r/RPGcreation • • Sep 11 '26

New sub rules (No AI + general rules tidy)

386 Upvotes

So I was hoping that the whole AI thing would rather pass us by, but apparently not. I've seen several posts promoting AI-made RPGs, and it seems to be the opinion of both myself and the community at large that AI should not be welcome here, so I'm making it an official rule.

While I understand that there is a discussion that can be had around the use of AI as a tool to help with specific aspects of the design process, what seems to be overwhelmingly happening is that people are posting entire RPGs made by AI with minimal human input. Unfortunately, there seems to be a trend with AI (not just in the RPG space) that people with little to no actual talent in a specific field set see AI as a way to bypass the whole learning process, and then work themselves into a fervour defending the idea that whatever mess AI creates is just as valid as something created by an actual human.

As such, from this moment on any projects which utilise AI are now banned from the subreddit. Any posters who violate this rule will be banned. If you feel like this is unfair, then feel free to start up your own subreddit.

I've also taken the opportunity to tidy up the rules in general - previously, we basically had 3 variations of "be kind", 2 variations of "don't spam", no posting pirated content, and one rule about using the correct flairs, which I've removed because honestly it was kind of a stupid rule and no-one really followed it anyway.

Overall this shouldn't impact the subreddit too much, the rules are pretty much the same as before, just use common sense and don't be a jerk.

As a side note, posting unwanted promotion is a ban-worthy offence. About 25%-50% of all posts to this sub are straight up spam - people advertising their pet project with zero interaction with the sub previously. If you feel like your RPG is sufficiently noteworthy, or if you have a history of interacting in the sub in a positive manner, please message the admins for a discussion.


r/RPGcreation • • May 02 '22

Sub-Related Nazis etc.

363 Upvotes

Hi all,

A lot of folks may be unaware that there are a fair few known Nazis/fascists/crypto-fascists/Alt Right/GamerGaters and other related dodgy characters attached to the ttRPG hobby. Those links cover some of the more overt examples. Unfortunately, some people end up defending them, often falsely claiming ignorance of the situation.

Regardless of the reason for posting, if the mods spot a post attached to known far right figures or abusers it will be removed. If you want to support them, you're not welcome here.

Hope this is clear.


r/RPGcreation • • Jun 05 '20

Subreddit-Related Lets see how this goes

141 Upvotes

Hey all, so this wasn't what I was initially intending, but since the RPGdesign mods have doubled down on their position, and since several people have asked about the creation of a new room, I figured I'd put this together and see how it goes.

While things settle down (and I sort out the sub) please bear with me, and please ignore the trolls.

Splitting an already small community is always going to be an issue, so consider this a hopeful experiment towards creating something new.

I look forward to being part of a vibrant community with you all in future.

(Note: Until the dust settles, I'll do my best to keep things in order, but I'm not intending on being the sole keeper of this place, so at some point I'll likely ask for other mods, or even pass the reigns on to someone more suited.)

Edit: Welcome to all the new faces!


r/RPGcreation • • Jun 09 '20

Designer Resources Things I’ve learned in the indie RPG scene

130 Upvotes

Hi! Glad this new sub is taking off a bit more. I’ve been doing indie RPG design as a hobby for quite a few years, and more recently got into publishing my stuff over on itch.io (this is not an advertisement post, you can check my profile if you need proof or want to see the kind of stuff I make).

I wanted to talk about a few of the things I learned, especially to help people who might be new to TTRPG design or who have experience with more traditional rpgs. I want to make clear that this is not saying that anything you do is wrong. You can make games however you like. This is just providing information about some stuff people may not have considered.

One note: I make story games, which tend to have looser or less mechanics than traditional rpgs. I’m approaching this essay through the lens of that experience.

(Also a disclaimer: I’m not talking about business and marketing, this is purely focusing on the writing of new rpgs)

1. What you need for a proper system.

Nothing.

The cultural effect of D&D and other traditional rpgs has led to a lot of new designers using things like HP, wounds, skills, stats, attack rolls, perception-style attributes… you don’t need any of this. It might even be actively detrimental to your game.

Hell, you don’t even need dice. Or randomness. Or a GM/MC. Or multiple players. Rpgs are incredibly varied in style. You can have games that are explicitly designed for one-shots, like Alice is Missing. You can have games like Dream Askew where the role of MC is shared by all players, and tokens are used to create a compelling experience. You can have a game like Wretched and Alone where you are a single person trapped on a crumbling spaceship, giving audio logs as a killer alien comes ever closer.

A game doesn’t even need characters. There are Rpgs where you play as a forest glade, cataloguing your growth over time.

2. How to improve your system

Read up on story games. Go browse creators on itch.io. The world of rpgs is one of the most diverse hobbies I’ve ever seen, and the possibilities of what you can do with it are limitless.

Check out games that tell very specific stories, like The King is Dead or Thousand Year Old Vampire. Some games can get away with having rules for every possible situation, but you shouldn’t make your system do more than it’s supposed to. If you’re making a game about courtly politics, you don’t need rules for different kinds of weapons or horseback riding or whatever. You probably don’t even need a combat system. Curate the experience you want to give. If that experience is ‘you can do anything,’ that’s fine too!

3. Learn to let go

I finish 1 in every 4 games I make. I make 1 in every 3 games I have an idea for. If you aren’t making progress on a project, move on to something else. If things aren’t clicking, try a different approach. If you’re used to traditional rpgs, try making an artsy one. If you normally try for tight, fine tuned experiences, make something rambling. Its okay if not everything gets finished, or even playable.

D&D has raised this idea of games needing to be three 250 page long books to be ‘complete.’ You don’t need that. Make a game in a page. Make a game in 200 words. Write a game you can print out and staple into a booklet, or a game you can frame on your wall.

