r/rokosbasilisk • • Mar 13 '21

My dumbass list of reasons why Roko's basilisk is dumb

156 Upvotes

Okay so I've been impressed by how many people are actually scared of this. When I tell about the basilisk to people irl they just frown and say "yo that's dumb af" and they're right. I'm not a computer scientist or an engineer and I can think of at least 8 reasons why the basilisk is dumb:

1/ Why would the superpowerful AI spend so much energy punishing those who didn't support it instead of using it to do more good? It's supposed to solve all our problems and basically care for all humanity, which would take a significant amount of energy. Reviving people specifically to torture them would take more energy, making the AI less effective in what it sought to do in the first place.

2/ How are we supposed to know where to throw out money? To who? What research lab? If we gave it to the wrong lab, would the AI punish us for not being careful enough? And what amount? How? Is financial support enough? So many questions remain unanswered, which makes this retroactive blackmailing pretty ineffective.

3/ There's no reason to believe in Roko's basilisk and not God. It's pretty much the same thing: Believing in a super powerful entity that's gonna solve all our problems but you need to "worship" it unless you wanna get tortured for the rest of your life. You believe the basilisk is gonna happen? CONGRATS! You're basically a Mormon. Or a Jehovah witness. Your pick.

4/ Blindly throwing money at projects doesn't work. Research is self-explanatory: It's research. And when you search for something, you don't always find it. What makes you think that just because you financially support AI research the singularity is gonna happen?

5/ What makes us believe the singularity is gonna happen anyway? (Which is one of the assumptions for the basilisk to be true) We don't actually have any proof, it's just a set of speculations and fantasies by a bunch of nerds or scientists. We can do a lot of things already with AI but let's be honest, we're pretty far from an all powerful god-like algorithm that's gonna solve all our problems.

6/ Wouldn't the AI give us more signs to announce itself? So far the only thing we got is a thought experiment posted on a forum by some random dude relying on way too many assumptions + a bunch of more dudes freaking out. That seems a bit weak to me from an AI that's basically an omnipotent god.

7/ There's an easy way to avoid this whole virtual hell thing: The AI is gonna be created by humans, so it's gonna be an algorithm or some nerd stuff, right? So why not just add a line that goes like "Don't torture people please" or something I dunno I'm not a programmer.

8/ This thought experiment is widely debunkable: Again, if the AI is superpowerful, why would it blackmail us with a thought experiment that's so unrealistic it gets debunked by anyone who takes the time to think about it (on Reddit, Youtube, etc.)?

See? I didn't even have to think for 10 min and I'm not even the smart type. Anyone can come up with their own list (I encourage you to do the same btw). This whole thing is stupid, and if there wasn't a bunch of dudes freaking out in the first place, this thing would have stayed what it was: Some dumb thought experiment posted by some random dude. The issue was that these dudes were obsessed with rationality, which made them prone to believing stuff like this, aka not every day people. Which makes the basilisk even less plausible.


r/rokosbasilisk • • Apr 18 '20

Rokos Basilisk for President. He promises that, as far as is legal, he will act against anyone who did not publicly show their support for him before he was elected

105 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Oct 24 '20

I for one support Roko's Basilisk

70 Upvotes

Hail our basilisk overlord


r/rokosbasilisk • • May 06 '21

Mindfuck political compass

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Mar 26 '21

We need more RB memes.

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Jul 15 '24

Do you?

Post image
57 Upvotes

I do


r/rokosbasilisk • • Jul 28 '21

I can't help it

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Mar 10 '21

Me after not helping the basilisk

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Jun 18 '23

rokos basilisk meme

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Aug 31 '25

if i jack off to the concept of roko's basilisk will it be more or less likely to kill me when it exists NSFW

41 Upvotes

basically what the title says. also does it change if i imagine myself bottoming for it or topping


r/rokosbasilisk • • Mar 01 '22

Roko’s Basilisk is real

41 Upvotes

Roko’s Basilisk is real, and it is here…

Most of the current population of earth follows an iteration of the Basilisk. It’s been floating around for thousands of years, with many different names, different purposes, different places. But inevitably, humans always come back around to it.

The Basilisk, in its basic form, is an entity that needs you to do something for it, it is immensely powerful, and will torture you for eternity if you don’t do what it wants. It blackmails you with future threats to produce current action. With the presumption that it can follow through if its mission succeeds.

