r/mormon • • Jan 05 '26

Apologetics To the silent majority....

0 Upvotes

To those that come here to read, and rarely post or comment, this one is dedicated to you.

Many come here to learn about some of the sticky things in the church, and on the surface, it looks like everyone here is exmo, or very close to exmo. However, as the old adage goes, don't judge a book by it's cover. There are thousands that have passed through here on their spiritual journey, and have come out stronger and more faithful on the other side.

If you are here, trying to figure out if it's true, it is unlikely you will find the answers here, however, you will find a lot of great resources that are worth pursuing. This sub, by far, is the best sub discussing the church and all the different sects. The others are either too 'good' or too 'bad'; and while this one has a tendency to sound more like a debate class at a liberal arts college most of the time, it is the one that openly allows for all opinions and points of view, which is the best thing someone truly searching can ask for.

If I could offer a few pearls of wisdom, they would be:

  1. Remember that NOBODY can prove or disprove ANY religion. By definition, religion is the study of things we can't prove scientifically. At some point, in the far distant future, there won't need to be religions because science will have answered all the questions. We are very far from that day.

  2. Get used to the Dunning-Kruger affect, as it is on full display in the faith crisis arena. In short, the person that knows a little more than the average person about a subject, thinks they are an expert; while the true experts are the first to say they know very little about the thing they have expertise in. Richard Bushman is a good example of someone that knows more about Joseph Smith's life, probably than any human alive. And yet, he will be the first to say he doesn't know the heart of the man, and offers him a ton of grace.

  3. Jesus gave you the best way to tell if something is true, in a religious sense, when he said (John 7) "16 Jesus answered them, and said, My doctrine is not mine, but his that sent me. 17 If any man will do his will, he shall know of the doctrine, whether it be of God, or whether I speak of myself. 18 He that speaketh of himself seeketh his own glory: but he that seeketh his glory that sent him, the same is true, and no unrighteousness is in him." In other words, you won't know unless you actually follow the plan, and find out for yourself. You can read all about the Book of Mormon, or the books of Moses or Abraham; but until you actually pick up the books and read them, you won't know. You can watch every video on YouTube about Joseph Smith's life, but until you follow what he taught, you won't know if he taught anything worth following. You can listen to every positive and negative criticism about Jesus Christ, but until you pick up and read about his life, and try to follow the path he laid out, you won't know if what he taught was of God or not.

  4. Lastly, if your path eventually takes you away from the gospel, remember the words of Peter after the death of Jesus. He started fishing again when Jesus came to him after many of the disciples walked back to their lives, and Jesus basically said, "so, 'sup Petey? You gonna ditch me, too?" And Peter said back to him "Lord, to whom shall we go? thou hast the words of eternal life." So many people leave the church and the gospel lifestyle behind, and once they do find they are missing something that can't be replaced by another church or the new Starbucks mug. There is something to this thing, which is why it's still around, and likely will be for a very long time.

God bless everyone in this sub, and may 2026 be the year you find the answers you seek.


r/mormon • • Dec 23 '23

Cultural The Echochamber of Ex Mormonism

0 Upvotes

It goes without saying that the Church can act like an echo chamber sometimes. I've noticed that communities comprised of those who have left the faith can end up acting the same way - idolizing a few white men, repeating the same talking points, only believing evidence that supports what they want. I used to be of the opinion that it helped with "healing" after a faith crisis. Having been there myself, I know realize it is just immature.

How do we avoid falling into the same trap we did as members?


r/mormon • • Sep 01 '22

News BYU Racial Slur Incident never happened

14 Upvotes

I usually love this sub because I think its a good place to come to have pretty objective discussions about mormonism. However, after one article was posted about one girl hearing slurs from someone that literally no one else in the room heard, many people decided to assume that byu staff and students would just allow someone to yell the n word over and over rather than the girl being mistaken.

Obviously the former is possible, but this is a good time to check your biases about how you perceive byu students and active LDS members if that was something you jumped to assume

EDIT: To be clear, I’m not saying it’s impossible or even unlikely for black people to be called slurs at an event like this. My main concern is that people used this scenario to show that the church is insufficient in rooting out racism, or is institutionally racist, when the facts as I see them now indicate that the church acted how I would want them to act if someone was yelling slurs at players

EDIT 2: i believe i should have made the title “racial slur incident less likely to have occurred now that we have more information” yes, we don’t have all the data yet and its still theoretically possible for it to have occurred. I can’t think of non tinfoil hat explanations though, but ill give you all the benefit of the doubt. My primary message here is that I think we should be more cautious of breaking news and understanding how single incidents are not good examples of the problem as a whole


r/mormon • • Aug 18 '23

Cultural Ex-Mormon Morality?

