r/RPGcreation • • 1d ago

Advice needed on Dice pool mechanic and health system

4 Upvotes

So I've designed what I consider a pretty clever system. It's for a survival/village management RPG I'm working on. The game is entirely player facing. The GM doesn't make a single roll for any NPCs, checks, damage etc. The game can be run GMless, though it's not really designed with that in mind.

The core mechanic uses a dice pool system similar to WOD and other games: a character's ranking in a skill determines how many D10s they need to roll. Everything over a 7 is a success and each check needs a certain number of successes to complete. Their ranking also determines how much of a particular resource they can carry. This resource is needed by the village but can also be spent by players to increase their rolls, allowing them to get more successes. Simple enough so far.

However, their Health (currently called Survival) is directly tied to their ability to roll dice. For every dice a player rolls using a "physical" skill, their Survival drops by 1. So get into a fight, roll 3 combat dice, and you spend 3 Survival. Additional successes over the required number can be used to regain lost Survival. It can also be regained by spending Food resources as well as a few other options.

My problem is that I just realised I think it hurts skilled characters too much. An unskilled warrior with combat 1 rolls only 1 dice, so can only take a maximum of 1 "damage" while a veteran warrior with combat 3 rolls 3 dice, so immediately takes 3 points of "damage". They've got more chances of passing the check, but it strips their health pool a lot quicker.

I've thought of two options. The first I've come up with is that it costs 1 Survival per physical check. A flat tax sort of thing. The other is that the number of successes required for the check is also how much Survival it costs to make the check, and that the number of successes a player actually manages to get replenishes that survival. So a player needing 2 successes only gets 1, they fail the check but only lose 1 survival. Hope that made sense to read. My concern with both those is that it might make survival drain a minor inconvenience, instead of a key resource players need to manage through an adventure.

Does anyone have any advice on how to make this work?


r/RPGcreation • • 21h ago

Sons of Saturn Project

1 Upvotes

Hey, I'm blindestangel, or just Angel. I've been working on a post-apocalyptic sci-fi, cyberpunk-esc TTRPG called Sons of Saturn. While it's only in its 0.1 Build, and very much non complete, I plan to steadily work on the project and release a complete, polished version soon.

As an independent (anti-Generative AI) creator, I am hoping to build a small community surrounding my little passion project and hoping to see it grow.

https://theblindestangel.itch.io/sons-of-saturn-project


r/RPGcreation • • 1d ago

Design Questions Your opinion on health systems + armor for mechs?

6 Upvotes

Hello! I'm designing a bio-mech, shroompunk ttrpg and I'm looking for opinions on the armor and health system. Can you think of any pro's or con's for this system? If you've played mech games, what do you enjoy? Thank you in advance!

Overview: Players pilot organic mecha whose structural health is comprised of two systems: the exterior armor and the hull.

Armor: I'm leaning toward armor being a numerical pool that gets chipped away as the mecha takes damage. The armor is not stationary. It reforms in areas where the mecha needs protection. Even if a mecha receives repeated damage in the same area, it will not take hull damage until all of the armor is destroyed. Certain weapons (like armor piercing) can bypass the armor.

Hull: Beneath the mecha’s armor is the hull. The hull is divided into anatomical sections, such as the head, torso, arms and legs. Each section has a threshold, which is tracked through its hull points (HP). When a component’s HP reaches 0, the component is destroyed. The mecha can operate, even if multiple limbs, or even the head, are destroyed, so long as the pilot (who controls the mecha from its chest cavity) lives. When the torso is destroyed, the mecha is destroyed.

Additional context: The combat system that I'm building is a bit Year Zero Engine meets Lancer. During combat, attackers roll a d6 dice pool to hit a target (dice get added to the pool based on various factors + bonuses). Targets do not roll for defense. Instead, dice are removed from the attacker's dice pool based on factors from the defender (i.e. if they're sprinting, in a defensive stance, etc.). Damage is a set value or rolled dice depending on the attacker's weapon.

Severing and then grafting salvaged body parts from fallen foes is big part of the game. I want combat to feel tactful but also fluid and improvisational--if your weapon breaks or maybe you require a new weapon that an enemy is weak against--you can then graft (or grow) a new weapon based on salvaged parts. Having an emphasis on targeting/destroying specific parts of the mecha means there's a certain amount of bookkeeping, however I really want to avoid this getting too crunchy.


r/RPGcreation • • 22h ago

I let my players name their own difficulty and nobody rolled a die for an hour

0 Upvotes

I laid a wooden bridge across the map and asked who could get the prisoner over it before the guard turned around. My rogue said six seconds. The fighter said five. The wizard, who has never crossed anything without asking its name first, offered four.