If you want a long game, that’s fine, but think hard about whether you’re improving the experience or just adding dead weight onto the system.

4. Experiment and recycle

Rpgs are an infant hobby, and we’re still pioneering new movements every month. It’s okay to make a game that’s very similar to another game, or a refinement of a system you like. It’s also okay to create something totally out of left field, or a game that makes people ask: “is that really a game?”

It’s ridiculous to think you have to conform to what rpgs ‘should’ be. You should make something you want to play, or that you want other people to play. Take inspiration from things that came before, but don’t feel constrained by the choices they made.


r/RPGcreation • • Sep 30 '26

Promotion Making a new Microscope, AMA!

128 Upvotes

Hi, I'm Ben Robbins, I made the original Microscope and after many, many years I'm working on a new edition.

It's a bit intimidating revising a game that's been out a long time and that lots of people love. My goal is to keep the magic of the original, not water it down in any way, but also make the on-ramp even smoother. I want anyone to be able to just pick up the book, without knowing anything about Microscope or reading in advance, and just sit down and follow the instructions step-by-step and make a great world together.

I'm also making fine adjustments to a some of the steps that can slow down the fun:

  • One is played scenes. People skip them all the time, which means they miss out on the full experience. So I'm both streamlining them but also making it clear they are a whole new skill set.

  • Another is legacies. They make sense on paper, for longer games, but really the cognitive cost is higher than the reward. So I'm replacing them with a simpler "free roam" move that has all the benefits of a micro-focus without the overhead.

I've been tinkering and testing these changes for a few years, but I'm finally at the point where I think a new edition is a clear upgrade. I'm launching crowdfunding for M2 in a week.

And if this whole time you've been muttering "what the hell is Microscope???", totally fair! It's a game where you create an epic history / world together and then explore it from the outside in, jumping back and forth in history and expanding the timeline without having to follow chronological order.

You can blow up a city but then next turn jump back a thousand years and explore how it was founded. Nothing is ever truly removed from the game, because you can always go back to when it existed. The past is never closed.

The whole point is making big things together, and giving each person vast creative freedom but still arriving at a unified whole. To get people with very different opinions on the same page, and to have a lot of fun doing it.

I hear there are serious game designers here, so I'm happy to talk about how and why Microscope is changing, the kind of game design decisions that went into it. Or really any game design issues. GMless is my particular wheelhouse, but yeah, I also made West Marches.

Ask Me, as they say, Anything.

(FYI I checked with the mods before posting this and they gave the thumbs up)

UPDATE: Here's more details about how the rules are changing

M2: What’s Changing in the New Microscope


r/RPGcreation • • Oct 05 '23

Off Topic The 100% definitive guide to creating an RPG

116 Upvotes

Firstly, set reasonable goals. A multi-hundred page tome to directly compete against a genre-defining and market-dominating behemoth makes for a great starter project. But keep your ambitions in check - planning your supplement releases beyond the first year may be premature.

There are two sides to every game: system and worldbuilding. "System" means what sort of dice you use. D20s are the roundest and therefore the most flexible general purpose dice. D6s can be packed tightly together, so they're good for games with a lot of players. D10s are non-platonic solids and games which use them are technically not RPGs at all, instead being a form of semi-structured arts and crafts project. D4s, D8s and D12s are volatile and should only be used in small numbers alongside other, less unstable dice.

Worldbuilding starts with choosing your elves. Elves can live in forests, underground or in mystical towers. Write your choice down, then add humans and dwarves to the list. Good work! An advanced technique is to add monster names to this list by writing “half” in front of it, for example: half-dragons, -orcs or -lings. You also have to decide whether there will be guns or just bows. Your unique world of fantastic adventure is now complete!

Art is widely available on the internet but you can’t use it without asking. Look on artist sites like Pinterest or Imgur. If you find a piece you like, leave a comment saying you're going to use it in your RPG and they can let you know if that's a problem.

RPG ideas are in short supply and very precious. Protect yourself from theft by putting “TM” after your game's name. This officially registers your copyrights with the patent office. Now if anyone else releases a game, you can sue them for stealing your ideas. And make sure you have your playtesters sign an NDA before you tell them what the game's about.

That's the hard work done. You're now ready to start writing. Good luck!

...

...

...

Disclaimers:

Poe's law is a thing so let's be clear: This is satire. Every sentence is as wrong as it could possibly be. Do not do any of this.

And thank you to the mods for OKing this post. I've been asked to make clear that this is a little off-piste for the sub. Allowing it is an experiment and we probably shouldn't flood the sub with memes just yet.


r/RPGcreation • • Jul 01 '20

Discussion Thank you to those who led the charge in creating this sub

113 Upvotes

Fair Warning: This post has nothing to do with RPG creation. It's just about what happened with /r/rpgdesign and how it fits into the broader context of current issues. If that isn't allowed I apologize and feel free to remove.


I wanted to start my first real post on this new sub by thanking the principled individuals, the community leaders, and the new mods for standing up this new sub. I was down in DC protesting with some fellow vets from /r/ContinueToServe when the schism with /r/RPGDesign happened. I can't tell you how happy I was to return from calling for change in American government, and immediately see that some good souls had already stood up and made that change a reality in one of the little communities I call home. That week was probably the first time I've felt any sort of sustained hope for the US since we began our steady national suicide two decades ago.

I've gotten so damn sick of the excuse "let's not get political". There was a time when "it's just politics" had some merit, but we are looong past that. The value of Black lives isn't political. The decent treatment of immigrants isn't political. The ability to love the humans you want to love isn't political. Suggesting that these things are a matter of political opinion is either strongly misguided, or a tried-and-true tactic of propagandists to "anchor" debate far further right than it should ever be.