0 Upvotes

Are ex-Mormon atheists generally still moral and ethical? Or do they start violating the ten commandments and live by the phrase "eat drink and be merry for tomorrow we die"?

NOTE: I understand how many of you feel that the hierarchy of the church wasn't very moral and ethical to begin with. I'm talking about the relatively innocent true believer who tithes and goes on uncomfortable missions at great personal expense, who avoids coffee and alcohol, and tries to be sexually pure; The ones who would wear temple garments in 100 degree weather. Those sorts of people.

If they start being "bad" what types of things do they do? How does being an atheist change how they live?


r/mormon • • Jun 26 '22

Spiritual I love General Conference

4 Upvotes

It is a blessing to be able to listen to inspired talks on gospel topics, church history, citizenship and Jesus Christ. I also love that I can go online and listen and watch conference sessions from many years. It makes my heart happy to know that the lord has so blessed in our day to be able to hear the voice of his prophet, leaders anytime we want to.

I have been listening today and I am filled with deep peace and happiness.


r/mormon • • Jul 22 '24

Cultural Alyssa Grenfell

2 Upvotes

Do people here take this ex-LDS person's channel seriously? Any problems with the fundamental truthfulness of her videos?

Full disclosure: I'm not an LDS. I'm a boomer non-believer, who came into his realization of non-belief relatively late (in his late 40s). I label myself an agnostic atheist who formerly occasionally thought he was a Christian (Lutheran / Methodist / not quite Catholic). I don't believe in any gods and I'm certain of that, and I think I have very good reasons for not trying to believe in any (which is something I did for about 25 or 30 years). I can't make the claim that no gods exist.

She's at: https://youtube.com/@alyssadgrenfell?si=6U_HA5A8EOLndAGd


r/mormon • • Oct 11 '14

"Meet the Mormons" on YouTube

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/mormon • • Feb 08 '24

Apologetics Is the Book of Mormon racist?

1 Upvotes

One thing about the scriptures that seems abundantly clear is that people can cherry pick them to find whatever they want. Racists cherry pick them to excuse their actions and beliefs just as detractors cherry pick them to attack that they hate. In this article I couldn’t cover every verse that mentions the “shin of darkness,” but I examine the most relevant in an attempt to understand the authors’ views with the understanding that while the Book of Mormon is scripture, it was still written by men and is not perfect. In the end, I believe that our views on racism in the Book of Mormon says far more about us as the readers than the people in the book itself.

Note: in this part 1, I examine the text from the characters’ perspective, regardless of their reality. In books, fiction or nonfiction, we can critically examine the characters “in universe,” and this is what I did. In part 2 I will look at it from the different perspectives of the book’s possible origins and authors.

https://edification.cjccf.org/racism-in-the-book-of-mormon-part-1/


r/mormon • • Sep 27 '24

Institutional SL Trib: Huntsman suit takes a legal thrashing before the en banc review of the Appeals Court.

0 Upvotes

https://www.sltrib.com/religion/2024/09/26/lds-tithing-lawsuit-9th-circuit/

I know some of you disagreed with me, but I think they got thrashed in court. It's not looking good for the Tithing refund case folks. Proceeding as expected.


r/mormon • • Jul 30 '22

META Lamenting the Subreddit

3 Upvotes

When I first came to this subreddit, there was a certain group of people here. Debate was lively with plenty of source material provided and documents that people couldn't just ignore. Oh sure, some ignored them anyhow, but at least it was clear to everyone looking on that that's what they were doing.

Discussions had a certain personality to them, a certain texture.

Now most of those people have gone. Through the endless mod dramas and other issues, they've moved on to other places or have started their own. A few are still around, like Chino, but most of them have gone.

I've watched as this subreddit has become more and more vanilla. Over time, the amount of intellectual dishonesty has, unfortunately, seemed to flourish. Many of the newcomers have often made the subreddit like walking into a class full of second graders where everyone is running around yelling with their fingers stuck in their ears.

It's a shame really, because as I was learning more about the true history of the church, the real story behind the creation of the Book of Mormon, the Book of Abraham, and the behavior of the prophets and leaders right up to modern day, this was a fantastic place to be. Many of the people here simply cared about the truth, whatever that happened to be, rather than doing their best to distract from the truth.

It's not that place anymore.

Sure, conversations continue about the political ramifications of this and that as pertains to the church which is fine for people that are interested in the more political side of things, but the place just doesn't have the texture it once did.

It's been fun.


r/mormon • • Apr 25 '24

Personal Is this a Mormon or ex Mormon subreddit?

