r/psychoanalysis • • Apr 12 '24

Racism in NYC institutes

9 Upvotes

There’s so much entrenched racism within psychoanalysis in general and I would love to be able to find an institute to train in NYC that is doing good work, not censoring those who are not pro Israel, and does not have a performative DEI team. Sometimes it feels hopeless but I would love to find a place to train where I don’t have to sacrifice my commitment to my social justice values.


r/psychoanalysis • • Mar 02 '24

Any theories concerning the topic of Transgenderism?

0 Upvotes

How can the psychoanalytical approach explain transgenderism, could it be contingent upon fixation through the psychosexual development or a form of defence mechanism?


r/psychoanalysis • • Mar 23 '24

How would "heteronormativity" be understood in psychoanalysis? Especially Lacanian

0 Upvotes

Edit: I've answered my own question (I think). Ordinarily I would include this at the bottom of the OP, but this sub has some rule regulating how long a post can be.

If you're interested in my general problem with "queer" discourse and discussions of heteronormativity, I think this comment stands in well for the critical or declarative aspect of my OP.

As for the answer to my question, I have arrived at the following: heteronormativity is an extimate "Other" which has been set up by the unary trait's "cut" which constructs a queer identity by distinguishing inner from outer (though in such a way that the outer is dangerously essential to the inner and at times threatens to invade it?). Normally, I suppose the NOTF/phallus would somehow stabilize this structure, but I'm not sure queer theory typically goes that far. In any case, this is the answer I've arrived at.

At this point, I think it would be appropriate for anybody to respond to the above (including the comment I've linked to), but not to continue to respond to the original original post which many people seem to have found confusingly confusing in any case.

Edit edit: changed my mind. Might be a NOTF for queer and I think it's called "internalized homophobia"? The "no" that you're not allowed to go beyond? Idk


r/psychoanalysis • • Oct 07 '24

Looking for resources on gender. It makes little sense to me.

1 Upvotes

Are there any resources on the abolition of gender or how gender is incoherent/useless? Or even one that argues the opposite? Trying to make sense of this.

So my experience of the world and of people it’s like everyone is an alien. Every single one. The only way I can position myself in such a way to make the world populated by non-aliens is by ignoring certain traits or generalizing. By omitting and glossing over or equating. But just can’t do it. I’m even alien to myself. And identity is just some inconsistent expectation. And everyone seems to have a different idea of what the details a certain identity is as represented by signifiers that are different for different people. It’s just a mess and I don’t see what exactly it is that is supposed to be in common with the various people underneath the whatever gender identity they choose.

Not so much a world where everyone belongs but one where nobody belongs. Belonging doesn’t sit well with me

So really gender just seems very useless. Always off the mark. It literally tells me nothing about a person. I grew up in a household where I was more “feminine” than the men and the women were more “masculine” than me. Sure there’s the term “non-binary” but I that’s such an “etc” category that just puts you in a binary relationship against the traditional gender binary - in a way it reaffirms it.

In addition to that it seems that the main place I notice gender is simply in advertisements. Trying to group certain aesthetics with certain categories (gender) and appealing to that category to sell something. But I don’t think finding identity in corporate shilling is good at all.

Then there’s always going to be more and more genders. Due to how each gender is an undefined variable and each variable fails to capture the traits a person has that are in common with others because of how each other under that variable has a different relation to that variable. I’m beginning to get lost as to what the point of it all is.

Even in my own life I would not care what gender I’m called in and of itself. I only care about the intent and judgement of falling out of or in line in terms of expectation. I present as a man I guess? But if someone calls me a woman or some other gender it’d be because they intend it as an insult. And so it’s that intent that I feel. Even when called a man though I feel alienated and uneasy about it because it’s just a set of expectations that I absolutely cannot fill. In the same way this extends to many other ways of identifying beyond gender. Identity is a trap.

Does anything I’m saying make sense? The whole thing makes as much sense to me as saying X = X + Y (where Y can’t be 0) or something. All I find is anxiety no matter the label. Be it applied to me or to others. When people say “I’m this type of person” I just think of every where they aren’t and every way that a “type of person” doesn’t actually exist.

Any readings that can help me conceptualize this? I’m rather lost.


r/psychoanalysis • • Jun 08 '24

What’s up with all the posts about people reading “psychoanalysis texts” but do not undergo analysis or god forbid study psychology?