I’d borrowed the bidding rule from the flip game where the winning bidder has to attempt the challenge. The idea was that the players would decide how much risk to take. Whoever made the boldest promise got to describe the first move and roll for it.

The wizard bid three. The rogue said two. The prisoner was still standing on the wrong side of the bridge when our quietest player put her pencil down.

“I can do it in zero.”

I asked how. She picked up the guard’s token and turned it toward the bridge. “You said before he turns around. Why are we letting him turn around?”

She wanted to keep him talking while everyone else walked across behind him. It was the first plan anybody had come up with that included the prisoner as a person who could walk.

I gave her the scene. The others had spent half the night bidding for one roll. She spent hers asking the guard whether he’d heard the wizard could do the whole thing in three seconds.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


r/RPGcreation • • 2d ago

Worldbuilding Using real names for countries and ethnicity in alternate history setting, yes or no?

4 Upvotes

I'm creating a steampunk setting, but I'm divided on how alternative my alternate history should be? It's clearly set in an alternate history Europe, and with "Difference Engine"-style steampunk (no magic or elves with goggles).

Should I use real names for countries (Germany, Great Britain etc) and ethnicities (like Romani and Jews) or is it better to use other names (with a strong or weak hint to the real world) so that players and GMs don't have to worry about authenticity and accuracy?

What would you prefer? What are the cons of stand-in names? What are the pros for using real names?


r/RPGcreation • • 2d ago

How do you give players a fair clue that a key ring holds the fare?

0 Upvotes

In a playtest scene I’m writing, the GM puts a brass key and a little silver capsule in front of the group. The ferryman has asked for cash, and they’ve just searched the room of a courier who takes that ferry every morning.

“Which door does the key open?” our ranger asked.

“The courier's room. You just unlocked it.”

She set the key back down and started looking under the mattress. The other players followed her lead. They had already searched the drawer, but now somebody wanted to pull it all the way out and check behind it.

The prop is based on a screw-top capsule with a clip for one rolled bill. The ring stays on the cap when you unscrew the body, so the keys can stay dangling. So far the GM has only described it as a silver thing on a key ring, which sounds about as interesting as the key ring itself.

The GM picks up the prop. The capsule clicks against the key. “Does that part turn?” the ranger asks.

In this version she opens it and pays the ferryman. I’d like players to get the same chance at a table that runs entirely on description. What would you say when you hand over the keys that might make somebody try the cap?


r/RPGcreation • • 2d ago

Who can spend the banknote inside a key no one owns?

0 Upvotes

On the first turn, the ferryman asks for one banknote. Pip has the key ring. Jo has the vote that authorized the journey. The person who usually plays the treasurer is in the kitchen looking for the good biscuits.

Our table is trying a game about a town that owns everything in common except the consequences. Its entire emergency budget fits in a little cash capsule with an internal clip. The cap stays on the ring. The body comes away and the clip holds one rolled note. During setup I said that anybody could see who was carrying the treasury. I forgot to say whether carrying the treasury entitled you to open it.

“Who’s got the key?” the ferryman asks. Everybody points at Pip. Pip points at Jo. Jo says that voting for a journey is not the same as voting for a fare the ferryman invented ten seconds ago. From the kitchen comes a voice saying, “He invented biscuits too. They’re terrible.”

The obvious patch is to give the treasurer sole spending authority. The moment I wrote that down, though, I missed watching those fingers travel round the table. I want the next group to get the argument without having to invent a constitution in the middle of crossing a river. Would you make the ring holder ask one other player for assent, or make spending automatic and require them to account for it afterward?


r/RPGcreation • • 3d ago

Playtesting SOUPIR : The bastion - Need beta testers and feedback

1 Upvotes

Playable Link: https://vivi-crazy-writer.itch.io/soupir-the-bastion

Or on android: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sP8GLi7Nmu4sbmVvWSgu0BYqYkWgKzB9/view?usp=drive_link

Platform: web/sugar/twine

PLEASE
Any feedback would already be extremely useful.
You can also add a UP for this post to stay visible :)

Description: 
Hi everyone!

