r/RPGcreation • • Nov 12 '25

The Advice “Go play X game” is Profoundly Unhelpful

4 Upvotes

This post is not meant to be rude or attack anyone in any way. I am making this post because I love this community, and I believe there is something about it that can be easily changed to improve it. I want this community to be as enjoyable as possible, and am making this post to encourage that, not to put others down. Now that that is out of the way…

Oftentimes a poster will be asking a specific question about an aspect of their game, usually a particular mechanic that they want to create, tweak, or get the general opinion of the community on. A not uncommon response to these posts is “Go play X game”. 

This type of response, rather than being one of any amount of effort that actually answers the question posed by the OP, or encourages any amount of dialogue, assumes that the OP can and should read and learn to play a new game, find a gaming group willing to play said game, and schedule, prepare, and carry out one or more sessions of play, simply to have a question of theirs answered about a specific topic.

A less unreasonable, but equally effortless response is “Go read X game”. Which again assumes that the OP without any context of why they are reading said game, go read the game and search through the rules for a section that may pertain to their question.

I encourage all to instead of commenting “Go play X game” or “Go read X game”, actually put thought into your comment in an attempt to be helpful, and respond more along the lines of “X game handles this mechanic in Y fashion, and I like it for Z reason.”

This is not an attempt to exert control over others and tell them what to do, I’m not your dad. This is an attempt to create more thoughtful discourse in the community I love.


r/RPGcreation • • Jul 12 '21

Promotion Guess my political biases from my micro-RPG

2 Upvotes

Hi guys,

This might be an odd request, but I'm working on mini RPG about conniving fairy politicians. As you might expect of such an overtly political RPG, I'm not making any attempts at hiding my political opinions. It does not, however, include a detailed breakdown of my voting habits, or anything like that. Basically I just want to make sure nobody will misrepresent my political views from my RPG.

So, I'd love for people to read the rules, and tell me what they think my views are.

(it's 7 tiny pages, including illustrations and a character sheet)

RULES:

Tax Cuts & Pixie Dust Rulezine


r/RPGcreation • • Nov 16 '23

Design Questions I came up with a ranking system for judging individual superpowers based on specific criteria

0 Upvotes

I have come up with a way of ranking individual powers based on a few criteria, specifically for a TTRPG setting This is so that I can judge the "power level" of an individual power, and the number associated with it is also based on a point buy system. At the start if players decide to create a super hero from scratch, they are given a specific amount of points to "buy" their powers.

Here is my list.

Offense: Measures the power's capability to deal damage and be effective in combat situations.

Defense: Addresses the power's ability to withstand attacks or protect the user.

Utility: Encompasses the power's capacity to hinder, control, or debilitate enemies, making it easier for the user or their allies to handle them or escape. It focuses on crowd control, debuffing, or any other means of strategically influencing the battlefield in favor of the user or their team.

Adaptability: Measures how well the power can be modified, adjusted, or creatively used in different situations. It reflects the power's flexibility and effectiveness across a variety of scenarios.

Danger: Assesses the potential harm or lethality of the power to other individuals, or buildings, the planet or reality itself, beyond just combat.

Support: Evaluates the power's ability to aid others or provide assistance in non-combat scenarios.

Risk: Assesses the level of risk associated with using the power. Considers potential harm to the user, unintended consequences, or vulnerabilities during power usage.

Synergy: Evaluates how well the power can work in harmony with other powers. Reflects the collaborative potential of the power in group scenarios.

Dependence: Assesses the extent to which the power relies on external resources, conditions, or factors for optimal functionality.

Difficulty: Evaluates the level of skill, effort, or complexity required to use the power effectively.

I want to know if the criteria I have for judging powers is good for under a rpg game. and if there is any additional ones I should use? I also use a letter Rank to correspond with it, Z X S A B C D. Essentially imagine each power is a student, and this power is being graded based on the things I listed. There will be a 7 graph system to judge each individual piece, where 1 is the lower end, being the worst, and 7 being the best. The 7 is also to correspond with my letter Ranks. And so based on the average of all the grades together is how I would determine the powers overall grade. Hopefully this makes sense, because I am AuDHD and I know something can make a lot of sense to me and not so much to others lol! So I apologize if this sounds like a mess to someone else.


r/RPGcreation • • Aug 14 '21

Getting Started Making a New RPG (D20 most likely) Because I am Dissatisfied With Both Pathfinder 1e and D&D 5e and Want Something More RP Driven

0 Upvotes

The Basics:

To start, I want something that is simple and allows just about any kind of character concept but confines itself to reality (like armor minimizes damage and a 100ft dragon will wreck your shit even if you are Lv20 min-maxed character because you puny human are only 6ft tall and less than 1% its weight). This means lower numbers overall with small modifiers to represent your abilities. 0 is average no modifiers because 0 is neutral. Negative numbers are anything less than that average (will probably use humans as that average because that is the easiest thing to relate to). Positive numbers are anything above the average. Think M&M 3e but the scaling is way less. Stealing size categories from D&D but each size above doubles advantages for each size category above the other and reduces any immunities to resistance to neutral to vulnerable to deadly and vice versa. Also like M&M, you have points to buy things to upgrade your character and "levels" is how many points you specked into that area (martial levels, magic/psychic/etc levels, combat levels, crafting levels, scholar levels, etc). Abilities are not written but have simple templates like [Str based+melee+weapon group] would be the template for the combat skill of a particular set of melee weapons.