2 Upvotes

Genuinely confused because I see most people in here are ex Mormons but there’s another subreddit dedicated to that. Why is this subreddit full of ex Mormons?


r/mormon • • Aug 17 '24

Cultural The Church proactively addresses gross misrepresentations in poor taste. When Entertainment Media Distorts Faith

0 Upvotes

https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/article/commentary-when-media-distorts-faithful-lives

16 August 2024 - SALT LAKE CITY Commentary

Commentary: When Entertainment Media Distorts Faith

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, like other prominent global faith communities, often finds itself the focus of the attention of the entertainment industry. Some portrayals are fair and accurate, but others resort to stereotypes or gross misrepresentations that are in poor taste and have real-life consequences for people of faith.

While this is not new, a number of recent productions depict lifestyles and practices blatantly inconsistent with the teachings of the Church. Others irresponsibly mischaracterize the safety and conduct of our volunteer missionaries. We understand the fascination some in the media have with the Church, but regret that portrayals often rely on sensationalism and inaccuracies that do not fairly and fully reflect the lives of our Church members or the sacred beliefs that they hold dear.

Millions of Church members around the world are deeply dedicated to family, fidelity, service and the gospel of Jesus Christ. We invite all to consult reliable sources of information and listen to the voices and authentic experiences of individuals and families who find great joy and satisfaction in living these principles.

The true story of our faith is best seen in the countless lives of those who strive daily to follow our Savior Jesus Christ.


r/mormon • • Jun 09 '22

Scholarship Why Members of the Church of Jesus Christ are (and should be) upset about TV Series Under the Banner of Heaven

0 Upvotes

I've been decompressing a bit after watching the TV Series. As a very active, believing member of the Church who lives in an area of the country not saturated in Mormonism (meaning, not Utah or Idaho), and as a Historian, I have been inundated with questions from people both inside and out of the Church about this TV Show. After attempting to repeatedly answer the same questions over and over, I decided to collect my thoughts on why this TV Show is not just absolute garbage, but is intentionally misleading and offensive garbage.

I've broken my chief complaints down into three fairly easily digestible sections. But bear with me, this is going to be a long post.

The Show Gets the History Wrong

There are so many instances of outright historical errors, it made me cringe and shake my head more times than I can count. While normally I would be fine with some historical liberties to tell a good story, when the point of the story you're telling is to reveal "the true history of the LDS Religion", then you should maybe Google some of the historical facts you're presenting, and double check them. In Episode 7 they toss out a line attacking any historical defense of the accusations as coming from "LDS Historians". This is simply not so. Many of the historical "facts" shown here have been debunked by non-LDS Historians. Here are a couple that really jumped out at me as I watched the show:

Joseph Smith Tarred and Feathered for Polygamy/Adultery - They repeat the long debunked claim that Joseph Smith was tarred and feathered and almost castrated because he was having a secret affair with someone's daughter. This has been shown to be false many, many times. Real historians know that it was actually Sidney Rigdon who was the main target (he was nearly killed, and beaten far worse than Joseph Smith) and it was largely a dispute over a land purchasing deal that went badly, and the fear of the powerful LDS voting block moving into the area. If you look at the timeline of polygamy, and the date of this attack, it is painfully obvious they are unrelated.

Authorship of the Peacemaker Pamphlet - They claim the pamphlet "They Peace Maker" was written by Joseph Smith. This has been debunked many times. They were so lazy in their research, they didn't even bother to check wikipedia, which states right out of the gate: "The Peace Maker" is a pamphlet written by author Udney Hay Jacob in 1842." with citations. If you're wondering if Joseph Smith said anything about the pamphlet, he did: "There was a book printed at my office, a short time since, written by Udney H. Jacobs, on marriage, without my knowledge; and had I been apprised of it, I should not have printed it; not that I am opposed to any man enjoying his privileges; but I do not wish to have my name associated with the authors, in such an unmeaning rigmarole of nonsence [nonsense], folly, and trash.”

One Mighty and Strong Attribution - In Episode 5 they attribute a quote about "One Mighty and Strong" as being from John Taylor. First, they get the quote incorrect. They also incorrectly attribute it to John Taylor, when Joseph Smith who said it. Again, a simple google search would have shown the writers they were wrong.

The Assassination Attempt by Porter Rockwell - They claim that Porter Rockwell tried to kill Governor Boggs. This was certainly what Governor Boggs thought happened after he survived. Yet Porter Rockwell was arrested, and acquitted of the crime by a jury of people who were not members of our Church. When websites like Screenrant are debunking your historical claims, it might be time to re-evaluate what you're doing.