I'm currently developing SOUPIR: The Bastion, a free browser-based text RPG set in the universe of my SOUPIR novels. I already made a post long ago but i make it again here as the game has a lot of new things now.

The world has collapsed under the spread of a strange fungal ecosystem, and humanity survives inside isolated fortified settlements known as Bastions.

You arrive as a newcomer in one of them.

From there, the game is about surviving, finding your place in the city, building relationships, working, exploring, improving your skills, getting involved in local factions, and dealing with the increasingly unpleasant things happening inside and outside the walls.

The game features:

  • Character creation with different backgrounds, attributes and skills

  • A large skill and progression system

  • Jobs and daily survival

  • NPC relationships and reputation

  • Factions, politics and clandestine groups

  • Exploration and expeditions outside the Bastion

  • Dynamic events

  • A living city with different districts and activities

  • Adult themes, violence and morally difficult situations

  • Lots of choices and different ways to approach situations

The game is still under development, so I'm specifically looking for people willing to test it and give honest feedback.

You don't need to play for hours but any feedback would already be extremely useful.

The game is Free to Play

Thank you very much :)


r/RPGcreation • • 3d ago

Who gets to declare the second click in a stealth scene?

0 Upvotes

My thief has one finger on the switch when the guard turns around. The player says she was only checking where the switch was. I believe her. The other player heard her say “click” and has already described diving under the table. Whose action should stand?

Here's the bit of equipment on the character sheet that makes the ruling matter: it takes two clicks to turn it on. One click by itself leaves the corridor dark. Everybody at the table has that information. The guard in the fiction has heard a noise but hasn't seen a light. The player under the table has spent a perfectly good turn reacting to something his character could reasonably have expected.

I could rewind his move. That puts him back by the door, but now the thief knows exactly what he intended to do if the light came on. I could keep the dive and let it give the guard a second sound to investigate. That makes a cautious player pay for having good ears.

My favorite suggestion so far came from the quietest person at the table. “Let me stay under here,” he said. “Just tell me whose boots I can see.” For a rules-light game, would you write that choice into the reaction rule or leave it for the player who committed first?


r/RPGcreation • • 4d ago

Getting Started somewhat new ttrpg hobbyiest seeking feedback for my system!

2 Upvotes

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sianvMb6vFc9-ztjEZwubEpEKxJbgpx2nN6e7p7kX1I/edit?usp=sharing

it's a classless system that is inspired by fear & hunger, with a small (very small) disco elysium influence to it. It is mostly intended for combat but does have mechanics for roll playing, the rules themselves are about 8 pages of a google dock long, and they do include races, spells (called skills) and there is a separate document tab for items. Any feedback i can be given that may help a playtest is very much appreciated!


r/RPGcreation • • 5d ago

[Playtesters Wanted] Looking for people interested in testing my original fantasy TTRPG

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I've been working on an original fantasy tabletop RPG based on a fantasy world and story I've been developing for quite some time.

The project started as a book, which I later adapted into an RPG Maker VX Ace game. Eventually, I decided to take things further and turn the world into its own tabletop RPG.

The system is heavily inspired by the world itself, rather than trying to recreate traditional D&D mechanics.

A little about the system:

  • 5 playable races, each with their own characteristics and racial abilities.

  • 8 unique classes, each with a distinct playstyle and mechanics.

  • 6 attributes that determine character capabilities.

  • A magic system based on four types of Primordial energy, each with its own identity and interactions.

  • A flexible action system that encourages players to describe what they want to do and how they intend to do it, rather than relying entirely on predefined actions.

  • A progression system with a maximum level of 5.

  • A mix of exploration, roleplay, puzzles and combat.

One of the main things I want to achieve is a balance between serious storytelling and entertaining gameplay. I want players to have room for creative solutions, unusual strategies and unexpected decisions, while keeping the world internally consistent.

What I'm looking for:

I'm looking for people willing to participate in playtesting the system and its campaign.

You don't necessarily need to be an experienced tabletop RPG player. In fact, feedback from both experienced players and newcomers would be valuable.

I'd particularly appreciate feedback on:

  • How enjoyable the gameplay is.

  • Whether the classes feel distinct and interesting.

  • Whether the mechanics are understandable.

  • Whether combat feels engaging.

  • Whether the system allows enough freedom without becoming confusing.