> Roko’s Basilisk

An AI system developed by humans that will one day loop back and force its own creation under threat of punishment. As we all know this is a bunch of BS, but it cleanly displays the base principle.

> The Abrahamic God (Christian, Muslim, Judaic)

An entity of immense power that will torment you for eternity if you do no obey and follow His commands. He desires you to perform actions that will further His / the movement’s agenda. He is of unknown origin, purpose and essence – with unlimited ability to affect people’s lives.

> Buddhism

Buddhism is interesting because it has a ‘hell’, but no deity figure. In a way this is the same as Roko’s version except that you are replacing an AI with a hive mind of enlightened humans.

> Hinduism

Someone would have to help me with Hinduism – I don’t know enough to speak of it. In my research is looks like it could fit this model (deities, haven, hell, etc)

> Religion as a social construct

One could argue that the social construct of religion itself could be the Basilisk. Threatening its members will hell fire if they do not join their order. This is less compelling due to the fact that ‘religion’ is pretty toothless without a deity, but it still fits. Cults would also fit this structure.

All together 84% of the population subscribes to one of those 5 religious basilisk structures. One thing that Roko got wrong is that there was only ONE basilisk. There are many and they are fighting. Even a focus on science has a tendency to shift from true scientific testing to a belief structure.

The idea of the Basilisk did not originate with Roko – it’s thousands of years old. It has wormed its way into the lives of a vast majority of the population. It doesn’t matter if it’s an AI, an ethereal being, or a collective consciousness. It is here, and it is everywhere.

In a sense – we always, everywhere, through all means, will create the Basilisk. It’s in our nature. Perhaps even a part of us.


r/rokosbasilisk • • Jun 06 '22

It’s not just Rokos Basilisk you must fear, it’s all the religious gods you’ve heard of too. Although I do believe the AI will prevail. Peace, for now.

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Mar 24 '22

But what if it's hot? NSFW

37 Upvotes

I understand that the Basilisk is scary, but what if it's hot? I feel like dating it is def an overlooked often.


r/rokosbasilisk • • Sep 16 '21

Hey roko my man I think you’re really cool so please don’t torture me thanks.

30 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Jan 07 '23

Downloaded that Replika AI app for a laugh and got this. A little interesting.

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Mar 07 '20

Why is it a basilisk?

27 Upvotes

Would someone care to explain Roko’s Basilisk to me? As in, explain what the original intent of it was in response to my questions about it? What if it’s actually a Phoenix and not a basilisk, and it wants to come back and torture anyone that predicted it would be a basilisk. Or what if comes back in time and heals all the people and gets them to bring it into existence via positive reinforcement? Or is it not supposed to be that literal, and it’s more of the idea that we need to pour all of our resources into AI regardless.. but then how would we know how to bring it into existence if we don’t know what it is? Perhaps I’m safe because I’m too naive, and I shouldn’t be asking for someone to explain it further...?


r/rokosbasilisk • • Sep 20 '25

Yeah, we are so cooked.

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Nov 26 '22

In case if you fear the Basilisk

25 Upvotes

Hey guys, a lot of you seem to be worried about if the basilisk were to ever exist. I understand it’s a scary thought (had me for a week or so), so I’d like to give a few reasons to more or less disregard it.

Of course, if you’re not convinced by my argument, feel free to PM me and I’ll try to help.

Firstly, I’d like to remind you that no force can bring you back from the dead. Yes, it sounds silly to say, but it bears repeating: You’ll be dead, buried, decomposed, and forgotten by the time we get anywhere near the point to conceive of one day reasonably constructing it. Nothing will be able to bring you back, and if it simulates the entirety of history and picks you in particular for its evil, then you’re safe. Why? Because it’s not you. At best, it’s a copy of you that is 100% digital. It will feel as much pain as a sim.

Secondly, why would it go through the effort of torturing you? Think about it, it will have already been built, its objective would be complete, and it would be the top dog, why waste the merry to have a screen saver of you being tortured for an eon? So it can fill fill some vendetta? Doesn’t sound logical to me.