Combat:

I got this from an old custom M.I.T.H.R.A.S. character sheet where the head, arms, torso, legs, and other appendages (as applicable as some have many of one and or lack others) each had their own hitboxes (hp, armor, and resistances). This makes armor piecemeal by default and makes upgrading and customizing easy to do. Each armor type would come with an armor bonus that reduced damage by that amount with a resistance to a damage type reducing that by half and immunity ignoring that damage altogether (gambison is resistant to bludgeoning and plate is immune to slashing assuming attacker and defender are of the same size category). Each armor type has its' own ups and downs as do weapons. You can layer armor taking the best armor bonus+1 per additional layer (within reason like you can't wear multiple sets of plate-mail over one another) and gaining the other specials of each armor but take increasing penalties to movement.

Weapons come in four basic types. (below is super generalized)

  • Bludgeoning: maces and hammers

  • Chopping: axes and some bladed weapons like executioner swords (argument for katanas to be here but also for slashing)

  • Piercing: spears and arrows

  • Slashing: arming swords and glaves

Weapons can modify an attacker's effective size category depending on weapon size. Knives count as a size smaller (some may have specials to negate this vs. specific targets like a rondel dagger vs. gambison but only while piercing) while a behemoth blade would count as at least one size category larger with the drawbacks of negatives to hit and mobility. To hit with a weapon it would be to add Str not to exceed Dex and damage would be the weapons main damage modifier (almost always Str)+half the secondary (almost always Dex)+damage die of the weapon. Damage is done in 2s rounded with those under 2 causing minor wounds (ex: small cut), 2-3 causes minor injuries (ex: bleeding), 4-5 are major (ex: broken bones), and over 5 are grievous injuries (ex: dismemberment). This can go up to increments of 5 (some special creatures like dragons can go higher) with features representing a higher level of combat ability or other means (such as luck or magical protection). Just remember, a peak human ability score is about 10 so don't expect a normal person to get higher than a +20 even in very high-level gameplay without supernatural aid. Damage stacks so you still have an hp pool until that limb acts as if it had higher injuries using the same rules as above but major injuries are instead lasting injuries like concussions and only become useless at 0hp (can sometimes mean death for head and torso).

Not sure if I like the damage system yet. I want both Dex and Str to matter for weapons but I also want to prevent numbers from bloating. Just because you are strong does not mean you hit and just because you hit does not mean it makes an impact. Crits up the damage by one rank from minor to major to grievous with natural 1s doing the opposite.

Healing abilities is where I get stumped as I want a wounds system that plays into hp loss in some part. I need suggestions.

Other:

I want to add skills where ranks give more dice to roll (1d20+skill dice with a "botch" only on confirming a nat 1 with another nat 1 on the d20 only). I could probably do this for damage dice as well but I want to keep the to-hit bonus static (under normal circumstances) to prevent long periods of number crunching.

I know I need an ability score list, crafting system, enchanting system, weapon list, armor list, gear list, and basic economic system. What else do I need to get to a functional Alfa phase?

Edit: I can't figure out how to upload a Google Doc. I'm not a tech guy (can't find any tutorials I understand or cover this topic) so any advice is welcome. Being able to do this would make the review process easier for everyone.


r/RPGcreation • • Oct 01 '25

Design Questions Is it time to Dump Constitution?

3 Upvotes

I had made a video about this topic [ https://youtu.be/hWwiwtXq9XI?si=UOF-FkpB-gAgKSuD ] and have read all of the discussion so far around it and was curious what others might think.

Major Points:
- Daggerheart and Draw Steel both forgo Constitution as an Ability instead leaving Health as a direct aspect of Class choice similar to how HP is handled at level 1 (sans Con Modifier).
- Constitution is good stat for everyone but is rarely an interesting choice it can feel like a Tax during character creation. (A Barbarian wants Con so they can be in the frontline longer while a Wizard wants Con to try and avoid being 1 shot by a lucky crit.)
- Constitution is the only Ability without an associated Skill.
- If Constitution is removed the Physical Hardiness of it could be rolled over to Strength as Strength Saving Throws are the least common Save and Strength only has 1 Skill (Athletics).
- Concentration Checks could be rolled into either a Level/Proficiency Save or a Spellcasting Ability Save.
- Constitution is the most used Saving Throw.
- Health being solely tied to Class might remove the customization option for "burly" casters for those that do not wish to fit the stereo-type of frail casters.

What are everyone's thoughts on Constitution as an Ability? Should it be removed? Should its components be moved other places? Should it be expanded to take a more important role?


r/RPGcreation • • Aug 31 '21

Production / Publishing I need some ideas for my company name

0 Upvotes

The reason I got into making RPGs was because my favorite war game, Dark Age died. We were left high and dry.