  • What feels unbalanced, frustrating or unnecessarily complicated.

I'm not looking for people who will simply tell me everything is great. I'd much rather receive honest criticism and find problems that need fixing.

The system is still under development, so expect some rough edges. I'm working on improving it through actual playtesting.

If you're interested, feel free to comment or send me a message. I'd be happy to share more details about the setting and the playtesting arrangements.

Thanks for reading!


r/RPGcreation • • 6d ago

Design Questions Honest opinions on an 'always-succeed' resolution system, please!

7 Upvotes

Hey y'all. In my experimentations, I stumbled across an idea that I'm playing with now in playtesting. Players think it's fun, but it's kind of a hot take, and I'd like to see what the broader appeal and opinions are.

Basically, the core resolution mechanic is 2d6 + some stuff. 8+: success. 7-: it depends; If the PC was reacting to avoid harm or consequence, the harm or consequence happens. But, if the PC acted independently, they succeed but with a heavy cost or consequence: a greatly diminished effect, Stress (physical or mental harm), escalation/attention, complications, resources or time, etc.

Essentially, the part I'd like thoughts on is the "if you act independently, you never fail" part. It seems kind of weird. In playtesting it hasn't broken anything, and it's essentially PbtA 10+, 7-9, 6- outcomes without the 6-; worst you can fail is a partial success. World of Dungeons works like this if you have a skill, so it's not unprecedented. And with how the rest of the system works, stakes are still high; take 3 Stress and you are at risk of permanent physical or mental trauma, and the complications can be quite bad. You just can't outright fail; if you want to jump across the pit, you jump across the pit. If you want to convince the merchant to give you a discount, they do. The question isn't if it happens, the question is what will it cost?

What do y'all think? Is there a situation I haven't thought of where you think this would fall apart? Does this sound like the dumbest, least fun thing ever? Does it stifle drama for players to know their action will succeed somehow before they act - it hasn't really in playtesting, but would it for you? I'm open to all thoughts, hypotheticals, and criticisms. Thanks!


r/RPGcreation • • 6d ago

[TTRPG] Fugitives & Fraudsters - a reverse heist in Agile 6 rules-light system

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm writing a slightly longer breakdown here to avoid dropping self-promo links. A friend and I recently released Fugitives & Fraudsters, a free one-shot adventure with our own built-in rules-light system, Agile 6 (if anyone wants to check it out, it's easy to find on Google).

​I wanted to share some of our game design choices on this project and get your thoughts on how we tied the mechanics to the setting. Any feedback on the concepts below is more than welcome.

​The setting is a "reverse heist" mixing political satire and magical realism.

Set in the fictional Latin American Federative Republic of Bergamota, players take on the roles of corrupt politicians whose coalition has just lost the election. With their parliamentary immunity gone and their passports seized, the group has 24 hours to recover their embezzled fortune from hiding spots and cross the border—all while fleeing the Federal Police, a sensationalist live TV show broadcasting the manhunt, and betrayal from their own party colleagues. Along the way, they deal with a "paper cattle" ranch (40,000 cows on paper, only one real bull in the pasture), a roadside prophet, a weeping saint statue that cries whenever someone lies nearby, and a bankrupt bank.

​The System (Agile 6):

We designed Agile 6 so the rules never slow down the narrative, supporting a frantic chase pace and total improvisational freedom. The core pillars are:

-> ​One-Sentence Character Creation: In Agile 6, a character is built from a single sentence: "\[Name\] is a(n) \[Aspect 1\] and \[Aspect 2\] \[Concept\] \[Occupation\]", plus 6 points split between Health (HP) and Energy (EP). For this adventure, we mapped the system's 3 base Concepts (Combatant, Specialist, Influencer) onto 6 satirical archetypes (Digital Guerrilla, Retired Colonel, Political Heir, Money Launderer, Flock Pastor, and Hate Marketer). Any archetypes not picked by the players automatically become rival/ally NPCs with pre-made stats.

-> ​d6 Pool, Actions, and Reactions: Checks use a pool of 1d6 to 6d6 (adding +1d for a relevant Concept, Aspect, Occupation, Item, or spent EP), reading only the highest die: 1–3 Failure, 4–5 Partial, 6 Success. Rolling a full Success (6) immediately restores 1 EP, which keeps the momentum going and rewards players for taking action. There is no initiative or combat rounds; antagonists act narratively and only engage mechanically through Reactions in opposed rolls (spending their own finite EP).