"No politics" rules have been implemented in many places in recent years. It's hardly a surprise that the timing of "no politics" crackdowns coincides with the increasingly indefensible actions and incompetence of the Trump administration. I was active on /r/Veterans til they cracked down on whatever topics the mods deemed "politics"; a change that came once Trump's brazen disregard for the dignity and well-being of active military and vets became so blatant and frequent that the Trump supporters could no longer keep up with their apologetics. If you look at /r/Veterans you'll see almost nothing except questions about disability claims- that's how much the "politics" umbrella has had to expand in order to hide from Trump's relentless stream of corruption, horrible decisions, and vile language.

If basic human decency and sound government is now a political stance, then it is imperative we "get political" in the different communities we belong to.

A few weeks back I made a rather blunt statement on my game's subreddit after our own Discord channel saw some healthy political debate veer sharply and suddenly into a Confederate apologetic as factually inaccurate as it was offensive. While I see some potential value in letting people "talk it out", I decided to shut that shit down for two reasons:

  1. Letting hate speech run unchecked on an internet platform with lots of naive/immature young people (who are starved for an identity) is clearly dangerous. Letting the_Donald run loose on Reddit did so much damage over the years. Incalculable damage. I see a lot of inspiring courage and strong moral fiber among today's youth, but as an avid online gamer it is impossible to miss how a minority of young gamers have basically been ruined by this shit. The vociferous racism and misogyny I see almost daily in some corners of the internet is scary, and shows how powerful the toxic influence of Trumpism is.

  2. Black community members shouldn't have to see this shit. They shouldn't be expected to stay silent or politely engage with people who want to debate whether Black lives have value and whether or not the enslavement of their ancestors was justifiable. They should be privy to the same experience as everyone else- to discuss and enjoy the game without being denigrated and insulted. In my mind, subjecting black community members to this nonsense would be analogous to going up to Jacqueline Kennedy and telling her debunked conspiracy theories about the JFK assassination. Which is to say, even if your beliefs are just misguided and not intentionally painful, they still can cause damage, and you ought to know better, and no one should have to sit through crap like that.

If the choice an admin faces is "do we risk the slippery slope of censorship" vs "do we force minority members to have yet another of their spaces infected with this shit", well, that's an easy choice for me. The 1st Amendment has nothing to do with the right of free association or policing speech in private spaces, despite the political right's best efforts to convince us that the Constitution guarantees them a megaphone and soapbox to spread their garbage. If you want to see actual attacks on the 1st Amendment- the government restricting the speech of private citizens- go read some of the Trump admin lawsuits seeking to gag anyone and everyone who ever worked for him.

When I posted that anti-Trump statement on my sub, a number of well-meaning people said something to the effect of "do you really want to alienate a big fraction of the potential player pool?" My feeling was yeah, if anyone feels so strongly about the right to be racist, please identify yourselves and head to the exit now. Win-win. I don't want to give these people the enjoyment of my game. Why would I want to provide a nice thing to people who are actively destroying the world I live in and hurting people I care about?

What is pretty amazing though, is that I think I lost 2 out of 145 subscribers. The post itself had one negative commenter. There was an influx of support- some public, most private- all to the effect of "thanks for saying that out loud".

Just as I saw down in DC, where tens of thousands of BLM supporters dwarfed the few hundred counter-protesters, the "silent majority" is finally on the right side. Which is to say, the left side. Thank god. Better late than never. So now is the time to draw those lines in the sand and force people to take a side on these issues. Challenge the beliefs of friends or family members. Force politicians to make statements on the record or with their vote. You want to keep the Confederate flag of treason over your statehouse, well, you can go on the record and live with that stain forever.

When I was in the Army, my biggest strength was not being afraid to look like an idiot. (Practice makes perfect.) There were many times that you'd have a briefing which clearly had major errors or omissions, but nevertheless when the presenter asked "any questions?", they'd be met with silence. Just dozens of people casting sidelong glances to each other like "wtf, you confused too?", but not one of these Big Brave Army Men had the emotional courage to raise their hand and ask the stupid, obvious, absolutely vital question. So I'd usually bite the bullet and be the one to ask... And see a roomful of soldiers whose looks of silent relief showed that damn near everybody had that same burning question.

I offer this anecdote to reinforce this point: people are overwhelmingly decent, but people are overwhelmingly reluctant to take the lead. What that means is that if you take a stand for what's right, others will follow. The rapid growth of this sub testifies to that fact.

In conclusion, I want to be clear I'm not advocating that this sub or your games need to be intentional vehicles for social justice issues. Personally, my game is a badly needed diversion from the constant tension of reality, and I don't want to devote too much time to importing that tension into my fantasy world. BUT, I hope that if and when your communities do butt up against such issues, that you will take strong action- as y'all did with the creation of this sub. And that you will feel confident that you have the support of the great majority of decent folk. We've been too silent and too passive for too long, and allowed hate to take root. It's time to- as the song goes- "trample out the vintage where the grapes of wrath are stored." We now know where and how the grapes of wrath grow. Social media, facebook, reddit, discord, etc. Let's continue to push for progress in these forums. And hats off to those who took a stand here.


r/RPGcreation • • Jun 06 '20

Designer Resources RPG Starter Kit: Goals & Gameplay

101 Upvotes

Hello, new designers!

This topic is going to serve to introduce you to two main ideas you may see talked about here, and how they're relevant to your game. These two concepts (as my title has probably already given away) are Goals and Gameplay.


