r/psychoanalysis • • Feb 10 '25

Is modern mental healthcare insane or am I?

975 Upvotes

I'm a budding therapist currently in the second year of my clinical MSW program. I was drawn to the field for classic reasons (parents struggling with mental illness, me seeking therapy as a result, yadayadayda). As a teenager and young adult, I was fascinated by the intricacies and nuances of people's experiences and by the power of therapy to make complicated people feel better. It took me awhile to find a therapist who "jived" with me, but once I did it was quite a profound experience.

For the past two years of my program, I have become more and more disillusioned with the field. I imagined that I would learn how to do what my therapist did for me. And while some of those skills have been mentioned (listening, empathizing, etc.) the orientation is wrong. Most of the people I encounter (professors, classmates, internship supervisors and colleagues) are not at all interested in (or even aware of??) the "depth" psychotherapy I know to be very real. Very few people seem to have a real idea of or ability to apply transference/countertransference (which, now that I learn about them myself, seem imperative for any beginning clinician to be aware of). I've had supervisors blatantly judge clients with no apparent awareness (like "There's just something off about him, he might have antisocial personality disorder" or "I could never just sit in silence with somebody. If you wanna do the work, I'm here for it, but I can't just sit there wasting time").

I find myself so confused and saddened by the current state of mental health care. What is happening? And I don't think it's only in community mental health. Most therapists I've tried to find myself since my one good experience (she retired, sadly) have not been able to engage in depth work. I was talking to my most recent therapist about my anxiety of not being able to help my clients, and she said, "Some people make their job their whole life. I'm just not like that."

I feel like I need reassurance that in this world of manlualized treatments, coping skills, and SMART goals, there are still people seeking depth, truth, and freedom. Reading about psychodynamic therapy has been, truly, a godsend.

I'd love to hear anyone's thoughts on this.

edit: Wow, I wanted to generate discussion but I never expected this! I so appreciate each person for commenting. I want to reply to every post but there are simply too many now. I'm reading each one and feeling very good about the solidarity/insight/support. Faith in therapy (somewhat) restored. Thank you all :)

edit 2: Just to let everyone know (since it's come up a few times in the comments), I do actually have a job lined up after graduation at a psychodynamically/analytically aligned agency with a lot of individual and group supervision as well as didactic instruction. I am STOKED about this, and the literature I'm currently reading as "onboarding" somewhat inspired this post in a sense of "If therapy can be THIS way, why on EARTH would people be practicing THAT way?" I'm less disillusioned with my own path, moreso the state of affairs and the quality of services most people seeking therapy will experience.


r/psychoanalysis • • Mar 28 '25

Psychodynamic psychotherapy is 100% evidence based at this point (references you can use

696 Upvotes

Shout this from the rooftops and shout down anyone who doubts this as completely out of date or politically motivated (in an "American therapy wars" sense). Shelder 2010 was a phenomenal review already noting the clear evidence for psychodynamic psychotherapy. Other research and meta analyses on psychodynamic psychotherapy continue to confirm the evidence base. Here are the reviews and global organizations that support what I'm saying. FYI these are top, high impact journals. Now please get out there and fight the good fight advocating, no educating others about this.

For Mood and Anxiety Disorders

Fonagy et al. (2015) – World Psychiatry

Leichsenring et al. (2015) - Lancet Psychiatry

Driessen et al. (2015) – Clinical Psychology Review

Milrod et al. (2016) – Journal of Clinical Psychiatry

Steinert et al. (2017) – American Journal of Psychiatry

Zhang et al. (2022) – Psychiatry Research

Leichsenring et al. (2023) – World Psychiatry

For Personality Disorders

Clarkin et al. (2007) - American Journal of Psychiatry

Bateman & Fonagy (2008) - American Journal of Psychiatry

Doering et al. (2010) – British Journal of Psychiatry

Town et al. (2011) – Journal of Personality Disorders

Jørgensen et al. (2013) – Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica

Leichsenring et al. (2015) - Lancet Psychiatry

Fonagy et al. (2015) – World Psychiatry

Cristea et al. (2017) – JAMA Psychiatry

Keefe et al. (2020) – Personality Disorders

Somatic Disorders

Abbass et al. (2009) - Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics

Leichsenring et al. (2015) - Lancet Psychiatry

Global Authoritative Bodies That Recognize Psychodynamic Psychotherapy as Evidence Based

