I noticed the "chemical imbalance theory" is not very far off from the religious practices of the ancient tribes. However, it's dangerous not because it's false, but especially because it's (mostly)1 true but misinterpreted and even taken out of context. The chemical imbalance theorists say that a chemical imbalance is enough to explain the causes of depression, anxiety disorders, schizophrenia, and so on but never ask what causes the chemical imbalance in the first place.
This is very similar to the practices of ancient tribes who blamed it on God or some sort of evil spirit possessing the ill person. Whenever they didn't understand something (the cause was outside their awareness, i.e. unconscious) it felt like the illness was "happening" to them, as if it was a force coming from the outside invading their body and mind. So they blamed it on demonic possession, an evil spirit just decided to possess you.
Nowadays, chemical imbalance theorists tell you that the chemicals in your brain just started going crazy randomly, no context, without asking why, as if God or some spirit decided to take the serotonin out of your brain. In both cases, it feels like an outside force invading your soul because the causes are unconscious and the unconscious is "outside", according to Lacan. The unconscious is the discourse of the big Other and both ancient tribes and chemical imbalance theorists are blaming it on the big Other ("God" or "nature/genes deciding to go crazy for no reason").
The real divide between what modern psychopathology considers "pathological", "healthy" or "adjustment disorder" is:
how socially acceptable is it to suffer in your context
how conscious the patient is of the causes of their symptoms
The formula of modern psychopathology is as follows:
a). If you suffer when we tell you to suffer, you are healthy and "normal".
b). If you enjoy when we tell you to enjoy, you are healthy and "normal".
c). If you suffer when we tell you to enjoy, you have either BPD, a mood or an anxiety disorder.
d). If you suffer when we tell you to suffer, but too much or for too long, you have adjustment disorder.
Hence, modern psychopathology functions in a similar way to ideology, in that it contains the super-ego compulsion to enjoy.
The real divide between a mood/anxiety disorder and an adjustment disorder is not whether your problems are "real" or "in your head" (since that is socially constructed), but whether you are conscious or unconscious of the causes of your symptoms. Take two examples: person A and person B.
Person A just went through a divorce, the death of a family member or their house was destroyed in a natural disaster, or even a mix of the above. They feel very sad for a period of time. Society considers these to be "real" reasons to be sad, so psychology will label them as healthy (or as having an "adjustment disorder" if they suffer for too long or too much).
Person B became famous, is full of money and attention all the time and has a ton of women and cars. After a while, his progress stagnates and he's stuck at the same (big) amount of wealth, same number of views per song (say, he is a musician), same number of subscribers etc. for a longer period of time. This stagnation makes him depressed. However, he does not know psychoanalysis and that this could be a cause of depressive symptoms as well. Society tells you that in such a situation, you don't have any "real" problem, so there must be something wrong with your brain for you to feel sad and empty in such a situation in life.
Since society hasn't taught him that such a situation often causes long-term sadness and lack of motivation, he didn't even make the connection between his stagnation and his symptoms and viewed it as a coincidence, a random correlation, when in fact it may have been the causation. He will then go on to say how he feels sad because of "no reason" and will be diagnosed with major depressive disorder instead of being labeled as healthy or as with having an "adjustment disorder" because his problems aren't "real".
Yet the only difference between person A and person B wasn't how "real" their problems (causes) were, but how conscious they were of them.
We can also see how much many critics of psychoanalysis are heavily projecting. In this video, psychodynamic therapies (psychoanalysis, Jungian and Adlerian) are criticized because "In both religious practices and the unconscious, there is an attempt to explain behavior by appealing to an inaccessible mind. Because of this inaccessibility, any assertions made about the motives about these supposed hidden minds are unfalsifiable speculations. Peddlers of demons are able to posit any demonic desire they like, and peddlers of the unconscious can posit any unconscious intention, all without any fear of empirical refutation. In both cases, clients are supposed to accept their assertions all because of fallacious appeals to authority".
Yet the causality is exactly reversed, it's not that psychoanalysis imitates religion but the other way around. Religious practices are a bad attempt at trying to explain the unconscious. The reason people believe in demonic possession is because the unconscious feels like an outside force possessing you, like the "possession by archetypes of the collective unconscious" Jung spoke about. In this way, psychoanalysis is actually the most down-to-earth approach to the unconscious, since it actually attempts to discover the causes of symptoms instead of blaming it on the big Other ("chance": God, evil spirits, chemicals in your brain deciding to go crazy on their own without anyone wondering as to why).
NPCs who repeat narratives like "All mental disorders are 'just' a chemical imbalance", "CBT is the only evidence-based treatment", "A DSM diagnosis is important and only a qualified professional can do it, you shall never self-diagnose" and a few others, without actually understanding them, are giving the DSM-V as the alternative in psychodiagnosis. Yet, ironically speaking, it's exactly where psychology regressed the most from psychoanalysis in terms of scientific rigor. In the days of psychodynamics (I'm looking especially at Lacan and Jung), everyone was ill in their own way, just that some people were more functional than others and some people had some symptoms while others had other symptoms. There was no clear, sharp line between pathological and healthy. Some diagnostics existed, but they weren't anything set in stone, but just a general guidance (like Jung's 8 psychological types of Lacan's 3 clinical structures) and you'd never hear about how a diagnosis is necessary to treatment and how you should never self-diagnose.
Now, the alternative is to go to a "trusted professional" to give you a diagnosis. But, the DSM shall never be used "like a cook book", you can't simply check the symptoms on your own. Instead, only the qualified professional possesses the magical qualities ("mana") that they can use to find out your mental illness, but they can never talk about their magic or ever actually write it in an actual book rigorously because only qualified professionals can understand. This is because the DSM is preached to be only a tool but never the full story as unqualified patients can't use it, thus, depression and anxiety aren't presented as "just a collection of symptoms" but some sort of hidden essence that's supposed to exist that only qualified psychologists can perceive. Psychology is the only medical field where disorders are not clearly defined.
The DSM conflates the definition, the symptoms and the diagnostic criteria of an illness into one (which never happens in the case of non-psychiatric medicine, for example the definition/essence of Coronavirus is a virus, the diagnostic criteria is a saliva or blood test and the symptoms are fever, cough, etc.). This caused some psychologists to say that the definition is something outside the DSM and that the DSM only provides symptoms and diagnostic criteria but not the definition/essence of the illness, which is never rigorously/formally written anywhere. Instead, it is a hard to perceive 'essence' (mana, objet petit a) that only a trusted expert can see after many years of training but they can never actually talk about it unless they talk to other professionals. They can talk "around" it but it will never be enough, there will always be something missing that they did not say about depression, GAD, OCD, etc. because a layman simply cannot understand.
They are treated exactly like the shamans and mana personalities of primitive tribes described by Jung or Freud in their anthropological studies. Only those who have the necessary 'mana' can perceive the essence of this invisible object that still directs our lives (objet petit a).
1: I say "mostly" true because on a few occasions it is straight up false. For example, it is a myth that serotonin causes depression. This has been debunked in trials where SSRIs increased serotonin levels in depressed patients after hours from ingestion but it took weeks for the symptoms to attenuate. There has only been established a correlation but not a causation between serotonin and depression. However, maybe there is a strong and positive correlation between medications that increase serotonin and medications that increase some other chemical that we haven't discovered yet that is the actual cause of depression.