Just finished the book, had a few questions I was interested in hearing some opinions on. Happy to share my own thoughts as well, but curious to hear how others interpreted these parts of the story and the symbolism behind them. One of things I found funny about Ishmael's narration is he will often go into exhaustive detail on what he thinks elements of the tale symbolize, almost like he is analyzing the text next to the reader. There are parts of his concrete world that he is not afforded the ability to do this with, and these three questions revolve around those parts.
What is your interpretation of Ishmael being the one to pick out the ship?
Queequeg tells Ishmael that Yojo has chosen him to choose the boat. In the Patrick Stewart adaptation they make a bigger deal out of this, Ishmael is an inexperienced landlubber who actually tries to get out of making the choice, which is what made me think of the question. Ishmael's choice effectively dooms them, why does Yojo direct Queequeg to give Ishmael power over the choice of vessel, any other thoughts on this?
What do Ahab's wife and child symbolize?
I am sure there has been commentary on this before. I found the young wife and child to be the most incongruous part of Ahab's nature, more so than the two wills battling within him, or the other dualisms contained in the captain. I think part of this stems from it being hard to picture the man in any sort of passion unrelated to whaling or the whale. My favorite part of the book is that moment of lucidity towards the end where he clearly regrets his marriage and what he has inflicted on his family. But apart from that, the wife and especially the child so rarely come up in the book. Why, and what do they mean?
The Crew
This is less of a question and more something I'd like to hear thoughts on. For such an iconic literary character I was surprised how few references to Queequeg were present in the later stages of the book (obviously ignoring the bulk of the middle part where he just talks about cetology without much reference to individual crew-members). This got me thinking about how Ishmael chooses who he describes and gives identity to. I was also thinking how abruptly the carpenter and the blacksmith are introduced pretty late in the book. I understand of course that not every crewman can be described in exhaustive detail, but we hardly know the goings about of any but the most prominent sailors, and even some of the most integral characters we only know a few things about. Modern authors want you to hear the interplay of discussion/opinion amongst casts of characters, even to the detriment of the plot sometimes, and in contrast Melville does this only very deliberately. But as a consequence you never know much about, say, the rest of Fedallah's men, who you can imagine as having a fascinating relationship to the other sailors. Or even something so consequential as the only man who dies on the voyage before the final hunt (the guy who falls off the ship)- this guy never even gets a name. So if it was a question I guess it would be, when and why does Ishmael choose to immortalize a crew member in his story, versus when he doesn't?
There are truly so many questions that would be great discussion topics. I would also appreciate it if anyone could link some contemporary readings of the book, for I be but a tyro in the literary seas.