National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) – United Kingdom

World Health Organization (WHO)

German Psychological Society & German Guidelines for Psychotherapy

Canadian Psychological Association (CPA)

The Karolinska Institute & Swedish Health System

The American Psychological Association (continues to be weird and apparently CBT-biased, they acknowledge the "empirical support" for PDT but haven't yet labeled PDT as an "evidence based treatment")


r/psychoanalysis • • Jan 18 '25 Diamonds are Forever

I love that psychoanalysis is anti-utilitarian and pointless

427 Upvotes

I'm an outsider who is fascinated by and fairly sympathetic to psychoanalysis. I have found that mainstream therapists' main criticism of the psychoanalytic school is that psychoanalysis is not evidence-based when it comes to improving people's lives. I think that's actually my favorite part about it... where CBT promises to treat your depression or other presenting problem by correcting your thought patterns, with the base assumption that you ought to feel good about yourself--the brainchild of a capitalist society in which all activity is meant to lead to a profitable end--psychoanalysis promises nothing. Not happiness, not increased functionality, not the job or partner you want, not stability, not better sex, nothing at all. In proper analysis we find nothing more than the gift of self-knowledge for its own sake, and its decline in popularity reflects the rarity of the type of person who is willing to undergo the terror associated with really knowing and seeing the person who you are rather than the one you imagine yourself to be. There are immeasurable benefits to this, of course, but almost all are intangible.

I am a very neurotic person who has gone to horrific, emphasis on horrific, lengths over the years to deconstruct the processes of my own mind, for most of my life unsuccessfully, and then successfully. I have no analytic training whatsoever so I can't speak to how it compares to what would have happened had I instead seen a professional (which is on my bucket list if I ever had thousands of dollars to burn). I'm not always glad I did it, but when I am, I have found it... rewarding is not the word. That's too pat. I'm not surprised that therapists who hang their hats on evidence and science don't care for it; in some ways it seems kind of like something where you "have to be there," inside yourself. Regardless, I think Zizek put it well when he said that psychoanalysis is not the freedom to enjoy, but the freedom to enter a space in which one is allowed not to enjoy. And it performs a valuable role in that sense.

Edit: a lot of commenters have received me as saying psychoanalysis can't help people and they are completely missing my point. I think it can and does help transform people and improve their lives, but it is more helpful in the way that art is helpful than the way that a tool is helpful, i.e. it is not perfunctory.


r/psychoanalysis • • Sep 04 '24

Why is psychoanalysis so hated in the US

353 Upvotes

This is something I’m very curious about. In my country it is taught as a psychological approach in every university and we always view psychology as a holder of multiple truths instead of one single truth. However, every time I come across foreign psychologists (especially from the US), it seems like the only acceptable approach is CBT and everything else is a scam. Why is that?


r/psychoanalysis • • Dec 06 '25

Long-Term Therapy Actually Works

298 Upvotes

A new naturalistic German study evaluated the long-term effectiveness of two psychoanalytically oriented treatments - psychodynamic psychotherapy (PP) and analytical psychotherapy (AP) - over a 6-year follow-up period. A total of 428 patients with diverse and often complex psychopathology were included, many presenting with multiple DSM-IV diagnoses and substantial personality dysfunction. The study employed annual assessments, SCID interviews at baseline and termination, and propensity score weighting to mitigate selection bias in this non-randomized design.

Both treatments produced substantial and durable improvements across all major outcome domains: symptom severity (GSI), number of diagnoses, personality dysfunction (IPO-16), interpersonal problems (IIP-64), and general life satisfaction. Within-group effect sizes were large—particularly for symptom reduction—confirming the effectiveness of psychoanalytically oriented therapies in routine care.

However, the temporal pattern of change differed markedly. PP showed rapid gains within the first treatment year, with improvements stabilising thereafter. This mirrors the model’s focus on circumscribed conflict and structured intervention. In contrast, AP demonstrated slower early change but continued improvement throughout the entire 6-year observation period, reflecting its greater intensity (mean duration 3.25 years; approx. 229 sessions) and deeper structural focus.