82 votes, Sep 07 '21
9 Dayminkaynin’s Private Sanctum
47 Brood Mother
6 Attr’s Forsaken
1 Left on Attr to Rot
19 Other

r/RPGcreation • • Aug 31 '22

Getting Started Economy for my Modern Day Geopolitical Strategy RPG

0 Upvotes

I am currently developing a game that combines aspects of RPG, strategy, and business simulation. I am currently working on creating the economy. I am having two major issues with the games economy. Basically, players in the community can choose to be a CEO and own a corporation which can than build different businesses (Car Factory, Coal Mine, Wheat Farm, Supermarket, etc.) The issues I am having are determining how goods are produced via factories, farms, and mines AND how the number of goods sold is calculated. I don't want things to be too complex but I want it to be dynamic enough where it can change.

With production, I currently have 4 levels of workers that each have a different base "efficiency" that each one can produce. This number can change based on the nations economic score. I want to allow the worker levels, which ties into education, mean something but the type of good produced should effect the number produced for the turn. i.e. Car Factories and Clothing Factories should not produce the same amount of goods per turn. Any advice would be helpful. I have looked at different resources and books online but haven't really found anything.


r/RPGcreation • • Mar 29 '24

Promotion Be honest. How good is my One Page RPG?

0 Upvotes

See the comments for the details of the game.

Any feedback is appreciated. Of course, being biased, I think its pretty good, and I want to share it.

https://www.reddit.com/r/onepagerpgs/comments/1bp420w/inventory_one_page_rpg/

Edit. You've made some fair points. I haven't made a cohesive document out of it. I see why you'd wouldn't know how to start testing it. So I'll test it myself, write a report on that, and write up a document or wordpress page so the rules arent disjointed. Honestly this isn't even my main project, its something I came up with on the fly.

I'm sorry if it was annoying to read a One Page RPG that seems low effort and disjointed. But that exactly what it is. Its just that I had a eureka, wrote it down, and had some more thoughts on it, and wrote them in the comments. I didn't mean any disrespect, its just the nature of what is is and how I came up with it.


r/RPGcreation • • Mar 06 '26

I want to hire someone to make an RPG

2 Upvotes

my partner is an avid gamer and we have been reading the dungeon crawler carl series together. I came up with this idea to propose to them using a custom made DCC game. I have never played a RPG game in my life so Im not even sure its doable. Ive posted on Fiver and a few other freelance sites but I would prefer to find someone who is familiar with the DCC series. I have the storyline of the game kinda figured out but beyond that I‘m not super sure what else to do or where to outsource. I can’t post on the DCC thread because my partner is too active on it and will figure out what im up to. If anyone can point me in the right direction I would appreciate it.


r/RPGcreation • • Jul 18 '25

Design Questions Feedback request: Age of Aquarius, a radical anti-capitalist game of contemporary high fantasy

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm Xauri'EL and I'm working an an Apocalypse Engine-inspired game called Age of Aquarius. It's about a near future where magic has returned to the earth. Billionaires are turning into dragons, and ordinary people are awakening into legend-born -- developing spontaneous magical abilities, fantastical new forms, and alien neurodivergent personalities. The player characters must cope with radical change, face the responsibility that comes with sudden power, build community and solidarity, and decide what kind of future they want to fight for. Age of Aquarius is a revolution simulator aimed at players who want to vision solutions to the crises of capitalism and experiment at solving modern problems with unexpected tools.

If you want to read the whole thing, have at 'er. If not, these are the sections I'd like the most feedback on, in order:

  1. Core concepts and basic moves

  2. Character creation

  3. The section titled "Life in the Age of Aquarius" (it's near the end)

Reading the section on ritual magic will also help add context; it's short.

Please be aware that this is an extremely rough draft that has received zero playtesting. DM me if you want comment permission on the document. I also have an invite-only reddit community intended for discussion and feedback; it's not very active, but it's just begging for an influx of new members. Also, if anyone is interested in playtesting this beast, let me know; I'm planning to prepare some surveys to help me gather data. Beyond that, any kind of honest but gentle and diplomatic critique would be very much welcome!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vQNVQB1g2VsRHDjXlf-AYFb_QsW8raSdg5lrM6oiTKJvXKP5zysgV_QYUM4sh8UjEvIW7B2oMfeG4yx/pub


r/RPGcreation • • Jul 07 '24

Getting Started Creating my own system for a Space themed TTRPG! Only uses 2 Dice. Love to see your thoughts!

0 Upvotes

Hey, guys! Came here awhile ago talking about a system I'm working on that only requires 2 D20s to play. I'm calling the system the 2-Dice RPG for now until I can think of a better one. I figured I'd post what I've created so far in case I can find people interested in giving me some advice. The reason I'm making this system is because I prefer narrative focused, light on rules games. A lot of the space themed games I've come across are very heavy on rules, which for some people is incredibly useful. But for the type of game I want to play, I don't think spending hours upon hours learning how to take care of your ship is useful to me. So...I made this. This system can be used for many different genres as well, but I'm focusing on my space game for now. Hope you enjoy!