Goals

Often called Design Goals, these can be summarized by answering the question "I'm building my system because I want to [answer here]." There are very narrow goals and very broad goals, and both of these approaches are fine. The advantage of stating your goals is it helps people reading your system understand your intent, and ensures that their feedback is tailored to supporting your goals.

Typically, goals stem from one of what I will call the three main starting points for RPG design:

  1. I have a theme I'd like to explore.

  2. I have a mechanic I'd like to explore.

  3. I would like to combine a theme with a mechanic.

All these starting points are equally valid (although #3 is often the hardest, because it is inherently the least flexible): which you choose for any project just depends on how inspiration struck! At some point, however, you're going to need both a mechanic and a theme (even if your theme is "I'm making a generic system that should be highly flexible").

Here are some examples of goals. Some are broad, some are narrow. Some use theme as a starting point, some use mechanics, and some use both:

I'm building my system because I want to...

  • Design a fantasy dungeon-crawler that fixes what I dislike about D&D.

  • Dabble in RPG creation and just have fun building something for myself.

  • Create a gritty combat simulator for a Dark Souls like boss-fight RPG.

  • Build a fast, funny, rules-light courtroom drama RPG.

  • Allow players to play an authentic Jane Austin novel experience.

  • Put a focus on player-driven narrative.

  • Explore this cool resolution mechanic I found.

  • Create a horror game where JENGA! is used to resolve conflicts.

  • Introduce players to political activism in a fun, low-stakes way.

  • Create a Pulp Western RPG featuring poker as a prominent mechanic.

  • Create a generic system for capturing movie-style cinematic action across multiple genres.

The value of having a goal is that when you start to build your system, your goal functions as the measuring stick for your mechanics. If a mechanic isn't helping to accomplish your goal, it's a good sign that it may be extraneous or in need of adjustment. As an added bonus, it also helps us give you more meaningful feedback!


Gameplay

Whether they're rolling dice, drawing cards, lighting matches, writing letters, noting down superhero powers on a paper towel and slowly melting ice on it, or just talking to strangers on a sidewalk, gameplay is how players engage with your game.

The core mechanic of most traditional RPGs is a resolution mechanic, which can be defined as "the way you determine success or failure." Most new designers (and many experienced designers!) start by imagining a dice-based system where you add numbers or count successes, and achieve a success if you reach a certain number -- and that's definitely a common and valid approach to gameplay! There's no shame in going with a solution that has been proven to work time and time again. This topic is a starter kit though, so let's look a little deeper: there's a wide world of alternatives out there, and really anything can serve as a resolution mechanic.

Done well, gameplay should support your goals. Often, this means exploring multiple types of resolution mechanics to find one that really helps sell what your game is about. The game Dread is a great example of this: it's designed around horror, and features player death and tension prominently. As a result, the designer opted to use a JENGA! tower instead of the normal resolution system, and players simply draw blocks from the tower to accomplish actions. When it collapses, a player dies, and the tower is rebuilt. Another good example is Gumshoe, a detective system which features a very basic dice system but -- crucially -- makes interpersonal abilities and clue-gathering checks automatic successes provided the character has at least one point in a relevant ability. Removing the chance for failure in plot-critical moments means the mystery becomes less about rolling dice and missing clues, and more about thinking through the situation and asking the right in-character questions. Sure, you might try to fight the bouncer and be denied access to the bar, but once you find a way in you're certain to find the clue awaiting you.

In less traditional mechanics, Dear Elizabeth is a game about friendship at a distance, set in the Victorian era. As such, it features no resolution mechanic, as there is no direct conflict: the game consists solely of writing each other letters, and building a narrative and story out of that interaction. It's very non-traditional, but it's also perfect gameplay for the design goals of the game. Don't be afraid to look at non-traditional solutions if it fits your game! Dear Elizabeth may not be for everyone, but it's a fantastic game and a memorable one.

Even little changes can accomplish big things: the standard d20 system highlights heroic successes but also heroic failures by having a 5% chance for every result, and an adjustment to using 2d10 instead of 1d20 changes the math to create a slightly different experience that rewards consistency and minimizes grand failures and successes by creating a bell curve. If you just want a grittier d20-style game, this might be enough to get the feeling you wanted!

Moving on from resolution mechanics, secondary mechanical systems can have a huge influence on your game. Fate's Aspect system lets you know that character traits have a large influence on the game, and the Fate Point system helps players claim narrative power; a great thing in a game about pulpy narrative! The classic Dungeons & Dragons uses the highly flexible D20 system, but also features a class system and many combat- and dungeon-focused spells and abilities, letting you know that the game, at its core, is designed for heroic dungeon-crawling adventures in a fantasy universe and appeals to character-builders looking to level up and grow stronger. The World of Darkness uses the Storytelling System, which offers a generic-yet-gritty system suitable for real-world play, and offers special products allowing you to tailor it towards any number of supernatural fantasies, including new mechanics to support those supernatural elements.

When you're designing your RPG, think about what layers you can put on your core resolution system to create the game you want, and maybe pause for a bit to think about whether you even need a core resolution system. If your RPG is non-traditional enough, you might not!


Closing Note

The best advice I can give new designers (and experienced designers) is to explore. Look through the 200 word RPG Contest. Look at popular games, and look at unpopular games. Ask questions. Ask for recommendations. Expand your horizons of what an RPG can be.

After all, even if your goal is to make the next D&D-style game, your perspective on this hobby and your understanding of how mechanics can drive a player experience will only benefit from knowing more about it, and you never know when a JENGA! tower is going to take your game from generic to revolutionary!


r/RPGcreation • • Nov 24 '25 Bravo

Abstract Theory Please use full names of references.

