r/mobydick • • Oct 04 '24

There's a whole subreddit for this?

0 Upvotes

Going through this book now. 5 hours into an audiobook that is 24 hours long. I understand that this isn't an adventure story. Although, when I first started it, right after "Ender's Game", I was hoping for such so. I enjoyed my time with queequeg and the building up story so far. But the book, unabridged, seems more about defining the absolute details about whales and never really pursuing the plot of the story. I enjoy its talks about religion as far as I have got. Which to my understanding seems to be a let be as it let be. To not really welcome new religions, but to understand them, and appreciate the people for what they are. But keep them as separate and appreciate them at a distance. Perhaps this explained more in depth? 5 hours into a 24 hour audio book I am beleaguered and weary as I struggle through it's prose. I can understand the whale talk of the author, or Ismael is truly going into depth about his voyage, and informing me about every little detail that will shape his forth cometh. That he is depressed or suffering the trails? But, if I hear one more fact about the great Grey, the whale, the whatever, about it's fins, or it's size, I will write an incredibly useless reddit post. 2 hours into my drive back home and no real plot.. Just the mundane prose about whales 🐋 and thier fins and the types of them. Again, only 5-6 hours in at best. Its heavy when I don't need it and I would prefer something less philosophical.

I researched a bit on the topic on reddit and one of the more upvoted comments (11) is that:" It wasn’t until my second read of it did I realize he was very meticulously piecing together the joyous moments he experienced and knowledge he gleaned before an immensely traumatic event. It’s just a man in therapy finding his way to The Trauma and taking as much time as he can to get there so as to avoid the inevitable as a coping mechanism, and rationalize what he experienced as a survivor." -Pinkcasingring (1 year ago).

Dealing with trauma? Fine okay..Just don't give me two hours about fins and whaling facts to get me there.

I did not go farther here..and spoiled I am, but I expected it. QQ dies. For me knowing it now 6 hours in I care not. The author built it up so much at the start caring for this "pagan". I'm not surprised it surmounted to the authors despair. At this point, I am not wanting to continue reading such. More whale facts will tire me even if it's just the author dealing with his journey.

I wish to skip this and instead read the "Epic of Gilgamesh", or the second book in the "Ender's Game".

Help me. Tell me something.


r/mobydick • • Nov 11 '25

It just feels oddly right??

Post image
0 Upvotes

first I came up with the top three and then the others started to find their place too


r/mobydick • • Nov 30 '23

My in depth Moby Dick book review. Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

Gosh Melville! Cetacean with a cee, not fish with an eff. From hells heart etc…!!


r/mobydick • • 16d ago

Im new to reading, this is the second thing i read after the stranger of albert camus, will i enjoy?

0 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Aug 09 '21

Modern English versions of Moby Dick

0 Upvotes

Hello. Are there modern English versions of Moby Dick and if yes which do you recommend?


r/mobydick • • 7d ago

Pequod vs. Samuel Enderby

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Jun 08 '25

Unneccessary (I think) whale descriptions?

0 Upvotes

I am through chapter 76 in my first reading of the book. I think that's about 60% of the way? There are some genius passages in here. I love the scene when Ishmael and Queequeg meet Elijah. His warning(s) are so subtle and well-written. The whole "well, I guess it's too late for you now" type of response. So simple and terrifying.

What I can't wrap my head around is the purpose, meaning, and necessity of these totally tangential chapters comparing, for example, the shape of a right whale head to the shape of a sperm whale head. To me, this stuff totally ruins the pace and rhythm of an otherwise very engaging plot and set of characters. This text has elite status in the canon of American fiction, and I can see several reasons why. However, I'm surprised to see these nearly irrelevant passages sprinkled into the story. How have readers and critics dealt with that? To me, they detract from the novel substantially. But it seems like others have been more willing to accommodate.

I'm sure this topic has been discussed at length before. I'd be curious to read any writing on this topic or to hear opinions from others.


r/mobydick • • Apr 07 '25

I was forced to watch Moby Dick (The one with Patrick Stewart) in school, so here's my opinion on it.

0 Upvotes

It was ok.


r/mobydick • • Feb 20 '23

[NYT] - An Artist’s Queer Take on ‘Moby-Dick’

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
1 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Mar 20 '23

First time reader of Moby Dick

2 Upvotes

I(M) 23 and I finally decided to read (audiobook) moby dick since it's so widely referenced in literature. Arguably, one of the most difficult thing I've ever read. Mainly because of the (imp) the fluff.