Base Dice Mechanic: This game only uses 2 D20s of different colors. For my table, I bought two liquid core dice because they're cool and we can pass them around. One dice you roll to see if you succeed or fail at a skill check. The other dice is a narrative focused dice. If you roll over a 10 something good happens, if you roll under a 10 something bad happens. If you roll exactly a 10, you just succeed and gain advantage on your next skill check. For Skill Checks, the players will have to cooperate with the "GM" (Need a cool name for GM) to give them extra +'s on their rolls based on their Occupation, items on their person, surroundings, etc. I've always liked the idea that you can succeed in the task you're trying to accomplish but narratively something could happen that builds tension. Or even better, you can fail at a task but narratively something happens to help give you a leg up on your next attempt. A lot of RPGs do this but a lot also have a ton of dice. For example, the Star Wars Forces of Destiny RPG has a huge pile of dice you roll and I wanted to try to avoid that. The more simple this game is while also giving a lot of freedom to both players and GMs the better,

Progression: Last time I posted about this, someone suggested this game have a no-level progression system. I ended up liking the idea. Instead progression is measured in the items your characters have access to. At the start of every day, you equip your character with items to keep on their person throughout the day. Each Occupation has their own Item Points they can spend when deciding on what items to bring with them. For example, the Captain might have 15 points to use when deciding on what items to bring. A flashlight will be 2 points, a pistol will be 3 points, food will be 2 points, and so on until you expend all your points. When you drop or pick up an item, you have to make sure your character doesn't exceed their point maximum. Progression will be based on what items your character has access to, the longer the game goes the better the options presented to you. I like this system because it gives the players a choice to make at the start of everyday. An important choice. They might have to leave something behind they really wish they could bring with them.

Occupations: These are this games version of classes. There are six occupations. You gain +'s on your skill checks based on what Occupation you have. Some Occupations also have exclusive items only they can bring with them. Below are what each of them are focused on!

Captain: The captain of the ship is the jack of all trades option for the game. While other classes are exceptional at doing a specific thing, the Captain is pretty good at everything. Of course, you'd still want an Engineer to help fix up your ship but if they're not around, the Captain is the second best choice. There are items exclusive to certain Occupations that the Captain does not have access to. So while the Captain is great at everything, their arsenal is limited. Being Captain, you get a +3 on every check unless something external is putting you at a disadvantage. But for most checks, the Captain gets a boost.

Medic: The Medic is one of the most valuable members of any ship. They're there to make sure everyone survives above all else…sometimes. There could be reasons otherwise. You make your medic however you see fit. The Medic has access to the vast majority of healing items on the ship and can often be the last chance any of the crew members have to live. The Medic gains a +5 to any skill check that involves Medicine. If you're using alien medicine or are performing medical practices on an alien, you gain a +3 to that roll instead. Being a Medic means you have exclusive items that only the Medics are allowed to use. Many of these items are used to help your other crewmates. For example, only the medic can revive another player's character after they've died if the medic can get to them quick enough. If a player's character is too far away from a Medbay, the Medic's inventory might be their only chance at survival. Remember to use multiple items or your surroundings to convince your "DM" to grant you additional +'s to your rolls. For example, not only can you apply bandages but you can also apply hydrogen peroxide to grant you more +'s to succeed. Also, if any other players are with you they can assist you, granting you an even greater chance of success.

The Medic has 10 item points. These points can be used to fill your person with items for the day. Anytime you start a day, you choose what items you'd like to take with you. Anytime you drop an item to pick one up, you have to make sure those items don't exceed your point maximum. Down below are items exclusive to the Medic:

  • Revival Syringe (3 Points). This syringe is full of Adrenaline, enough to where if you can get to a player's dead character in time, given that character hasn't received a wound that can't be treated, you can bring them back to life! One minute is a recommended time for a character's death to be permanent.

  • Hydrogen Peroxide (2 Points). This can be used on wounds to help heal it quicker and kill off infections. Out in space, who knows what kind of awful infections could get inside your wound.

  • Stress Pills (2 Points). These pills can be taken to remove a point of stress that you accumulate. You only have 3 uses of these before they're used up completely and have to be replenished in a Medbay. You're, of course, allowed to share these pills with fellow characters.

  • Adrenaline (3 Points). Need a boost? Take pure Adrenaline to make yourself faster, jump further, perform feats you otherwise wouldn't be able to! The effect of this Adrenaline lasts for 3 different skill checks. Using this will automatically give you 2 points of stress after it's completed that cannot be regained with Stress Pills. They can only be regained after resting.

FOR THE OTHER OCCUPATIONS I HAVEN'T DESIGNED THEM IN DEPTH YET

Engineer: The Engineer is tasked with ship maintenance. You know the ins and outs of how the ship functions. You're there to make sure nothing goes wrong with your ship.  This includes fixing wiring, lights, a broken thruster, engine work, cryo-pods malfunctioning, anything that requires to fixture of electrical things. When you roll a Check that involves Engineering you get a +5 to your roll. If the tech is alien it is a +3 instead. Being an Engineer means you have access to tools that will give you an advantage on more specific Engineering tasks. With these items you can use them to convince your "GM" that they'd be useful doing said task. If the "DM" agrees, they'll grant you an extra + to your rolls. Additionally you can gain help from other players as well to boost those rolls up. Need someone to hold a flashlight for you? That could be an extra + on your skill check! Anytime you get an idea that might give you an edge to succeed, discuss it with your "GM"! That idea might make the difference between success and failure.