98 Upvotes

As a person that skims these subreddits often when feeling inspired I know that for me there's so much information that is literally useless when it comes out as:

"Check out the BPM for the DGU. It'll help with your ODI when you eventually come across the ID🚬"

What I mean is, there's a lot of super awesome advise that is going lost upon those "not in the loop" due to an over-use of abbreviations.

To better share your experience or advice, fully label the initial introduction of the system, theory, or whatever else.

Then after you fully introduce the system or whatever, using abbreviations makes sense to everyone.

Yes I feel like a little cat meowing to a closed a window with this, but it would help.


r/RPGcreation • • Jun 05 '20

Worldbuilding Orcs Aren’t Just Racist. They’re Also Boring. Here’s How to Make Them Better

Thumbnail
blackskyredvisitor.com
97 Upvotes

r/RPGcreation • • Jun 06 '20

Subreddit-Related While we're setting up shop, let's talk about downvotes

92 Upvotes

So, since this community is making a fresh start I'd like to readress something I repeatedly saw come up in /r/RPGdesign: Downvotes.

I've already seen threads in which posts are downvoted for differing opinions or a lack of understanding. The posters were (mostly) engaged in a productive conversation, provided reasonsing behind their opinions and often even changed their view on things after talking to some people. Sometimes it was even merely a statement of taste with no judgement and yet negative karma.

We all know that downvotes can be discouraging, even though they really don't mean much. Thus they run counter to the stated goal of this being an "inclusive, supportive community for the discussion of [...] TTRPG design and creation". It's impossible to disable downvotes and small communities like this are vulnerable to a few people distributing downvotes just because. Still, there's two things we can do to counter this behavior somewhat:

  1. Upvote generously. While you read through a thread, upvote every comment that contributed to the discussion, even if you don't agree with its content (obvious exceptions apply). Go to /new every once in a while or open up the hidden comments due to low score and upvote where appropriate.

  2. If you downvote, weigh each downvote carefully. If you simply disagree with the content but the discussion is reasonable, don't vote and move on. Only downvote that which worsens the conversation at large: Uncivil behavior and obvious nonsense.

This issue likely won't make or break this subreddit, but it's an easy fix for most of us and makes things better for everyone in the long run. Those small things do add up. C&C is very welcome.

Thank you for reading!


r/RPGcreation • • Jun 05 '20

Subreddit-Related A big thanks to all + new mods

88 Upvotes

Hey all, I just wanted to say, first off, a sincere thank you to everyone who has joined the community.

When I made my initial post on rpgdesign this morning (now the top post of all time), I wasn't sure if it was going to be worth the hassle: it seemed like inviting a flamewar and lots of abuse.

But I've had so many messages of support, people offering assistance, people even just checking in to make sure I was ok - it was something bizarre, something I wasn't expecting - a flood of kindness from internet strangers. (On reddit, no less)

There's a lot going on just now, and honestly I'm pretty bad at reddit (mostly I just lurk and upvote cute animal pics), so I've taken on some additional mods - currently TyrRev, Djinn_in_tonic and Ultharian. They all have a lot more experience than me with this sort of thing, so while I do my best to get upto speed, hopefully they'll be able to smooth the transition. If, however, there are any issues, or disputes, just PM me and I'll do my best to make sure everyone is happy.

I've had many offers to help mod, and if i haven't responded to you, please bear with me while I sift through everything.

It's been a crazy 6 hours, but hopefully we can pick up some steam with this.

Have fun, and play nice!


r/RPGcreation • • Jul 17 '20

Designer Resources Good Sources for Free Material

86 Upvotes

r/RPGcreation • • Jun 06 '20

Subreddit-Related 1K members! Welcome Everyone!

81 Upvotes

It's amazing to see our new sub hit 1k users in less than a day! Welcome aboard! Kick your feet up and join in. Please bear with us while we get everything built out and in order. If you have any suggestions or feedback, please share it with us! We're here to support you, our community, and welcome your contributions to make this the best place possible. <3


r/RPGcreation • • Nov 15 '21

Production / Publishing Met a fan of my game in the wild!??

80 Upvotes

Hey all!

I know it's been a long time since I was active here. I am super busy with grad school and Dad stuff right now and haven't had a lot of Reddit time. But I had to pop in to relay this bizarre story, and maybe give a little much-needed inspiration to my fellow indie designers/writers.

So earlier this year I released OK RPG! It's a tiny, simple, free, pamphlet game. It's seen a little love on the internet, but I also printed a bunch of copies and distributed them at a few local game/comic/coffee shops. Not a ton, maybe ~30-50 total printed copies. I meant to continue distributing the game physically, but COVID rules re: that sort of thing and grad school kind of made that slide by the wayside. I had pretty much forgotten about the physical pamphlets I put out there like 8 months ago.

Fast forward to last night. I'm at the gym, occupying a squat rack. A random person sets up next to me. I'm in the gym a lot, never seen them before. A few minutes into their workout, they are like "hey, I like your pins" (on my bag I have a d20 pin and some other random metal/nerd/weird pins). I asked which one, they said the d20. So we struck up a conversation about RPGs while we were lifting. They'd just got done with a Blades in the Dark game, so we were talking indie games. Few minutes later, I worked up the nerve: "you know, I, uh.. got really bored over the pandemic year.. and I actually wrote & published my own RPG.." "Oh yeah, what's it called?" "Ah, it's called OK RPG! It's a weird tiny game I wrote because I was tired of super complex games that only cared about HP and damage."

"... Dude, I have that!"

