mimic humans in a fashion that is indistinguishable from the outside looking in. As we play as simon from a 1st person point of view we wrongly assume that he and cathy are sentient in some way. The reality is they are computer programs that do not think and feel as humans do. They just react to their environment and stimuli as humans would. This is an important distinction.

we assume wrongly that simon, cathy and the arc are the last of humanity. But these computer programs do not feel, so despite Simon’s cries at the end. It may come as some comfort to you that he does not suffer anymore than a furbie crying for affection.

The true horror of the game is that humanity died with Sarah. But as we don’t see the world from her point of view. Her story. Our story. The story of mankind. Becomes nothing more than a footnote to the adversity faced by its own shadow. The scans.

2. The implications on consciousness

The game is a display of ontological philosophy. I.e. what it means to be. This is a question that has been tackled by many great thinkers from Aristotle to Descartes and Hegel. Essentially the question has never been analytically answered or empirically proven. However we don’t need to know the answer to that question, in order to know what the answer is not. And what consciousness certaintly isn’t is something definable from the outside looking in. Consciousness is the mechanisms the drive our behaviour, not merely the behaviour itself.

3. SOMA and a Brave New World.

There are multiple definitions of the word SOMA, but given the sci fi nature of the game. Huxleys definition seems most apt. In the novel SOMA is a drug used to mollify existential angst by means of pleasure. This essentially mortifies humanity. Much in the way that the arc is a poor consolation for humankind.

Conclusion: there is no happy ending for the game of life is over before it starts.


r/soma • • Jul 10 '26

Was I the only one slightly disappointed…

0 Upvotes

Played Soma for the first time last week and I have to say, I was expecting a plot twist a bit different than the reveal at the end. I was really expecting that Catherine wasn’t Catherine at all but the WAU mimicking her in order for Simon to help him out in its “mission”. The reveal at the end was kind of expected based on the knowledge you gain during playing. What did you expect to happen at the end first time playing?


r/soma • • Oct 18 '25

The show Rick and Morty is full of SOMA-like situations

0 Upvotes

The other day I made a very low effort post with a screenshot of an episode of R&M where they wake up being the residue of a detoxification process without breaking subjective consciousness continuity, meaning for a couple minutes they feel like they're the original version, just in a different place. Cath would say they lost the coin toss.

But that's not the only time this happens, I can recall at least two more (I have a newborn at home so binging R&M was a nice time filler while bottle feeding him lol):

  • The two Beths dilemma, where neither of them know which one is the original and which one is the clone.

  • The decoys episode, where there are hundreds of versions of the original family and they all think they're the legit one until they realize it's decoys all the way down.

Maybe there are more, considering cloning and parallel lives are kind of the main ingredients of the show. I think the only reason this doesn't hit as hard as SOMA, is that the game puts us inside of the head of someone who experiences this subjective consciousness continuity, so we feel it as well. As an audience you just don't care as much, since there's nothing at stake.

Man, I love this game.


r/soma • • Mar 08 '24

Played "Soma" after "Prey" and...

12 Upvotes

Hello, I really wanted to share my experience with these games and would like to know your opinions. For starters, I'm 36, a big horror game fan since my teens. My fav series is Silent Hill.

Recently I played "Prey" and finished it on easy & normal. I was really surprised by its gameplay mechanics diversity, story development, characters, atmosphere & the endings. Everything was just top notch for me.

Then I played "Soma". My hopes were really high about it because I've read a lot on the net about its having a unique atmosphere, deep story & many people agree that it is one of the scariest games ever.

Well, after finishing the game on Normal, I agree with them about the atmosphere, it is unique in its own way. However, the story wasn't that 'deep' for me. From the beginning it was obvious that human minds were 'injected' into robot bodies. It is really a disturbing idea, right & it thrilled me, but it was obvious. Then the thing about copying minds into the Ark, it was VERY obvious throughout the game (mostly from the audio recordings) that minds do NOT get transferred there, they were just being copied! That's why a group of people chose to kill themselves instantly after the process! Then it was clearly demonstrated to the player after taking the power suit. So the ending (which seems to be a big surprise to most players) just made me sit there & think "Really? Am I supposed to be shocked now or what?"

Now don't get me wrong, I enjoyed most of the game. Just the ending was WAY beyond disappointing for me. I don't know if that was because I played "Prey" right before it. From the start of Soma I noticed some similarities between the two games. Nonetheless, "Prey" had almost a perfect story & execution. Like to know your opinion guys.


r/soma • • Mar 08 '25

I asked Claude about Soma recommendations

4 Upvotes

SOMA is a first-person horror game developed by Frictional Games that explores themes of consciousness, identity, and what it means to be human in a post-apocalyptic underwater facility. If you enjoyed SOMA, here are some similar games, books, and films:

Similar Games:

  • BioShock series - Underwater dystopian setting with philosophical themes

  • Observer - Cyberpunk horror that explores consciousness and identity

  • The Talos Principle - Philosophical puzzler about AI consciousness

  • Amnesia series (also by Frictional Games) - Similar horror mechanics with existential themes