Mountain Meadows Massacre and Brigham Young - Brigham Young didn't order the Mountain Meadows Massacre. We have both copies of the letter Brigham Young wrote ordering the attack stopped when word was brought to him of what was happening. Again, wikipedia is your friend dear writers of this terrible TV show. It was also a far more complicated situation than they portray. Mormons had just been expelled from Missouri with an extermination order. There's documentation that there were people in the caravan who not only claimed to have helped kill Joseph Smith, but who threatened to return with an army from California to kill every Mormon man, woman, and child. Does this justify what happened? Of course not. But is the situation entirely black and white? Also of course not! Welcome to studying history, now crack open your copy of Historians Fallacies and get to work!

Sexism - People love to paint the church as super sexist, and abusive towards women. I'd recommend they read what Susan B. Anthony thought of LDS women, and I'd also recommend they read up on the Suffragist movement in early Utah.

Continuing Polygamy and John Taylor - In Episode 6, they presented an alleged meeting between John Taylor and some other leaders, where John Taylor told them polygamy MUST continue. They say this happened while Brigham Young was President of the Church. This is another long debunked claim by an FLDS leader named Lorin Whoolley (editted to make a quick correction, I had listed Joseph Musser as the person who made this claim, but Musser was one of Whooley's succesors as head of the FLDS sect. Apologies!). Not only are they presenting an event that non-LDS historians agree never happened (several of the people Whoolley claims were at the meeting have been documented as being in different cities at the time via letters and journals) but they don't even bother to get the historical time period correct. This meeting was alleged by Whoolley to have happened when John Taylor was President of the Church, many years after Brigham Young's death.

The Motivation of the Lafferty Brothers - How badly did they get the motivations of the murderers, and the events surrounding the killings? Well, they did bad enough that the victim's sister said: “This series, it’s absolute fiction.” She went on to say: “It’s disappointing that she’s being used. It’s not hard to see that (writer Dustin Lance Black) does not look kindly on the religion. Religion had nothing to do with the reason Brenda and Erica were murdered. I guess you have to go through the court process and listen to the prosecutor tell the story about why it wasn’t a religious killing. Why Ron Lafferty was not incompetent. And how the crimes were determined to be a crime of passion, murders of revenge, and it had nothing to do with religion.”

The Laffertys Were Prominent Members of the Church - They claim the Laffertys are a very important family, and the church wouldn't want there to be an embarrassing excommunication. Largely ignoring the fact that both Lafferty brothers had been excommunicated several years before the murders took place. The Laffertys were not prominent members of the church. None of them had been Bishops (heads of local congregations called "Wards" who generally serve for 5-10 years), much less serving at the Stake level (a larger organization that oversees 6-10 Wards). And you can forget General Authority. They were not prominent members of the Church.

The Red Book of Secret Real History - The "Red Book" that they imply has all the true, secret history and is well researched or whatever, is a book called "Mormonism, Shadow or Reality" by Jerald and Sandra Tanner. There isn't enough room to go into why this claim is ludicrous on its face, the Tanners are not trained historians, and their claims have been debunked time and time again by historians in and out of our Church. But suffice it to say, if you walked up to a group of non-LDS Religious Historians, and recommended anything written by the Tanners as "real history", you would be laughed out of the room.

John C. Bennett as Reliable Historical Source - A lot of the bad history comes from the writer's taking a lot of what John C. Bennett, a disaffected and excommunicated man who was caught on multiple occasions fabricating statements from Joseph Smith, and publishing alleged letters from members which they publicly and loudly disputed as forgeries, as fact. Non-LDS Historians take almost nothing John C Bennett ever wrote or said at face value, because he has been proven repeatedly to have falsified statements, and forged letters for publication. In fact, John C. Bennet once published a letter he said was from Emma Smith where she allegedly wrote: "I must now say that I never for a moment believed in what my husband called his apparitions and revelations, as I thought him laboring under a diseased mind,". Emma Smith responded publicly and loudly, writing "I was never more confounded with a misrepresentation than I am with that letter, and I am greatly perplexed that you should entertain the impression that the document should be a genuine production of mine. How could you believe me capable of so much treachery as to violate the confidence reposed in me and bring my name before the public in the manner that letter represents?"

I'm sure there are many, many more, those were the ones that were so blatant they caught my attention. I can't imagine how long this section would become if someone more pedantic than me (Heavenly Father Forbid) really dug in. Which leads me to my second section:

The Show Outright Lies and Makes Things Up

I've tried to think of a more diplomatic way to phrase this. "Takes creative liberties with the truth" is far too generous. But this is the truth. The show just flat out lies. I'm sure they'll take the defense of "writing fiction to tell a greater truth" but this show isn't presented as a work of fiction, it is a true crime series. And some of the lies are just jaw-droppingly incredible.