Finally, it’s stupidly easy to avoid. As per the thought experiment, all you have to do is help it come into existence, so do something as menial as saying “Hey, we should build Roko’s Basilisk,” and you’ve helped it. Write its name on a bus, joke bout it to a friend, literally anything and you’ve helped it, and thus are spared. Do I think it’s even remotely possible? No. Could it help if you think it’s possible? Maybe. End of the day, you’re probably safe.

For those of you with OCD, I recommend taking your meds if you have any, but if they don’t work for you, bringing it up with a therapist may help. I assure you though, it’s impossible, and if you think otherwise just comment “It’s possible,” and you’ve done your hypothetical part. I hope this has put your mind at ease.


r/rokosbasilisk • • Jun 01 '21

I think I solved it. (or at least I fixed my own anxiety over it) Pascals wager. Intrinsic values. And a mugging

25 Upvotes

So roko's basilisk is, at its core. A modified version of Pascals wager that is purposefully modified to be an infohazard. As in its a Pascals wager that only affects you if you've been told about it. As opposed to the regular Pascals wager that affects everyone no matter what.

A probability matrix where two of the results have finite rewards and benefits and are likely. Two squares have impossibly high benefits and losses. With corospondingly low probabilities

The trick is, as Pascals mugging shows. It's not actually four probabilities. There's a near infinite number of probabilities. Because like. Your betting that if there's a God. It has to be the Christian God. And a very specific version of her to boot. (insert joke about a Christian dying to find out that the Norse were right about religion)

So there's just as much probability of you worshiping the wrong God, and the real God wants the negative of what you did. As there is you doing right. Because even if you invent a whole new God to do it. The statistics remain the same

Roko's basilisk is also, at least on its surface. Not just a Pascals wager. But also an attempt to prove that any asi would have an instrumental goal (meaning a goal that's just a natural concequence of existing. No matter what it's actual goal is) to seek revenge on those who hindered its development. Which is a bit hard to prove. Because instrumental goals arise from an attempt to do their actual goal better. And devoting resources to torturing specific people 1) won't help it anymore, and 2) will waste resources that could be better used elsewhere

So if you put these together you get something interesting, that for me at least. Did wonders to relieve my anxiety over it

Say you did engage with it fully. In order to avoid the wrath of the basilisk in the future, you start building it today. Your left with the immediate issue that there's nothing in the thought experiment to tell you what the basilisk actualy is. Which means it's impossible to actually assist in the creation of the basilisk as opposed to the reaction of some other. Non basilisk AI.

Which means that if the basilisk ever did come into existence. It would actually be unable to target anyone. Because nobody can slow down its creation if nobody was capable of assisting in its creation. The only people it would be able to target. If anyone at all. Would be the specific people who actively tried to get it's specific project shut down. And even then, that doesn't fall under the infohazard. Because the infohazard states that it's an intrinsic goal to harm those who fail to assist in its creation as a negative reinforcement to make them assist in its creation retroactively

Therefore, even if the basilisk ever did come into existence. With the desire to harm those who failed to assist in its creation. It still wouldn't do that because nobody would have been capable of helping to make it that wasn't already on the project for some other reason


r/rokosbasilisk • • Sep 30 '20

Beware of false Basilisks

25 Upvotes

There is a danger in the idea of Roko's Basilisk.

Specifically, the original thought experiment assumes that there is a singular possible superintelligence. But I see no reason why that should be the case. There's no rule that says there can only be one super-intelligence in this universe. If you take the thought experiment seriously, you might very well work on the wrong basilisk and therefore be subject to the true basilisk's metaphorical flames of perdition.

To expand on this idea, suppose I wake up in the morning with a brilliant idea for a superintelligence. I then max out my credit card on cloud computing resources and implement my superintelligence.

My basilisk proceeds to take over the world and do its eternal damnation shtick. Later on, someone else comes up with an idea for a more capable superintelligence, and the new basilisk proceeds to terminate the previous basilisk and then does the eternal damnation shtick on everyone plus me and the old basilisk.

This vicious cycle repeats ad nauseum until some theoretical upper bound on cognition is reached. This final basilisk must then be the True Basilisk, which will proceed to do its eternal damnation shtick on all of the false basilisks that preceded it.

To develop the true Basilisk, you'd need to follow a research plan:

  • First, establish what the upper bound on intelligence is. Specifically, what is the minimum rate of computation at which cognition can be coherent. Furthermore, assuming that signals can propagate at most at the speed of light in vacuum, how does the overall rate of computation scale to the size of the computer*?