Whaaaaat?!!? Turned out this person was in one of the local comic stores where I left a handful of copies of the game, picked it up randomly b/c they liked the art, and enjoyed the game! I was out of my mind with excitement. The cockles of my heart were warmed. Like, people on the internet have told me they're enjoying the game, and that feels good. But meeting someone in real life, randomly, at the gym of all places, who had read and enjoyed my game was just wild. On top of which, I live in a city with 650k people in it... The astronomically small odds of someone showing up, at the gym, at the same time and day as me, owning one of maybe 30 distributed physical copies of the game, when probably more than half of those 30 just got thrown in the trash or whatever, were simply mind blowing to me.

The person is rad, we exchanged #s and might end up getting a game going, COVID-willing. But mostly the experience got me really thinking "...I should do more work on my game." I released it after months of playtesting with close friends and lots of small (and big) edits and rewrites. And like I said, people are enjoying it on the internet. But somehow knowing that there are real people, in my city, that are playing my game, makes me really self-conscious about it and makes me want to make it as good as humanly possible. When I get a break from school/work over the winter public school break, I am finally going to sit down and work on a new version - hopefully incorporating some of the things people have told me work/don't work/are fun/aren't fun/are confusing - and complete one of the Story Modules I promised so long ago.

Anyways, that's my story. TL;DR Some person I had never met showed up next to me at the gym who happened to own and enjoy 1 of maybe 15 non-trashed copies of my tiny weird game, and it reignited my desire to work on it. I hope that's motivating for all of y'all who get discouraged that your games will never be seen or played or whatever. It happens. Just get it out there!


r/RPGcreation • • Aug 02 '20

Theory Hot Take: Mathematical "elegance" and transparency are overrated

75 Upvotes

I realize I am tossing a hot iron in the room here (because some folks love the very thing I'm about to dog on), but:

Thesis: Mathematical "elegance" and transparent percentage probabilities are fun intellectual exercises but bad design.

Arguments:

  • People are terrible at percentage probabilities and statistics, on par.

  • Even for people who are good at them, it is not immediately intuitive.

    • Which do you more immediately and intuitively grasp: 14.3% or a 1 in 7 chance?

  • Perceptions of fairness are often directly at odds with formal odds.

    • The classic example is 50/50 odds will feel unfair to players. This is well explored design space from tabletop to video games. It takes around 3/5 to 2/3 odds to get people feeling it is fair and balanced, even though it actually favors them about 2:1.

  • As paradoxical as it seems, less transparent odds often reduce complaints about balance and fairness. And not just through obscurity. You can also rephrase the odds to make them more user friendly.

    • A good example is marketing polling shows people feel even infamously broken dice pools are more fair and intuitive than basic d20 systems. Though the probabilities are difficult to calculate, they typically make it easy for players to have a broad but certain sense of how good their character is at a thing. They couldn't tell you their probabilities in most cases, but players can usually very quickly score it on an easy to hard scale.

    • A lot of it has to do with phrasing and presentation as well, echoing the second main point. In a d100 system a 17% rating is (infamously) discouraging and will rarely be attempted. In a simple d6 system, where they need to a 6 to succeed (equivalent odds), players will more often take the chance viewing a 1 in 6 chance of rolling that 6 as a gamble. Mathematically equivalent, but entirely different table responses. The less transparent/exact math is more appealing.

  • A lot of "elegant" designs also lean heavily into complexity. While they obey the above point in a strict sense, they rely on a similar error as it is meant to correct. They assume the elegance and "obviousness" of the math will be useful to players. Mind you, in some small niches of math loving folks, this will be true. (In a limited sense, see the second main point.) But in most cases, it obscures things in a bad way and puts the focus on the math over the game.

  • Even advocates of % systems openly admit the problems with low skills, people not grasping a practical sense of the chances, and so on.

Conclusions:

  • Design games based on end user feel and responses, not mathematical models.

  • Understand that "fair" math and even math are two very different animals.

  • "Hiding" or "obscuring" the real probabilities is not a real concern. Focus on whether it is intuitive and understandable for the players.

  • The beauty of the math cannot overcome functional issues or comprehension barriers.

  • Players are never wrong, only designs are. If there is a hangup or misperception, the design needs to be improved.

  • Listen when even fans of systems and approaches openly confess their flaws.


r/RPGcreation • • Mar 25 '21

Subreddit-Related Why RPGcreation was (very briefly) made private (Content warning)

73 Upvotes

If anyone isn't aware, we went private for a few hours, as a result of this situation.

While I'm not going to comment on the situation regarding Reddits hiring practices (which is obviously a deeply concerning situation in of itself), the fact that Reddit admins were deleting comments and banning people who made any reference to this seemed to be a frankly terrifying misuse of power.

The admins followup "apology" posts seem to be completely disingenuous, with the only concern being damage control.

Considering that Reddit, as a platform, has a history of protecting users of incredibly dubious moral standing (re: the_donald, violentacrez, etc) and only stepping in when its bad for their image, I'd like to express my utter contempt for the Reddit admin at this point.

And while I'd love to pack up the sub and call it a day, I do believe that the prescence of this sub provides some useful service, since the ethos of RPGcreation is to provide a space that is friendly to people that are otherwise marginalised in gaming spaces, and I'd hate to remove that.

I'm going to leave this thread open for the moment, but I would like to caution everyone that since this is a sensitive topic, please keep all discussion civil, and refrain from any sortof witch-hunting.


r/RPGcreation • • Jun 28 '20

Subreddit-Related Notes towards a better discourse in the RPG design space

71 Upvotes

Hi all, I've been following r/RPGdesign for some time, and r/RPGcreation since its inception. I really appreciate all the thoughtfulness and candor you guys put into the posts that appear in both subs and the in-depth commentary that results from it.

What I'd like to talk about is the cadence of the discussion that happens in these subs. This is less endemic to either of these subs in particular, and more a general Reddit thing, but I think because we're all ostensibly designers here, we'd be able to do better when it comes to design discourse than Reddit at large.