Comparatively, AP outperformed PP on nearly all outcomes except life satisfaction, with between-group effect sizes in the small-to-medium range. Crucially, baseline severity moderated this effect: patients with higher initial symptom burden or personality dysfunction benefited significantly more from AP, showing moderate to large differential gains (e.g., d = 0.53–0.88). For lower-severity cases, PP and AP performed similarly, suggesting that PP may be more cost-efficient for milder presentations.

The findings highlight that long-term, intensive psychoanalytic treatments yield incremental benefits particularly for complex and severe cases, and that meaningful change in deep personality structures often unfolds over extended periods—beyond what short-term trials typically capture.

Henkel, M., Zimmermann, J., Volz, M., Huber, D., Staats, H., & Benecke, C. (2025). The long-term effectiveness of psychodynamic and analytical psychotherapy in routine care: Results from a naturalistic study over 6 years. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 93(12), 814–828. https://doi.org/10.1037/ccp0000985


r/psychoanalysis • • Dec 03 '25

I'm a student of psychoanalysis, looking for a penpal. (Currently in prison)

276 Upvotes

Hello,

This is somewhat unusual, but I wanted to give it a shot despite my reservations.

I'm in my 30s. I've lived in the US most of my life, got a decent education, and I'm serving time in a prison. When my sentence is over (in less than two years), I will be deported back to my country of origin. My arrest happened 4 years ago, and life as I knew it was turned to dust. Strangely enough, it was as liberating as it was painful. In a period of desolation and uncertainty (although I was certain about the impending prison sentence), I discovered psychoanalysis exactly when I needed it. For the past three years or so, I've been studying it on my own, mostly through books and self-analysis. I've read a fair amount of text by/about Freud, Klein, Winnicott, Kohut, Bion, Bollas, the 'French school', Kernberg, Lacan etc, enough to feel like I've made it past the beginner stage. Currently I think I'm well-situated to begin a deeper study of Freud and Lacan's primary texts.

Studying psychoanalysis and engaging with the unconscious in prison has been an incredibly valuable and transformative experience, but also uncomfortable, painful, and lonely. I'm lucky to have the friends I have here, but there is no one with whom I can engage in a 'psychoanalytic' way, no one who can really 'hear' me. Believe me I have searched. The almost complete lack of privacy here does not help either.

It occurred to me recently that perhaps I could try looking for someone on the outside. I asked myself, why did it take me so long to give this a try? It might have to do with my current Lacan phase and the elevated angst that comes with that. Also, my conviction, my dream to become a psychoanalyst someday has steadily grown throughout my experience. It's a difficult road to walk alone, in confinement no less. I'm getting tired of thinking about things in my head and getting excited about psychoanalytic theory without being able to share it with anyone who has the capacity to understand.

I'm hoping to find an epistolary companion who considers psychoanalysis a true vocation and who won't assume my moral inferiority simply based on my incarceration.

It doesn't have to be frequent (I'm actually quite busy!), but I would like it to be meaningful.

If you are interested, please send me a message to maybesomeday9200 (at gmail).


r/psychoanalysis • • May 02 '24

What creates a masochistic personality (not to be confused with the sexual sort)?

257 Upvotes

For example someone who self-sabotages and puts themselves in iffy positions when they otherwise know better and have the capability to do something different.

Some people seem to act in a way that cause shame and they seem to enjoy this.

What drives this? How to sort through it? Is there a fix?


r/psychoanalysis • • Sep 24 '20

I was informed that this video was taken 22 days before Freud died. It's really a precious relic.

251 Upvotes

r/psychoanalysis • • Jan 28 '24

Oral sex is considered dishonorable in my culture

226 Upvotes

In the culture I grew up in( a patriarchal secular muslim society) performing oral sex is considered diabolical and has derogatory terms associated with it for both men and women. Such sexual acts are considered abhorrant and people engaging in them are thought of as lacking self-respect. There are cases of people who commit suicide because of their performing oral being publicised through revenge porn and such. On the contrary, in the modern west, oral sex is quite common and people doing it are definitely not thought of as having serious moral flaws. There are certainly people who do not engage in it but almost never their reason for it concerns morality. I wanna know why an honor culuture like mine takes issue with people who enjoy fellatio and cunnilingus. Could there be a psychological reason behind it where someone with a healthy mind would not incline to performing oral sex which is overlooked by western culture and excessively emphasized in other cultures?


r/psychoanalysis • • Jun 05 '24 Popcorn Take My Silver

Who do you consider the most brilliant psychoanalytic thinker and why?

