I've always liked the Book of Mormon version of the Adam and Eve story. It subverts traditional narratives, framing Eve as courageous. Some might say it is a much more feminist recounting of the Garden. However one of the things I dislike the most is the murder of Laban, but I never connected the two and how deeply they impact Mormonism until now.
Eve broke rules for the greater good, and so did Nephi. But so did Joseph Smith, when he pretended to know where to find buried treasure. He tricked people as a way to scrape out of the poverty he was born into. So, what we see in the Book of Mormon is Joseph's defense of his own immorality. The thing about this that blows me over is how the LDS church became the incarnation of it.
I don’t think Smith wrote the Book of Mormon in 1829 with some 12-year master plan to coerce women into polygamy. He wasn't thinking that far ahead. But he reused his immoral theology again as one endeavor gave him more opportunities. The 1842 Happiness Letter to Nancy Rigdon is an example. To me, both this letter and the BoM come from the exact same internal morality, just playing out at very different stages of his life.
You can see that exact mindset in 2 Nephi 2. Traditional Christianity sees Adam and Eve’s fall as a tragic sin, a failure, while The Book of Mormon flips it into something good. Adam fell that men might be, and men are that they might have joy. To move forward and actually experience life, you have to break a lower rule for a higher good.
Fast forward to 1842. Smith isn't a poor farm boy anymore. He’s the undisputed prophet of a massive movement, and he’s trying to convince 19-year-old Nancy Rigdon and dozens of other women to enter into secret plural marriage.
To get devout 19th-century Christians to go along with something that violated their morals and even contradicted the Book of Mormon itself, he leaned right back into his earlier logic.
When women reacted to polygamy proposals with shock or revulsion, the Happiness Letter told them to ignore their gut. Whatever God requires is right, no matter what it is, although we may not see the reason till long after (perhaps not until after we die.) Feeling disgust wasn't a warning from God anymore. It was just spiritual immaturity, it was failure to see the bigger picture.
The letter goes all-in on situational morality too. That which is wrong under one circumstance might be and and often is right under another. Right and wrong depended completely on what Smith claimed God was asking for in that moment. And because both texts frame joy or happiness as the entire point of human existence, he was able to tie that ultimate happiness directly to plural marriage. Compliance became a test: the only way to unlock eternal exaltation for them and their families.
All these pieces from his early life and his later leadership fit together. What started as a unique take on human progress, born out of his own rule-bending instincts, became the exact tool he needed to justify polygamy. He didn't foresee where that logic would take him in 1829.
The thought process that created Mormonism starting in The Book of Mormon is the same that maintained it. We still see it alive and well today in the church. Follow the prophet, endure to the end. Give all you have, obey the prophet even if they're wrong. If he leads you astray, you were meant to take that detour.
That confusion you feel is Satan and if it isn't Satan it is your own weakness if it means you don't believe in the church.
We're still listening to the illogic of a desperate boy and following him around to get through life.