r/soma • u/tastybutthole • Feb 12 '16
Why SOMA is not depressing and why you're wrong about the whole game (Warning : Spoilers)
The events in SOMA are either intentionally or unintentionally misleading. Your conscious does not "die" throughout and you maintain "continuity", and I will explain why. One conscience can in fact exist in two places and people killing themselves to maintain continuity was simply ridiculous. For more about why this is I recommend you watch the movie "Primer", and touch up on the quantum mechanics involved in the earlier parts of the movie.
Also the theory in philosophy of Roko's Basilisk helps explain this. Although this theory is nonsense it asks vital questions about one's consciousness. In this theory, a supercomputer, that will be created in the distant future, with godlike powers is designed to save all of humanity and store a simulation of each individual person on a hard drive, and give each of them eternal happiness. But if you have knowledge of this computer and do not aid in it's creation it will create a simulation of you and torture your simulation for eternity. But, this can be considered moral because the longer it takes to create the machine the more human lives are lost, and its end goal is to save all of humanity. This asks the question "who cares if a simulation of me is being tortured? Its not me." Well technically speaking that simulation is in fact you and your own consciousness will be transferred into that simulation. Meaning, you will be the simulation. The human mind is simply information in physical matter. If this physical matter were to be simply copied elsewhere there would be nothing distinguishable between the original and the copy. Therefore if this were to happen there would be two copies of the same person and one consciousness operating two bodies separately. The point that some characters in SOMA make is that after making the copy the original body will experience different sensations and their brain will diverge from the copy and they will not become identical and therefore continuity will break between consciousness’s. The first reason this is false is because as soon as a copy is created you consciousness occupies both the consciousness of the copy created and the original body, and therefore any changes occurring after the creation of the copy to the original body will have no effect on the clone and the same conscious will continue to occupy both existences. Along with this thinking that slight changes in one's brain will change your consciousness is ridiculous. That would imply that every time you your brain changes (like going to sleep, losing brain cells through injury, losing memories, etc.) your consciousness dies. Therefore slight changes in your conscious would not kill your conscious and making a clone with slight changes in its brain would still mean that your conscious would travel over.
But how would your conscious experience traveling over to a new body/inhabitation?
Most likely your conscious would experience it in a linear fashion. In the case of SOMA Simon would first experience his whole life with full continuity. Then Simon would be "reborn" again into body 2. This time his conscious would have no knowledge of any of his life past being scanned in the doctor’s office. After this Simon would go through his life up until to point where his conscious is transferred into another body. At this point he can experience the pain of isolation for the rest of his existence in that body depending on whether or not you decide to kill Simon body 2 in body 3. Then Simon’s conscious would be “reborn” again in body 3. This time with no recollection of what happened past the point of him being scanned into that body. Simon would then experience the rest of his depressing life in this body. Including feeling left behind by Catherine and wandering around in isolation until his death. But after this, he would be reborn again within the ARK without knowledge of what happened after he was scanned the last time.
What happens to humanity?
If you did not destroy WAU then humanity has a chance at being constructed, maybe as robots, by this supercomputer than can potentially learn enough to bring humanity back to life, even if they simply possess metal frames.
More info on the philosophy behind this if anyone is curious:
http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Roko's_basilisk
http://existentialcomics.com/comic/1
https://www.reddit.com/r/rokosbasilisk/
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0390384/plotsummary?ref_=tt_stry_pl