0 Upvotes

What the title says. I’m a psychoanalyst, and psychologist (which i consider different things as a whole). I see lots of people posting about certain texts and asking about intricate terms and concepts. My take on this is the following: get formal education on it. There are a lot of possibilities that range from free/not expensive to ridiculously overpriced. Study from the basics, learn neurobiology 101, development, social psychology, etc. Psychoanalysis is not just fancy literature (even if it may bring you intelectual narcissistic rejoice, like it does for me) and to actually be a tool, be an analysand. Undergo the process. As Lacan puts it, after a proper analysis, what comes out is a good analyst.


r/psychoanalysis • • Jun 20 '24

Why does Nancy McWilliams talk about unlocking repressed memories when we have research showing memory doesn’t work this way?

1 Upvotes

Isn’t it immoral to treat people with that in mind if it is not only not backed up by research, but actually debunked by it?


r/psychoanalysis • • Mar 09 '24

Why did psychoanalysis and depth psychology kind of disappear? Psychiatry is thought of as a worthwhile replacement, but the scientific process does not make value judgements.

0 Upvotes

And we need value judgements to help people. We need some kind of a dogma about what is good or bad, roughly what is a sane and an insane person. I know that being too strict with those definitions is not good, but vagueness is the opposite problem.

My understanding of a very simplistic reading of the history is. Schopenhauer (Pessimism, looking at life as a bad thing, opposed to Christianity) > Nietzsche (We are just animals chasing power, and that is fine) > Freud, Jung, Adler (Symbolic language, "Will to power again", Jung being the Plato of the unconscious ) > [Other stuff] > Ernest Becker (We are motivated by running from the unconscious fear of death). But it kind of ends there for me.

Then this stuff latched off of science and empiricism. And Foucault comes along with some other people to just project the "will to power idea" from Nietzsche to everything. And for some reason we stop looking into the human soul, it seems like. Opposing sides are just clinging on to their belief systems and fighting for it. But we seem to lack any general "theory of mind".

Maybe the people who want to study their souls just stay alone, quiet and humble. But people who don't do that. Just go around pointing fingers and blaming other people for this and that. I think it would be good if we returned from certainty to some soul searching. But perhaps even making that claim, I am expressing my (Nietzche would say will to power, Becker would say cosmic heroism to seek eternal life) to try and make other people like me.

So how can we help people? If the only thing we can do is help ourself, and the moment we start trying to control the souls of other people, we become corrupted and start trying to control them for your own benefit. Then evil will win, I think. The only solution I see is not caring about the souls of others. Just be thankful for what you have, and try to live in virtue, what else would you want to do? Why?


r/psychoanalysis • • Apr 09 '24

What exactly is the point of psychoanalytic interpretation?

3 Upvotes

There's one aspect I don't understand, and that's what someone really does with the wild speculation and theorizing of the unconscious. Let's take for example a guy who argues with his female boss and tells that to his therapist. This is a constant problem for him so, the analyst suggests, or leads him to conclude that this is a repetition of childhood trauma or some oedipal situation. The boss really represents his mother, he's arguing with her because he argued nonstop with his mom or maybe didn't argue with her enough and she was absent, or for whatever reason it's the moms existence that makes him run into issues and is a stand-in.

My question then becomes, assuming that notion is 100% true, what does any of that do? Maybe it seems like a dumb question but it feels like 'Just is' stories and theories like this are very much aggrandizing. That there's some idea that the therapist should be revered for bringing this up or the patient should honor them by feeling some cathartic release, not unlike when a priest blesses them or absolves them of their sins. See the light of Freud, feel at ease and free! Why should this happen however? I feel like there's a vanity to assuming this like psychoanalysis does? Like Freud called all his patients 'stubborn' when they wouldn't change or said their resistance was too strong for not just flipping like a lightswitch at all his theories, even when many cases went badly in terms of how the treatment went, and he just blamed them instead of what, pretending to be cured and treating him like gospel?

Let me put it into perspective, what happens if the patient goes to the therapist and brings this theory up first, flat out declaring "I argue alot because of my mother situation and have this oedipal problem. I know why so and such." Wouldn't the Analyst immediately be disinterested and annoyed at how they come to them with that, instead of being told it by the analyst first or rightfully diagnosed it? Or maybe not annoyed, but one can see how this thinking can serve as a Just-So story that serves as an excuse or a fixation for the patient that is not leading to emotional maturity or benefiting them in moving on from their issue, since this story they're telling themselves (I have an oedipal situation with my Boss) is what's holding them down in not dealing with why their not getting along with her in the first place. They can keep hitting themselves with a psychoanaylsis textbook and get affirmations from the analyst and feel good about themselves for doing it despite not having done anything, and the analyst gets out of this that they had the theory affirmed (this is important!) first and foremost, above all else.