224 Upvotes

If you also have any recommended readings, that'd be a bonus!


r/psychoanalysis • • May 10 '25

Why does society hate psychoanalysis so much?

185 Upvotes

There seems to be a systematic rejection to psychoanalysis. For the average person Freud was just a pervert that wanted to bang his mom (and I have to admit I was one of them too) and it's disregarded as pseudoscience because it lacks falsiability. But even if it is why is it such a big deal? There is so much stuff that are not based in scientific evidence and helps millions of people, like religion, art, etc. Why reject something immediately because it is not scientific? The funny thing is that I have seen those same people believe in horoscope, reiki, acupuncture and other things.


r/psychoanalysis • • Mar 06 '25

Clinicians that are resistant to psychoanalysis/psychoanalytic thought

176 Upvotes

Anyone else exhausted by the amount of clinicians that are resistant to psychoanalysis and or write it off completely as antiquated BUT have no idea what it is today and or how it is actually practice? I’m in a doctoral program, and my cohort is so resistant and often pushes back/disengages whenever we have a professor that touches on psychoanalytical theory. We’re a cohort of mostly folks of color (great) and this has lead to many classmates saying that it doesn’t resonate, and they’re interest in theorist of color (I once brought up Fanon in a different class (same cohort), but only me, the professor, and another student were aware of his work). I think what is more frustrating is when you hear some of my classmates talk about their interventions, it’s based on vibes? Like they don’t actually have any orientation for practice. I’m considering saying something collectively to the class, I’m open to hearing folks suggestions.


r/psychoanalysis • • Jun 21 '24 Take My Silver

Read Freud please

176 Upvotes

Anyone that believes themselves to be a psychoanalyst or psychoanalytic thinker and has not even attempted to read Freud (whether they like his work or absolutely hate it) is majorly lacking (no pun intended). It’s not about becoming a Freudian as it is exploring an extremely important part of psychoanalytic history. Sure it’s difficult at times but I promise you if you take it slow it’s easier than everyone thinks and if you break through that difficultly, he simplifies the theory down to its subversive yet important core. Psychoanalysis is not supposed to be easy nor easily digestible, it’s the human condition at its most radical. Too many people hate cause of the reputation or stigma and man, you guys are missing out.


r/psychoanalysis • • May 19 '21

Freud's 'sober judgement of Zionism'

171 Upvotes

The following letter was sent by Freud to Chaim Koffler of the then newly formed Jewish Agency for Israel in 1930.

It is a response to a letter in which Koffler asks Freud to sign a petition condemning the Palestine riots of the previous year and the British government's response (which was to restrict Jewish immigration to Palestine).

Arguably the letter goes towards clarifying Freud's position on Zionism (bearing in mind that the letter was written three years before Hitler's rise to power and eighteen years before the establishment of the state of Israel).

I thought it might be of topical interest...

Vienna: 26 February 1930

Dear Sir,

I cannot do as you wish. I am unable to overcome my aversion to burdening the public with my name, and even the present critical time does not seem to me to warrant it. Whoever wants to influence the masses must give them something rousing and inflammatory and my sober judgement of Zionism does not permit this. I certainly sympathise with its goals, am proud of our University in Jerusalem and am delighted with our settlement's prosperity. But, on the other hand, I do not think that Palestine could ever become a Jewish state, nor that the Christian and Islamic worlds would ever be prepared to have their holy places under Jewish care. It would have seemed more sensible to me to establish a Jewish homeland on a less historically-burdened land. But I know that such a rational viewpoint would never have gained the enthusiasm of the masses and the financial support of the wealthy. I concede with sorrow that the baseless fanaticism of our people is in part to be blamed for the awakening of Arab distrust. I can raise no sympathy at all for the misdirected piety which transforms a piece of a Herodian wall into a national relic, thereby offending the feelings of the natives.

Now judge for yourself whether I, with such a critical point of view, am the right person to come forward as the solace of a people deluded by unjustified hope.