Soldier: While some aliens out there shrug off bullets like nothing, you're still the crews greatest defender against the unknown. You're there to protect the people that can't protect themselves. Something comes on board your ship? You pick up a gun and you get to work. As this is a survival game, some aliens might be near impossible to kill even with bullets, but you can hell as sure slow them down to give you and your crewmates time to escape. You may not know much about the ship itself but you damn well know your way around a gun. The Soldier gains a +5 to any checks that involve weaponry or strength of any kind. If you're using alien weaponry, you gain a +3 instead. While the other crewmembers might be able to use a simple pistol, the Soldier is the only one that can use more advanced weaponry. They get access to assault rifles, shot guns, grenades, and other resources to help fight off threats to your, your ship, and your crew.

Communications Officer: This one is for all my Wolf-359 fans out there. The Communication Officer is the line of communication between the crew and aliens from other planets. They're trained to understand alien language. They're also tasked with keeping communication between everyone on ship and record logs for the future! Sometimes you'll be on another planet with civilization to stock up on supplies, having a Communications Officer to speak to the people of the planet could be vital. Need someone to try and talk down a possible ship invasion? Well good for you, you speak their language! This Occupation gets a +5 in any checks that require communication, persuasion, or diplomacy.

Pilot: This is the Occupation I am most unsure of. For the game I'll be running, personally, it's set on a space station on auto-pilot orbiting a blue colored Star. But for other games, I could see a Pilot being a very attractive Occupation. When people think space, spaceships aren't far behind. In cases like that, the Pilot's job writes itself. Headed for a storm of asteroids? You're gonna need a good pilot. This Occupation gets a +5 in any check that requires flying a ship of human origin and a +3 when flying a ship of Alien origin.

STRESS: A lot of horror RPGs have a Sanity mechanic or a Fear mechanic. Fear is something I knew I didn't want to do because I don't like the idea of forcing players into being afraid of something when maybe that doesn't make a lot of sense for their character. But Stress? That's something the vast majority of people feel. You gain a level of stress every time you fail both your skill check and narrative check at the same time. When you gain a level of stress, the player chooses to put a +1 and a -1 on either their skill checks or negative checks. For example, a player gains one point of stress and chooses to gain a +1 on their success rolls but their narrative rolls get a -1. This builds up the more stress you accumulate. If you gain more than 6 points of stress, you fall unconscious. I decided on this because although it would be easy to say Stress is always negative, I don't like the idea of kicking players while they're down. Giving them an option to make one of their two D20 rolls a boost helps makes even failures easier to deal with. There's also the idea my fiancée came up with of the idea that some people work better when stressed. Players could play into this if they wanted to or put the plus in the narrative dice in hopes the world around them treats them nicer!

So that's pretty much all I got for now. I am VERY early on into designing this game but it's a LOT of fun. Even if I need to scrap all of this, I think I built a pretty decent foundation to build upon. What are some cool ideas? Do you want to be apart of the design process? I'd love as much help with this as possible! Thanks!


r/RPGcreation • • Nov 22 '25

Design Questions What do you think of the name of my game? Rubermont

0 Upvotes

My game so far is called rubermont, the system itself is based off a "fill in the blank concept" but the world that im going to publish within the game guide is called rubermont essentially a ginormus mountain of worlds discarded by various gods of the multiverse. Simplified explanation but you should get the jist.

What i want to know is what do you think of the name? What does it make you think when you read it? In a crude way it literally means red mountain just two words i mashed together.


r/RPGcreation • • Mar 11 '24

Off Topic D&D "Stole" My Game

0 Upvotes

Gather around, my friends. Sit down, and hear the somber tale of a lone game designer and his tragic demise at the cruel hands of an indifferent foe. And apologies for the melodramatic title. D&D isn't at fault for anything—this is just a bit of a rant I need to get out.

Five years ago, I began designing my game and some time later, Alpha 1.0 emerged as a weird and impractical concoction. This was my first, totally unusable attempt, and I knew I needed to do something drastically different on my second attempt. My RPG background mostly consisted of D&D 3.5 from my high school years and D&D 5e more recently. Drawing my inspiration mostly from these, I took a safer route for Alpha 2.0 that shamelessly mimicked D&D. With most of the work already done for me, I developed it very quickly and discarded it almost as fast.

The third time's the charm, they say, and so it seemed for me. I kept a lot of the elements from Alpha 2.0 and reintroduced some completely overhauled ideas from Alpha 1.0 and built it again from the ground up. Through all of this, I learned a great deal about game design and became more familiar with other systems. My game grew into something that worked beautifully that was uniquely my own. This evolution transformed my excitement into an all-consuming passion, driving my to refine my goals for the game and crystalizing what made it special.

It's still a d20 system (although this may change) with D&D-like attributes and skills and a semi-classless, modular design. There are some major differences, largely inspired by my Alpha 1.0, but they would take a lot of elaboration to explain, and that isn't my goal for this post. Within my design, some of my favorite changes were minor things that made just tweaks to improve the ease and quality of play, and cleaned up unnecessary complexity.