There seems to be nothing really to do with that theory that benefits them or changes anything, whether it's true or not. Sure the therapist can say "Well just quit and find a boss not like your mother.", but then they're not doing psychoanalysis- they're giving life advice which isn't really what psychoanalysis is about. Do you see any validity in what I'm saying?


r/psychoanalysis • • Aug 07 '22

What do you guys think of Sigmund Freud?

0 Upvotes

i find that without the inventions of sigmund we wouldnt have probably gone so far in psychology but what about the underlying character of this man?


r/psychoanalysis • • Mar 13 '24

Can "internalized homophobia" be a mode of jouissance?

0 Upvotes

Somebody who allows their jouissance to be inscribed as "gay" or "queer" is given a kind of symbolic position as well as imaginary identity. But somebody who resists being corraled in this way can enjoy the lack of any generalizable signifier that would inscribe all their jouissance. If on the surface, "assimilationist" gays are regarded as masculine and as capitulating to heteronormative ideals, their masculinity can be construed as being like that of St. Teresa while it's the anti-assimilationist queers who exhibit more of a masculine structure by trying to construct a queer identity that would name their jouissance.

It's worth noting that almost nobody would call himself "assimilationist" except as a response to anti-assimilationism (aka they are not-anti-assimilationist). The "assimilationism" rubric is set up by the antis, although it's got a lot of institutional backing at this point and is generally the way we understand this "debate" or difference. But at the end of the day it's just a word and in no way indicates that the anti-assimilationists aren't trying to assimilate to something. Whereas rejecting a "place" in the "queer community" can be construed as a form of non-assimilation.


r/psychoanalysis • • Jul 21 '24

What impact will AI have on psychoanalysis?

2 Upvotes

I was warned by a friend to be careful about any field where you only work with words, as these fields are being rapidly replaced by AI. (I know this subreddit will have retorts to the idea that psychoanalysis only works with words and am welcoming them). Do you think AI could ever take the place of psychoanalysis, given they can be trained on all of the psychoanalytic literature and case studies ever? Is there something AI couldn't ever do, at least in the foreseeable future?

My take is that whatever AI can do in this field, there will always be more that humans can add on top.


r/psychoanalysis • • Nov 21 '25

Finished Jung, Freud, Adler... Next is Carl Rodgers or Lacan?

0 Upvotes

Mostly looking for recommendations and tips.

I did Jung's Psychological Types and Aion. Was considering coming back to him long term and reading Archetypes and maybe red book.

Did Freud's Dreams, 3 essays on sex, beyond pleasure, and ego and id.

Did Adler's Individual Psychology.

I kind of want to end the post here, but I'll mention some personal preferences that aren't really necessary, but maybe you can customize if you have thoughts:

I particularly like shorter books with high ROI. For this reason I preferred the essays from Freud over his book on dreams. Not that I don't read long books, but I prefer frontloading the short books. Gives a better understanding asap. Better to read 3 concepts in 20 hours, than a single in that same time.

Maybe one other cavet: Winter is coming, and I spend probably 4 hours a week running outside listening to these books while doing voice to text notes. In the 0 degree weather, I'll probably not be holding my phone and able to do voice to text. If you have any suggestions for mostly passive books that I should save for January/Feb, that's bonus points.

Super appreciated, gotten a lot out of this subreddit.


r/psychoanalysis • • Jul 09 '26

When, if ever, is it ethical to psychoanalyze someone publicly without their consent?

0 Upvotes

I’m asking this partly because of something that happened to me, and I want to understand the broader ethical issue.

For context, I’ve been the target of a long-running online harassment and smear campaign. As part of that, someone without any psychological or psychiatric training wrote a detailed “psychoanalysis” of me and my behavior based on limited exposure to my online interactions. They included this in a large public callout document. That analysis is treated as “evidence” that I am unstable, dangerous, and manipulative.

To be clear, I know that someone without training should not do that. It's the same sort of thing as someone with no formal training in law, medicine, or engineering presenting themselves as qualified to make expert conclusions. It is especially harmful when the “analysis” is used to isolate or discredit someone.

I also know that trained mental health professionals generally should not do this either. I’m not saying bad apples don’t exist, but the actual professionals I’ve spoken to have all agreed that publicly diagnosing or analyzing a person they have not evaluated, especially without consent, raises serious ethical concerns.

Where I get confused is in the gray area.