-> ​Pressure and Paranoia Mechanics: To make the 24-hour clock matter, we created the Day Clock (at 1:00 PM the judicial seal is lifted and the public stops treating the group like "authorities" on the street) and the Siege Thermometer (a d6 in the center of the table that ticks up from 1 to 6 whenever the group makes a public blunder or goes viral as a meme, spawning new hunters on their tail). Additionally, each player gets a secret Skeleton in the Closet card (a signed plea deal, being a frontman/"straw man" for another player, having voted for the rival candidate), and each location has a built-in trigger designed to "poke" that secret without forcing a reveal.

-> ​"Real-Time" Character Evolution: Rolling a Critical Success (two or more 6s) grants a new Trait tied to that specific Aspect, while rolling a Critical Failure (matching dice on a failed roll) when using a Trait causes you to lose it.


r/RPGcreation • • 9d ago

Taking on a big project

3 Upvotes

First time poster, not really accustomed to this reddit business.

Over the last 2 years ive written a (mostly) full universe and guidebook for my own sci-fi RPG.

Ive just started doing some playtests with my dnd group (of which I'm the Forever DM - stereotypical I know) but life is getting in the way at the moment. And I feel like im way more invested in this world ive created and a whole ass game than any of my social circle.

So I guess im looking for brains I can bounce ideas off? The holy grail would be a DM with a cool gang who's willing to run playtests for me.

Anyway I know im asking alot but it would be cool just to get some feedback.

Chuck me a DM :)


r/RPGcreation • • 9d ago

Design Questions Best way for figuring out layout?

3 Upvotes

I've been working on a physically made TTRPG for a while now and it's getting to the point where I have to start formatting it so it's not just slabs of text like a book. What's the best way to experiment and design the formatting? Any softwares, ideas etc


r/RPGcreation • • 10d ago

Dumb question regarding selling RPG stuff

3 Upvotes

I am currently working on some RPG stuff to hopefully sell, and I hope if you could enlighten me on some details of the market.

More questions will come soon, but right now the one that I wanted to know was which on-line sellers were best, in terms of security for the transaction, the security of the product (you know, no “you will own nothing and be happy” for those who buy it) and the profit percentage given to the developer. If it helps, at this current time it is impossible for me to set up any printing method (that will come later, for sure) so the product would be purely a PDF.


r/RPGcreation • • 10d ago

Design Questions Mission Grading System

2 Upvotes

Hi all!

I'm soon to be running an SCP-inspired campaign following to groups of makeshift task-forces who's goal is to capture anomalies.

I want a "requisition" system, where players are graded on how well they did in a mission, and are allocated requisition points, with which they can gain access to gear (rather than spending money or something).

However, I'm a lil stumped on what to add to the grading!

This is what I've got so far, any ideas are welcome!

OutcomeRange
Operative Deaths-90 for all but one dead, +100 for all alive.
Civilians Alerted (Without Cleanup)+100 if none, up to -500 if it was widespread/journalists, and on the extreme end, in the -10,000’s for an actual outbreak.
Police Alerted+100 if none, up to -1000 if it was significant, and in the -10,000’s for an actual outbreak.
Agencies Alerted (Anomalous)+0 if none, up to -10,000 if Apotheon(Specific faction) or Icarus Initiative(Specific faction) are alerted of the team’s efforts.
Civilians Killed+0 if none, up to -200 if in the tens. If its in the larger numbers, that becomes a Civilians Alerted problem.
Anomaly ContainedBased on Anomaly grade, and success. S grade - 100,000

r/RPGcreation • • 13d ago

Production / Publishing Looking to Connect with Independent TTRPG Creators and Publishers!

33 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

We're a group of students in the Entrepreneurship program at the University of Minnesota, and we're currently exploring a startup idea focused on helping independent tabletop RPG creators publish and market their games.

Before moving forward, we want to better understand the experiences of people in the TTRPG community, particularly independent developers and publishers.

We'd love to hear about your experiences with:

  • Publishing and distributing your games.

  • Marketing and reaching new players.

  • Challenges you've encountered as an independent creator.

  • Resources or support you wish you had access to.

We're especially interested in learning what parts of the publishing process creators find most difficult and where additional support might be helpful.

If you're interested, we'd love to set up a brief, informal informational interview. We're happy to chat over Reddit messages or arrange a short call, whichever you prefer!