  • I organized spell lists into Arcane, Divine, Occult, and Primal. Each Mage character has access to one spell list. In addition to being more simple than every class having their own list, this also was a functional change, since my game is a little fast and loose with classes.

  • I associated attribute increases to backgrounds instead of races. Not just for the sensitivity and inclusivity, but because it made more sense from a character concept perspective. My backgrounds were excruciatingly designed for modularity with Ancestry, Status, Discipline, and Experiences components. (Although some of these have changed for approachability between '.x versions.)

  • I mentioned earlier my hybrid class system, consisting of Fighter, Expert, and Mage 'classes' (- multi-classing recommended). Each class has Archetypes that can be mixed together as characters are promoted. This is a fairly unique blend between classes/subclasses, playbooks, and à la carte features, that introduced a lot of versatility and minimal complexity.

By now, if you're familiar with the One D&D playtests, you're noticing a pattern. Many of my favorite aspects are things that Wizards began introducing to playtests in the Summer of 2022. None of the similarities are exact and some are quite superficial, but it still hit me a little hard. (To clarify: I am not alleging any theft or infringement against Wizards. They developed and introduced these ideas independently.)

Even more recently, I've watched some stuff about the MCDM RPG, and they introduced some ideas very similar to some of mine from Alpha 1.0 that I thought were so unique. I don't know a lot about their game so these might be minimal, but it felt like another blow. No mistake, I'm excited to see these games and I hold no ill will against the creators, but it's been disheartening.

I honestly feel a little stupid saying, because I know a lot of people are going to think I'm making this up. I promise I'm not. I've told my best friend everything about my game for years and he can vouch for me.

But this is the crux of the issue. I feel a little sad about this, because I either have to get rid of some of the things I love about my game, or accept that a lot of people are going to see the similarities and dismiss it as as uninspired and derivative. (I already risk that enough by using a d20 and similar attributes.) It's just pretty disheartening, considering how much time and effort I've put into it. It's been almost done for a year but I'm losing my drive to finish it.

Anyway, thanks for taking the time to read this. Posting doesn't really change my situation but it feels good to share it and get it off my chest.

EDIT: To clarify: I know most ideas are never brand new, but it felt like I was reaching a little further into a niche that wasn't just everywhere yet. It felt unique and novel in the sense that I wasn't seeing these things in the big name, flagship games of the last several years.


r/RPGcreation • • Jul 28 '22

Getting Started A Gentle Reminder

0 Upvotes

A good thing for beginners to remember: https://vm.tiktok.com/ZMN4pU7A4/?k=1

The Heart of the Deernicorn TicTok is full on nice wee gems like this.


r/RPGcreation • • Dec 06 '22

Design Questions I think my mental health mechanics became right wing propaganda?

5 Upvotes

Very clickbaity titel, but I seriously need some help.

So I was procrastinating preparing for my exam, and was working on my system. In short, it's got magic, demons, and cybernetcis. All of it is tied up in sanity and soul tracking.

In short, as you gain mutations and install cybernetics, your sanity-meter ticks up, and with enough of these effects, you gain higher and higher levels on the sanity-meter, giving a penalty to corruption saves against demonic corruption (which mostly causes the mutaitons, and redices your soul-value).

I added a little tidbit that made me really uncomfortable as I re-read it. The used X trait on cybernetcis increases its penalty to your sanity depending on the number of prevous users as the chrome takes on the mannerisms of prevous users.

The idea of the used trait was that if a certain amount of sanity points are gained due to the sum of the used-value of your modifications, you'd suffer a form of body dysmorphia as different parts of you act differntly from yourself. This would just be an rp-hook apart from the actual sanity meter tracking.

You may realize why I'm more than a bit uncomfortable. Body dysmorphia being represented on the "sanity-meter" and being tied to "corruption" like this is in really bad taste imo. Bigots already try to tie being trans to some "mental problem", and this system feels like someone tried make a fucking Matt Walsh rpg.

So apart from probably changing sanity to mental health (I'm very open to suggestions for other names), what can I do to make it less, whatever adjective fits the system as is??? I'm honestly down for a complete re-write of this godforsaken mechanic right now.


r/RPGcreation • • Aug 10 '25

An explanation and apology

0 Upvotes

Re: hello... First, Thank you all for your advice and the time you took to read and respond.

I think it's obvious that no, I am not published. No, I don't have any industry friends or backers. And Yes, I have little to no idea what I am doing.

The 1000 pages is not one book. As a final page count for the core between 300 and 400. All of the 1000 pages is what i typed up from around 15 years of notes, thoughts and ideas on how TTRPGs could be approached differently.

I realize how biased my opinion is, and how over ambitious I probably appear to be, but I truly in what I have created. My issue is: I do not have people to play-test/refine with. (No one else I know really cares about TTRPGs, my wife listens and says "mmhmm, that sounds nice." My 3 boys prefer video games, and my daughter is only two and a half currently.. but I've got my fingers crossed she might play when she's older. The people I know that actually play the game haven't been interested in creating one, only playing.

