r/RPGcreation • u/ancientgardener • 1d ago
Advice needed on Dice pool mechanic and health system
So I've designed what I consider a pretty clever system. It's for a survival/village management RPG I'm working on. The game is entirely player facing. The GM doesn't make a single roll for any NPCs, checks, damage etc. The game can be run GMless, though it's not really designed with that in mind.
The core mechanic uses a dice pool system similar to WOD and other games: a character's ranking in a skill determines how many D10s they need to roll. Everything over a 7 is a success and each check needs a certain number of successes to complete. Their ranking also determines how much of a particular resource they can carry. This resource is needed by the village but can also be spent by players to increase their rolls, allowing them to get more successes. Simple enough so far.
However, their Health (currently called Survival) is directly tied to their ability to roll dice. For every dice a player rolls using a "physical" skill, their Survival drops by 1. So get into a fight, roll 3 combat dice, and you spend 3 Survival. Additional successes over the required number can be used to regain lost Survival. It can also be regained by spending Food resources as well as a few other options.
My problem is that I just realised I think it hurts skilled characters too much. An unskilled warrior with combat 1 rolls only 1 dice, so can only take a maximum of 1 "damage" while a veteran warrior with combat 3 rolls 3 dice, so immediately takes 3 points of "damage". They've got more chances of passing the check, but it strips their health pool a lot quicker.
I've thought of two options. The first I've come up with is that it costs 1 Survival per physical check. A flat tax sort of thing. The other is that the number of successes required for the check is also how much Survival it costs to make the check, and that the number of successes a player actually manages to get replenishes that survival. So a player needing 2 successes only gets 1, they fail the check but only lose 1 survival. Hope that made sense to read. My concern with both those is that it might make survival drain a minor inconvenience, instead of a key resource players need to manage through an adventure.
Does anyone have any advice on how to make this work?