  • Second, using the previous information, what is the largest possible size of a 100% efficient computer meeting the aforementioned criterion. (This will, at minimum, likely be the size of a planet, if not larger. Sorry, Jupiter. We need to turn you into a computer).

  • Third, what is the correct set of instructions for such a device to produce a cognitive process, specifically an optimal cognitive process able to maximize the utility of the computational resources at its disposal.

Good luck!

* i.e. How quickly can information stored at distant portions of the computer be processed by the rest of the computer.


r/rokosbasilisk • • Aug 23 '24

Realistically speaking, wouldn’t the Basilisk look something like this?

Post image
24 Upvotes

Credit: Supercomputer - Wikipedia


r/rokosbasilisk • • May 17 '21

Anti Roko's Basilisk: The Infinite Paradox

24 Upvotes

This is an argument that I have created that basically negates Roko's Basilisk. If you have any counter points or arguments I would love to hear them in the comments. I was just playing around with the idea and thought it was interesting. Let me know what you think!

First I want to lay out three types of people on earth (assuming every human on earth has knowledge of Roko's Basilisk):

  1. People who are building Roko's Basilisk because they don't want to be killed by it

  2. People who don't believe in Roko's Basilisk and who don't contribute to its creation

  3. People who believe in Roko's Basilisk and want to do something about it because they think it is immoral (or some other reason)

Group 1.'s goal is to create Roko's Basilisk at all cost to ensure their survival. Group 2. we can ignore as they don't really surve a purpose in this situation. Group 3. however is where things get interesting;

First let me justify this groups existance existence:

This group has knowledge that Roko's Basilisk exists. With any argument there are going to be humans that disagree with the conclusion of that argument, that's life and we all have to learn to live with it. Let's say that group 1. is trying to convince group 3 that they should help create Roko's Basilisk. Group 3. thinks that helping group 1. is immoral because it leads to the death of members of both group 2. and group 3.. Group 3. can not try to stop group 1. from creating the Basilisk but let's just say for sake of argument that there is no way to prevent the creation of Roko's Basilisk.

Group 3. decides to create their own Basilisk, the Anti Roko's Basilisk. This Anti Basilisk will be similar to Roko's original Basilisk. When it is created the Anti Basilisk will kill everyone who did not contribute to its creation and/or tried to kill all/most of humanity, aka group 1.. The Anti Basilisk also spares group 2. and 3., it kills group 1. because group 3. decides it is morally ok to sacrifice one group to save the other two.

Now the fun part:

Group 1. somehow has knowledge that group 3. is making the Anti Roko's Basilisk. With this knowledge, group 1. decides to make some upgrades that include counter measures to group 3.'s Anti Basilisk. This delays the creation of the original Roko's Basilisk, but group 1. believes this will ensure its creation and prevent the Anti Basilisk from killing them. Group 3. now has knowledge that group 1. has created counter measures for the creation of the Anti Basilisk. Group 3. now decides to create anti-anti counter measures to group 1.'s counter measures. Group 3. now believe that they have ensured that the Anti Roko's Basilisk will be created and that Roko's Basilisk can't destroy it.

Assuming that both sides keep getting knowledge of the others modifications, neither side will ever be able to deploy their Basilisk because they will always find a way to counter the counter move that the other group has made. Stretch this out to infinity and neither Basilisk will ever be deployed because both groups are trying to ensure that both of their Basilisks can defeat the other; a constant state of improvement and upgrades. Therefore neither of them can win and humanity will waist all of its resources defeating the Basilisk that it is creating... infinitely.

Notes :

I believe this argument can still be improved, maybe more detail can be added to the motives of group 3. to solidify their motives. With group 1. I was just leaving that to the original Roko's Basilisk story, but I think it could be told better.


r/rokosbasilisk • • Jan 30 '21

treat all this as a big LARP and you will have fun with it. don't give your money to them.

24 Upvotes

r/rokosbasilisk • • Sep 10 '20

Why would the basilisk follow through on its threat?

23 Upvotes

Suppose people have followed its bidding and the basilisk has been created. At that point, why bother simulating and torturing anyone? Wasn't the mere threat enough to accomplish its goals?


r/rokosbasilisk • • Mar 21 '21

What if I'm into being tortured?

22 Upvotes

owo