Whether you're just starting out, currently developing a game, or have already published multiple games, we'd love to hear your perspective.

Thanks for your time!


r/RPGcreation • • 17d ago

Alpha test for reviews

1 Upvotes

Hello, I'm just getting started into ttrpg creation and wanted some help with play testing my alpha version if folks have the time. The last page of the google doc here has a link to a survey for feedback and I'd love to hear what people think about what I have so far. Thanks!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1gWdFFL7eKorKMeGkJEL_dM60GZUb_Y4KtxNDmNBfoVQ/edit?usp=sharing


r/RPGcreation • • 18d ago

Playtesting Looking for playtesters for my TTRPG

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I've been working on my own tabletop RPG called Aetherfall for a while now and it's finally at the point where it needs real people at the table. So I'm looking for playtesters.

The whole game is built around making your own stuff. You don't pick skills off a list, you build them. Every skill is made from parts: a Foundation, a Motion, an Outcome, then Refinements on top. So two characters with the same weapon can fight in totally different ways depending on how they build their skills. This also comes with crafting for armor, consumables, weapons,and even player bases.

Magic works the same way but with runes. You pick an Essence (Force, Heat, Cold, Light or Dark), how it's cast, its shape and its effect, then add Enhancements to push them further. You put them together yourself. You can even combine a skill and a spell into a hybrid style of combat.

Some other stuff in it:

  • Combat with real choices. You get a set number of actions each turn and spend them however you want: attacking, moving, blocking or catching your breath to get Stamina and Aether back. Evade dice cut damage down, and you can commit extra actions to dodge harder. Blocking works too, but it wears down your gear.

  • Six stats (Might, Agility, Vitality, Intellect, Awareness, Presence) that feed straight into how strong your skills and spells can get.

  • Crafting. Build and upgrade your own weapons and armor with materials you find.

  • Signature Weapons. Bond with a weapon and it grows with you over time.

  • Companions. Summon or tame creatures to fight alongside you.

  • A creature creator for GMs. Build your own monsters with a point system that sets their Danger Rating, so you know how tough a fight will be. Bosses get extra traits and phases where they change up mid fight.

What you get as a playtester:

  • The prototype core rulebook

  • A 4-page printable character sheet

  • A creature creator sheet for building your own monsters

  • Printable creature cards and boss cards for running fights

  • Crafting cards, item cards and companion cards

I'm planning a Kickstarter down the line, so anyone who helps playtest now is shaping how the game turns out. I want to know what feels fun, what feels broken, and what's confusing.

If you like building characters, breaking systems, or just want to try something new, come join the Discord. Whether you play once or stick around, any feedback helps a ton.

Discord link


r/RPGcreation • • 18d ago

Design Questions How do you handle the messy parts of building and testing a tabletop game prototype?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

We’re The Forge, and we’re currently testing BGK, a digital workspace for creating and playtesting tabletop games.

We realise this community focuses on RPG creation, while BGK is intended for tabletop games more generally, including board games, card games, and other types of prototypes. We’re mainly interested in whether some of the practical challenges around designing, organising, and testing a game are familiar across different types of tabletop games.

Once a project grows beyond a few notes and a rough draft, the surrounding work can become messy: keeping images and components organised, trying different versions of a project, and getting a playable version in front of testers without creating extra work every time.

BGK brings these parts together in one workspace. It includes:

  • bulk asset importing,

  • version management for different iterations or variants, and

  • link-based sharing for playtesting.

The goal is to support the design and testing process while a game is still being developed, rather than having designers manage each part of the workflow separately.

We’re still testing the workspace and would appreciate honest feedback from designers. How do you currently handle these parts of your workflow? Do you use separate tools for assets, different versions, and playtesting, or have you found one system that works well? Which part of creating and testing your game usually takes more time than it should?

If anyone would like to see the current beta, it’s available here.

We’re happy to answer questions here and hear how other people approach this part of game creation.


r/RPGcreation • • 19d ago

Design Questions Opinions on 'Drive' mechanic

6 Upvotes

Howdy pardners!

I'm working on a mechanic right now that I'm calling Drives, and I'm looking for some feedback and opinions. For context, the game is a very lightweight statless 2d6+mod system with narrative consequences and skills, inspired both by PbtA games and FKR stuff.