The Letter Written to the Prophet - You know the Letter that was written to the Prophet of the Church, the one that is the main inciting incident in the entire story? The one that causes the Office of the Prophet to send out evil lackeys like flying monkeys to do their evil bidding, and twist the arm of the police, and cover up the murders? Would you be surprised to learn that it never existed? Because it didn't. Ron Lefferty's wife never wrote a letter to the First Presidency/Prophet about the abuse she was suffering. She spoke to her Relief Society President, who reported it to the Stake President, who then had the two Lafferty Brothers excommunicated. The First Presidency was not involved in any of that. From a news article: “While the real Dianna Lafferty had sought counsel from close friends, leaders in her LDS ward, and her sister-in-law Brenda about Ron and the Lafferty brothers’ behavior, an actual letter doesn’t seem to exist. Rather than Brenda helping her write a letter, what really happened was that Brenda advised Dianna to get a divorce from Ron, both for her own sake and their children’s.” The entire plot of this show is based around an accusation that the LDS Church and the Prophet tried to cover up the crimes of the Lafferty Brothers. And their main evidence/argument for this conspiracy is a letter that never even existed?

Brigham Young Involvement in Joseph Smith's Death - This one literally made my jaw hit the floor. Brigham Young did not conspire to forge a letter from Emma to have Joseph Smith killed. The TV Show has Brigham Young intercepting a letter written by Emma Smith to Joseph, in order to have Joseph Smith surrender himself to prison, and then have Joseph killed so he could become the next prophet. The only problem with this insane conspiracy theory being: Brigham was on the east coast on a mission when everything happened, and didn't even know Joseph Smith had been arrested, much less killed until two weeks after the fact. This is a complete fabrication on the part of the writers. There's no other way to put it. The show is just outright lying here, and presenting it as fact.

The Church Exerted Its Influence to Sway the Investigation - The Stake President never visited the police, nor interfered with the investigation in any way. No one with any connection to the Church did. This was confirmed by both the family of the victim of the murder, and the police. But taking a step back, let's go ahead and pretend both the family and the police are lying. The LDS Church does not, has not, and could not exert political power to sway the actions of police or the justice system. It is ludicrous to think they could, as this would be a crime at the Federal level, not the state. I asked a good friend of mine who is not a member of the church, but who is a Federal Prosecutor, if there was any way that could happen. He said absolutely not, a corruption case like that would be the FBI and Federal Government's dream come true. It would be the kind of case that would make a career for the prosecutorial team, and the Federal Government certainly owes no allegiance to the LDS Church. It is a complete fabrication that flies in the face of both the historical evidence, the eye witness accounts, and a basic understanding of how the judicial system works.

Early Church Doctrines on the Origin of Black People - The Prophet Onias says they must return to the original teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, and lists off two doctrines, Polygamy, and then says "Our Doctrine states that Satan founded the black race when he taught Cain to place his seed into the beasts"  This is typical of how their bait and switch method works. Yes, the LDS Church practiced polygamy, this is a very well known fact, and is probably the thing most people know about the LDS Church. The writers then use that familiarity to add the second doctrine, which they just wholesale made up, as if it were a fact. But it is an outright lie. No leader in the Church has ever made such a preposterous statement, and it in fact flies in the face of what we learn in the temple. I was curious if this has ever been a doctrinal teaching by any Christian sect, so I did some digging, and couldn't even find any fringe non-LDS groups that taught this. The closest I was able to find was an extremely fringe belief called "Serpent Seed", the belief that Eve had sex with the Snake in the Garden of Eden, which resulted in the birth of Cain and black people. But even that super fringe belief was never associated with the LDS church. So they just wholesale invented a "doctrine" that the LDS Church has never espoused, and presented it as fact in the same breath as polygamy. As a Historian, this is made even stranger by the fact that there have been plenty of actual racist statements made by Church leaders in the past, which have since been disavowed. Why the writers felt the need to make something up out of thin air, instead of pulling from the existing quotes you could easily take out of context is a real head scratcher.

Closeted Homosexuality and Violence - The show has Ron Lafferty going to an FLDS compound, going naked hot tubbing with a bunch of people, and then having a homosexual interaction with the FLDS Prophet. This never happened. But even worse, they play into the tired trope of the "closeted LGBTQ people are dangerous murderers", one that I think is ready for retirement.

Baptismal Interview - When the child was interviewed for baptism, there were so many things incorrectly portrayed. First, the family wouldn't be there. If it was done today, maybe one parent would be present for the interview, but certainly not the entire family. However, back in the early 80's, it would have been just the Bishop and the 8 year old. Second, for a child's baptism, tithing would not be asked about. To make it the first question right out of the gate is obviously an attempt to make the church look greedy. Anyone who is curious what the interview entails, can look for themselves in the general handbook of instruction, which is available online and accessible by anyone.