Your obediant servant,

Freud

Edit: Since I have been accused of antisemitism for posting this, let me reiterate that this letter was written three years before the rise of Hitler, eleven years before the holocaust, and eighteen years before the Nakba and the establishment of Israel. I have not framed Freud's letter in the context of the current violence in the Middle East.


r/psychoanalysis • • Mar 22 '25

What is with these “narcissist” channels on YouTube?

151 Upvotes

Bit of a rant, but these channels where “narcissists” (are they even talking about NPD?) are basically made out to be pure evil and totally irredeemable seem highly problematic

Yes, people with NPD act horribly and do a lot of damage to those around them, but I do think there is currently a small chance to at least improve quality of life for some of these people. Isn’t the rate something like 20%?

And they are also putting them all in the same box without acknowledging the varying degrees.

From a psychotherapy perspective I thought there was a potential for patients who are more likely to take responsibility and that the prognosis is only poor (like these videos would imply) when they get closer to the antisocial category, such as parasitism, highly defiant and unwilling to admit fault, etc


r/psychoanalysis • • Sep 23 '24 Take My Silver

McWilliams on the problems with categorical diagnoses and modern application

150 Upvotes

In McWilliams' Psychoanalytic Diagnosis, Second Edition (2011), she has many concerns about giving patients categorical diagnoses as did the DSM-IV and as does the DSM-V (published after this book). She says,

"lt may [also] contribute to a form of self-estrangment, a reification of self-states for which one implicitly disowns responsibility ... "I have social phobia" is a more alienated, less self-inhabited way of saying "I am a painfully shy person." Many women become irritable when premenstural, but it is one thing to say, "I'm sorry I'm kind of cranky today; my period is due" and another to announce, "I have PMDD [premenstrual dysphoric disorder]." It seems to me that the former owns one's behavior, increases the likelihood of warm connection with others, and acknowledges that life is sometimes difficult, while the latter implies that one has a treatable ailment, distances others from one's experience, and supports an infantile belief that everything can be 'fixed.' Maybe this is just my idiosyncratic perspective, but I find this inconspicuous shift in communal assumptions troubling."

I found it quite prescient for today's attitude towards autism, ADHD, bipolar disorder, anxiety, dyslexia, etc. Indeed I find that many people today make such things their identity, and can hardly begin a discussion without stating, "as someone with dyslexia..." or "I have ADHD, you know, so..." Part of this I realize can be self-consciousness or a desire to call it out before someone else does, but I think her point stands that it separates the diagnosis from the person, and then their behavior becomes the diagnoses' doing and not theirs.

I definitely see her concern about the self-estrangement and "reification of self-states for which one implicitly disowns responsibility" although I sort of imagine this will make me unpopular in today's "respect my diagnosis and do not challenge it!" society.

Well, blame Nancy, not me; I'm just agreeing with her.

EDIT TO ADD: this might be one of the best and most interesting discussions I've gotten out of posting something on Reddit, so thank you! It's been quite rewarding so far.


r/psychoanalysis • • Feb 22 '26

What (good) psychoanalytic therapy actually is.

142 Upvotes

I rewrote my private practice website recently and used the opportunity to describe in my own words the central tenets of how I practice psychoanalytically. I think it is a useful exercise to share how we work in real life, especially given that analysis is subject to an unusual number of cultural cliches and assumptions. The main things I focussed on were:

An Acknowledgement of the Unconscious Mind

Psychodynamic therapy has its foundation in the idea that we are often impacted by patterns and forces within ourselves that we are not consciously aware of.

Healing Beyond the Correction of Cognitions

Psychodynamic therapy works on the basis that, for a person to heal, they need to be supported to discover an alternate way of being that is not only rationally thought through, but fully realised and wired into their physical body, so that it exists in an organic, spontaneous way. In the mind of the psychoanalytic therapist, a person who is left to police their thinking patterns forever is not healed.

Finding the Correct Place for Logic and Intuition

In largely forgotten history, the rational mind was considered the important, faithful servant of one’s intuition.

I think of good therapy as a process that supports the patient to become acquainted with this balance.

Deep Listening

The process of retrieving unconscious processes requires the patient and therapist to engage in what has become an uncommon and unusual process: deep listening together for how the patient’s real self is trying to reveal itself in the present.