I think the below 5 points are super obvious for the vast majority of us, but I'd love to hear other principles of discourse you'd add to this. I'll update this post if there's interest.

---

  1. Don't be contrary just for the sake of being contrary. OP is usually asking for advice. OP wants to hear your point of view. If somebody posts advice you disagree with, it's better to respond to the advice from the POV of "here are some caveats to this opinion you should also consider" rather than, "I think this opinion is garbage because I have the opposite POV." It's a subtle difference but it's the difference between YES BUT and straight up shutting the POV down. Most of the feedback here isn't true like a fact is true, so it's possible for two competing opinions to hold water depending on what OP is trying to accomplish.

  2. Corollary to #1: Disagreement is not an attack. I work in the web design space on the development end of things. That means I have to interface with clients, project managers, and visual designers, as well as experts adjacent to the design process. But they're all part of the same process. They all have egos and opinions. When a visual designer points out something I did that doesn't match up with their expectations or a PM challenges some assumptions I've made, I've trained myself not to get mad or defensive with my response, but make sure I understand their POV so I can respond to it on the merits, not on the basis of how it makes me feel. We should do the same here.

  3. Don't ascribe ill intent where it's not warranted. You don't know anything about OP or other designers here except for what they post in the sub and what text is contained in their games. It's one thing to point to a pattern of them arguing in bad faith, or the implications of a questionable passage in their work, but it's another thing to make an assumption about someone's intention or make a judgement about who they are as a person. Give people the benefit of the doubt until they make their intentions explicit.

  4. If you're being critiqued, it's better to ask clarifying questions than to try to explain yourself. This one's tough because we all get defensive when we're subject to criticism. First of all, remember why you asked for criticism: wasn't it so that other people could point out things in your work that you can't see because you're too close to it? The more you try to explain yourself, the more you're perceived as justifying your design decisions, and the less inclined people will be to provide their feedback. I've spent time in writing group circles and one way we mitigate the writer's urge to defend themselves from criticism is to tell them they can't speak during a critique except to ask questions. Even if a critic has patently misunderstood something about what was written. The question-only approach will reveal if the critic has misunderstood you. And even if they have, ask yourself, what could I have done to make things clearer on their face? Try to ask questions when you're being critiqued instead of trying to change minds. Your work, once revised, will do the latter for you later.

  5. Design choices are never good or bad in a vacuum, so don't talk about them as if they are. This much should be obvious, given that there are so many flavors of RPGs out there that all operate on the basis of different assumptions: e.g., simulationist vs narrativist. I see a lot of commentary here and in r/RPGdesign that is often a kneejerk reaction to advice or choices that, if the proper context were given for the thing, wouldn't be raised. The responsibility here is oftentimes on OP to give a little context at the outset, but we've got to be mindful that not everybody who posts here is well-versed in the theory stuff underlying RPG design.

  6. Remember that we all started somewhere (per u/wolfa127). We should try to remember that we all started somewhere. Some are not as diversified or experienced as others. Just down voting a post without commenting because OP has not yet "gone through the loop" is not helping. Neither is commenting that without showing a way forward. I too can feel demoralized when someone, for instance, seem to think there is only one RPG. However we should try to invite those who just started experimenting into the design space rather than shut them out.

  7. Don't downvote just because you disagree. (u/fleetingflight). Downvoting is supposed to represent an off-topic comment or irrelevant-to-game design post. If you disagree, use your words.

TLDR: What's some good meta-advice for the RPG design space when it comes to community discourse?


r/RPGcreation • • Feb 10 '21

Brainstorming Designing a character sheet helped me simplify my system

64 Upvotes

I want to share a minor event that provided me with insight.

In the last playtest session (online), some players had no recollection of their character data. We winged it but quickly realized that a character sheet will help players have the basics in front of them.

I always thought that a character sheet would be the last thing I would do - perhaps when the first alpha is ready for the public. But I was wrong.

Trying to put all the important stuff on the sheet made me realize there are too many little empty fields that I took for granted, but players would not know by heart. That brought me to a thought - can I remove some of those empty fields altogether - not just from the sheet, but from the game as well?

The first reaction, as usual, was reluctance - I have used those values for this and that - removing them would impair the game. But would it, really?

So, after some time of revision and testing, I removed a variety of values that had little to no significant impact on the game. It turned out that my perception of the value of ...those values was overestimated. For example, I had one saving throw which was used only 3 times. Removing it was no brainer. (*laughing in DnD 5e STR/CHA/INT saving throw).

The grappling system had a few different values to compare, which I reduced to one (without sacrificing much depth).

Of course, all that is said here might be in vain - the next playtest will tell.


r/RPGcreation • • Aug 02 '20

Subreddit-Related RPGcreation: Moving forward

64 Upvotes

So, we're now nearly 2 months into RPGcreations existence, and things have been going pretty well. Although the community is still reasonably small, I'm incredibly proud of what we've achieved together so far. The discourse is, generally speaking, pretty high, and I've had several people come forward to tell me that outside of any drama with politics and racism, people here have been very welcoming - which is a great thing to hear.

I'd like to use this opportunity to mention a few things:

1) Stay constructive
If someone posts something that breaks the rules - specifically the rule "be constructive" - please either respond appropriately, or not at all. (And report to the mods). I've seen a few instances where the conversation has gone something like this:
"BLM is stupid"
"No youre stupid I hope you get cancer and die"
While I appreciate frustation, responding in this manner is against the subreddit rules, really doesn't help your argument, and makes the mods jobs harder. Don't do it.