It took 20 chapters before the voyage actually began, and the following chapters about the different types of whales almost made me hit my head on a wall. It's now to the point that I'm basically skimming the book and now I'm not sure which parts are important and which aren't. Which is a shame because there are some moments that the book grabs me and hooks me. Moments like Captain Ahab's speech to the crew convincing them to join his vendetta against the white whale. Then came the chapter about them dancing and once again I'm skimming.

I'm 42 chapters in, and I'm getting tired. Is it worth listening on?


r/mobydick • • Oct 12 '25

Various questions about Moby Dick

0 Upvotes

Hello all. Is it okay if I create a running thread (this one) to cover various small(ish) questions I have about Moby Dick? It's because I'd rather not litter the sub with a new thread for every little thing I wonder about. I'll add questions as top-level comments, marking them clearly as "New question". Anyone knowledgeable about MD, please subscribe to this thread.

One request though: no shooting from the hip please. If I ask a question about something you've never noticed (about the text), or have never thought about, please don't fabricate an instant opinion on the fly (as many Redditors seem to be in the habit of doing these days). IOW, if you don't know, please just don't comment, or at least spend some time thinking about it first before you do. Thanks much.


r/mobydick • • Oct 04 '26

To Catch a Whale - A Comparison of Primetime to Henry Melville's Classic

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Nov 16 '21

the new audio book of Moby Dick read by Cardi B

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Feb 27 '23

Does Ishmael believe in necessity, free will, or chance? What happens to his “ball of free will”? If “necessity” means what is unchangeable, “free will” what we can choose, and “chance” what is unexpected, then how do these three things relate to Ahab, the crew, and Moby Dick?

0 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Apr 30 '19

"Ahab" represented Arabs/Jews, attempting to latch onto the white whale/culture/democracy/government. They launched Christianity onto the white race, and hooked it in the 1200s. They continue to hang on. P.S. I am white and I welcome our Jew and Arab dudes to climb aboard. I converted to their God!

0 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Oct 14 '26

Does anyone know the value of this

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Found it in a op shop, I don’t know the value


r/mobydick • • Jan 01 '24

Who would win? The Babadook vs Moby Dick

0 Upvotes

Could either side defeat the other if they came to blows with each other?

Mister Babadook from The Babadook, Moby Dick from In the Heart of the Sea


r/mobydick • • Jan 19 '26

The Whiteness of the Whale

0 Upvotes

There's some great stuff in this chapter, thought-provoking passages on color to human psyche, beautiful phrases per usual . . . but dude. He just goes on and on with five million different examples of whiteness. It's so redundant. You'd think he could pick the most poignant and move on with it. Really been enjoying the language and Ishmael's philosophical musings, but every once in a while there's chapters like this where the horse has long since been beat to death, and Melville is just grinding it to a bloody pulp


r/mobydick • • Mar 31 '25

Reading Moby Dick on YouTube

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Mar 23 '26

Struggle with pacing

16 Upvotes

Hiya! I’m about 34 chapters in to Moby Dick. I was greatly enjoying it until Melville started going into the descriptions of all the whale types. I find this extremely tedious. I’ve just finished Mast heads and I found the exact same problem with his descriptions of mast heads and historical figures. I undedtand he does this kind of thing a lot during the novel, such as hunting techniques, equipment etc… are these sections worth reading to understand the obsession of the whale and whaling? Or (if I’m really losing interest) is it to skim through or even skip? I want to get the most out o Moby Dick, but these sections do hurt my interested and enjoyment.


r/mobydick • • Dec 07 '18

Ahab was the real Ishmael

1 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Sep 02 '25

Starbuck making coffee

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Sims 4 Starbuck becomes the Moby Dick household's barista.


r/mobydick • • Aug 18 '26

Come sono sopravvissuto a Moby Dick Spoiler

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/mobydick • • Jun 18 '26

Does anyone think Moby Dick is not Melville's best work

13 Upvotes

He's one of those writers whose most famous work is synonymous with his name. But does anyone here think Melville has better books? Has anyone read or heard of anyone making this point? Could be one of his other novels/novellas, a short story, or a poem. I personally think MB is his best (very uncontroversial opinion) but I am really interested in hearing arguments to the contrary. I'm currently trying to read all of his writing (except for Clarel, probably not going to make it through that) and I don't think anything I've read comes all that close to beating it, as much as I love Bartleby and Pierre and Benito and Battle Pieces. Thanks