For example, I’ve seen online controversies where someone with a degree in a mental health-related field breaks down a public callout document. They discuss how a certain mental health condition can lead to specific behaviors or beliefs reflected in the document. They may not explicitly say, “This person has X disorder,” but it can still feel like they are psychoanalyzing that person or implying something clinical about them.

So my question is: When, if ever, is it appropriate to psychoanalyze someone publicly without their consent?

Is this mostly a black-and-white issue? Should someone who feels tempted to psychoanalyze another person publicly keep those thoughts to themselves?

Or are there situations where it can be ethical, such as:

  • Discussing public behavior without diagnosing

  • Talking generally about patterns without assigning a condition to a specific person

  • Analyzing a public figure’s statements or writings

  • Discussing how certain mental health conditions can affect behavior, without claiming a specific person has that condition?

Where is the actual line?

I’m especially interested in hearing from mental health professionals, therapists, counselors, psychologists, and psychiatrists, or anyone familiar with professional ethics. I’m not asking anyone to diagnose anyone involved in my situation. I want to understand what is considered ethical when people use mental health language to explain, discredit, or warn others about someone online.

From my perspective, having a layperson’s detailed psychoanalysis of me published and treated as proof that I’m dangerous has been very damaging. I’m trying to determine whether my instinct is right in believing this should be considered completely inappropriate or if there are legitimate gray areas I’m overlooking.


r/psychoanalysis • • Aug 15 '24

Psychoanalytic texts on Non-Binary Identity

4 Upvotes

Hello! Something of a novice to psychoanalysis, but I’m wondering if there are any books and articles that deal with non-binary gender identity. I consider myself non-binary and am curious about how the development of such identities is currently viewed. Also interested in androgyny and androgynous gender presentation more generally. Thanks for any suggestions!


r/psychoanalysis • • Apr 18 '25

LLMs and Lacan

1 Upvotes

Is anyone here interested in Lacanian psychoanalysis and understands ChatGPT? I have a master's thesis idea (Psychology MA) and would really love to ask a crucial question about GPTs ability to map and intervene in a user's discourse.


r/psychoanalysis • • Sep 11 '20

Zizek isn’t a psychoanalyst, but a political philosopher influenced by psychoanalysis. What are people’s thoughts about removing him from the sidebar?

0 Upvotes

There are lots of philosophers (along with social and natural scientists) influenced by psychoanalysis who aren’t included in the sidebar.

There are strict psychoanalysts working who aren’t included in the sidebar.

Zizek’s introduction into the sidebar as the only philosopher/political theorist essentially places a certain ideology on this sub, one that’s supportive of left-leaning policies on wealth distribution but hostile to left leaning policies on women’s rights, lgbt rights, racial equality, animal rights, etc. and using an eco-communist authoritarian method of solving the coming climate change crisis (permanent power in favor of the left, with no form of representation on the right being the best form of government, according to one of his talks).

His contributions to psychoanalysis is bare and convoluted. He himself says that he failed in his own analysis and quit midway through self-sabotage.

I don’t understand the inclusion behind it, as the only political philosopher and social scientist. What are other people’s thoughts?


r/psychoanalysis • • Apr 12 '25

How to become an analyst

1 Upvotes

I've been interested in becoming a therapist for 10+ years. One reason I haven't gone through with it is because I am more interested in doing deeper intensive work with people who are somewhat privileged. Not because I have anything against unprivileged folk but the answer to someone with poor mental health b/c they are unhoused is to get them a goddamned house, not for me to try to make it easier for them to deal with our society failing them. Perhaps unfairly I struggle to work with individuals on the borders of our system because of how angry it makes me with the system.

Anyhow. My understanding is that psychoanalysis is less social work and much more intensive form of talk therapy. That is to say most of the folks you are working with are more likely to be dealing with more advanced problems rather than a lack of their basic needs being met.

Is this correct? If so what are the routes to get into analysis? I was under the impression that the routes were either therapy (msw or similar) or psychiatry (med school), but analysis seems like a 3rd route. What is the training like, how long does it take? Has anyone done it as an older individual (I am 40). I am extremely successful in what I do but am interested in branching out.

Thanks!

edit: Because I forgot this is state dependent, I will include location. Currently in California but from nyc and could move back without too much difficulty.


r/psychoanalysis • • Dec 05 '25

Practicing psychoanalytical psychotherapy/psychoanalysis without a medical degree - could this complicate the work?