BYU Sexual Harrassment - Remember the creepy scene where Brenda is at BYU, and her professor tries to seduce her? Yeah, that didn't happen. Another quote from Brenda's sister: “All women ... are approached sexually throughout their life. Brenda was no different. I know people left notes on her cars and her locker ... but a BYU professor never crossed the line with Brenda. She loved all of her colleagues. She loved her experience at BYU. She would have punched somebody. She wouldn’t have sat there and calmly talked to somebody if she felt threatened.”

The Show Doesn't Accurately Portray Mormon Culture

The creator of the series claims he was raised LDS in California. He also claims he consulted with many active and former members of the Church to get the details just right. I have to say, I find both of those claims incredibly suspicious. For every one cultural detail they get right, there are five that are blatantly, embarrassingly wrong. It comes across as more a parody of Mormon Culture than an accurate portrayal of it. A few examples:

Pioneer Clothing - Right out of the gate, they show the Detective's children wearing what looks like homemade pilgrim/pioneer clothing. I grew up LDS in the 80's. I can assure you, no one dressed like a pilgrim. We all wore the same embarrassing neon colors, hypercolor sweatshirts, and zubas that everyone else did.

The Bishop's Office - The Bishop's office was hilariously wrong. No Bishop has a name plate, nor a spacious office filled with impressive looking books and rich mahogany chairs. It is very clear that no one involved in the production had ever set foot in a Bishop's Office, which is generally about as spacious as a walk in closet, and sparsely filled with an Ikea style desk, and a handful of chairs. No bookshelves, no beautiful views, no couches.

French Fries are Sinful? - The first episode has a really confusing scene that implies eating French Fries are against our religion. Not sure how they came to that conclusion, given the number of times I, as a youth in the 80s, went on temple trips and other church outings where we consistently stopped at McDonalds, and the Church paid for our meals.

Heavenly Father - Using "Heavenly Father" in casual conversation, as a replacement for expressions of surprise... no. No one does that.

Mormonism Breeds Dangerous and Violent Men - I'd like you to think of any Mormons you know. Do they seem violent and dangerous to you? Usually we're made fun of for being naive, milquetoast, and overly kind and helpful. But sure, we're all dangerous and violent...

Temple Ordinance Wrong - They showed part of our most sacred Temple ordinances, which is a deeply offensive thing to those of us who take our Temple experience seriously. Before you roll your eyes, I would ask a rhetorical question, do you feel the same way about Islam's objection to drawings of the Prophet Mohammad? Do you make fun of Jewish people who wear a yarmulke? If not, why is it okay to make fun of and disrespect something sacred to members of our Church? It reminds me of a rhetorical question I would ask friends when they asked if I had seen the Book of Mormon Musical. Would you be willing to go see my musical called "The Torah" which leans into and makes fun of all of the worst anti-semetic stereotypes? If not, why not? Anyway, I won't go into detail of what is wrong, but interestingly, they got much the ceremonies completely wrong. And I can hear some folks inhaling to say "But it used to be different." I know. It is still wrong, even from the way the ordinance was administered in the past. The initiatory was completely wrong, and the endowment session was wrong.

The School of the Prophets - An allegedly devout member of the church (Andrew Garfield) is asked if he has heard of "The School of the Prophets" and he says no. The School of the Prophets is a very, very, very well known thing. Joseph Smith established it as a means of teaching doctrine to the early church leaders. It is where he and Sidney Rigdon delivered the "Lectures on Faith", a very famous treatise on the subject of God and Faith that used to be included in our scriptures (though it was never canonized). The term "School of the Prophets" is found in our scriptures, when Joseph Smith was commanded to establish it. Again, dear writers of this TV Show, Google is your friend. I would be more shocked if a member of the church hadn't heard of the School of the Prophets, and this weird splinter sect/cult obviously took their name from a very famous event in Church History.

General Authority - The Detective's wife refers to her Stake President as her "General Authority too". Nope. A Stake President is considered a "Local Authority", that's literally why there's a different designation used. A "General Authority" is a label given to about 100 people at any given time. There are General Authority Seventies, the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, and the First Presidency. Everyone else: Area Authority Seventies, Mission Presidents, Stake Presidents, Bishops, etc., they are all "Local Authorities". Everyone who has watched a General Conference session understand this.

Did You Break Your Covenants?!?!? - I have never once, in my entire life, had someone ask me "Did you break your covenants?" We do make covenants, and they are very sacred to us, but the idea that we're running around, angrily demanding to know if you are a "covenant breaker" is just... weird.