Respect for Symptoms

Symptoms are considered not as a function of some innate wrongness or disorder, but as signposts to aspects of a person which have fallen out of alignment.

While I recognise these are perhaps not the most classical hallmarks of psychoanalytic work, I think they form the most meaningful cornerstones of how I practice. I wrote in more detail on Substack, including some more references to the evidence base for psychodynamic therapy, and how to choose a good therapist (and avoid a bad one) on Substack, if you’re interested:

https://thepsychoalchemist.substack.com/p/24-what-good-psychoanalytic-therapy?triedRedirect=true

Curious to hear how other therapists resonate (or not!).


r/psychoanalysis • • May 01 '26

Treating patients who free associate and make strong insights as a defense…never leading to action or change

138 Upvotes

Looking for anyone to point me in the direction of readings (or personal insight) about working with these kinds of clients. Over mentalizing, working with them for months on end and listening to very strong insights about their relationships, feelings and internal world leading to some level of changes to their symptoms of depression and anxiety. But no new relationships get formed, no career steps get taken, and the therapist comes to realize they are complicit in the same sort of situation the client lives in…simply living in their mind and not in the world.

It is fairly easy to understand and grasp as to what is going on here, but I don’t know how to break it and am not sure what the literature says for working with clients such as these that seemingly can make insights forever and even have a sense of accomplishment with each new one.


r/psychoanalysis • • Jan 27 '25

How would you characterise clients who come to therapy to work on their 'bad' qualities, flaws, their 'abusive' behaviours?

137 Upvotes

These are clients that want to focus on ridding themselves of their badness. They want to get down and 'do the hard work'.

They often see themselves as bad or abusive to others but on closer look it seems like regular assertive anger or displeasure from others' controlling behaviour. They take on all blame for relational failures but be angry and resentful towards the other. Same in the transference.

They seem to feel ashamed of themselves and speak to themselves like an old fashioned school teacher like "I just have to get my head down and get my act together".

They seem very willing to do this self punishing type work, but self compassion or self empathy seems miles away with plenty of primitive defences like denial (they will cry or voice will crack but say they got something in their eye or have a dry throat).

There is something masochistic about it, and there's definitely a hostile superego. How else would you see it?

This is a client type that I notice but I don't know how I would characterise it...


r/psychoanalysis • • Apr 22 '23

What is your favorite book on psychoanalysis, whether diagnosis, therapy, or just an insightful psychoanalytic take on a subject (e.g., politics, history)

131 Upvotes

I am reading The Unsayable: The Hidden Language of Trauma, which is an interesting psychoanalytical approach to trauma. It is written by Annie Rogers.

But was looking for other psychoanalytical books, anything interesting, not limited to psychotherapy. Want to broaden my horizons. Do you have any favorites or recommendations?


r/psychoanalysis • • May 14 '25

Boredom as countertransference

130 Upvotes

I have 1 or 2 clients where I feel so bored and so tired during sessions. I’m trying to use this as a piece of information in regard to countertransference….

Some open ended questions I’m wondering about:

  • is this their internal experience of the world? Bored, blunted, not wanting to be “here”

  • is this their internal experience of their own anxiety; tiring, exhausting

  • are they enacting something with me, which figure of their home life might I represent?

I feel there’s more here, curious if others have thoughts or insights or have dealt with this specific type of transference and can speak to some of their own experiences here


r/psychoanalysis • • Oct 20 '22

What is the psychoanalytical theory behind being a ‘contrarian’?

129 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I was wondering what the psychoanalytical theory would be behind being a ‘contrarian’, a person that always needs to be contrary in every situation. I don’t mean being contrary to stimulate a conversation or discussion, but contrary by all means.

By example: You’re a person that likes to party, but if others want to go with you, you resist and suddenly feel that you’re a ‘stay at home’ type of person.

It’s a type of ‘being contrary’ in every form of relationship you can have.

Does this have anything to do with control? Wanting to be independent or have ‘free will’? If it would be the last one, it couldn’t be true because if you conform or be contrary, you’re never free because you still act on it.

This has been keeping me busy lately. Besides that, is there any good literature on this topic?

Kind regards


r/psychoanalysis • • Sep 24 '19

Embracing the Lacanian "lack" has helped me enjoy my life

125 Upvotes

One of my biggest takeaways from psychoanalytic thought has been this.