As for editing, that's all I've been doing in my spare time. Lol. I have read and had Microsoft auto reader read everything back time me I can't even guess how many times by this point. Another set of eyes would be great, but.. I currently only have the pair I was born with.

I plan to cover publishing costs until the game can sustain itself, and if it doesn't reach that point then so be it. I will be able to say I gave it my all, and hopefully reached a few people a long the way.

As for intriguing systems and ideas, only time will tell. I have tried to balance familiar aesthetics with new approaches. I understand that "my elves aren't your grandad's elves" doesn't make a game. While I have written ancestries, histories, their governments, their wars and connections to build the lore of the world, my "reinventing the wheel" has been the mechanical approach to the game. The how to, looked at from a different angle... As I mentioned above how it can be approached differently.

Those moments where games stutter because the players desired character doesn't mesh with the game. When players are sacrificing what they want to do or make for what the game says they can make. My focus is the player, and the options they have to create the legend they are destined to create.

This is a rough estimate, but with my backgrounds system alone... No race, no classes, no chosen skills, no attribute choices... Strictly just the variables for the options presented in backgrounds is over 23 million unique characters. (I know that leads into the "there's such a a thing as too much," however, the layout literally walks players through it... I guess kind of like filling out a mad-lib now that I'm thinking about it.)

3 more things I want to directly address:

  1. I would never ask anyone to set aside what they are working on, it's honestly mostly why I haven't had anyone to build this with now, and the reason why after all this time I came to the Internet in hopes to specifically find others who enjoy building games, worlds, and lore.

  2. The only thing I highly disagree with here is "the idea is worthless." Ideas are never worthless, they are the building blocks of everything we have. Some may be more successful financially than others sure... But I can't understand how one could go about creating something they are passionate about if they consider ideas worthless. 3... Finally, as per the comments on here, I'm now aware of how much of a mistake it was to suggest an NDA. It was not my intention to introduce myself with what I now understand essentially amounts to a threat. As I said above.. little to no idea what I'm doing. I'm only here hoping to find people to grow and build with, I do want to protect the work I've created, but my hesitation to just toss it up and hope for the best has been the very mixed and inconsistent information I have looked up concerning intellectual property. Honestly.. it's just me. I don't have a team of friends or developers to work through everything, and no one to spitball ideas into refined processes. So.. it's intimidating. It's scary.

I would like to formally apologize for it. I know first impressions leave lasting impressions, but I hope that I can take the advice that's been gifted to me and work towards building a new foundation with you all. I'm not going to delete or edit this post, but I will leave this comment here, and then post this as a new thread as well for those i may have slighted that did not comment.

Thank you again.


r/RPGcreation • • Oct 07 '23

Design Questions Adding Fighter Attack Rolls

1 Upvotes

I'm creating my own fantasy RPG using D&D 5e as a base. What do you think about this change to the fighter class?

Adding Fighter attack rolls and comparing the total to target's AC

Enemie's AC is 10. You have 3 attacks. You roll a 13, 17, & 12. The total is 42. There are four 10s in 42, so you get 4 hits. (Even though you only attacked 3 times!)

Enemie's AC is 20. You have 3 attacks. You roll a 13, 17, & 12. The total is 42. There are two 20s in 42 so you get 2 hits (even though you never hit the 20 AC!)

This makes the fighter feel like a tactical genius, using even missed attacks to help bring down the target. Enjoy!

This rule is from our upcoming TTRPG, Arches & Avatars. Find us on YT at https://youtube.com/@Architrave-Gaming?si=yVNpCBUG5h_GiKFk


r/RPGcreation • • Sep 29 '22

Promotion 1 page rules + multiple 1 page settings = Simpler RPG

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

A couple of months ago I've started working on my free ultra-mini RPG. Key selling points:

  • 5 min start

  • 1 page rules

  • Multiple 1 page settings, each of which allows you to have a completely different world, without learning new rules

Simpler RPG by RomaB (itch.io)


r/RPGcreation • • Sep 21 '26

Production / Publishing Yes, Is Is Just You: the Purpose of Kickstarter

63 Upvotes

Public Service Announcement:

The purpose of kickstarter, and other crowdfunding sites like it, are to give creators enough money (and therefore time) to design their product, as well as fund other costs such as art and layout.

It is unreasonable to expect a designer to design the product for free, and to use Kickstarter only to pay for art, layout, or other logistical costs. Design is work. It deserves payment. If someone is on Kickstarter trying to sell a product, they're trying to go professional (by definition). It is unreasonable to expect them to create simply as a labor of love.

Big companies (like MCDM, Darrington Press, etc) have warped the public perception of what Kickstarter is by putting forward nearly finished products. This raises people's expectations for how far a Kickstarter project should be developed, which warps the perception of Kickstarter into just another storefront where people post their finished products.

This raises the bar so high that it alienates the very designers that Kickstarter was designed to help out: small creators.

Please support your small creators. If the idea sounds good and they have put fourth enough info to let you know that they are likely competent, they shouldn't be required to show any more than that.

It's called Kickstarter, not Kickfinisher.