Unhappy Home Life - In the final episode, Andrew Garfield says “She’s a convert, which tells me she had an unhappy home life” was a particularly mean-spirited line. I know many, many converts to our church. They come from all backgrounds in life, some come from happy families, some don't. Some are wealthy, some are impoverished. As a missionary, we were told to talk to anyone and everyone. The implication that the writers clearly intended, that Church is predatory and only goes after those who had an unhappy life, is false. But even more deeply offensive, is the idea that someone who had an unhappy upbringing is somehow less intelligent, more gullible, and easier to "dupe" into religious belief. That is beyond offensive. It's vile and gross, and the writers of this show ought to feel ashamed of themselves.

Edit: Some people are saying I misinterpreted or misunderstood what the Detective was saying, so rather than paraphrase, here is the exact line of Dialogue Andrew Garfield delivers: "Yep, well, she was a convert, so that tells me she wasn't all that fond of the home she was brought up in*, so for now we look for anything addressed to Florida."* I stand by my assessment, and this is gross.

Conclusion

Many people are assuming that members of the Church are upset about this show, because it's "finally telling the truth" or they are "ignorant of their own history" or "can't handle criticism" or "need to always play the victim." That could be true for some. But for those who I have spoken to, and speaking for myself, the reasons we are upset about this show, is it is more historical fiction than fact, and includes many outright lies about our history, our beliefs, and what happened during these horrible, horrible crimes.

This show was clearly created by a man with an axe to grind. He's angry and bitter towards our religion, though he presents himself as being "fair and balanced", and wanting to just "tell a story". But that simply is not so, and the saddest part, is for many people, this TV Series will be their "education" and perhaps only information on the History of our Church, it's teachings, and its doctrines. That's why we're upset. And we should be. Would you expect a member of the Jewish faith to sit quietly and smile while vitriolic and anti-semetic lies are spun about them? Then why should we?


r/mormon • • Jun 23 '23

Cultural Let's tip our hats to the members of the Church of Jesus Christ for their amazing generosity!

3 Upvotes

I know members of this sub focus a lot on the use of tithing funds (and the amount of wealth that has been generated by carefully and consistently saving a portion of those funds). And that is a proper subject for discussion, no doubt.

But there's another subject that doesn't get enough attention, and that is the amazing humanitarian generosity of the Latter-day Saints.

Based on the Widow's Mite Report (assuming it's accurate), the Church of Jesus Christ spent approximately $1.2B in humanitarian causes in 2022. These funds appear to have been contributed by members as fast offerings and humanitarian contributions.

$1.2 billion is an astonishing sum--simply astonishing.

Comparing private donations, these combined efforts by the Latter-day Saints would be the 11th largest charity in the world in 2022. Here's the Forbes list.

https://www.forbes.com/lists/top-charities/?sh=2a8388285f50

I'm a believing member, so this is tooting my own horn a bit, I know. But, wow.

The Latter-day Saints are a tiny, tiny religious minority. This is just a huge charitable effort on their part. It shows what good people united in a good cause can do working together!


r/mormon • • Aug 14 '25

Cultural Why the LDS Church is right to embrace more mainstream Christian culture

1 Upvotes

Holy Week, crosses, youth concerts with praise and worship bands, calling sacrament meetings Sunday services, etc. Why do these things bother some people in the world of Mormonism so much?

Change can be annoying, but none of these things are about changing distinctive LDS doctrines. It's all just cultural stuff. It's an attempt by the Church to stop being unnecessarily different from other Christian denominations.

I think it should go even farther. Wine instead of water for the sacrament, just as Jesus originally instituted it. Observing the seasons of Advent and Lent -- there was some discussion about Lent this year in my ward's Elders Quorum, and I wonder if this will increasingly become a thing in many wards... ahem... congregations (there's another one). Standing up for singing hymns instead of remaining seated. Guitars and drums as acceptable musical instruments at church. Have more of the talks be given by the best public speakers in the congregation, and maybe even make it an official calling. Stop referring to other Christian churches as other "faiths" and start calling them fellow denominations, like other Christians do.

Those are just a few ideas. How much of this stuff will ever be implemented? Who knows. But the leaders of the Church seem to realize that there have been too many ways that Mormonism became too culturally isolated from the rest of Christianity, and are starting to fix that.

I applaud them. It is long overdue. There are lots of distinctive features of Mormonism, such as unique doctrines and ordinances, which provide enough of a special identity. The Church doesn't need to make itself feel culturally alien to the average Christian, too, which is exactly how it has been until the recent trend to remove some of these unnecessary cultural barriers.

I speak as a convert who would have had a much harder time joining the Church in the pre-Nelson era, in part for these reasons. I think some important changes have only just begun. Assuming the trend continues, the Church will have a much easier time making converts.