By rejecting the idea that there is something "out there" that can satisfy and make us whole, we can actually find liberation through the embrace of the lack and the ordinary unhappiness of life.

A lot of the misery we face in life is a result of unmet desires and/or a refusal to name and acknowledge the lack in our lives.

Psychoanalysis helps us look at the very things we avoid looking at (or simply cannot see without the help of an outside perspective). Our acknowledgement of the lack robs the lack of its power over our lives.

In this way, our misery is transformed into common unhappiness.

There is a more detailed exploration of this (and a look at Jack Kent's book There's No Such Thing As A Dragon as a metaphor of this idea) here: https://medium.com/mind-cafe/embrace-your-lack-and-enjoy-your-unhappiness-f7ec49d516ad?source=friends_link&sk=0d73b3b61dff8b4835af2e427f87e770


r/psychoanalysis • • Apr 20 '22

From a psychoanalytic perspective, the "chemical imbalance theory" and the modern field of psychopathology function like ideology and the religious practices of ancient tribes

122 Upvotes

I noticed the "chemical imbalance theory" is not very far off from the religious practices of the ancient tribes. However, it's dangerous not because it's false, but especially because it's (mostly)1 true but misinterpreted and even taken out of context. The chemical imbalance theorists say that a chemical imbalance is enough to explain the causes of depression, anxiety disorders, schizophrenia, and so on but never ask what causes the chemical imbalance in the first place.

This is very similar to the practices of ancient tribes who blamed it on God or some sort of evil spirit possessing the ill person. Whenever they didn't understand something (the cause was outside their awareness, i.e. unconscious) it felt like the illness was "happening" to them, as if it was a force coming from the outside invading their body and mind. So they blamed it on demonic possession, an evil spirit just decided to possess you.

Nowadays, chemical imbalance theorists tell you that the chemicals in your brain just started going crazy randomly, no context, without asking why, as if God or some spirit decided to take the serotonin out of your brain. In both cases, it feels like an outside force invading your soul because the causes are unconscious and the unconscious is "outside", according to Lacan. The unconscious is the discourse of the big Other and both ancient tribes and chemical imbalance theorists are blaming it on the big Other ("God" or "nature/genes deciding to go crazy for no reason").

The real divide between what modern psychopathology considers "pathological", "healthy" or "adjustment disorder" is:

  1. how socially acceptable is it to suffer in your context

  2. how conscious the patient is of the causes of their symptoms

The formula of modern psychopathology is as follows:

a). If you suffer when we tell you to suffer, you are healthy and "normal".

b). If you enjoy when we tell you to enjoy, you are healthy and "normal".

c). If you suffer when we tell you to enjoy, you have either BPD, a mood or an anxiety disorder.

d). If you suffer when we tell you to suffer, but too much or for too long, you have adjustment disorder.

Hence, modern psychopathology functions in a similar way to ideology, in that it contains the super-ego compulsion to enjoy.

The real divide between a mood/anxiety disorder and an adjustment disorder is not whether your problems are "real" or "in your head" (since that is socially constructed), but whether you are conscious or unconscious of the causes of your symptoms. Take two examples: person A and person B.

Person A just went through a divorce, the death of a family member or their house was destroyed in a natural disaster, or even a mix of the above. They feel very sad for a period of time. Society considers these to be "real" reasons to be sad, so psychology will label them as healthy (or as having an "adjustment disorder" if they suffer for too long or too much).

Person B became famous, is full of money and attention all the time and has a ton of women and cars. After a while, his progress stagnates and he's stuck at the same (big) amount of wealth, same number of views per song (say, he is a musician), same number of subscribers etc. for a longer period of time. This stagnation makes him depressed. However, he does not know psychoanalysis and that this could be a cause of depressive symptoms as well. Society tells you that in such a situation, you don't have any "real" problem, so there must be something wrong with your brain for you to feel sad and empty in such a situation in life.

Since society hasn't taught him that such a situation often causes long-term sadness and lack of motivation, he didn't even make the connection between his stagnation and his symptoms and viewed it as a coincidence, a random correlation, when in fact it may have been the causation. He will then go on to say how he feels sad because of "no reason" and will be diagnosed with major depressive disorder instead of being labeled as healthy or as with having an "adjustment disorder" because his problems aren't "real".