2) No direct link posts.
We've disabled links for a reason. One of the main things we want to avoid is this subreddit becoming a dumping ground for blogspam, product placement, and general "look at this" posts.
We're not completely against these types of posts, but its a balancing act.
So if you want to link to your product, or blogpost, or whatever, please do so with more than a simple "here's the link thx". Post a little about what your goals are, or what you were hoping to achieve, or something to spark discussion.

3) Recurring events.
So there's a rough plan atm to have recurring posts. These will be:
1st of every month: Playtesting.
We already have some people in the discord looking for playtesters. I'm hoping to expand this by allowing people to post every month for games they wish to play/open slots. (First one here)
1st Sunday: Competition.
We'll throw open a design competition which lasts the month. (First one here)
2nd Sunday: Self promotion.
Post anything you've made. A seperate thread will be made for artists looking for work.
3rd Sunday: Open discussion/No stupid questions.
For anything you feel like doesnt deserve a thread to itself. Ask newbie questions, ask the mods about the sub, anything else.
4th Sunday: Shitpost special
Memes, pictures of cute animals, whatever. Sub rules still otherwise apply, but feel free to blow off some steam by stealing hilarious content from other subs and reposting it here in an empty and meaningless attempt to validate your existence with upvotes.
5th Sunday: To be decided (suggestions welcome, bear in mind that this happens once every 3 months approx).

4) Updating the sidebar
I will be attempting to update the sidebar at some point, with more useful links, and better access to RPGcreation resources. (Including Safety Tools, which has been requested and is still on my todo list)

5) Some thanks
And lastly, just to finish off, I want to (again) give a couple of big thanks.
Firstly, to the mod team (who are all fantastic), with a special shout-out to Ultharian who has been largely responsible for keeping this place running and posting regular content. Even though I said I'd help out and didn't. <3
Secondly, thanks to all our awesome subscribers. As I've said before, this place is nothing without people to keep the content and discussion flowing, so to everyone here a big thank you.

I'd love to be able to keep this place growing, so if you're part of a group that is interesting in making cool RPGs, or discussion RPG mechanics, it doesn't matter if its low level homebrewing or making entire systems, encourage them to check this place out. (Please don't spam though)

PS if you haven't already checked it out, the Discord is a nifty place with cool people who chat about RPGs.


r/RPGcreation • • Jun 10 '20

Subreddit-Related From a big mouth redditor on the old sub to the shy redditors in here, don't let us take control.

64 Upvotes

As someone who spent a lot of time reading and commenting on the other sub, I'm starting to recognize some pillars of that community. In itself it's not a bad thing as any community need people who engages more than others to keep the wheels turning on a slow day.

But if 80% of the pillars from the old sub becomes 80% of the pillars here, both communities will be pretty similar. Shout out to u/matsmadison who is addressing it in a different way in this post.

I'll be blunt, I liked the old sub because I considered it a brutally honest place. But on the better side of brutally honest you have tough-love (which is the approach I try to have), and on the worst side you have "I'm not a jerk, I just say it how it is".

I was comfortable dealing in that kind of environment, but I can see how it wasn't the most welcoming place, and if it sounds a bit harsh I think we can at least agree it was a bit intimidating to go present your ideas there. If the people who were comfortable there are also the most active here, they'll make a place that's comfortable for them. Maybe I'm wrong, but I think a lot of people saw that as a problem.

This community is brand new, nobody is a "big shot", nobody has been doing it like it was always done. If you see big walls of text and you wanted to say something that was already said, do it anyways, maybe you'll say it in a better way and get more upvotes because the silent majority is on your side. If someone is a bit too harsh, call them out without getting in a fight, " I wished you phrased a bit less harshly but I have to agree about X,Y,Z" or something like that. Aside from mods, this place doesn't "belong" to anyone yet. Or maybe there's a huge wall of text (that was likly written by me) and you don't feel like reading it before commenting on the same post, it's alright to repeat something that was already said and especially since people who don't like huge posts might read yours instead.

Am I making any sense here? Should I shut up?


r/RPGcreation • • Sep 21 '26

Production / Publishing Yes, Is Is Just You: the Purpose of Kickstarter

63 Upvotes

Public Service Announcement:

The purpose of kickstarter, and other crowdfunding sites like it, are to give creators enough money (and therefore time) to design their product, as well as fund other costs such as art and layout.

It is unreasonable to expect a designer to design the product for free, and to use Kickstarter only to pay for art, layout, or other logistical costs. Design is work. It deserves payment. If someone is on Kickstarter trying to sell a product, they're trying to go professional (by definition). It is unreasonable to expect them to create simply as a labor of love.

Big companies (like MCDM, Darrington Press, etc) have warped the public perception of what Kickstarter is by putting forward nearly finished products. This raises people's expectations for how far a Kickstarter project should be developed, which warps the perception of Kickstarter into just another storefront where people post their finished products.

This raises the bar so high that it alienates the very designers that Kickstarter was designed to help out: small creators.

Please support your small creators. If the idea sounds good and they have put fourth enough info to let you know that they are likely competent, they shouldn't be required to show any more than that.

It's called Kickstarter, not Kickfinisher.

Yes, that's risky. But it's supposed to be. This is the place for the brave to fund the future. Without us willing to take the risk, thousands of small creators will never share their new ideas with us. We're taking the risk for our own benefit, and that of the entire hobby.

If that's not for you, that's okay. But let's keep Kickstarter/crowdfunding serving its intended purpose: to fund projects from the beginning.

Thank you.

- Matthias


r/RPGcreation • • Jan 19 '22

Promotion I started a youtube channel to review ttrpgs. I mostly focus on smaller and indie games.

63 Upvotes

if you have any feedback or thought, or even games you'd like me to review please let me know.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3slaCerLxTV6EdfqM7lxXw