  • Prey (2017) - Space station setting with questions about identity and humanity

  • Observation - Sci-fi thriller where you play as an AI

Similar Books:

  • "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?" by Philip K. Dick

  • "I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream" by Harlan Ellison

  • "Blindsight" by Peter Watts

  • "Neuromancer" by William Gibson

  • "Permutation City" by Greg Egan

  • "House of Leaves" by Mark Z. Danielewski (for psychological horror elements)

Similar Films:

  • Ex Machina - AI consciousness and ethics

  • Moon - Identity and isolation

  • The Abyss - Underwater setting and tension

  • Blade Runner - Questions of what makes us human

  • Sunshine - Space horror with existential themes

  • Underwater - Deep-sea facility horror

  • Event Horizon - Cosmic horror in a space setting

What aspects of SOMA did you find most interesting? I could recommend more specific works based on whether you enjoyed the philosophical elements, the horror, or the underwater setting.


r/soma • • Aug 17 '24

Spoiler I was going to play SOMA, but it lefted the gamepass

0 Upvotes

So I decide to watch a resume on youtube and I have to say... if mind upload became possible, I will stay the hell away for that, jesus I had a panic attack for real have Catherine dies. Good news? I probable discovered I have autophobia...


r/soma • • Feb 14 '25

No Platinum = Crime

0 Upvotes

Not adding a Platinum Trophy for this game is a total Crime..

I was very disappointed when i finished the game and realized that there was no Paltinum for it.

I was just getting into the Platinum trophy grind and i really think that Frictional Games really underestimated their own game

BIG MISTAKE!


r/soma • • Jun 19 '26

No spoilers, should I restart the game on Safe mode?

1 Upvotes

The stealth isnt too bad but those MISRABLE FUCKING SUBMARINE CHASE fuuuuck that. Piece of shit layout a green fucking stinky ship where everywhere looks the same, frustrating piece of shiiiiit.

So worth it to just restart? EDIT: just finished the game on normal thanks guys. Most other enemies are much easier.


r/soma • • Jul 29 '26

Nope....Part 5.......I have work tomorrow.....stress meter already high.............. save it for ya mama NSFW

0 Upvotes

w/e you had to say............I'll tty tomorrow................


r/soma • • Jan 24 '26

Simple explanation for why the coin toss isn't real

0 Upvotes

A copy would have all the memories of the original the moment they are "created", but there's no reason to think they actually "experience" those memories the same way the original did.

For the copy to actually question it's past memories it has to also experience the context of the copy, for example Simon 2 would have be in Pathos looking around while also thinking about this past self. Basically it's not possible for Simon's scan to remember being in Toronto without also having knowledge of being a robot. That's why the coin toss isn't real, if you are questioning wheter you're actually a scan then it means you aren't a scan, because the scan would only be able to do that after it's scanned


r/soma • • Feb 11 '25

Is that it?

8 Upvotes

So I bought and started playing Soma yesterday but I just can’t get into it. I am 3+ hours in, exploring the CURIE wreck, feeling slightly annoyed and thinking whether I want to continue. It’s weird because I saw the overwhelmingly positive reviews and I enjoyed other indie games like layers of fear, firewatch or the outer wilds in the past, but with this one I am just not convinced.

Does it get better later on, or should I just drop it?


r/soma • • Jul 28 '26

Spoiler Things I didn't like about the plot Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I know, almost everybody love the game. I liked... parts of it. Still we can be friends, no need to hate me :p

So here it is

  1. WAU killing ppl

I understand WAU having the idea to experiment with gel and corposes and ressurrect them, and even WAU taking close to death ppl and place them on comatose state to lot let them die.

But there are flashback scenes of healthy humans fleeing the monsters and being killed by them. It makes no sense to me that WAU hunts down and kills healthy humans, it made their last days miserable to the point that they argued and Cath was killed "by accident".

I'd expect WAU to do its best effort to protect those few last living humans. Probably take dino birds example and find resources to feed them and keep them alive so they can have children in hope that if enough generations lives the Earth will become livable again and mankind can repopulate it.

2. Ross not kill WAU himself and not help Simon

I may have lost something here. Why didn't Ross just took the gel and went to kill it?

And, if for some reason Ross couldn't and needed Simon to do it, why didn't he just show up to Simon, explained to him the situation, and asked him for help? Instead, he stalked him the whole path hoping he'd not die and get the gel.

Simon struggled a lot just for not knowing what was happening and could die lots of times. It's against Ross's interest to not even save Simon when he was about to die.

3. Continuity when memory is duped

Ok, I understand the rise of the religious idea that if a human kills himself after being scanned he'll continue as his scan while if he doesn't die he diverts apart from the scan then ceases to be when he dies. It's a nice idea, similar to many religious groups that practice mass suicide. They're close to extinction and will die anyway, so it makes sense to shorten their human life a bit for the chance of reaching continuity.

And the game makes it very clear this continuity doesn't work and they were wrong and that AIs aren't humans.

But then we have Simon 2 and 3 and Cath 2. Cath accepted nicely the "losing coin flip" idea, but Simon 3 suffered a lot and certainly Simon 2 did too.