Yet the only difference between person A and person B wasn't how "real" their problems (causes) were, but how conscious they were of them.

We can also see how much many critics of psychoanalysis are heavily projecting. In this video, psychodynamic therapies (psychoanalysis, Jungian and Adlerian) are criticized because "In both religious practices and the unconscious, there is an attempt to explain behavior by appealing to an inaccessible mind. Because of this inaccessibility, any assertions made about the motives about these supposed hidden minds are unfalsifiable speculations. Peddlers of demons are able to posit any demonic desire they like, and peddlers of the unconscious can posit any unconscious intention, all without any fear of empirical refutation. In both cases, clients are supposed to accept their assertions all because of fallacious appeals to authority".

Yet the causality is exactly reversed, it's not that psychoanalysis imitates religion but the other way around. Religious practices are a bad attempt at trying to explain the unconscious. The reason people believe in demonic possession is because the unconscious feels like an outside force possessing you, like the "possession by archetypes of the collective unconscious" Jung spoke about. In this way, psychoanalysis is actually the most down-to-earth approach to the unconscious, since it actually attempts to discover the causes of symptoms instead of blaming it on the big Other ("chance": God, evil spirits, chemicals in your brain deciding to go crazy on their own without anyone wondering as to why).

NPCs who repeat narratives like "All mental disorders are 'just' a chemical imbalance", "CBT is the only evidence-based treatment", "A DSM diagnosis is important and only a qualified professional can do it, you shall never self-diagnose" and a few others, without actually understanding them, are giving the DSM-V as the alternative in psychodiagnosis. Yet, ironically speaking, it's exactly where psychology regressed the most from psychoanalysis in terms of scientific rigor. In the days of psychodynamics (I'm looking especially at Lacan and Jung), everyone was ill in their own way, just that some people were more functional than others and some people had some symptoms while others had other symptoms. There was no clear, sharp line between pathological and healthy. Some diagnostics existed, but they weren't anything set in stone, but just a general guidance (like Jung's 8 psychological types of Lacan's 3 clinical structures) and you'd never hear about how a diagnosis is necessary to treatment and how you should never self-diagnose.

Now, the alternative is to go to a "trusted professional" to give you a diagnosis. But, the DSM shall never be used "like a cook book", you can't simply check the symptoms on your own. Instead, only the qualified professional possesses the magical qualities ("mana") that they can use to find out your mental illness, but they can never talk about their magic or ever actually write it in an actual book rigorously because only qualified professionals can understand. This is because the DSM is preached to be only a tool but never the full story as unqualified patients can't use it, thus, depression and anxiety aren't presented as "just a collection of symptoms" but some sort of hidden essence that's supposed to exist that only qualified psychologists can perceive. Psychology is the only medical field where disorders are not clearly defined.

The DSM conflates the definition, the symptoms and the diagnostic criteria of an illness into one (which never happens in the case of non-psychiatric medicine, for example the definition/essence of Coronavirus is a virus, the diagnostic criteria is a saliva or blood test and the symptoms are fever, cough, etc.). This caused some psychologists to say that the definition is something outside the DSM and that the DSM only provides symptoms and diagnostic criteria but not the definition/essence of the illness, which is never rigorously/formally written anywhere. Instead, it is a hard to perceive 'essence' (mana, objet petit a) that only a trusted expert can see after many years of training but they can never actually talk about it unless they talk to other professionals. They can talk "around" it but it will never be enough, there will always be something missing that they did not say about depression, GAD, OCD, etc. because a layman simply cannot understand.

They are treated exactly like the shamans and mana personalities of primitive tribes described by Jung or Freud in their anthropological studies. Only those who have the necessary 'mana' can perceive the essence of this invisible object that still directs our lives (objet petit a).


1: I say "mostly" true because on a few occasions it is straight up false. For example, it is a myth that serotonin causes depression. This has been debunked in trials where SSRIs increased serotonin levels in depressed patients after hours from ingestion but it took weeks for the symptoms to attenuate. There has only been established a correlation but not a causation between serotonin and depression. However, maybe there is a strong and positive correlation between medications that increase serotonin and medications that increase some other chemical that we haven't discovered yet that is the actual cause of depression.