Every PC has a Drive, which is like a virtue/vice/compulsion/motivation. Currently it works as follows: "When a PC acts to fulfill their Drive despite costs or risks, they have Leverage (a small bonus), and they either clear 1 Stress (Injured, Exhausted, etc) or restore 1 Preparation (a meta-resource)." The idea here is that it's a simple roleplaying trigger that refreshes or reinvigorates PCs. Clearing 1 Stress is particularly powerful - Stress gives a roll penalty, and the only other way to clear it is extended rest between adventures.

I'd love your opinion on two things:

  1. Should Drives be 'action statements' a la Dungeon World, e.g. "Defeat a worthy foe", "show the superiority of my faith", "steal something important", "run away when my allies need me"? This gives players a very clear trigger for fulfilling a Drive, but runs the risk of not coming up that often. Or, should they be more vague one-word things like "hospitality", "ingenuity", "mischief", where it's more open to interpretation/negotiation (including possible arguments...), but will be more applicable to a wider variety of situations?

  2. I worry about the "despite costs or risks" qualifier... The idea is to prevent 'spamming' and make it so the PC actually has to make a meaningful choice to fulfill the Drive, but this wording presents some weirdness, e.g. if a PC tries to fulfill the "show off" Drive by doing a stunt and fails, they could gain a Stress, but also clear a Stress? Is having that qualifier worth it? Or should it just read "When a PC fulfills a Drive, they act with Leverage, and either clear 1 Stress or restore 1 Preparation"?

I'm happy to give any additional context or info. Thanks for your thoughts!


r/RPGcreation • • 18d ago

Looking for authors: lend a storyline to a pixel-art stickman RPG

0 Upvotes

Hi! I’m Ell, a graphic designer and animator, and I’m making an indie RPG with pixel-art stickman characters. Players choose a species at the start, and the choices they make shape who their character becomes and their plot line.  

There are many traits a human can have and so I decided it would be an excessive waste of time to make hundreds of plot lines when I have fellow authors who would gladly cooperate. I want each species to carry a storyline from a book, used with the author’s permission. That’s why I’m writing to you.  

What I’m asking: permission to adapt a storyline from your book as the plot line for one species in the game.  

What I need from you (submit a short form from the link below, about 5 to 10 minutes):  

  • Which book, and which species or race the storyline is about. If yours isn’t on my list, add it.  

  • Which of your characters I may include, and any I may not.  

  • Whether I may use all the details from your book (names, places, lore) or only some.  

  • A few quick picks about the kind of character your story rewards.  

  • Anything off-limits, and anything else you want me to know.  

See what’s already in: These boards show which species and traits have storylines so far, so you can pick a gap:   Species and plot lines so far-Plot Lines Per Trait (All Species) -Plot Lines Per Species 

What you get: Recognition at minimum  

Nothing is used without your say-so.  

Form: [form link] · Questions: Reach me at [email protected]


r/RPGcreation • • 21d ago

Playtesting SOUPIR : The bastion - Need beta testers and feedback

0 Upvotes

Playable Link: https://vivi-crazy-writer.itch.io/soupir-the-bastion

Or on android: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sP8GLi7Nmu4sbmVvWSgu0BYqYkWgKzB9/view?usp=drive_link

Platform: web/sugar/twine

Description: 
Hi everyone!

I'm currently developing SOUPIR: The Bastion, a free browser-based text RPG set in the universe of my SOUPIR novels. I already made a post long ago but i make it again here as the game has a lot of new things now.

The world has collapsed under the spread of a strange fungal ecosystem, and humanity survives inside isolated fortified settlements known as Bastions.

You arrive as a newcomer in one of them.

From there, the game is about surviving, finding your place in the city, building relationships, working, exploring, improving your skills, getting involved in local factions, and dealing with the increasingly unpleasant things happening inside and outside the walls.

The game features:

  • Character creation with different backgrounds, attributes and skills

  • A large skill and progression system

  • Jobs and daily survival

  • NPC relationships and reputation

  • Factions, politics and clandestine groups

  • Exploration and expeditions outside the Bastion

  • Dynamic events

  • A living city with different districts and activities

  • Adult themes, violence and morally difficult situations

  • Lots of choices and different ways to approach situations

The game is still under development, so I'm specifically looking for people willing to test it and give honest feedback.

You don't need to play for hours. Any feedback would already be extremely useful.

The game is Free to Play

thank you very much :)