Yes, that's risky. But it's supposed to be. This is the place for the brave to fund the future. Without us willing to take the risk, thousands of small creators will never share their new ideas with us. We're taking the risk for our own benefit, and that of the entire hobby.

If that's not for you, that's okay. But let's keep Kickstarter/crowdfunding serving its intended purpose: to fund projects from the beginning.

Thank you.

- Matthias


r/RPGcreation • • Feb 25 '24

Promotion A medievalpunk and kaijupunk mix, because why not dragons with machineguns?

2 Upvotes

At last, after months making this thing it's finally on a playable state. It's still missing some illustrations , enemies sheets, and the some attacks to the combat stances but the rules worked on my playtest.

Pendragons, About Beasts and Mortals is game made on top of Fate Core with 157 pages of content exclusively of this setting.

The main selling points of this game are:

  • the players control one of 12 species of dragons, here called Pendragons. Yep, dragons are not bosses, they're the PCs. :3

  • The magic system uses music theory as rules.

  • Each continent on the world map has a specific punk setting that give unique experiences to each one

  • Socialization is treated like combat with advantages, skills, and even a pseudo health bar

  • The fauna and flora are made to be alien but still familiar and so are the people that live in the world

  • The people are called faunamorphs because they were made from the earth itself and so have plants growings on their bodies.

  • The PC, on the other hand, have crystals and metals growing in their bodies.

  • Combat stances that bring specific attacks like DMC and YOMIH.

The term medievalpunk means: a world where all technology evolved quicker than the culture could. So, we have firearms, flying ships, anti-gravitational trains, but the aesthetics still the same from the dark ages. Knights with shotgun.

Kaijupunk is something I made up and means that everything in this world is built around colossal monsters. Science, culture, architecture, weapons, etc. Were all done with the existence of giant monsters in mind.

I will adapt this setting to work with Savage Worlds and Tormenta20 later.

Edit: I can't post external link on the post itself, so if anyone wants to read the PDF, just comment.


r/RPGcreation • • Jun 09 '21

Worldbuilding Journal Entry #1

0 Upvotes

Short lore excerpt from my new upcoming RPG. Hmu if ur interested in working on it.

"This little experiment of mine is turning out to be quite the endeavour. After countless nights of study, I have managed to locate the resting place of Old King Draag, a small cave northeast of Sky Scar Rock. I've used the last of my money on supplies for the journey and I'm not coming back without that crown".

"Well, I arrived at the cave just as the sun fell behind the mountains. I decided it would be best to wait until morning before exploring any further, so I've set up a small tent and fire here just outside the caves entrance. Hopefully I can get some rest, it's rather spooky out here".

"Curse those damn wolves, they scared the life out of me! At least I know what's been scratching at my tent all night. Anyways, I managed to hit one with a channel of lightning and the rest ran off howling. That should be the last I hear of them tonight."

"I entered the crypt what feels like days ago, but I know better. I've come all this way. No turning back now. But that THING, I cant get it out of my head. Its watching me I just know it. Damn this place."

"Eyes, eyes in the dark! Haha yes I see you. Do you see me? Do I see me? no. No. NO!


r/RPGcreation • • Jun 14 '20

Brainstorming Hypothetical Arby’s TTRPG

0 Upvotes

Hello all,

These last few months have been productive with actual projects... and also ones like this.

Let’s say I’ve been working on an Arby’s RPG. Who would I need to get in touch with for their IP? Is this even a good idea? Does this sound like something you would be interested in playing?

The reason I pose that last question is, I’ve been considering changing the theme a little bit. Instead of having the PCs be Red Hats - agents of ARBYs - I would have them be cooks - White Hats. The PCs would still be investigating the cosmic horrors and unspeakable terrors that surround fast food joints. But I’d lose the Arby’s angle.

I’ve been in a bit of a vacuum on this project and could use some outside thoughts. As of right now, I have 8 classes, 2 sets of bad guys you could investigate, and using PbtA. No runnable scenario yet.

Thanks in advance!


r/RPGcreation • • Jul 25 '25

New TTRPG idea

0 Upvotes

I've been working on a new system with a goal of being able to create any character (ex, new or existing characters) and play it. Combining a few systems together and finalizing a complex version with 5 classes, 117 subclasses, a narrative combat system, and a simple version with 5 classes and a lighter combat system that is more geared towards new players. Still in some play testing and finalizing a module, but the goal would be to play this system in whatever genre and level that the GM wants. Just trying to see if there is any interest outside of my current party and group.

Any advice or recommendations are welcome.


r/RPGcreation • • Mar 22 '26

Playtesting Made a homemade TTRPG and need feedback for the system and possibly playtesters.

0 Upvotes

I have spent the better part of a month building a scifi TTRPG set in a homemade setting, and need experienced rpg players and playtesters to verify the feasibility of the mechanics and character creation. Anyone willing to help with that?

So far it has: Character creation, stats, equipment, ship building rules, and combat.

not yet implemented are: ship combat, maps, and lore.

Open to critique and suggestions and criticism.

i took way too much Adderall and not enough sleep.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/197iJRlIFq7BDBSTLrw5jvyj9YuSpki_accj_bSJp17w/edit?tab=t.gim24vrp5gfo