But there it is, they didn't have to suffer. Because for scans, continuity works! A transfer as Simon expected couldn't happen because data is copied, not transfered, but data can be deleted after being copied. When Simon 2's memory is transferred to the new body, Cath could just shutdown Simon 2's body herself, instead of let Simon 3 see it, and even worse prepare the battery shutdown and leave to Simon 3 choose to activate it or not. Same for Simon 3 after being transfered to the Ark. She could just have lied to him about previous data remaining.

During the Ark launch it's even worse, because if she could make the data upload and launch be triggered by a single cmd, she could have added to it their wipe too.

4. Transferring data to the Ark during the launch

That's dumb. The bullet and the Ark weren't designed to be attached to each other, just to be powered by. The bullet is designed to place any kind of payload on the satellite. It makes no sense to be able to upload data to the Ark or any payload during the launch, it'd be too much risky. If the launch happens and some transfer fails, the payload would have high possibility of malfunctioning at space.

At max, there could be a system to upload data *then* launch once the upload is completed and confirmed. But even that makes no sense. Any payload would be properly prepared and fully tested to only then be placed on the bullet.

5. WAU death

Just boring and useless. It feels it was rushed. The WAU was spread everywhere, including the places that humans sealed to stop it. I'd expect some spread effect when it died, but nothing at all happened. There was no consequence at all.

And even when Simon meets Cath again, they make no big deal of it. "I just passed by on a side area on my path to here and killed WAU and lost my arm in the process", "ah ok cool, can u complete the mission without the arm?", "yes probably yes".

6. Double Cath on the Ark

It was very interesting how it only shows his entrance and how the Ark is then ends. But while I walked I was very curious if Cath 2 got there, because she was uploaded before him, then got very annoyed to confirm she did.

Did she get doubled then, and there were 2 Caths? I considered that Cath 3 would override Cath 1.5, but that would make less sense. They diverged, so Cath 1.5 had memories inside the Ark, and the ppl there had memories with her. Deleting her and replacing with Cath 3 would make the population annoyed too.

I see she was very fine with the dupe idea and also with leaving her dupe behind, so I guess she'd not mind having a dupe there. But still.


r/soma • • Apr 23 '25

Spoiler Very good experience, very disappointed with the ending Spoiler

0 Upvotes

We (me and my sister) had never played a game like Soma, the atmosphere, the plot, everything felt special and we really enjoyed the whole experience.

But that ending is just so foreseeable and just not up to the whole game. It was just so obvious that we were gonna be the copy that "doesn't make it". In my opinion, this "twist" would have had way more impact if we actually didn't know we were a copy until the end. The second time we switch bodies (to get the diving suit), we shouldn't have been told we were indeed copied, but just "transfered".

Would have been also nice to know more about the WAU. I kinda avoided it because I thoight it would change the ending if you used them it too much to heal yourself (Catherine called it "Cancer") but not at all.

8/10 in my book still.


r/soma • • Oct 23 '24

Spoiler Why can scans only be copied, not transferred? Spoiler

5 Upvotes

It doesn’t particularly make a lot of sense. The data is all there and stored in some chip, a chip that can easily be transferred manually mind you, but WAU is able to upload pre-saved scans into the machines around the base. That in it of itself says that the scan can at least be transferred from whatever server is storing it into a unit, but not from unit to unit? The whole premise of the game sits on the fact that scans can only be copied, but once again, if you’re able to scan an entire person’s brain, memories and personality and all, store it in some database, why wouldn’t that be able to be easily transferable?


r/soma • • Oct 09 '15

Spoiler [SPOILER] Catherine tricked you.

2 Upvotes

Okay, so to start we'll take a quick look at Catherine's motivations.

It's clear everyone believes the ARK to be a fantastic thing 'eternal bliss among the stars'. For Catherine, it started out as a 'pet project' which then got elevated to fame when the comet struck. So does Catherine have an altruistic view about the ARK? She's described as shy/quiet by other PATHOS-2 staff and never seemed very considerate during scans (as can be deduced from other staff). Still she talks ethically about it with Simon as our last hope. Then at the very end of the game we find Catherine's body and read her black box. This is where her motivations shine through the most. Even if we disregard the fact that she ignores potential damage to the ARK as it launches and refuses to let it wait for a while, she says specifically 'this is MY project'. It certainly seems more about her work than about saving what remains of mankind at that point.

So how does she trick you? We know (through hard lessons) that brain scans copy, not transfer. Catherine claims she's made this abundantly clear. But as we're sitting in the pilot seat of the Omega space gun, she hooks up the consciousness-copy and launch sequence to the same buttons. Why? Of course to keep us thinking we'll be moved TO the ARK. If not, why not just let us copy over at our own pace and leave Simon-3 and Chun-2 to launch the ARK? Because there's a risk Simon-3 won't go through with it and Catherine wanted her project to launch regardless of what Simon-3 thinks.

Even if her motivation to launch was to save mankind's memory, she tricked us into doing it by making it a one-button push. We were misled into thinking we'd go on. Knowing that makes it hurt just a little more to know Simon-3 is stuck down there alone.