0 Upvotes

What I've understood is that some of the therapists/analysts have background in medicine while some have not. Do you think practicing psychotherapy/analysis without medical training could make the work more difficult? What I'm thinking about is that even though someone has an understanding of psychological symptoms and their possible origins/developmental paths, the patient could also suffer from physiological symptoms caused by their psychological illness (e.g. conversion disorder).

So, I guess with medical training it could be easier to understand and diagnose the patient more holistically. Whereas without a deep understanding of the human body and the nervous system there could possibly arise situations where the patient must be referred to someone else for medical evaluation to rule out other than psychological origins of their symptoms?

(Asking as someone who's been considering doing MSW and then maybe someday becoming therapist/analyst.)


r/psychoanalysis • • Apr 13 '25

Can someone succinctly explain how holding in faeces to prolong attention from caregivers becomes repetitively doing stuff in OCD?

0 Upvotes

Op


r/psychoanalysis • • Mar 17 '21

The reason Freud's theories can't be (shouldn't be?) scientifically demonstrated is...

2 Upvotes

Because Freud was a philosopher, not a scientist. Despite being a trained physician, and despite apparently loathing philosophy...

[Freud himself, from New Introductory Lectures on Psycho-analysis]:

"Philosophy is not opposed to science, it behaves itself as if it were a science, and to a certain extent it makes use of the same methods; but it parts company with science, in that it clings to the illusion that it can produce a complete and coherent picture of the universe. Its methodological error lies in the fact that it over-estimates the epistemological value of our logical operations… But philosophy has no immediate influence on the great majority of mankind; it interests only a small number even of the thin upper stratum of intellectuals, while all the rest find it beyond them."

...that's exactly what he seems to be. A philosopher. The above perfectly describes his realm of thought. His theories 'cling to the illusion that it can produce a complete and coherent picture of the [mind]' and its 'methodological errors lie in the fact that it overestimates epistemological [arguments].'

We've had a number of discussions here on why Freud can't and shouldn't be scientifically or empirically evaluated, and that his work is more humanistic and epistemological in nature. Fair enough: he's a social/interpersonal philosopher. Which means he had a lot of interesting things to say about the nature of the mind, but none of them can probably be empirically demonstrated to be true, and then the question becomes: ought we still practice a psychology on people that is just a philosophy and not a science? And yes: I would say this as well to an existential therapist, although there have been many successful studies done in the area of mindfulness that demonstrate aspects of that philosophy to be both useful and readily employable on patients.

Thoughts? This isn't a shitpost, but I'm also making a case I don't know if I believe 100%. Call me a sophist, I'm just trying this stance out to see how it feels. =)


r/psychoanalysis • • Nov 14 '25

The School of Life: How Childhood Shapes Adult Views on Intimacy and Desire

0 Upvotes

I personally love this channel and it has given me so much insight over the years. I wonder, if anyone has seen this video, what are people's thoughts on it? In summary, it discusses how the longer you are in an intimate relationship with someone, the harder it is to want to explore sexual deviance (especially once kids are born). But sexual exploration with strangers seems much easier and more thrilling. This is down to how our parents raise us and teach us about our sexuality.


r/psychoanalysis • • Sep 11 '24

Against a lay person who may or may not have a background in psychology how best to convince him of the unconscious

1 Upvotes

When he she may just reply “of course I know what I am thinking how can I not know? Are you dumb?”


r/psychoanalysis • • Apr 27 '26

Is the current psychoanalytic training model geared more towards masters level clinicians?

0 Upvotes

One of my frustrations as a counseling psych PhD candidate and as a psychoanalysis enthusiast is the nature of the current analyst training programs.

The current training model seems to be marketed to masters level clinicians seeking to attain certification as an analyst. For example, after completing a 2-3 year masters, the 5-6 additional years of training in analysis functions as a quasi-PhD program in psychoanalysis.

For those who have already completed a 5-7 year PhD in clinical or counseling psychology, the prospect of beginning another 5-6 year program feels difficult. Especially if a PhD level clinician has already completed masters level training (an additional 2-3 years), the road to becoming a psychoanalyst is very, very long.

Does anyone else resonate with this assessment? Does anyone know of any streamlined paths for doctoral students to acquire certification as an analyst (ideally, a path that would not add an additional 5 years of schooling)?


r/psychoanalysis • • Aug 05 '24

Is there any correlation between being successful and having a very bad relationship with your father?

0 Upvotes

I am increasingly surprised to meet famous people who achieve truly extraordinary things, such as becoming presidents, becoming influencers who give life advice, or emperors who directly killed their father to gain power.

What motivates such a person to be successful?