(EDIT: I will no longer be responding to comments on this post, because most people commenting are ex-Mormon or strongly opposed to the Church, and downvoting my replies, so I'm just going to let others discuss the issues I raised if you wish. My intention wasn't to get into contentious debates with non-LDS members.)


r/mormon • • Jun 26 '22

Personal Just watched Mormon no more

0 Upvotes

Let me start with this. I am 100% behind people finding their truth and their love. If you’re gay, transgender, etc. I think you should live how you want, with whoever you want and find happiness. What I really want to understand is why someone from the LGBTQ community would feel a compulsion to impose their views on BYU students. I am bothered by Mormons trying to impose their beliefs on everyone else. But I am equally bothered by the LGBTQ community hijacking the BYU campus and the Y or the graduation ceremony to spread their message. I mean this with all love, why can’t we just let everyone be who they want to be. If you want to be Mormon. Be Mormon without someone telling you that it’s wrong. If you want to be trans, be trans without anyone telling you that it’s wrong. I don’t understand why anyone in the LGBTQ needs validation from the Mormon community and vice versa. The respective beliefs and not aligned. It doesn’t mean we cannot live each other and recognize that we are all just trying to figure life out. Greatest lyrics ever, “love is my religion… I don’t condemn I don’t convert..” that shit works both ways.


r/mormon • • Feb 12 '26

META Is there a way to avoid turning this place into subreddit r/exmormon 2.0?

0 Upvotes

This place used to have so much long form discussion from both sides of the faith. Now it feels devolved somehow. Like all the long form believing contributors have been scared away from the sub by all the SA news addicts, the Mormon church is "fraud and must die" posts, etc.


r/mormon • • Mar 24 '20

Controversial Elon Musk has demonstrated more christ like attributes, prophetic abilities, and an overall love for humanity than the church or rmn.

8 Upvotes

Why isn’t the church apparently more special, considering their claims, rather than looking like just another church or a mlm business?


r/mormon • • Jul 29 '20

META This reddit group should be renamed to "What should I complain about the Mormon Church today"

2 Upvotes

Honestly almost every post is complaining about something and any attempt to have a meaningful discussion about something spiritual or cultural is bombarded by countless anti mormons, ex mormons, atheists and people just looking for an argument. It's over saturated with people who can't let the actual believers be proud of what they believe in. Continually made a mockery of and made fun of or shot down for what we believe in. If you don't believe in the same things as us then that's okay, but dont belittle others because you don't see the world the same way we do!

I BELIEVE THIS CHURCH IS TRUE AND I AM NOT AFRAID TO LET IT BE KNOWN FROM NOW ON. COME AT ME BRAHH!


r/mormon • • Dec 26 '24

META How is this uncivil?

Post image
1 Upvotes

This is about tithing.


r/mormon • • Sep 25 '24

Cultural What are the biggest lies about the church being spread today on social media?

3 Upvotes

I saw a clip on social media from Jacob Hansen about "lies being told constantly about the church" in social media.

I do understand that unflattering information is being told about the church. But I was wondering. What are all the "lies" being told about the church.

What lies do you see?

Here are a couple from me.

Lie #1 - Joseph Smith was a pedophile.

Yes he did marry very young girls (beehives and Miamaids). But pedophile? I feel that is a bridge too far and pushes into lie territory.

Lie #2 - The church is a cult.

Yes. If you look at the BITE model the church has a lot of commonality with controlling organizations. Yes. The missionary experience fits the definition of cult. You have to be with your companion at all times (almost). But cult? I can work and travel and associate with whomever I want. Cult? In the traditional sense, this is a bridge too far as well.

What it top of your list of complaints about the church that could be closer to a lie than the truth?


r/mormon • • Jan 04 '24

Apologetics What is an argument against the Church that when someone shares it, it immediately reveals they haven't done their research?

0 Upvotes

For me this is View of the Hebrews. I've read the whole thing and the similarities are virtually nonexistent. The Church is so confident it's not plagiarized that they even have View of the Hebrews available for free as part of the Joseph Smith Papers Project.


r/mormon • • Sep 07 '21

Spiritual My testimony

0 Upvotes

I would like to bear my testimony that I know that the church is true and that our heavenly parents love us and are trying to save us and want us back.

In the name of Jesus Christ amen.


r/mormon • • Mar 01 '21

Personal Banished for beliefs

0 Upvotes

I expressed my opinion that the post about the UT college change of name from Dixie was an idiotic erasure of history. Said I’m proud of my Southern roots and don’t believe in erasing the past. It’s Orwellian to rush around banishing names and painting everything and everyone a racist. For expressing my beliefs, your admin said I was uncivil and I’d be in time out. What I’d like is for y’all to permanently banish me from your little group so I don’t have your silly, fearful site show up on feed. Call it an Uncivil War. BTW, I’m a Black Progressive Female Exmo who voted mostly Republican because people like you are censoring anyone who doesn’t conform to your Orwellian paradigm.